Saturday, October 1, 2011

Lebanon UN SC Month Ends With Felafel & Palestine, Of Turks & Jerks & Giuliani

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 27 -- With three days left in Lebanon's presidency of the UN Security Council, Ambassador Nawaf Salam threw an end of presidency bash in his huge Madison Avenue apartment on Tuesday night.

One longtime Deputy Permanent Representative marveled that there was no one burning issue of the evening, but rather discussions of Palestine, Libya, the Turkish fight with UN Security and holding up the rear Sudan, in that order.

The floors were lacquered red, the walls wood paneled and the felafel was hot. The Permanent Representatives of China, Portugal, Germany, South African, Nigeria, India, Bosnia, Brazil and more moved through the crowd, talking sanctions and GA intrigue, winding down from the UN's highest week.

Without attributing the sentiment to anyone in particular, there seemed to be a consensus that nothing will move fast on Palestine's application for full UN membership. The Ad Hoc comment might have to report, but the full Council can sit on it.

One European diplomat told Inner City Press it is impossible that any of the four EU members of the Council would vote "yes" for Palestine in the Council. The candidates for the next Council - Romania and Hungary, Morocco and Mauritania, for example -- might now be grilled on their views of Palestine.

Otherwise the interest was in the Turkish UN fight -- most people saying Ban Ki-moon, who did not appear, should never have apologized so quickly. Ban officials Patricia O'Brien and Kiyotaka Akasaka were in the house, as well as some from Security Council Affairs. Ban's scheduled had him going to Indonesia, but that was true of many Ambassadors.

What has to be said of Nawaf Salam is that despite being in a sense awkward, he was and is essentially decent, endeavoring to answer questions, in three languages, under constraints. Like Bosnia, Beirut's moment to moment politics do not make voting easy. By his heavy loaded bookshelves Inner City Press posited what an absent journalist had said, that Salam was a Maoist. An aide did not disagree.

Another joked, Giuliani lives across the hall -- some location for a Maoist. But Salam is an intellectual, as previously noted, an author and editor of books. More of this is needed at the UN. Hats off. Shukran -- with three days left. Watch this site.

Ban's Apology to Turkey After UN Staff Were Beaten Still Unexplained

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 27 -- Dissatisfaction with UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon grew on Tuesday as his Office refused to explain why he apologized to the Turkish delegation of Prime Minister Erdogan even as UN Security officers lay injured, beaten by Erdogan's guards.

Inner City Press, which exclusively on September 23 reported the fight and fall out, on September 27 put questions to Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky in writing and then at the noon briefing.

By five o'clock none had been answered, except for a "no" to a request that UN Security chief Greg Starr hold a press conference on the scandal. Security source suggest that the person to brief is David Joseph Bongi.

Before 11 am Tuesday, Inner City Press put five questions by e-mail to Nesirky, none answered or acknowledged six hours later:

Here are five question for this morning in addition to the ones pending:

1. Did the S-G himself come up with the idea of preemptively apologizing to Prime Minister Erdogan, or was this a recommendation of one of his advisers?

2. There are Security officers complaining that a more proper course of action would have been to conduct a full inquiry before making an apology. If the apology wasn't Mr. Ban's idea, whose was it? Mr. Nambiar's? Mr. Pascoe's? Mr. Starr's? Can these officials answer questions?

3. Will the UN Secretariat, or the Secretary-General, take any steps to advise Delegations to heed the instructions of security personnel?

4. Some DSS officers and UN staff believe that the SG owes them an apology for how he handled this incident. Is there any contrition on the part of the S-G or his advisers, or would you have handled this the same way again (e.g. a preemptive apology)?

5. Will there be an actual investigation of this incident, including the retaliatory actions against the officers by Management, and if so, who will conduct it?

Nesirky and his team, two of whom were cc-ed, never even acknowledged receipt of these questions.

So at Tuesday's noon briefing Inner City Press had to ask:

Spokesperson Nesirky: Yes, Matthew?

Inner City Press: one question I sent you earlier today and then something else that’s just factual on this. You’ve said that there there is an attempt to look into avoiding this in the future, in whichever way it is. And I wanted to know if that involves in any way telling delegations to, you know, heed the instructions of UN Security or to not, it seems with the apology, the implication is that the UN Security were in the wrong, although they were the ones injured. So I wanted to know, is there some message going out to the delegations, I say this because people in UN Security say they said “stop”, they didn’t stop and that’s what happened. So is that viewed by you as part of something that the Secretariat could clarify to delegations, or is it just, if anything happens, UN Security is wrong, as it appears to some?

Spokesperson: What I said yesterday was that necessary action is being taken to prevent such misunderstandings in the future. And that action could take various forms. I don’t know at this stage what that could include. Clearly, liaising with delegations in the run-up to the General Assembly is an important part of such activities to prevent misunderstandings.

Inner City Press: Factually, it seems that even the Turkish Mission and delegation acknowledge that they requested and received extra passes, that their delegation involved not only the Prime Minister, but a Deputy Prime Minister and five separate ministers and then a bunch of security. And so the question is: is it possible to know what other countries were given extra passes in this way, because it seems to some in Security to have contributed to the incident?

Spokesperson: Let me ask. Yeah?

Inner City Press: maybe you will answer this one. you didn’t say it was an apology, but the Turks have said in the Turkish press that it was, that he received an apology. And it seems to have taken place around 2:30 p.m. on Friday. So, given all the constraints that you’re under, to say, what did the Secretary-General know at that time that led him to say something that the Turkish side took as an apology? Did he speak to Mr. Starr? What was the basis of his information? even if you don’t want to say what the information was, what did he know at 2:30 p.m. Friday that led him to say something that was interpreted as an apology?

