Saturday, June 18, 2011

At UN on Abyei Draft, Sudan PR Denies Food Theft, Dismisses Burning of “Huts," UNSC to Set June 10 Meeting

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 3, updated -- Seventy hours after the US introduced a draft Presidential Statement on Abyei, Sudan's Ambassador Daffa-Alla Elhag Ali Osman walked into the Security Council in a bright white suit. Already a Council Deputy Permanent Representative had told Inner City Press that more work was needed on the Statement, to begin at 1 pm on Friday.

As Sudan's Ambassador walked out of the Council, Inner City Press asked him about the draft. He said it had been inaccurate to call Sudan's tanks in Abyei an occupation. (Inner City Press is told that this word is being removed). He took issue with the phrase that the influx of Miseriya was an attempt at ethnic cleansing.

“That is prejudging,” he said. “Let it happen, genocide or ethnic cleansing, and then talk about it.”

When Inner City Press asked him about the accusation that tons of food was stolen in Abyei, he said he hadn't seen the World Food Program see that. Asked by another journalist about the burning of houses, he said, “those are huts, these things happen in war. Where are you from - Lebanon? These things happen there.”

And then he was gone, at least until 1 pm.

Update of 11:40 am -- a Deputy Permanent Representative tells Inner City Press that the meeting on the Sudan PRST has been moved up from 1 until just after the consultations on UNOCA, as early as noon. What else will come out of the draft? Watch this site.

Update of 12:30 pm -- Inner City Press is told that if the Council finally reaches agreement on this PRST, it will be adopted by being read out in the Chamber at 4 pm...

Update of 1:19 pm -- after a Deputy Permanent Representative tells Inner City Press that the Sudan PRST is “definitely” going to be adopted at 4 pm, another source explains to Inner City Press that there is only one paragraph open, in which the US wants to require new meetings on the topic every seven days, other members don't. Eminently solvable.

Update of 2:26 pm -- while another Deputy Permanent Representative tells Inner City Press that the Council has agreed to hold another meeting on Sudan next week, says they have still not agreed on how to express it in language and “put it on paper.” A Western representative asks Inner City Press, if we put it out at 4, the news can still be distributed, right? But of course...

Update of 2:51 pm -- the Political Coordinators have just left the Council, a number of them telling Inner City Press that the agreement, to be typed up by the US and translated into French in which Gabon will read it out, is to remain seized of the matter and to calendar another meeting on Sudan for June 10... Timing of adoption now depends on US typing up, and translation...

Update of 4:32 pm -- while the players have arrived for adoption of the Sudan PRST at the Security Council, still the meeting hasn't started. Meanwhile, reports of a UN leak saying it WAS ethnic cleansing in Abyei, here

Update of 4:39 pm -- a Deputy Permanent Representative tells Inner City Press, “the French translation is not ready.”

Brazil Says Advocate Against Dam to Displace 12,000 Could've Come to UN “on Vacation”

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 2 -- During the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues in New York last month, the absence of Brazil's Azelene Kaingang was much noted. She was scheduled to speak on a panel as an advocate against that country's Belo Monte dam project. But she did not come.

On June 2, Inner City Press asked Brazil's Permanent Representative and Mission to the UN about Ms. Kaingang's abence and was told that she was not allowed to come as a government employee, but that she could have come if she had “taken vacation days.”

Brazil's Mission provided a vigorous defense of the dam, saying it would displace “only twelve thousand people” in a poor area “without electricity or running water... not indigenous land.” The defense included deriding those concerned about the displacement as “ladies from Stockholm and Mayfair who need to keep their NGOs going.” One of these NGOs, it should be noted, is Amnesty International.

More substantively, it was argued that after the nuclear power accident in Japan, and the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, hydro-power is the only way for Brazil to go. But what about the 12,000 people the government acknowledges it would displace? We will continue to follow this.

Footnote: during the Permanent Forum, Inner City Press was told of the existence of a blacklist administered by the UN, at the request of governments, of indigenous activists who are not to be allowed to attend in this or future years. This, we are looking into.

At UN, Amid Haggling on Sudan, Haysom's Hat in Ring, Pascoe Eager to Leave?

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 1, updated -- Twenty four hours after the US presented a draft Presidential Statement on Sudan asking for Security Council action that same day, the Council remained in negotiations on it, from 11 am Wednesday until Deputy Permanent Representatives began arriving along with a new US draft after 3 pm.

One sticking point was flagged on the margins of Tuesday's Council meeting: whether Khartoum's tanks in Abyei should be called an occupation.

China's Permanent Representative Li Baodong told Inner City Press that the word occupation will not be in the PRST. He said that Sudan is the priority for June, that China has no preference if stability is brought by UN peacekeepers or Ethiopian troops under an African Union banner.

