Saturday, November 5, 2011

As UN Refugee & Crime Agencies Sign Deal, No Safeguards, No Protection

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 31 -- After the UN's refugee agency UNHCR signed a Memorandum of Understanding on Monday with the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, UNODC chief Yuri Fedotov told the press, "where there are refugees, there are always crime." Video here, from Minute 2.

Inner City Press asked Fedotov to explain: was this only about crimes committed against refugees, or would it include checking refugees, and even by implication sharing information with governments? Video here, from Minute 6:36.

The question seemed obvious, for example considering the controversy in the United States when Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) says it will work with any criminal justice agency: protests ensue, and suspension or safeguards are demanded. Wouldn't the UN have some safeguards?

Inner City Press requested, and ultimately obtained and is putting online here, the Memorandum of Understanding, which does not appear to have any such safeguards. Fedotov's answer was that "refugees appear not in peaceful countries." UNHCR's Antonio Guterres added that conflicts today are rarely between two states.

Take for example the recent entry into Somalia by the Kenyen Army, reportedly with supportive bombardments by France (from the sea) and, it seems, from the US. This is not a conflict between two states but a self-described "hot pursuit" operation by a state on a non-state actor, Al Shabab.

But over the weekend, an aerial bombardment of a camp inside Somalia killed five, according to Medicins Sans Frontieres. Guterres insisted it isn't clear what happened, and that UNHCR has no mandate inside Somalia.

Likewise when Inner City Press asked Guterres about the plight of Kachin people displaced by Myanmar's Army offensive, he replied that UNHCR is only in other parts of Myanmar and wants to keep open the "asylum space" in Thailand. But Malaysia is moving to return people to Myanmar.

Given all this, the lack of safeguards in UNHCR's agreement with the UN's crime agency is of concern. We hope to have more on this.

Footnote: both Fedotov and Guterres were in New York meeting with Ban Ki-moon and the Chief Executives Board. On Friday outside the CEB meeting, Inner City Press poses another protection question to World Food Program chief Josette Sheeran, so far without answer.

Christine Lagarde of the IMF was there too -- to what end, nobody knows. Now Ban, Lagarde, Barack Obama and others are headed to the G20 meeting in Cannes, the UN briefing regarding which was closed to the press and public. And so it goes at the UN.

Rabobank Admits Subprime Exposure & Purchase of Failed Banks, Desjardins on Citigroup Deal


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 31 -- When the UN scheduled a press conference Monday entitled "Financial Crisis and Cooperative Banks," it was expected that the two cooperative banks invited to speak would be akin to the credit unions being praised in the Occupy Wall Street movement, in opposition to big banks like JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America.

But on the UN podium was the chairman of Dutch multinational Rabobank, Mr. Piet Moerland. Inner City Press asked him about protests to Rabobank in the United States, complete with mariachi bands and complaints of discriminating against small borrowers, and also about Rabobank's statements that it was "exposed" to subprime lending in the US. Video here, from Minute 26:05.

Moerland replied that Rabobank had to expand outside of The Netherlands because of its small population, and that the US is its most important non-Dutch market. He acknowledged the exposure to subprime lending, calling it "indirect," but bragged that Rabobank grew from 30 billion Euros in 2006 up to 40 billion Euros.

He said in the US it's made purchases "at the request of the FDIC" - that is, of failed banks. Apparently, Rabobank has profited from the global financial crisis. Moerland said that in California, Rabobank is "about half way there." We'll see.

Why such a multinational bank would be presented at the UN as the poster child of the cooperative movement, a topic on which former UK prime minister Gordon Brown speechified to the General Assembly later on Monday, is not clear.

Smaller but similarly mystifying was the presence of Canada's Desjardins Group. Its CEO Monique Leroux said that before growing outside of Canada -- it already has a presence in Florida in the US -- or making other expansions, it would speak with its people.

Inner City Press asked about a recent Desjardins deal with Citigroup and Staples, to buy a credit card portfolio. Did Desjardins check with its depositors before that business transaction? Ms. Leroux referred back to a 2009 meeting at which business lines were agreed to. After that, it seems, it's just business.

Footnote: a reporter from Agence France Presse, which is 41% funded by the French government, asked if either bank would lend to Greece. During the Brussels meetings, French president Sarkozy said Greece shouldn't have been allowed to join the Eurozone, and was angry to play second fiddle to Germany's Angela Merkel. Neither banker answered the Greece question, and the AFP reporter didn't push. And so it goes at the UN.

On Myanmar, As UN Dodges on Kachin IDPs, Nambiar Set Off on Quiet Diplomacy

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 31 -- The UN has an envoy to Myanmar, Vijay Nambiar, but his work is kept nearly secret and he has repeated refused to answer press questions at the UN.

On October 25 Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky

Inner City Press: Tomas Ojea Quintana, the Special Rapporteur [on the situation of human rights in Myanmar] had noted that an offer was made by the UN system of aid to Myanmar to assist those being displaced by this fighting between the Government and the Kachin rebels, and says that the Government turned it down flat. So what I wonder is, is there any response by Ban Ki-moon or Vijay Nambiar, the envoy or good offices, to this rejection of help for people that — at least according to Ojea Quintana — are in need?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I don’t have anything for you, and I will obviously be able to check to see if there is anything, and indeed it may be something that Ms. Amos will be able to address tomorrow when she briefs you.

When Valerie Amos, the UN Humanitarian Coordinator, spoke on October 26, she said that generally the will not do anything beyond its mandate, in order to not get thrown out of a country.

She was referring to Sudan -- apparently not having read the Darfur peacekeeping mission UNAMID's 2007 mandate regarding disarming the Janjaweed militia -- but this silence seems to be the approach of the UN or at least Nambiar with respect to Myanmar.

