Saturday, June 25, 2011

As Khartoum Floats Aid Cut Off, Juba Says Harun Should Be In The Hague, Not El Obeid, UN Flew Him, Says All Is Fine

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 20, updated -- Amid reports of ethnic cleansing in Southern Kordofan as well as Abyei, the UN Security Council assembled in its chamber at 10 am on Monday for a briefing by video from Addis Ababa by mediator Thabo Mbeki and UN Mission in Sudan chief Haile Menkerios.

After a delay, Mbeki appeared on screen to describe a just-signed agreement on Abyei, and predict that one will be reached on Southern Kordofan. Ethiopian troops will be sent into Abyei, after Security Council authorization of the deployment and, it seems, an understanding about “Somalia-style” rules of engagement.

After the briefing, the Ambassador of Sudan, following by the South Sudan representative, came to the stakeout to take Press questions. Inner City Press asked the National Congress Party's Permanent Representative Daffa-Alla Elhag Ali Osman about his statement that humanitarian aid to Southern Kordofan “might” be restored shortly -- was this an admission that it has been cut off, and food used as a weapon?

He blamed it on the SPLA, and said that they had tried to install Al Hilu “who lost the election” as governor of South Kordofan. Video here.

Moments later, the representative of Southern Sudan Ezekiel Lol Gatkouth told Inner City Press that Ahmed Harun the supposed winner of the Southern Kordofan election, which the UN praised, doesn't even come from Southern Kordofan, has fled to El Obeid and “should be in the Hague” for war crimes. Video here.

Since the UN has in fact offered helicopter flights to Harun, who is indicted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes in Darfur, Inner City Press asked the South Sudan representative if he thought the UN should arrest Harun, rather than flying him around. “He should be in the Hague,” he repeated.


Ezekiel Lol Gatkouth at stakeout, Haroun not shown

With these deep disagreements, it is difficult to know what to make of the 10 page Abyei agreement announced with such fanfare by Mbeki and the UNMIS' Menkerios. He has been in Addis for day, meanwhile UNMIS has been “categorically denying” it did anything wrong on Southern Kordofan. This UN's reflexive denial undermines its credibility.

In the middle of the Security Council debate, Inner City Press ran through the UN's garage to the day's noon briefing. But neither of the two Sudan questions put to Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky got answered. Confirm or deny The Guardian / Observer's report that UNMIS in Kordofan lost control of its weapons -- Nesirky said he'd look into it.

In Darfur, over the weekend Inner City Press asked the spokesperson both for UNAMID and the UN World Food Program to confirm or deny a report that the UN stopped delivering food to IDPs in El Geneina. Neither responded, and neither did Nesirky at Monday's noon briefing.

And now the UN peacekeeping presence in Abyei is being jettisoned for a different one, from Ethiopia. And in Southern Kordofan? Watch this site.

Footnote: Ezekiel Lol Gatkouth presented to Inner City Press this timeline: South Sudan will formally declare independence on July 9, followed by Security Council vote-in as a state on July 13, and General Assembly on July 14. We'll be here.

Update of 4 pm: Later, this arrived:

Subject: Your question on Darfur and Sudan
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Mon, Jun 20, 2011 at 3:45 PM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

The World Food Programme has confirmed that the food distributions to El Geneina are on track, and any reports suggesting that such distributions have stopped are inaccurate.

As for any reports of UNMIS losing control of heavy weaponry, UNMIS does not have heavy weapons. Its weaponry includes AK-47s and armoured personnel carriers.

The first answer, then, has the UN denying in entirety a story (with quotes) from Radio Dabanga. The second denied a story in The Guardian about Southern Kordofan, on which WFP has separately told Inner City Press that

“On Kadugli, we still have not been able to obtain access to our warehouse. However we have received assurances from the local authorities that our food is intact.”

And so it goes at the UN.

On Sudan, As Mbeki Presents Ethiopian Solution, “Somalia-Like” Mandate in Play?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 20 -- As Thabo Mbeki briefed the UN Security Council about Abyei in Sudan on Monday morning, he mentioned that the mandate of the Ethiopian troops to replace Sudan's forces is still being worked on.

Sources close to the negotiations tell Inner City Press that Ethiopia has said it will not be as “passive” as the UN peacekeepers have been. “Look at the UN blue helmets,” a source told Inner City Press. “They let people just take their guns away. Is that a military force?”

Most recently the UN forces in Southern Kordofan are reported to have allowed heavy artillery and anti-tank and anti-aircraft guns to be taken from them.

But others harken back to when Ethiopia went into Somalia in 2006, blasting away until it reached Mogadishu. Is this the solution the UN and Security Council members want in Abyei?

Mbeki said he'd met with Southern Kordofan SPLA leader Al Hilu. As Inner City Press reported last week, Al Hilu through his spokesman accused the UN peacekeepers in Kadugli of rape. After first delaying, the UN subsequently denied the charges, saying that no evidence had come forward.

