Wednesday, September 8, 2010

At UN, As Ban's Sustainability Panel May Include Rudd, Can His Rule Be Sustained?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 9 -- After weeks without taking questions from the independent press at the UN, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon will hold a press conference Monday at 11. While questions of mis-management, silence on Darfur and powerless panels on Sri Lanka and the Gaza flotilla swirl, a more upbeat pretext for the presser has been found.

Ban will announce, or launch in UN parlance, a “High Level Panel on Global Sustainability.” In announcing Ban's long delayed press conference, the UN said it “will also address other topics, including the Secretary General's recent trip to Japan.”

Just before he left on that trip, Ban took a single on camera question, about his Gaza flotilla panel. For this question, he chose the UN's own media, UN Radio. The self-interview was then called a “media stakeout” by UN Television.

While presumably in an attempt to build suspense the UN's announcement said that the “full list of Panel Members and their Terms of Reference will be available at the press conference,” one possible member of the Panel has been asked about by Inner City Press, repeatedly, resulting in a series of “no comments” from the UN.

After his loss of power in Australia, Kevin Rudd flew to New York and met with Ban Ki-moon. Inner City Press attended the photo op, and noted that Ban's climate advisor Janos Pasztor was in attendance, and that the meeting lasted a full 50 minutes.

(While Inner City Press published its photos, it appears that none of UN Photo's shots are on the UN website, when searched by "Rudd.")

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson if the meeting involved the offering of a UN position of any kind. It was just a courtesy call, Inner City Press was repeatedly told -- even after Rudd, back in Australia, bragged through his spokesman about the offer of a post.

UN climate staffers and Ban Ki-moon defenders approached Inner City Press to say that what was being offered was not a full UN position, rather membership on a new body -- the “High Level Panel on Global Sustainability.”

This would explain the claim that the UN position Rudd was referring to would not require relocating to New York, and would allow him to remain involved in politics in Australia. His goal seemed to be to show his successor his high international profile, to gain the foreign minister spot. While this now seems unlikely, and Rudd's project of seeking a Security Council seat may also be abandoned, this morning's announcement may well involve Kevin Rudd.

If it does, it will represent Ban causing a “major embarrassment” for the current leader of Australia, Julia Gillard. Why would Ban do this? Sources say that the Obama administration, which could veto a second term for Ban, has urged Ban to find a position for Rudd.

Some wondered why Ban would name Alvaro Uribe to his Gaza flotilla panel just after Venezuela delivered to Ban a letter accusing Uribe of trying to raise tensions in the region. Now, Venezuela speaks of using its upcoming post as head of the Group of 77 and China to try to stop a second term by Ban. Watch this site.

Footnote: Ban is made a pattern of collecting outgoing heads of state. He named Uribe to his Gaza flotilla panel even before Uribe left power in Colombia, on August 7. Uribe will be deputy to former New Zealand prime minister Geoffrey Palmer, a protoge of Helen Clark, whom Ban named as the head of the UN Development Program (from which she has increasingly commandeered other top UN posts, often to Ban's detriment as in the case of naming Paul Kagame as Zapatero's co-chair for MDGs advocacy, and a Costa Rican over African candidates for the Number Two spot at UNDP.

Some see the contradiction: Ban refused to allow ostensibly independent OIOS chief Inga Britt Ahlenius to choose her deputy, but allowed Helen Clark to ignore a commitment made to the African Group to get the deputy post at UNDP, when Clark was named to the top job, representing the developed world. And so it goes in Ban's UN.

As Sudan Starves Kalma camp and Jebel Marra, UN Has Stayed Quiet, OCHA is AWOL

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 6 -- In Darfur, why has the UN remained so quiet not only about Sudan blocking humanitarian aid into the Kalma camp since August 2, but into eastern Jebel Marra since February 2010?

In an August 4 response to a question from Inner City Press about restrictions and the Kalma camp, chief UN peacekeeper Alain Le Roy said that the government had blocked humanitarian groups for the four previous days.

On August 5, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky to confirm this blocking of aid. Nesirky said he would check. Since the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs is supposed to have and provide information on just these topics, Inner City Press e-mailed two OCHA spokespeople, thinking that confirmation should be on hand. But hours later, OCHA replied that it was checking with people.

Still having no answer on the morning of August 6, Inner City Press asked OCHA again, and some addition questions about the discontinuation of UN reporting on humanitarian issues in Darfur, including malnutrition. (OCHA referred this question to UNICEF, to which Inner City Press has now forwarded the questions).

