Saturday, May 14, 2011

At UN, As Libyan Resolution 1973 Passes With Five Abstentions, Half Answers by Lebanon & Dabbashi, Rice Chats with Sudan


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 17 -- The Libya resolution passed the UN Security Council Thursday evening with ten votes in favor and five abstaining: Russia, China, Brazil, Germany and India.

Russia said that its ceasefire proposal had the support of “a number of (Council) members,” and that its questions on the resolution just adopted remained unanswered. What are the limits of the use of force? He said if things go badly, it will be the responsibility of those who use force.

Brazil's Permanent Representative said her country is sensitive to the call of the Arab League for a no fly zone, but that the resolution in Paragraph 4 went beyond it.

Germany's Permanent Representative Wittig also said that military force carries risks that have been under estimated.

India through its Deputy Permanent Representative criticized the whole resolution, saying the Council should have waited for the report of Ban Ki-moon's envoy Al Khatib, and that sanctions may hurt the Libyan people.

After the vote, Inner City Press asked Libyan diplomat Ibrahim Dabbashi to respond to India's statement about the sanctions hurting Libyans. Dabbashi's response was only that the resolution does not allow foreign occupation.

Inner City Press asked Dabbashi about the possibility at some point of UN peacekeeping mission. No, Dabbashi that, not that. He said it's the Libyan people against Gadhafi.

Lebanon's Permanent Representative took questions, and Inner City Press asked him about the critique of some of the abstainers that the resolution went beyond what the Arab League has asked for. He replied that the Arab League only spoke about a no fly zone. Exactly.

Susan Rice took a few questions then it was “last question.” Since she had said Gadhafi had lost legitimacy by attacking his own people, Inner City Press asked, “What about Bahrain... and the crackdowns there?” These have included attacks on hospitals, blatant violations of international law. But Susn Rice was gone.

Footnote: Before she spoke at the stakeout, Susan Rice was speaking with a Sudanese diplomat from Khartoum. Inner City Press is seeking the US read out on the communication, and what the US is going to do, especially at the UN, about the stand off between SPLM and Khartoum on the reports of Khartoum aiding the two renegade generals in and around South Sudan, and on the crackdown on student protesters in Darfur that even UNAMID reported on earlier today. Watch this site.

On Haitian Rubble, UN Ban's Estimate Is Amended Overnight, Downplaying Cholera

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 17, updated -- Bragging to Central American leaders about the UN's performance in post-earthquake Haiti on March 16, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said that “by the end of this year we expect roughly half the rubble is being reused, recycled or disposed of an an increasing rate.”

At least this is what Ban's spokesperson's office e-mailed out to the Press at 6:56 pm on March 16.

Eight hours later at 3:10 am on March 17, Ban's office sent a new version of his Guatemala City remarks, this time portraying Ban has having said only that “The rubble is being reused, recycled or disposed of at an increasing rate.”

Did Ban's expectation for “roughly half the rubble” change overnight? The new version was labeled “amended,” as if Ban and his remarks were a Constitution or draft resolution such as the one on Libya Ban was missing during his Central American foray.

Earlier on March 16, Inner City Press had asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky for the UN's response to criticism published that day in The Lancet, saying that the UN had under-estimated Haitian cases of cholera by nearly 100%.

Both are just estimates, Nesirky replied reading from notes. So what was wrong about the estimate about “roughly half the rubble” that Ban reportedly said in Guatemala City? Watch this site.

Update: on the UN's panel on cholera in Haiti, and its causes, Inner City Press on March 16 asked Nesirky when the report will finally be ready, and if it will be public. Late March or early April, he said, and yes. We'll see.

Ban in another foray this year, to Los Angeles, did a "Facebook townhall meeting" about Haiti with the band Linkin Park in which cholera in Haiti and its causes were barely discussed.

In a recent interview, Mike Shinoda of Linkin Park explained the session: "we got an email from the UN. They were asking if we wanted to do a meeting wiht the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon."

With Libya on fire, and Haiti under-estimated, who is Ban e-mailing now?

Update of March 18: When Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky to explain the amended transcript and, separately, the state the UN's expectation of when 50% of the rubble would be addressed, Nesirky said he would deal with this outside of the briefing room. After that, and not receiving an answer from Nesirky by email or otherwise for 24 hours, Inner City Press asked again at the March 18 noon briefing.

Nesirky said it was an error by his office. When Inner City Press asked, without regard to the unamended or pre-amendment Ban statement, when the UN expects half the rubble to be addressed, Nesirky repeated that the first statement was an error by his office. But what is the UN's expectation? Watch this site.

