Saturday, November 5, 2011

Amid Bombing in Somalia, Cabral to Hear from Kenya, Eritrea Blocked, Ban Silent

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 4 -- As Kenya's intervention in Somalia continues, past bombing Internally Displaced Persons to threatening any aircraft from landing at Baidoa in Somalia, silence at the UN continues. But it will, Inner City Press learned Friday, result at least in a meeting between the Security Council president for November and Kenya's Ambassador early next week. Video here, from Minute 3.

Inner City Press has twice asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky about Kenya's entry into Somalia. Asked Friday about Kenya's Baidoa "no fly zone," Nesirky directed Inner City Press to statements of Ban's envoy Augustine Mahiga. Inner City Press asked, "Has Mahiga said anything about Kenya's threat to airplanes in Somalia?"

No, Nesirky said, not yet. Video here, from Minute 8:41. Mahiga was strikingly accepting of Kenya's bombing of the IDP camp, which Doctors Without Borders MSF says killed five civilians.

On November 3 Inner City Press asked November's Security Council president, Portugal's Ambassador Jose Filipe Moraes Cabral, if he was aware of letters to the Council from Kenya. Cabral said no, he was not aware. Inner City Press asked him, doesn't the Security Council's total inaction on this "hot" war undermine the UN's credibility?

"We'll look into it carefully," Cabral said. Video here, form Minute 7:50.

The next day on November 4, Inner City Press asked again about the letter(s) and what Cabral would do. Cabral replied this time that yes, there was correspondence during the last Presidency -- that is in October, under the Nigerian presidency. He added that he will "meet Kenya's Ambassador at the beginning of next week." Video here, at Minute 3.

Off camera, Inner City Press asked Cabral about the meeting. Kenya will want to explain what it had done, Cabral predicted.

Kenya is accusing Eritrea of arming Al Shabab. The Security Council is considering imposing additional sanctions on Eritrea for this and other reasons. But now that Eritrea's president Isaias Afwerki has asked to speak to the Security Council, the US is opposing Afwerki's request -- click here for the explanation US Ambassador Rice gave Inner City Press on November 3.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Nesirky if Ban, as the UN system's top official, thought that a head of state, when he or she asks to address an organ like the Security Council, should be allowed to: if talking is better that not talking. Video here, from Minute 9:30.

Ban's spokesman Nesirky said, "it's for the Security Council to decide."

Some wonder whether previous Secretaries General would have had NOTHING to say about the legality and impacts of one country's intervention into another, or about one country's block on a head of state whose country faces sanctions addressing those who'll vote on sanctions. This seems to be beyond "quiet diplomacy." Watch this site.

Angry at Press on Its Position on Palestine, France "Witch Hunt" Defused by Portugal

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 4 -- In the middle of the Security Council's closed door meeting on Palestine on November, Inner City Press learned and published that France had just announced inside the meeting that it would abstain on Palestinian UN membership. Click here for that unchanged story.

Minutes after the story was uploaded at 4:16 pm, inside the Security Council's "private" meeting French Ambassador Gerard Araud complained about it, multiple sources tell Inner City Press. Complaints were also made, not for the first time, by US Ambassador Susan Rice.

Araud pointed the finger at perceived "supporters of Palestine" on the Council. (While even those not supporting Palestinian UN membership all say they support Palestine, Araud was focused sources say on at most eight, and seemingly fewer, countries.)

November's Council president Jose Filipe Moraes Cabral of Portugal defused the situation by saying to count him, and Portugal, among Palestine's supporters.

After a change of government and foreign minister, Portugal is less supportive of Palestine than before, for example abstaining on Palestinian membership in UNESCO.

Cabral is a proponent of UNSC Working Methods reform and greater openness, for example holding press stakeouts on both November 3 and November 4. France's Araud, by contrast, did only three stakeouts in the entirety of the last month he was Council president, May 2012. Click here for that story, and here for more on French Mission anti-Press moves.

Some say that if Security Council members, particularly the Permanent members including Western members which often speak about press freedom and transparency, were in fact more open, "real time" reporting, for one Permanent Representative congratulated Inner City Press on Friday, would not be viewed as disruptive.

The following morning on November 4, Araud stopped on the stairs outside the Council and said, with his new spokesman tape recording, that if Palestine wants a vote in the Council on its application for membership it will need to get a Council member to ask for a vote. Watch this site.

Downer Says Cyprus "Slower Than Expected," Press Banned from Toilets

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 4 -- So what was accomplished at this week's meetings on Cyprus held at Greentree in New York's suburbs? It is unclear. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was out there, but when he returned to UN headquarters he merely read out a statement and took no questions.

His envoy Alexander Downer briefed the Security Council and took questions on Friday. Inner City Press asked about criticism that there might come a point in which the UN's involvement in a process without any progress could further undermine the credibility of the UN and Ban Ki-moon. Video here, from Minute 7:45.

Downer said there might be "a point when we have to concede there is deadlock... The Secretary General would have to report to the Security Council [there is] a deadline." He said things have been "slower that we had expected three years ago;" he blamed this in part on a change in the Turkish Cypriot leadership "getting into the saddle."

