Saturday, April 7, 2012

At UN on Syria, Rice Says Assad Unfit to Govern, Defends Helping Rebels, But Obama Told Kiir Not To in Sudan

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- Why does the Obama administration treat Syria and Sudan differently? Why does it defend Qatar and Saudi Arabia paying the Free Syrian Army, while President Obama on April 2 told South Sudan's Salva Kiir not to help the SPLM-North in Southern Korfofan?

When US Ambassador Susan Rice took ten questions from the media on Tuesday, the first eight were about Syria. In response she said that Bashar al Assad is "unfit to govern."

Before Rice turned to a question from Twitter, also on Syria, Inner City Press asked if a Sudan question would be taken. Yes, Rice allowed.

After Rice praised the mediation led by Thabo Mbeki, Inner City Press asked why the Sudanese opposition is being told to disarm and join the Qatar brokered process on Darfur, and not to seek regime change, especially since Sudan's Omar al Bashir, unlike Syria's Assad, has already been indicted by the International Criminal Court along with his defense minister and crony Ahmed Harun, who after being flown to Abyei by the UN was filmed saying "take no prisoners"?

Rice replied that "our policy in Syria is to resolve it if possible... through a Syrian-led political process, quite similar to our view of optimal outcome in Sudan."

This does not answer if Rice and the US think that Sudan's Bashir is also "unfit to govern," nor who killed more people?

As to Sudan, Rice said that "war and fighting for generations" have not brought "greater freedom or greater security." So is it that the Sudanese opposition had their chance at changing the government but have not succeeded, and so should stop trying?

Or is the US priority the development of their ally South Sudan, such that leaving Bashir in relative peace is the strategy?

Rice continued, rather than about Sudan as a whole including the youth movement, that "Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile are... inherently political, but Khartoum has decided not to deal at the negotiating table" and so is "facing an intensified rebellion."

But the US is telling South Sudan not to assist the rebellion in Sudan, while in the same press conference, as she had in response to Inner City Press' question the day previous at the stakeout, she defended Qatar and Saudi Arabia paying Syrian rebels, and the US providing communications equipment to the opposition. What's the difference?

On the topic of Sudan's four ICC indictees, Rice insisted that the US is at the forefront of "demanding justice and accountability for genocide and war crimes" by Bashir and those around him.

But did the US and Rice criticized the UN, then, for providing free flights to ICC indictee Ahmed Harun to and from Abyei?

Have they commented publicly on Harun's statements on video that no prisoners should be taken? Or on joint UN - African Union envoy to Darfur Ibrahim Gambari taking photos with Bashir at a wedding reception for Chad's Idriss Deby and the daughter of Musa Hilal, the Janjaweed leader? Watch this site.

Footnotes: Rice explained that she had to leave for a lunch and then retreat with Ban Ki-moon. It was also noted that the impending North Korean missile launch, a topic of much concern to the many reporters for Japanese media in the UN audience, was not broached.

In the run-up to Rice's press conference on the Security Council's program of work for April, Inner City Press asked via Twitter why the US is not having a Horizon or DPA briefing -- especially strange since the US controls DPA, now with Lynn Pascoe and prospectively, as first reported by Inner City Press last week and asked at Tuesday's UN noon briefing, by Jeffrey Feltman. Watch this site.

From the US Mission to the UN's transcript:

Inner City Press: I just want to ask you this: You said that, as to President Assad of Syria, that he's unfit to govern because he's killed his people and all these things. It seems to some that the U.S. and certainly the Security Council is calling on the opposition in Sudan to not seek regime change, to disarm, to become part of the Darfur process in other ways. So what's the difference, given that Omar Al-Bashir, Ahmed Haroun, the defense minister, they've all been indicted for war crimes and genocide and crimes against humanity. What's the difference in terms of telling the opposition not to seek a change of government in the same way you do elsewhere?

AMBASSADOR RICE: Well, first of all, our policy in Syria is that this should be resolved, if possible, through a negotiated, Syrian-led, political process that results in a democratic dispensation for the people of Syria. That's quite similar to our view as to what is the optimal outcome in the context of Sudan, where there has been war and fighting for generations, and it has not led to greater freedom or greater security for many of the people of Sudan.