At the UN noon briefing of Friday, August 6, Inner City Press asked again about Kalma camp, and Nesirky said again that he would have to check. Where is OCHA chief John Holmes? Inner City Press asked, isn't this precisely the type of situation OCHA is supposed to advocate, and loudly, about?

After the noon briefing, Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq provided this answer, that OCHA confirms lack of access to Kalma camp since August 2, and to eastern Jebel Marra “since February 2010.” He said the OCHA is advocating “locally.”

First, this “local” advocacy, if it exists, has not worked: witness the continuing lack of access to east Jebel Marra for more than FIVE MONTHS.

Second, it is unclear why this OCHA would grow so quiet on this issue. Inner City Press asked, are there other situations OCHA is staying quiet about? Nesirky did not answer, and the OCHA spokespeople have yet to answer the questions Inner City Press put to them on August 5.

Nor would Nesirky confirm to Reuters the Sudan Tribune's report on the UN's “talking points” to Khartoum, nor to Inner City Press whether Khartoum has formally asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to turn over six people in Kalma camp it claims are responsible for the violence.

Has the UN come to any of the “full understanding of the facts” behind the violence in Kalma camp which the Security Council asked for a full week ago? You could have asked Le Roy on August 4, answered Nesirky, who on that day limited Inner City Press' questions.

The question remains: where is OCHA? Where is John Holmes? Where, for that matter, is Ban Ki-moon. Physically, he is in Japan. But where is he on the issue, of Sudan's intentional starvation of people in Kalma camp and eastern Jebel Marra?

And if this is addressed with a “statement attributable to the spokesperson for the Secretary General,” would Ban Ki-moon walk away from the statement, after a governmental complaint, as he did on the UN's statement about Kashmir? Watch this site.

UN's Kashmir Email was Drafted by DPA from its "Morning Prayers," Watered Down by Nambiar, Blamed on Haq


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 5 -- When the UN made a statement on Kashmir, then stepped away from it and blamed it on an Associate Spokesman, there was more than met the eye. Inner City Press has inquired and finds the following: the initial response on the violence in Kashmir was produced by the UN Department of Political Affairs, in what is called it “morning prayers” meeting, chaired by DPA chief Lynn Pascoe.

Then, even before the statement was released, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, a former Indian diplomat and intelligence operative, edited the statement, “watering it down” as one senior UN official puts it.

After UN Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq emailed the statement to four journalists and it was published, the Indian Mission to the UN protested. They came to meet with the UN, Mr. Nambiar, for more than two hours. Apparently, Nambiar did not fully disclose his initial role in editing the statement.

Next, the UN Spokesman Martin Nesirky stepped away from the statement, emphasizing that Ban Ki-moon never said it, and it was mere “guidance from the Secretariat,” and claiming that it had been misinterpreted. How?

On August 4, Inner City Press asked Nesirky to think it through: if he could walk away from this statement attributable to the Office of the Spokesman for the Secretary General, how can any of his future statements be taken seriously? I have said all I am going to say, Nesirky replied. Okay...

Footnote: attendees that DPA's "morning prayers" quote Pascoe, for example that "Hillary Clinton is going to Colombia, what does she think she can accomplish?" While some attendees conclude from this that Pascoe is aligned with US Republicans who appointed him, others say it establishes his "street cred" as an internaional civil servants. But is this what HRC and Obama want? Watch this site.

From the UN's August 3 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: a controversy has arisen around a statement that Farhan Haq had put out, talking about Indian-occupied Kashmir and calling for restraint. And, basically, it says that the Indian Foreign Ministry or Ministry of External Affairs has taken issues with it, that your Office has clarified that the Secretary-General never made those comments. Have you seen that story, and what can you do to clarify the seeming discrepancy between the Indian Foreign Ministry and your Office?

Spokesperson Nesirky: The Spokesperson’s Office released to the media guidance which was prepared by the UN Secretariat, and that seems to have been taken out of context. This was not a statement of the Secretary-General.

Question: What was taken out of context? This was a formal statement.

Spokesperson: Let me repeat what I just said: the Spokesperson’s Office released to the media guidance which was prepared by the UN Secretariat, and it seems to have been taken out of context. This was not a statement of the Secretary-General. That’s what I have; I don’t have anything to add.

Question: But the statement said the Secretary-General calls for restraint, and is there concern about it?

Spokesperson: As I said, I don’t have anything to add to what I’ve just said.

