Saturday, June 11, 2011

At UN, As Georgia Loses HRC Bid It Blames Russian Lobbying, 5 Votes for Syria

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 20 -- Of the 17 countries running Friday for 15 seats on the UN Human Rights Council, only two were going to lose.

Inner City Press asked the Permanent Representative of Georgia Alexander Lomaia what he felt his chances were, facing off against Romania and the Czech Republic for two Eastern European group seats.

Ambassador Lomaia said, without hesitation, that Russia had been asking countries not to vote for Georgia, that at least two delegations had disclosed this. In many UN fora, Georgia and Russia exchange rights of reply regarding Abkhazia and South Ossetia. This is just one more battle.

After the election, in which Georgia got 89 votes but still lost to Romania's 131 and the Czech Republic's 148, Inner City Press asked a Russian diplomat about the result. He smiled and said, “Oops.”

Nicaraguan representatives said they liked their chances, but they too took a loss, despite receiving 98 votes. Austria pointed out that the two votes cast for Australia were probably for it.

Syria tried to play down the five votes it received, after postponing its run to 2014, to mere errors. If that was a write in campaign, it wasn't much. Kuwait, Syria's replacement, waltzed in with 166 votes.

The Permanent Representative of the Philippines, another winner with a clear or unopposed slate, acknowledged to Inner City Press that there are human rights issues in his country, such as unsolved killings of journalists. But, he said, the trend line is up.

Later on Friday in the same General Assembly Hall, military bands of China and the US played together. Only at the UN.

As Climate to UN Security Council, Just Words or Coal Mine Sanctions?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 20 -- When Germany assumes the Presidency of the UN Security Council in July, it plans to devote its thematic debate to “the security implications of climate change.”

On Friday the German and Portuguese Missions to the UN held a panel discussion on the topic, during which the Foreign Minister of the Marshall Islands said that putting climate change on the Council's agenda wouldn't lead to “sending peacekeepers to close to coal mines.”

From the floor, the Permanent Representative of the Philippines said that too many issues were being sent to the Security Council: it is being “overloaded,” he said.

One proposal made was for the appointment of a Special Representative of the Secretary General on Climate and Security Response, to report to the Council every six months. But to what end, if the Council didn't then use its coercive powers on the issue, as it does on sanctions, travel bans and the authorization of force?

The Assistant Director General of FAO, Alexander Muller, said that the capital of Nigeria will grow by 400% by 2050. Belynda Petrie of OneWorld linked the xenophobic violence in South Africa to scarcity caused by climate change.

Madelena Lucas, an adviser to the Portuguese government, delated a quote that the fight for resources will shift from oil and gas to food and water. Afterward the Permanent Representative of Cape Verde said that for some small island states, history will end. One hopes not before July and the Security Council debate. Watch this site.

Footnote: a more lively UN event was found across First Avenue in the North Lawn building, where Maori from New Zealand offered greetings with spears and a conch shell. The Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, from which some indigenous representatives have been blocked at governments' requests, soldiers on. More to follow.

Amid DSK Case, Theory of Replacing Ban & US Taking IMF, China WB Revived

By Matthew Russell Lee, News Analysis

UNITED NATIONS, May 18 -- The arrest for sex crimes of International Monetary Fund managing director Dominique Strauss Kahn, and his interim replacement by his American deputy John Lipsky, have together revived a story exclusively reported by Inner City Press in 2009.

Then, two senior advisers to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon told Inner City Press of worries that the US would take over the top spot at the IMF and give the World Bank to China, which in turn would not insist that the UN Secretary General term beginning in 2012 go to an Asian.

Under that theory, if Europe lost the IMF -- as seems even more possible now -- and China got a top Bretton Woods institution spot, the Europeans could make a play for the 2012 UN term.

Until Strauss Kahn's arrest, and now US Treasury Secretary Geithner's call that a formal “interim” replacement be named, quite possibly Lipsky, those close to Ban like South Korea's Permanent Representative to the UN were bragging that a second term for Ban was in the bag.

Now, at least until the IMF situation is resolved, Team Ban's 2009 nightmare scenario is suddenly closer to coming into play.

Eastern Europeans candidates were already circling to succeed Ban, albeit in 2016, among them Srgjan Kerim, Jan Kubis and even Navi Pillay's deputy Ivan Simonovic.