(He added that the AU felt “marginalized” on Libya, and that China welcomes a visit to New York by an AU ministerial delegation in mid June, on which Inner City Press reported on Tuesday, click here.)

The elephant in the (consultations) room is what the future of the UN Mission in Sudan or its successor will be. Ban Ki-moon proposed 7000 peacekeepers, which Southern Sudan said is not enough.

Tuesday evening UNICEF official Hilde Johnson confirmed to Inner City Press its previous report, that she, Ian Martin and at least one other UN official are under consideration to replace Haile Menkerios as head of UNMIS.

Inner City Press can now exclusively report the name of this “other UN official” -- it is Ban Ki-moon's savvy South African adviser on peacekeeping and political affairs Nicolas Haysom. Sources told Inner City Press a week ago that the onus for Haysom's consideration is Ban Ki-moon's on again off again policy of mobility, of no more than five years in a UN job.

Under this policy, for example, Department of Peacekeeping Operations' long time spokesman has been sent out to Somalia.

But others notice that the policy is not being applied to many of those closest to Ban, for example his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, his (and Kofi Annan's) adviser Robert Orr, and genial DPKO chief Alain Le Roy, of whom more and more sources tell Inner City Press a (French) replacement has been chosen, akin to the proposed Lagarde for DSK switch.

The head of Ban's Department of Political Affairs Lynn Pascoe is said to one close to him to “want out, badly.” But would the UK take his spot? And if so, what of Valerie Amos?

Pascoe, even when he skips the stakout, answers on such topics as Kyrgystan. On Wednesday the Spokesperson's Office took a question for him about the mutinies in Burkina Faso. Watch this site.

Footnote: Menkerios on Tuesday evening told Inner City Press, when asked when he'll come back to New York, "when they call me." On Wednesday, Li Baodong told Inner City Press Menkerios is "experienced" and "knows both sides," and that China hopes he will stay while he is needed. We'll see.

Update of 3:50 pm -- outside the DPR level consultation, a close observer marveled to Inner City Press that the US hadn't given any time for members' experts to even confer with their DPR - the US "just keeps pushing."

Update of 4:13 pm -- the DPR's have left, two telling Inner City Press that the experts' work wasn't done, it was too early to have convened them. On the substance, some point at Southern Sudan having put a claim to own Abyei in its draft constitution a provocation, just like what's now being called the North's "takeover" (not occupation) of Abyei. Susan Rice has done in to meet with Gabon, as storm clouds (literally) gather over the UN.

Update of 4:53 pm -- as US Ambassador Susan Rice left her bilateral meeting with June's Gabonese Security Council president, Inner City Press asked her to confirm that the word “occupation” of Abyei is coming out of the PRST. It doesn't matter, she said. It's just a word.

Sources say that the alternative is “takeover.”

Inner City Press asked Ambassador Rice about the US' just announced “boycott” of the Durban III review conference. Not a boycott, she said. Non-participation.

Another word switch. And so it goes at the UN.

Update of 5:40 pm -- on the US drafted Sudan PRST, the experts meeting has broken up. Inner City Press is told it will be sent to capital, also subject to more negotiations Thursday morning under “Other Matters” alongside the program of work consultations.

This is a substantive text, an expert complained. They only introduced it yesterday afternoon - how can they expect us to just go along? Delegations had problems not only with “occupation” applied to Abyei, but also “ethnic cleansing.” Which words will be traded out? Watch this site.

As Azeri Minister Meets Ban Ki-moon on Nagorno Karabakh, Seeks UNSC Seat Over Hungary and Slovenia, Citing EU Rules

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 1, updated -- A three way race for a UN Security Council seat is shaping up between Azerbaijan and two members of the European Union, Hungary and Slovenia.

Azerbaijan's argument is that under the EU's common foreign policy provisions either of these two would be aligned with Permanent members the UK and France.

Azerbaijan, a member of the Organization of the Islamic Conference and recent joiner of the Non Aligned Movement, would in this view bring a different perspective.

Azerbaijan recently detained people who protested in Baku, and is seeking to confine protest organizer Bakhtiyar Hajiev for two years, ostensibly for refusing the mandatory year of military service. (Azerbaijan remains in a frozen or “protracted” conflict about Nagorno-Karabakh with Armenia, which they say has dropped out of the race for the Security Council seat.)

Inner City Press asked one of the spokespeople for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Wednesday if in his May 31 meeting with Azeri foreign minister Elmar Mammadyarov Ban had raised these detention or other human rights issues, and if Nagorno Karabakh was discussed, as has been reported.