From the UN's August 4 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: Some think that the way that it was answered yesterday — it’s hard for them to take; what weight should statements by the Spokesperson for the Secretary-General be given if they’re later characterized as mere guidance and the Secretary-General didn’t mean them. For your own purposes, how do we — is this a one-off, or does this somehow change; you get a statement today about Tanzania — is that a statement of the Secretary-General, or is it mere guidance, and from who — who gave the guidance on Kashmir?

Spokesperson Nesirky: You know very well what it said [on Tanzania]: it said “a statement attributable to the Spokesperson for the Secretary-General”, and that clearly is a statement. But I don’t have anything beyond what I’ve already said on this topic. Okay?

No, not okay.

With UN Under Fire for Inaction on Myanmar, Japan is Offered Good Offices Post, Sources Say, Rejects It So Far


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 3 -- Facing questions of what the UN has accomplished on Myanmar through its “Good Offices” mandate, since Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar has filled the post, the Good Offices are being offered to a variety of Japanese officials, sources tell Inner City Press.

When Japanese Ambassador Yukio Takasu left, he was reportedly offered the Myanmar “Good Offices” post.” Takasu turned it down; Japanese mission sources, while fully believing that Takusa would be offered a senior UN post, say that he is going to retire.

Others say that the UN Myanmar post, which Ibrahim Gambari vacated when he went to UNAMID in Darfur, is now being offered to two other Japanese diplomats, including the highest placed one in the UN system. With Ban Ki-moon in Japan this week, watch this site.

This comes as questions have built up, without being answered, about the UN's “Good Offices” on Myanmar mandate, particularly since Nambiar took over from Ibrahim Gambari. Inner City Press has repeated asked for information about the work and accomplishments in any. On June 22, Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: on Myanmar, there’s a lot to be said, but there’s a recent report, Bloomberg and Jane’s Intelligence Review, which is respected in the field, giving more credence to Myanmar developing nuclear weapons. A whistleblower, to coin the phrase, has left the country and has produced photographs of a facility near the new capital. Does the UN have any, either the good offices role? What is the UN’s knowledge of that, given that the IAEA [International Atomic Energy Agency] is unable to inspect? And two, what really has been accomplished through this good offices role in the past six months? We have heard very little, and that may be part of Ms. Ahlenius’ critique.


UN's Ban, Gambari and Nambiar: Japanese official or Mr. Choi not shown

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: First, the Secretary-General has been outspoken about what is going on in Myanmar, first on the elections, the need for the elections to be transparent and inclusive, and for all the political actors to be able to take part if they so wish. He’s also been very outspoken on the need for the release from house arrest of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. Also, on the first part of your question, this is something, whether allowed into the country to inspect or not, the International Atomic Energy Agency would be keeping an eye on, and let’s see what the agency has to say about that. [He later added that the IAEA had said: “The IAEA has seen the media reports and continues its analysis of information on Myanmar, as it does with information on other countries.”]

The next day, July 23, Inner City Press followed up, as "one reporter" --

Inner City Press: Yesterday, during the response by Ms. [Angela] Kane and [Catherine] Pollard, they declined to say, to respond to this part of the [Inga-Britt] Ahlenius memo that said — it is only one country among many but it was the first one listed, Myanmar — and the senior UN official who spoke later, for some reason, declined also to discuss it. I guess I want to ask you, what have been the accomplishments of the good offices mandate since Mr. [Ibrahim] Gambari let it go, and another official took it over. What has been done? There has been an ASEAN [Association of South-East Asian Nations] meeting, various countries have spoken about the election. Has the UN made any comment? What’s the UN doing on Myanmar?

Spokesperson Nesirky: We’ve made comments in answer to you and to others, and I said just to you the other day that there are important elements here; the need for transparent and inclusive elections, that’s absolutely critical. There is also the need for political prisoners, including Aung San Suu Kyi, to be released unconditionally and quickly. And we continue to work, as I also said to you before; the good offices [team] is not one individual, if you like, it’s people working behind the scenes. Not everything that happens is in the public eye.

Well, that is true. At the same time that Takasu left, Japan's representative on the UN's Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions Misako Kaji also left, despite her term running through December 2010. While Japan quickly nominated Akira Sugiyama to replace her, this “clean sweep” of Japanese at the UN has caught the eye of some. Watch this site.