On Libya, Rice Explains Rejection of Russian Ceasefire Proposal, Blame Game On

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 16 -- On Libya, Russia offered a ceasefire resolution and offered “Chapter Seven” of the UN Charter, Russian Ambassador Vitaly Churkin told the Press on Wednesday evening when the UN Security Council meeting ended.

Asked why other Council members did not all agree to the ceasefire proposal, Churkin told the Press that Russia does not describe other countries' positions, and to ask them.

Inner City Press asked US Ambassador Susan Rice to explain opposition to Russia's ceasefire proposal. She said that there was a need for enforcement action, and that a call to end violence was already in the Council's previous Resolution 1970 on Libya.

A Western spokesperson emerged and told the Press that since this earlier Council call for a cessation of violence had no effect, the Russian ceasefire resolution would have sent the wrong signal.

Asked if the US now supports a no fly zone, Rice said the US is looking at a package that includes a no fly zone but goes beyond it.

Rice did not list Arab countries which have offered to enforce a no fly zone. Ibrahim Dabbashi, the diplomat for Libya but not Gadhafi, said there are five such countries.

Inner City Press has heard of four: Jordan, Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Qatar, whose Permanent Representative and presumptive next President of the UN General Assembly came to visit the Council consultations on Wednesday, accompanied by a bodyguard.

Accused of filibustering, Churkin denied it, saying this is not the US Senate or House of Representatives.

Susan Rice, when asked if Churkin was filabustering to give Gadhafi more time answered, “What do you think?”

To some the proceedings have the aura of a blame game. Russia can now argue that it is not obstructionist, it offered a ceasefire resolution which was rejected.

The US can explain what many saw as its indecisiveness about calling for a no fly zone by saying that it wants MORE than a no fly zone.

And if Russia somehow blocks such a proposal -- the deployment of a veto seems unlikely -- the US could blame Russia for being obstructionist.

In the background, countries like India and even Germany have expressed reservations or questions about a no fly zone.

For now, Council members' experts will convene Thursday at 9 am, the Permanent Representative at 11 am. But what will happen in the next 13 hours in Libya? Watch this site.

UN General Assembly Fails to Oversee Ban Ki-Moondoggle & Mercenary Deals

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 16 -- General Assembly President Joseph Deiss has staked a claim for global governance by the UN, which he calls the “G-192” to distinguish it from the G-20 club of large and rich nations.

But in his term so far, he allowed the already marginal General Assembly to be circumvented even by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, on matters ranging from the budget to the UN's relations with corporations.

Earlier this month in the GA's budget committee, a complaint was lodged that by adding money and time to the UN Capital Master Plan, in this case $100 million in US Tax Equalization Funds, Ban Ki-moon had violated a General Assembly resolution requiring that the GA be told and approval any such change in scope to the CMP.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman about the criticism to what is now being called the “Ban Ki-moondoggle” and was told to ask CMP chief Michael Adlerstein. But Adlerstein when asked said to ask the member states.

On March 16, Inner City Press asked Deiss and GA spokesman Jean Victor Nkolo if Deiss agrees with the Group of 77 that Ban violated a GA resolution in changing the budget and time table of the CMP without GA input.

That's up to the committee, Nkolo said. What then is the role of the President of the GA when the GA roles is being ignored?

Similarly, Inner City Press asked Nkolo about a UN Joint Inspection Unit report this year that the General Assembly should assert oversight power on the UN Global Compact, an initiative started by Kofi Annan that under Ban Ki-moon has put a convicted fraudster, from South Korea, on its board of directors, and most recently granted UNGC membership to a private military contractor, G4S, under fire for involvement in Israeli run prisons in the Occupid Palestinian Territories.

Nkolo said the Global Compact is a unit of the Secretariat -- exactly what the UN JIU was criticizing and asking the GA to change -- and that he would see what committee deals with the UN Global Compact. No GA commitee does: that's just the point that the JIU should be changed.

Meanwhile, neither Ban's spokesman nor the Global Compact has yet answered Inner City Press' questions about the mercenary firm G4S's membership in the UNGC, 24 hours after the questions were posed.

Finally on March 16, Inner City Press asked Nkolo if Deiss believes that meeting of the committee on revitalization of the GA, at which greater media access was called for, should remain closed to the public. Inner City Press went into the committee's meeting this week and quoted and analyzed a few statements by Japan and Peru in Twitter posts.

Then US Deputy Permanent Representative Rosemary DiCarlo came up and said that the meeting was closed to the press. A GA staffer later confirmed this. Deiss has said he is for openness. We'll see.

With PJ Crowley Out For Speaking, US Mission Silent on Darfur & UN Corruption

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 13, updated -- The ouster from the State Department of spokesman PJ Crowley for calling the Defense Department's treatment of accused Wikileaker Bradley Manning “counterproductive and stupid” was not unexpected.