Inner City Press asked if disputes between Turkey and Cyprus, about maritime borders, exploration and other matter have impacted his work. He said they've had "no impact inside the negotiations" but they have had impact "on public opinion."

Downer referred to the interest in the minutiae of the process by "the public," then amended that to "the press." But the treatment of the journalists who went out to Greentree to cover the meetings was, in the word of one, "outrageous."

"We got there at 7:30," the journalist recounted, saying that there were "no toilets." After a time, journalists found two toilets but were told "they are old" and couldn't be used. There was a Greak Cypriot media room "ten minutes away but the Turks had to go into Manhattan. So for hours, they didn't go," the journalist said.

The UN Department of Political Affairs blamed the treatment on the Greentree estate "not being media friendly." But to deny the use of toilets to journalists trying to cover a negotiation DPA itself has bragged about hit a new low, the journalist concluded. Even for the UN. Watch this site.

As UAE Prosecutes Online Critics, Ban Does Not Raise to FM, Instead Syria & Iran

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 4 -- Amid crackdowns throughout Middle East on not only physical but also intellectual opposition, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon seems to focus on the former.

On November 3, Inner City Press asked Ban's Deputy Spokesman Eduardo Del Buey

Inner City Press: In the UAE there is a trial of five on-line activists. They have been put on trial in what's called the UAE five case for insulting UAE Government officials in an on-line forum, and Amnesty International and a variety of groups have said that the trial is a travesty and that international organizations should speak against it. I am wondering if anyone in the UN system is observing that trial, do you have any statement on the UAE putting essentially bloggers on trial for their speech.

Deputy Spokesperson: No, we have no statement on that yet. If we have anything, we will let you know.

While Ban's Spokesperson has yet to issue any statement on the UAE's so-called "Franz Kafka" blogger trial, the Office did put out a read-out of Ban's meeting on the sidelines of the G-20 meetings in Cannes with the UAE's foreign minister Sheikh Abdullah Bin Zayed Al Nahya, with no mention of the trail or crackdowns by the UAE.

Instead, Ban says he discussed Syria and "they also discussed the situation in Iran." What about the situation in the UAE?

Inner City Press also asked about Ban's whirlwind stop off in Libya on his way to the G-20 meeting in Cannes:

Inner City Press: Yesterday I asked you, maybe you have an answer now, when the Secretary-General flew to Libya -- he has now left so there is no security concerns -- on whose aircraft did he fly? Did he fly commercial?

Deputy Spokesperson: He flew, he and the delegation flew from here to Frankfurt on commercial aircraft, and then from Frankfurt to Libya on a UN-chartered aircraft; and then from Libya to Nice on a UN-chartered aircraft.

Inner City Press: just contracted out, paid?

Deputy Spokesperson: To the best of my knowledge, yes... A UN-chartered aircraft.

There are mounting questions about the costs and manner of Ban Ki-moon's travels. Watch this site.

US Opposes Eritrea President Meeting Security Council, Susan Rice Tells Inner City Press Why

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- Facing sanctions, the President of Eritrea Isaias Afwerki has asked to meet with the UN Security Council. Going beyond Inner City Press' initial exclusive story, several Council members on Thursday told the Press that the United States -- one said "only the US" -- is opposed to Afwerki speaking to the Council.

By contrast, South Africa's Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu stopped and told Inner City Press "I don't there anything wrong with hearing from the President" of Eritrea. China said it supports Afwerki's request to address the Council.

Under Nigeria's presidency in October, Nigeria wrote back to Afwerki and said that the request was received and was being discussed. Now it's said it will be the subject of a closed door Security Council consultation, under the heading "Any Other Business."

Late Thursday morning Inner City Press asked USUN:

"what is the US Mission position is on Eritrea's President's request to speak to the Security Council? Several Council members I've spoken with support the request, and not only if all of Eritrea's neighbors are also included in the particular session. What is the US position and why?"

Five hours later US Ambassador Susan Rice stopped to answer when Inner City Press asked "is the US against the idea of the President of Eritrea briefing the Council?"

She paused and then told Inner City Press, "We had the foreign ministers come in July. That was sufficient drama for my taste. I think if one comes, they'll call come. I'm not sure what we'll hear that's much different. I think any time you bring together leaders at that level with the degree of tension that exists between them. It's not going to promote improved relations or greater peace and stability. So I think we have to be very cautious about it and thoughtful about it."

The answer is appreciated. But some point out that generally if a head of state asks to address the Security Council, particularly one which is facing, as first reported by Inner City Press, a new round of sanctions from the Council, the head of state is or should be heard. Now Ambassador Rice has made an argument why, in this case, the request could or should be denied because, she says, it does not "promote improved relations or greater peace and stability."

The July drama to which Susan Rice referred took place a closed door meeting in the UN's North Lawn building exclusively reported by Inner City Press. (Click here for Inner City Press interview with Afwerki's adviser Yemane.)

As the Security Council broke up late on Thursday, Inner City Press asked November's Council president Portuguese Ambassador Cabral for his view. Passing the media pen outside the Council he said that if a country which is on the Security Council's agenda asks to be heard, it should be. You can discuss the format, he said, but the country should be heard.

You heard it here first. Watch this site.