Footnotes: An earlier good one about the Good Offices has Cote d'Ivoire SRSG Choi returning to New York to take on the part time Myanmar good offices role, and to manage Ban's campaign for a second term. But Choi has said he'll remain in Cote d'Ivoire until there is an election....

On August 2, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky who is in charge of the UN, with Mr. Ban traveling in Japan and DSG Asha Rose Migiro on annual leave. While Nesirky insisted that Mr. Ban is always in charge, Inner City Press asked if anyone had formally be made officer in charge. Even the following day on August 3, no answer was given. Watch this site.

At UN, Sri Lanka Panel's 4 Months Has Not Begun, Ban Gives In to Protest?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 3 -- After Sri Lanka's May 2009 “bloodbath on the beach” which killed thousands of civilians, it took UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon more than a year to name a three person Panel of Experts to merely offer advice on accountability.

On August 2, two months after the assault on the Gaza flotilla which killed eight civilians on the ship, Ban launches a four person Panel of Inquiry, stating that its work formally started August 10, with a first report in mid September, before the UN's annual General Debate.

Inner City Press on August 2 asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky about the contrast between the two panels, the speed with which Ban formed them, and the strangely narrow scope of his Sri Lanka panel:

Inner City Press: I didn’t know we were going to get into comparative panels. But following up on the Bhutto discussion, some have wondered about comparing panels, comparing this to the Sir Lanka panel, which is three people instead of four.

Spokesperson Nesirky: Why did I think you were going to go there?

Inner City Press: Yeah, yeah. The question is, I guess, it hasn’t started yet, due to staffing, I’m told. And so I wonder how can you explain the difference of the speed — I mean, the speed should be, in all cases, I would assume — what would you say that to those who say it took a year to name one in Sri Lanka and it still hasn’t begun due to some staffing issues, whereas this one you’ve said when it’ll start, when it’ll report…

Spokesperson: You’re saying there are staffing issues; I have not. And, that’s the first… [talkover]. The first thing is, as you know, they [the Sri Lanka panel] have already met, and they are looking at exactly how they will work. They have a Chief of Staff, we’ve already named him, as you know. That person is already working with the three experts. So, that’s the first thing. The second thing is, in all of these cases, where you’re setting up an inquiry, a panel of experts, or whatever else you want to call it, this involves careful groundwork and diplomacy. And, this can take, in some cases, a long time; in some cases, it can take less time. You can’t compare one to another. This is how diplomacy works.

So if a country complains loudly enough, leading up to blocking UN staff inside their building, then Ban Ki-moon's UN will move slowly and cautiously on war crimes, apparently. What is the message to countries like Sudan and Myanmar?


Sudan appears to have already learned the lesson: they have announced that UN staff in Darfur must now give prior notice before traveling the road, and will have their bags searched in the airport.

As to the still unclear Sri Lanka panel timing, Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: has the four-month clock started? When did it start?

Spokesperson: As we’ve said, you have the experts and you have the support team. The support team is working in the background. The experts will be meeting again in the coming weeks, and that is part of the process, part of their work as they’ve been mandated to do so by the Secretary-General.

Inner City Press: When does the four-month clock start?

Spokesperson: I’ll let you know. So, I’m happy to take any other questions on this, but is this on the panel?

Ban was very proud of his Gaza panel, going so far as to interview himself -- or have UN Radio do it - in a mock “stakeout” in his North Lawn building office. Then he flew off to Japan.

Following Inner City Press' report that Mahinda Rajapaksa is listed as Sri Lanka's speaker in September's general debate, unprompted letters copied to Inner City Press have invited Ban's panel's three members to be sure to interview Rajapaksa at that time. We'll see.

Footnote: over the weekend, we noted that the Sri Lankan Mission to the UN's embattled and outgoing Deputy Permanent Representative might be providing some views early this week. He had formally invited Inner City Press to “lunch at the Sri Lankan restaurant” on August 2.

But that morning, the Mission wrote to Inner City Press saying the DPR was “indisposed” and unable to attend, that it might be rescheduled. As it happens, the PR is throwing a farewell to his deputy on August 3, at a non-Sri Lankan restaurant on Third Avenue by the UN and Mission. To this, Inner City Press has yet to be included among the invitees. Interesting list that must be. Watch this site.

Of UN Women and Ban Ki-moon's Second Term, Dirty Deals, Double Crosses, Albright Boutros Echoes

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 2 -- How badly does Ban Ki-moon want a second term as UN Secretary General?

