Saturday, October 8, 2011

After Apologizing to Turks, Now Ban Thanks UN Security for Restraint

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 29 -- After six days of UN stonewalling about the Turkish delegation beat-down of UN Security and UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's fast apology to Prime Minister Erdogan, on Thursday morning Ban belated put online a note to UN staff, particularly Security and Protocol, thanking them for their "restraint." See below.

Fast reactions from UN staff included disgust, amazement and anger. Why did Ban immediately apologize to Turkey, even as at least three UN Security officers lay injured? One, Inner City Press has learned, is still using crutches.

Meanwhile questions have arising about the role of the UN's Protocol Office. For three days, Inner City Press has asked a simple factual question: how many extra ID passes to enter the UN were given to the Turkish delegation?

On September 27, Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky said he would check. But he had no answer on September 28, or since. The goal seems to be to have the story die, due to lack of answers.

But the UN is a public organization. On September 28, Inner City Press asked the spokeswoman for the President of the General Assembly, who referred all questions back to Nesirky, who would not answer them.

Meanwhile UN Security sources said that beyond Officer Matthew Sullivan with injured ribs and the female officer beaten in the face, another male UN Security officer was left walking on crutches, suspended then on "administrative leave" after Ban apologized to the Turks.

The level of anger at Ban is growing, but as numerous of Ban's guards tell Inner City Press, Ban is totally isolated, "living in his own world."

And from the world, here's is Ban's belated double speak:

Message from the Secretary-General
Posted: Thursday, 29 September 2011, New York | Author: Secretary-General BAN Ki-moon

As the 66th General Debate draws to a close, I would like to express my immense gratitude to all officials and staff of the UN Secretariat for their hard work and dedication. The demands have been great and, as ever, you have risen to the occasion.

In particular, I wish to thank the Protocol and Security Officers of the United Nations. The pressures they faced in performing their duties were especially difficult, and they met these pressures with dignity, restraint and high professionalism in the best tradition of the Organisation.

To all, I ask that you accept my sincere thanks and deep appreciation for your commitment to the great causes that bind us.

BAN Ki-moon

Saturday, October 1, 2011

France Tries to Block W. Sahara Briefing to Aid Morocco's UNSC Bid, AU Pushes Back


By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, September 28, updated -- During April's fight at the UN about human rights in Western Sahara, it was agreed that UN envoy Christopher Ross would come back and brief the Security Council in October.

But with Morocco up for a contested election with Mauritania for a seat on the Council, the Secretariat of Ban Ki-moon told the Council's president for October, Nigeria, that Ross didn't want to brief, that he had little new information and didn't want to conflict with the Council election.

That is, a briefing about human rights violations in Western Sahara would not be helpful to Morocco's run.

Inner City Press on September 28 asked South African Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu about the claim the Ross did not want to brief. "Preposterous," Sangqu called it, adding, "They were trying to say there is an election to the Security Council, with Morocco running."

Supporting or directing Ban Ki-moon's Secretariat in this was Morocco's main supporter France, assisted to the surprise of some by the United Kingdom. (Even one of the surprised said perhaps the UK wanted to "preserve the Special Envoy's independence," and noted that the election for the Security Council has been moved to later in October.)

Late Wednesday, Inner City Press asked Ambassadors Gerard Araud of France and Mark Lyall Grant of the UK, "What about Western Sahara?" Looking surprised, Lyall Grant said "You have to ask my French colleague about that, the UK has a carefully balanced position on Western Sahara." Araud himself did not answer.

In order to stand up to the pressure, South Africa and Nigeria joined forces with Brazil, and also to the surprise of some Gabon, which went silent on Western Sahara back in April.

In a rare UN victory for non-Permanent members, the African Union Three and Brazil appear to have won, with the decision as of September 26 being that Ross will brief the Council on October 11. But could that change?

Some were reluctant to confirm it. Inner City Press asked Nigerian Ambassador Joy Ogwu, October Council president, who looked surprised and replied, "All those are speculation." But multiple sources say this is just how it happened. How will October be?

In another contested race, Hungary faces off against Slovenia and others, with positions on Palestine one of the litmus tests. Watch this site.

On Iran Contrary to Juppe, Araud Threatens Military Action, State Media AFP Gushes, Bungles

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 28 -- French foreign minister Alain Juppe said "no" on September 19 when asked "Were diplomacy and sanctions to fail in the case of Iran, would France favor military intervention?"

Juppe replied, "Very simple answer: No. We intervened militarily in Libya, but I would like to reassure you, we are not fans of military intervention, of course, especially against a country like Iran... I think that sanction are efficient on the long term."

Eight days later French Permanent Representative to the UN Gerard Araud was dutifully quoted by French government media Agence FRANCE Presse that "If we don't succeed today to reach a negotiation with the Iranians, there is a strong risk of military action."

So which one is true? AFP did not mention Juppe's previous statement, only intervening statements of Nicolas Sarkozy. AFP called these Araud's "surprisingly frank comments at a New York panel discussion" -- but it involved only Araud and a single questioner.

Nor did AFP analyze another Araud quote it transcribed, that "'All the Arab countries are extremely worried about what is happening' with Iran's nuclear drive." One question is obvious: isn't Syria an Arab country?

Lebanese Permanent Representative to the UN Nawaf Salam was holding a reception Tuesday night less than 20 blocks from Araud's "panel discussion" to which UN press corps members were only selectively invited. AFP reported the most breathlessly about Araud's remarks, without analyzing or weighing any of them.