But viewed from the UN, it looks particularly stupid and counterproductive.

Crowley's too infrequent visits to the US Mission to the UN's new briefing room were bursts of news and on-the-record quotes that differed from the usual silence from USUN.

In September 2010 during the UN General Debate, Crowley led a press conference including Samantha Power, and took questions from a range of media. During the session, Inner City Press got an on the record response about Sudan, and later from Crowley an answer on Myanmar he couldn't give the first time around.

By contrast, the US Mission to the UN rarely holds press briefings or even informal stakeouts in front of the Security Council. While the previous US Mission spokesman routinely briefed journalists before Council meetings, the US is now noticeably absent from such session. A non permanent member, India, holds month dinner press briefings by its Ambassador, unlike US Perm Rep Susan Rice.

It is not just about face time. Ten days ago, Inner City Press e-mailed the three top USUN spokespeople a simple request for the US position on the UN in Sudan providing free flights to Ahmed Haroun, indicted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes in Darfur.

After four days of silence from the US Mission -- during which time the UK Mission to the UN, for example, submitted a response -- Inner City Press reminded lead USUN spokesman Mark Kornblau of the questions, now including one about violence in Sudan's contested Abyei region. I just got back, he quipped, I'm going to pretend I didn't get your e-mail.

Still having no response, Inner City Press asked an associate spokesperson who is now leaving the Mission. She said that an answer would be forthcoming. But still, none has been.

Perhaps the blame runs higher, in that Susan Rice despite her public statements about Darfur has had little to say on the topic of late. Rice is loath to criticize any action by the UN, including the UN Mission in Sudan flying an indicted war criminal around.

Under Rice, USUN has had little to nothing to say about improving UN management, remaining silent for example on the UN's recently exposed mishandling a contract with PriceWaterhouseCoopers.

Perhaps the silence comes from the Secretary herself, Hillary Clinton, who POLITICO said never left Crowley crack her inner circle of Philippe Reines and counsel Cheryl Mills.

Here's hoping that Crowley's replacement Mike Hammer brings better performance, or at least more civility, to the US Mission to the UN. Second and third changes are usually the American way. But from here, it looks like the wrong person had to leave, and for the wrong reasons.

At UN, As Ban Ki-moon Promotes Indian Ambassador's Wife, Are Rules Needed on Lobbying for 2d Term?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 13, updated -- A UN Secretary General asks for the support of UN member states, not only to endorse his programs but also, as is the case these days with Ban Ki-moon, to vote for a second term. Should there be rules governing how he goes about lobbying for this support?

On March 11, Ban's deputy spokesman Farhan Haq announced that Ban has appointed Lakshmi Puri as an Assistant Secretary General in the new UN Women entity.

Haq dismissed the question of if Ms. Puri is the wife of Hardeep Singh Puri, the Permanent Representative of India, currently a member of the Security Council which must vote on Ban getting, or not getting, a second term as Secretary General.

Haq said, "I am not aware of the family relationships of the people I just named. I only just got this list." [See update below for Haq's March 14 statement.]

On March 12, Inner City Press wrote directly to Ambassador Hardeep Singh Puri to ask for confirmation, and ask for a “response to those that say it might have or appear to have any impact on how the Secretary General is viewed or treated, especially but not only as he goes for a second term.”

On March 13, Hardeep Puri called Inner City Press and presented his side. He said that he and Lakshmi have been married for some 35 years, adding that “my being here and her being there has not made any difference in terms of one influencing the other... She was in Geneva with UNCTAD... Then here in New York as director of High Representative on Least Developed Countries, since October or November of 2009. She applies for jobs as do several others in the UN system.”

Inner City Press asked Hardeep Puri if he thought that any rules should apply to the Secretary General giving jobs to spouses of the Permanent Representative who will vote on his second term.

Hardeep Puri to his credit acknowledged that if a person “completely from the outside, without the qualification, were offered the job... in this kind of situation, obviously eyebrows would be raised.”

Rightly or wrongly, in this case some eyebrows have been raised. One analogy is to a public corporation, in which it would be problematic for a chief executive to give a job to the spouse of a board member who is supposed to oversee his performance and continued employment.

Hardeep Puri issued a challenge, telling Inner City Press to watch “if you suddenly find Hardeep Puri restrained.” We will.

The question remains, should the UN enact rules to govern this situation which is fraught with the possibility of conflict of interest?