So badly, sources tell Inner City Press, that he has offered special input into the awarding of the top job in the new UN Women agency to Permanent Five Security Council members who could block his second term, in exchange for their support.

This quid pro quo was not favorably viewed in Washington. With UN management harshly criticized in the End of Assignment report of outgoing Office of Internal Oversight Services chief Inga Britt Ahlenius, it was hardly the time to offer top posts in exchange for political support for a second term.

The U.S. State Department of Hillary Clinton, in any case, felt it should have input into who heads UN Women without having to lock in support for Ban Ki-moon getting a second term.

Back in 1996, the Democratic administration of Bill Clinton played its cards close to the chest until, late in the process, Madeleine Albright came out against Boutros Boutros Ghali. (For the record, Susan Rice is reciting support for Ban Ki-moon as well.) Team Ban does not like that precedent and is seeking commitments now. But this, one source said, was just too ham handed.


The Obama administration cannot accomplish its goals through the UN with Ban Ki-moon at the helm, argued the reflexively pro-UN pundit James Traub, probably too practical to intentionally burn his bridges to the UN.

Some time ago, Inner City Press exclusively reported the first fear among Team Ban, that the U.S. will cede the top post at the World Bank in 2012 to China, in exchange for Asia Group control of the UN S-G post being moved, and Obama getting his own choice. This fear and possibility remains.

There is another UN women -- without the capital W -- theory on the move in the North Lawn building. In it, Inga Britt Ahlenius' devastating memo is linked with the ambitions of her friend Alicia Barcena to swoop in as Secretary General in 2012.

Inner City Press has already shown Ahlenius writing to Barcena to be sure to be on selection panel to get Ahlenius' friend Danielle Coolen a job. Click here for the story, here for Ms. Ahlenius' email. But these theorist say Ahlenius and Barcena met and dined before the fateful memo was leaked, and that there are other UN women, some ostensibly close to Ban Ki-moon, involved in the plan. Watch this site.

Footnote: the interview for the top UN Women post were presumably to have included, or been led by, Deputy Secretary General Asha Rose Migiro, interim head of UN Women. But with Ms. Migiro in Uganda and now on annual leave, the interviews have proceeded, with the involvement of Ban's senior advisor Kim Won-soo (who appears repeatedly and prominently in the Ahlenius memo.)

On August 2, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky who is in charge of the UN, with Mr. Ban traveling to Japan and Ms. Migiro on annual leave. While Nesirky insisted that Mr. Ban is always in charge, Inner City Press asked if anyone had formally be made officer in charge. Watch this site.

In Darfur, UN Says Travel Restrictions Break Agreement, But No Attribution of Pilot Hostake Taking or Kalma Camp Violence


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 2 -- In Darfur, the embattled UN - African Union mission UNAMID has been instructed to only travel, including on the roads of Nyala, after giving prior notice to the government, which has also said it will search UNAMID personnel's bags in airports.

Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky about these new Sudanese government rules. “If implemented, then these restrictions on movement would not be consistent with the Status of Forces Agreement,” Nesirky replied in what seemed a prepared statement. Video here, from Minute 33:38.

Does that mean that UNAMID is resisting the restrictions, in a way it did not resist the orders to only use its helicopters on 48 hours notice, even to defend its peacekeepers? “We're working with the local authorities in South Sudan,” Nesirky said.

Inner City Press last week repeatedly asked if and when the UN would disclose what it knows about who took hostage the Russian pilot, and beat his passengers. On July 30, Inner City Press was told that the pilot, already then released, would rest before being interviewed as to who had taken him.

But when on August 2 Inner City Press asked the UN, which has presumably now interviewed the pilot, to say whether as reported it was pro-government militia, Janjaweed, who were responsible for the incident, Nesirky said the UN still does not know.

Asked if the UN and its Department of Peacekeeping Operations has begun work toward the Security Council required (and compromised) “full understanding of the facts” behind the deaths and violence in the Kalma camp last week, Nesirky said that DPKO chief Alain Le Roy will conduct a previously scheduled briefing for the Press on August 4.

Nesirky then read a prepared that the situation in Kalma has “improved but remains tense,” and that deputy joint Special Representative Mohamed Younis visited Nyala and spoke with the Wali of South Darfur sheiks and UNAMID staff. Nesirky did not fully confirm until after the briefing that three UNAMID peacekeepers, from Sierra Leone, while accompanying Younis died in a car crash. RIP.

We will have more about the roads of Nyala. Watch this site.