While the UN usually puts out canned “read outs” of Ban's meetings with visiting foreign ministers, this time it had not.


Ban & Azeri FM, still no UN read out shown

In her first noon briefing replacing lead spokesman Martin Nesirky, Vannina Maestracci told Inner City Press she would try to get a read out of the meeting.

She delivered answers on two questions that Nesirky had left unanswered the previous, which may portend well. Watch this site.

Footnote: Mammadyarov was leaving New York on Wednesday for Washington, to meet with Hillary Clinton. Some have analogized the US and Russian relation with Azerbaijan to those with Georgia, and even pointed to the 2008 denouement of the frozen conflict of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, whose president Sergei Bagapsh recently died while seeking medical treatment in Moscow.

Would the US provide more back up to Azerbaijan than to Abkhazia, whose break away from Georgia was just recognized by Vanuatu? Yes, some say, pointing to its natural gas reserves, and US Ambassador Richard Morningstar who works the issue....

Update of 4:10 pm -- and some hours later, this belated readout:

From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Wed, Jun 1, 2011 at 3:59 PM
Subject: Response to your question on Azerbaijan.
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

In their meeting yesterday, the Secretary-General and the Foreign Minister of Azerbaijan discussed the status of the Nagorno-Karabakh peace process. The Secretary-General encouraged the parties to support confidence-building measures proposed by the Organization for Security and Coooperation in Europe (OSCE) Minsk Group Co-Chairs to ease tensions on the ground.

In French Month Atop UN Council, Araud's 3 Stakeouts Hit New Low, Of Misstatements to Press & "Hostile Acts"

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 31 -- France's month as president of the UN Security Council ended with a whimper on Tuesday when a meeting on Sudan had no outcome, not even a Press Statement. French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud did not go to the stakeout and deliver any summary of the discussion, or any closing statement for his generally unsuccessful and untransparent month atop the Council.

A review of the UN Webcast Internet site reflects that of the past eight presidents of the Council, France's Araud did the least press stakeouts during his month. His output was doubled by Brazil in February, Colombia in April, and the UK last November.

At one of Araud's listed stakeouts, on May 11, he took no questions at all. He read a statement about Sudan in French, then left a translator at the stakeout to read it out in English, after he said, smirking, “Since I speak no English.” Click here to view.

Araud's last stakeout was on May 27 at 7:30 pm, with only three reporters present, click here to view. Araud came late, having not been able to find his way into the UN building. “He doesn't even know how to get in here,” one UN staffer marveled.

When Araud finally arrived, Inner City Press asked him why the statement he read, only in English, about the arrest of Ratko Mladic had been delayed from 10 am, when the French mission told UN TV to set up a camera, until 7:30 pm. Araud said he would not explain, and added despite France's bragging to the contrary that “we are not ready” and not promising on Syria.

On May 9, Inner City Press asked Araud if the trip he was leading to Sudan would go to Abyei, if Sudan had agreed to that. He said yes, there is no problem, they have agreed, there are only logistics. Click here to view.

But as Inner City Press reported at the time, Sudan's Deputy Permanent Representative repeatedly said that Khartoum has not agreed to the Abyei visit, which ultimately did not happen as fighting broke out there.

This was not the French mission's only misstatement in the month.


Araud as President in May, talk to press & results not shown

At the beginning of the month Araud claimed, in French, that he wanted to make the Council less formal. But then another Council member told Inner City Press that Araud had gone back on a reform from November, and now required countries to sign up in advance to speak in the Council's closed door consultations.

When Inner City Press asked, at a Friday reception hosted by Italy, France denied this. But then another Council member said that on that Sunday, France emailed to other members to reverse the policy they had just told Inner City Press they didn't have.

The French Mission to the UN's public relations appear to have less to do with the truth than with what they view as power politics.

When for example this year Inner City Press obtained and published documents from the Mission and the French military about French policy in Cote d'Ivoire, including the NYC Police Department arrest document for a French Mission diplomat, Romain Serman, accused of attempted purchase of cocaine and resisting arrest, the French Mission approached Inner City Press and called the publication “a hostile act.”

(Since then, the normal ways one uses to get a Mission's answers don't work, but will continue to be tried, not least in fairness to the Mission, which apparently doesn't like to be asked questions.)

Later, the French Mission asked pointedly that the Romain Serman arrest document be taken off line -- although it precisely the type of document widely published concerning the arrest, for example, of French political figure Dominique Strauss Kahn, around whom impropriety and corruption scandals swirl, not unlike at the Mission here reviewed. The negative impacts may have been (slightly) more on display during France's now concluded month atop the Council, but will continue. Watch this site.