Now Western Europeans may renew interest, if Europe loses the IMF. Staffan de Mistura is said by his staff to be interested. But surely there are others. Watch this site.

With Ban's Son-in-Law Leaving UNOPS, Now Said in Line to Lobby UN for IFRC


By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 18 -- When the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's son in law Siddharth Chatterjee in 2009 was given the top Middle East job for the UN Office of Project Services in Copenhagen, issues of nepotism were raised by the Press and angrily denied by Ban's spokesmen at the UN.

In March of this year when Inner City Press asked about Chatterjee leaving UNOPS, where sources described him as ineffective and called “the furniture,” the UN first tried not to answer, then said

“Chatterjee left his position as UNOPS Regional Director for Europe and the Middle East in July 2010 and, after taking accumulated annual leave, went on special leave without pay until 31 May, of this year, 2011. The end of the special leave without pay coincides with the end of his period of secondment to UNOPS from UNICEF.”

Some thought that this leave from the UN system meant an end to nepotism, an end to Chatterjee trading off his connection to the top man in the UN system.

Now, multiple sources tell Chatterjee is lining up to be given the job of “chief diplomatic officer” for the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, overseeing a “New York Delegation to the UN” based at 420 Lexington Avenue.

That is, IFCR is reportedly hiring Ban Ki-moon's son in law to lobby (or engage in “diplomacy” with)... Ban Ki-moon.

Here is the UN's transcript of the March 15 noon briefing:

Inner City Press: I asked a simple question whether the son-in-law of the Secretary-General was still being paid by UNOPS, [United Nations Office for Project Services] as well as whether his educational things may be being paid. Farhan [Haq] said, “Ask UNOPS”. So, I sent them an e-mail, I don’t have an answer, but I also notice that Farhan is listed as the New York Spokesman for UNOPS on their web page. So, I just, I think you may… maybe you have an answer to it and so then all of this is now moot, but, what is the answer?

Spokesperson: It is, Matthew. First of all, UNOPS will probably be sending you the e-mail saying what I am going to say, which is that Mr. [Siddarth] Chatterjee left his position as UNOPS Regional Director for Europe and the Middle East in July 2010 and, after taking accumulated annual leave, went on special leave without pay until 31 May, of this year, 2011. The end of the special leave without pay coincides with the end of his period of secondment to UNOPS from UNICEF. And during his special leave without pay, Mr. Chatterjee does not receive any payments or funding from UNOPS. And for your information, a new Regional Director for Europe and the Middle East joined UNOPS on 4 October 2010. That’s what I have for you, okay.

After that, Inner City Press sent these follow up questions to Haq and Martin Nesirky.

They responded, “please contact UNOPS. The information provided at the briefing today came from UNOPS.”

Inner City Press then sent the follow to UNOPS, still with no response:

Hello. Yesterday I was told to “ask UNOPS” about the S-G's son in law and I emailed Copenhagen questions (although Farhan Haq is listed as New York contact for UNOPS).

I have yet to receive any e-mail response from UNOPS, so I had to ask at the noon briefing, and Mr. Nesirky read out a response, saying he expected I'd get an email from UNOPS. I still haven't, so I emailed Nesirky and Haq, UNOPS New York contact. Now I get a reply to that saying “ask UNOPS.” This seems like a run around: I would like an answer, in writing, today, to the below:

1. You said that Chatterjee is on leave without pay until May 31, 2011, when his secondment from UNICEF runs out. Will be remain in the UN system as a staff member after May 31st?

2. UN staff rule 5.3(a)(i) says that "Special leave may be granted at the request of a staff member holding a fixed-term or a continuing appointment for advanced study or research in the interest of the United Nations, in cases of extended illness, for child care or for other important reasons for such period of time." For what reason did the UN approve leave without pay for Chatterjee?

3. Who made the decision to place Chatterjee on leave without pay?

Watch this site.

Petition on Sri Lanka War Crimes Is Fake Carried Into Empty Building by UN Staffer, Nambiar Stonewalls

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 18 -- On the second anniversary of the bloody end of the conflict in Sri Lanka, outside the UN in New York chants of “UN, UN, Never again” and “Ban Ki-moon, Act Now” echoed off the white metal building where Secretary General Ban's office now is.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if the UN's envoy to Sri Lanka Vijay Nambiar would be willing to answer some questions, about his role in the final stage of the conflict, watching Unmanned Aerial Vehicle footage and telling surrenderees to come out with white flags, whereupon they were killed.

