Saturday, April 7, 2012

At UN on Mali, France Defers to ECOWAS on Sanctions, UN's Ban Silent

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- The UN and countries like France often says that sanctions should be targeted, so that civilians do not suffer. But when ECOWAS this week closed the borders of Mali, with an eye to shutting down the country's electrical grid, former colonial power France supported it, and the UN had nothing to say.

French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud came to the stakeout to brag about a draft statement he had introduced, supporting ECOWAS. Inner City Press asked him about the impact of the sanctions, and to explain why Foreign Minister Alain Juppe said France would not intervene in Mali while it played the key role in ousting Laurent Gbagbo in Cote d'Ivoire. Video here, from Minute 2:09.

Araud stammered that "the only difference between Cote D'ivoire and Mali is that in Cote d'Ivoire we had a UN mandate, resolution 1975.... [here] we are not doing to ask for it, no French intervention in Mali."

He continued, "As for sanctions, it's decision by ECOWAS, they have knowledge of the region, president Sal in Dakar, [Blaise] Campoure will be mediator, the coup leader has announced he is going to restore constitutional order, Inshallah."

A country like France which make pronouncement on human rights and the protection of civilians, it is not enough to simply to defer to a regional group. Did Jean-Maurice Ripert defer to ASEAN, when he called for intervention in Myanmar?

But this is a former French colony, and so there is more than meets the eye. At the UN's noon briefing on Tuesday, Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: On Mali, some are saying that the ECOWAS sanctions, they’re closing the borders, that there are already people lining up for gas, they are not targeted in any way. So, I heard you say that the UN humanitarians are concerned about shortages, but Valerie Amos, for example, on South Sudan said that they should keep pumping oil because of humanitarian needs. What does the UN say about a sanctions regime that would essentially close the border and block the entry into, of consumer goods like gasoline. Is that, how is it consistent to talk about shortages when they are being caused by the sanctions?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, these are measures that have been introduced by the regional organization, ECOWAS. I would refer you to them to ask about that. From a purely humanitarian point of view, it is obvious that the sooner that the political side of this can be dealt with, and we can get back to constitutional order in the country, the easier it will be to deal with the humanitarian crisis that existed even before this, and has obviously been exacerbated by the developments of recent days. I think that’s what we have at the moment. I will come back to you.

But hours later, nothing more than been provided. Watch this site.

At UN on Somalia, Diplomat Admits Probe & Firing, Mercenaries Not Known

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- To represent Somalia at the UN is not easy. Tuesday with the Permanent Representive and his Deputy Idd Bidl Mohamed both away, First Secretary Omar Jamal held a press conference trying to put the country in the best light. Inner City Press asked about mercenaries and human right violations. Video here, from Minute 19.

Omar Jamal would not answer about the mercenaries, and said that rights violations are "under investigation." He said this is "under strict investigation by the government, there has not been any denial of this." In fact, there was been denial.

Perhaps reflecting his Minneapolis diaspora roots, Omar Jamal said the Al Shabab's suicide bombers in Mogadishu are targeting "soft targets before bars" -- how many bars are there, in Mogadishu, despite the recent MSM pitch of its gentrification?

Inner City Press asked about the TFG's contract to protect the coast with Nairobi based Halliday Finch, a topic it has asked the UN about, without answer. Omar Jamal said, "I am not aware of that, I think I cannot comment, I am not aware of it."

And so Inner City Press asked about a specific UN - Somalia issue: the unceremonious firing in January 2012 of Deputy SRSG Christian Manahl, just after Ban Ki-moon visited the country.

Omar Jamal said, "I am aware of his dismissal, but I am not going to get into the reasons. On record, he has been dismissed. He would be the perfect person to respond, why and under what circumstances."

But Ban Ki-moon gives in to host countries, most recently in Sierra Leone, and then those fired don't talk, perhaps hoping for another UN job.

From the UN's March 30 transcript:

Inner City Press: On Somalia, there are reports saying that the Transitional Federal Government has contracted with a private security firm based in Nairobi called Halliday Finch to patrol its coast. I wanted to know, one, whether there is any UN involvement — whether Mr. [Augustine P.] Mahiga is aware of this, whether this constitutes the use of mercenaries, the reason I am asking this is that Halliday Finch being involved in this transfer of 17 pirates who were in the Seychelles, now transferred to Somaliland, which UNODC said it played a role in, issued a press release about. My real question here is whether the UN is in fact directly or indirectly involved with a mercenary firm in its work in Somalia.

Deputy Spokesperson Eduardo Del Buey: No, we’ll have to get information on that; I don’t have anything with me on that.

And still nothing... Watch this site.

As Colombia Pushes Back at UN on Child Soldiers, Its FM Seeks UN Post from Craven Ban Ki-moon?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3, updated -- While Colombia pushes back against the UN on child soldiers and other issues, its foreign minister Maria Angela Holguin is said by Inner City Press sources to be seeking a senior UN post, as early as June.

