Saturday, November 5, 2011

US Opposes Eritrea President Meeting Security Council, Susan Rice Tells Inner City Press Why

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- Facing sanctions, the President of Eritrea Isaias Afwerki has asked to meet with the UN Security Council. Going beyond Inner City Press' initial exclusive story, several Council members on Thursday told the Press that the United States -- one said "only the US" -- is opposed to Afwerki speaking to the Council.

By contrast, South Africa's Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu stopped and told Inner City Press "I don't there anything wrong with hearing from the President" of Eritrea. China said it supports Afwerki's request to address the Council.

Under Nigeria's presidency in October, Nigeria wrote back to Afwerki and said that the request was received and was being discussed. Now it's said it will be the subject of a closed door Security Council consultation, under the heading "Any Other Business."

Late Thursday morning Inner City Press asked USUN:

"what is the US Mission position is on Eritrea's President's request to speak to the Security Council? Several Council members I've spoken with support the request, and not only if all of Eritrea's neighbors are also included in the particular session. What is the US position and why?"

Five hours later US Ambassador Susan Rice stopped to answer when Inner City Press asked "is the US against the idea of the President of Eritrea briefing the Council?"

She paused and then told Inner City Press, "We had the foreign ministers come in July. That was sufficient drama for my taste. I think if one comes, they'll call come. I'm not sure what we'll hear that's much different. I think any time you bring together leaders at that level with the degree of tension that exists between them. It's not going to promote improved relations or greater peace and stability. So I think we have to be very cautious about it and thoughtful about it."

The answer is appreciated. But some point out that generally if a head of state asks to address the Security Council, particularly one which is facing, as first reported by Inner City Press, a new round of sanctions from the Council, the head of state is or should be heard. Now Ambassador Rice has made an argument why, in this case, the request could or should be denied because, she says, it does not "promote improved relations or greater peace and stability."

The July drama to which Susan Rice referred took place a closed door meeting in the UN's North Lawn building exclusively reported by Inner City Press. (Click here for Inner City Press interview with Afwerki's adviser Yemane.)

As the Security Council broke up late on Thursday, Inner City Press asked November's Council president Portuguese Ambassador Cabral for his view. Passing the media pen outside the Council he said that if a country which is on the Security Council's agenda asks to be heard, it should be. You can discuss the format, he said, but the country should be heard.

You heard it here first. Watch this site.

After UN in Guinea Bissau Sheltered Drug Kingpin, Mutaboba Against Trials

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- Guinea Bissau is on the agenda of the Security Council, but the assassination of its president and Army chief in 2009 has yet to result in any trial, much less indictment or conviction.

Inner City Press on November 3 asked both the UN's envoy in Guinea Bissau Joseph Mutaboba and this month's Security Council president, Portugal's Ambassador Cabral, about the lack of accountability for the 2009 assassinations.

Not only Mutaboba but also, surprisingly, Cabral answered the accountability question by referring to security sector reform and even a pension fund for soldiers. Cabral video here. Both are fine ideas, but are not the accountability that Cabral and some other Permanent Representatives on the Security Council often loudly call for.

Mutaboba said that accountability cannot be allowed to undermine the security gains he said have been made. Asked if that meant putting off accountability, he said it had to be "balanced." This is not the standard UN answer -- it is one that Omar al Bashir, and more recently Saif al Islam Gaddafi, would like.

Mutaboba appeared defensive, not only on accountability but also on drugs. Video here. Inner City Press asked him about the case in which his UN Mission had provided refuge to a US-named Narcotics Kingpin, Bubo Na Tchuto. Mutaboba replied that not all member states see it that way. A close observer said that Mutaboba is hoping his past decision to shelter a drug kingpin just "goes away."

In fact, the US Ambassador who spoke about this at the Security Council was Brooke Anderson, just before she left the UN Mission. Will there be follow up? Watch this site.

At UN on Palestine, France Says It Will Abstain, Bosnia "Can't Speak," Sources Tell Inner City Press

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, November 3, 4:16 pm -- As Security Council member stated their positions on Palestine UN membership behind closed doors on Thursday afternoon, Inner City Press learned that inside the meeting, France said it would abstain.

The key, the source said, would be Bosnia and Colombia, adding that despite rumors to the contrary, Nigeria and Gabon "have to support Palestine," given their membership in regional groups. Colombia seems unlikely to support Palestinian membership.

Bosnia, one well placed European Union source said, is "unable" to state its position on Palestine, given the tripartite nature of its government and the role of the Repulika Srpska.

Thus, the source said, there are not nine votes for Palestine at this time. Others said that Guatemala's vote for Palestine at UNESCO does not portend support for membership when Guatemala joins the Council in January. France voted yes at UNESCO, and Thursday said it would abstain in the Security Council.

Other peculiarities about the UNESCO vote include Sweden, where the foreign ministry did not control the vote in Paris, but would in the General Assembly. Watch this site.

And see, http://www.innercitypress.com/pal2frport110411.html

Of Tear Gas Used on Occupy Wall Street, UN Says Oakland "Acted Responsibly"

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- The day after police used tear gas in Oakland, California to put down an Occupy Wall Street protest for second time in eight days, Inner City Press asked United Nations spokesman Eduardo Del Buey is anyone in the UN is tracking this and if the UN thinks the responses in Oakland have been proportionate.

