Saturday, June 18, 2011

On Cambodia Genocide Court & UN Quittings in Protests, Ban Ki-moon Puts Off Substantive Comment for 2d Term

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 14 -- A week after Ban Ki-moon on June 6 met with the Asia Group of states at the UN seeking a second term as Secretary General, controversy swirled around the dropping of a genocide case by the UN affiliated Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia.

On June 13, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky:

Inner City Press: a number of international staff have left because the third case was sort of suspended without investigation by the judges. So, it says, this is what I wanted to ask you, it said that these staff members wrote to the Secretary-General before they quit. I wanted to know if that’s true and I wanted to know what he thinks, given the controversy that surrounded his visit to Cambodia; does he have any comment at all on what is viewed as sort of disorder in the court or shutting down of the inquiry into the Khmer Rouge era there?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Probably a little later today, Matthew.

During Ban's trip to Cambodia last October, Hun Sen spoke of the removal of the head of the UN human rights office in Phnom Penh, Christophe Peschoux. Ban offered little defense of him. Nesirky called it “an internal personnel matter” and when Peschoux left earlier this year, Nesirky's office through his deputy Farhan Haq had “no comment at this time,” or since.

But on June 13 a comment was promised, and 24 hours it was issued -- a statement on the ECCC. The statement is long and detailed but is hardly responsive to the human rights and accountability questions raised. As on Peschoux, it says that Ban's UN will “not comment on internal United Nations administrative or staffing processes.”

Eschewing comment, it says that public scrutiny will come at some unspecified later date. Ban is expected, with Asia Group support, to get a second five year term as Secretary General on June 16 in the Security Council, then June 21 in the General Assembly.

As Ban Ki-moon Moves For 2d UN Term, Human Rights Groups Go Silent To Keep Access, Press Controlled

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 13 -- Ban Ki-moon has been subject to critiques for being weak on human rights for nearly all of his four and a half years as UN Secretary General. While such weakness is surely a comfort to many UN member states, to others at least on paper it should be a problem, in supporting him for a second term. So how did Ban seek to turn this around?

One way is to control what people say. In the run-up to Ban's drive for a second term, Human Rights Watch had been critical of Ban's record. But after HRW director Kenneth Roth met with Ban this Spring, and Inner City Press asked HRW on the record if Roth had brought up Ban's record in Myanmar, Sudan or Sri Lanka, the response by HRW's UN Director,a former journalist, was:

“To preserve our ability to have frank discussions with UN officials and advance our advocacy goals, we don't typically communicate on the content of discussions we have with them.”

UN officials, of course, should not condition listening to or acting on human rights concerns on the silence of their interlocutors. (Separately, it is unclear to whom HRW would communicate what it raised: only donors?)

But such a non-answer, delivered less than ten days before the June 6 campaign kick off for a second term as UN Secretary General, is certainly better for Ban.


Ban & book; rights communications withheld to keep access

Earlier this Spring a group of ethnic Tamils came to the UN trying to deliver a petition calling for an international investigation into what they -- and Ban's own Panel of Experts -- call the killing of tens of thousands of Tamil civilians by Sri Lanka's government.

They asked Inner City Press to cover their demonstration across First Avenue from Ban's office. The Ban administration told them that a mid level official would be willing to accept the handover of their petition in the lobby of the UN General Assembly, but that no members of the press should be among their group.

Inner City Press stood to the side, to not hear anything that was said, and took two photographs of the handover. Shortly thereafter, Inner City Press was told that if photos of the handover were published, the Ban administration would not meet again with that group.

There are in the wider world worse ways to silence people. But questions exist as to whether these actions are appropriate to the UN, not only for the past five years, but for five to come. Watch this site.

Amid Ban's 1 Candidate Anointment, Global Model UN Had 10, Staff Union Charged With Just What Ban Does

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 11 -- With the UN Secretary General for the next five years about to be anointed with only one candidate and no competition, the ironies abound. Even the Global Model United Nations had ten candidates to lead its upcoming meeting in Incheon, South Korea.

