Saturday, October 22, 2011

Amid UN SC Stalling with "Palestine Ping Pong," Mansour Says October Conclusion

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 13 -- The Security Council's slow charade of mulling Palestine's application for UN members continued Thursday in a three hour meeting in the Council's consultations room.

Afterward representatives of the "Strong Six" supporting Palestine expressed frustration, that those seeking delay spoke in circles and now wanted to refer the matter back up to the level of Permanent Representatives and then have it sent down again. One wag dubbed this "Palestine Ping Pong."

October's Security Council president Joy Ogwu of Nigeria told the press that the process is "arduous," and that the Committee might meet again as early as Friday. (Later when the Committee members left, several said the next meeting would be Monday at earliest.)

Inner City Press asked Ogwu if she expected the process at the experts' level to be completed during her presidency. She said she didn't know.

Palestinian Permanent Observer Riyad Mansour arrived after the meeting was over. He told Inner City Press, "This process will come to a conclusion soon."

Inner City Press asked him, "During the Nigerian presidency?"

"Yes," Mansour said or predicted. We'll see.

As UN Silent on Occupy Wall Street, Ban Added B of A Chair to His Energy Group


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 13 -- On protests taking place less then 100 blocks south of the UN, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has had no comment for ten days.

Back on October 3, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if there was any UN comment on the arrest of 700 non-violent protesters. No, Nesirky said, "I don’t have anything immediate for you. If I get something then I would certainly let you know."

The UN has said nothing since. On October 11, Inner City Press reported on an Occupy Wall Street action targeting Bank of America largely for its involvement in funding mountain top removal coal mining. Click here for video from Inner City Press.


Protest of Bank of America across from Zuccotti Park, (c) MRLee

On October 13, Inner City Press asked Nesirky why Ban had, only on September 20, 2011, named Bank of American chairman Charles O. Holliday Jr. to the UN's High Level Group on Sustainable Energy Access. Video here, from Minute 41:18.

Was Ban aware of the mountain top coal mining issues at Holliday's Bank of America? What does Ban think of mountain top removal?

Nesirky's response was that Ban took part in a conference in Norway about sustainable energy. Inner City Press asked for a response to the critique that Ban naming Holliday to the UN position was inconsistent with sustainable energy, given Bank of America's record. Video here, from Minute 43:40.


"I heard you the first time," Nesikry said. But did he? The request for UN comment on Occupy Wall Street was made by Inner City Press ten days ago. Is Ban Ki-moon's UN blind?

Ban's UN certainly doesn't like to answer questions. Consider:

Ban Ki-Moon doesn't deign to talk about pop stars. On Saturday, the United Nations' secretary general observed the 20th anniversary of South Korea's admission to the UN with a press reception at its consulate on E. 45th St. Among the guests were some Korean pop acts, including DBSK and 4 Minute. Ban thanked them for coming and accepted a CD from one artist, but his receptiveness did not extend to what we think was a legit question about his teeny bopper guests. When The News' David Yi asked Ban why it was important for the acts to be there, he reports the UN chief turned away and three of his handlers "pushed" him aside. "How dare you ask a question like that to the UN secretary general?" said one. Seriously? [Click here, last item.]

Inner City Press has twice asked the UN to confirm or deny, and which security was involved: South Korean mission security? No answer at all.

Footnote: After just returning from Norway, Denmark and Sweden, Ban head tonight to Washington for President Obama's reception for South Korea's president. Then Ban head to Switzerland. Will protesters catch up with him?

At UN, Top Peacekeeper Ladsous Dismisses Tunisia Scandal, Haiti & Rwanda Comments

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 13 -- Herve Ladsous is the fourth Frenchman in a row put atop the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations, a Gallic functionary who was earlier this year chief of staff to disgraced French foreign minister Michele Aliot-Marie who flew during the Arab Spring on planes provided by allies of Tunisian dictator Ben Ali.

Six weeks ago, Ladsous was suddenly given the UN job upon the nomination of the French government of Nicolas Sarkozy, after the UN rejected Jerome Bonnafont who had started bragging to diplomats in India about getting the post.

Finally on October 13 Ladsous finally took questions from the press.

Inner City Press asked Ladsous about l'affaire Aliot-Marie and Ben Ali, as well as about comments he made in 2004 urging elected president Jean-Bertrand Aristide to leave Haiti, and in 1994 defending France's position on Rwanda, which was to support the killings led by Colonel Theoneste Bagosora. Video here, from Minute 21:52.

"I will not go into personal aspects," Ladsous replied, saying dismissively that Rwanda was 15 years ago -- of course, it remains a major scandal and trauma for UN Peacekeeping, pulling out as 800,000 people where killed -- and that, as with Haiti, he was only speaking for the French government, so he wouldn't respond.

Structurally similar, in Sudan Ahmed Haroun says that everything he did was for the government in Khartoum. That doesn't mean that Haroun isn't held responsible. Why would it be different for Ladsous? Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky cut off the follow up question. Video here, at Minute 25:09.

If even what Ladsous did earlier this year, presiding as chief of staff over flights in dictator's allies' planes, is somehow irrelevant, a "personal aspect," what ARE Ladsous' qualifications for the top UN Peacekeeping job, other than the endorsement of Nicolas Sarkozy?

France, of course, has its own national interest in sites of UN Peacekeeping, for example in Cote d'Ivore, which Ladsous used as his first example of UN Peacekeeping success. Despite knowing that the question was coming, Ladsous did not deign to respond to the critique that the job shouldn't only be given out based on nationality, and now four times in a row to the same nationality. This does not bode well.

