Saturday, October 1, 2011

DSK Argues He's Immune Under Convention IMF Can Waive, US Hasn't Signed

By Matthew Russell Lee

BRONX NY, September 26 -- In the sexual abuse civil case pending against him in The Bronx, Dominique Strauss-Kahn now argues that he is absolutely immune under the 1947 Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the Specialized Agencies.

Strauss-Kahn acknowledges that the US is not a party to the Convention, but argues the courts in The Bronx are still bound by it in DSK's Memo of Law, obtained by Inner City Press and put online here.

It is elementary that the US is not bound by treaties and conventions which it hasn't signed and ratified. Plaintiff Nafissatou Diallo's lawyer quickly argued in an email. “Strauss-Kahn’s claim of diplomatic immunity will clearly fail because: (1) he is not a diplomat; (2) according to his own story he was in New York on ‘personal’ business; (3) he, not the IMF, paid for his room at the Sofitel; and (4) he was obviously acting in his personal capacity when he violently attacked Ms. Diallo.”

But it is also worth noting that the Specialized Agencies Convention says that "[e]ach specialized agency shall have the right and duty to waive the immunity of any official in any case where, in its opinion, the immunity would impede the course of justice and can be waived without prejudice to the interests of the specialized agency."

That is to say, the IMF can and should waive any immunity that DSK is arguing for.

Many disputed having DSK replaced by other French political official, on the theory that his successor would have a conflict of interest in deciding such questions as whether to waiving argued-for immunity. Now that issue is here: what will Christine Lagarde do? Inner City Press has asked the IMF:

"the IMF can waive any immunity that is being argued for. The question: will the IMF waive the IMF-based immunity for which Mr. Strauss-Kahn is arguing, or will the IMF shield him from the charges?"

Watch this site.

At UN on Libya, Jibril Says Gaddafi Is Needed at ICC, No Fly Scepticism of IRSA Unanswered

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 26 -- Libya was a main focus at the UN and Security Council throughout 2011, but Monday it was an afterthought, with the spotlight back on Palestine. The Libyan National Transitional Council's Mahmoud Jibril briefed the Security Council, asking that all assets be unfrozen.

Afterward Inner City Press asked Jebril if the TNC wants the travel ban and asset freeze to remain on Gaddafi and cronies. Gaddafi is "need at the ICC," Jibril answered, referring to the International Criminal Court. (Friday he told Inner City Press Gaddafi might end up being tried in Libya, click here for that.)

On the question the NATO, Inner City Press asked when the TNC thought NATO should put back. When civilians are not being killed, Jibril answered. When he left the microphone he chatted with Ambassadors Shalgam and Ibrahim Dabbashi, who also defected from Gaddafi's government.

A source inside the Council's consultations said that India, South Africa and Russia (call them IRSA) all asked when NATO would stop, pointing out that if commercial flights have resumed and high officials travel to Tripoli, the no fly zone is no longer in place, and notice is not being given to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.

"We didn't get an answer," the source said, not seeming surprised.

Likewise scepticism was expressed about unfreezing all the money. "It's money for the government," the source said. "Except there is no government yet. We don't want it disappearing."

"In the desert," Inner City Press mused.

"Or to small islands," the source answered. There was a joke about small island states. And then the Libya issue was gone, eclipsed by Palestine. And so it goes at the UN.

Soft UN & Dead Media Replaced By NGOs, Elite Soros Crowd Told at River Club

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 26 -- When the UN has gone soft and corporate media is dying, who or what will pick up the slack?

That was the question Monday night at the River Club ten blocks north of the UN where the non-governmental organization Global Witness hosted George Soros, financiers, journalists and tennis players in an Art Deco space beside a gleaming turquoise pool.

One of Global Witness' three founders Charmian Gooch told the crowd how they began on Cambodia, then illegal mining and now Gaddafi's Libya investment funds.

She said proudly, we have no membership, no public relations, no marketing. Then an Alex Soros was introduced to speak, as a history student at Berkeley, followed by investigative journalist Ken Silverstein.

Silverstein spoke of the death of media, how the Los Angeles Times closed its investigative unit and tried to replace three reporters' 900 bylines a year.

He now works at Harper's, and did a story on the side for Global Witness but at least initially kept his name off it, he told Inner City Press, in order to get into Cambodia.

All of this took place close to the UN, during the annual General Debate, but the UN wasn't mentioned once.


Soros looks heavenward at GW event by UN Monday night, publish what you pay

Inner City Press asked Silverstein about Equatorial Guinea being the head of the African Union, and Gabon on the Security Council. Silverstein said that the son of Equatorial Guinea's long time ruler Obiang leaving the US shows the power of the pen. But to what end?

Another journalist present cautioned, you cannot change the world. Then what was this event about, with the senior George Soros present, acknowledged from the podium? Tennis players in whites wandered through on their way to indoor courts, the signs outside of which told "Babysitters" to not enter without The Pro.

Footnote: Among the attendees was one Scott Wallace, writing about uncontacted tribes in Brazil. Inner City Press asked him about such tribes impacted by the Belo Monte dam; he said they exist. He said Peru denies the existence of such tribe. He will be in New York at the Explorers' Club in November. And we will try to be there.

