Saturday, April 14, 2012

On Syria SC Diplomat Tells ICP of "Kofi Letter," Tuesday Briefing, Slams Banning

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 9, updated -- The UN Security Council may be briefed Tuesday about Syria, a Security Council Permanent Representative told Inner City Press on Monday night, referring to a "letter from Kofi... we need clarification on the ceasefire deadline."

[At 11 pm April 9 Inner City Press wrote a follow up story quoting sources that Annan will move to give Assad an extension and, separately, specifying that Annan's deputy Guehenno be on video, confirmed to Inner City Press by Annan's spokesman on April 10. Click here for that story, itself being updated.]

This diplomat, contrary to others' defense of cutting off UN Television coverage on April 5 before Syria could responded to Annan's and others' speeches, told Inner City Press that the cut-off was "not the standard process," and made the UN look bad.

Another Council diplomat, also present, wondered by Inner City Press hadn't yet in April writing about what he called the "lack of productivity under the US presidency" of the Council. He hearkened back to CNN using the need to "check in with Atlanta" as excuse for cutting off Omar Abdel-Rahman when accused in the (first) World Trade Center bombing, as he mentioned the US' support for Hosni Mubarak.

Earlier on Monday, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky for Ban's position on Saudi Arabia and Qatar, the country of the President of the General Assembly who determined to cut UN TV on Syria's defense, funding the salaries of Syrian rebels:

Spokesperson Nesirky: The Secretary-General has wide-ranging contacts, and I would simply remind you that he has said repeatedly, including in his remarks to the General Assembly, that militarization, further militarization of what is happening is really not desirable. Yes, Matthew?

Inner City Press: I wanted to ask, what does he think of this as opposed to militarization the idea of paying the salaries of the Free Syrian Army, which is something that Saudi Arabia and Qatar are now saying at the Friends of Syria meeting that they would begin to provide funds for either the opposition or armed rebels, is that… does that fall into his idea of militarization or is that okay?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I would simply say that militarization is not desirable.

But what about paying salaries? Watch this site.

Amid Ban's Duplicity, Sri Lanka Says S. Korea Supports Silva, Who's Away from UN

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 9 -- On Sri Lanka, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has long tried to have it both ways. During the slaughter in April and May 2009 he refused to call for a ceasefire (unlike for example Syria now). But later after pressure he appointed a three person Panel of Expert to advise him after the fact on accountability.

Now Ban's duplicity is ever more in focus. He refused to comment on the Asia Group nominating to his Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping its member Sri Lanka, who sent General Shavendra Silva whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel's report as engaged in war crimes.

Ban's appointed expert Louise Frechette, after pressure, issued a one-way press release that Silva's participation was "inappropriate." Ban did not back this up.

On April 2, Inner City Press went to see if Silva was still attending that day's SAG meeting. A UN Security officer came to speak with Inner City Press then went inside the meeting room; he emerged to say that no one had asked that Inner City Press be removed (as Sri Lanka had during the last meeting), and so Inner City Press could stay.

Later, Ban's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit told Inner City Press that the SAG's "organizers" -- whoever they are -- did not invite media coverage, and Inner City Press should henceforth only attend with MALU (and Ban) minders. Click here for that.

On April 9 at an event attended by Ban Ki-moon, Inner City Press sought and obtained clarification from Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative to the UN. Before the conversation was broken up -- not by Kohona -- it emerged that the only reason Silva did not attend the April 2 meeting of the SAG was that Silva was out of town.

Tellingly, it was said that South Korea, which sponsored the event that Ban and Kohona were at, was mad at Frechette for barring Silva. So which side is Ban on? Watch this site.

In UN GA, Ban's "Coup" Voted Down 98-48 As He Won't Disclose Funding

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 9 -- The vote against giving UN Secretary General the "Change Management" powers he wants grew more pronounced Monday in the UN General Assembly, where a US-sponsored pro-Ban amendment was voted down with 48 in favor (up one from the Budget Committee vote on April 2), 97 against (up nine from April 2), with four abstentions.

Delegates told Inner City Press that while most of the increased opposition to Ban's Change Management power-grab or "coup" represented countries which had not been present on April 2, it was significant that what they called the US "lobbying" had not had success.

To many, the vote was not a set-back for Ban's so-called reform, but rather an expression of democratization at the UN: an openly pro-West Secretary General should not be able to bypass the other member states in the General Assembly. That Ban thought he could do it, the analysis goes, show him to be out of touch.

A senior Fifth Committee source early on April 9 said that maybe Ban's new chief of staff Susana Malcorra would come and speak to the General Assembly before the vote, to try to sway some votes. It did not happen. Rather, after the US amendment was voted down, the Group of 77 sponsored resolution calling Ban to account was passed, 98 in favor (up one from minutes before), 48 against and four abstaining.

Afterward the European Union predicted an upcoming fight on the scales of assessment, and US Ambassador Joe Torsella, whose positions we'd like to understand and be able to explain in a non "one-way" fashion, again decried the deferral of changes including to travel. He has spoken of interns flying business class, and a proposal for Ban officials to fly Economy class on flights below six hours in a single country.

While some say Ban can't practice what he preaches, there are questions about the size of delegations he takes with him, and why he won't routinely disclose when he take non-UN travel and how it is not a conflict of interest.

