Saturday, November 5, 2011

Ocampo Brags, But ICC Tainted by French Vote Swap & US Loophole for Qatar

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- The UN Security Council's referral of the situation in Libya under Gaddafi to the International Criminal Court was the subject of Council debate Wednesday afternoon.

The ICC's outgoing prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo speechified, then France and the US among others gave speeches about their commitment to the ICC and accountability, respectively.

But as was recently exclusive reported by Inner City Press, France offered to support an unqualified judge for the ICC in exchange for support for its current candidate Bruno Cathala -- click here for that story.

Ocampo bragged that people associated with Saif al Islam Gaddafi contacted the ICC asking hypothetical questions about surrendering. Afterward a reporter from AFP, 41% funded by the French government, asked where exactly Saif Gaddafi is. One imagines French jets awaiting the answer that, not surprisingly, never came.

Now the US' pushing in February for an exemption to the Libya ICC referral has been shown as more substantial than argued at the time by US Ambassador Susan Rice, by non ICC member Qatar's bragging that it had hundreds of "boots on the ground" in Libya during the conflict.

While publicly calling for an end to impunity, the US at a Security Council experts' meeting on the morning of February 26, 2011 demanded the following paragraph:

6. Decides that nationals, current or former officials or personnel from a State outside the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya which is not a party to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of that State for all alleged acts or omissions arising out of or related to operations in the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya established or authorized by the Council, unless such exclusive jurisdiction has been expressly waived by the State.

When the resolution was adopted later that day -- after Security Council ambassadors quietly attended a Chinese circus before the 8 pm vote -- Inner City Press asked French Ambassador Gerard Araud about the paragraph.

Araud said, “that was for one country, it was absolutely necessary for one country to have that considering its parliamentary constraints, and this country we are in. It was a red line for the United States. It was a deal-breaker, and that's the reason we accepted this text to have the unanimity of the Council.”

On March 1 outside the UN General Assembly, Inner City Press managed to ask US Ambassador Susan Rice:

Inner City Press: Can I ask you a question about the Security Council resolution? (inaudible) On the Security Council resolution that passed Saturday, some have now raised a question about the US asking for that paragraph six, which exempts Americans, and, I guess, others, anyone that's not an ICC member, from referral and prosecution by the ICC. They say it undercuts international law-Brazil said it, now the head of the Rome Statute grouping of member states said it. Why did the US ask for that? And don't you see a downside to saying there's no impunity if you are excluding people from referral?

Ambassador Rice: No, I don't see a downside. As you well know, the United States is not a party and we have thought it important, if we were going to, for the first time, affirmatively support such a resolution, to make sure that is was clear the limitations as to who jurisdiction applied to. That's why we supported that phrase. Your assertion and that of others that somehow this provides a pass for mercenaries, I think, is completely misplaced. I don't think that the International Criminal Court is going to spend its time and effort on foot soldiers that have been paid small amounts of money by Qadhafi. They're going to focus on the big fish, so I think your interest was misplaced.

Counting on the ICC not to prosecute a certain size of killer seemed a bit strange. Now with Qatar's admission, it is worse...

For Portugal's SC Month, Palestine & LRA, Working Methods for New Members

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 2, updated -- With Portugal taking over the Security Council presidency for November, their focus is on working methods, training incoming elected members, and pushing Portuguese as a seventh UN language.

In his ten months on the Council, Portugal's Jose Filipe Moraes Cabral has stood out from his colleague in a commitment to the primacy of the General Assembly, most recently by refusing to show up for the Security Council's meeting on Yemen held the same afternoon as the General Assembly voted on electing five new Council members.

Now the five elected are being brought in, as a form of training, into Council consultations. Togo comes in first, since it will take the presidency in early 2012, as the alphabet turns.

Azerbaijan's Permanent Representative told Inner City Press he is returning home and so will start after the other Permanent Representatives, who attend the so-called "Finnish workshop" on November 17-18 then start watching closed door consultations.

Since Finland is running next October, against Australia and Luxembourg, for a 2013-14 seat, some wonder if they can still run the Finnish workshop, or it is gives them a head-start.

Of those joining the Council, Pakistan, Azerbaijan and Morocco are viewed as solid votes for Palestinian membership in the UN. Guatemala took a reservation from a Group of 77 position to this effect, but most recently voted "yes" for Palestine to join UNESCO. So it remains possible that Palestine's vote count goes up in November. But is it to nine or merely eight positive votes?

Click here for Press review of Cabral's first nine SC months.

Cabral's press conference on his program of work for the month, originally scheduled for the normal midday time, was moved back until after deadline and business hours at 6:15 pm.

But the one-page Program of Work has emerged and reflects, among other things, a November 9 meeting on protection of civilians at which Portugal's president will attend, and an end of the month debate on working methods.

On November 21, Yemen is on the agenda, by name. Nobel Peace Prize winner Tawakkul Karman, when the Council passed its resolution on Yemen, said she would stay in New York until the Council referred Saleh to the International Criminal Court and froze his assets. Since then, she told Inner City Press she was going to meet with Hillary Clinton. What will happen November 21?