At a June 10 briefing, Inner City Press asked the winner, Tatiana Makarova of the Russian Federation, about the competition. As written up by the UN itself, “Asked how she had been selected to be Secretary-General and if there had been more than one candidate, Ms. Makarova said that 10 people had been nominated from around the world in a long and difficult process. Debates and interviews had followed.”

For Ban Ki-moon, by contrast, there have been no debates at all. He made his pitch in closed door meetings with regional groups, and now awaits a Security Council rubber stamp vote on June 16, when he won't even be in the country but rather visiting Security Council member Brazil.

A Caribbean nation's Permanent Representative told Inner City Press later on June 10, “once the Big Five signed off on Ban, it was a done deal, the rest of us are just window dressing.” He referred to the second stamp, even more rubber, set for the General Assembly on June 21.

But even without competition, sources in Ban's office tell Inner City Press that recently the re-appointment has been the focus of that offices work, putting pressure on member states to get instructions from their capitals within 24 hours and issue statements.

Ironically, in the contested UN Staff Union election held from June 7-9, the incumbents who have been critical of Ban are charged with using their UN offices on 48th Street for campaigning - meanwhile, Ban's Office just to the south has long been devoted to politicking. What could happen, before June 16 and 21? Watch this site.

For Congo, A Single South African Copter, Meece Concedes, DRC Says UN Can Stay Because It Needs the Money

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 10 -- The UN's envoy in the Congo, Roger Meece, told the Press on Friday that any time he can ask a member state for helicopters for his Mission MONUSCO, he does. But facing the impending loss of the third of three tranches of helicopters, only one aircraft has been secured, from South Africa.

Others talk about offers from Ukraine and even Sri Lanka, which used its craft in the killing of civilians detailed in the UN Panel of Experts' recent report, on which Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has declined to act. Inner City Press asked Meece on June 10 about these offers. Meece said he wouldn't discuss particular states' offers.

Nor, asked for the second time in two days if he will deploy UN peacekeepers to Lord's Restance Army impacted areas like Bas Uele, did Meece make any commitment. He did say that Joseph Kony “to speak frankly should be neutralized one way or another.”

Inner City Press asked him about a critique of his work, that he seeks to ingratiate himself to Joseph Kabila. Meece took issue with the word, and spoke of MONUSCO's integrated human rights reporting function.

The International Peace Institute spokesman said the critique was mostly of Meece's predecessor Alan Doss, who left amid a nepotism scandal in which he urged the UN Development Program to show him “lee way” and give a job to his daughter.

Later on Friday, Inner City Press asked DRC Permanent Representative Atoki Ileki about the same critique. He called it strange, saying “when the war is over you have to change your approach.” He said DRC does not mind the UN stay: “we need the money.”

And so the UN uses the Congo, and the Congolse government uses the UN. But are civilians served? Watch this site.

Syria Denounces AIDS Declaration, Lebanon Expert Says Arab Group Didn't Agree

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 10 -- Immediately after the UN General Assembly adopted a declaration on HIV / AIDS, the Syrian Permanent Representative took the floor and denounced it, ostensibly on behalf of the Arab Group.

Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari said the Arab Group objected to the listing of vulnerable groups in Paragraph 29, saying that such designations are up to member states and their “national characteristics.”

Outside the General Assembly, Inner City Press was approached by Lebanon's expert on the AIDS negotiations, who said that Syria did not speak for all of the Arab Group in what it said.

“He was speaking for himself,” the Lebanese expert said of Ja'afari, even mentioned what Syria is going “on the ground,” referring to the killing of protesters. (This last seemed strange, as Lebanon blocked even a press statement in the Security Council about Syria.)

But didn't the Arab Group have consultations on what they would say in the General Assembly and who would say it? The Lebanese expert said that Ja'afari had not been authorized to say what he did.

By then, Ja'afari had left the General Assembly. The Holy See denounced condoms; the mining firm Anglo American somehow finagled an invitation to promote itself in the name of “civil society.”

Inner City Press stood outside the GA, asking about the controversy diplomats from countries in all continents. Some said that Iran, at least, had been more honest, delivering its denunciation of “risky and immoral behavior” in its name alone.

Inner City Press asked UNAIDS chief Michel Sidibe about Iran's speech. He replied that he will keep speaking out on these “controversial” topics, continue to work on it. There's much work to be done in Iran, he was asked -- “a lot,” Sidibe replied. And then he was gone.