At UN, Sri Lanka Panel Stalled on Staffing, Rajapaksa's RSVP for September, Rice and Kyrgyz Constrasts


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, August 1 -- The UN's panel of experts on Sri Lanka war crimes and accountability has still not officially begun its work. Why not?

Inner City Press is told that the hang up is the staffing for the panel. It has been confirmed that the initial plan was for the chief of staff to be Jessica Neuwirth, close ally and friend of UN Human Rights Commissioner Navi Pillay.

But after reports alleging, at best, nepotism it was decided to switch to Richard Barrett, a staffer without similar connections. The fig leaf now is that Neuwirth's time on a UN system contract had expired -- true, that was the reason to find her a new job -- and that she is now a “consultant.” With the UN or its Human Rights Commission? That's a separate inquiry.

On the panel itself, its four month time line does not begin until it is fully staffed. So are the three experts not yet working, then? If so, did they start getting paid by the UN when they met at the UN back in July or not? The hotel rooms -- “at UN rates” -- were certainly paid by the UN. So it is hard to argue they are not yet working for the UN.

On the UN's schedule for its upcoming General Debate in September, Mahinda Rajapaksa is listed as attending. If he does, this would be a perfect time for the panel to interview him. His embattled minister of external affairs G.L. Peiris has already said the panel will not get visa to visit Sri Lanka. So let Mahinda cooperate with the panel while he is in New York. If, that is, he comes to New York.

Outgoing Japanese Ambassador Yuki Takasu, when asked on July 27 by Inner City Press to describe innovations during his time in charge of the Security Council's working methods, listed the Council's informal basement meetings on Sri Lanka, in the final stages of the conflict.

Given the level of civilian killing, it is still not clear what those meetings accomplished. But now even Japan, through foreign minister Okada, has urged Sri Lanka to cooperate with the UN panel. Will it?

Later on July 27 at Takasu's farewell reception at his residence, Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative worked the crowd, including his U.S. counterpart Susan Rice. Ambassador Rice has claimed, contrary to her State Department colleague on Sudan Scott Gration, that accountability for war crimes is at the top of the Administration's agenda. Sri Lanka is a test.

The approach not only of Ambassador Rice and Ban Ki-moon but others to this mere Sri Lanka panel stands in contrast to the unequivocal way the UN says it will participate in any independent international investigation into the causes of the recent violence in Southern Kyrgyzstan. From last week's UN transcripts, first of July 26:

Inner City Press: On Kyrgyzstan, the OSCE [Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe] Parliamentary Assembly Special Representative, Kimo Kiljunen, he said there’s going to be an investigation conducted by his organ… by a commission, international commission, of the violence in southern Kyrgyzstan. And he also said that the United Nations would be involved in the commission. So, I wanted to know, is that the case? What will be the United Nations role in an international investigation of the causes of violence in southern Kyrgyzstan?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Let me find out. Just a general point, the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly is not the same thing as the OSCE itself, as I’m sure you understand. So we would need to see precisely what the composition, the intended composition, would be. But the other more general point is that we’ve said already that there should be an independent investigation into the events that took place in Osh and Jalalabad and in the south of Kyrgyzstan. So let me get back to you on that, okay?

Having heard nothing back, Inner City Press asked again on July 30:

Inner City Press: you’d said you would find out, and I wanted to ask whether you have. One is, what is the UN’s role in any possible investigation into the causes of violence in southern Kyrgyzstan?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: As I mentioned to you, that is a work in progress amongst different international organizations. It is being actively looked at, and I know that my colleagues in the Department of Political Affairs are keeping a close eye and talking to their colleagues, as is Mr. Jenca, the Special Representative for Central Asia, Miroslav Jenca. No firm words yet. But, as I’ve said to you before, this is an area where we have been very closely watching. And not just watching, but involved in bringing people together, monitoring and reporting what’s been happening...

And on Sri Lanka?

The Sri Lankan Mission to the UN's outgoing Deputy Permanent Representative, who came in with a flurry of accusatory letters and leaves accused himself of sexual harassment of a Mission staffer, may be providing some views early this week. We hope they are on the record. Watch this site.

At Morocco's Throne Day, W.Sahara and Kosovo Contrasted, Non-Recognition by India and Romania, Diplomats Pay Cut

UNITED NATIONS, July 31 -- On Morocco's Throne Day, the talk was of sovereignty. In Rabat, King Mohammed VI broadcast that "Morocco remains committed to its sovereignty" over Western Sahara and "will not cede an inch of its Sahara.”