But as Kordofan sources point out, Hilu is on the run from the forces of Khartoum. Top UN peacekeepers Alain Le Roy on June 16 told Inner City Press he hadn't spoken to Al Hilu, then said seeming uncertain that the Mission (UNMIS) had spoken with Al Hilu about the charges. But had they? Watch this site.

As Ban Claims Libya Talks Are Led by Khatib, Jordan Activities Still UNexplained


By Matthew Russell Lee, News analysis

UNITED NATIONS, June 19 -- As Libyan rebels deny negotiating with Gaddafi, on June 18 UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's office issued a statement that “the beginnings of a negotiation process are now underway under the auspices of [Ban's] Special Envoy to Libya, Mr. Abdul-Elah Al-Khatib.”

Khatib, who notably did not attend or engage with the African Union ministerial delegation to the UN in New York last week, has been allowed by Ban to continue as a paid Jordanian senator. Inner City Press has repeatedly asked Ban's spokesperson how this double-service for the UN and Jordan complies with the letter and spirit of UN rules.

While Ban's lead spokesperson Martin Nesirky took to saying that Khatib's contract with the UN was still being formalized, a US diplomat on background assured Inner City Press weeks ago that it would all soon be normalized.

But nothing has been said by Ban's office. The Obama administration has nevertheless reflexively quickly supported Ban's campaign, announced June 6, for a second five year term as Secretary General.

As Inner City Press reported, Khatib after Ban hurriedly hired him refused to give up or suspend his political work and business in Jordan. Inner City Press asked Khatib on camera about protests and democracy in Jordan itself, and Khatib minimized the protests. Since then, with the King's convoy stoned by protesters, media that reported it were cracked down on.

Ban's office has dodged even specifying which exemptions or special powers they may be invoking to be declaring as a UN Under Secretary General and staff member a sitting politician.

Similarly, when asked throughout last week what safeguards will be imposed on the lobbying of Ban by his son in law Siddarth Chatterjee now that he's confirmed as hired as “Chief Diplomatic Officer” of the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, Nesirky has simply said there are rules and we'll comply with them.

What rules? How can the UN preach rule of law when it would even describe it own processes with regard to lobbying of the UN by members of the Secretary General's immediate family and double service for the UN fraught with conflicts of interest? Watch this site.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

At UN, As European Union Uses Special Rights, Caricom Calls It Abuse, Qatar on Tap as President of the General Assembly

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 17 -- Six weeks after the European Union won special rights in the UN General Assembly after months of opposition led by the Caribbean states group CARICOM, the struggle continued at the tail end of a General Assembly debate on the Millennium Summit.

After GA President Joseph Deiss allowed the European Union to speak, Deiss tried to end the meeting. But the Ambassador of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Camillo Gonsalves asked to take the floor.

He said, on behalf of Caricom, that the EU should not have been allowed to speak in the Explanation After the Vote section, since as a non member state, the EU had no vote.

Deiss said he “took note” of the statement, then again tried to end the meeting. The representative of Venezuela tapped her formica country name plate on her desk until Deiss begrudgingly gave her the floor.

After she said that Venezuela for the record supported CARICOM's objection, Deiss called hers a “declaration after a declaration,” and gaveled the meeting closed.

Afterward, Inner City Press asked Ambassador Gonsalves to explain. “There were to be no general statements,” he said. “The EU was inscribed to speak after the vote. A special provision was created by the chair for the EU, who didn't ask if anyone else wanted to speak in that way. As soon as the EU spoke, he shut it down.”


Ban Ki-moon & Ashton: "When Cathy met Ban Ki," 1 wants special rights, the other a 2d term

An EU member's Permanent Representative argued to Inner City Press that while St. Vincent should then have been allowed to make a general statement, if the EU did, there was nothing wrong with letting the EU make a general statement. But only the EU? When member states weren't allowed? This is why they were and are called special rights. Will the incoming President of the General Assembly, the Ambassador of Qatar who is to be elected on June 22, be so accommodating to the European Union? Watch this site.

As UN Denies Sri Lankan Copter Offer, Killing Fields Moved Out of UN

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 17 -- The UN on Friday denied it has received any offers for helicopters from Sri Lanka.

After air force spokesman air force spokesman Andy Wijesuriya was quoted that “we have offered our aircraft” -- Ukraine-manufactured Mi-24 helicopter gunships as well as Chinese-made Y-12 fixed-wing transporters -- Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky how the Panel of Experts' report on war crimes would impact the UN's review of the offer.

Four hours later Nesirky's office sent this response to Inner City Press:

Subject: Your question on Sri Lanka
Date: Fri, Jun 17, 2011 at 4:24 PM
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com
Cc: Martin Nesirky [at] un.org

Regarding the offer of gunships, DPKO's Force Generation Service has not yet received any formal offer from Sri Lanka.

