Saturday, June 11, 2011

Report Links UN to Cholera in Haiti, South Asia Strain, Bad Practices, Denials

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 4 -- The much delayed report to the UN on whether it was the proximate cause of the cholera outbreak in Haiti was given to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon earlier this week, and was released by the UN after 5 pm on Wednesday, here.

The report concludes that “the evidence overwhelmingly supports the conclusion that the source of the Haiti cholera outbreak was due to contamination of the Meye Tributary of the Artibonite River with a pathogenic strain of current South Asian type Vibrio cholerae as a result of human activity.”

The report also chides the UN for its sanitation practices, recommending

1) The Haiti cholera outbreak highlights the risk of transmitting cholera during mobilization of population for emergency response. To prevent introduction of cholera into non-endemic countries, United Nations personnel and emergency responders traveling from cholera endemic areas should either receive a prophylactic dose of appropriate antibiotics before departure or be screened with a sensitive method to confirm absence of asymptomatic carriage of Vibrio cholerae, or both.

2) United Nations missions commonly operate in emergencies with concurrent cholera epidemics. All United Nations personnel and emergency responders traveling to emergencies should receive prophylactic antibiotics, be immunized against cholera with currently available oral vaccines, or both, in order to protect their own health and to protect the health of others.

3) To prevent introduction of contamination into the local environment, United Nations installations worldwide should treat fecal waste using on-site systems that inactivate pathogens before disposal.

The report is beginning to be called "shifty," for blaming the UN but also a "confluence of circumstances." Inner City Press back on January 11 asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Nesirky about calls in Haiti for compensation from the UN for cholera.

From the transcript:

Inner City Press: And just one other thing, maybe just for a response…

Spokesperson: Is this about Haiti?

Inner City Press: It is about Haiti. There’s a group there known as SOFA, the Solidarité des Femmes Haïtiennes. They’ve recently, I guess in connection with, or slightly before this one-year anniversary, they’ve said that – I guess, more explosively, they’ve asked the Government to somehow indict the UN for – they say – having brought cholera. But they’ve also raised this issue of compensation – so I wanted to make sure that the two things – can you, they’re saying that the UN should pay some compensation for - for cholera. That’s their claim. They’re a Haitian group, you can – so I guess I just want to know, what’s the UN response to that? Are they aware of that call, and what’s their response?

Spokesman Nesirky [misidentified as “Question” in Transcript] -- As you know, the Secretary-General instituted a panel. Those four experts are working precisely to establish the source of the outbreak of cholera, which has not been established so far. That’s their job to do so, to the extent that they are able to do so, and to report back to the Secretary-General and the Government of Haiti as quickly as they can. And to go the next step beyond that is not really helpful at this point. There is a clear job to do, and that’s the job that the panel has been asked to carry out as swiftly as possible, and in the meantime, of course, the key priority is to help those people – you heard from Mr. [Nigel] Fisher yesterday about the death rates being lower, but still the number of cases being very high. So this is something that needs to be tackled as a priority.

Inner City Press [misidentified as Spokesperson in transcript]: So I understand that the panel comes first. But I just want to know, I mean maybe you can answer this — does the idea, in the abstract, of compensation seem unreasonable to the UN? Depending on what it finds?

Spokesman Nesirky [misidentified as “Question” in Transcript]: Look, I don’t – this is something that – let’s do things step-by-step. And the most important thing is to help those in need. You’ve heard extensively, not just from Mr. Fisher but most recently from Mr. Fisher, on that. And you also know that this — the four panel members, experts each in their own right, are working hard to establish precisely what the source of the outbreak was, if they are able to do so.

And now they have. How will the UN respond?

Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, setting out on a trip to Bulgaria, has said he

"intends to convene a task force within the United Nations system, to study the findings and recommendations made by the Independent Panel of Experts to ensure prompt and appropriate follow-up.... On behalf of the UN family, the Secretary-General reiterates his deepest sympathies to the victims of the epidemic and their loved ones."

Is that enough? Watch this site.

At UN, Ocampo of ICC Hasn't Read Sri Lanka Report, Checking Dual Citizens, Dodging on Harun, NATO & Libya

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 4 -- With International Criminal Court prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo at the UN on Wednesday on Libya, Inner City Press asked him about the UN Panel of Experts report describing tens of thousands of civilians killed in the final stage of the conflict in Sri Lanka.

Ocampo said dismissively that he would not read it. He said he is the prosecutor for 115 ICC member states. Sri Lanka is not a member. Ocampo said that asking him about the Sri Lanka report is like asking a United Kingdom prosecutor about alleged crimes outside his responsibility.

While this level of indifference seems strange for a self-styled proponent of international justice and an end to impunity, Inner City Press asked Ocampo, what about people described in the report who are dual citizens of countries which are members of the ICC, like Palitha Kohona, joint Australian citizen involved in the so-called White Flag killings of surrenderees.

We have received something on that, Ocampo acknowledged, apparenlty referring to the filing that also describes and questions the role of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar. “We are checking that,” Ocampo said. We'll see.