On Syria, Assad Won't Take Call from Ban, Draft Resolution Stalled

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 10 -- With a resolution on Syria stalled in the UN Security Council, and the Council now scheduled on June 16 to vote to recommend Ban Ki-moon for a second term as Secretary General, Ban has tried to call Syria's Bashar Al-Assad. But Assad has not taken his call, his staff telling Ban that Assad is “not available.”

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky to confirm this on June 10, just after the Security Council set its schedule to recommend a second term for Ban and kept the draft resolution at the “experts level,” with no vote on June 10.

Nesirky confirmed it, that Ban has been trying to call Assad, without success. While he may think this makes Assad look bad, to others it highlights the low profile of Ban Ki-moon, or of the UN under Ban Ki-moon. Is this why the veto-wielding Permanent Five members of the Security Council want to give Ban a second term?

Meanwhile on the resolution, German Permanent Representative Peter Wittig told the Press that it remains at the experts level. Asked if he is as frustrated with the position, for example, of Brazil as the US' Susan Rice is, Wittig declined to criticize. We are talking with them, Wittig said. We'll see.

Amid Lagarde & DSK Scandals, IMF Won't Answer on Belarus or Jamaica

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- Without a managing director, without transparency and seemingly without regard to human rights, the International Monetary Fund is negotiating with Belarus about a loan larger than the $3 billion the Russians lent, conditioned on privatization to Russian firms.

During the IMF's bi-weekly briefing on June 9, Inner City Press submitted this question:

“On Belarus, what is the IMF's thinking after Russia cut electrical supply this week, after crackdown on online protests and long sentences to political opponents, and what does the IMF say that to require privatization would be serving Russian buyers of Belarus assets?”

IMF spokesperson Caroline Atkinson, facing in-person questions about Dominique Strauss Kahn, took three online questions -- about Pakistan, Argentina and Latvia -- but not this Inner City Press question about Belarus (nor another one, about Jamaica).

After not acknowledging the timely submitted questions during the briefing, afterward Inner City Press received this email from the IMF about Belarus:

Subject: Your question on Belarus
From: [ ] @imf.org
Date: Thu, Jun 9, 2011 at 10:43 AM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

Matthew, With regard to your question today on Belarus. As you probably know, a previously scheduled IMF mission is currently in Minsk (the dates are June 1-13) to conduct post-program monitoring. The standing policy has been that we don’t comment on specific country matters while missions are in the field and discussions are in progress. We will update the press on the mission’s outcome when it concludes.

The purpose of this mission is to discuss policies that would restore economic stability and put the economy on the path of strong and sustainable growth. The mission will use the opportunity to exchange views with the authorities on possible next steps in response to their request for the Fund-supported program.

Regards, [ ] IMF Press Office

It's been reported that IMF Head of the mission Chris Jarvis has met Deputy Prime Minister Sergey Rumas. Inner City Press replied with a request to be informed of any IMF press conference call about any announcement with Belarus, but the IMF press person who had replied was listed as out of the office.

On Jamaica, the IMF asked for more specifics, to which Inner City Press replied:

Jamaican Finance Secretary Wesley Hughes met with the IMF, now returns to Jamaica for talks with trade unions, in connection with which Minister of State in the Ministry of Finance and the Public Service, Senator Arthur Williams, has spoken of the “Government’s inability to pay the $20 billion owed this year, and has proposed an extended payment period, to protect the gains made in the economy and to preserve its agreement with the IMF.”

So 1) does the IMF dispute that the Jamaican gov't can't pay, must extend the payment period “to preserve its agreement with the IMF”?

Separately, 2) what did the IMF tell Finance Secretary Hughes about this?

After not taking this question during the briefing, then asking two rounds of counter questions about it, the IMF finally replied:

Subject: RE: FW: Question Received (6/9/2011 10:10:02 AM)
From: [ ] @imf.org
Date: Thu, Jun 9, 2011 at 1:14 PM
To: matthew.lee [at] innercitypress.com

Matthew, We are not going to make any comment on ongoing negotiations between the administration and the unions. I would refer your questions to the Jamaican authorities.