The Sri Lankan air force was involved in what even UN under secretary general John Holmes called the “bloodbath on the beach” in 2009, most recently depicted in UK Channel 4's “Killing Fields” documentary.

This was to be screened inside the UN in New York on June 21, just before a vote is taken in the General Assembly on Ban Ki-moon getting a second five year term as Secretary General. (As of June 15,Ban had not watched the filmAs of June 15, Ban had not watch the film, Nesirky told Inner City Press.)

But now the screening has been moved outside of the UN, to the “Church Center” across the street. Sri Lankan Ambassador Palitha Kohona told Inner City Press he was going to attend the screening if it was inside the UN. Apparently, he will not attend across the street. Of the scenes of extrajudicial execution, he said one cannot prove who is Sinhalese and who is Tamil. There is, of course, a sound track. Watch this site.

At UN, “Going Through Motions” on Syria Resolution, Attending Just to Listen

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 17 -- When UN Security Council experts met Friday morning about the long pending Syria draft resolution, China and Russia attended, unlike on Saturday, June 11. But China said they are not prepared to negotiate about the text, “just listen,” Inner City Press is informed.

The Permanent Representative of another Council member told Inner City Press, “With two veto threats, the West is just going through the motions.”

Three hours later outside the Security Council's so-called “horizon briefing” at which Syria was one of five agenda items, a Western Council member's representative told Inner City Press that in the closed door meeting, comments were made that the refusal to engage of “certain members” made the Council look bad. This did not seem to much impact those with a veto.

Rather, the resolution's proponents are now openly calling out those whose foreign ministers have made comments about the resolution, to come and negotiate around specifics in the text.

South African's foreign minister this week told the press that a Syria resolution could “insinuate regime change.” The response seems to be, show us where in the text the insinuation can be found. But the concern may not be only or even mostly textual.

Ban Ki-moon has been in Brazil, but his spokesperson's office's read-outs of meetings with the president and foreign minister do not mention any discussion of Brazil's position on the resolution. Ban is seeking a vote on a second five year term as Secretary General on June 21. Watch this site.

Footnote: the non-attendance at last Saturday's meeting on the draft Syria resolution was explained as a matter of worker's rights: only work on weekends if necessary, and since no change of voting Monday or Tuesday, why meet Saturday? So further weekend sessions, at least on Syria, seem unlikely.

As UN Council Touts Ban 2d Term, GRULAC Hasn't Endorsed, Process Questioned


By Matthew Russell Lee, News analysis

UNITED NATIONS, June 17 -- Who chooses the UN Secretary General and how? On Friday at the UN, the 15 members of the Security Council in a closed door meeting, not even by vote, recommended Ban Ki-moon for a second five year term by acclamation.

Moments later the President of the Security Council for June, the Ambassador of Gabon, came to the stakeout to read on camera a statement that “in a private meeting,” Ban was recommended.

When Inner City Press asked, “are you aware that GRULAC has not endorsed Ban?” he walked away from the microphone. Standing by the stakeout was Kim Won-soo, Ban's chief adviser and ostensible deputy to chief of staff Vijay Nambiar.

GRULAC is the Latin American and Caribbean states group. On June 7, Inner City Press reported that five GRULAC members had said they didn't have instructions from their capitals to endorse Ban.

Earlier on Friday Inner City Press stood outside the GRULAC meeting in the UN's North Lawn building. When Colombia's Ambassador emerged to attend the Council's 11 am meeting, he told Inner City Press that one country was still saying it didn't have instructions. He offered a name; later the spokesperson of a Western Council member said “I think it is Barbados,” amid laughter.

But the critique by GRULAC was more substantial, that Ban was too attentive to Permanent Five members of the Council, ignoring even countries which contribute peacekeepers to the missions voted by the Security Council.

Some of the Security Council members who made much of the unanimous recommendation for Ban say in other settings that Ban's pliant style is bad for the UN and multilateralism.

Something is wrong with a process in which, despite this view, unanimous reappointment for five years is delivered without any competition, no other candidates, not even a campaign speech and pledges.

The General Assembly vote is scheduled for June 21 at 3 pm. As one GRULAC Permanent Representative told Inner City Press, “once the Permanent Five decide, we are all just window dressing.” Watch this site.

At UN, GRULAC Delay of Council Vote for Ban Is To “Send A Message,” UNheard?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 16, updated -- After Ban Ki-moon's second term as UN Secretary General was delayed on Thursday in the Security Council, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky about it, and whether Ban had spoken with countries in the Latin American and Caribbean states group GRULAC, whose failure to endorse Ban was twice exclusively reported by Inner City Press.