On Wednesday at the UN's noon briefing, AFP reporter Tim Witcher came and asked the spokesman for Secretary General Ban Ki-moon if he wished to say more about Syria than was in the short read-out of Ban's meeting with that country's foreign minister. Not surprisingly, and seemingly scripted, the spokesman did have more to say.

This same reporter on Tuesday after Sudan's foreign minister Ali Karti said that of the UNISFA peacekeepers "fifty percent are there" in the contested Abyei area asked Karti, "fifty percent have left?" Karti said "no, deployed." Anyway, France is sure to have its own numbers. Watch this site.

At UN on Palestine, Lobbying Works Both Ways, Goodluck to All

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 28 -- After a meeting on Palestine mere minutes in length, Israeli Permanent Representative Ron Prosor and Palestinian Permanent Observer Riyad Mansour both spoke to the press.

Mansour said, in essence, look how many meetings: Monday, Wednesday and Friday as the first meeting of the committee "at the Ambassador level" on Palestine's application.

He said that Israel's Netanyahu government announcing 1100 new settlement housing units was 1100 "no's" to peace. Inner City Press asked Mansour for the response to the Quartet Statement, which he'd said would be Wednesday.

You will hear from Ramallah, Mansour said and left the stakeout. Prosor took his place and said again, by way of opening, that Jerusalem was the capital of the Jewish people while London was still a swamp. (Prosor began using this line when he was Israeli Ambassador to the UK -- some think he should update his material.)

Inner City Press asked him for his Security Council vote count for Palestinian UN membership, and if Israel is lobbying Gabon, Nigeria and Bosnia, at least the Republica Srbska portion.

Prosor cited US President Obama that "through the Security Council, Palestine will not become the 194th member state," then acknowledged that Israel, too, is lobbying: "truthfully, we are both working."

One step was Ehud Barak meeting with Nigeria's Goodluck Jonathan. Some think it was an error to come out of the meeting bragging that Nigeria would abstain, and talking about meeting with Nigeria's oil minister. But to each his own. Game on.

On Palestine, OIC & NAM Cards Played, Kosovo & Syria Are Back

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 28 -- Still searching for nine votes for Palestine membership in the UN, the Non-Aligned Movement caucus met in the Security Council Tuesday afternoon, joined by Egypt's pre- and post-Arab Spring Permanent Representative and the Palestinian delegation.

Afterward Nestor Osorio of Colombia, a NAM member which will not vote for Palestinian membership, took the line that bilateral negotiations are the only way. Others rolled their eyes.

And so Wednesday morning at 9:30 the application of Palestine is set to be referred to an Ad Hoc committee made up of the same 15 Security Council members. One well placed diplomat emphasized to Inner City Press that the Ad Hoc committee can't just "sit on" the application, but has to make a report.

"The full Security Council, for sure, can sit on the Palestinian application," the diplomat continued, smiling.

While one Permanent Representative told Inner City Press action on Palestine could be expected in two weeks, another well placed European source said "at the very least a month," tying this to the Quartet statement of September 23.

There's been a lot of questioning about the positions of three countries: Bosnia, Nigeria and Gabon. Some say that members of the OIC should of course vote with Palestine. Others point to US and French ties and, for the former, to the Republica Srbska.

On a somewhat related matter, Inner City Press on Tuesday morning began asking diplomats about the tensions in northern Kosovo, with seven Serbs and four NATO peacekeepers injured.

At first few had heard of it, and at noon Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky answered Inner City Press' question about it by saying if he got a statement or "line" he'd pass it on. (It hasn't happened.)

Later Kosovo was put on the Council's agenda for Wednesday afternoon along with, not disclosed in the Program sent out, the new Syria draft resolution. Apparently now resolution "in blue" can be easily superceded and replaced: call it "light blue."

Wednesday there is also a meeting about Counter Terrorism and, not in the UN Journal, a consultation of the Permanent Five members about Sudan. Watch this site.

On Myanmar, France Cautiously Welcomes, UK Worries of Kachin & Shan, Nambiar

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 27 -- When Ban Ki-moon's Group of Friends on Myanmar met Tuesday afternoon things were different. Despite an upsurge in government attacks and displacement in East and Northern Burma, the mood was congratulations, for freeing Aun Sang Suu Kyi and holding elections how ever flawed.

On the way into the meeting, Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar could not find his way, even to the bathroom, requiring directions from an Associate Spokesperson. Afterward even the UK's Mark Lyall Grant said he hadn't raise the issue of replacing Nambiar, since Ban said he would send him back to the country.

But Nambiar never speaks to the press or answers questions. He is a Myanmar unto himself, perhaps perfect for the job if the job is cover up.

When the meeting was over, or actually before, French Ambassador Gerard Araud left the room, intent on presenting about Iran up at the French consulate. He told a reporter, as told to Inner City Press with direct concern, that France cautiously welcomes the changes in Myanmar. But what does that mean?

UK Permanent Representative Mark Lyall Grant, who left later, was more direct, saying that the UK is concerned about violence in the ethnic areas of the Kachin and Shan, and want the NLD political party to be able to register.

Inner City Press asked Lyall Grant if he'd raised his previous point, about the need to replace Nambiar. Not this time, Lyall Grant indicated, saying that since Ban had said he'd be sending Nambiar back to Myanmar and soon, he had held his tongue. And so it goes at the UN.