The government’s commitments related to the program are outlined in the documents of the second and third reviews of the stand-by arrangement, which you can consult online in the Jamaica page [of the IMF].

So, after not acknowledging the timely submitted questions during the briefing, and even asking questions about the questions, the IMF declined to answer either of them. Some transparency. The IMF did not even respond to repeatedly emailed questions about its policies on gifts. To be continued.

At UN, As Ban Credits Bassole for Darfur “Progress,” He Left Post on June 8

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- When UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon announced on June 6 for a second term, he was asked about failing on Darfur, one of his top two stated priorities in his first term. Ban replied that process is accelerating, and credited Joint Chief Mediator Djibril Bassole.

On June 9, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky:

Inner City Press: if I understood it correctly Mr. Djibril Bassolé was described as stepping down as the joint AU/UN mediator. But he has since been quoted as saying he remains a mediator. And he did go to these Doha talks. So, is he the UN’s mediator or not? It’s unclear. He says that he is, but it was said here that he is not. Which is it?

Spokesperson: I think it was also said here that he has a split role at the moment and will continue to — was continuing, I should say — was continuing to serve as one of the mediators in the run-up to the meeting that you spoke about. But there will be a change in that status, and I think I’ll be able to give you precisely what that change is after this.

Just after the briefing ended, Nesirky said he would look into it. Later this was added to the UN's transcript:

[The Spokesperson’s Office later said that Djibril Bassole’s contract as a United Nations-African Union envoy ended Wednesday, 8 June.]

So Ban's man on Darfur is no longer in the post.

And where do we stand? Rebels supporting Minni Minawai and Abdel Wahid al Nur did not sign onto the recent Doha process. The head of the joint UN - AU peacekeeping mission UNAMID, Ibrahim Gambari, is often in New York, most recently listed as giving a speech in Connecticut on June 4. What is the UN doing in Darfur? It is not clear. Watch this site.

With Northern Congo Civilians Unprotected from Lord's Resistance Army, UN envoy Meece Does Manhattan

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- Amid criticism that the UN Mission in the Congo MONUSCO under Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's envoy Roger Meece is downplaying human rights violations in order to remain close to Joseph Kabila, Meece briefed the Security Council on June 9.

Ban's report to the Council mentions some 100 human rights violation through May of this year in the run up to November's elections. But the UN has not provided details on these violations.

It had been announced that Meece would take questions from the press after the meeting. But after chatting with his staff and US Ambassador David Dunn, Meece headed up to the stairs to leave the building.

Inner City Press pursued him, after first his staff then Meece himself, what about the stakeout?

“Who else is there?” Meece asked, before relenting and coming back. He delivered a summary then asked for questions.

Inner City Press asked about the 100 human rights violations, and why the details are not public or publicized by MONUSCO. Meece responded in terms of the National Elections Commission, and said that things are better now than for the 2005-06 election in that three armies have made peace.

The Lord's Resistance Army, of course, is not one of these three ostensibly peaceful or integrated armies. Inner City Press asked if Meece will, as NGOs have urged, be sending peacekeepers to Bas Uele in North Congo, where the LRA is killing and kidnapping civilians.

Meece answered as the UN so often does, that it is a vast area, hard to defend. He added that there had been a meeting in Addis Ababa last week about the LRA. But if the mandate of MONUSCO is to protect civilians, to many MONUSCO's presence in Bas Uele is insufficient.

There is also, unmentioned by Meece at his begrudging stakeout, the problem of a lack of helicopters. India previously provided them for a price to MONUSCO, then said they needed them back. Some blamed India; others called for other donors, perhaps South Africa. What about the Ukrainian attack helicopters which the UN pushed to transfer from Liberia to Cote d'Ivoire? Is the Congo less important?

Inner City Press concluded by asking Meece how long he had been in New York this time. Meece acknowledged he was in New York around May 17, for a meeting sponsored by the French Mission to the UN during their Council presidency, then again this trip, starting last week. There is grumbling among UN staff who care about the Congo. Meece took the three questions and left.

There are of course other questions, such as the follow through on those responsible for rapes in Walikali, a scandal with which Meece's tenure at MONUSCO began, amid disputes about what he knew and when he knew it.

