Saturday, November 5, 2011

UN Uses Mercenaries, UN Expert Says, Citing "French Person" in Libya

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 2 -- "The UN does use private military companies," the Chairperson of the Working Group on Mercenaries Faiza Patel told Inner City Press on Tuesday. Video here, from Minute 11:32.

At her press conference, Inner City Press asked about Somalia, where the mercenary firm Saracen which is partially owned by a relative of Ugandan president Yoweri Museveni was found to be violating sanctions, Afghanistan and Iraq.

Of some in the UN system's defense of using Saracen to combat piracy, Patel told Inner City Press that "the UN system is a large beast."

Earlier she had said that the UN is "very aware" of the mercenary issue, and has a program to coordinate its use of private military companies to ensure that those charged with human rights violations are not used.

When Inner City Press just after the press conference asked for details of this UN program and whether it is in the Department of Safety and Security, Patel said she wasn't sure. She said that while the UN and its agencies use private military companies in many countries, Iraq is not one of them.

But she did not know that there is in that country, from which the US and its protection are slated to leave, a new Special Representative of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. We hope to have more on this.

Patel said she will soon visit and report on Cote d'Ivoire and Libya. Inner City Press asked if the focus in Libya will only by on Gaddafi's use of mercenaries, or would include trainers provided by such countries as Qatar and France. Video here, from Minute 21:33.

Patel said, you must be aware of "a French person killed, setting up a private security company" in Benghazi. Yes -- but will that be investigated for her report? Watch this site.

Ms. Patel is employed at the Brennan Center at NYU, and was described at the beginning of the press conference as "independent of all governments." She did criticize Equatorial Guinea, which she visited. But some might say she is not independent of the UN, saying for example that peacekeeping missions are "our" interaction with the world.

Beyond this symptomatic pronoun problem, she was also very quick to try to say the UN's use of private military companies is per se better than governments, without being able to provide specifics. She tried to say that securing a convoy would bring about "engagement with civilians" and a "human rights incident" more than providing "static security or close protection." Why?

And what of UN Peacekeepers themselves, and the human rights incidents created in places like Haiti, and inaction in places like South Kordofan? A person in Ms. Patel's position should be or try to be scrupulously independent of the UN as well, as least its Secretariat. We'll see.

On Landmines, UN Defends TNC of Libya as on Reprisal, No SOFA in Abyei?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 1 -- When the UN held a press conference Tuesday about landmine usage in Libya, one expected them to at least mention that some of the use was by the rebels or Transitional National Council.

But when Inner City Press asked about the documented usage by rebels of Belgian made PRB-M3 anti-vehicle mines on the side of the main road into Ajdabiya, the UN's Program Manager for the Joint Mine Action Coordination Team in Libya Max Dyck quickly defended the TNC. Video here from Minute 8:15.

He urged to "take it into context, saying it was "done early in conflict, in March." (Actually, it was filmed as late as April 17, 2011). Dyck continued, "This issue's been addressed with the NTC... That was the only incidence of landmine use by the NTC revolutionaries."

When Inner City Press tried to ask a follow up question, the Deputy Spokesman did not allow it (while allowing the next correspondent to follow up). Since there were virtually no other questioners, Inner City Press was then able to ask Dyck about his tone: did it mean that to work with the NTC, the UN had to praise it? Video here, from Minute 12:01.

Dyck did not answer, rather the Acting Director of the United Nations Mine Action Service, Justin Brady did, saying that the UN raised it to the NTC as soon as they became aware, and that the NTC attributed it to "local commanders."

One wonders if this is a predictor of what the UN will do, or not do, in looking into the reprisal killings by NTC forces in Libya: 53 bound bodies in Sirte, a whole village chased away.

(c) MRLee
UNMAS' Dyck & Brady: where have you gone, Maxwell Curley?