After Elevator Falls in UN Building, Injuring Staff, Ban's Office Unaware, Lawsuit?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 31 -- After a UN staff member was injured when an elevator fell to the first floor in the building the UN's rented at 380 Madison Avenue, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky about the fall, and if the UN is going to litigate against the landlord it chose, to protest its workers there.

Nesirky said while “safety of staff is paramount,” he hadn't heard about the elevator fall.

But less than an hour later, a Town Hall meeting on the topic was held in the UN's North Lawn building. Afterward, one of the UN officials who made a presentation in the closed door meeting said that the UN's version was sent out in a broadcast e-mail (which could or should have been read by Nesirky's office), and that it is too early to talk about litigation, until the health of the staff member is known.

He said the incident took place on a Friday, but that UN Management wasn't told of it until the following Monday, when it complained to the City of New York. City officials took action on Tuesday, but staff members who spoke to Inner City Press on condition of anonymity for fear of retaliation say they are not convinced, and that there's been more than one elevator fall. We'll see.

Footnote: Ban is also under fire for the firing of elevator operators inside the UN, and their replacement by non-union contractors. Meanwhile Ban, who just returned for the weekend from a trip including Nigeria and Deauville, leaves again on June 1 for Italy. Watch this site.

Update of 2:59 pm -- Twenty minutes after publication of the above Inner City Press received -- not from the Spokesperson's Office -- the broadcast email:

Elevators in 380 Madison Avenue

There have been two recent incidents involving the elevators in 380 Madison Avenue. On Monday 16 May 2011, elevator cab #5 descended rapidly to the ground floor and stopped between levels. After 30 minutes the doors were opened and all five passengers were escorted out. No injuries were reported at the time.

On Friday 20 May 2011 at around 5pm, an elevator carrying two passengers descended rapidly from the 6th floor to the lobby level and stopped abruptly. At the time, no reports of the incident were received by building management or the security officers on duty. Both passengers left the building. Subsequently, one elevator passenger sought medical assistance and has since been admitted to the hospital having sustained back and knee injuries.

The 20 May incident was reported to the Office of Central Support Service (OCSS) on 23 May, OCSS then reported it to the building management and filed a formal complaint with the New York City Department of Buildings, the same day. An inspector from the Department of Buildings arrived on Tuesday 24 May and checked all elevators over a period of four hours, together with the building management, the elevator contractor and a UN security officer. The NYC Department of Buildings website now reflects the outcome of the city inspection as showing the complaint to have been resolved. The 380 building management has informed us that elevator maintenance will continue throughout this week.

Staff in 380 Madison have asked about using the stairs instead of the elevators. This is against New York City fire code as stairs can only be used for emergency egress. Please be assured that all efforts are being made to ensure the safety of staff.

The Facilities and Commercial Services Division continues to monitor the matter with the management of 380 Madison Avenue. Staff are encouraged to report any incidents of elevator malfunction immediately to security or building staff on duty and to file a report to the FMS helpdesk at 3-7376.
Andrew Nye, Officer In Charge
Facilities and Commercial Services Division
Office of Central Support Services

On Sri Lanka, As Pillay Supports UN Report, Ban Merely Says It's Out There

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 31 -- Even after UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Navi Pillay said in Geneva she supports that an international mechanism on Sri Lanka be established, as Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Panel of Experts recommended to him, Ban has not supported the recommendation.

Inner City Press on Tuesday asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if Ban agrees with what Pillay said, and if he has any comment on the video depicting extrajudicial executions by Sri Lankan soldiers.

Ban's spokesman said that “in the first instance it is the responsibility of sovereign states to conduct a credible investigation,” and that the Panel's recommendations are “there are all to see.” But does Ban support them? Nesirky said, “There should either be consent from the SL authorities or a mandate from an intergovernmental body.”

Even regarding the video, Ban's spokesman said “we are certainly aware of it,” and that it underscores the need for a “national” accountability mechanism. But Ban's own Panel concluded that the Rajapaksas' Lessons Learnt & Reconciliation Commission is deeply flawed.

There is as yet no action even on the one thing Ban said he would do, review the UN's own actions on Sri Lanka, presumably including with regard to the so-called White Flag killings of surrenderees.

Ban Ki-moon, having just returned for the weekend from a trip including Nigeria and Deauville, now leaves again on from June 1 to 3 to Italy. And so it goes.

Saturday, June 11, 2011

After Zuma Libya Trip, AU Visit to UN SC Planned, Forum Shopping as Risk

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 31 -- South African president Jacob Zuma's just concluded trip to Tripoli was discussed by the UN Security Council in closed door consultations on Tuesday.

Afterward South Africa's Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu told Inner City Press that “there is a African Union ministerial delegation we are planning to have an engagement with the Security Council members,” possible in mid June.