No, Nesirky replied, Nambiar would not be taking questions from the press, even after he spoke to the Security Council the next day.

Out on Dag Hammarskjold Park when Inner City Press went out into the rain after this inter-change to cover the protest, the name of Nambiar came up. Leaders of the demonstration said the UN had promised to at least send an official to meet them inside and accept a petition from them. The UN had asked, they said, that there be no press coverage.

For that reason, Inner City Press did not stand with them in the lobby of the General Assembly as the time for the meeting or encounter came and went. Inner City Press was speaking with another journalist, about another topic, when a staffer of the UN Department of Political Affairs working under Tamrat Samuel belatedly met the Tamil group.

Inner City Press did not interrupt the brief exchange, but did take a picture of the petition being handed over. [Later, the UN requested that even a photograph not be published. Hence this:]

After that, the UN staffer walked not toward the North Lawn building with Ban's office in it, but rather into the General Assembly, toward the entirely closed Secretariat building.

Mystified, Inner City Press followed and watched as the staffer looked behind him, stopped then reversed his steps. He had walked purposefully toward a dead end to give the impression of resolve. But with the Tamils having left the General Assembly building, he walked again the length of the lobby and toward the North Lawn building.

Inner City Press followed him and asked, what will happen with the petition? He shrugged, “can't really say.”

Since some Ban staffers have been telling Inner City Press that Ban would do “something” about the UN Panel of Experts report alleging tens of thousands of civilians killed, Inner City Press asked what to expect. Again, there was no answer.

Inner City Press told him it was Ban or Nambiar, really, who should be answering press questions. This seems undeniable. But Ban has not held a press conference in months, and is heading out of New York again, first to Cote d'Ivoire.

A sign out on Dag Hammaskjold Plaza read, "UN: Libya - yes! Ivory Coast - Yes! Why not Sri Lanka?" Why not indeed. Watch this site.

As UN Welcomes Election Haroun Claims, Council Trip Stalls on Haroun Meeting

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 17, updated -- After Ahmed Haroun, indicted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes in Darfur, declared victory in the recent election in South Kordofan, the UN Mission in Sudan put out a statement “welcoming” the election.

Now in the Security Council, sources tell Inner City Press, there is controversy over what to do if Haroun is at the airport when the Council arrives on its trip later this month.

At least one Council member is pointing at UNMIS' statement as a basis for meeting with Haroun. Others, including an African member, say it would be very “difficult.”

There was a lunch with the Permanent Five members of the Council, South Africa and Nigeria. Gabon was supposed to come but didn't, sources say. US Ambassador Susan Rice invited US envoy Princeton Lyman. While one of the non-Western P-5 say that his country and the US are “on the same page about North - South” issues, the Haroun issue remains a problem.

UNMIS and the UN Secretariat have added to this problem by, at least twice, flying Haroun to Abyei.

In New York on May 16, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky about the allegations by the SPLM in South Sudan that Haroun rigged the election. Nesirky pointed again at the statement, emphasizing that the UN “urges all parties to remain calm, and encourages those with complaints regarding the electoral process to address them through legal means or dialogue.”

On May 17 Inner City Press asked Nesirky, in the context of “legal means,” if the UN had any comment about Khartoum's National Congress Party government retaining two journalists for their coverage of the elections in South Kordofan.

Nesirky merely said the UN is aware of the reports, and that the Mission, UNMIS, is checking into it.

But UNMIS has repeated said it was checking into killings, mostly of Dinka, in Abyei and environs, most times without following up. In fact, UNMIS has at least twice offered free flights to Ahmed Haroun, despite his history of organizing attacks.

Inner City Press also asked Nesirky about a report in Sudanese state media that UNMIS is already moving out of North Sudan, shifting equipment from Kadugli, Port Sudan, El-Obeid and Khartoum down to Juba in the South.

Nesirky responded that any extension of UNMIS' mission is up to the Security Council. But shouldn't the Secretariat be able to confirm or deny movements by the peacekeeping missions it administers?

