Wednesday, July 14, 2010

As Sri Lanka Burns UN Ban in Effigy, Some NAM Members Abandon It, UN In Disarray, Kohona Dressed Down

UNITED NATIONS, July 6 -- In the wake of the government sponsored or allowed hostage taking of UN staff in Colombo, Inner City Press on Tuesday asked the Permanent Representative to the UN of a major South Asian country if he still supported Sri Lanka's requested Non Aligned Movement statement opposing the UN's war crimes panel.

We'll just stay out of it now, the Permanent Representative said. He and his Deputy expressed disgust at the Rajapaksas allowing hostage taking at the UN compound, and the burning of the Secretary General in effigy. Photos here. Very stupid, the Deputy called it.

But when Inner City Press late Tuesday asked several senior UN advisers about the hostage taking, they appeared ill informed and in disarray. One of the “Conspirators” portrayed on a sign board in Colombo only asked, “Did they spell my name right?” and thought that the dressing down of Sri Lankan Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona was enough.

Kohona was back on the scene on Tuesday, in the General Assembly Hall to hear Queen Elizabeth II's speech. Afterward he walked desperately through the hall, looking for hands to shake. They were few and far between. When your government allows the burning of the Secretary General in effigy, it tends to go this way. Ask Omar al Bashir, who still takes Ban Ki-moon's calls.

By day's end the question was, why hadn't Ban Ki-moon yet tried to call the Rajapaksas? Did he think they would not answer?

Was it beneath him, since he was the one burned in effigy? He will meet on Wednesday with Benyamin Netanyahu. And we will try to be there. Watch this site.

Footnote: Inner City Press has obtained, and now puts online as a public service, the NAM draft as of June 30. Click here to view. It is obvious how paragraph 4 conflicts with what's being asked of Ban about the Gaza flotilla attack.

“It is a well recognized international norm that in situations where there are allegations or breaches of international law that the country concerned should in the first instance be allowed to conduct its own investigation and to make known its findings.”

Another miscalculation by Sri Lanka. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri6panel070610.html

UN Downplays Sri Lanka Hostage Taking of its Staff, Ban Has Not Called Rajapaksa

UNITED NATIONS, July 6 -- The UN continued running scared of Sri Lanka's Rajapaksa, even after its staff in Colombo were held hostage by a mob led by a minister in Rajapaksa's government, Wimal Weerawansa.

Inner City Press asked the Associate Spokesman for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, Farhan Haq, what he made of Weerawansa's cell phone call to Gotabaya Rajapaksa, after which police pulled back and allowed the mob to continue to trap UN staff. Video here, from Minute 6:28.

Haq did not dispute or deny the call, responding rather that the “bottom line” was that late in the day, staff were able to leave, while the mob remained in front of the UN building.

While Haq repeated spoke of contacts with and assurances from “officials to the highest level,” the highest he listed was the (non-Rajapaksa) Prime Minister speaking with the UN's local representative Neil Buhne.

Will Ban Ki-moon himself, Inner City Press asked, be speaking with Mahinda Rajapaksa? “At this stage I don't have anything to say about the Secretary General making any such calls,” Haq replied.

Why not? Ban has returned from Montego Bay, Jamaica. At 10:30 on Tuesday he had a meeting with the head of the UN Mission in Afghanistan, then nothing listed until 2:50 p.m..

Is is that hostage taking of UN staff is not important enough? When it takes place in Sri Lanka? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri5panel070610.html

At UN, Serbia's Long Shot Request for more UNMIK Before ICJ Rules Foretold

UNITED NATIONS, July 6 -- As Serbian president Boris Tadic finally began speaking in the UN Security Council, five days after the deadly grenade attack in Mitrovica which triggered the “emergency” meeting, what he would say had been foretold. Radio Srbija, hours before the meeting, reported that Tadic had asked for a UNSC condemnation of the attack.

The contested office opening in Mitrovica, which the Radio Srbija story calls “illegal,” is the real issue. Will it be opened before the International Court of Justice rules on Kosovo's Unilateral Declaration of Independence?

Will the UNMIK mission, whose shrinkage foreshadowed that of MONUSCO in the Congo, step forward to perform a peacekeeping role? At 10:55 a.m., Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremic told Inner City Press that the meeting would be open. At 11 a.m., Tadic began. Watch this space.

Update of 11:15 a.m. -- Tadic's speech closely tracks Radio Srbija's foretelling, or vice versa. He calls the ICJ case the "largest in history."