The danger, Ambassador Sangqu told Inner City Press, is that “if there's a plethora of initiatives there will be forum shopping and no commitment to any of them.”

At Tuesday's UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky what the relation is between Zuma's endeavors and those of part time UN envoy Abdel-Elah Al Khatib.

While Nesirky responded by describing a visit by Al Khatib to Cairo, mentioning Catherine Ashton, the coordination is not clear.

Ambassador Sangqu told Inner City Press that Al Khatib should be in New York in mid June for the meetings.

Footnotes: Another diplomat exiting the Council, asked by Inner City Press about this mid June timing, quipped "if Gaddafi's still there -- or still alive."

Also at Tuesday's noon briefing, UN spokesman Nesirky told Inner City Press that Ban Ki-moon has not received any notice, under Resolution 1973, of the attack helicopters the UK and France say they are sending, nor of the "boots on the grounds" depicted near Misurata.

The chair of the Council's Libya Sanctions Committee said he'd seen the media report of Western boots on the ground, but nothing had come through the Committee, on that or the report of steps to block Gaddafi's television broadcasts. We'll see.

At UN, Council President Won't Explain 10 Hour Mladic Delay, Syria Not Promising

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 27 -- The Security Council president Gerard Araud showed up at the stakeout at 7:40 pm on Friday night, more than nine hours after it was announced he would read a Council Press Statement on the arrest of Ratko Mladic.

“Three for the price of one,” Araud told the Press, before reading out statements on an attack on UN peacekeepers in Lebanon and the arrest of Mladic, and a separate “elements to the press” on the arrest of Rwanda genocide suspect Bernard Munyagishari in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

After Araud finished reading, Inner City Press asked him to explain the ten hour delay on the Mladic statement.

Sources say there was resistance to including a reference to Srebrenica in the statement -- one wag noted that the UN itself might be embarrassed to have it in, given the charges against peacekeepers in that case.

Araud said he would not as President of the Council describe any negotiations.

Inner City Press asked him about the draft resolution on Syria, whether he thought it possible it could be voted on during France's presidency, which ends Tuesday.

No, Araud said, we are not ready, we are not close. Later he went further: less promising. And so it goes at the UN.

As UN Plans for Durban Discussion, Tiptoeing Around Holocaust Denial, Press Access

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 26 -- In the run up to September's UN meeting on the Durban Declaration, with Holocaust denial in the air, a meeting was held Wednesday on 48th Stree to scope out the session. Should the opening run from 9 am to 11:30? Or only to 10? Should it be televised? These were the questions, in the so-called “informal informal” consultations held in the UN's North Lawn building.

Monaco and Cameroon were in the chair position, and Switzerland spoke more than any other delegation. Sources tell Inner City Press that the US and Canada are nowhere to be seen in the process. But whether this will serve them come September remains to be seen.

European Union sources tell Inner City Press they are between a rock and a hard place. They would like to denounce racism, the ostensible goal of the Durban Declaration. But given how things went in Durban in 2001, and even more in 2004, they are concerned the event will provide a platform for Holocaust denial.

At the same time the EU does not want to be seen questioning free speech. Try to block media coverage -- to some, one possible solution -- or to ask in advance what participants will say, is hardly in keeping with freedom of expression.

Inner City Press covered the vote on Durban III in December 2010, when funding was approved 102 for, 33 abstaining and 17 against, including Canada and the United States.

The French Mission to the UN later told Inner City Press it had abstained because “there were many elements in the text that we couldn't support, but we support the Durban declaration and want to engage in the Durban process. Hence our vote."

The fights on May 25 were mundane: would the speakers come from regional groupings or so-called political groups like the G-77; would there be “program budget implications;” would the panel discussions be televised. The elephant in the room was who would use the spotlight, and for what purpose. We'll see -- watch this site.

As Kyrgyzstan Bans Kiljunen, UN Ban Has No Comment, Sri Lanka Report Echoes

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 26 -- The UN's relationship with reports on ethnic violence and war crimes under Secretary General Ban Ki-moon gets more and more convoluted.

On Thursday, Kyrgyzstan's parliament voted to ban from the country Kimmo Kiljunen, the Finnish author of an independent report on last year's ethnic violence from entering the country, saying his findings were a threat to national security.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if Ban or the UN had any comment on Kiljunen being barred from entering Kyrgyzstan. Nesirky began by emphasizing that despite “logistic” support, Kiljunen's was not a UN report. He then said the report could be useful.

If the UN thinks the report could be useful, Inner City Press asked, why no Ban Ki-moon reacting to its author being banned from the country?

Nesirky said again, there would be no comment.