Update of 7:20 pm -- when UNSC President for May Araud emerged from the Council past 7 pm Tuesday, Inner City Press asked him about Haroun. After a pause, he said sever words: "We are not going to meet him." Watch this site.

As UNSC Eyes Sudan, Martin & Johnson Vie, Vladimir Safronkov Hands Cup to UK's Quarrey

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 16 -- As the UN Security Council prepares to travel to Sudan, albeit not to Darfur, the question arose Monday of who will replace Haile Menkerios atop the UN Mission in Sudan.

Sources tell Inner City Press that at least two current UN officials wants the post: Hilde Johnson of UNICEF, and Ian Martin of the Department of Political Affairs, only recently tapped for post-transition (or post-Gaddafi) Libya.

The question arose at a reception at the Russian Mission to the UN, a farewell to Vladimir K. Safronkov, Russia's political coordinator. It was a good turn out, including among other DPA chief Lynn Pascoe, UK Permanent Representative Mark Lyall Grant and US Deputy Permanent Representative Rosemary DiCarlo.

The ceremonial highlight of the evening was the passing of the torch, or the “cup of dean of P-5 political coordinators,” to David Quarrey of the UK. He joked that he will only hold it for six week, then pass it on to France. From there it will go to China.

At the back, political coordinators from non Permanent Security Council members groused about not being in line for the cup, about Sudan, Libya and Cote d'Ivoire.

One asked Inner City Press, what's up with Alain Le Roy? Well placed UN sources tell Inner City Press he will be replaced, by another Frenchman, who's already been selected. The question, then, is Pascoe, or maybe Angela Kane.

Vladimir, who is returning to Moscow to work on multilateral diplomacy and international organizations, has been well-liked in the UN. Inner City Press can speak highly of him as far away as a tarmac in Goma in the Congo, calming other ambassadors down after their plane was shot, from the inside.

As of Monday evening, the logistics of the Council's upcoming trip were still not set. Le Roy's Department of Peacekeeping Operations is to briefing them on Tuesday afternoon; for now they will land at Kadugli on their way to Abyei. Ahmed Haroun, the ICC indictee who Menkerios has insisted on flying, will not meet with them. And so it goes at the UN. Watch this site.

As IMF Chief Strauss-Kahn Is Arrested, Denials of Rule-breaking Recalled, Immunity & Air France Arrangement Questioned

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- With Dominique Strauss-Kahn of the International Monetary Fund having been detained and then this morning arrested for sexual assault allegedly committed in the Sofitel near Times Square, attention has turned to the IMF's failure to discipline him for what its Executive Board called a “serious lapse of judgment” in 2008.

In this case, IMF spokesman William Murray has been quoted that the IMF “has not immediate comment” on the arrest or charges.

IMF staff, too, have been defensive about Strauss-Kahn and his compliance with rules. Inner City Press covers the IMF as well as the wider United Nations, and on March 17 Inner City Press asked the IMF to respond to what sources described as a pattern in which “DSK gets friends and family hired by IMF affiliates.”

At that time, the IMF answer other of Inner City Press' questions, while ignoring this one. Two weeks later, Inner City Press asked:

Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2011 9:58:14 AM
To: IMF, Media Briefing Center

Again, Please state whether Dominique Strauss Kahn has any relatives working in the World Bank or other UN affiliated organizations, and if so why this does not run afoul of anti nepotism rules and principles? From: Matthew Russell Lee Media Outlet: Inner City Press

This time, the question drew a quick answer, albeit a dismissive one, from Mr. Murray:

From: Murray, William [at] mf.org
Date: Thu, Mar 31, 2011 at 10:22 AM
Subject: FW: Question Received (3/31/2011 9:58:14 AM)
To: Matthew Russell Lee [at] InnerCityPress.com

Matthew,

He has no relatives on the staff of the IMF. Given the premise of your question, let me note that the Bank and UN are wholly separate institutions from the IMF, with no fiscal or managerial connections. At the IMF we certainly have nepotism rules, and they have not been violated in any way.

But does the IMF have rules, that they require not be violated?

It's now reported that Strauss-Kahn “has an arrangement with Air France that allows him to get on any flight and sit in first class.” What kind of arrangement is that? Who paid for it, and how much did they pay? Inner City Press has asked three spokespeople of the IMF, including Mr. Murray. Watch this site.