Inner City Press also asked Ocampo about a statement by South Africa in the Security Council, that he should look at NATO as well, if it has gone beyond the Council resolutions.

Ocampo said he would await the report of the Commission of Inquiry on Libya, which heard allegations by the government there. Other journalists followed this one up, but Ocampo went no further.

Ocampo mentioned Ahmed Harun, an ICC indictee for war crimes in Darfur whom the UN flies around in UN helicopters, at least twice. But no question to Ocampo on the UN's actions with Harun were taken at the press conference.

Afterward, Inner City Press asked Ocampo about the UN flying Harun around. “They are debating that in the UN,” Ocampo said. Actually, the UN has repeatedly defended flying Harun to Abyei, even after violence followed his visits.

Now Harun is accused of sending militias to commit murder in the home village of his political opponent in South Kordofan, the deputy governor. Ocampo mentioned a UN rule about only dealing with ICC indictees if absolutely necessary. Then he was gone.

On Sri Lanka, Araud of France Says Accountability Is Up to Locals, Unlike in Libya


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- After the UN belated published its Panel of Experts' report on war crimes in Sri Lanka, Inner City Press asked the French Mission to the UN in writing for a comment on the report and what should happen next.

While the French mission never answered in writing, a spokesman told Inner City Press that a response would take time, and would come from Paris.

But French ambassador Gerard Araud, taking over the UN Security Council presidency for May, brought up Sri Lanka during his beginning of the month press conference. Explaining that the Security Council often chooses not to get involved in bloody conflicts, he referred to 30,000 dead in Sri Lanka, and the Council choosing not to get involved.

During what even the UN called the “bloodbath on the beach” in April and May 2009, Araud's predecessor as Permanent Representative, Jean-Maurice Ripert, was often ambiguous on whether France wanted the Council to consider the conflict, which had regional dimension.

Ripert would refer to Bernard Kouchner traveling to Sri Lanka with “water bladders” and other humanitarian supplies, but never called for a ceasefire. Click here for an Inner City Press piece from that time.

Inner City Press on May 3 asked Araud what France thinks should be done about the UN Panel of Experts report, which Araud himself summarizes as detailining 30,000 killings in Sri Lanka.

Despite Araud having pushed this year to refer for example Libya to the International Criminal Court on a decidedly smaller death count, and has called for the same in former colony Cote d'Ivoire, Araud on May 3 said that investigation is up to the Sri Lankan authorities, as something they should do to “improve the reconciliation process.”

Ironically, the Sri Lankan authorities -- the Rajapaksas -- speak loudly about a Western conspiracy. If one exists, France is not a part of it, at least not in Sri Lanka.

Despite France's rhetoric about the primacy of the protection of civilians, Araud relegated accountability for 30,000 deaths to the sole responsibility of the Sri Lankan authorities, and only because it might improve reconciliation. Perhaps this seeming incongruity will be further explored this month. Watch this site.

On UN Ban's Relief at Killing of Bin Laden, NY Exception to Extrajudicial Execution?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- After Sunday night's announcement of the killing in Pakistan of Osama Bin Laden, on Monday morning in his office at the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said, “I am very much relieved by the news that justice has been done to such a mastermind of international terrorism.”

By the next day, Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky was being asked if by this quote, Ban wasn't embracing what some call an extrajudicial execution. The questioner said that while relief and more might be natural emotions in the United States, should a UN Secretary General be speaking this way?

Ban's spokesman took a strange tack in response, emphasizing that since Ban himself was in New York on September 11, 2001, he “personally” felt relief, a sort of honorary New Yorker.

But the question remains: should a UN Secretary General jump so quickly into expressing relief at the shooting death of anyone, and calling it “justice be[ing] done”?

Inner City Press asked Nesirky when Ban will hold the next of his promised monthly press conferences.

Nesirky replied that Ban held a stake out, a week ago. But that is not a sit down press conference with twenty or so questions.

Ban is heading on another trip, beginning in Bulgaria. Staffers accompanying him have airplane tickets costing over $9,000 a piece. Where is this all leading? Watch this site.

At CFR, Citigroupers Rhodes & Zedillo Won't Answer on Citi's Greek Debt Spin

By Matthew Russell Lee

NEW YORK, May 3 -- Citibank's senior adviser William Rhodes and Citigroup board member Ernesto Zedillo spoke Tuesday as two of three panelists on sovereign debt, with an emphasis on Greece, at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York. Both predicted and promoted debt restructuring.

But when Inner City Press asked them to comment on the Greek government's charges against Citigroup trader Paul Moss, who spread buzz about restructuring just before Easter, and to distinguish their presentations from his, Zedillo cut in.

“The gentleman is retired,” he said, gesturing at Rhodes. “I am a board member of Citigroup and I never comment” on the company, Zedillo said, to some audience laughter.

To Paul Moss and many in Greece, of course, it is not so funny.