On October 27, Nesirky in the opening to the UN noon briefing read out this statement:

"just to follow up on a question from the other day, regarding assistance to vulnerable people in northern Myanmar, we have asked our colleagues on the ground in Myanmar, who tell us that assistance is being delivered in reachable areas. Meanwhile, discussions continue to ensure that assistance reaches all those in need."

Inner City Press immediately asked for clarification:

Inner City Press: what you just read out, does that mean over the border or within Myanmar itself?

Spokesperson Nesirky: It says what it says, Matthew — to reach all those in need.

Inner City Press: You said “reachable areas”, and the question was what [areas inside Myanmar].

Spokesperson: Well, there are two parts. It says that assistance is being delivered in reachable areas, and meanwhile discussions continue to ensure that assistance reaches all those in need. I don’t have anything beyond what I have just read out to you; otherwise, I would have read out a little bit more. What’s your next question?

Well the next question might be: what if anything is Nambiar going to do or at least say on this issue during his just stealthy begun trip to Myanmar? Watch this site.

Footnote: Nambiar has not only said no to repeated requests to give a press conference, he also rebuffs UN correspondents, and not only this one, in the type of informal Q&A most officials engage in.

As Inner City Press and another UN correspondent from the Middle East recently waited -- in vain as it turned out -- for an in person read out of Middle East meeting by Ban Ki-moon and his staff, Nambiar came out of the elevator. The other correspondent said hello and began to ask a question. But Nambiar was gone. And now in Myanmar.

As Israel Writes SC on Violence from Gaza, OIC Lobbies for Palestine at UNESCO

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 30 -- As Israel complained of Security Council silence on their complaint of "violence emanating from Gaza" and the Organization of the Islamic Cooperation promoted its lobbying in Paris for Palestine to join UNESCO, it was a Sunday morning of dueling press releases.

First at 8:04 am from Israel's Mission to the UN came Ambassador Ron Prosor's letter which the Mission said was sent to the Council on snowy Saturday night, saying

"Two days ago, I wrote to the Security Council and expressed my Government’s concern about the escalating violence emanating from Gaza, alerting the international community about the dangerous potential for civilian casualties. The Council did not utter a single word of condemnation. Today one Israeli civilian was murdered and others lay injured in hospitals this evening as a result of the escalating rocket fire – and we still only hear silence from the Security Council."

Some, particularly on the Sunday morning talk shows if they got it in time, would see this in context as an implicit critique of the Obama administration, or at least the US Mission to the UN for not seeking a Council meeting. Click here for Prosor's letter.

Inner City Press on Friday outside the Security Council asked Ambassador Prosor about Palestine's bid for UN membership, specifically the November 11 meeting at which the full Council will get a report from its Committee on the Admission of New Member.

Prosor replied that he doesn't think the Council will vote that day on Palestine's application.

The addition to the Council on January 1 of Pakistan, Azerbaijan -- whose foreign minister told Inner City Press on camera he'll follow the OIC line on Palestine -- and Morocco, which has said the same off camera, may result in those opposing Palestinian membership calling for a vote before then. Click here for first story by Inner City Press on this.

Palestine's application to join UNESCO remains pending; Security Council members Germany and the US, among 58 UNESCO members in the preliminary vote, opposed it as untimely.

Now OIC chief Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu has described his lobbying in Paris on October 30 of OIC members and non member states in advance of the October 31 voting. If Palestine joins UNESCO, not only would World Heritage Site status be on the table: it would seem to be a precedent for Palestine joining the International Criminal Court and being able to call, as an ICC member, for investigation of the situation in Gaza. Watch this site.

Saturday, October 29, 2011

For ICC, France Offered to Support Unqualified Judge Quid Pro Quo for Cathala

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, October 29 -- In the run up to the election of six International Criminal Court judges set for New York in December, France offered to support a candidate found to be unqualified if his country would support the French candidate Bruno Cathala, Inner City Press has learned.

There are 19 candidates for the six ICC judge seats. They were reviewed by the Independent Panel on International Criminal Court Judicial Elections and four -- from Tunisia, Cyprus, Costa Rica and Mexico -- were found to be "unqualified."

The Panel's members include not only South African justice and international prosecutor Richard Goldstone, and ICTY and US judge Patricia Wald but also former top UN lawyer Hans Corell.

Nevertheless, when one of the "unqualified" candidates met with France to try to make his case, he tells Inner City Press that he was surprised to be offered a deal: that if his country committed to vote for the French candidate, he could count on France's vote.

France styles itself a champion of international criminal justice and accountability. But just as it asserted itself to place atop UN Peacekeeping Herve Ladsous, the chief of staff of foreign ministers Alain Juppe and Michele Aliot-Marie including when she flew on planes owned by cronies of Tunisian dictator Ben Ali, it is seeking to its candidate Bruno Cathala as a judge on the ICC. Will it work?

Beyond this quid pro pro, when Inner City Press previously asked Cathala when he was ICC Registrar about immunity given toLaurent Nkunda in the Kivus in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, he replied that the ICC was not part of the negotiation of that immunity which, he claimed, did not include war crimes or other ICC-relevant crimes.

Cathala quoted the ICC's deputy prosecutor (and now candidate to replace Moreno Ocampo) Fatou Bensouda that the ICC's phase of investigation in Ituri was over. But indicteee Ngudjolo's co-warlord Peter Karim was and is still in the Congolese Army, despite having kidnapped and killed UN peacekeepers.

Since Karim ultimately released some of the peacekeepers, it appears that he got some deal. So even beyond the quid pro quo, there are further questions to be asked. Inner City Press' series on the ICC and ICJ judicial elections and needed reforms will continue. Watch this site.