Footnote: Inner City Press has been asked how, if Strauss-Kahn as an IMF official has a form of immunity, he could be detained, questioned and arrested by the New York Police Department. (The IMF has a history of citing immunity, for example for Paul Ross in Pakistan, click here.)

Earlier this year, Inner City Press (un) covered the case of a French diplomat who was arrested for attempted purchase of cocaine and resisting arrest, but was later allowed to flee the country before trial.

The practice is to allow one such flight - but the person is not supposed to re-enter the United States -- which, in the cocaine case, has in fact happened, which neither the French government nor US State Department have yet explained, click here. Watch this site.

UN's Ban Greeted & Dined with Coup Leader Rajoelina, Says They Didn't Meet

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- As UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was returning from Istanbul and the Least Developed Countries meeting there, Inner City Press asked Ban's acting deputy spokesman Farhan Haq about one of Ban's encounters there with

Inner City Press: Andry Rajoelina, the disputed leader of Madagascar, who is not recognized by the African Union... There is a lot of wonders why the Secretary-General would meet with this… why he was in Istanbul, although that’s not your concern, but did Ban Ki-moon meet with him? If so, why, and can we get a readout of this controversial meeting?

Some hours later, Ban's Spokesperson's Office sent this denial:

From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Wed, May 11, 2011 at 3:47 PM
Subject: Your question on Andry Rajoelina
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

Regarding your question at the noon briefing, I can inform you that the Secretary-General did not meet Andry Rajoelina in Istanbul.

This turns on the meaning of the word “meet.” As Inner City Press asked Ban's lead spokesman Martin Nesirky at the May 12 UN noon briefing, multiple photos exist of Ban shaking hands with and greeting Rajoelina, and sitting at the same table with Rajoelina for a dinner.

After Nesirky said that Inner City Press' question had been answered the previous day, he said that the Istanbul meeting was “multilateral diplomacy,” and that the invitations were made by Turkey's president Gul.

That may explain it -- alongside the greeting and dinner with Ban and Gul, Rajoelina made a deal with Turkey for an expensive dam:

Turkey plans to develop a 300- megawatt hydropower plant in Madagascar, Turkish President Abdullah Gul said. The facility will be built at Mahavola, 150 kilometers (93 miles) west of the capital, Antananarivo, Gul said in a statement e-mailed by Madagascar’s presidency yesterday. Gul met Madagascar’s president, Andry Rajoelina, at a conference in Istanbul yesterday, it said.

Multilateral, indeed. Watch this site.

IMF Has Request from Egypt, Takes Question on South Sudan, Ignores Haiti

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- The International Monetary Fund on Thursday said that Egypt has made a formal request for funds toward its $10 to $12 billion program running to June 2012.

Asked if the Greek government has sought an extension , IMF spokesperson Caroline Atkinson said “I have no news.”

Taking a question from Inner City Press, Ms. Aktinson read out “What is the status of the IMF considering South Sudan for membership, and of its program / trust fund for South Sudan?” She said she didn't have the answer, but would provide one later.

But fully three other questions submitted by Inner City Press she did not even acknowledge, on Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Haiti: “what is the IMF's estimate of how much the introduction of cholera cost the Haitian economy and people?”

That question wasn't acknowledged, despite a recent IMF self-congratulatory announcement about Haiti. Part of the Sri Lanka question was also submitted and not acknowledged two weeks ago.

So how does the IMF choose which questions to answer and acknowledge?

A question was read out from TASS, whether what John Lipsky said about the declining power of the United States is an IMF view.

No, Ms. Atkinson said, that was a projection, not an official position.

A journalist present at the IMF in DC asked what it would mean for the Fund's legitimacy if another European were chosen to replace Dominique Strauss-Kahn. Ms. Atkinson said that DSK is in place and on the job. The reporter folllowed up, But he won't be forever.

“He once suggested he might,” Ms. Atkinson quipped. And somewhere Sarkozy smiled. Watch this site.

At UN, Syria “Postponing its Candidacy” for HRC to 2014, No Dera'a Answers

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- The Asian Group met Wednesday morning in the UN's North Lawn building, with whether Kuwait would replace Syria as its candidate for the Human Rights Council on the agenda. The Press watched through the wide windows of the ECOSOC Chamber as Syria and Kuwait both spoke.