Spokesperson: Well, as I have said, we believe that this has been satisfactorily resolved. I confirmed yesterday that the Secretary-General did indeed meet the Prime Minister. And I don’t really have anything further on that...

Inner City Press: One, just more on that. Did Mr. Starr give a yes or no in terms of giving some kind of a press availability about UN Security as regards this incident and otherwise?

Spokesperson: Not explicit, but I believe it’s no.

So UN Security sources suggest to the Press one David Joseph Bongi. They also tell Inner City Press there is an investigation, or "fact finding," but doubt any results will be made public unless the press keeps pushing. Keep Pressing, they say. Will do.

In Abyei, Sudan Says UN Half Deployed, UK Says SAF Must Leave Sept 30, Frustration

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 27, updated -- At the last UN Security Council meeting about Abyei, the still acting chief of UN Peacekeeping Edmond Mulet told the Press that Sudan had committed to pull its troops out of Abyei by September 30.

With three days to go before that deadline, Inner City Press on Tuesday asked Sudanese foreign minister Ali Karti if the pull-out would be completed.

He answered that things are in process but noted that "fifty percent of those forces are there in Abyei," referring to the 4400 UNISFA peacekeepers mandated by the Security Council.

The designated new chief of UN Peacekeeping, Herve Ladsous, has still not appeared for work in New York, more than three weeks after he was named by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.

Tuesday at noon Inner City Press went and asked Ban's spokesman why only half of the UNISFA force has been deployed, and when the UN understands that the Sudanese Armed Forces should leave. Nesirky said he would check and answer, but four hours later nothing had been received.

UK Permanent Representative Mark Lyall Grant told Inner City Press that any argument that the rate of UNISFA deployment justified a failure to pull out by September 30 was "disingenuous." He said "we'd be concerned if that pull out didn't take place" by the end of the month.

Here is a copy of the agreement, which Inner City Press obtained and is putting online, here.

Inner City Press asked South African Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu if UNISFA's slow deployment could justify Sudanese delay. He shook his head, "They have to leave anyway. It takes time to deploy.... They have to move."

Thus it seems clear that Sudanese Armed Forces are expected to be out of Abyei in three days. But will they be?

Inner City Press also asked Karti about being on the US state sponsor of terrorism list. He said, "We don't have any connection with that issue... There are some political problems here, There is no yet real determination that Sudan should be removed from that list.. We know and they also know we don't have any connection with terrorism."

Sources in Khartoum say that Karti is being judged on whether he can get Sudan removed from the US terror list. And if he can't?

Update of 5:10 pm -- in the Quadpartite meeting of the UN, Ethiopia, North and South Sudan taking place in the North Lawn building, sources say there is great frustration, "Sudan keeps changing things that were already agreed to." Chicken and egg: no full deployment without SAF having pulled out; SAF apparently won't pull out until full or near full deployment. Watch this site.

Update of 5:54 pm -- even as acting DPKO chief Edmond Mulet told Inner City Press things are going well with UNISFA (except, when asked, with SAF's pull out from Abyei by September 30), China's Permanent Representative Li Baodong told Inner City Press that there will be "P-5 consultations tomorrow about Sudan." Watch this site.

Indonesia's Natalegawa Pitches Business With A Dash of Human Rights at CFR

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 27 -- When the US foreign policy establishment as represented by the Council on Foreign Relations hosts Indonesian foreign minister Marty Natalegawa, what gets asked about?

Mostly business rights, leavened or made palatable by a couple of human rights question, from two representatives of the same organization.

When Natalegawa replied Tuesday at CFR that Sri Lanka is "trying to do the right thing," there was no response or opportunity for Press questions.

CFR's presiding moderator was corporate lawyer James D. Zirin, whose specialty the program listed as "the defense of major accounting firms and financial institutions." So he's defended predatory lenders who took US government bail outs, before asking Natalegawa about his country's economic growth.

The money questions were followed up by, among others, Drew Ladner of Pascal Metrics Inc., who began by helpfully disclosing that he is "long" Indonesia. Listed as participants were businesspeople from Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, Blackstone and Corsair Capital.

As if to give the filthy lucre a sheen, both Human Rights Watch and Human Rights First were in the house, although only HRW got to question, twice as it happened. In essence this was window dressing to make the profit focus less venal.

Natalegawa twice emphasized his country's economy grew six percent in 2010, with 6.5% projected for 2011. If these was a roadshow, CFR was buying.

Inner City Press despite being invited, RSVP-ing and arriving on time was not allowed a question, nor a follow up to the Sri Lanka answer. No one asked for example about Saudi Arabia's treatment and execution of Indonesian workers.

Thankfully, thirty blocks from CFR's Park Avenue headquarters Inner City Press came upon Natalegawa and his Permanent Representative Monday evening in front of the UN, and asked if Tibor Toth's statement that Indonesia is about to join the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty is true.

Yes, Natalegawa answered, it is in the works. At CFR he spoke of a nuclear free zone, of ASEAN meetings with the nuclear powers. He fielded questions about Western Papua, speaking of groups armed with bows and arrows.

Natalegawa described Indonesia's policy at the Human Rights Council in Geneva as in evolution; he chided the proponents of country-specific resolutions for putting forward the same drafts year after year. Natalegawa called this inertia, a term that could equally be applied to today's Council on Foreign Relations. Watch this site.