In New York's Waldorf Astoria Hotel, Moroccan Ambassador to the UN Mohammed Loulichki greeted guests by the 18th floor entrance to the Skylight Room. Inside there were musician, carved lamb, sweet tea and a slew of diplomats, including UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his wife.

Inner City Press wanted to ask about this “won't give one inch” statement, in light of the long standing obligation of the UN to run a referendum on independence for Western Sahara. While this might have to wait, surprisingly what other Ambassadors approached Inner City Press about was another sovereignty dispute, that of Kosovo.

While Serbia, with out without a throne might feel like the Moroccan king, earlier this month the International Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion largely upholding Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence. Kosovar foreign minister Hyseni told the Press he is staying in New York to meet with non-recognizing states.

But just for example, two such states told Inner City Press on Friday night they have no intention of recognizing Kosovo, even after the ICJ opinion. Romania's Permanent Representative Simona-Mirela Miculescu told Inner City Press that for “historical reasons” her country will not recognize Kosovo, and the European Union can't force it to. She called the EU like a family, in which some can disagree.

(Ambassador Miculescu also told Inner City Press that the surviving parts of the austerity measures required for an International Monetary Fund facility to Romania have resulted in her salary being cut by fifty percent. Click here for Inner City Press' previous coverage of the IMF and Romania.)

India, too, will not recognize Kosovo. Hyseni has asked to meet with them, but it appears this will be a waste of the Kosovars time. And with the world's largest democracy, and country with the world's second largest Muslim population, not recognizing your state, is independence complete?

Things turned decidedly more philosophical as the night wore on. As others left, citing the lack of alcohol, Inner City Press was regaled with tale after tale of Morocco's openness, to Moshe Dayan in Ifrane in the 1970s and before that those fleeing for Spain, to Morocco standing up to Vichy France.

The synthesizer and sweet tea were packed away, and Throne Day was over. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1morthrone073110.html

At UN, Ban Ki-moon Plans Quick Unveiling of Flotilla Panel Win, With N.Zealand Chair, Sources Say, An End to Leaks?

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/ban1flotilla073110.html

UNITED NATIONS, July 31 -- While Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak's meeting with UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on July 30 was shrouded in secrecy, afterward UN diplomats bragged about their boss' “win.”

They said Israel has agreed to Ban's -- or really the Security Council's -- idea of a independent panel about the assault on the Gaza flotilla. They said that while the UN's cursory Friday evening read out didn't say it, the unveiling of Ban's “win” would take place next week.

Some who spoke to Ban later on Friday night said the announcement will be Sunday evening, and that the chair of the panel will be from New Zealand, with other members from Israel and Turkey.

Team Ban, typically, sees this development in the context of Ban's recent travails triggered by the leaked End of Assignment memo by Inga Britt Ahlenius, until then the UN's chief of the Office of Internal Oversight Services. Trying to combat the memo's critique, including of Ban's diplomatic skills, Ban has deployed first his chief of staff, then his chief of Management, without much impact.

To package and unveil a diplomatic win, just before Ban travels for the week to Hiroshima in Japan, seems to Team Ban a true turning of the corner. We'll see.

According to Ban administration sources, in Ban's closed door selective briefing to some Japanese reporters to hype up his trip, Ban asked for “East Asian solidarity” in fighting leaks and attacks on his image.

He complained he was particularly offended by Ahlenius' critique since he had thrown her a retirement party and invited her into his home. It's an Asian thing, he in essence said, this simply isn't done. What, leaking? Whistleblowing? Criticizing one's boss?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1flotilla073110.html

On Darfur Camp Violence, Nur's Role as Unclear as US Stance on Doha, Sudan Says Camp Is Under UN Control, Lobbies

UNITED NATIONS, July 30, updated -- Darfur camp violence was taken up by the UN Security Council on Friday afternoon. According to UN sources, members of the Liberation and Justice Movement group which is negotiating with Khartoum were targeted by members of the Abdel Wahid Nur faction, which is not.

While the United States called for the consultations, it is not clear if the US stands with the UN and its Darfur envoy Ibrahim Gambari in saying that the solution to Darfur is to be found in Doha across the table from Omar al Bashir's negotiators.

French foreign minister Bernard Kouchner loudly announced that Paris based Abdel Wahid Nur would be joining the Doha process. Nearly immediately, Abdel Wahid Nur qualified this with the conditions previously listed, including safety in Darfur.