It's done, a Deputy Permanent Representative exiting the Chamber told the Press. All they have to do is gavel it.

But before they did, UN Security moved the press away from the windows, and then from the Chamber as a whole.

When finally the ambassadors emerged, Syria's Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari put the best face on his stand-down. It's just a postponement of our candidacy, he told the press.

Why? To focus on other priorities, he said, not without irony.

Inner City Press asked about Dera'a, and whether the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs will be allowed in to assess needs. But Ja'afari did not answer. His Kuwaiti equivalent said they would take the seat from 2011 to 2013, then Syria will run for 2014 to 2016. We'll see.

UNEP Calderon Presser Allows No Nuclear Power Questions, Germans Everywhere

By Matthew Russell Lee

NEW YORK CITY, May 10 -- When Mexican President Felipe Calderon came to New York days after nationwide demonstrations against his bloody war on drugs, he did not go to the United Nations on Manhattan's East Side, where on Tuesday the Security Council was meeting about protection of civilians.

Rather he came to get an award from the UN Environment Program, and take no questions, at the Museum of Natural History on the West Side. He shared the podium, and UNEP award, with Chinese businessman Zhang Yue, in a ceremony sponsored by South Korean's LG Electronics.

Inner City Press tried to ask Calderon, after the questionless UNEP press conference, about his use of nuclear power, and secondarily of dams.

But there were no answers.

The press was shepherded to the large hall of the museum, where under the lit up replica whale another award winner, Angelique Kidjo, performed with drums, guitar and bass.

Master of ceremonies Don Cheadle was a no-show, replaced by a representative of the MTV music television network.

UNEP chief Achim Steiner chatted with fellow German UN official Franz Baumann. Another German, Under Secretary General Angela Kane, delivered the message of the missing Ban Ki-moon.

It is known that Germany would like UNEP to be replaced by a more powerful agency, tentatively named World Environment Organization or UNEO, and believes the UN systems environmental oversight to be subpar.

But the UN is giving its “premiere” environmental award to a president enamored with nuclear power, sponsored by an electronics company.

On the other hand, Louis Palmer of Solar Taxi fame, with whom Inner City Press previously spoke at the UN two years ago, was on hand to get an “inspiration and action” award. Afterward Inner City Press asked him if President Obama is going enough. “No,” he said, calling the administration a disappointment.

A Swiss correspondent asked Palmer how he would respond to villagers and architects who decry the installation of solar panels. This is a crisis, Palmer answered, not a beauty contest for villages. Hear, hear.

Morocco Goes for 2012 UNSC Seat over Mauritania of AU

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- With the UN Security Council members slated to meet with the African Union later this month in Addis Ababa, there are questions about the African Union's role in the process of selecting the Council's non-permanent members.

Morocco, which largely due to Western Sahara and the African Union position that a referendum with independence must be held there is not an AU member, is a candidate to for a Council seat for 2012 - 2013.

In the African Union, which usually makes recommendations for empty African seats on the Council, Mauritania would be next in line. AU sources have told Inner City Press that the Mauritania may pass up this right, they say, upon the pressure of its neighborhood Morocco.

Inner City Press on Tuesday asked Moroccan Permanent Representative to the UN Loulichki about the situation, including Mauritania being “due” to be the next African Union nominee for the empty seat.

“Every member state has a right to run for the Security Council,” Loulichki replied, adding even more formally that “Morocco is a candidate for 2012 - 2013.”

In apparent reference to coverage by Inner City Press earlier this year of his lobbying of Ban Ki-moon, Loulichki said, quote me on this, making a gesture with his hands. There: we've done it.

During the negotiation of the Security Council's annual Western Sahara resolution, the African Union position that a sentence “without prejudice to the legal status of Western Sahara” should be added was rebuffed by the Council.

The rebuff was particularly stinging given the belief that the absence of this qualification from the draft resolution was a mere oversight by the Group of Friends of Western Sahara -- an oversight they then refused to fix.

If the African Union now “backs down” to Morocco, as one source put it, what would the message be? Watch this site.

Footnote: in Tuesday's debate in the Security Council, Moroccan Permanent Representative Loulichki said without any trace of irony that more resources should be given to UN Peacekeeping missions which have protection of civilians in their mandates -- not, it is clear, referring to the MINURSO mission in Western Sahara.