Footnotes: Ladsous said to show him "indulgence" and not ask about details, at least yet. And so Inner City Press directed its question about UN Peacekeepers' inaction in Southern Kordofan to UN spokesman Nesirky, who said he was "just making the point" that this should have been asked to Ladsous instead of the background and qualification questions. Video here, from Minute 37:57.

There are other question, already: Ladsous is said to have told the Security Council that South Sudan forces are still in Abyei, but many think this was overplayed, that the South Sudan numbers are small and understandable. And why isn't DPKO flying in the Ethiopian deployment to Abyei? Ladsous continued to speak Thursday about flooded roads.

What of the discipline, if any, of Beninois peacekeepers repatriated from Cote d'Ivoire for buying sex for food from under-aged girls? How can an official who refused to address or explain his own actions implement a zero tolerance policy? We'll stay on this - watch this site.

Sudan Border Help Stalled by Money Questions of France & US, UN Kordofan Inaction

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, October 13 -- Even as further evidence of UN inaction and cover-up regarding murder in Southern Kordofan emerges, the UN Security Council has yet to vote to modify the mandate of the peacekeeping mission in Abyei, UNISFA, to allow its Ethiopian troops to provide protection along the contested border outside of Abyei. Why?

On October 12 multiple Council sources told Inner City Press that in closed door consultations on October 11, two Permanent members have raised questions about the costs of allowing and transporting even just 300 peacekeepers to act along the long border between South and north Sudan.

That France is one of these two P5 members is not surprising: they "played cheapskate," as one major troop contributing country put it, during the formation of UNISFA, and led the charge in the UN's budget committee to deny peacekeepers a long overdue raise.

Asked by Inner City Press, a UK spokesman responded that, "We have not raised the issue of the additional costs of these proposed further 300 peacekeepers in the Security Council.

But as with all proposed force changes for any PKO, we’ll want to look at costs carefully, and if approved, continue to monitor costs and the overall effectiveness of these changes.”

So the second country, at least to some activists, comes as a surprise: the United States. Apologists for this US approach say, predictably, that it "not just about the money."

They say that the US Mission to the UN, led by Susan Rice, is frustrated that not only Khartoum but also South Sudan have yet to remove their troops from Abyei as agreed.

In this view, not "giving in" to the rare joint request of South and north Sudan for these 300 plus peacekeepers -- and four helicopters and two jets, Inner City Press is told -- is a way to force them to live up to their agreement to leave Abyei.

With the US current focused the alleged Iran versus Saudi Arabia plot and other issues including Palestine's application to the Security Council for full UN membership, which the US opposes, it is not clear if a linkage between implementation in Abyei and agreeing to assist along with longer contested border can be publicly acknowledged and defended.

Meanwhile, in the wake of the UN's cover-up of its Egyptian peacekeepers' inaction in Southern Kordofan before the UNMIS mission's mandate expired on July 9, a new report provides additional details about murders by the "Abu Tira" Central Reserve Police organized by Ahmed Haroun.

Haroun was and is a war criminal indicted by the International Criminal Court whom the UN flew back and forth to Abyei in a UN helicopter.

Of this incident, as Inner City Press raised August 15 to the UN, the UN's initial report stated that

"29. On 8 June, an UNMIS independent contractor (IC) was pulled out of a vehicle by SAF in front of the UNMIS Kadugli Sector IV Compound in the presence of several witnesses, while UN peacekeepers could not intervene. He was taken around the corner of the compound and gunshots were heard. Later he was discovered dead by UNMIS personnel and IDPs. Several sources confirmed that the victim was an active SPLM member." (Emphasis added.)

When the edited version was released, this paragraph appeared with the key phrase "while UN peacekeepers could not intervene" entirely removed, as if the Egyptian UN peacekeepers had not been there:

"17. On 8 June, an UNMIS individual contractor (IC) was pulled out of a vehicle by SAF in front of the UNMIS Kadugli Sector IV compound in the presence of several witnesses. He was taken away from the vicinity of the compound and gunshots were heard. Later he was discovered dead by UNMIS personnel and IDPs. Several sources confirmed that the victim was an active SPLM member."

Now, the Sudan Sentinel Project early on October 13 put out a press release including

"eyewitness reports of the abduction and murder of Numeiri Philip Kalo, a UN independent contractor with Tri-Star Fueling and a Catholic seminarian, were communicated to SSP. One witness reported to SSP that Abu Tira abducted Numeiri, a Nuba man who was an active SPLM supporter, on 8 June from the east UNMIS gate. They reportedly put him in an Abu Tira Land Cruiser, drove around the corner, shot him with automatic weaponry, and dumped his bullet-riddled body from the moving vehicle in front of the CRP compound. Egyptian peacekeepers, among other people, reportedly observed the abduction and murder."

The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights report which was leaked and then carefully edited, as exclusively reported by Inner City Press, played down the knowledge and inaction of the UN's Egyptian peacekeepers.

Back in late August, after multiple inquiries by Inner City Press, OHCHR spokesman Rupert Colville in Geneva replied about this edit:

"draft para 29 / final para 17: original phrase 'while UN peacekeepers could not intervene' is ambiguous. Does it mean they were not ABLE to? If so was that for circumstantial reasons, or because of rules of engagement? Or does it mean they chose not to? After checking with the field, we were unable to establish the precise circumstances, so the reference was deleted."

For UN peacekeepers to fail to act during killings, important in this instance to no less that the Bishop of Kadugli and previously of interest from Srebrenica to Rwanda, should not be left ambiguous -- but it should definitely not by deleted, by the UN.

The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights could and should have determined what were the rules of engagement for these UN peacekeepers, and should have addressed the allegations by the Bishop of Kadugli and others that the peacekeepers decided not to act because they sided with Khartoum and its militias.

To delete the reference and airbrush out the peacekeepers is, in this view, entirely irresponsible. Now what? Watch this site.