The UN should be trying to publicize the situation in the Congo, where so many have died. But some atop the UN, it seems, are tempted to dodge the press and even, some say, their duty stations. Reforms at the UN? It would have to start with accountability.

Meece will be appearing again in New York on June 10 and may further address these issues. Watch this site.

At UN on AIDS, Egypt Named for Obstruction, Uzbeks for Arrogance

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 8 -- In the run-up to today's HIV / AIDS summit at the UN, member states have been meeting on the second floor of the North Lawn building to negotiate an outcome documents. Outside, civil society and medical groups complained to Inner City Press about the politics and prejudice inside the closed UN room.

On June 6 at a press conference sponsored by MSF / Doctors Without Borders, Inner City Press asked the Chair of South Africa’s Treatment Action Campaign Nonkosi Khumalo which countries had been the most problematic.

While so often in the UN being diplomatic means not naming names, and therefore reforming nothing, Ms. Khumalo to her credit named Egypt, Uganda and Malawi as the most retrograde, while chiding Swaziland as chair of the African Group for not speaking up enough.

Inner City Press asked if Egypt's position hadn't gotten any better after the outer of Mubarak in what's called the Arab Spring. No, Ms. Khumalo said, Egypt's position hadn't changed, leading her to wonder out loud from whom Egypt's delegation to the UN is receiving its instructions.

On June 7, the head of UNAIDS Michel Sibide was scheduled for a 12:15 press conference. The moderator announced that he would not appear, as he was still in the Security Council. Inner City Press ran there and asked him, what about anti-AIDS activist Maxim Popov, arrested by Uzbekistan for distributing an AIDS education pamphlet funded by the UN?

Thanks for asking me again, he answered. He said he continues to work on the case, but that the Uzbek government does not engage in dialogue.

Inner City Press asked, with the NGOs?

Nor with us, he answered. Inner City Press also asked about Ukraine's harassment of NGOs who work on AIDS, picking over their finances with a fine toothed comb. He said he'd heard of it; his colleague blamed this on Ukraine being uncomfortable with harm reduction and methadone programs. And so it goes at the UN.

Footnote: NGOs are complaining that they are Banned from the UN's North Lawn building from Wednesday through Friday, because the UN Department of Safety and Security considers this a summit. Will that mean that all NGOs are barred? We'll see.

On Reprisals in Cote d'Ivoire, Juppe & UN Speak of Past But Not Protection

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 7 -- Amid reports of attacks on supporters of Laurent Gbagbo by the forces of Alassane Ouattara in Cote d'Ivoire, there appears to have been a hiatus in the “protection of civilians” trumpeted earlier this year by the UN and the French “Force Licorne” or Unicorn.

Last week Inner City Press asked the UN what its mission in Ivory Coast, ONUCI, is doing to protect civilians, and how it responds to reports of the killings of those perceived to support Gbagbo. Transcript below. So far there has been no answer.

On June 7 outside the UN Security Council, where previously France's Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud spoke at length about the need for a resolution to empower UN and French attack helicopters to “protect civilians,” Inner City Press asked Araud's boss French foreign minister Alain Juppe what France is doing to protect civilians:

Inner City Press: I want to ask on Côte d’Ivoire, whe[ther] the Force Licorne has a responsibility to protect civilians, even now. There has been a report of Ouattara’s forces engaged in reprisal killings, is Licorne still on the streets to defend people or is it to return to its [base] ?

Alain Juppe: Please don’t mix everything. In Libya we think that we are acting in the framework of resolution 1973 of the Security Council. We are targeting military objectives and we are avoiding the civilian casualties. On Côte d’Ivoire, everybody recognized that our intervention has been successful. We are now supporting the process of national reconciliation engaged by President Ouattara and President Ouattara said that there will not be impunity for any kind of massacres or of casualties made either by one side or the other one.

But the allegations are not only of impunity for killings before Gbagbo was seized, but after. Human rights groups report on killings since then, presumably with ONUCI and Licorne standing by.