Nesirky declined to provide any readout of Ban's meetings with GRULAC representatives including heads of state. Later on Thursday, a GRULAC diplomat told Inner City Press “we want to send Ban Ki-moon a message that we are not satisfied by his first term, that he must do better in his second. There is no other candidate, so this is all that we can do.”

Meanwhile the Security Council, which would like to say that it recommendation to the General Assembly is just that, and not an unfair domination by the Permanent Five members, decided that it will adopt a resolution recommending Ban behind closed doors on Friday at 11 am, whether or not GRULAC delivers its endorsement by them.

While some see that as a disrespect of the regional groups and their process -- there is, after all, no rush to re-annoint Ban -- others see it as honest: as one GRULAC Permanent Representative told Inner City Press, “Once the Permanent Five express themselves, we are all just window dressing.”

Interestingly, some in GRULAC have endorsed Mexico's Carstens to head the IMF, over France's Christine Lagarde. One said, “At least the IMF has more than one candidate.”

Ban, who traveled this week to Colombia, Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil, might want to look closer not only at the ALBA countries, but also at Mexico (known to want more General Assembly input into the selection of the Secretary General, and more attention to Latin America), Guatamala and Paraguay, peacekeeping contributor countries...

Meanwhile work circulated Thursday that Ban's spokesperson's office was already inviting select UN correspondents to be “briefed” by Ban on June 21, when obviously Ban and his office expect to receive the final General Assembly vote. Some call it jumping the gun, or worse -- watch this site.

From the UN's June 16 transcript of its noon briefing:

Inner City Press: various diplomats early today said that it is because the GRULAC, the Latin American and Caribbean regional group, has not yet endorsed the Secretary-General for a second term, that it was postponed until tomorrow at 11 a.m. Now, what I wanted to know is, is that the Secretariat’s understanding: as of 7 June, five countries in GRULAC had said they hadn’t gotten instructions or weren’t, didn’t endorse. Has the Secretary-General or the Secretariat spoken, do you believe, with those five countries on this topic?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I think anything to do with this matter needs to come from the Member States, and particularly anything related to the Council deliberations, and then indeed the General Assembly deliberations needs to come from the Member States.

Inner City Press: But I guess it’s because sometimes we get readouts of the Secretary-General’s communications with, certainly, Heads of State, but sometimes even foreign ministers. So I am asking really about the Secretary-General’s own communications with Heads of State.

Spokesperson Nesirky: As I have said, we’ve said from the outset and the Secretary-General announced it here that he was making himself available for a second term, should Member States so decide; then he would be honoured to be able to serve a second term. And it is for the Council, in the first instance, to discuss and decide, and then for the General Assembly to follow up on that. And I think that’s the process that needs to run its course, and any other comment at this point is really not for us to make.

But why then already be making invitations to a victory party / briefing?

UN Admits Kadugli Peacekeepers Refused Convoy Escort, France Downplays It

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 16 -- When the UN Security Council met behind closed doors Thursday about the humanitarian situation in South Kordofan, Sudan, much criticism was directed at the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations, whose troops in Kadugli reported declined to leave their base and do their jobs, as recently happened with the Zambian peacekeepers in Abyei.

After the meeting, Inner City Press asked DPKO chief Alain Le Roy about the criticism. He acknowledged that a UN battalion in Kadugli was “not willing to escort a convoy... there was heavy shelling.”

Moments later, Inner City Press on camera asked French Ambassador Gerard Araud if the Council discussed if a peacekeeper battalion declined to provide escort or come out of its base. According to the French Mission's transcript, Araud replied that

“a question was specifically asked whether all the instructions had [always] been followed. Alain [Le Roy] told us 'yes, they have always been followed.' The only example - which was an example where the personnel was requested to evacuate, so it’s not a question of protection - was when the personnel hesitated for a few hours because of their own safety on the ground.”

But Le Roy spoke about a battalion refusing to escort a convoy, presumably not only of soldiers. In fact, the UN evacuated -- or relocated, as UN OCHA put it -- international staff from Kadugli to El Obeid. In any event, refusing orders to escort a convoy is a “command and control” problem, as one Council delegation put it.

Some skeptics wonder if the French Mission's and Ambassador's speed to speak on these issues is entirely attributable to a concern for protection of civilians, or might involve defending the performance of DPKO whose past, current and seemingly future chiefs as promised by S-G Ban Ki-moon seeking a second term are all French.

Inner City Press asked Le Roy about the safety of Sudanese UN staff, who were not evacuated by the UN to El Obaid. Le Roy to his credit said that the UN was trying to contact all of them by radio, but had not been able to reach those in “downtown Kadugli because we have no access to downtown Kadugli.”

Some question how UNMIS can be said to be protecting civilians in Kadugli if it has “no access to downtown Kadugli.” Watch this site.

As Sudan Pulls US & UK Diplomats from UN Helicopter, Raising of Stakes?