Footnote: after this response, Hardeep Puri called back to make two final arguments, first that it was Michele Bachelet that interviewed Lakshmi Puri, and not Mr. Ban himself. In fact, this was pointed out in spokesman Farhan Haq's announcement, perhaps acknowledging that if Ban himself did the interviews and was entirely responsible, there would be an issue. But Ban is the decision maker here, and the issue remains.

Second, Hardeep Puri argued that a country's position would not be influenced by such a hire. But it is widely reported that France conditioned its support of Kofi Annan second term as Secretary General on being given the Under Secretary General for Peacekeeping post. So the danger of conflict of interest and improper lobby remains. There should be rules.

Update of March 14: While on March 11 the UN's Haq said "I am not aware of the family relationships of the people I just named," when Inner City Press asked again on March 14 if the Secretariat was claiming it hadn't known of the spousal relationship, Haq said "I don't believe that is regarded as a relevant criteria," then sought for a question from any other journalist. Video here, from Minute 10:44.

Later on March 14, even an official close to Ban said these concerns existed and were expressed internally, and that Haq and the UN should have had an acknowledgement and answer. Watch this site.

At UN, Attacks on Labor Extend to Elevator Operators, Security, Tradespeople

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 13 -- Beyond the anti labor moves the UN has deployed on its UN TV and other engineers, now the elevator operators at the UN are under fire.

In the week since Inner City Press wrote about moves under Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to stop collecting dues for the UN Staff Union, and to more slowly pay lower level staff, the UN hasn't answered but other workers have stepped forward.

The elevator operators face cut backs; the Trades and Crafts staff are threatened with downgrade to General Service. UN Security officers see this impacting them, although senior UN official Franz Baumann denies or distances himself from it.

But the pattern is unmistakeable: under Ban Ki-moon, the UN is eroding labor and collective bargaining rights. The UN TV and engineers jobs have been advertised, at G-7 posts. And under Ban, payments for injury in the line of duty at the UN in New York have reportedly been decreased by 42%. Will the outside union working on the Capital Master Plan respond?

On Friday the UN Dispute Tribunal shot down the attempt to stop collecting union dues. Click here to see the decision. But still the UN Controller Jun Yamasaki wants to dictate where the funds are deposited.

On March 7, after writing a first round up on Ban's anti labor moves, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky for a response:

Inner City Press: I wanted to ask you about a couple of labour issues that seem to have arisen. One is the Union, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, that represents the UNTV, UN Radio and Conference Services people, put out a press release over the weekend complaining of how they… complaining that their labour rights are being destroyed. I know that the Staff Union here has said that the UN no longer collects dues for it and essentially seems not to recognize it as a union. And the G-level staff have submitted a petition — maybe you could confirm that — to the Secretary-General about changing the ways in which they are paid and saying this violates their rights. What’s… is it… what would you say to those who say they see a trend of kind of anti-labour actions by the Secretary-General and on each…? Can you confirm the receipt of the petition, and will there be a response to complaint of these IBEW workers that they have now made public?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I really don’t agree with the notion that there is some kind of trend here. On the other specific questions you have asked, if I have further details, then I would get back to you.

But no response has been forthcoming. We have to go back some time to a written response from earlier this year, to just one of the issues, from UN official Franz Baumann:

Subject: Re: Three Press questions
From: Franz Baumann [at] un.org
To: Matthew R. Lee [at] InnerCityPress.com

Dear Matthew, Thanks, as usual, for checking... On the Publishing staff: I can confirm that DGACM has requested OHRM to convert to the General Service (GS) category all Trades and Crafts (TC) category posts and staff in DGACM. This, incidentally, is not at all a downgrading, and our request emphasized that the conversion is to be done in a cost-neutral fashion and that the emoluments of the staff should be what they are now. Converting the TC staff makes them more marketable.

The reason for this request is that technological advances – the replacement of traditional offset printing by digital, high speed photocopiers and much reduced print-runs - obviates the need for licensed tradesmen since digital equipment can be operated by GS category staff. And by considerably fewer. So, when switching from steam to electric trains, what to do with those who have shovelled the coal? A compassionate employer converts them so that they can find useful & satisfying employment.

In reality, the TC category has long been obsolete in the Publishing Section. Of the currently 70 or so TC staff, less than a quarter came with licences. It is worth noting also that the staff at the three other DGACM conference-servicing duty stations, UNOG (Geneva), UNOV (Vienna) and UNON (Nairobi), who work in similar printing facilities, are – and always have been - in the GS category.

While Baumann says he has nothing to do with UN Security staff, the same argument is being made, that outside of New York, UN Security are General Service staff. But under Ban, payments for injury in the line of duty -- taking a bullet, as one argues -- at the UN in New York have reportedly been decreased by 42%.