Like Juppe, the UN has not answered. From the UN's June 2 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: there have been at least a number of major NGO [non-governmental organization] reports out about the killing of pro-Gbagbo supporters by Ouattara forces since Gbagbo was put under arrest. There is also an ICG report saying that the Government formed by Ouattara has virtually no members of Gbagbo’s party. So, on both of these two fronts, both the protection of civilians and on the sort of, quote, reconciliation, what does UNOCI [United Nations Operation in Côte d'Ivoire] say? It seems that both of these respected NGOs have said that things are not going well, that the retaliation killings taking place, which presumably UNOCI should be trying to stop -- So, what’s the UN’s response to that?

Associate Spokesperson: On human rights violation and abuses, there is the international commission of inquiry. It’s about to report — it was in Côte d'Ivoire, maybe it still is — and it’s about to report to the Human Rights Council in June, that session. So, I can check for the exact date if that’s helpful, but I think it would be that first and then I think the High Commissioner also will have a report during that session, also in June, in Geneva on Côte d'Ivoire. So, that’s the first thing. On the formation of the Government, I don’t really have a comment.

Inner City Press: Just to be clear, and I am talking about what UNOCI does day to day to quote, protect civilians, which is part of its mandate.

Associate Spokesperson: Yeah, yeah.

Inner City Press: Human Rights Watch is saying that since 11 April.. Gbagbo supporters have been killed in the Yopougon neighbourhood. So, I wanted to know… it’s not happening? Is UNOCI trying to stop it? it seems like a very different picture than what UNOCI is saying.

Associate Spokesperson: Well, UNOCI’s mandate includes the protection of civilians, as you know. So, if there are allegations they’ll certainly go and investigate them. They have a human rights division, and it documents human rights abuses and violations. I can check specifically if you want the Yopougon thing, okay. Anyone else?

But in the five days since, the UN has provided no answer. And on June 7, the Spokesman for Ban Ki-moon, Martin Nesirky, rushed in a nine minute noon briefing at exactly the time Alain Juppe was speaking at the Security Council, such that no questions could be asked of the UN. Watch this site.

Amid Libya Rift, Western UNSC Members Try to Have African Union for Lunch

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 7 -- With African Union ministers scheduled to come to New York concerning Libya on June 15, there is a fight in the Security Council about what format to meet them in.

South Africa, which pushed for the ministerial meeting, would like it to be an open, inter-active dialogue. They have support on the Eastern Front of the Permanent Five for this.

Western P-5 members, on the other hand, have despite their stated respect for and even deference to the African Union proposed that interaction with the AU ministers be confined to a non-public lunch, non Western Council sources have complained to Inner City Press.

They say the United States wanted there to be no public meeting with the African Union, and that the UK then proposed it merely be a lunch.

This is “disrespectful to the African Union,” they say. They explain it as an attempt by Western members to avoid airing in public the disagreement the African Union expressed to the Council when it visited Addis Ababa last month.

The Western members of the Council like to “use” the African Union, it's said, until the AU disagrees with them. Then it's time to retire to a private lunch.

Inner City Press asked French foreign minister Alain Juppe to respond to the African Union criticism of how Resolution 1973 is being implemented. Juppe avoided any specifics, merely stating that the actions of France, and presumably of NATO, are in compliance with the resolution. Bon appetit!

Amid UN Praise of Arab Spring, a One Candidate Coronation of Ban Ki-moon Begins

By Matthew Russell Lee, News Analysis

UNITED NATIONS, June 6 -- While leaders in the UN loudly praised the Arab Spring as a move toward democracy, Ban Ki-moon is being anointed without any competition or even debate for another five year term as Secretary General.

If democracy is good in the Middle East, why not in the UN itself? Wouldn't a more formal process, including questions ranging from Libya through human rights to the budget, benefit the UN and its legitimacy?

Even the International Monetary Fund, derided for lack of transparency, last month announced a process whereby candidates can put in their names by June 10, with three or four to be interviewed and a decision made by June 30.

At the UN by contrast, there is no deadline, and no explanation of the sudden rush. Much is made of the lack of other candidates, but no formal process for nominations was ever announced.

There is no transparency: the Security Council could take up and adopt, without vote, the dipositive resolution without any notice to the public, in any closed door consultations as early as today.