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 16, updated -- When a UN Mission in Sudan helicopter landed in White Nile state, the Sudanese government took a US and a UK diplomat off the plane.

As described to Inner City Press by a spokesman for the UK Mission to the UN, the Sudanese authorities said they had not been notified of the flight and therefore questioned its purpose and passenger list.

Inner City Press asked US Ambassador Susan Rice about a “US diplomat arrested in Sudan.” She said, “I don't think that's the right word,” and went into the Security Council for a closed door meeting about violence involving the Sudanese Armed Forces and militias and tribes they support.

Asked if this detention should been as a raising of the stakes by Khartoum, the UK Spokesman told Inner City Press no. He could not name another time that Sudanese authorities have similarly questioned the use of UNMIS facilities by UK diplomats, but posited that the issue was more that the UNMIS helicopter had not given notice of its landing in Magennes than the identity of the passengers.

Hiring of Ban's Son in Law to Lobby UN Confirmed by IFRC, No Safeguards

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 16 -- With a second term for Ban Ki-moon stalled in the UN Security Council due to a lack of endorsement by the Latin American and Caribbean states group, the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies has now partially answered questions about their hiring of Ban's son in law as Chief Diplomatic Officer, including lobbying Ban and the UN.

The IFRC says it doesn't see any need for safeguards, hiring a son in law to lobby his father in law at the UN. They also say the IFRC didn't initially know Siddarth Chatterjee is related to the Secretary General of the UN, until he was “shortlisted” for the Chief Diplomat Officer.

Then they say this close family relationship played no role in selection, and requires no safeguards or recusals. We'll see.


Ban & book; rights communications withheld to keep access

Here are IFRC's response, from its (sole) media relations officer:

Q: At today's UN noon briefing I asked the spokesman for Ban Ki-moon to confirm that Ban's son in law Siddharth Chatterjee has been selected to work for IFRC, on information and belief as chief dipomatic officer, and if there are any safeguards in place regarding lobbying or diplomacy by a relative. On both questions, the UN spokesman said I should “ask IFRC.” So now I am, in writing 1) confirm that Ban's son in law has been selected by IFRC.

Confirmed.

Q2) please state what role his relation to Mr. Ban played in his selection. None.

Q3) Was IFRC aware? The search and short-listing of Mr. Chatterjee was carried out by an independent recruitment company. The IFRC has full trust in the methods and diligence of this company. When Mr. Chatterjee was shortlisted the IFRC became aware of his connection through marriage to the UNSG but this factor played no role whatsoever in Mr. Chatterjee’s final recruitment. Mr. Chatterjee’s professional background has been thoroughly checked and referenced by the independent recruitment company, the outcome of which showed conclusively that Mr. Chatterjee was a highly-accomplished and well qualified candidate for this challenging position at the IFRC. The IFRC will assess Mr. Chatterjee on his performance in his current role and not entertain unsubstantiated rumours which may have followed him from the UN.

Q4) Are there are safeguards in place? Safeguards against what?

Q5) please describe the position of chief diplomatic officer, including all ways it may intersect with the UN system.

The newly adopted Strategy 2020 established Humanitarian Diplomacy as one of the three enabling actions to deliver on the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent’s (IFRC) strategic aims and to strengthen the coherence and impact of our collective voice. According to Strategy 2020, Humanitarian diplomacy is a multi-directional effort that highlights the needs and rights of vulnerable people, whilst striving to give them a strong voice in all negotiation processes. IFRC seeks to prevent and reduce vulnerability by using appropriately the auxiliary role of National Societies in order to achieve greater access to people in need, and by drawing attention to the causes and potential consequences of emerging or re-emerging vulnerability. IFRC promotes the image of the Movement through its worldwide network of informed representatives who can project its work more widely. This is complemented by strong external partnerships and a diversified and expanded resource base.

Under the direction of the Under Secretary for Humanitarian Values & Diplomacy, the Head, International Relations (Chief Diplomatic Officer), will implement the humanitarian diplomacy goals of Strategy 2020. Working with such external actors as opinion leaders, decision-makers, policy-makers, corporate leaders, academics, think-tanks and other stakeholders within governments, international, multilateral, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, civil society groups, regional groupings, professional networks, representative organizations, and other global entities, he/she will leverage the Red Cross/Red Crescents’ collective voice at local, national, regional and global levels.

So -- Ban's son in law with “work with...intergovernmental organizations,” presumably including the UN, to “leverage the Red Cross/Red Crescents’ collective voice.” That's called lobbying, by one close family member of another. No need for safeguards? Watch this site.

At UN, Lack of GRULAC Endorsement Delays Ban's Re-Appointment

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 16 -- When Ban Ki-moon ten days ago announced he wanted a second term as UN Secretary General, he went to meet behind closed doors with the UN's Regional Groups. As first reported by Inner City Press on June 7, in the Latin American and Caribbean States group, called GRULAC, at least five countries said they needed more time.