Moderator Roger Altman had introduced Rhodes in terms of his 53 years at Citigroup and Zedillo as a member of the board of director of Citigroup and Alcoa. The CFR program listed Rhodes as, currently, a Citigroup “senior adviser.”

If after the charges against Citigroup's Paul Moss for spinning Greek debt restructuring these two are going to refuse to answer questions, some wonder, should they be speaking in this way about... Greek debt restructuring?

Their co-panelist Adam Lerrick, helpfully identified as the chairman of Sovereign Debt Solutions Limited offered as solution that weak banks disappear, either acquired by larger ones or “liquidated” -- he called the difference “a matter of indifference.” He accused the International Monetary Fund of “fudging.”

As Inner City Press reported from last month's Spring Meetings of the IMF and World Bank, the IMF is pitching bank mergers, specifically praising the acquisition of Fortis of Belgium by BNP Paribas.

So what of Greece's Hellenic Postbank and ATEbank? Watch this site.

Footnote: Rhodes repeatedly told the audience, you know what I mean, you worked in this during previous debt restructurings. One questioner identified himself as a “creditors' advocate.” We note that Citigroup in Indonesia is charged with a role in the death of a borrower while being interrogated about his Citi credit card debt. Some advocacy, that...

At UN, as EU Wins Special Rights Over 2 Objections, GA Voting Boards Broken

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- Just before the UN General Assembly meeting on the European Union's resolution to get special rights in the GA, diplomats told Inner City Press that the Caribbean grouping CARICOM had reached agreements and would support the EU.

Click here for Inner City Press' exclusive review last week of the issue.

Some others thought the changes relatively minor: for example, reducing the EU's right of reply to a single turn instead of two. As one Western diplomat put it to Inner City Press, the EU's 27 member states can reply for it, giving in 54 replies.

So there was suddenly hope that the EU resolution would go through on consensus, without a vote. Just outside the GA chamber, Cuba's ambassador talked loudly on his cell phone, mentioning Zimbabwe.

While there were very few journalists covering the meeting, at least two were from Iranian media. They told Inner City Press that “their” Permanent Representative would be speaking. A Western diplomat wondered if Iran might block consensus.

When the meeting began, gaveled to order by Afghanistan's Permanent Representative Tanin, Caricom spoke in favor, as did Nigeria's Permanent Representative on behalf of the African Group.

Zimbabwe spoke to ask to introduce an amendment, but was pushed back in the speaking order, after the Secretariat, which said the change would cost $10,000 for new chairs and audio equipment, but that the money could be found.

Sudan's Permanent Representative spoke for the Arab Group, saying that the EU has agreed to support other groups, specifically the Arab League, to get these rights.

Then Nauru, or a person on behalf of Nauru's Ambassador, launched an impassioned plea against giving rights and powers to non-states. A Western diplomat joked to Inner City Press that Nauru has so few people, something could be arranged for them. But they had a point.

Zimbabwe next made its point: that the Rules of Procedure prohibit observers like the EU from having the right to reply. Exceptions were made for the Holy See and Palestine, but these were distinguished. Zimbabwe called for a vote on its proposed amendment.

As the votes went up on the GA's electronic voting boards, it became clear that the boards were broken. Votes appeared without country names next to them. As best as could be made out, Zimbabwe was joined by Venezuela and Nicaragua and three others, with twenty abstaining including Uganda, Ecuador, Chad, Burundi and Kenya.

Next was the vote on the EU's resolution, up or down. Only Zimbabwe and a country left unidentified by the board voted against. The GA is so broken down that there is no Wi-Fi internet service, only “only 1 megabyte for everyone,” as one diplomat told Inner City Press.

Inner City Press ran to the UN noon briefing and asked who in the Secretariat is in charge of the GA, with its broken voting boards and lack of Internet. “You well know,” said the spokesman for Ban Ki-moon. Yes, we do.

Footnote: it has also become more difficult to cover the General Assembly. Last week, Inner City Press and other journalists were stopped from standing in front of the GA to ask questions. While it has been said that this can be fixed by a new paragraph in the rules, it has yet to happen.

On Tuesday, when Inner City Press took the elevator up from the Security Council's meeting on its May Program of Work, a UN Security officer said there would be no access to the GA press booths “unless accompanied.” This was arranged, but there was no Internet inside, and the voting boards were broken. So it goes at the UN.

Saturday, June 4, 2011

UNDP Now Defers Programs in Yemen & Bahrain, Won't Provide Copies

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 2 -- On Saturday April 30, the UN Development Program announced it was postponing the presentation of its program for Syria to its Executive Board's June meeting, due to the crisis there.

Inner City Press immediately on April 30 asked UNDP, and published a piece questioning, why UNDP was not similarly postponing programs still on the June agenda for Yemen and Bahrain.