To some, this is similar to Ban's reaction to date to the Sri Lanka war crimes report that, under pressure, he commissioned from a Panel of Experts. While a recommendation was that Ban initiate an investigative mechanism, Ban immediately said that he cannot or will not do this without a vote by the General Assembly, Security Council or Human Rights Council.

It has been pointed out that the investigations are possible without such votes, for example in the case of the Democratic Republic of the Congo Mapping Report. Nesirky told Inner City Press he would respond to this comparison, but has not.

It emerged this week that Ban has not even transmitted the Sri Lanka report to the UN in Geneva.

Now, on another report -- albeit one further removed from the UN -- Ban has no comment on the report's author being banned from the country.

From the UN's May 26 transcript:

Inner City Press: on Kyrgyzstan, this Kimmo Kiljunen.

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Kiljunen, Kiljunen, yeah.

Inner City Press: okay, however said, he is now being blocked from the country. The Parliament has voted to bar him because of his report on the violence that was in Kyrgyzstan. Given the UN’s role, you know, and stated… he said that the UN sort of supports his report. Is that true and do you have any comment?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, first of all, you know, let’s be clear that it was not a UN report. Some technical, logistical advice was provided to Mr. Kiljunen and those who put together the report. It’s an important step in the right direction. Again, talking about the need for accountability for actions that took place and crimes that were evidently committed last year in Kyrgyzstan.

Inner City Press: but does the UN, if you are thinking it’s a useful thing, what about this, the country now seeking to bar the author of the report. Is that --

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, that’s really a matter for the Kyrgyz authorities and Mr. Kiljunen. I don’t have any comment on that.

IMF Claims Didn't “Find Bad Stuff” on Ethics, No Answers on LP, Severance

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 26 -- With Dominique Strauss Kahn now under townhouse arrest in Tribeca in New York, the International Monetary Fund on Thursday held its first open and online press briefing since DSK's arrest for sexual assault.

IMF spokesperson Caroline Atkinson began blithely about DSK's interim replacement John Lipsky's travel.

When she opened up for questions -- with only three exceptions on Greece and Portugal, only from those in the briefing room in Washington -- she was asked directly, did you check the IMF's files before saying you were “not aware” of other complaints against DSK?

“I am not a lawyer,” Ms. Atkinson said, adding that it would somehow be inappropriate for the IMF to make disclosure of previous formal complaints against Strauss Kahn, since he is now on trial.

Likewise, she declined to answer a question about the ability to withhold the reported $250,000 severance payment to Strauss Kahn.

The IMF spokesperson was reduced to saying that the (American) ethics adviser at the Fund hadn't “found any bad stuff.”

In the past week, Inner City Press has submitted factual questions to the IMF that the IMF has not answered, such as on May 20:

--In today's UN noon press briefing I was told to “ask the IMF” about Dominique Strauss Kahn's UN Laissez Passer. If holding the LP is based on being an IMF official or staffer, given Mr. Strauss Kahn's resignation, why hasn't the LP been retrieved? What policies does the IMF have for the LPs of persons who resign or are terminated?

--what policies does the IMF have regarding the pensions and end-of-service payments to individuals charged with, or convicted of, felonies including those involving moral turpitude, such as sexual assault? Has Mr. Strauss Kahn receive any payment since his resignation, or does his resignation trigger one?

-- on my outstanding question about disclosures to the IMF under the IMF's cited policy on gifts, I have asked about Mr. Strauss Kahn and Mr. Lipksy but am now expanding the request to cover the ten top IMF officials.

Other reporters in the room on Thursday complained about not having their questions answered, and about Executive Board members saying they'd been told to refer all question, regardless of topic, back to the IMF Media Department (which does not answer).

Inner City Press iterated the above questions, and a pressing one on Sudan, during the IMF's briefing on Thursday. But it seems the IMF is trying to hide from straight forward questions.

Update: after publication of the above, an answer was received on Sudan, nothing on the DSK questions:

Matthew: For your question on Sudan, you can attribute this to an IMF spokesperson. We deplore the violence and hope for a speedy end to the fighting. As you know, South Sudan has applied for membership, and that process is ongoing. A mission is on the ground now in Juba to discuss the membership process with the authorities.

At UN, Ban on Mobility Means Post for Khare, Musical Chairs, Orr for Nambiar?

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 25 -- Earlier in his five year term as UN Secretary General, Ban Ki-moon announced a policy of mobility under which no official should serve in the same position for more than five years.

On May 25, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky for an update on the policy, specifically with regard to Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, political chief Lynn Pascoe, top peacekeeper Alain Le Roy, and his (and Kofi Annan's) adviser Robert Orr.