These were questions Inner City Press put to Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky on October 31:

Inner City Press: all of the people have been chased out of a town called Tawerghaand... 53 bound bodies of Qadhafi supporters presumably were found in a hotel in Sirte. So what’s the response in terms of accountability for what would pretty clearly be war crimes?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, as you know — two things really — first of all, the Security Council resolution on this point is very clear. And that’s speaking directly to the Libyan authorities, namely that they were expressing grave concern about continuing reports of reprisals, arbitrary detentions, wrongful imprisonment and extrajudicial executions. And as you will also remember from last week, there was a statement from the Commission of Inquiry on Libya that urges the National Transitional Council and indeed future interim authorities to undertaken independent, impartial, transparent investigations into all allegations of violations of the rights of detainees in their custody and if they deem it necessary, recommends — meaning the Commission of Inquiry — that they seek the support of the interntional community. So I think you can see that there is a body of opinion out there that says that the Libyan authorities will need to investigate all cases of alleged abuse, reprisals and that is precisely what the National Transitional Council has undertaken to do and the interntional community will watch that very closely.

Inner City Press: I just wanted to know, sort of what the role of the UNSMIL Mission would be, particularly in the case of these Tawergha people, they are not dead or at least yet, they are in the desert and they can’t return to their town. Is there some effort being made by Mr. Martin or UNSMIL to actually act on these still pending situations?

Spokesperson: I’d have to check precisely on that. As I think I mentioned last week, there are human rights officers within the Mission, and so let me check to see what I can get for you on that.

A full day later no answers had been provided, and Nesirky canceled the November 1 noon briefing.

While the Mine Action Service does some good work, it seemed Tuesday to go out of its way to praise the government of Sudan, blaming all land mines in the country on "non state actors."

Sudan blocked even the medical evacuation of four UNISFA peacekeepers injured by a mine, four of whom ended up bleeding out and dying.

But when Inner City Press asked if any Status of Forces Agreement or other safeguard was no in place to evacuate mine removal personally, Brady said to ask the "Office of Military Affairs." Video here, from Minute 17:55.

Footnote: Inner City Press asked about Syria's use of landmine on its border with Lebanon. Brady said Syria is a sovereign country and not a party to the convention. He said it ill-serves the country, but to ask the Permanent Mission of Syria. Video here, from Minute 15.

So landmine questions are referred by the Mine Action Service to other parts of the UN and to Permanent Missions, while the Mine Action Service takes it upon itself to case the case for the TNC, even as reprisals continue. Still, some good work is done. Watch this site.

At UN, Ban Defends Chair of BofA, Mountaintop Removal, Orr Unaware


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 1 -- With Bank of America being protested not only for its bailout and corporate welfare but specifically as the largest funder of mountaintop removal coal mining, why did the UN make BofA chairman Charles "Chad" Holliday the co-chair of its "High Level Group on Sustainable Energy for All"?

Inner City Press asked the UN spokesman on October 13, after attending a protest of Bank of America on the topic in lower Manhattan, across Broadway from the Occupy Wall Street encampment on Liberty Street. Spokesman Martin Nesirky said he would check with Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.

Hearing nothing back, when Ban held a press conference on November 1 about sustainable energy, Inner City Press sought to ask Ban the question directly. Nesirky did not allow the question from Inner City Press. But in the hallway outside, Inner City Press did ask Ban. As transcribed by the UN:

Inner City Press: [inaudible] Bank of America is considered number one taking off the tops of mountains to take out coal, and has been protested for that. So on October 13th I asked here, what do you think of taking off the top of mountains for coal, and why is the guy [Charles Holliday] co-Chairman of the Group [High-level Group on Sustainable Energy for All]?

SG Ban Ki-moon: His record is quite clear, in the area of development, and particularly on energy issues. He is the Chairman of the World Council for Sustainable Development. He was CEO of Dupont where Dupont set an exemplary record in terms of energy. I have been, we have been working with him quite a long time. That is why he is nominated as Co-Chair of this group. I am sure that he will lead this sustainable energy group very well.

While to some being the CEO of Dupont is equally dubious, Ban Ki-moon did not answer on the question on mountaintop removal coal mining. Inner City Press went back into the briefing room and asked Assistant Secretary General Robert Orr what he and Ban thought of mountaintop removal mining.

Orr said that "Chad Holliday is a giant in business around the world." Calling mountaintop removal mining "a specific question" that Inner City Press should ask Bank of America about, Orr went on to say "I am not even aware of the issue you are raising." Video here, from Minute 18:40.