Two days later, UNDP has responded to Inner City Press that the programs in Yemen and Bahrain are also being deferred:

From: Sausan Ghosheh [at] undp.org
Date: Mon, May 2, 2011 at 11:50 AM
Subject: RE: Press Qs on deadline re Bahrain, Yemen, etc
To: Matthew Lee [at] InnerCityPress.com

Hi Matthew, As per your questions below:

UNDP reviews content and submission schedules of country programme documents in the context of development priorities in each country. UNDP has taken the decision to defer the submission of its upcoming five year programme documents for Yemen and Bahrain to the Executive Board pending further review. This is to ensure that the new programmes address the evolving development needs of the people of both countries.

Inner City Press had asked for copy of the program documents, which unlike for other countries were not put on the UNDP website. This and other questions remain pending.

But one Inner City Press question, about seeming conflict of interest, was answered. Inner City Press asked:

On Yemen, please state whether former Saleh minister Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa has recused herself from consideration of Yemen programs Please also state, on deadline, whether Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa or any family member would be covered by the immunity deal negotiated between Saleh and the Gulf Cooperation Council Please provide copies of the program documents for Yemen, Bahrain and the Syria documents, on deadline.

And UNDP answered:

UN staff are all international civil servants who act in accordance with the United Nations’ standards and norms. Ms. Amat Al Alim Alsoswa assumed her post as Assistant Secretary General and Director of the Regional Bureau of Arab State in 2006 after leaving her official functions with the Government of Yemen. Ms. Alsoswa is not part of any political discussion or agreement taking place in or on Yemen.

But how does one head up Arab States for UNDP without taking part in discussions on Yemen? Watch this site.

As Alsaidi of Yemen Retires to IPI, Roed-Larsen Bahrain Trip's UN Link?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 29 -- When Abdullah M. Alsaidi announced earlier this year he was resigning as Yemen's Ambassador at the UN, where he had represented President Ali Abdullah Saleh since 2002, it was described as an act of principle, akin to Ibrahim Dabbashi and Shalgam resigning as Libyan diplomats in protest of Gaddafi's crackdown.

But sources well placed on Yemen inform Inner City Press that before his loud “resignation,” Alsaidi was informed by letter that it was time for him to retire. For some time, Alsaidi had been seeking a job with the UN. If he simply retired, he would have to return to Yemen. So he resigned.

Soon thereafter he was hired not by the UN but by the International Peace Institute across the street, which announced on its website that

“Ambassador Alsaidi was the Permanent Representative of Yemen to the United Nations from 2002 until his resignation last week in response to the killing of dozens of demonstrators by pro-government forces in Sanaa... Terje Roed-Larsen, IPI's President, welcomed Ambassador Alsaidi, saying, 'His considerable experience both as a high-level diplomat and as an academic will be a strong asset for IPI in helping the UN and its partners better understand ongoing developments in the Middle East.'”

Some find it particularly appropriate that Alsaidi lands at IPI under Roed-Larsen, who is viewed as an ally of Saudi Arabia, among others.

Recently Roed-Larsen traveled to Bahrain. While the UN has said publicly that Roed-Larsen traveled in his “personal capacity” and not in any connection with his part time post as Under Secretary General and representative on Security Council Resolution 1559, Inner City Press has been told some of the backstory.

Sources say Roed-Larsen asked to travel to Bahrain in a UN capacity, but that the UN said no. He then traveled there, taking one of the UN staffers from his Resolution 1559 post who, sources says, traveled with a UN Laissez Passer. While in Bahrain, Roed-Larsen presented himself as a UN official.

How the UN is served by allowing a person to simultaneously be an Under Secretary General and run a think tank some view as partisan directly across from the UN, and to blur the roles, remains a mystery.

At the UN noon briefing of April 29, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky to confirm or deny that Roed-Larsen took to Bahrain with him a UN staff member using a UN Laissez Passer. Nesirky said he didn't know, and that if he find out he will say. Watch this site.

IMF Ready On Yemen “Once Situation Allows,” Saleh Test Unclear, Watching Syria

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 28 -- With Ali Abdullah Saleh still in power in Yemen, the International Monetary Fund has said it “would be ready to work with the Yemeni authorities including by looking at the means of financial assistance once the situation allows.”

On April 28, Inner City Press asked the IMF's David Hawley to “describe the IMF's interface with Syria and Yemen, and how the crackdowns there may impact that, and how they are viewed by the IMF.”

Hawley said that the IMF's program with Yemen are “on hold in the current situation,” and then referred to comments by IMF Middle East and Central Asia director Masood Ahmed -- who is the one who said, the previous day in Dubai, that the IMF is “ready to work with the Yemeni authorities... once the situation allows.”

Does that mean a reduction in violence -- which could be brought about, at least theoretically, by MORE repression rather than less -- or the exit of Saleh? The IMF didn't say.

The World Bank has pulled staff out of Yemen, Robert Zoellick said in response to Inner City Press' question at the IMF & World Bank Spring Meetings two weeks ago, click here for that.

On Inner City Press' Syria question on April 28, Hawley said that the IMF “like other observers is following the situation closely” and “deplores the loss of life associated with unrest.”