Nesirky answered that the policy is being considered by the General Assembly. While this may be true of wider human resources policy, Ban's implementation of his own stated ideals in his own cabinet does not require outside approval.

While Inner City Press is informed of impending changes with regard to the above-named officials, what is most striking is what sources say about Bob Orr trying to replace Nambiar as Ban's chief of staff, despite his already long service in the Executive Office of the Secretary General.

As noted, Nambiar has refused to take any questions from the press, despite a formal request from the UN correspondents' association.

There's said by UN sources to be another Frenchman in line to eventually replace Le Roy, and another American for Pascoe -- unless the UK gets its wish to “get DPA back” and thereby releases Valerie Amos from the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.

Meanwhile, the spirit of mobility is being violated, in the name of “Change Management.” With Edmond Mulet returning from Haiti to reclaim “his” post as Deputy chief of DPKO, the current holder of this post Atul Khare must leave.

But Khare is not of retirement age, and his native India wants to keep a high post, particularly if Nambiar's to leave.

So what does Ban do? Inner City Press twice asked Ban's spokesman Nesirky without getting an answer. Now multiple sources tell Inner City Press that Ban's solution is to create a new post for Khare, called Assistant Secretary General for Change Management, which will report to Deputy S-G Migiro. As one source said, “this is how you make sure nothing changes.”

From the UN's noon briefing transcript of May 23:

Inner City Press: Just factually, I wanted to know, I think Mr. [Edmond] Mulet is coming back from Haiti, from his time in Haiti at the end of this month. And some had said he is going to become the Deputy in DPKO [Department of Peacekeeping Operations]. Is that true, and what happens to Mr. [Atul] Khare, does he remain with DPKO or does he--

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Yeah, you asked that question by e-mail on Friday, and when we have an answer we’ll let you know, okay?

Watch this site.

At UN, Gay Group Denied Consultative Status 8-7, Kyrgyz Pivot, India on Dalits

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 23, updated -- Culture wars continued at the UN on Monday when the International Lesbian and Gay Association came up for a vote for consultative status in the Committee on Non-Governmental Organizations.

First, countries which opposed ILGA tried to stop them on a so called no-action vote, emphasizing that the group had declined to answer a new round of questionnaires, calling them discriminatory. In February, as exclusively covered by Inner City Press, ILGA was blocked by a no-action vote, 9-7.

This time the blocking vote failed, 7 to 7 with several abstentions:

US- No. Venezuela- abstain. Belgium- No. Bulgaria- No. Burundi- Yes. China- Yes. India – No. Israel- No. Kyrgyzstan- Abstain. Morocco- Yes. Mozambique- Abstain. Nicaragua- Abstain. Pakistan- Yes. Peru- No. Russia- Yes. Senegal- Yes. Sudan- Yes. Turkey- No

After that vote, Belgium asked the committee chair for “rules of procedure for dummies.” Venezuela took exception to being called a dummy. Things proceeded without humor.

Now the vote turned against ILGA, 8 to 7. The swing vote was Kygyzstan, which abstained on the no-action vote, but vote “no” against ILGA:

Sudan- No. Turkey- Yes. US- Yes. Venezuela- Abstain. Belgium- Yes. Bulgaria- Yes. Burundi- No. China- No. India- Yes. Israel –Yes. Kygryzstan – No. Morocco- No. Mozambique- Abstain. Nicaragua- Abstain. Pakistan- No. Peru- Yes. Russia – No. Senegal- No.

The International Foundation for Electoral Systems was delayed, 8-6, on a no action motion. Various groups were delayed by questions. For example, Human Rights House Foundation was blocked by a question from Morocco, backed by China and Sudan. (See update below.)

And the International Dalit Solidarity Network was blocked by India, which questioned if the caste based system is not already adequately addressed by the Indian government. The Dalit are... untouchables. And so it goes at the UN.

Update: the Human Rights House Foundation has written in to say

“We are glad to see that you pay attention to the work of the NGO Committee -- the process in the Committee needs more attention and should get on the radar of the media. On 23 May... some delegations including Morocco needed more time and were requesting that our application is dealt with on 24 May. For your information, HRHF has applied for ECOSOC consultative status in 2005 and received since 2007 51 questions from the NGO Committee. We have been deferred many times, but at this May 2011 session we have not been deferred and on 24 May 2011 the NGO Committee recommended by consensus that the consultative status should be granted to HRHF.”

As UN Council Cancels Abyei Trip, Georgian Echoes Amid AU Diagnosis of Narcissism

By Matthew Russell Lee, News Analysis

UNITED NATIONS, May 22 -- What does it say about the UN Security Council that outright war broke out in Abyei between North and Southern Sudan just as the Council prepared to visit the contested area?