Not only did Inner City Press asked Ban's (and Orr's) spokesman about the practice on October 13 -- any cursory review of environmentalist literature identifies the issue. Inner City Press sought to ask a follow up, if there was any civil society or environmental activist input in the UN process, but spokesman Nesirky cut in.

(c) MRLee
From right, Ban, Orr, TV: Bank of America, #OWS and MTR not shown or known

Some wondered why Nesirky went to such lengths not to allow the question to be asked of Ban Ki-moon. Did he not want Ban mouthing these answers to appear on camera?

Soung-ah Choi of his (and / or Ban's) office tried to cut off the question even in the hall. First she claimed that Ban inside "answered all the questions." Then after the question was posed, and before Ban graciously if disappointingly answered, she said "we'll get back to you."

Beyond claiming to be unaware of basic environmental issues, the UN's Ban Ki-moon team claims to be paying attention to Occupy Wall Street. Its knee-jerk defense and praise of Bank of America and its involvement in mountaintop removal coal mining are telling and troubling. Watch this site.

At UN, To Avoid Bank Question to Ban, Spokesman Replays UNESCO

By Matthew Russell Lee, Review

UNITED NATIONS, November 1 -- When UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon arrived, 13 minutes late, for a 30 minute press conference on Tuesday, his spokesman Martin Nesirky announced that Ban would take "at least one question."

One assumed, given Nesirky's previous insistence on limiting the topics that can be asked about, that this question would be about Ban's "High Level Group on Sustainable Energy," a topic on which Inner City Press questioned Nesirky back on October 13.

That question concerned why Ban put the chairman of Bank of America, which is been multiply protested as being the number one funder of mountain top removal coal mining, on his "Sustainable" energy group.

When question time came, more extended due to broken UN technology to connect in a speaker from Sierra Leone, Nesirky did everything possible not to take the Bank of America question from Inner City Press.

Nesirky even called on a journalist who had no hand raised, just to see if a question could be cajoled to kill the time. Previously at the stakeout after Ban Ki-moon cajoled re-election to a second five year term as Secretary General, Nesirky was so desperate for a friendly question that he called on an intern from the UN's own radio station, who asked Ban for his message to the world's children.

(Nesirky later blamed this on the intern for being at the stakeout, when for the record it was not her fault.)

As Inner City Press said, "Sustainable energy question," Nesirky took two questions about UNESCO, after having already said Ban had spoken (if not answered) on the topic the previous day. Then Nesirky said there was no more time to question Ban, and Ban left.

Inner City Press did manage, despite blockage by another member of Nesirky's or Ban's team, to ask the question, the gracious if disappointing answer to which will be reported in a separate story. Between the 12 and 12:30 press conferences, Nesirky canceled the daily noon briefing, just as he abruptly ended it on Monday with questions still outstanding.

Nesirky's still relatively new Deputy, Eduardo Del Buey, handled the next press conference, about the UN Mine Action Service in Libya. Inner City Press asked a question, then was not allowed a follow up question by Del Buey - who proceeded to allow the next journalist to follow up. (We will have a separate story about the substance of the Mine Action press conference as well.)

Last Friday October 28 with Del Buey conducting the noon briefing, numerous UN correspondents said things hit a new low, with no answers provided if Del Buey did not have a prepared answer or "line" with him.

Several said to Inner City Press that it is shameful that the UN is being run, or represented, in this fashion by Nesirky and sometimes Del Buey.

Several have proposed boycotting the briefing. Whlie that would seem to just give them what they want, what the other options are remains unclear. Nesirky still sometimes jokes, and it's appreciated, but most see him as getting worse. "They made him this way," as one correspondent put it, referring not only to Ban but his whole team of senior advisers.

Inner City Press ended up asking Del Buey if he would just read out the "lines," since they had been prepared, so that the world would know what Ban's UN thinks. That not how we do it, Del Buey replied.

Inner City Press considered writing a review of Friday's surreal briefing but decided against it -- again, Del Buey is still relatively new. Ultimately, Nesirky is responsible for his Office, and Ban despite Tuesday gracious hallway answer is responsible for Nesirky. Watch this site.