Saturday, April 7, 2012

After Central African Republic Happy Talk, Press Asks of Kony, UN Nepotism

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- When the Prime Minister of the Central African Republic Faustin-Archange Touadera briefed the press at the UN on Thursday, it was mostly happy talk about disarmament. Touadera said that all armed groups are ready to stand down, and he was asked light questions about the technicalities of so-called DDR.

Inner City Press then asked Touadera about the Lord's Resistance Army, how big a problem it is, how his country works with the 100 US military advisers sent by the Obama administration, and whether he thought the Kony 2012 film and phenomenon is helpful, or a problem has Uganda has said.

Touadera adroitly turned the question around, saying that countries should help finance disarmament so that the Central African army can focus on the LRA. He thanked the African Union, and the US for its 100 militaires.

Already Touadera had answered that most of the LRA is in the Central African Republic, but then he got asked by the original light journalist if he thinks Joseph Kony is there. The focus of the briefing shifted and again one wondered, it is helpful?

Inner City Press asked Margaret Vogt, the Special Representative and Head of the United Nations Integrated Peacebuilding Office in the Central African Republic (BINUCA), if the UN is yet in Obo, and if she has acted to reform the critique of the UN in CAR as a "family operation" -- specifically, of DPA's Sammy Buo (for background see here and below).

Vogt responded at length about the "UN family," saying she has created task forces and a "cell" in her office about protection. She said "we are given mandates but not money," and appeared to say the UN has yet to have an ongoing presence in Obo. The UN now has a plane, she said, and so flies back and forth to Obo.

Here, however, was the part of the critique:

Inner City Press formally asked the director of DPA's Africa II Division Sammy Kum Buo the following questions:

Mr. Buo -- I am writing a story about this morning's Security Council session on BONUCA / Central African Republic. I am also covering management issues in BONUCA and DPA and am writing for you to confirm or deny on deadline each of the following [about BONUCA staffers]

Is Gabriel Buh Kang a relative of yours? A cousin?

Is BONUCA staffer Ekei a relative of yours? Your niece?

What is the status of Brindou Germain Kabran ?

When in CAR, have you stayed with Brindou Germain Kabran?

Did you still collect DSA? Please provide records.

What can you say about the case of Gozo Tshamala?

On deadline, Matthew

Mr. Buo is also accused of hiring a former mercenary from Executive Outcomes, in violation of UN rules. While Mr. Buo has refused to respond, Inner City Press has discussed the matter with other Mission officials and finally with Mr. Buo's then-boss in DPA, Haile Menkerios. Mr. Menkerios confirmed he is aware of the issue. Inner City Press asked Mr. Menkerios what DPA's response would be. It is a management issue, Mr. Menkerios replied, that will be responded to in a management way.

But has it been? It is still not sure. Wach this site.

IMF On Sri Lanka Deficit, No Reference to Defense, No Timeline for Egypt Deal

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- At the International Monetary Fund's briefing on April 5, Inner City Press asked about Egypt and Sri Lanka. The Egyptian answer was short and picked up by wire services -- "the timeline for concluding an agreement is not fixed and will depend on how quickly progress is made by all sides on these issues" -- but the Sri Lanka answer was provided later and so is published here.

Inner City Press asked, "What is the status of the IMF's program in Sri Lanka? Is the IMF only looking at balance of payments? When would it consider releasing the next and final tranche?"

Later, just after embargo deadline, the following came in:

From: IMF Media Relations
Date: Thu, Apr 5, 2012 at 10:37 AM
Subject: Question Received
To: Matthew Russell Lee [at] InnerCityPress.com

Dear Matthew, Thank you for your question. Please attribute the following to Gerry Rice, Director of External Relations Department, IMF.

On April 2, the Executive Board approved the completion of the Seventh Review of the Stand By Arrangement, which enables the disbursement of SDR 275.6 million (approximately $400 million). The Board also approved the extension of the program by 2 months to July 2012 to allow time for the completion of the Eighth and final review.

The main pillars of the program are to rebuild Sri Lanka’s reserves, while transitioning to a more flexible monetary and exchange rate policy framework, reducing the budget deficit to sustainable levels, and strengthening the financial system.

This follows back and forth with the IMF regarding Sri Lanka's increased defense spending.

The question of if the IMF is only looking at balance of payments refers, for example, to the recent UN Human Rights Council resolution on Sri Lanka and accountability for crimes in the final stages of its military conflict in May 2009 -- after which defense spending continued nevertheless to climb, impacting the very budget deficit the IMF refers to.

Meanwhile the military SCAF government in Egypt is reportedly poised to take out an IMF loan. Inner City Press asked, What is the IMF's reaction to the reported deal in Egypt around an IMF program? Will the program now go forward? Does the IMF think enough 'stakeholders' agree?"

It was to that that the IMF responded, "the timeline for concluding an agreement is not fixed and will depend on how quickly progress is made by all sides on these issues." Watch this site.