"Obviously the fact that tear gas was used, the authorities thought that tear gas had to be used," UN spokesman Del Buey said. Video here, from Minute 14:55.

This is a strange logic for the UN, that if "the authorities" do something, they must have thought it was necessary -- and it must therefore be justified. The UN does not use this approach elsewhere.

Del Buey said that the mayor of Oakland "apologized" for the first use of tear gas, which fractured the skull of US veteran Scott Olsen with a police projectile, "so we believe the authorities are acting responsibly."

Elsewhere, the UN does not say that apologizing is enough, or means that authorities are "acting responsibly."

All three times, so far, that Inner City Press has asked the spokespeople for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon about authorities' responses to Occupy Wall Street it has begun by acknowledging that the violence used is qualitatively less than in countries like Syria and Yemen, both of which Inner City Press asked about at the UN on Thursday.

So what standards does the UN have and apply in the US?

Consider that Ban Ki-moon named as the co-chair of his High Level Group on Sustainable Energy for All Charles Holliday, chairman of Bank of America, protested by Occupy Wall Street for being the number one funder of moutaintop removal coal mining.

Earlier this week Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky went out of his way to allow any other question -- including about UNESCO -- rather than Inner City Press' question about sustainable energy and Ban's Bank of America nomination, click here for that story. Now the UN says using tear gas, including dangerous projectiles, against Occupy Wall Street is "acting responsibly." Is it time to Occupy the UN? Watch this site.

On UNESCO, Palestine Calls Out the Czechs, Ban on Joining UN Agencies

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- Palestine's Permanent Observer Riyad Mansour emerged from the Security Council midday Thursday, telling the Press he'd met with Lebanon and with Portugal, as November's Council president.

Inner City Press asked Mansour about Portugal's decision to abstain on Palestine's successful application to become a member of UNESCO. This is seen as part of Portugal's shift toward American position.

Mansour said countries' votes at UNESCO "are being studied," including the No vote of a country which has formally recognized Palestine as a state.

Off camera, Inner City Press asked the Palestinian delegation to name the state. After a pause came the answer: the Czech Republic. Other sources tell Inner City Press that Palestinians are none too happy with Portugal's decision to abstain at UNESCO.

Inner City Press also asked Mansour about UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's statement that, beyond UNESCO, Palestinian efforts to join any other UN agency -- seemingly including the International Criminal Court -- are "not beneficial for Palestine and not beneficial for anybody."

Mansour said slowly, "We respect the statements of the Secretary General" - then said "we are studying it." Some ask, who is Ban Ki-moon say that trying to join the ICC, or other agencies, would not benefit Palestinians?

Earlier, Inner City Press reported on complaints from inside the Ban Ki-moon UN administration that Ban was seeking a legal memo from his top lawyer Patricia O'Brien, who refused press questions, on how to delay or stymie a Palestinian filing to join the ICC, for which the UN Secretariat is the repository.

Ban's new statement put this is a new light and is, as said, "being studied." Watch this site.

Footnote: while there is much media interest in the session of the Security Council Committee on the Admission of New Members slated for Thursday afternoon, less than two hours after Mansour spoke, the meeting will be closed, and new Council president Cabral would not say if he would summarize the meeting afterward. We'll see.

IMF Defers Comment on Ukraine, Stonewalls on Greece, Lagarde & UN


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- When the International Monetary Fund's spokesman David Hawley held a press briefing on November 3, he faced multiple in-room questions about Greece, its referendum and possible default, and when and how Managing Director Christine Lagarde knew about them.

Hawley deflected all questions, saying Lagarde had already spoken, and learned about the referendum as everyone else did. A Greek journalist concluded, so "you don't have anything for today for us?"

Inner City Press submitted three questions through the IMF's "online briefing center," which Hawley said will soon be re-named the "Press Center" and offer translation. More fundamentally, it seems, is for the IMF to clarify which questions submitted online it deigns to read out loud and answer, and which ignore.

Hawley was about to end the briefing when he said there was "a question" from Inner City Press, which he paraphrased as, "Can I comment on current state of discussions with Ukraine?"

Then Hawley offered this: "We are in Ukraine at the moment, discussions are ongoing. I prefer to wait for the conclusion of those discussions before making a further statement."

Actually, the question Inner City Press submitted, through the Online Briefing Center and e-mail, was

"On Ukraine, please confirm or deny public reports that the IMF is urging the government to sharply raise utility prices, and comment on the public protests of the IMF in Kiev."

In other circumstances the IMF does offer comment, how ever conclusory, about public protests. Why not here?

Inner City Press also asked, without answer or acknowledgement by deadline:

"Managing Director Lagarde attended UN's Chief Executive Board meeting last week. Please describe her and the IMF's coordination with the UN, on food security, climate finance and in the Horn of Africa and elsewhere, going forward."

On Libya, about which Inner City Press also asked, Hawley chose a less detailed question and said the IMF "will meet with the authorities soon." Watch this site.