Some have said Ban would like to do it with the Presidents of Gabon and Nigeria in town: that is, on the margins of Tuesday's speeches about HIV / AIDS.

Beginning with an Inner City Press report midday on Friday that Ban would meet with the Asia Group on Monday morning then announce to the press Monday at 11:30, it has been widely reported that the process has begun (and just as widely predicted that there is no opposition.)

Monday in the UN's North Lawn Building, Inner City Press observed a slew of high UN official going up to Ban's third floor office: Alain Le Roy and Susana Malcorra of Peacekeeping, information technology's Mr. Choi, manager in waiting Franz Baumann -- whom Inner City Press thanked for a recent written answer -- Ban's Special Adviser on Africa and other issues, and top Political adviser Lynn Pascoe, who told Inner City Press “it's just the boss holding his normal Monday morning meeting.” We'll see.

Amid Burkina Faso Unrest, UN & Djinnit Stay Silent, Under France's Watchful Eye

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 4 -- Now that the fighting in Burkina Faso has killed civilians, the UN's long silence seems all the more strange, when contrasted to its comments on unrest in other countries.

On June 1, Inner City Press asked the Office of the Spokesperson for Secretary General Ban Ki-moon what the UN had to say about the ongoing mutiny in Burkina Faso, which resulted in 24-year rules Blaise Campaore dissolving the government and calling home UN Darfur mediator Djibril Bassole as foreign minister.

From the UN's transcript:

INNER CITY PRESS: I just wonder if anyone at the UN is tracking these mutinies in Burkina Faso where the army has been for several months rebelling against the Government. There is just now a recent outbreak of shooting in the main town, and I just wonder, does the Secretary-General have, you know, I don’t know… is there… Burkina Faso is a big contributor of peacekeepers, a big player in peace initiatives in Africa — has there been any statement at any point by the UN about this ongoing turmoil in Burkina Faso?

That day, the UN Spokesperson's office had no comment, merely saying that Ban's Department of Political Affairs was watching and would be checked with. Later Inner City Press was told that Ban's envoy for West Africa Said Djinnit was “of course monitoring,” but chose not to say anything.

And now, Campaore's forces have rumbled into the second city of Baso Dioulasso and at least seven have been killed, including a young girl. Colonial power France is said to be watching. Some wonder, watching to make sure the UN doesn't criticize? We'll see.

Former Saleh Minister Is UN Face in Arab World, UNDP Yemen Website Dormant

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 4 -- Amid news that Ali Abdullah Saleh is leaving Yemen, under the immunity deal he has three times before rejected, the United Nations' engagement with Saleh's thirty year rule has come into focus.

Inner City Press has repeatedly asked the UN Development Program about its director for Arab states, Amat Al Alim Alsoswa, who previously served as a Saleh minister and has since “been the UN's face” in the region, according to UN sources critical of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's performance during the Arab Spring.

In April, Inner City Press asked UNDP:

“On Yemen, please state whether former Saleh minister Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa has recused herself from consideration of Yemen programs. Please also state, on deadline, whether Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa or any family member... would be covered by the immunity deal negotiated between Saleh and the Gulf Cooperation Council.”

Days later, UNDP's spokesman responded that

“UN staff are all international civil servants who act in accordance with the United Nations’ standards and norms. Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa assumed her post as Assistant Secretary General and Director of the Regional Bureau of Arab State in 2006 after leaving her official functions with the Government of Yemen. Ms. Alsoswa is not part of any political discussion or agreement taking place in or on Yemen.”

Inner City Press followed up:

“On Yemen, I wanted to know if she is involved in UNDP's program for Yemen, if she or her brother are covered by the immunity negotiated by the GCC.”

UNDP's spokesman responded that she had not recused herself:

“Regional Bureaux perform an oversight function over country programmes. They review the programme and the evaluation plan, based on the quality criteria, to provide in-house quality assurance of the programme. The Director of the Bureau endorses the quality of the evaluation plan prior to the submission to the Executive Board. Ms. Alsoswa and her brothers are not part of any immunity deal.”

The deal, which some say was developed with the input of the US Embassy in Sanaa, doesn't specifically name all of the Saleh associates who would be covered by it.