Huge Turkish Delegation Felt Erdogan Was Pushed, Previous Run-Ins Alleged


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 26 -- As questions mount about UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon having apologized so quickly to Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan even as UN security officials were hospitalized following a run in with Erdogan's delegation on Friday, another perspective emerged on Monday afternoon.

Picking up on a line in Inner City Press' exclusive story, why lay hands on a prime minister, a source said that Erdogan and his large delegation were led the wrong way in the run up to Mahmoud Abbas' speech on Friday.

Coming from a bilateral meeting on the 4th floor balcony of the General Assembly, the wrong path to the speech was shown to them.

Already the GA Hall was full, and Erdogan's delegation included not only the security personnel, but also five ministers and a deputy prime minister.

The Turks were given extra passes to the UN, but some say other delegations were as well. In any event, the large delegation, having been led the wrong way, was stopped -- and Prime Minister Erdogan was jostled.

This triggered the melee that left UN Security Office Matthew Sullivan with injured ribs, and a female Caribbean UN officer with facial injuries. The Turks also suffered injuries or impacts but, tough guys to the end, did not seek hospitalization.

In this account, Ban Ki-moon apologized between 2 and 3 pm on Friday -- so soon after the incident that no investigation would have been possible. As UN Security officers see it, Ban Ki-moon "threw them under the bus," and didn't defend them.

"It's like Algeria," a UN Security official, referring to the UN staff killed by a bombing in Algeria. "He does nothing for us - it's all about him."

The source confirming the apology and its timing told Inner City Press that the run by Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar and Security chief Gregory Starr across First Avenue at 2:20 pm on Friday was to meet Ban at the Turkish Mission for the apology. Another Under Secretary General, Lynn Pascoe, is said to have apologized to Erdogan in the Indonesian Lounge next to the GA Hall.


While understanding to some degree not only the UN Security side, but also the Turkish side if Erdogan was pushed, what remains incomprehensible if not reprehensible to some is Ban Ki-moon so quickly casting the blame on the people who work for the UN.

At 2:30 on Friday it was impossible to know the specifics of how the UN Security officials got injured. Furthermore, UN Security sources now say that Erdogan's delegation had another run-in with authorities.

They point to a previous run in at the 46th Street entrance, false passes to the UN garage, even the beating of a journalist by security at a previous Turkish sponsored conference. So what did Ban Ki-moon know and when did he know it? Watch this site.

Driving for 9 Votes, Palestine Targets Bosnia, Gabon & Nigeria, Mulls Quartet

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 26 -- When Palestinian Observer Riyad Mansour spoke to the press on Friday afternoon, he began by maintaining that the nine Security Council members which have previously recognized Palestine will vote "yes" on membership.

Inner City Press asked, what about Bosnia, has Palestine met with the Republica Srbska third of the government?

Mansour described a Palestinian visit to Bosnia at which the delegation was well received; he said he visited Belgrade in Serbia and spoke with the relevant people. But who can reach Republica Srbska? It is not clear.

As South African Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu entered the Security Council, Inner City Press asked him if there would be three African Union "yes" votes for Palestinian membership. I can only speak for my vote, Baso said. South Africa is a yes; Gabon and Nigeria less so. According to Mansour, both will also be new visits.

Asked about Friday's Quartet Statement, Mansour said that the Palestinian leadership will meet about it on Wednesday. But he said that a cessation of the settlements is required. The Quartet didn't speak to that, as noted by Mahmoud Abbas to the media on his way back to Ramallah. Mansour also noted that Israel has not embraced the Quartet Statement.

Beyond the fight between UN Security and the Turkish delegation that Inner City Press exclusively reported on Friday, Inner City Press has been informed that while Abbas gave his speech on Friday, Avigdor Lieberman did come into the GA Hall -- only in order to immediately leave it.

Even before Monday's consultations started, spokespeople told the Press that there would be an open meeting on the Council on Wednesday to formally refer Palestine's application to an "Ad Hoc" committee on membership -- all 15 members are on the committee -- and that the committee will meet for the first time on Friday. And so it goes at the UN - watch this site.

On Palestine at UNSC "No Nine Votes" So Delay Predicted, Quartet As Pretext

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, September 26 -- In the run up to the UN Security Council's Monday afternoon meeting on Palestine's application for UN membership, Inner City Press asked Council diplomats what they expected to happen.

"I don't think they have nine votes," one well placed Council source said. "So the Arabs may want to delay it." This source said that the Quartet statement of Friday afternoon made it easier for those not wanting to vote "yes" -- he listed Nigeria, Gabon and Bosnia -- to explain their changed position.

Another source said given a lack of nine votes, ironically the US might want to call for a vote now, and not have to use a veto. But that would be difficult.

While it was argued last week that since nine Council members have in the past recognized Palestine there should be nine votes now for membership, Bosnia for example can be hamstrung by the position of the Republica Srbska third of its triumvirate government.

Bosnia's Permanent Representative Ivan Barbalic told Inner City Press "the Presidency" is considering how to vote, and that it was difficult to say anything on Monday morning. Nigeria, too, is not considered a sure yes vote.

Germany's Deputy Permanent Representative Miguel Berger told Inner City Press the obvious, that things will not move as fast as they did for South Sudan: a three day rocket docket. It will be procedure, to decide how to proceed, he said. Watch this site.