Nevertheless it was announced that the Security Council would meet on June 16 to recommend Ban for a second term. Ban's Spokesperson's Office on June 15 issued a schedule with re-appointment on the Council's agenda.

But early on June 16, this changed. Ban's Spokesperson's Office put out another announcement, that only the Council's “Program of Work” would be considered on June 16.

Sources tell Inner City Press this is because GRULAC has still not endorsed Ban for a second term. Ban has spend the last five days in Latin America. But as one source put it, “look at his record, especially in Latin America.”

In typical UN fashion, the source pointed first to Ban's appointments, or doling out of top posts. Asked about Ban's recent appointment of Mariano Ferandez, a Chilean to head up the UN's Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), another source said “that was only for Bachelet.” The Haitian government, it's said, preferred a Trinidadian candidate. “What has Bachelet accomplished for Ban?” the source asked.

(Inner City Press notes that Bachelet's UN Women office has responded to questions about allegations of rape by UN peacekeepers in South Kordofan in Sudan, by asking the Department of Peacekeeping Operations at the highest level.)

More generally as one GRULAC source told Inner City Press, “Ban has not focused on Latin America enough. We want a commitment that this would change in a second term.” Watch this site.

Libyan Rebels Play “For Outside Patrons,” Rugunda of Uganda Says, Alleging Colonialism

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 15 -- Western countries on the UN Security Council pushed hard to keep most of the African Union presentations about Libya behind closed doors.

Now we know and can report why.

Outside the closed door session in the UN's North Lawn building on June 15, a European Permanent Representative complained to Inner City Press that all speeches inside were constructive “except Uganda.”

Uganda was until December on the Security Council, represented by Ambassador (and medical doctor) Ruhakana Rugunda. Inner City Press asked Rugunda if he had called for NATO to stop bombing, and Ruganda indicated that he had.

Inner City Press has now obtained and is publishing Uganda's representative Rugunda's statement in the Council's closed door meeting on Libya. The statement goes beyond calling for a ceasefire by NATO -- it says that the rebels in Libya are playing for external patrons and likens them to Mobutu in the Congo.

Rugunda says that what is happening in Libya is a civil war, not genocide, for which he gives as examples Rwanda and the Holocaust. He says that both Gaddafi and the rebels are engaged in war crimes, and cites positively the “provisional immunity” offered in Burundi.

In this case, of course, Gaddafi has already been referred to the International Criminal Court. Along the margins of the meeting, some Council members complained that too much power had been given to UN part time envoy al-Khatib, who hadn't even deigned to come to the June 15 meeting. The Western powers didn't want him to come, it was speculated. But what is he accomplishing?

Here is the full text of Ugandan representative Rugunda's June 15 closed door speech:

HE Dr Ruhakana Rugunda, Permanent Representative of Uganda to the United Nations At A meeting between the UN Security Council and the African Union High Level Ad hoc Committee on Libya

15th June, 2011

Mr. President,

1. Thank you for organizing this interactive dialogue. It is good that the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has met the African Union (AU) Mediation Committee (High-Level Ad hoc Committee on Libya) so that we can exchange views on the situation in Libya in a candid and frank manner. This should have happened much, much earlier because Libya is a founding member of the AU. An attack on Libya or any other member of the African Union without express agreement by the AU is a dangerous provocation that should be avoided given the good, relaxed international situation in the last 20 years since the release of Nelson Mandela from jail and the eventual freedom of South Africa.

2. The UN is on safer ground if it confines itself on maintaining international peace and deterring war among member states.

3. Intervening in internal affairs of States should be avoided except where there is proof of genocide or imminent genocide as happened in Rwanda or against the Jews in Germany and the European Countries that were occupied by the Third Reich.

4. There are differences on the issue of Libya as to whether there was proof of genocide or intended genocide. Fighting between Government troops and armed insurrectionists is not genocide. It is civil war. It is the attack on unarmed civilians with the aim of exterminating a particular group that is genocide – to exterminate the genes of targeted groups such as the Jews, Tutsis, etc. It is wrong to characterize every violence as genocide or imminent genocide so as to use it as a pretext for the undermining of the sovereignty of States. Certainly, sovereignty has been a tool of emancipation of the peoples of Africa who are beginning to chart transformational paths for most of the African countries after centuries of predation by the slave trade, colonialism and neo- colonialism. Careless assaults on the sovereignty of African Countries are, therefore, tantamount to inflicting fresh wounds on the destiny of the African peoples. If foreign invasions, meddlings, interventions, etc, were a source of prosperity, then, Africa should be the richest continent in the world because we have had all versions of all that: slave trade, colonialism and neo-colonialism. Yet, Africa has been the most wretched on account of that foreign meddling.