Meanwhile it is reported that Kuwait will step in to run for the Asia Group seat on the UN Human Rights Council for which Syria had initially been running unopposed. But even if that's true, will Syria be promised some other UN system seat, like Iran was given a seat on the Commission on the Status of Women? We'll see.

After Ban Ki-moon Said Stood Behind UN Rights Rep in Cambodia, His Leaving Draws No Reaction, like ECCC

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 9 -- When UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon visited Cambodia last October, Prime Minister Hun Sen “ordered” him to remove the head of the UN human rights office in Phnom Penh, Christophe Peschoux.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky about it. Nesirky called it an “internal personnel matter,” then added that Ban stands behind the office and, by implication, its staff.

Now six months later, Peschoux has been chased from the country. Human rights groups call it “worrying.” Mr. Peschoux himself has said that in Cambodia

“human rights are tolerated to the extent that they do not challenge the political, economic and financial interests of the ruling elite. That’s where the red line runs. If you cross that line, trouble starts... Of course I’m leaving because it has become impossible for me to continue to operate in this environment.”

Given this, one might have expected Ban Ki-moon to have some follow up comment, if not to have actually defended Mr. Peschoux. But when Inner City Press on May 9 asked Ban's acting deputy spokeman Farhan Haq about Peschoux's leaving Cambodia, Haq said “we do not have any comment at this stage,” nor “any reaction.”

Back on April 12, Inner City Press had asked Haq about Cambodia:

Inner City Press: there is a lot of controversy about the UN-backed Court [Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia] there. Some are saying that the President told Ban Ki-moon that there should be no more prosecutions and that the Court should be wound down. And advocates are saying that the UN hasn’t spoken up in defence of the Court’s mandate. Does the Secretary-General have a view on whether this Court should go on in a non-politicized fashion, or, as many say, should be moving to dismiss future cases beyond those it has?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: The Secretary-General fully supports the work of the Extraordinary Chambers in Cambodia, and he believes that it is up, ultimately, to the senior officials of the Extraordinary Chambers to proceed with their work as they see fit.

Since then, concerns have only grown. Ban Ki-moon and human rights: que pasa? Watch this site.

Ban's Office Admits UN Staffer Traveled to Bahrain, with Roed Larsen, Who Refuses to Comment, Calling It Personal Trip

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 6 -- With the ruling family of Bahrain now sentencing demonstrators to death, the UN in New York is engaged in double-talk at best about it engagement with the government.

On May 6, Inner City Press asked part time UN envoy Terje Roed-Larsen if he took a UN staff person with him on his trip in April to Bahrain. “I do not wish to comment on that,” Roed-Larsen said.

Moments later Inner City Press ask UN acting Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq to confirm or deny that UN staff member Fabrice Aidan accompanied Roed-Larsen on a trip that Haq on April 18 said was not “in any UN capacity.”

Inner City Press had asked this same question on April 29, in connection with publishing a piece about Roed-Larsen “non-UN UN” trip to Bahrain, from which as Inner City Press exclusively reported a previously proposed UN envoy Oscar Fernandez Taranco was blocked, by a call from Saudi Arabia to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon:

“just a yes or no — whether in fact a staff, a UN staffer that works with Mr. Roed-Larsen on resolution 1559 (2004) accompanied him, and if so, if he used a laissez passer and if in fact it was characterized in Bahrain as a UN trip?”

On April 29, Haq's boss Martin Nesirky told Inner City Press, “I do not know the answer to that. So if I have any answer, I’d be happy to give it to you, okay?”

Despite this statement that Inner City Press would be given any answer to this simple question, nothing was provided until on May 6 Haq when questioned again said that yes, Fabrice Aidan did travel to Bahrain.

Inner City Press asked, to make sure, that it was at the same time as Larsen. Yes. How then was this not a UN trip? In fact, it was characterized that way, at a time when it benefits the Bahrain royal family to claim to be on the inside with UN officials.

When Haq was asked by Inner City Press if the UN Secretariat had told Roed-Larsen to make sure this was not construed as a UN trip, Haq would not comment.

This UN allows Roed-Larsen to work part time for the UN, on Resolution 1559, and part time (but for a high salary) as the head of the International Peace Institute.

Well placed sources, of the facts of Fabrice Aidan's travel belated confirmed by the UN, say that Larsen goes to places like Bahrain and allowed the ruling families to portray this as UN support, and received support to IPI, which raises his salary.