On April 3 at the UN, Inner City Press asked a panel from the Watchlist on Child and Armed Conflict about Colombia's record. The answers ranged from the government's pressure on and against the UN mechanism to its opposition to inquiries by the International Criminal Court, in which outgoing ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo concurred.

As Inner City Press reported from the Security Council, in connection with the last briefing by also outgoing Special Representative on Children and Armed Conflict Radhika Coomaraswamy, Colombia accused Coomaraswamy of mission creep, saying that the UN should stay out of the issue. The argument, made more recently, is that this is merely crime, and not technically armed conflict.

While pushing back on the UN, Holguin is said to be seeking a UN job. There are only four open Under Secretary General positions in New York available: Public Information, Economic and Social Affairs, Field Support and Conference Services.

Some wonder how Ban Ki-moon's five year rule applies for example to Alicia Barcena at ECLAC, when her counterpart in Africa has recently been replaced.

How craven, some wonder, can Ban Ki-moon become? He has ceded UN Peacekeeping to France, and Political Affairs to the US. But, the question goes, to give a USG post to a country and official which pushes back at the UN?

The Watchlist in responding to Inner City Press noted child soldiers in Myanmar as well. Ban Ki-moon has said he may go there this month. But would he raise child soldiers?

From Tuesday's UN noon briefing, on the topic of DPA and Inner City Press' scoop on Jeffrey Feltman:

Spokesperson Nesirky: The recruitment process for these positions — and I am talking in particular about the ones that were recently advertised, unusually so, as you know, — but that’s a recruitment process that is under way. And when it is completed, we will make the appropriate announcements. I don’t have anything at the moment. I think you can also rest assured that our colleagues in the various departments are perfectly able to keep things moving along quite smoothly. Yes, Matthew?

Inner City Press: One follow-up on that. Some people say that, DPI, DGACM, DESA — these were all advertised in The Economist and there is a whole process, where as DPA wasn’t. So, some people interpret this to mean this is designated for the United States, maybe for Jeffrey Feltman. And I just wonder, what is the rationale for advertising some empty USG posts and not others — other than the explanation that I have just offered you?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, it sounds like you are doing my job for me. So, I am not sure I need to answer that. I think put simply, there is a transparent process under way to appoint senior officials, and when we have announcements to make on these appointments we will do so. I don’t have anything else at the moment.

Watch this site.

After Budget Committee Curtails his "Coup," Ban Thanks Them for Feedback

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- The day after UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's attempt to bypass the General Assembly with a "Change Management" program now led by his right hand man Kim Won-soo was roundly rejected by in three 90 to 47 votes in the Budget Committee, Ban issued a wan statement thanking member states for their input.

Monday night Inner City Press exclusively covered the rejection of a US sponsored amendment to the Group of 77's resolution requiring Ban to come for GA approval of Change Management, rather than make moves unilaterally in what some took to calling Ban's coup.

Tuesday at the UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky what Ban thought of what several member states called a debacle. Nesirky had no comment except that he might have something later.

Tuesday at 6:27 pm Nesirky informed the press that he belatedly had this to say:

In response to questions about the Fifth Committee and the Secretary-General's Change Management plans, the Spokesperson has the following to say:

The Secretary-General appreciates the interest of all Member States in the recommendations included in that report. In particular, the Secretary-General notes the constructive comments and feedback received over the last several days. The Secretary-General provides his assurances that he will, as requested, seek consideration and prior approval for the implementation of those recommendations referred to in the resolution.

Then why was Ban trying to bypass the General Assembly? And why did he think it would be allowed, especially as he's overseen a $433 million cost overrun on the Capital Master Plan?

One particularly well-placed Budget Committee diplomat snarked that "it was very amusing to hear Ambassador Torsella say that the Secretary General should be able to change air travel regulations on his own authority, despite the fact that the US negotiators were engaging on the draft resolution on air travel dealing with these issues throughout the first resumed session.

"Moreover, Ambassador Susan Rice herself was on the phone to a number of G-77 Perm Reps, trying to get them not to vote for the resolutions. Demarches were also made in capitals. In his letter to member states transmitting the change plan, Ban 'acknowledged broad endorsement' of the recommendations. It would be interesting to know if, after last night, he still feels there is broad endorsement."

This is not answered in Ban's wan statement.

From the UN's transcript of its April 3 noon briefing:

Inner City Press: Last night in the Fifth Committee, usually no votes are taken, but last night votes were taken, three votes, it was Ban Ki-moon’s change management proposal which the EU and the US wanted t go through without GA review. In fact, it has been made subject to GA review. Many people decried it, the G-77 won the vote — 93 to 47, and I just wonder, what does the Secretary-General think? Does he, does he now intend to bring those proposals to the GA? And also one smaller question that arose was this position, this, Robert Orr, Mr. Robert Orr position of public-private partnerships, is it in the budget? What Department is it in and how is it funded?

Spokesperson: On the latter question, I’d have to check with you, Matthew; I’ll check for you, Matthew. On the first part, I think I’ll probably have something to say a little bit later on this, but I don’t have anything right now.

The Bob Orr question has yet to be answered, even as of April 7 -- watch this site.