Saturday, November 12, 2011

To Reform UNSC, Japan Tries to Divide Africa, Others Try G-4 Split

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 8 -- With the perennial topic of UN Security Council reform the subject of speeches Tuesday in the General Assembly, the lack of seriousness with which the Council's five Permanent members took it was in evidence.

French Permanent Representative Gerard Araud, for example, cut out early with this spokesman from a Security Council consultation on upcoming elections in the Democratic Republic of the Congo -- but not to speak in France's slot in the General Assembly debate a mere two stories above.

Rather, he left his Deputy Permanent Representative Briens to deliver that speech.

Likewise the US, which has promised India for example its support for a permanent seat on the Council, was represented not by Susan Rice but rather her Deputy, Rosemary DiCarlo.

Shortly after DiCarlo's low key speech, when Cuba was speaking the UN Television camera swung back to where DiCarlo had been sitting. Now it was a junior US diplomat, typing on his cell phone.

Japan of course is lusting for more from the UN. Its Permanent Representative Nishita distributed his speech to the Press in advance, and chatted with Inner City Press on his way up to deliver it.

He announced a November 14 conference in Toyko. Not long after, a diplomat who will attend in Tokyo told Inner City Press succinctly, "Japan will be trying to divide Africa, but we'll be trying to divide the G-4." And so it goes at the UN.

Earlier on Tuesday countries reviewed the Security Council's annual report and actual performance. Ireland for example questioned the seriousness of the Council's all day thematic debates, saying that the promised interactivity was in practice nearly zero.

A member of the so-called S-5 suggested that the reports by each month's Council president should be more serious, and that the annual report should be distributed further in advance.

Amazingly, Nepal was listed as among the Council's successes in the year -- the UN was in fact thrown out -- while tardiness on Cote d'Ivoire was chided, while France used the Council to legitimize its Force Licorne's assault on the Presidential palace.

The P-5 do what they want and the rest just talk, as one wag put it. Speeches will continue on Wednesday. And so it goes at the UN.

As Linkin Park Joins UN on Energy Citing Haiti, No Cholera or BofA Coal Answers

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 8 -- As four members of the band Linkin Park stood with UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on November 8 talking about people in Haiti, five blocks south the plight of the more the six thousand Haitians killed by cholera which four reports say was brought in by the UN was being discussed.

Inner City Press, carrying a copy of the Petition for Relief filed with the UN on behalf of the Haitians ran to Ban Ki-moon's stakeout with Linkin Park, but Ban Ki-moon was gone.

Band member Mike Shinoda was speaking about participating in Ban's "Sustainable Energy for All" initiative, co-led by Charles Holliday the chairman of Bank of America, protested at Occupy Wall Street for being the number one funder of mountaintop removal coal mining.

Inner City Press asked Shinoda and the three others about the UN's role in the cholera in Haiti, and about Bank of America, MTR coal mining and if they would use their access to make the UN improve. Video here, from Minute 19:47.

Shinoda gestured to Ban Ki-moon's adviser on such issues, Bob Orr. Band member Brad Delson took the microphone but did not directly answer. He spoke about solar lamps the Linkin Park fan base helped purchase. He said, "We're here for humanitarian issues.. we're not politicians, we're musicians." Not a politician yet, one wag snarked.

But it's clear that the UN, and the UN Foundation wanted Linkin Park to appear with Ban. So how will the band use this access, given that the UN has so far claimed immunity when charged with misdeeds and negligence in Haiti and elsewhere?

Again Delson answered for the band, if not responded: "We're talking about solutions we believe in." Fine. To raise money for lamps in Haiti is good. But to appear, twice now, with Ban Ki-moon and the UN, one might expect some due diligence, some follow through. What do the (other) members of Linkin Park incluing Rob Bourdon and Joe Hahn who were at the stakeout but said nothing, and fan base, think of Bank of America and its practices?

Bob Orr finished up, saying that for sustainable energy "we need everyone on board." One wag wondered: BP? Bernie Madoff? It would seem a line is drawn somewhere: the question is where.

Footnote: Orr also said, "We are not hiding any facts... Yes Bank of America is involved." But less than an hour later at the UN's noon briefing when Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky why Orr is not even named on the list of Ban's senior officials making public financial disclosure, Nesirky had no answer. Watch this site.

Amid Cholera in Haiti Demand to UN for Negligence, Ban Brags With Linkin Park

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 8 -- More than a year after the cholera outbreak began in Haiti, on Tuesday lawyers seeking compensation from the UN for the victims spoke to the Press about the Petition for Relief they've filed with the UN Mission in Haiti, MINUSTAH, and the Office of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Video here.

Inner City Press asked lead counsel Ira Kurzban if similar evidence existed against a private corporation, if it would support the relief he is requesting. Absolutely, he said, the evidence is clear. There was no cholera in Haiti before the UN brought in peacekeepers from a region of Nepal beset by cholera.

Kurzban and Brian Concannon of the Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti said that the UN has been engaged in a cover-up, both of cholera among the contingent from Nepal and through the purportedly independent study Ban Ki-moon commissioned.

As Inner City Press asked the UN about with regard to Port Salut, where the most recent publicized incident of sexual abuse by UN personnel occurred, there is still evidence of the UN dumping garbage and sewage. IJDH says it wants to force an improvement of the UN's practices in Haiti.

But can they break though the UN's usual immunity?


The petition for relief says that the Status of Forces Agreement "requires that the UN establish a standing claims commission to settle all third-party claims."

Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky at Tuesday's noon briefing if MINUSTAH had, in fact, established such a claims commission. Nesirky said the UN is "studying the letter" from IJDH. But it is about the letter, it is a factual question: was a claims commission ever established, and has it adjudicated any cases?