March 11 at the UN, Department of Safety and Security staff told Inner City Press of fight back at the ISCE, and of more fights to come. Others spoke of solidarity with the elevator operators, and with the Aramark food service workers, also hurt by the Capital Master Plan. But would the Plan be slowed, by the Teamsters and AFL-CIO workers? Watch this site.

UN Puts Zewde Atop Nairobi With Nepotism in Central Africa UNanswered

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 11 -- After UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon unceremoniously demoted Anna Tibaijuka from heading the UN Office in Nairobi, reassigning that power to German UNEP chief Achim Steiner, the General Assembly rebelled and created a new, separate Under Secretary General position to run UNON.

(In her other job atop UN-HABITAT, Ms. Tibaijuka was replaced by Mr. Joan Clos of Spain. Since then, the UK has cut all of its funding to HABITAT, calling it “irrelevant.”)

It was understood that Ban should fill the UNON post with an African, and today he did. But the person he selected, Sahle-Work Zewde of Ethiopia, while heading the UN office in the Central African Republic (BINUCA), refused to clean up or even answer on documented nepotism in BINUCA:

In late 2009, Inner City Press asked Ms. Sahle-Work Zewde, Special Representative of Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon and Head of the United Nations Peacebuilding Support Office in the Central African Republic (BONUCA) about a series ofBONUCA hires of relatives of the head of the UN Department of Political Affairs Africa II Division, Sammy Buo. She said she would look into it, take action and report back.

Nine months later, having heard nothing from her or about any changes, Inner City Press asked her for an update. “I don't want to speak about the past,” she said.

Inner City Press asked, “But are the individuals, including the former employee of the Executive Outcomes private military firm, still employed by the UN in the CAR?” She would not answer.

How can the UN credibly preach transparency and anti-corruption if these are its practices?

And without answers, how will UNON fare?

Inner City Press formally asked the director of DPA's Africa II Division Sammy Kum Buo the following questions:

Mr. Buo -- I am writing a story about this morning's Security Council session on BONUCA / Central African Republic. I am also covering management issues in BONUCA and DPA and am writing for you to confirm or deny on deadline each of the following [about BONUCA staffers]

Is Gabriel Buh Kang a relative of yours? A cousin?

Is BONUCA staffer Ekei a relative of yours? Your niece?

What is the status of Brindou Germain Kabran ?

When in CAR, have you stayed with Brindou Germain Kabran?

Did you still collect DSA? Please provide records.

What can you say about the case of Gozo Tshamala?

On deadline, Matthew

Mr. Buo is also accused of hiring a former mercenary from Executive Outcomes, in violation of UN rules. While Mr. Buo has refused to respond, Inner City Press has discussed the matter with other Mission officials and finally, on December 21, 2010 with Mr. Buo's ten boss in DPA, Haile Menkerios (since made UNMIS chief).

Mr. Menkerios confirmed he was aware of the issue. Inner City Press asked Mr. Menkerios what DPA's response would be. It is a management issue, Mr. Menkerios replied, that will be responded to in a management way.

But has it been? Yet?

On Sri Lanka, UN's Haq Insists His Denial Meant Nambiar Isn't Target of ICC Complaint, Is Only Called a "Co-Perpetrator"

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 11 -- On Sri Lanka, a complaint filed with the International Criminal Court against Palitha Kohona states of UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff that there is “a basis to question whether Vijay Nambiar was in fact an innocent neutral intermediary or in fact a co-perpetrator within the negotiation related community.”

Inner City Press on February 21 published a story containing that quote, and this paragraph from the complaint:

"NAMBIAR again through the United Nations-24 hour dispatch center in New York. NAMBIAR replied to COLVIN that MAHINDA RAJAPAKSE, GOTABAYA RAJAPAKSE, AND PALITHA KOHONA had assured NAMBIAR that the LTTE members would be safe in surrendering to the SLA and treated like “normal prisoners of war” if they “hoist[ed] a white flag high.”

Days later Ban's Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq sent a reporter an on the record statement that

“The Inner City Press story is inaccurate; there has been no complaint formally filed at the International Criminal Court.”

Inner City Press asked Ban's lead spokesman Martin Nesirky to explain Haq's statement, but Nesirky refused, saying that Haq had sent it to another journalist, not Inner City Press. But it was an on the record response. Still, no answer, including from Nambiar.

On March 11, for the first time in weeks Haq and not Nesirky took questions at the UN's noon briefing. Alongside questions about the vetting of Ban's envoy to Libya and UN actions in Sudan, Inner City Press asked Haq to explain his statement.

After attempting the evade the question by calling it "all of your personal things" and saying it could be addressed outside of the briefing room -- Inner City Press has asked outside of the briefing, without answer -- Haq now argued that he had been asked if the ICC complaint named -- that is, was against -- Nambiar.