Update of 11:19 a.m. -- Tadic says that no democratic government in Serbia will ever accept UDI. He emphasizes, at always, that the fight back is diplomatic. It brings to mind today's taking hostage of UN staff in Colombo by a Sri Lanka government minister and mob...

Update of 11:28 a.m. -- Lamberto Zannier of UNMIK runs through an account of the grenade attack, asking the Council to join him in expression of concen for the shot Serbian MP Petar Miletic.

Update of 11:33 a.m. -- EU speaker also describes the grenade attack "600 meters from the office." Also speaks of Petar Miletic. Says EULEX has been threatened in Northern Kosovo.

Update of 11:38 a.m. -- "Kosovo is sovereign, determined to exercise its authority, regardless or ethnic or religious background." Kosovo says the "violent protest" obviously had the support of Belgrade.

Update of 11:47 a.m. -- Kosovo says its office in Mitrovica "will continue."

Update of 11:50 a.m. -- those hand grenades were most probably thrown from the very protesters, Kosovo says.

Post meeting update: after the meeting was over, and Tadic and Jeremic left without speaking with the Press, Skender Hyseni of Kosovo came to take questions. Inner City Press asked him to respond to Tadic's statement that the office in Mitrovica is unpopular. It's very popular, he replied.

Why not wait until the ICJ rules? There is no connection between the office and the ruling, he replied. We'll see: watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1mitrovica070610.html

Sri Lanka Minister and Mob Hold UN Staff Hostage, Ban Remains Silent

UNITED NATIONS, July 5 -- The UN's compound in Colombo has been surrounded, UN staff held hostage by a crowd led by Sri Lankan government minister Wimal Weerawansa. "We warn the U.N. to withdraw the (investigating) panel if they want to get the employees out," Weerawansa told the protesters.

The siege came six days after Weerawansa urged crowds to take UN staff hostage. Inner City Press on June 30 and July 2 asked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq for Ban's response.

On June 30, Haq said Weerawansa's threat may have been misquoted, and was in any event merely “individual.”

Inner City Press asked a very senior UN official about the threat and was told it was a “Gandhian” threat.

On July 2, when Inner City Press asked why the UN would minimize a government minister's threat against UN staff as “individual,” Haq claimed that an apology might be forthcoming from the government and told Inner City Press, "I will let you know if something like that comes through."

On July 3, Weerawansa made clear he was not misquoted, and the threat was not individual. Inner City Press published stories on July 3, 4 and 5. Ban Ki-moon, in Jamaica, said nothing. Haq and his Office sent nothing.

On July 6, UN staff were taken hostage, and the Sri Lankan government did nothing to stop it.

It is called a government endorsed and protected action against UN staff.

While Weerawansa and some Sinhalese activists are calling on Ban to be “impeached” for his belated and begrudging naming of a panel to advise him on Sri Lankan war crimes, others including UN staff and supporters point to other reasons: the inexplicable delay, and this failure to perform the most basic part of the UN S-G job, to protect or at least speak up for UN staff in the field. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri4panel070610.html

Sri Lanka Army Claims Dutch Ambassador Support Despite EU Human Rights Cut of GSP Plus Concession

UNITED NATIONS, July 5 -- As the European Union cut off Sri Lanka's trade concession on human rights grounds, the Sri Lankan Ministry of Defense claimed that EU member (and World Cup semi finalist) The Netherlands “appreciates the diplomatic and strategic position upheld by the Government of Sri Lanka with respect to the pressure exerted by certain countries in connection with the internal political issues of the country.”

This appreciation was sourced to Leoni Cuelenaere, The Netherlands' Ambassador to Sri Lanka in a July 2 meeting with Sri Lankan Prime Minister D.M. Jayaratne, and was placed on the government's web site and numerous other sites.

Since this seemed a strange position for an EU member to express, email inquires were made with Leoni Cuelenaere, resulting in an electronic reply that “as you can imagine, I said nothing of the kind!”

But why, then, has not The Netherlands and the EU more publicly sought a retraction from the Sri Lankan Ministry of Defense and the other sites which have carried and are carrying this presentation of The Netherlands' position?

Similarly, with UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in Jamaica, he has said nothing about Sri Lankan Minister Wimal Weerawansa's threat to take UN staff in Colombo hostage. Ban's Associate Spokesman has said that Weerawansa's call was only as an individual, despite his position with the Rajapaksa government.