We'd like a response to this, but Roed-Larsen “wouldn't like to comment on that.” Watch this site.

On Syria, Larsen told the Press that two countries disagreed whether it is a threat to international peace and security. When this was conveyed to Syrian Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari, Ja'afari said “you know we don't trust him.” Syria is not the only one.

At UNDP, Carlos Slim Praises Competition After $1B Antitrust Fine, As With Bill Gates, UN Likes Monopolists

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 6 -- Fresh off a $1 billion fine for monopolization in Mexico, Carlos Slim Helu appeared Friday with the UN Development Program talking about economic development in Latin America.

Inner City Press asked Slim about the case, and the place of antitrust law and competition in economic development. Slim cut the question off and launched into an underdog story, of having taken on AT&T, MCI / Worldcom, Verizon.

Yes, he acknowledged, there are places where his company comtrols 100% of the market. He said this could be attributed to who had the better and more extensive network.

Many who attended his press conference at UNDP wondered why Carlos Slim would come to the UN at this time. But this is not his first or only connection. Already, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon named him to a climate change advisory panel.

Mexico and climate change seem to together in the eyes of the UN system. As Inner City Press exclusively reported, the Latin American head of state left unnamed by UN Environment Program in the run up to its “Champions of the Environmental” award ceremony on May 10 is president Felipe Calderon Hinojosa.

After Inner City Press fruitlessly asked Slim about the case and $1 billion antitrust fine, a UNDP staff came over and pointed out that Bill Gates was charged with similar monopolization. It occurs that the UN has a thing for monopolists. Inner City Press raised the same questions about Gates, for example when an Under Secretary General's brother held an event at the UN as “Microsoft's Ambassador to Africa.”

Friday's press conference, held in connection with the Fourth Ministerial Forum on Development in Latin America, was supposed to include Viviana Caro, Minister of Development Planning of Bolivia -- but did not.

Alongside Carlos Slim was Angelino Garzón, Vice President of Colombia, who jumped in to say that monopolies must be opposed by governments. One wanted to ask, by $1 billion fines? But the press conference was over.

Serving as moderator was UNDP's chief for Latin America Heraldo Munoz. Before going to UNDP he as Chile's Permanent Representative to the UN, and chaired a UN inquiry into the murder of Benazir Bhutto. When the report was released, he held a press conference, something that has not been done by the more recent UN panels on Sri Lanka war crimes and then cholera in Haiti. And so it goes at the UN.

UN Economists Disagree With IMF & Geithner on China, Bollinger Blind on US Banks

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 5, updated -- While the International Monetary Fund and US officials like Timothy Geithner call for changes in the valuation of China's yuan, the UN on Thursday said that economic problems in the US and countries like it cannot be blamed on China, and defended valuation of currency and capital controls as sovereign rights.

Inner City Press asked UN Deparment of Economic and Social Affairs official Jomo Sundaram about Geithner's and the IMF's charges, and to explain the UN's and IMF's differences on issues ranging from India's economic prospects to the place of capital controls.

Jomo replied that the IMF has been ignoring Article Six of its Articles of Agreement, which he says gives states the right to manage their capital accounts. He said UN bodies like the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, are “closer to governments” that the IMF, which works from Washington.

Certainly, ESCAP chief Noeleen Heyzer has made comments viewed as favorable to the still military dominated government of Myanmar, and Jomo on Thursday tossed seemingly gratuitous praise to Sri Lanka, just after a UN Panel of Experts described 40,000 civilians killed there.

Update of May 7: Jomo Sundaram has written in that "I only mentioned Sri Lanka to make the point that rapid growth in South Asia was not just an India story." Duly noted, although some might also note while it is the IMF's modus operendi to ignore human rights concerns, one expects has historically expected something a bit more nuanced from the UN. But duly noted.

But ESCAP was not able to report much data about the Democratic People's Republic of Korea -- so they are not able to get close to ALL governments.

Also at the UN this week, Columbia University president Lee Bollinger told the press that there needs to be more journalism in China because “we don't know the condition of Chinese banks.” One wanted to ask him, what about the US banks whose dalliance in predatory mortgages led the whole world into economic meltdown? But the question was not taken. So it goes at the UN.