But Haq's statement in his e-mail, which Inner City Press published on February 23 and is reproduced in full below, did not refer to whether Nambiar was the named target, which he couldn't be as a citizen of India, which is not a member of the ICC. (Kohona is named because he is a joint citizen of Australia, which IS an ICC member.)

Rather, Haq's statement called inaccurate “the Inner City Press story,” which quoted directly from the ICC filing, as set forth above. The story was not inaccurate.

It appears, including to the journalist who received the e-mail from Haq, that the goal was to convince other media to ignore any link between Nambiar and the ICC complaint, and the underlying killing including “white flag murders” in Sri Lanka.

Even many of those closest to Ban Ki-moon have questioned why Ban sent to Sri Lanka former Indian ambassador Nambiar, given India's interest in Sri Lanka especially after the murder of Rajiv Gandhi, and with Nambiar's brother Satish writing publicly in praise of the Rajapaksas military campaign in Northern Sri Lanka which has given rise to the war crimes charges.

One Ban insider says, “It's not really Nambiar's fault, Ban should just never have made him the envoy to Sri Lanka.”

But the mistakenly-given role of Nambiar for the UN in Sri Lanka has so distorted the Ban administration's and the UN's response to the events in Sri Lanka that the spokespeople act as described above, and won't even answer with whom Ban's Panel on Sri Lanka met. It is a low point in Ban Ki-moon's tenure as UN Secretary General.

From the UN's transcription of its March 11 noon briefing:

Inner City Press: there was a filing with the International Criminal Court (ICC), admittedly not by a Government but by a private group, naming the Sri Lankan Ambassador here, but also having two paragraphs concerning the Chief of Staff of the Secretary-General, Vijay Nambiar. And I, it has come to my attention that you wrote to a journalist saying that this is inaccurate; that there is no complaint filed with the ICC. And I wanted to know what the basis of that statement was, since they claim it was filed and they have proof of filing?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: Again, you know, this briefing is not for me to discuss all of your personal things. We can always discuss this outside. The basic point is a reporter — and I don’t know what his exchange with you was, but his exchange with me was whether a complaint had been filed naming Mr. Nambiar. That is not the case.

But here is what Haq sent out:

From: Farhan Haq [at] un.org
Date: Tue, Feb 22, 2011 at 7:16 PM
Re: Question about Nambiar, ICC and Burma envoy role

Yes, he is still the acting Special Adviser on Myanmar.

The Inner City Press story is inaccurate; there has been no complaint formally filed at the International Criminal Court. Please ask the ICC for anything more on that.

As for a full-time Special Adviser, Ban Ki-moon has been considering that idea; there is nothing to announce for now.

As Gillard Is Asked Of ICC & Australian Sri Lanka Citizen Kohona, UN Still In Denial

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 9 -- Joint Australian - Sri Lankan citizen Palitha Kohona is the subject of a filing with the International Criminal Court for his role in presumptive war crimes in the final stages of the conflict in Sri Lanka. When contacted by the press, Kohona has refused to “dignify” the case.

On March 9, Inner City Press asked Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard about this filing against Kohona, who has also represented Australia before he represented Sri Lanka, and about the UN's and Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's handling of his Panel on Sri Lanka, which has not visited the island. Video here.

“I'm not personally aware of all details of that case,” she answered. “We are a supporter of the ICC and a supporter of proper legal procedure and practice, one rule... is that political leaders should not comment on legal matters that are underway.”

While some of the journalists traveling with Prime Minister Gillard later called this a dodge, it's more than the UN has had to say. Without explanation, Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq has denied to other media the existence of the ICC filing against Kohona -- which also mentions and questions the role of Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar in the so called white flag killings

Ban's main spokesman Martin Nesirky, also not explaining Haq's statement, has refused to answer questions about Ban's Panel on Sri Lanka, saying that only the Panel can answer them. But the Panel has no spokesperson, and let its mailbox overflow and reject submissions from victims. Only at the UN.

Footnotes: Australian Labour Party MP John Murphy has been quoted, about Kohona, “I call on the government to independently investigate Dr Palitha Kohona, an Australian-Sri Lankan dual citizen and former DFAT official who participated in the surrender of the Tamil Tigers in the last days of the war. On 18 May 2009, several innocent Tamils were slaughtered while holding a white flag.”

One of the journalists traveling with Minister Gillard asked her if she'd told “Secretary Moon” that Australia is seeking a Security Council seat, as well as discussing a possible no-fly zone over Libya. She confirmed that Australia is seeking a seat, and insisted that there are no differences between her and Foreign Minister Kevin Rudd. We'll see.