But now that Weerawansa has said he was officially speaking for a political party that is part of the Rajapaksas' coalition, the National Freedom Front, one expects at least a correction, and more substantively some defense of UN staff, from the Secretary General. We're still waiting.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri1dutch070510.html

Candidates for Top UN Women Post From Rwanda, Tunisia, Malaysia, No Bachelet

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/un1women070210.html

UNITED NATIONS, July 2 -- As UN Women, the world body's so-called Gender Entity, was birthed Friday in the General Assembly, Inner City Press learned for a well placed Mission about six of the eight candidates for the Under-Secretary General position at the top of UN Women.

These are the Rwandan foreign minister, Louise Mushikiwabo, UN gender advisor Rachel Mayanja (nominated by Gabon), a Malaysian official who heads up the gender work of the Non Aligned Movement, officials from Tunisia and Norway and, Inner City Press is told, Sri Lanka's Radhika Coomaraswamy.

The biggest donor, assured for that reason a seat on the Executive Board, is said to agree that the USG should come from the Global South. So the Norwegian, it seems, has little chance.

Earlier on Friday, Inner City Press asked UN Deputy Secretary General Asha Rose Migiro to name the candidates, since she had said the process would be open and transparent. Eight countries, she said, have submitted names, including one country naming another's national. She gave as an example the United States nominating her. “Have they?” Inner City Press asked. No, she said.

Not on the list is Michelle Bachelet of Chile. Some say she wanted UNICEF and is miffed. Others say she will only take it if offered: i.e., if it is not a competitive process. We'll see. Watch this space.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1women070210.html

At UN, Defense of Ban's Failure to Appear Is Like Sudan's Bashir, Glass House Undermined

UNITED NATIONS, July 1 -- Under fire for seeming to thumb his nose at the rule of law in the UN, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's top lawyer Patricia O'Brien faced the Press on Thursday, reading a script. She said Ban has the right to appeal. But why, Inner City Press asked, appeal an order that the decision making official appear in the UN Dispute Tribunal?

By appealing such an order -- as took place in March -- Ban appears to align himself for example with Omar al-Bashir, who seeks to argue around the International Criminal Court's indictment without even appearing once before the ICC in The Hague.

“Your ICC analogy is interesting,” Ms. O'Brien replied, but noticed that the ICC is criminal while the UNDT is administrative. But to many the principle is no different: by refusing to even appear, the rule of law is harmed. Bashir is fine with that. But why is Ban?

O'Brien deployed words like “suspensatory” impact, and cited one example where a senior UN official appeared by video conference to the Tribunal in Nairobi. But what happened in March, before now-gone Judge Adams? Why has Ban been criticized, first exclusively by Inner City Press in the Shaaban Shaaban case, then by the Post and Times, for undermining the UN's internal justice?

The director of the Tribunals Andei Terekhov argued that the New York staff like the system, as proved by the SMCC. But the New York Staff Union doesn't participate in the SMCC, as after an Inner City Press follow up he acknowledged. Sitting in the front row was the human resources official who had tried to divide and conquer the union. There was no time to follow up.

The Head of Management tried to dodge the question of whether the closure on two days notice of the UN after-school program had been her decision. The decision was necessary, she said, while it is being reconsidered. But did you make it? The answer appears to be yes.

Footnote: After the UN justice briefing, the chief of staff of the President of the General Assembly told the Press that the Gender Entity is formed. It will be voted on on Friday. We'll be there: Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undt1banshir070110.html

At UN, Colombia Serves Coffee, Anti-FARC Spin in Council Bid, Delegates' Might Close

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1colombia070110.html

UNITED NATIONS, July 1 -- Amid writhing dancers, drums and a soprano saxophone, Colombia on Thursday night at the UN promoted its candidacy for the Security Council in 2011-2012.

In a more cloak and dagger fashion, a subtext was that the UN should not be speaking with the FARC rebels. Under the banner of children and armed conflict, a diplomat complained, the UN is seeking to give credence to the rebels, who are losing. One size, the diplomat said, does not fit all.

Up on the stage, with the East River as a backdrop, Colombian dancers moved quickly. Some Ambassadors gaped. This, one said, is what Security Council reform should be all about.

Also working hard was Uzbekistan's Permanent Representative. He spoke to Inner City Press, emphasizing his country's bona fides despite the closure of the border. He lobbied the UK and other Permanent Five members. He was more mobile than the wait staff, which distributed lamb chops and small bowls of ceviche.

Of under secretaries general, those of management and public information were visible. Turkey's Ambassador stood appreciating music. Brazil's greeted all and sundry. Both voted no on Iran sanctions. While Iran did not appear, North Korea put in an appearance. Out the window ships passed by.

Russia's Vitaly Churkin was in attendance, and was asked by a journalist-- not this one -- whether a family member working for Russia Today let slip that he might take over from Lavrov. Churkin denied it all. There: for the record.