In other answers, Hawley said Egypt has not yet made a proposal for money, despite reports of a $4 billion request. He declined to say if the IMF would consider “going it alone” and arranging its own bailout for Portugal if European participation were blocked by a veto.

Hawley dismissed the possibility of Greek debt restructuring and denied that Dominique Strauss-Kahn is going to Athens for meetings. We'll see.

Foonote: Inner City Press timely submitted another question on April 28 which Hawley neither answered nor even mentioned, and will be writing about it, but is first waiting to see how and if the IMF responds. Watch this site.

On Syria, Security Council Member Tells Lebanon That Open Meeting Wasn't a Good Idea, All Claim Victory

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 27 -- During the public session of the UN Security Council on Syria Wednesday afternoon, a handwritten notes was passed to Lebanon's Ambassador Nawaf Salam which said, as recounted to Inner City Press by its author, “Open meeting was not such a good idea after all.”

Syria, at least publicly, thinks differently. Its Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari told the press after the meeting that a Western attempt to hijack the Security Council's Middle East agenda item had failed.

Inner City Press asked Ja'afari what he estimated the vote count to be in the Security Council. You know the dynamics of the Council, Ja'afari told Inner City Press, if you have the Permanent Five members you can do what you want. He emphasized that Russia and China were with him.

Ja'afari ignored and did not answer Inner City Press' question about Lebanon's position.

But sources in the Council tell Inner City Press that Lebanese Ambassador Nawaf Salam, who later received the above-quoted note, was opposed to the Council issuing any press statement on Syria.

The struggle in Beirut between the Hariris' Future Movement, described by some as supporting the demonstrators in Syria, and those aligned with Hezbollah plays itself out in the positions that Salam takes in New York.

When Inner City Press asked French Ambassador Gerard Araud, usually voluble on Lebanon, what he made of Salam's speech and position during the Council's open meeting, Araud said to “ask Lebanon.”

Communications to Lebanon, as noted, were in writing. And in the UN Security Council things get more surreal, or UNreal, every day.

Footnotes: Araud emphasized to the press France's strategy to hold Assad to account in the UN Human Rights Council -- on which Syria is seeking a seat. The US is opposing Syria's bid, while Ja'afari on Wednesday condemned the US for giving "six million dollars... to Barada TV" based in London. (Ja'afari cited the Washington Post, after saying "don't believe media accounts.") Meanwhile Barada TV says it has an annual budget of only $1 million. We'll have more on all this. Watch this site.

On Sri Lanka, Ban Claims UN Couldn't Assess Casualties, Leak Shows UN Did

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 27 -- On Sri Lanka, UN “staff were not in the position to assess” the number of casualties in 2009, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky told the Press on April 27, as they had to withdraw because the Government said security could not be guaranteed.

But as Inner City Press reported and published on March 27, 2009, a detailed UN document it obtained reported that the "minimum number of documented civilian casualties since 20 January 2009, as of 7 March 2009 in the conflict area of Mullaitivu Region [is] 9,924 casualties including 2,683 deaths and 7,241 injuries.”

Click here for the leaked document, and here for Inner City Press' report which exclusively published it.

Ban's UN refused to confirm its own Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs casualty figures. It now appears, including based on statements by staff who have since left the UN, that Ban's UN consciously decided to withhold and once leaked deny the casualty information it WAS in the position to compile.

Nesirky on April 27, when Inner City Press followed up on questions it put to Ban the previous day, said that this topic and others will now be reviewed by the UN, by Ban and his senior advisers.

Inner City Press asked Nesirky if Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, who was involved in the White Flag killings which appear in the UN report at Paragraph 171, will be one of the senior advisers involved in the review.

“There are many senior advisers,” Nesirky said, adding that the review “will look at the full range of topics contained” in the report.

The question remains: should a senior adviser like Nambiar be allowed to play any role in the review of an incident he was involved in? The answer should have been, and should be, no -- but hasn't been.

Inner City Press asked if this review will be made public. Nesirky would not say, but acknowledged that there is a public interest in it. With 40,000 civilians reportedly killed, yes there is a public interest.

Amazingly, after Ban said he “is advised” that the report's recommendations can only be investigated if the Rajapaksa government consents or members states vote for it in an intergovernmental forum, Ban when he reported on Sri Lanka to the UN Security Council on April 26 did not even ask them to schedule a vote on the recommendation for an investigation of war crimes. We'll have more on this.

At UN, As US Said to Want Fingerpointing at Assad of Syria, Lebanon Between Iran & Hard Place

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 26, updated -- Amid buzz about Syria at the UN Security Council Tuesday afternoon, Syria's Permanent Representative went into the Council, followed by a diplomat from Kim Jong-Il's Democratic People's Republic of Korea.

The draft press statement circulated on Monday, sources tell Inner City Press, only referred to violence in Syria, without naming the government. The US, which is now on the record opposing Syria for the UN Human Rights Council, is said to want more direct finger pointing at the Assad government.