Only because the Qatari President of the General Assembly acknowledged it was a confirmation received by Inner City Press that Ban used a Qatar government -- that is, royal family -- jet. What has he flown on since, and what will he fly on in the future? Change management, indeed. Watch this site.

An analysis: again, the irony here is that the US and EU put their "reform" -- often meaning "cost cutting" -- faith in Ban Ki-moon, who is hardly a reformer and has for example overseen a $433 million cost overrun on the Capital Master Plan.

It seems to some they do not really see him as a reformer -- how could they? -- but rather as someone they can and do control. But the opposition, then, is not between GA or G77 "bureacracy" and agile reform, but between whether a Western controlled puppet should be free to do what the West says, or have to answer UN democracy style to other member states...

As UN Cites Immunity for Haiti Cholera, Ban as the Face of Impunity

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 9 -- Haiti shouldn't even be hosting a UN Peacekeeping mission, human rights lawyer Mario Joseph told the Press on Monday. The $800 million it is spending a year should instead be spent on reparations for having brought cholera, and on a new water system.

Inner City Press asked Joseph what he thought of the response, or non-response, of UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, who has pointed again and again to the inconclusive findings of a panel whose members have since said the UN's role in bringing cholera to Haiti has been proved. Joseph replied that immunity cannot -- or at least, should not -- mean impunity.

His fellow panelist and translator, Brian Concannon of the Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti, added that there should be a General Assembly resolution by member states, telling the UN -- that is, the Secretariat and Department of Peacekeeping Operations -- to be accountable for cholera.

Abby Goldberg of the New Media Advocacy Project told Inner City Press that the film she had just screened was intended to help civil society to demand accountability from the UN.

Inner City Press would suggest that future edits of the film put a face on the UN and personalize it. For months the claim for compensation has been "studied," without comment, by chief UN legal officer Patricia O'Brien. Ban Ki-moon has dodged questions about accountability, even while reading out speeches demanding it from others. The footage is there: now it's time to focus. Watch this site.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky on April 2, 2012, about the

Inner City Press: article about Haiti and cholera, and they go into great detail and they say that, even the members of the panel that the UN cites so much, say that new evidence tends to show that it was introduced by the UN. There is a quote by Mr. Banbury to the contrary, but virtually everything else in the article points to the UN and says it is… the UN’s refusal to take responsibility has led to further problems in Haiti. And so, I wonder, I have seen Mr. Banbury’s quote, but is there any reflection on the UN on the mounting evidence that they are responsible for the introduction of cholera into Haiti?

Spokesperson: Well, I think, as we have said on numerous occasions, there are a couple of points. One is that the UN has indeed received claims related to cholera in Haiti, and it is studying those claims. And this is obviously a highly complex matter which will require thorough consideration. And given the unique nature of the claim, needless to say, this will take some time. And I think, as you can appreciate, when it comes to claims, that is not unusual. The UN has advised the claimant that it is looking into the matter. So, that’s the first thing. The second thing is that, as you mentioned, there was the report of the independent Panel of Experts and, as you will recall, that Panel concluded that it was not possible to be conclusive about how cholera was introduced into Haiti. And as I say, the claims are being studied and, therefore, at this point, I don’t have any further comment, including on the New York Times story.

Inner City Press: just to make it a little more pointed, it seems like some of the panellists have now been quoted as saying that some subsequent scientific research makes the… they no longer stand behind the idea that it can’t be proved. They are saying it pretty much has been proved, so…

Spokesperson: Well, as I say, there was that Panel, there were the findings from that Panel, and clearly, at this point, given that the UN has received claims and those claims are being looked into, we don’t have any further comment right now, okay?

And not for the week since, either. Watch this site.

Ban's UN Silent 13 Hours as Saleh Gunmen Take Yemen Airport

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- The UN has touted as a rare success its role in Yemen, where Ali Saleh ostensibly stepped down in exchange for impunity. But now that gunmen loyal to Saleh have taken over the Sana'a airport, the UN has nothing to say.

Early on April 7 -- 13 hours ago as of this initial publication -- Inner City Press asked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's two top spokesman if Ban had "any comment (or calls) about the reported closing of the Sana'a airport by elements of Yemen's military?"

Ban's office provided no comment or response, even as it sent out messages touting an upcoming "Google +" chat by Ban with young people, presumably in Yemen as well. Ban's UN likes good news, at any cost.

The day previous, it declined any comment on the death of Malawi's president until after for example the US had chimed in an urged the transition of power to the vice president. Only once that happened did Ban timidly comment.

Some skeptics wonder if in this case, Ban wants to see if Salah emerges stronger, so that Ban is not found criticizing a strongman who is returning to the fore.

Last year when the impunity deal was announced, Ban appeared in the half light in front of the Security Council to deliver prepared quotes to selected friendly journalists. Inner City Press was there was well, as that is from where it works. After Ban delivered sound bites about his conversation that day with Saleh, Inner City Press asked if he had raised the amnesty. It wasn't discussedin detail, Ban said.

Now Ban is silent as Saleh's men take over the capital's airport. There are others in the UN who have tried to work against impunity. But Ban is not among them -- Ban has allowed, without comment or "discussion in detail" beyond saying it's entirely up to member states, an alleged war criminal to become his adviser on peacekeeping operations. And so it goes in Ban's UN.