Colombia's swag bag contained a pound of Juan Valdez coffee, in a small burlap bag one could imagine on a burro. They have an office in Beijing. That, as they say, is the future.

Footnote: Sadly, the Delegates' Lounge where this took place might soon be a thing of the past. Due to UN planning, a week ago Aramark stopped food service in the UN cafeteria at 2:30 instead of 7:30. Now the buzz among employees is that the Delegates' will close, due to lack of business. What made the UN, the UN, is all falling by the wayside. Diplomacy is suffering, but no one seems to care.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1colombia070110.html

As Romanian Court Rules Against Pension Cuts, IMF Nods at 5% VAT Increase

UNITED NATIONS, July 1 -- Romania's Constitutional Court has struck down the pension cuts connected to the International Monetary Fund's facility to that country. On July 1 Inner City Press asked IMF Spokesperson Caroline Atkinson for the IMF's reaction to the decision, and if the government's move to boost the Value Added Tax from 19% to 24% would be enough for the IMF.

Two weeks earlier, Ms. Atkinson had responded to Inner City Press' question about the Constitutional Court in this way, as transcribed by the IMF itself:

“I have a question online, which is a bunch of questions, but on Romania: 'The government’s measures are being challenged in the Constitutional Court. What does the IMF think of the suit? What impact might it have on the IMF facility for Romania?' And it’s absolutely right that the fiscal adjustment measures, which are prior actions for our program, have to be approved by the Constitutional Court, and of course we respect that process. That’s an entirely appropriate process. We don’t think that that will lead to any -- I mean, that’s not something that we’re concerned about.”

And so on July 1 Inner City Press asked, “the Constitutional Court has now rejected the pension cuts connected to the IMF facility. What is the IMF's reaction, since two weeks ago it was said that the IMF did not expect this result?”

Ms. Atkinson said, “I'm not sure about that.” But she'd said of the Court review, “That's not something that we're concerned about,” a lack of concern that can be equated with not expecting a negative court decision.

Now on July 1, Ms. Atkinson said “the Romanian authorities have identified other measures... What we look at is an overall package, not specifying one measure or another.” She noted that the IMF Board will consider Romania on July 2. Watch this site.

And see, innercitypress.com/imf4romania070110.html

As Sri Lanka Threatens UN Staff, Ban's UN Makes Excuses, Calls It Gandhian

UNITED NATIONS, June 30 -- As Sri Lanka's minister of housing called for UN staff to be held hostage until any war crimes inquiry is stopped, the UN in New York made excuses for the threat. Inner City Press asked about Minister Wimal Weerawansa's call for “to surround the UN office in Sri Lanka and trap the staff inside until a decision is taken by the UN Secretary General to dissolve the panel he appointed on Sri Lanka.”

Rather than condemn this call, as it would in Sudan or elsewhere, UN Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq first told the Press that perhaps the minister had not been “quoted correctly.” Video here, from Minute 10:46.

Next, Mr. Haq said that the Rajapaksa administration had assured that Weerawansa's call was an “individual position.” Inner City Press asked how the UN distinguished between the position of the Sri Lankan government, which has already said it will deny visas to the panel, and that of a government minister. Video here, from Minute 11:59.

The UN House, Haq said, has not reported any mobilization. Who received the assurance? The UN resident coordinator. But isn't he, Neil Buhne, the one who stayed quiet while two UN system staff members were imprisoned and tortured, they said, by the government last year?

Later on Wednesday, Inner City Press asked a very senior UN official about Sri Lanka's threat. This justification was more telling: according to the UN official, Weerawansa's call was really for GANDHIAN civil disobedience, not violence. So the Sri Lankan government is to be praised, then.

Inner City Press asked Haq if the terms of reference of the panel, the preparation of which was offered as an excuse for the 90 day delay between announcing and forming the panel, will be released to the public. No, Haq said, it is an advisory body, not a body outside its advisory function. Video here, from Minute 15:52.

In a new development Haq said that perhaps the panel will not even conclude with a written report. Some terms of reference. Some defense of UN staff. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri9bantor063010.html

UN's Ban Takes Note of Grenade-Scarred One Party Election in Burundi, Mutineer Taking Power in Guinea-Bissau

UNITED NATIONS, June 30 -- When an election on which the UN has spent years ends up with a single candidate and the opponent in hiding, and polling's marked with the deadly tossing of grenades, what does Secretary General Ban Ki-moon do? He “takes note” of the one party election, in this case in Burundi. But what does this mean?