Immediately after the IJDH question and answer session Inner City Press saw on UN Television -- which did not broadcast the Haiti press conference -- Ban Ki-moon speaking at the stakeout below his office with members of the Linkin Park band, mentioning the UN's good work in Haiti.

Inner City Press ran to the North Lawn building but was told that Ban Ki-moon has already left the stakeout. Inner City Press asked the members of Linkin Park, who had also spoken about Haiti, about the cholera issue.

They did not answer, deferring instead to Ban's Assistant Secretary General for "global goods" Robert Orr. The Linkin Park / Orr stakeout is a separate story. But tellingly, and as uncontroverted and unexplained by Nesirky, Orr is not even named on Ban's list of senior officials making public financial disclosure in 2010. Watch this site.

As Kissinger Protested, AIG's Greenberg Feted at CFR: Some Crimes Forgotten

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 7, updated with video -- Some crimes can never be forgotten, while others escape even articulation. Monday in Manhattan an old man chanted "Kissinger, mass murderer" in front of the Waldorf Astoria.

To the side of the entrance another protester with Occupy Wall Street on his jacket called "shame" to men in tuxedos, "love your botox" to companions on their arms.

Inside the New York Historical Society was giving an award to Henry Kissinger. Outside protesters held signs ranging from Vietnam to Cyprus and Angola, Cambodia to Bangladesh. "There's blood on your bow tie," an older women shouted. Soon the police would come. Inner City Press was told to move, but didn't.

While the protest was announced at a General Assembly at Zuccotti Park / Liberty Square, it was small by Occupy Wall Street standards. Many of the protesters had been on this beat for some time, with weathered signs about East Timor and apartheid, also Salvador Allende.

(c) MRLee
At Waldorf, Devil's sign says "We are waiting for you, Kissinger"

It was a street meeting, in a sense, of the new and old worlds of protest. When the police tried to move an ornery older man off "their" sidewalk, call went up for cameras. The man was scarcely moved. Inner City Press filmed it - video here and below.

A mere twenty blocks north on Park Avenue, Maurice "Hank" Greenberg of AIG infamy was similarly honored at the Council on Foreign Relations, where he introduced and questioned the chief executive of Hong Kong, Donald Tsang.

(c) MRLee
Hank Greenberg of C.V. Starr & Donald Tsang, no protesters

An oil painting of Greenberg hung on CFR's wood paneled walls: he is honorary vice chairman of the organization. He let his politics hang out, asking David Tsang how fast construction can be done in Hong Kong, without all the local protests.

But how has Greenberg escaped Occupy Wall Street's protests? On a recent traipse through midtown, the names of Jamie Dimon of JPMorgan Chase and Brian Moynihan of Bank of America were chanted.

Even Citigroup's founder and former CEO Sandy Weill appeared on a sign, albeit with a pig nose. But nary a mention of Greenberg or of AIG.

When the Basel Committee on Bank Supervision Friday announced its list of 29 global systemically important institutions -- read, Too Big To Fail -- eight were based in the US, but AIG was not among them.

There were the Big Four -- Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America and Wells Fargo -- and Goldman Sach, Morgan Stanley, Bank of New York Mellon and even Boston-based State Street.

But AIG, so central in the crisis and such on a conduit for the bailouts, was not on the list. And while Occupy Wall Street marchs have targets Goldman and Chase, and the Bank of America across Broadway on Liberty, AIG on Pine Street has escaped.

So Greenberg smirks in CRF's paneled walls -- Inner City Press was not allowed a question -- and may have been present, at least in spirit, at the ceremony for Henry Kissinger downtown. And so it goes in New York, even amid Occupy Wall Street.

Flaws in UN Aid to Central Africa Republic Detailed by Bangladesh Diplomat

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 7 -- After a UN meeting on "Civilian Capacities" from which civilians and the press were excluded on November 4, a detailed complaint about the endeavor and about the UN's engagement with civilians was made to Inner City Press by the Permanent Representative of Bangladesh, Abulkalam Abdul Momen.

Momen told Inner City Press that inside the meeting, in a UN conference room that was far less than half full, he had described a recent and troubling trip to a country on the UN's Peacebuilding agenda, without in the meeting naming the country.

He said he visited UN projects in the rural part of the country and found that civil society groups and even direct neighbors had never heard of the projects.

He met with the president of the country, who said he did not know how much the UN spent in his country, or how. He said there are almost no roads in the country, "fifty years after independence."

Inner City Press asked him, "Is it the Central African Republic?" After hesitating, Momen said yes.


What was this meeting [closed]? (c) MRLee

Inner City Press has previously spoken about CAR with the head of the UN's Peacebuilding configuration for the country, Belgium's Permanent Representative Jan Grauls, who painted a rosier picture of things in CAR's capital, Bangui.

"There's not even a hotel there," Momen said. He contrasted CAR with his country and its vibrant civil society. When Inner City Press said, "Even the indigenous," referring to a previous story about complaints that Bangladesh denies it has indigenous people even in the Hill Tracks and uses their land to train UN peacekeepers, Momen laughed. Yes, vibrant.

Because the meeting was closed, Inner City Press had to wait until it ended to ask the presenter, the UN's chief of Field Support Susana Malcorra, about Momen's critique.

Malcorra told Inner City Press, that's why we had the meeting. She said, we have to focus on the needs of a country, not only on what the UN is already ready to deliver. We have to align ourselves with the plans of governments, she said.

Inner City Press asked her, what about governments which are killing their own people. Malcorra said the meeting was focus on "post-conflict" situations. But are those already without attacks on civilians? Now even in UN post conflict post child Liberia, political opponents are being shot by police.

The UN might benefit from having such meetings open, rather than reflexively keeping them closed to the press and public and making critiques diplomatically, without naming names. Public money is being spent, and it should all be public. Watch this site.