As Somalia Says It OKs US Drone Strikes, Susan Rice Doesn't Confirm

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- The day after the acting chief of Somalia's mission to the UN told Inner City Press that his country's Transitional Federal Government has given approval to, and gets prior notification of US drone strikes against Al Shabaab, Inner City Press asked US Ambassador Susan Rice about it.

Rice said she wouldn't comment on intelligence matters, but that the US remains "extremely focused" on Al Shabaab. Transcript below.

The Obama administration's use of drones has been a matter of controversy not only in Pakistan, which is serving on the UN Security Council with the US, but also in Yemen, whose human rights minister says she has complained to the US about particular killings of civilians.

The acting chief of Somalia's mission, Omar Jamal, is in fact neither the Permanent Representative nor Deputy Permanent Representative -- both, Jamal told Inner City Press, are away on business. But Jamal made his comments about US drones on camera, reiterating that he spoke for the TFG.

Last month when Amnesty International issued a report on executions, Inner City Press asked AI's representative to the UN about US drone strikes, as rationalized by Attorney General Eric Holder, and the response was that the US strikes are not viewed as judicial executions.

Inner City Press was told that the US State Department's legal department might be responding but has yet to see such a response. Once aware of one, it will be published.

Meanwhile, the head of UN Peacekeeping Herve Ladsous proposed in a closed door session of the UN Special Committee on Peacekeeping that the UN start using surveillance drones, as exclusively reported by Inner City Press then subsequently confirmed by the UN.

A member of this C-34 Committee tells Inner City Press the word is that Ladsous, the fourth Frenchman in a row at the top of UN Peacekeeping, already has a French company, Thales, in mind. Watch this site.

From the US Mission transcript:

Inner City Press: Yesterday the Somali mission's first secretary, Omar Jamal, held a press conference, among other things here. And he said that his government, the TFG, has given permission to the U.S. to use unmanned aerial vehicles or drones to make strikes in Somalia fighting Al Shabaab. So it seems sort of-I wanted to know, is that the case? And what is the U.S.'s role itself-I understand, in your national capacity-in actually fighting Al Shabaab who has claimed credit for this national theater bombing?

Ambassador Rice: I'm not going to get into matters that relate to intelligence. I will say that the United States has been and remains extremely focused-as do all members of the international community-on combating the terrorist threat that Al Shabaab poses, as an active threat not only to Somali but to the people of the region and beyond, in particular, given its active affiliation with Al Qaeda. So we'll continue to work with partners in Somalia and beyond to deal effectively with the Al Shabaab threat.

UN Blacks Out Syria's Speech, Ban's Amateur Hour & Minute of Silence?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- When Kofi Annan gave a briefing by video to the UN General Assembly Thursday morning, though the press was not allowed in the conference room, the speech was broadcast on UN Television. So too the speeches by the Qatari President of the GA Nassir Abdulaziz Al-Nasser, and Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.

But just as Syria's Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari took the floor to respond, UN TV went dark. To some it seemed, especially with regard to the speeches of Ban and the PGA, like hearing the prosecution but blacking out the defense -- and thereby even giving the defense an issue. Welcome to amateur hour.

Inner City Press asked the spokeswoman for the PGA why UN TV had stopped broadcasting. It was agreed, she said. Inner City Press asked, "Agreed by whom?"

Through the windows of the ECOSOC chamber, the Press could see the Permanent Representative of Saudi Arabia speaking, then another country which "raised its flag" or asked to speak but was not permitted.

Meanwhile, despite the argument that it was a closed meeting, the French Mission to the UN was tweeting from inside, decrying the "rant" of the Syrian Ambassador. When French Permanent Representive Gerard Araud left mid-speech, Inner City Press asked him about the curtailed UNTV coverage but he did not answer. Cradle of media freedom?

When the session was over several Permanent Representatives were critical of what they called "the PGA's use of the UN for Qatar's foreign policy." As Ban Ki-moon swept out and into the elevator up to his third floor office, Inner City Press asked why UN TV, which the Secretariat controls, was turned off.

Thirty minutes later at the noon briefing by Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky, Inner City Press asked why the cameras had been turned off. Nesirky said, as the PGA's spokeswoman had at some length, that it was an informal meeting, therefore not televised.

Inner City Press asked, but why then was a portion of the informal meeting televised?

Nesirky said, because there was public interest in it.

But there was some interest in hearing from Syria, too, Inner City Press asked, trying to understand.

You're not trying very hard to understand, Nesirky said. Moments later when Inner City Press asked him what Ban thought of Ja'afari's request that a moment of silence be observed for "all" the victims in Syria, and if Ban had observed it, Nesirky referred the question back to the PGA's spokeswoman.

But it's a question for Ban: did he observe the requested moment of silence or not?

Inner City Press recounted that in the untelevised portion of the meeting Saudi Arabia's Permanent Representative said that if the Syrian government cared about victims, it would stop killing, and asked if Ban shares that view.

Nesirky said that Ban has spoken about the dead of Syria. Again, it's a question for Ban: did he observe the requested moment of silence or not?

Once the noon briefing was over, Nesirky's office announced that Syria's Ja'afari would now hold a press conference at 3 pm. Watch this site.