Before the Council members left New York for Addis Ababa then Sudan, they negotiated the “logistics” of visiting Abyei while attempting to downplay the possibility of Ahmed Haroun, National Congress Party governor of South Kordofan and International Criminal Court indictee, showing up to greet and try to meet them on the way to Abyei.

UN officials told Inner City Press confidently “we can definitely protect the Council in Abyei, it's only a question of landing first at the airport in Kadugli or Wau.”

Things change, obviously. But why? An Council member left unnamed is quoted that the North invaded Abyei in order to discourage the Council's visit. Beyond what some see as the narcissism of the statement, even if true, would this mean that the Council's visit inflamed rather than de-escalated tensions?

When President Barack Obama's Press Secretary said on May 21 that the initial May 19 attack in Abyei was the responsibility of “Southern Forces” but drew a disproportionate response, it brought to mind the Georgian - Russian conflict in which Georgia is said to have tried to retake South Ossetia, then Russia rumbled down into Georgia itself.

In hindsight, some say Georgia erred in giving Russia the pretext to take land. So might the “attack by Southern forces” of May 19 be viewed in somewhat the same way?

Or is Southern Sudan smarter than Georgia, triggering a response from Khartoum, under the nose of the Security Council, that will meaningfully rebound against Omar al Bashir, Haroun and the National Congress Party? Watch this site.

Footnote: In the Addis Ababa leg of the Council's trip, Ramtane Lamamra of the African Union derided the Council for overriding the AU in authorizing and not stopping the continued bombing of Libya by NATO. While numerous Council members including two with veto power agree that action has gone beyond Resolution 1973, others note that Lamamra's from Algeria, more supportive of Gaddafi than most AU members...

At UN, As Georgia Loses HRC Bid It Blames Russian Lobbying, 5 Votes for Syria

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 20 -- Of the 17 countries running Friday for 15 seats on the UN Human Rights Council, only two were going to lose.

Inner City Press asked the Permanent Representative of Georgia Alexander Lomaia what he felt his chances were, facing off against Romania and the Czech Republic for two Eastern European group seats.

Ambassador Lomaia said, without hesitation, that Russia had been asking countries not to vote for Georgia, that at least two delegations had disclosed this. In many UN fora, Georgia and Russia exchange rights of reply regarding Abkhazia and South Ossetia. This is just one more battle.

After the election, in which Georgia got 89 votes but still lost to Romania's 131 and the Czech Republic's 148, Inner City Press asked a Russian diplomat about the result. He smiled and said, “Oops.”

Nicaraguan representatives said they liked their chances, but they too took a loss, despite receiving 98 votes. Austria pointed out that the two votes cast for Australia were probably for it.

Syria tried to play down the five votes it received, after postponing its run to 2014, to mere errors. If that was a write in campaign, it wasn't much. Kuwait, Syria's replacement, waltzed in with 166 votes.

The Permanent Representative of the Philippines, another winner with a clear or unopposed slate, acknowledged to Inner City Press that there are human rights issues in his country, such as unsolved killings of journalists. But, he said, the trend line is up.

Later on Friday in the same General Assembly Hall, military bands of China and the US played together. Only at the UN.

As Climate to UN Security Council, Just Words or Coal Mine Sanctions?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 20 -- When Germany assumes the Presidency of the UN Security Council in July, it plans to devote its thematic debate to “the security implications of climate change.”

On Friday the German and Portuguese Missions to the UN held a panel discussion on the topic, during which the Foreign Minister of the Marshall Islands said that putting climate change on the Council's agenda wouldn't lead to “sending peacekeepers to close to coal mines.”

From the floor, the Permanent Representative of the Philippines said that too many issues were being sent to the Security Council: it is being “overloaded,” he said.

One proposal made was for the appointment of a Special Representative of the Secretary General on Climate and Security Response, to report to the Council every six months. But to what end, if the Council didn't then use its coercive powers on the issue, as it does on sanctions, travel bans and the authorization of force?

The Assistant Director General of FAO, Alexander Muller, said that the capital of Nigeria will grow by 400% by 2050. Belynda Petrie of OneWorld linked the xenophobic violence in South Africa to scarcity caused by climate change.

Madelena Lucas, an adviser to the Portuguese government, delated a quote that the fight for resources will shift from oil and gas to food and water. Afterward the Permanent Representative of Cape Verde said that for some small island states, history will end. One hopes not before July and the Security Council debate. Watch this site.

Footnote: a more lively UN event was found across First Avenue in the North Lawn building, where Maori from New Zealand offered greetings with spears and a conch shell. The Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, from which some indigenous representatives have been blocked at governments' requests, soldiers on. More to follow.