The challenge of Southern Kordofan and indeed Blue Nile is inherently a political one, as both sides recognize in the context of the CPA. The problem is that the government in Khartoum has decided not to deal with this at the negotiating table, and so they are facing an intensified rebellion. But the prescriptions are analogous. And yes, we have been at the forefront of demanding justice and accountability for genocide and war crimes committed by President Bashir and many around him, and that remains a central part of U.S. policy. Let me end.

UN Ban's Unilateral Changes Voted Down, As He Flies Qatar Jets, Favors Friends

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 2 -- In what must be seen as a failure for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and those who support him, Ban's plan to beginning implementing "change management" without General Assembly approval was resoundingly voted down on Monday night.

After deadlines passed votes were called. The United States proposed a pro-Ban amendment to a resolution introduced by Algeria for the Group of 77. The US amendment lost, with only 47 for, five abstaining and 88 against.

Then US Ambassador Joe Torsella provided to divide Algeria's resolution in two. After much confusion, this too was voted down, with 48 in favor, four abstaining and now 91 against.

Finally, Algeria's resolution which requires Ban to come to the GA was adopted with 93 for, 47 against and give abstaining. Afterward, Torsella said that Ban should not have to come to the General Assembly about his dictat that others fly economy class.

But Ban for example flies in Qatar's fancy jet, disclosed only after Inner City Press repeatedly had to ask. It remains unclear if Ban will disclose when he accepts such gifts, which may present a conflict of interest, from particular member states.

This is the problem with Ban's reforms -- Ban is not reforming, witness the $433 million Capital Master Plan cost overrun under this watch, and he is not transparent. He proposed mobility for others, but kept his friends like Kim Won-soo close at hand by moving them laterally while staying in New York.

Another long time Executive Office of the S-G staffer previously covered, Inner City Press is reliably informed, didn't even want to leave his office on the North Lawn's third floor on April 2, for the short "mobility" move to the so-called Luggage Building. Some reformer. We will have more on this -- watch this site.

The session ended, as before, with Eritrea's Fifth Committee representatives praising the chairman but not the working methods, which he this time called "camping in Occupy Wall Street style in Conference Room 5."

Analysis: Some wonder, how can Ban and UN preach democracy while trying to bypass member states on their often hypocritical or only partially implemented "reform" proposals? The debate demonstrated once again the extent to which Ban is a man, or puppet, of the West.

In UN Budget Fight, Ban's Change Management Mistrusted, Vote Called

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 2, updated -- The UN Budget Committee was supposed to close this resumed session at 3 pm on Monday. But even at 5 pm, as Bhutan's event on happiness as an economic indicator continued, Budget Committee delegates milled around waiting for the outcome of a small meeting of Permanent Representatives in a small room next to the Bhutanese event.

Those inside included the Permanent Representative of Algeria, the chair of the Group of 77 and China, US Ambassador Joe Torsella, the EU and UK Deputy Permanent Representative Philip Parham. As he left, Parham told Inner City Press that things might come to a vote.

When the Committee convened, three drafts were circulated: on the Capital Master Plan and its $433 million cost over run, on the Office of Internal Oversight Services and makings its audits available online, and an "Accountability," mostly Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's so-called Change Management Plan.

The fight is one of separation of powers: how much can Ban do or try to do without General Assembly consent?

Before discussion of these three documents began, Inner City Press was told the leave the room, that it was an "informal" session. This seemed strange, since what chairman Tommo Monthe said might constitute a sort of legislative history of what was voted on.

In interviews just outside the conference room, Inner City Press gleaned that after Monthe's "plea," Russia spoke and called the Change Management paragraph 7 unbalanced. The chair of G-77 said much the same thing.

Inner City Press can report that the G-77 chair was summoned over to Monthe, who suggested an amendment. The G-77 chair said he would have to consult; he was willing to stay but it was just a vote, anyone can vote.

Soon the meeting was suspended for 20 minutes, and G-77 convened in a room across the hall. It seemed the vote was on, concerning what some call Ban Ki-moon's coup. Watch this site.

Update of 8:36 pm - as delegates gathered to vote, Chairman Monthe came and told Inner City Press there will be a vote on section 2 of Accountability, first on an amendment. There will be no vote on his proposed compromise. "Malcorra would come" and give assurances, but this wasn't believed either. A well-placed delegate told Inner City Press, "this is the test for Malcorra." One of her supporters by contrasted called it a "task." If only one could do that in school....