This would make Russian and Chinese opposition all the more certain. Lebanon, too, unlike on Yemen where it wanted a statement, is queasy about criticism of domineering immediate neighbor Syria, and more distant influencer Iran.

Within the UN Secretariat, there is a debate about trying to send an envoy as was done to Yemen. But a similar attempt to send Oscar Fernandez Tarranco of the Department of Political Affairs to Bahrain was shot down. Is Ban, even with this "Good Offices" power, running scared?

When the Security Council let out past 5 pm, Ambassador Cabral of Portugal told the Press that it will be discussed tomorrow. Asked if the statement he introduced can be adopted, he said "I hope so."

Update: Syria's Permanent Representative came and took a dozen questions. Inner City Press asked if Assad would accept an envoy from the UN, as Yemen did. No, he answered, it is too early.

Update of 6:26 pm - When Susan Rice finally took two questions, her spokesman had pre-selected the first, then pulled the plug after the second.

Update of 6:41 pm - the Arab Group met in the Security Council, heard from Lebanon expert. Exiting, a diplomat told Inner City Press that after Lynn Pascoe's briefing Wednesday afternoon on Syria, if there is no agreement on the draft press statement, an open meeting will be requested at which each member will have to make public its position, "so it doesn't die on the vine like the Yemen statement." We'll see.

The reasoning of the US, and its accommodation of Lebanon's position, were not immediately clear: the US Mission to the UN sent a heads-up of Ambassador Susan Rice's press availability to only some in the UN press corps.

The US position was also unclear on the pending Western Sahara resolution. Susan Rice “holds the pen” on that, but her position on the jurisdiction of Moroccan rights bureaucracy over Western Sahara, a major issue for the African Union, is not known. Watch this site.

Colombia's UN Council Month Ends in Music & Middle East Turmoil, Dissing of EU & Caricom, by France & Ban Ki-moon?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 26 -- Throughout Colombia's month as president of the UN Security Council, diplomats have streamed in and out of the Council chamber for small servings of hot or iced coffee in light brown cups emblazoned with the Juan Valdez image.

The Colombian presidency cannot end, some have joked, twitching. But end it must.

Monday night a the Upper East Side townhouse where Permanent Representative Nestor Osorio lives the end of presidency reception was held, complete with lobster and avocado canapes and music featuring indigenous flutes, a Colombian former child television star and reknown classical guitarist Nilko Andreas and his usual soprano partner Angelica de la Riva, who sadly did not sing.

In the second floor's front room, a mixture of Security Council and Latin America group diplomats mingled exchanging tidbits of information, on Council topics ranging from Syria to Western Sahara (click here and here respectively for those stories.)

In the General Assembly the European Union, it seems, is pushing for action in early May on its request for “special rights in the GA,” as one delegate put it.

The Caribbean regional group CARICOM is said to still be opposed. A European Union leader complained to Inner City Press that the EU doesn't know “what bothers Caricom.” Another developing world diplomat, from Asia, seemed to know: the EU's request to have its representatives including Catherine Ashton speak before member states in the GA. Ah, protocol.

“Caricom's been hard to reach,” the Asian diplomat conceded. “They've been traveling, and they are small delegations to begin with.”

Another Caricom issue, or exclusion, was raised regarding Haiti. To replace current UN envoy Edmond Mulet, a diplomat from Caricom was in the running but rejected. One of the Ambassadors most involved asked Inner City Press, does it have to ONLY be a Latin American?

That is what Osorio has said. Monday night he was gracious, greeting Ambassadors as they came up to the second story, among them the Permanent Representatives of Turkey, Japan, South Africa, Nigeria, Mexico, Venezuela and Morocco. There was a representative of Palestine, but not Polisario.

From the UN Secretariat's Department of Political Affairs, Lynn Pascoe and new Security Council Affairs chief Mosves Abelian were seen there, but neither Secretary General Ban Ki-moon nor his advisors Vijay Nambiar or Kim Won-soo. Ban and Kim, to be fair, were earlier attending a malaria event in the GA entrance.

China's Li Baodong appeared to be the only Permanent Representative of the Permanent Five Security Council members in attendance.

From the “host country” the US, Numbers Two and Three were there -- Susan Rice, not present, nevertheless e-mailed out two statements, one on malaria and another on Sri Lanka which unlike many of the diplomats queried on the topic by Inner City Press at the reception did not expresss surprise at Ban Ki-moon's cover letter saying he “is advised” that he cannot order any investigation without the consent of Sri Lanka or a vote by member states.

Click here for Sri Lanka story and report, here for podcast done Monday night after the Colombian reception.

Russia's new jovial Deputy Permanent Representative was there; another diplomat recounted that he served in Burkina Faso when it was still Upper Volta.

Talk turned to Djibril Bassole, the mediator of teh Darfur process in Doha, returning on an emergency basis to become the Burkinabe foreign minister, something on which Inner City Press has asked the Secretariat and on which we'll have more.