At UN, Lucent Official Talks Congo & Congress, Ed Royce's “Take Me To Your Leader" - Kabila Fils & Pere

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- Holding a glass of wine in front of a tapestry depicting the Great Wall of China, the corporate social responsibility director for Alcatel - Lucent Marie Royce Tuesday night spoke to Inner City Press about Rwanda and the Congo, Kabila and bonobos.

“My husband is a member of Congress,” she said, describing a trip by Rep. Ed Royce (R-California) to Kinshasa on the day that Mobutu was overthown by Laurent Kabila. “My husband was in a jeep, protected by a group of men with guns. He was able to say, for the first time in his life, 'Take me to your leader.'”

With that, Marie Royce laughed heartily. She said Alcatel - Lucent is in 45 countries in Africa, she has been to Rwanda and the war crimes tribunal in Tanzania. Rwanda, she said, has “better P.R.” in Washington, the Congo can't compete.

Inner City Press pointed out that while the DRC is Francophone, Rwanda has shifted to English. There is that, she said, adding that she has met twice with Joseph Kabila. Returning to the past, she said her husband spoke with Laurent Kabila when he first came to New York and stayed in the Waldorff = Astoria. “He had never seen snow,” she said.

She shifted to bonobos, how “a man named Antoine” gave her a tour and called up to the primates in the trees, who waved back. They were just like people, she said. And so it goes at the UN.

UN Envoy Al Khatib Is On Board of Jordan Ahli Bank, Links With Libya Central Bank

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- In selecting Abdul Ilah al Khatib as the UN's envoy on Libya, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon moved quickly -- maybe too quickly.

Since serving as the foreign minister of Jordan, describe even some close to Ban as an autocracy, al Khatib has served on the boards of director not only of Lafarge Jordan Cement Company but also of Jordan Ahli Bank.

Jordan Ahli Bank is active beyond that country's borders. A sample connection: along with Libyan Foreign Bank, a fully owned subsidiary of the Central Bank of Libya, Jordan Ahli Bank is a top 20 shareholder of Union de Banques Arabes et Francaises.

Could there be conflicts of interest? Did the UN's Ban administration even consider these?

Ban previously claimed that 99% of his officials have made public financial disclosure. But when Inner City Press showed this is not true -- even Ban's close ally Choi Young-jin, his envoy in Cote d'Ivoire, declined to make public financial disclosure -- Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky said Ban's statement had been “metaphorical.”

Now Ban names and injects al Khatib into a struggle about democracy and free press, when as Inner City Press noted yesterday

"Foreign Minister Abd al-Ilah al-Khatib in January initiated a criminal defamation suit against weekly newspaper al-Hilal's editor-in-chief Nasir Qamash and journalist Ahmad Salama. He [al-Khatib] objected to the content of a January article, and said his tribe had threatened to beat up Salama if he failed to take action. The case remains in the courts at this writing."

By what process was al-Khatib vetted and selected? Watch this site.

Amid Torched Villages in Abyei, UN Flew in Torcher Haroun, Questions Unanswered

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 7 -- Amid the torching of villages in Abyei by Sudanese nomads, the UN flew into Abyei Ahmen Haroun, indicted by the International Criminal Court for organizing nomads to commit war crimes in Darfur, it confirmed to Inner City Press on March 4.

In follow up, Inner City Press over the weekend asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky to

“provide all previously requested specifics of ICC indictee Ahmed Haroun's now second flight with the UN, and did DPKO tell the Security Council? Was it a special or scheduled flight? How much did it cost? Did the UN ask why Sudan's air force couldn't make the flight? Did OLA consider and approve this? When will Patricia O'Brien hold a press conference and take questions?”

On March 7, with Nesirky not having answered any of the questions, he used his noon briefing opening to deliver praise to the government of Omar al Bashir, also indicted by the ICC for genocide, for now agreeing to try to avoid violence. Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: on Sudan, I mean, I heard your message lauding this agreement between the SPLM and the NPC. Has the UN seen, and can it… seen this report, and can it confirm that three villages were burned down in Abyei, 300 buildings destroyed, and what’s the relation between that… is this the violence that the agreement that you are applauding will be stopping or… and what was, did Ahmed Haroun, this indicted ICC [International Criminal Court] individual, what was his role? Did he sign this for the NPC, and do you think that villages will no longer be burned down in this way?

Spokesperson Nesirky: First of all, it is precisely that kind of violence and damage with human, as well as material, cost that this agreement would be designed to stop, and to try to stop. Governor [Ahmed] Haroun of South Kordofan, as you know, is responsible for the Misseriya’s respect for the rule of law and finding a solution to their migration, and so that is why his role was crucial in that respect.