Inner City Press asked Ibrahim Gambari on July 27 about Abdel Wahid Nur's participation. Gambari said no, and characterized the conditions, including safety, as something you get at the END of negotiations, not as a precondition. One can see this as either realism or a too cavalier attitude to the protection of civilians, especially for one in charge of a peacekeeping mission with such a mandate.

Sudan's acting Ambassador, on his way at 4 pm into the Council's suite where he would not be allowed into consultations, said that Gambari had told him at 2:30 that he would be placing some calls to get information, and would himself be giving the briefing at 4. But at that time, he was spotted by an Inner City Press source strolling the streets outside the UN, dress in white national dress.

Gambari also said on June 27 that he has gone to Paris twice to meet Abdel Wahid Nur. Three days later, he is still in New York, but not in the consultations room. Briefing was Alain Le Roy of Peacekeeping, joined at 4:40 by Lynn Pascoe of Political Affairs.

The South Sudan referendum Eminent persons monitoring group the UN is moving to set up, which Inner City Press exclusively reported earlier today, would be staffed by Pascoe's Department of Political Affairs and not the UN peacekeeping mission run by Haile Menkerios. Whether Pascoe's arrival at the Council was about this, or the Doha process implications of the attacks in the Darfur IDP camps is not yet known. Watch this site.

Update of 5:09 -- Sudan's charge d'affaires was lobbying in the hall outside the Council. “We cannot live with a paragraph about inspecting the Kalma camp... the camp is under the control of UNAMID...” Then, after fumbling with their passes, they went into the Council's suite. Coming out were the outgoing Nigerian presidency's plants and bean bag chairs with Islamic script. Coming in -- Russia's set up, for August..

Update of 5:29 p.m. -- there will be a press statement. Unclear if it will include the paragraph about inspecting or investigating in Kalma camp, which Sudan is opposing.

Update of 5:55 p.m. -- while UN TV had been told the press statement would be ready and read by now, the Council has gone into recess. Inner City Press is told by Council source that France has proposed the UN send an investigation team to Kalma camp. China and Russia have opposed it, as does Sudan. Developing.

Update of 6:13 p.m. -- Here's what happened: France “aggressively” asked for an investigation, setting of “red lights” among some other delegations. But wait - the US asked the meeting, but France made the proposal. Why? Le Roy pointed the finger at the Abdel Wahid Nur group, but France says they've spoken to him and he denies it. THAT's why France wants the investigation. You heard it here first....

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc2sudan073010.html

UN Council Meets Late on Darfur Violence, Eminences to Bless S.Sudan Referendum

UNITED NATIONS, July 30 -- On Darfur, the UN and its Security Council lurch from interest to disinterest. Friday morning, for the vote on mandate of the joint UN - African Union Mission in Darfur, no Permanent Representatives appeared, except Nigerian Permanent Representative Joy Ogwu for what she thought would be her last meeting as Council president.

But sometimes events outstrip disinterest. With news spreading of increased violence in the Darfur camps, a request -- some say a response to pressure or coverage -- was made for another meeting in the afternoon, for a behind closed doors briefing by top UN peacekeeper Alain Le Roy.

Inner City Press asked outgoing President Joy Ogwu if the meeting, at 4 p.m., will focus on the shootings in the Kalma camp, which have been attributed to members of the Abdel Wahid Nur faction, targeting members of the Liberation and Justice Movement -- formed by a paid UN staffer -- for negotiating in Doha with the government of Omar al Bashir. She responded by mentioning Sudan as a whole.

On South Sudan, with Bashir threatening to put off the independence reference unless the border is demarcated in a way that favors Khartoum, on July 29 top UN peacekeeper Alain Le Roy told the Security Council of plans to “monitor” the referendum. Afterward he did not speak with the press, and won't until next week, unless this changes after the July 30 consultations on Darfur.

But sources in the UN's North Lawn building say moves are afoot to create a panel of former and perhaps current African leaders to give their blessing to the referendum.

Inner City Press confirmed this with a Council member's political coordinator on Friday: it will be a group of “Eminent Persons,” with technical support from the UN.

Le Roy reportedly told the Council that while the UN generally does not monitor elections, in this case it will support Eminent Persons to do so. Skeptics wonder if these Eminent Persons, like former South African president Thabo Mbeki already on the case, will be decidedly pro Bashir.

We will continue to cover this, including the upcoming meeting(s) on Darfur. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc1sudan073010.html