Another US connection is on November 14, when the Lord's Resistance Army will be considered.

After US President Obama announced he'd send forces to Uganda against the LRA, Inner City Press on October 18 asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman if there was any coordination with the UN and its peacekeeping missions:

Inner City Press: the Obama Administration has announced, to its credit, that it’s sending troops to help track down Joseph Kony and the LRA. But I wanted to know whether there is any coordination in this with MONUSCO or whether this also complies with international law.

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Well, I am glad to hear you approve of what the Obama Administration is doing, Matthew. I don’t have any comment on that at the moment. If I do, we’re certainly aware of the reports, and…

Inner City Press: Was MONUSCO informed?

Spokesperson: As I say, I am aware of the reports and we’re aware of the reports. If I have any further details, then I’ll, I’ll let you know.

Two days later, the UN provided Inner City Press with this:

Subject: Your questions on MONUSCO
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply @un.org
Date: Thu, Oct 20, 2011 at 11:11 AM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

The Department for peacekeeping Operations says that:

MONUSCO was not consulted about the US decision to send a small group of military advisers to assist the forces that are countering the LRA, before it was officially announced on 14 October. Regarding coordination, there are currently two US information analysts based at the Mission's Joint Information and Operation Centre in Dungu, in Province Orientale. MONUSCO, consistent with its mandate, works together with the Congolese army (FARDC) and the Ugandan army (UPDF) in Dungu at the JIOC to gather and analyse information about LRA activities and coordinate operations.

MONUSCO is undertaking operations in a number of areas where armed groups are active. The Mission is also providing support to some FARDC operations in compliance with the human rights and due diligence policy. The complete lack of attack helicopters, however, affects the Mission's operations.

While we publish in full the plea for attack helicopters, the question of the day is how or whether these US "analysts" in countries which are members of the International Criminal Court are somehow exempt from the ICC.

Perhaps this and other questions will be answered on November 14, or at least during the Portuguese presidency of the Security Council.

As UNDP Uses Arab Spring for Green, Had Aisha Gaddafi as Ambassador

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 2 -- In what some see as opportunism, the UN Development Program which had Aisha Gaddafi as a Goodwill Ambassador today proclaimed that "the 'Arab Spring' shows need for greener development." One wag wondered: is UNDP's reference to Gaddafi's Green Book?

Then at UNDP's press conference, among the few questions was one about hydro-fracking. Despite opportunistically using environmentalism to raise money -- that is, "green" -- UNDP said it is no expert and to ask Nick Nuttall of UNEP. (Nuttall has repeatedly refused to answer press questions about Ban Ki-moon giving a UN post to Samuel Koo of South Korea.)

During the Arab Spring, the UN system's coordinator for Libya, UNDP official Costanza Farina, had in fact been praising Gaddafi's regime. She said, “''Libya has made immense progress and is well positioned among the countries that will be able to say that they have reached 8 of the Millennium Objectives in 2015.” And click here, 2010 "UNIC Tripoli organizes Reception at UN House in celebration of UN Day."

She also praised Gaddafi on women's rights, as Libya is on the board of UN Women:

“the UN chief for Libya, Costanza Farina, said that the fight against violence against women was one of the priorities of the agencies operating in the country and announced that the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), thanks to a contribution from the Dutch embassy in Tripoli, would be able to support the programme financially. Farina added that Libya is one of the 41 members elected to the executive committee of the new UN Women agency, which was created on July 2 to show the desire of governments to respect women. Farina also said that "Libya confirmed the equality in rights between men and women in 1969.”

Maybe she is unaware, as “local UN officials said, the new coordinator of the UN in Libya, Costanza Farina, credited only last June 1, is located in Geneva.”

On February 17, Inner City Press had asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky

Inner City Press: Is there any thought of using the existing UN programs on the ground, whether it is UNDP or otherwise? There was some criticism of this training of police in Egypt prior to the — there was criticism by NGOs that it didn’t bring in human rights activists but rather Government people. Is there some thinking of how — the UNDP website about Libya hasn’t been updated now in several months, I guess — it seems to some, due to the turmoil. What about these UN…?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Who might that be? Who is it, these people who think it might be?

Inner City Press: People that look at it and have seen that it was updated all the way, until suddenly there was turmoil in the country and then it is not updated any more. What’s the role, according to the Secretary-General, of the existing UN programmes in countries like Libya and Yemen, where Helen Clark visited and didn’t say anything about democracy?

Even since then, UNDP Administrator Helen Clark has declined numerous requests from the Press and UN correspondents to hold a press conference at UN Headquarters and answer questions.

Instead, UNDP sends out members of its extensive "communications" team, to block questions to each other and refer other questions to other UN system agencies.

While the Human Development Report has interesting section that will surely be used in future articles, when an agency has this much money, and tries to raise more citing the Arab Spring despite its record, while its Administrator refuses to answer questions, this is the result.