Earlier this year, even as Saleh has started ordering the use of life ammunition against protesters in Sanaa, UNDP's Helen Clark visited the country accompanied by Amat Al Alim Alsoswa. In UNDP's statements, democracy and the right to peaceful protest were absent.

UNDP promoted the joint visit of Helen Clark and former Saleh minister Amat Al Alim Alsoswa on UNDP's Yemen web site. A visit to the site on June 4 found that it had not been updated for a month, and said virtually nothing about the killing of protesters.

Likewise, the UN's Syria website has been fun of happy talk -- until it disappeared from the Internet on June 3 as part of Assad's crackdown on the 'Net. But why block access to the UN when it is aligned with the dictators? Watch this site.

On Syria Draft Russia, China & India Won't Engage, S. Africa Won't Without Them

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 3 -- At a UN meeting Thursday about the draft Syria resolution, Russia, China and India said there was no reason to begin word by word negotiation: they overall oppose the resolution. Then the European sponsors tried to reach out to South Africa and Brazil, to see if they would engage in negotiations without the nay-saying three. They were rebuffed.

As South Africa's Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu put it to Inner City Press on June 3, “We are in solidarity with the E[lected] Ten, we will not go into some cocoon of the Security Council. If they won't negotiate, either will we.”

Also on June 3, Russia's Deputy Permanent Representative Pankin asked Inner City Press, “Why a new resolution -- for more bombing?” The reference was to what NATO has done in Libya after Russia and China, along with non veto wielding India, Brazil and Germany, abstained on Resolution 1973.

The Europeans' draft resolution still refers to a statement by the Organization of the Islamic Conference, to which the OIC has objected in a letter it sent to the Security Council president for May, Gerard Araud of France.

At this stage, Inner City Press is putting a copy of the draft resolution online, here. Watch this site.

* * *

France Pitching Lagarde for IMF Called “Not Incompatible” with Leading G-20

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 3 -- For the second time during France's presidency of the Group of 20, a French minister has come to the UN and held a closed door briefing, excluding the press, about how open the Sarkozy administration's leadership of the G-20 is.

But when Labor and Health Minister Xavier Bertrand came on June 3, something had changed. Dominique Strauss Kahn had lost the top post at the International Monetary Fund after being charged with sexual assault on a maid at Sofitel in New York, and fellow French minster Christine Lagarde is globetrotting to procure a vote this month to replace DSK.

Inner City Press asked Bertrand, flanked by French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud and his spokesman, about a complaint by South Africa's minister of finance Pravin Gardhan that the fast moves for Lagarde breach some commitment by the G-20 for a more open process.

As Bertrand rolled his eyes even before the question was finished, Inner City Press asked if there might be a conflict of interest in France leading the G-20 while pushing for Lagarde to replace DSK. Might a G-20 with a developing world president speak and act differently during this period?

After saying he hadn't come to speak about the question of the IMF, Bertrand emphasized that Lagarde has support “beyond France, even beyond Europe.” He said that while “certain [people] take into account nationality,” Lagarde's experience goes beyond that.

He claimed that France's leadership of the G-20 is “collective,” and is “not incompatible,” with pushing Lagarde.

Inner City Press did not mentioned DSK, having noted that Bertrand has even come to the defense of fellow French official Georges Tron, also charged with sex abuse. Innocent until proven guilty, Bertrand has said -- without referring to the upcoming June 10 court decision on Lagarde's role in the payment of a large governmental settlement to Sarkozy ally Bernard Tapie. Watch this site.

Footnotes: while some in France ascribe Agustin Carstens counter candidacy to l'affaire Cassez between Mexico, others tell Inner City Press that if Lagarde's candidacy survives the June 10 court decision, and if she replaced DSK, it would not be for a full term, and a stronger commitment would be made that her successor would not be European. We'll see.

At Bertrand's closed door G-20 pitch, Singapore's Permanent Representative Vanu Gopala Menon on behalf of the Global Governance Group (3G) urged France to “allow greater involvement of non G-20 countries in work groups” of the G-20. Inner City Press asked Bertrand about this as well; he responded that Singapore is invited, France's G-20 is not a club. Watch this site.