5. Whatever the genesis of the intervention by NATO in Libya, the AU called for dialogue before the UN resolutions 1970 and 1973 and after those Resolutions. Ignoring the AU for 3 months and going on with the bombings of the sacred land of Africa has been high-handed, arrogant and provocative. This is something that should not be sustained or repeated. To a discerning mind, such a course is very dangerous. It is unwise for certain players to be intoxicated with technological superiority and begin to think that they alone can alter the course of human history towards greater freedom for the whole of mankind. Certainly, no constellation of states should think that they can recreate hegemony over Africa.

6. The safer way is to use the free gift God gave us – the ability to talk – in order to solve all problems.

7. The UN or anybody acting on behalf of the UN must be neutral in relation to the internal affairs of states. Certainly, that should be the case with respect to the African countries. The UN should not take sides in a civil war, for instance, in an African country. The UN should promote dialogue, reconciliation, the peaceful resolution of conflicts, and help in enforcing agreements arrived at after negotiations such as the agreement on the Sudan.

8. Regardless of the genesis of the Libyan problem, the correct way forward now is dialogue without pre-conditions. The demand by some countries that Colonel Muammar Gadaffi must go first before the dialogue is incorrect. Whether Gadaffi goes or stays is a matter for the Libyan people to decide. It is particularly wrong when the demand for Gadaffi’s departure is made by outsiders.

9. In order for dialogue, without pre-conditions, to take place, we need a ceasefire in place that should be monitored by the AU troops among others. This will help the AU to confirm the veracity of the stories of Gadaffi killing civilians intentionally.

10. That dialogue should agree on the way forward in the direction of introducing competitive politics. Gadaffi thinks that he has the most democratic system in the world of people’s authority – elected local committees. Since so much chaos in Libya has emerged on the issue, Gadaffi should see the wisdom of accepting competitive democracy. Gadaffi cannot ignore the fact that the rebels took over Benghazi and his authority melted away before NATO came in to confuse the picture. The pre-NATO uprising in Benghazi was, mainly, internal. Gadaffi may say that they were organized by Al Qaeda. Even if that is so, it is a fact that a sizeable body of the Libyans in Benghazi threw out Gadaffi’s authority or it melted away. Therefore, Gadaffi must think of and agree to reforms, resulting into competitive politics.

11. A transitional mechanism could, then, be worked out and elections – competitive elections – would take place after an agreed timetable.

12. What about security for the opposition members? We have plenty of experience on such issues. What did we do in Burundi? We provided a protection force (a brigade) for the Hutu leaders who were living outside Burundi or were in the bush. One of them is now the President of Burundi after winning democratic elections.

13. How about those who are alleged to have committed war crimes – including Gadaffi and the rebels? Again, our decision in Burundi is useful here. We used the concept of “immunité provisoire”, - provisional immunity – for all the stakeholders so that they could participate in the dialogue. After peace is realized, then a Truth and Reconciliation body could be set up to look into these matters. After democratic elections, trials of those that are guilty can take place.

14. Long term safety of every body can be ensured by security sector reform and especially reform of the army, so that it takes orders from any elected President.

15. The intervention in Libya was premised on the basis of protecting civilians and preventing further civilian deaths. civilians and preventing further civilian deaths. However, the humanitarian situation in Libya remains serious and continues to get worse with continued hostilities. Looking at how resolutions 1970 and 1973 are being implemented, the international community and the United Nations in particular, are being severely put to the test, as what is happening in Libya will undermine future efforts of the United Nations in the protection of civilians. There is, therefore, no need for any war-like activities in Libya because there is a peaceful, risk-free way forward. There has been no need for these war activities for many weeks now – ever since Gadaffi accepted dialogue when the AU mediation Committee visited Tripoli on the 10th April, 2011. Any war activities after that have been nothing but provocation for Africa. It is totally unnecessary war. It must stop.

16. The story that the rebels cannot engage in dialogue unless Gadaffi goes away does not convince us. If they do not want dialogue, then, let them fight their war with Gadaffi without NATO bombing. Then, eventually, a modus vivendus will emerge between the two parties or one of them will be defeated. The attitude of the rebels shows us the danger of external involvement in internal affairs of African countries. The externally sponsored groups neglect dialogue as well as building internal consensus and, instead, concentrate on winning external patrons. This cannot be in the interest of that country. Mobutu’s Congo as well as performance of all the other neo-colonies of Africa in the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s and their eventual collapse in the 1990s prove that foreign sponsored groups are of no value to Africa.

17. It is essential that the United Nations Security Council works with the African Union to ensure that a ceasefire is immediately established with an effective and verifiable monitoring mechanism and dialogue embarked upon, leading to a political process including transitional arrangements and the necessary reforms. The crisis in Libya requires a political solution and not a military one; and the AU Road Map is the most viable option.

Finally, what is needed on the issue of Libya is a genuine partnership between the United Nations Security Council and the African Union. By working together we can find a lasting solution to the crisis in Libya. I thank you.

