Saturday, April 7, 2012

In UN SC, Syria Draft Under Silence to 9 am Thursday, Kofi Briefs at 10

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 4 -- On the eve of Kofi Annan's briefing of the UN General Assembly, Security Council diplomats met past 6 pm on Wednesday negotiating a Presidential Statement about Annan's mission to Syria.

The idea, several Council sources told Inner City Press, was to "agree on a PRST before Annan's 10 am briefing." The negotiation went slowly, from 3:30 pm -- after an hour, a source emerged to say they were "only on paragraph two." Two became four.

A Western diplomat told Inner City Press, it will look terrible if the Council can't agree on something this simple before Kofi briefs the Council. A non-Western diplomat said the statement had to be balanced, and use "carrots" as well as sticks.

An Arab diplomat opined that "Russia will be harder this time."

But just after six the meeting broken. Multiple sources told Inner City Press that the amended draft is under "silence procedure" until 9 am on Thursday, with an eye toward reading it out in the chamber at 9:45 - unless a member objects. PRST must be unanimous.

One Western diplomat quipped, as he left, sure 9:45, Russia has guaranteed it won't object. There are, of course, no guarantees.

Meanwhile the UN itself remains absurdly secretive. Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky to merely confirm that Robert Mood of Norway is the head of the assessment team being sent to Damascus. Nesirky refused to confirm.

The two deputies, Nassar El-Kidwa and Jean-Marie Guehenno, are said by sources to be at the Assistant Secretary General level. Inner City Press asked Nesirky if Ban's financial disclosure, including public financial disclosure, regime applies to them.

Nesirky referred to prior back and forth -- mostly back -- about the composition of Annan's team, and said he wouldn't answer. Inner City Press noted that while Annan spokesman Ahmad Fawzi disclosed at least some names -- Lamine Sisse, for example, and Nicolas Michel as a consultant -- he hadn't disclosed Martin Griffiths, and in any event the financial disclosure question was for the UN Secretariat, Ban in particular since he made so much of this disclosure regime.

"Don't get me wrong you can ask of course," Nesirky said. "And if we have something I'll let you know." But six hours later nothing had been said. So much for disclosure.

Footnote: at the same time as the Syria consultation, another meeting took place in the Council's suite, on one of the US Mission's thematic debates this month, called "Illicit Flows." An exiting diplomat quipped to Inner City Press, "Sounds like a disease." Indeed.

As Mali Representative Asks Why Close Borders Amid Hunger, At UN No Answers

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 4 -- Despite much talk that sanctions should be targeted, the UN Security Council on Wednesday adopted a Presidential Statement supporting "the efforts of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS)," which has moved to close Mali's borders, leading to long lines for gasoline and impending loss of electricity.

The UN Secretariat, even with its humanitarian mandate, has refused to criticize these untargeted sanctions. On April 3 Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman

Inner City Press: On Mali, some are saying that the ECOWAS sanctions, they’re closing the borders, that there are already people lining up for gas, they are not targeted in any way. I heard you say that the UN humanitarians are concerned about shortages, but Valerie Amos, for example, on South Sudan said that they should keep pumping oil because of humanitarian needs. What does the UN say about a sanctions regime that would essentially close the border and block the entry into, of consumer goods like gasoline. How is it consistent to talk about shortages when they are being caused by the sanctions?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Well, these are measures that have been introduced by the regional organization, ECOWAS. I would refer you to them to ask about that. From a purely humanitarian point of view, it is obvious that the sooner that the political side of this can be dealt with, and we can get back to constitutional order in the country, the easier it will be to deal with the humanitarian crisis that existed even before this, and has obviously been exacerbated by the developments of recent days. I think that’s what we have at the moment.

Also on April 3 Inner City Press asked Gerard Araud, the Ambassador of France, about the impact of the sanctions, and to explain why Foreign Minister Alain Juppe said France would not intervene in Mali while it played the key role in ousting Laurent Gbagbo in Cote d'Ivoire. Video here, from Minute 2:09.

Araud stammered that "the only difference between Cote D'ivoire and Mali is that in Cote d'Ivoire we had a UN mandate, resolution 1975.... [here] we are not doing to ask for it, no French intervention in Mali." He continued, "As for sanctions, it's decision by ECOWAS, they have knowledge of the region.

But if that's the logic, wouldn't one assume that the representative of Mali knew even more about the plight of Mali's people than ECOWAS?

Wednesday after Jeffrey DeLaurentis of the US, as president of the Security Council for April, read out the Council's statement, he gave to floor to "the representative of Mali," Ouman Daou. He has been the Permanent Representative of Mali at the UN since 2008. Now with his president overthrown by "mutineers," it is not clear who exactly he represents.

Oumar Daou handled it with aplomb. He said he represented "the people" of Mali; he questioned the ECOWAS sanctions, asking "is this the time to close the borders? To leave us thirsty and hungry?"

But the Council, having just expressed support for ECOWAS, did not answer. DeLaurentis thanked "the representative of Mali," and deemed the meeting over. Will Ouman Daou continue to appear at Mali's representative? Will anybody listen? Watch this site.