Inner City Press: What do you say to those who say that, since he is actively charged by the ICC with organizing nomadic tribes to burn down villages that may be relying on him, transporting him may be not a good idea?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I think the point here is that, as I just said, his role in ensuring that Misseriya respect the rule of law and also in helping to find a solution to their migration is really crucial. And, indeed, the talks between the Ngok Dinka/SPLM and the Misseriya/NCP really can’t take place without his participation.

So it is impossible to deal with murderous nomads without the UN flying in a Sudanese government official indicted by the ICC for organizing nomads to murder in Darfur. Is the resulting and continuing murder any surprise?

Footnote: Meanwhile on March 7 Inner City Press on deadline asked the three spokespeople of the US Mission to the UN the following question, so far without response:

“Does the US State Department / Administration find the new Satellite Sentinel Project imagery, confirming the deliberate burning of three villages in Sudan's contested Abyei region, useful? How is the Obama administration focusing on Abyei? Do you agree with the conclusions of the Satellite Sentinel Project that it's systematic targeting of civilian infrastructure, and as such, evidence of a possible war crime?”

There are other questions to the US Mission to the UN that have gone unanswered. Watch this site.

Saturday, May 7, 2011

On Sri Lanka, UN Denies “Secret” Meeting, Won't Say If Report Public

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, March 7 -- The UN's evasiveness on the meetings, travel and report of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Panel on Sri Lanka continued on March 7, with Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky telling Inner City Press that it is up to the Panel to speak for itself, even to decide if its report should be public.

Nesirky called “shaky” reporting that has suggested a secret February 23 meeting, telling Inner City Press “you know, you were there taking pictures, that was not the case.”

Inner City Press asked, were the members of Ban's panel in town, in New York? Even this Nesirky would not answer, saying it is up to the Panel to say. But where is the Panel?

Then Nesirky said that deadline is “this month.” Inner City Press asked, will it be public?

That will be up to the panel, Nesirky said, in consultation with the Secretary General.

Inner City Press covered a surprise meeting on February 23 between Ban and Sri Lankan officials including the Attorney General and ex-general Shavendra Silva, responsible for what UN officials called the “bloodbath on the beach” in May 2009.

At the time, Inner City Press repeatedly asked Nesirky what relation that meeting had with the work of Ban's panel and Sri Lanka's Lessons Learnt & Reconciliation Commission. Nesirky would not relate them in any way.

On March 6, the Sri Lanka Sunday Times reported that the Sri Lankan delegation on February 23, after the meeting exclusively reported by Inner City Press, met with Ban's panel, and that the panel's deadline was extended two or three weeks. Immediately upon seeing the article, Inner City Press sent questions by e-mail to Nesirky and his deputy Farhan Haq on the morning of March 6:

A UN source is quoted in the Sri Lanka Sunday Times that after the meeting between Messrs. Ban, Nambiar, Haysum, et al and Sri Lanka's Attorney General and External Affairs minister on February 23 which you have told me was about reconstruction and rehabilitation,

1) the two Sri Lanka official met with Mr. Ban's Panel -- true or false? If true, why kept secret, and does this replace the trip to Sri Lanka Ban has repeatedly said is allowed by Mahinda Rajapaksa's flexibility?

2) the deadline for the Panel, set for March 1, has been extended “two to three weeks” - true or false? If true, why was this not announced, and extended for what purpose?

Yes or no: will the report be made public?

Please provide a complete list of attendees of the Ban meeting, and of the reported meeting afterward with Mr. Ban's Panel.

Nesirky and his deputy Farhan Haq never answered or even confirmed receipt of these questions. More than 24 hours after submitting the questions, at the March 7 UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Nesirky to answer them, to respond to the Sunday Leader story, and to state if Ban's Panel will travel to Sri Lanka (as Ban has repeatedly claimed).

Nesirky called the Sunday Leader's reporting “shaky” in suggesting a secret meeting, emphasizing to Inner City Press “you know, you were there taking pictures, that was not the case.”

Inner City Press asked, were the members of Ban's panel in New York? Even this Nesirky would not answer, saying it is up to the Panel to say. But where is the Panel?

Nesirky said that deadline is “this month.” Inner City Press asked, will it be public?

That will be up to the panel, Nesirky said, in consultation with the Secretary General. We'll see.

Meanwhile, former Sri Lanka UN ambassador HMGS Palihakkara, a member of Mahinda Rajapaksa's LLRC, was in New York at the same time, sources say, as part of Ban's advisory group on disarmament. So an LLRC member was in New York at the time -- were the members of Ban's panel? Watch this site.