At UN on Libya, African Council Members Want Statement on Compliance With Resolution 1973, US Said to Oppose

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 14 -- When African Union ministers wanted to come engage with the UN Security Council about NATO's bombing of Libya, the United States wanted to keep the meeting behind closed doors, the UK even suggesting it merely be a lunch, sources told Inner City Press.

Now in advance of the June 15 meeting, which will be a briefing and “interactive dialogue,” sources tell Inner City Press that the US is opposing an African proposed Presidential Statement, which would reiterate the importance of compliance with Council Resolution 1973.

Below is a copy of the draft, obtained by Inner City Press, which among other things “reaffirms that resolution 1973 (2011) explicitly excludes a foreign occupation force of any form on any part of Libyan territory.”

The three African members of the Security Council -- South Africa, Nigeria and Gabon -- are proposing the Statement. The US is apparently saying they cannot decide on the draft in 24 hours. (Others note that recently on Sudan, US Ambassador Susan Rice put forward a draft Presidential Statement at 2 pm and asked for it to be adopted that day.)

The timing excuse, some feel, is a ruse: the US is hoping that Gaddafi can be killed and taken from power before the Security Council issues any further statement on Libya.

Before publication of this story, Inner City Press asked US Mission to the UN in writing to answer three questions, including this one. While the Mission's spokesman provide an interim answer to one of the three questions, there was not answer to the request for denial or confirmation and comment on the US "opposing on Libya a proposed statement reiterating compliance with Resolution 1973, and why."

Inner City Press spoke to an anti-Gaddafi member of Libya's Mission to the UN, who confirmed the African proposed statement and that the US will not accept it. He said, “the freedom fighters are now within 40 kilometers of Tripoli.”

Neither Libyan side, he predicted, will speak in the interactive segment of the June 15 meeting. “We don't have credentials,” he said. Previously, the UN let Ambassadors Shalgam and Dabbashi speak, but no more. Nor does Gaddafi have a representative at the UN, after Nicaraguan former president of the General Assembly Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann was blocked, with Susan Rice saying his tourist visa would be revoked if he tried to speak for Gaddafi.

Footnote: No other than Louis Farrakhan of the Nation of Islam has moved to hold a press conference at the UN. As it happens, it will not be inside the UN but rather across the street. Watch this site.

Here is the African-proposed Draft Presidential Statement on Libya

At the _____th meeting of the Security Council, held on 15 June 2011, in connection with the Council’s consideration of the item entitled “the situation in Libya”, and having received a briefing from a ministerial delegation of the African Union High-Level Ad-hoc Committee on Libya, the President of the Security Council made the following statement on behalf of the Council:

The Security Council expresses its deep concern over the continuation of violence in Libya, and reaffirms its commitment to the full implementation of United Nations Security Council resolutions 1970 (2011) and 1973 (2011) in letter and spirit to ensure protection of civilians in Libya. The Security Council reaffirms that resolution 1973 (2011) explicitly excludes a foreign occupation force of any form on any part of Libyan territory.

The Security Council demands a complete end to violence and all attacks against and abuses of civilians, perpetrated by all parties and the establishment of an immediate and comprehensive ceasefire. They stressed the need for such a ceasefire to be credible and verifiable, and encouraged the African Union and the United Nations, as well as other stakeholders, to spare no efforts in achieving this objective. The Security Council further demands a speedy solution to the crisis which responds to the legitimate aspirations of the Libyan people and tackles the underlying causes of the current crisis.

The Security Council stresses the need for a political solution to the conflict in Libya. In this respect, and recalling the provisions of paragraph 2 of UN Security Council resolution 1973(2011), they welcome the efforts of the Special Envoy of the Secretary-General for Libya, Mr. Abdel-Elah Mohamed Al-Khatib, and those of the AU High-Level ad hoc Committee on Libya in the context of the AU Roadmap. The Security Council agreed on the need for close coordination of all efforts in support of the UN and in accordance with paragraph 2 of Security Council resolution 1973(2011) to find a solution to the crisis. The Security Council welcomes the joint effort being undertaken by the UN, AU, LAS, OIC and EU and looks forward to the outcome of their next meeting to be held in Cairo, Egypt on 18 June 2011.

The Security Council expresses its serious concern over the deteriorating humanitarian situation in the country, and calls for full compliance with human rights and International Humanitarian Law and the creation of the required conditions for the delivery of assistance to all needy populations across Libya, including by guaranteeing appropriate access to humanitarian organisations. The Security Council stresses the need to provide necessary support to the African migrant workers living in Libya, including those seeking to leave the country.

The Security Council reaffirms its strong commitment to the sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity and national unity of the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya.

The Security Council will remain seized of this matter and will continue to meet to review the implementation of its resolutions on the situation in Libya.