Somalia Diplomat Says TFG Approves Drones by "US, UK, NATO," Minneapolis in Manhattan?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 4 -- The Somali Mission to the UN's First Secretary Omar Jamal, previously of Minneapolis, has held press conferences two days in a row now in the UN auditorium. In a sparsely attended session on April 3, Inner City Press asked Jamal about human rights, the firing of UN Deputy in Somalia Christian Manahl, and his government's use of mercenaries. Jamal said that drone strikes against Al Shabab leaders are understandable, even welcome.

On April 4 Jamal appeared again, this time with a larger audience. In the interim a suicide bomber had killed ten people in the refurbished national theater, the day after the New York Times reported that things were getting better in Mogadishu.

Most questions Jamal faced were about the attack, of which he said he knew little; he speculated that the bomber may have had "inside information" that the Times piece was coming out and killed to try to counteract it.

Inner City Press asked Jamal to be more specific about drones: to which governments or entities has the Transitional Federal Government given approval for drone strikes, is the TFG informed of targets in advance? Jamal's answer mentioned the US, UK and NATO; then he refused to say more.

Other diplomats have remarked to Inner City Press that its rare for a "First Secretary" -- at most, a Mission's Number Three -- to hold press conferences, particularly two days in a row.

"Well, Omar Jamal is media savvy," said one diplomat. "His foreign minister isn't here?" asked another diplomat. "Why is he doing it? Is he trying to take over?"

The Somali mission has seen this before, as Inner City Press reported involving Deputy Permanent Representative Idd Bidl "Mogadishu in Manhattan" Mohamed. Some wonder, do we now have "Minneapolis in Manhattan"? Watch this site.

After Sudan's Harun Is Filmed Threatening War Crime, Ban's UN Says It's Up to ICC to Respond

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- On film, the governor of South Kordofan Ahmed Harun said, "You must hand over the place clean. Rub it, crush it and sweep it. Don't bring them back alive. We have no space for them." Given the similarity to Gaddafi comments that led to UN rebuke and NATO bombing, Inner City Press on April 2 asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman:

Inner City Press: footage has come out over the weekend of Ahmed Haroun, the Governor of Southern Kordofan, shown in very clear video fashion telling troops in Southern Kordofan to take no prisoners and to clean them out, and a general stands next to him and says, “let’s eat them raw”. And many are saying that this is proof of a war crime and obviously into some [inaudible] back to the UN actually flying Ahmed Haroun to Abyei and back. Does the UN, given its continuing interest in this area, Southern Kordofan, and its role in the past with Ahmed Haroun, have any view of this tape and what should happen now?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Well, listen, as you know, we don’t have direct full access to Southern Kordofan in the fashion that we would obviously like. So, it is very difficult for us to have a full picture of what is happening on the ground. We are obviously extremely concerned about the reports that are coming out of there. I think it is a bit of a stretch to be linking what may or may not be happening now with previous engagements of the kind that you mentioned — transporting this gentleman by helicopter. But, I understand what you are saying. I don’t have anything further on that particular point, except simply to stress that we are concerned about the reports that are emerging from there. But, we don’t have the direct access that we would need to be able to really understand fully what is going on.

So, the UN sought not to respond to what Harun was filmed saying, and even to avoid commenting on what is going on in South Kordofan by citing its lack of access. Did the UN have more access to Benghazi? Or to Syria now?

While the UN, which as noted has offered free helicopter flights to Harun after he was indicted by the International Criminal Court, had nothing to say, even Cathy Ashton of the European Union issued a statement:

"I am alarmed at video footage showing Ahmed Haroun, the Governor of Southern Kordofan, urging Sudanese soldiers to take no prisoners during fighting in Southern Kordofan and a Government of Sudan spokesman defending these statements. A deliberate policy of taking no prisoners during armed conflict constitutes a war crime. The Geneva Conventions prohibit ordering that there shall be no survivors. The Government of Sudan must ensure that the Sudan Armed Forces abide by international humanitarian law at all times."

And so on April 4, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Nesirky about it again. This time, Nesirky said "there's a couple of points here. There appears to be some controversy around the video itself.... as a general principle any incitement that could potentially lead to war crimes we would not welcome... There are already outstanding accusation against Mr. Harun, that's within the bailiwick of the prosecutor of the ICC, it's for them to deal with that."

So that's why Gaddafi's "rats" comment got him into trouble? He hadn't yet been indicted by the ICC?

This takes place in the context of Ban Ki-moon being slow to criticize his envoy to Darfur Ibrahim Gambari for taking photos with ICC indictee Omar al Bashir at a wedding reception for Chad's Idriss Deby and the daughter of Musa Hilal, founder of the janjaweed militia. Then after Ban issued wan and belated criticism, and Gambari said in essence that he would do it again, Ban said nothing.

In further context, Ban has had nothing to say as Sri Lankan General Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted engaged in war crimes in Ban's own Panel of Experts report, was named to Ban's Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations. It was a decision of member states, Ban told Inner City Press, and nothing since. From photos with Bashir to no comment on Silva and now Harun: this is Ban's UN.