Syria Says Turks, Saudis & Qataris "Declare War," US Too, Rice Says Non-Lethal

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 2 -- After Kofi Annan gave a closed door briefing Monday to the UN Security Council, Ambassadors including those of Russia and China said that April's Council president Susan Rice of the US would give a summary and statement.

When Rice emerged she read from notes then took questions. Inner City Press asked if there had been a discussion of Gulf countries in the Friends of Syria group saying they will fund the rebels, and about the US provision of communications equipment to the opposition, are there any safeguards?

Ambassador Rice said that "one delegation" had raised the funding of the rebels issue. On US aid, she said it would be non-lethal.

Moments later Inner City Press asked Syrian Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari about this aid to the rebels and opposition. He quickly denounced the meeting in Istanbul of the "Enemies of Syria," going on to call the funding of rebels an act of war.

Inner City Press asked again about the US, and Ja'afari denounced this communications aid as well. He was asked about Turkey's assistance to refugees. He replied that Turkey is not an enemy of Syria, but Turkey's government should have consulted Damascus before hosting such a meeting and should stop talking about regime change.

Ja'afari referred to Annan as the UN envoy, and did not mention the Arab League, which has called for a "political transition" away from Assad. There is a game, of who Annan is representing. On March 31 a Security Council Ambassador, one of the Elected Ten and not Permanent Five, told the Press on background

Before Rice spoke, Russian Ambassador Churkin told the Press that it was a "good meeting" and that "Kofi Annan is working hard." Chinese Ambassador Li Baodong told the Press that "we are studying his proposal" and "we will have a chance to discuss." Will that mean a Security Council "output"? Watch this site.

From the UN Mission transcript:

Inner City Press: Was there any discussion-was there any discussion of the announcement by some of the Friends of Syria that they would begin to pay salaries to the Free Syrian Army or other rebels? And can you also say-the U.S. offered to provide communications equipment. Can you specify a little bit who would get it, whether it could have any lethal usage, and what safeguards are in place?

Ambassador Rice: Well, let me in my capacity as president be clear in saying, I think, if I'm not mistaken, only one delegation raised that issue. Most were focused on the contents of the Joint Special Envoy's briefing today. From the U.S. point of view-now speaking in my national capacity-as you know, we announced our readiness not only to increase our humanitarian assistance now to $25 million but also to begin to provide non-lethal assistance to the opposition, including in the form of communications equipment. That communications equipment is by its nature and by its definition non-lethal, and we will continue to work with other partners in the Friends of Democratic Syria, as was agreed in Tunis, to strengthen our efforts to support the effectiveness and coherence of the opposition.

On Syria, Annan Team Won't Comment on Funding Rebels, Confirms DPKO

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 2 -- In the run up to Kofi Annan's closed door briefing of the UN Security Council about Syria on Monday, the Friends of Syria moved to fund and aid the rebels, including a US pledge of communications equipment.

Inner City Press asked Annan's spokesman Ahmad Fawzi

Does the Joint Special Envoy have any view of or comment on the decision at the Friends of Syria meeting, attended by Deputy El-Kidwa, by Gulf states to start paying money to armed rebels in Syria, andthe possibility that these funds will be used to purchase weapons? What about the US saying it will provide communications equipment - does the JSE think there should be any restrictions on this? Will you confirm a DPKO advance team going early this week, and that the proposal is for 200 to 250 monitors?

Fazwi responded, but declined comment on assistance to the rebels:

Subject: Re: Hi, Q on outcome(s) of Friends of Syria meeting, and DPKO
Date: Mon, Apr 2, 2012 at 1:19 AM
To: Matthew Russell Lee [at] InnerCityPress.com
From: Ahmad Fawzi

I will not make any comment unti after the JSE briefs the Council today at 1000EST/1600CET.

I can confirm, however, the DPKO advance team getting ready to send advance team. No comment on figures, yet.

The figures were given out on Thursday March 29 by a "senior Western diplomat," seemingly sourced from the head of DPKO, the UN Peacekeeping department, who seen going into the Security Council's closed door briefing on Monday morning. As first reported by Inner City Press, he has proposed the use by the UN of drones -- some wonder if they would be useful, or are already fully in use by various parties, over Syria.

Another Security Council Permanent Representative, one of the Elected Ten and not Permanent Five, told the press on Friday March 31 on background that what he knew of DPKO's plans he only knew from reading the newspapers. And so it goes at the UN.