The UK's Deputy and spokesman were there, but France's did not appear to be, despite France taking up the Council presidency in May. Ironically earlier on Monday in the Secretariat, French Permanent Representative Gerard Araud had met with Ban on just this topic. That is, unlike some other P-5 Perm Rep, both here in New York, but not at Osorio's. Mais c'est gauche, one frag quipped in a fragment. Watch this site.

Literal Footnote redux: to update our April 6 note about the Colombian Mission's intrepid spokeswoman's foot having been run over that a Turkish diplomatic car, she was up and about and greeting Monday night, joking to Inner City Press that she is going to send the medical bill... to Turkey.

As UN Releases Sri Lanka Report, Ban Says He Can't Investigate w/o Consent or Vote


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 25, updated with link -- After close of business on April 25, the UN belatedly released -- and immediately undermined the recommendations of -- its Panel of Experts report on war crimes in Sri Lanka, eleven days after the UN told Sri Lankan Deputy Permanent Representative Shavendra Silva it would be released in 36 hours.

The Report was released along with a page and a half cover letter by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, which in pertinent part states that

“In regard to the recommendation that he establish an international investigation mechanism, the Secretary-General is advised that this will require host country consent or a decision from Member States through an appropriate intergovernmental forum.”

Ban "is advised" by whom? This is a huge letdown, and some say abdication. We will have more on this.

Click here to view UN-released report.

Inner City Press, which obtained and quickly up online Monday morning a leaked copy of the report, asked Silva about the report and its delayed release late Monday afternoon in front of the UN Security Council, which Silva visited for more than a half hour.

Silva said he'd seen the publication on Inner City Press, as well as the day's UN noon briefing, at which questions about the involvement of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar were left unanswered.

Silva is quoted in the Panel's report, as well as his role in the 58th Battalion, which moved in on the so-called No Fire Zones. He was polite but non committal.

Ban's undermining of the Report's recommendation must make him, and the Rajapaksa and certain others, relieved.

Ban's spokesperson's office has refused to answer questions about Nambiar, not only in the briefing but also in writing. On Monday before the release of the Report by the UN, Inner City Press asked some factual questions, militating for a press conference by the Panel members and Mr. Nambiar:

Paragraph 171 states that “Defence Secretary Basil Rajapaksa provided assurances that their surrender would be accepted... following a particular route indicated by Basil Rajapaksa.”

Factual questions: since Gotabaya Rajapaksa was and is the Defense Secretary, is this just a typo?

Who is the Panel saying indicated the route: Basil or Gotabya Rajapaksa?

And when specifically did the OSSG know about the Feb 22 meeting between Mohan Peiris and the Panel, as set forth in Annex 2 of the Report?

Also please state the role of Mr. Nambiar in reviewing the report, please disclose how much was spent by the UN in preparing the report, please state whether the Panel or any member traveled to Sri Lanka and if not, why not, and please deny or confirm and describe any meeting by any Sri Lanka government official since the Panel's work began.

None of these questions have been answered. Watch this site.

Sri Lanka Report Held by UN's Ban & Nambiar Partially Describes White Flag Killings Nambiar Involved In: Conflicts

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 24 -- With the UN still withholding its Panel of Experts' report on war crimes in Sri Lanka, The Island in its ninth day of publishing portions of the reported that were leaked, presumptively by the government of Mahinda Rajapaksa, has run the “'White Flag' incident” section (see below).

This section raises questions about UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon not having required the recusal of his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, who was involved in the incident -- about the the Panel of Experts itself.

The Panel's report as leaked to The Island describes part of the White Flag killings and lists by name the involvement of Mahinda Rajapaksa, his brothers Gotabaya and Basil and Permanent Representative to the UN Palitha Kohona, against whom a filing has been made to the International Criminal Court for his involvement in the presumptive war crime.

As partially described by the UN Panel of Experts, “Nadesan and Pulidevan, and possibly Colonel Ramesh” conveyed a request to surrender to an “official[] of the UN” and received assurances they would not be killed through “intermediaries.” They were then killed.

While the Panel's reports, troublingly, does not disclose the involvement of Vijay Nambiar, instead referring only to a UN intermediary as having conveyed assurances that those surrendering would not be killed, Nambiar has acknowledged being involved.

Inner City Press, which visiting Sri Lanka covering Ban's trip in May 2009, has followed this issue closely, repeatedly asking for a statement by Mr. Nambiar describing his role. Inner City Press was directed to a single filmed interview Nambiar gave, in which he acknowledged a role

The Panel of Experts, named and essentially paid by the UN of Ban Ki-moon, was remiss in not naming Nambiar. Given how and by whom the Panel's members were named and paid, and their final work product, there was a conflict of interest.

Ban Ki-moon, many now conclude, has been remiss in allowing Nambiar to remain involved in handling the report, even inreviewing it for what the UN should do next. It is a blatant conflict of interest.

Following numerous previous inquiries by Inner City Press into this, including Palitha Kohona heatedly disputing the account that Nambiar gave, on April 12 and 19 Inner City Press again asked Ban's deputy spokesman Farhan Haq if Nambiar would be involved or recused.

Haq, who previously denied the existence of the filing with the ICC which details Nambiar's role in the White Flag killings, said that Nambiar is a senior advisor and was involved in reviewing the report.

Other leaked portions describe Nambiar interfacing about the review with Kohona and his Deputy, General Shavendra Silva, also reportedly involved in war crimes at the end of the conflict.

Still other leaked portions allude to a February 22 meeting, which Ban's lead spokesman Martin Nesirky in essence denied to Inner City Press took place, between the Panel of Experts and Sri Lankan Attorney General Mohan Peiris, in the office of another of Ban's advisers, Lynn Pascoe.

Late arriving on the scene, in Sri Lankan press accounts, is Ban's deputy chief of staff Kim Won-soo, perhaps in belated acknowledgment that Nambiar should never have been allowed to be involved in the report, which partially describes the White Flag killings in which he was involved.

Now it is said that Ban will take a call from Minister G.L. Peiris. Even if the report is released on April 25, along with a UN response in which Vijay Nambiar has clearly been involved, it is too late, and poisoned by the conflicted involved of Nambiar. This is all a new low for this UN. Watch this site.

From the leaked Panel of Experts report:

The "White Flag" incident

170. Various reports have alleged that the political leadership of the LTTE and their dependents were executed when they surrendered to the SLA. In the very final days of the war, the head of the LTTE political wing, Nadesan, and the head of the Tiger Peace Secretariat Pulidevan, were in regular communication with various interlocutors to negotiate surrender. They were reportedly with a group of around 300 civilians. The LTTE political leadership was initially reluctant to agree to an unconditional surrender, but as the SLA closed in on the group in their final hideout, Nadesan and Pulidevan, and possibly Colonel Ramesh, were prepared to surrender unconditionally. This intention was communicated to officials of the United Nations and of the Governments of Norway, the United Kingdom and the United States, as well as to representatives of the ICRC and others. It was also conveyed through intermediaries to Mahinda, Gotabaya and Basil Rajapaksa, former Foreign Secretary Palitha Kohona and senior officers in the SLA.

171. Both President Rajapaksa and Defence Secretary Basil Rajapaksa provided assurances that their surrender would be accepted. These were conveyed by intermediaries to the LTTE leaders, who were advised to raise a white flag and walk slowly towards the army, following a particular route indicated by Basil Rajapaksa. Requests by the LTTE for a third party to be present at the point of surrender were not granted. Around 6.30 a.m. on 18 May 2009. Nadesan and Pulidevan left their hide-out to walk towards the area held by the 58th Division, accompanied by a large group, including their families. Colonel Ramesh followed behind them, with another group. Shortly afterwards, the BBC and other television stations reported that Nadesan and Pulidevan had been shot dead. Subsequently, the Government gave several different accounts of the incident. While there is little information on the circumstances of their death, the Panel believes that the LTTE leadership intended to surrender.

On the morning of April 21, Inner City Press asked Ban's top two spokesmen to "please state the role of Mr. Nambiar in reviewing the report." No response has yet been received, more than 60 hours later. We will have more on this. Watch this site.

On Sri Lanka, After Russia Bashes UN Report, Ban Withholds It, Asks Medvedev to Support Him for Second Term as S-G

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 22 -- Shortly after reneging on his Spokesperson's Office repeated commitments that the UN Panel of Experts' report on Sri Lanka war crimes would be released “this week,” UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon told Russian leader Dmitry Medvedev, "I'd like to really count on your strong support, leadership and guidance in continuing my work as secretary-general.”

In Colombo, Russia's Ambassador Valdimir P.Mikhaylov had the previous day appeared at a press conference with Defense chief and presidential brother Gotabaya Rajapaksa and said "unfortunately it seems that the panel of experts went beyond its task, at least as it had been made known to our representatives of New York... we speak not about a 'UN report', since it was prepared neither by a UN body or nor even by its request. It was just a personal initiative of the UN Secretary General.”

In this context, for Ban to ask Russia in this way and at this time not to veto the second term he wants seems to many to telegraph that while the report may inevitably be released, Ban will not take serious action on it.

As leaked to The Island newspaper, presumptively by the government, the report urges Ban to himself investigate the UN's own compliance with international humanitarian law.

Ban's own chief of staff Vijay Nambiar was involved in the so called white flag killings of surrenderees, as described in a filing with the International Criminal Court.

As such, Nambiar is at a minimum a witness, perhaps a person of interest, in a violation of international humanitarian law.

But Ban has allowed Nambiar to be involved since then in the work on the Panel of Experts, including handing the report to General Shavendra Silva, reviewing the reports and, it seems, deciding not to release it when promised.

On the morning of April 21, Inner City Press asked Ban's top two spokesmen to "
please state the role of Mr. Nambiar in reviewing the report." No response has yet been received, more than 24 hours later. We will have more on this. Watch this site.