On June 28, after Ban praised the referendum in Kyrgyzstan that was marked by ethnic cleansing then declined to take questions on his praise, Inner City Press asked his spokesman Martin Nesirky if Ban would also praise Burundi. We'll have something tomorrow, Nesirky said.

And indeed he did. In the opening of the June 29 noon briefing, Nesirky provided updates on two outstanding questions:

Yesterday I was asked about Burundi. The Secretary-General takes note of the presidential election that took place on 28 June. In regard to the rest of the electoral cycle, the Secretary-General calls on all Burundians, and their political parties, to continue settling their disputes through peaceful means and an inclusive dialogue, and he urges them to persist in consolidating national cohesion and their hard-won peace.

I was also asked yesterday about the appointment of a new Chief of Staff in Guinea-Bissau. The United Nations takes note of the appointment of Major-General Antonio N’djai as the new Chief of General Staff of the Armed Forces of Guinea-Bissau. The Special Representative of the Secretary-General in Guinea-Bissau, Joseph Mutaboba, is consulting national and international stakeholders on the way forward, particularly with respect to security-sector reform, addressing impunity, restoring respect for the rule of law and strengthening democratic governance. Our goal is to secure the cooperation of all concerned, including the military leadership, in the continued pursuit of our peacebuilding mission, which includes as a central feature the introduction of vital reforms in the security sector.

It goes without saying that a one party election is far less than ideal. In Guinea-Bissau, the UN had expressed concern that the mutineer might be rewarded with a government post. But then when it happened, the UN merely “took note.” And so Inner City Press asked Nesirky:

Inner City Press: I just wanted to follow up on these two announcements that you made on Burundi and Guinea-Bissau. In the Burundi election, there was only one candidate, and since then grenades have been thrown at the Electoral Commission, killing two people. You’re saying Ban Ki-moon takes note of it. What does that mean?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I said he took note of the presidential election.

Inner City Press: Is that some kind — “taking note” means he doesn’t view a one candidate’s election positively, or he views the throwing of grenades as unhelpful? What is he taking note of?

Spokesperson: Of the presidential election that took place on 28 June. And what it also says — I can repeat it for you — is that he calls on all Burundians and their political parties to continue settling their disputes through peaceful means and inclusive dialogue; peaceful means and inclusive dialogue. And that’s a message that he took directly to the people, including the President, when he visited Bujumbura earlier this month.

Inner City Press: I was just wondering, maybe if you could get [inaudible] like at the Security Council, like taking note. Is he troubled by it? Is he concerned by it? Is he just aware of it? I just want, if you could give…

Spokesperson: Well, for now it says what it says, Matthew. It says what it says. There may be more coming from the Mission subsequently, but that’s what we’re saying at the moment. And importantly, he stressed on the spot, when he was there in Bujumbura, and he’s saying it again now, through me, as he is on his way to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, that this is a process after a conflict, and there needs to be some persistence here to work to consolidate national cohesion. No one is saying that they’re there yet. But they need to push ahead with that. And in doing so, they need to be as inclusive as possible. Okay, and you want to add something on Guinea-Bissau, did you say?

Inner City Press: No, I think it’s just you used exactly the same phrase, and it seems like, I think the question you were asked yesterday is whether the UN, which had expressed concern about this individual getting the post, is concerned now that the person has gotten the post. And I guess, I put the two together, maybe “taking note” means there is concern. I just wasn’t sure.

Spokesperson: Well, it’s not for me to try to parse or interpret the wording. I think, probably, I’d have to leave that to you.

So how should we interpret Ban's mere "taking note" of this UN's inability to positively impact even Burundi and Guinea Bissau? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1notes063010.html

IOC Says Saudi Arabia, Qatar & Brunei Sent No Women to Olympics, Sochi Time Bomb?

UNITED NATIONS, June 29 -- Three countries have never sent women athletes to the Olympics: Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Brunei. This emerged on Tuesday, when Anita DeFranz of the International Olympics told the Press there are 204 national Olympic Committees and only three have not sent women. “Which three?” asked Inner City Press. Ms. DeFranz named them.

The IOC has become an Observer at the UN. Since the UN has 192 members, how does the IOC have 205? Ms. DeFranz explained that for example Puerto Rico and Guam has organizing committees but are not countries for purposes of the UN. Inner City Press asked, “And Abkhazia?”

While there was laughter, by the 2014 Winter Olympics it may not be so funny. Those games were awarded to Russia, for its notably warm resort town of Sochi. Georgia call for a boycott, after its war with Russia for Abkhazia and South Ossetia. (Georgia's Ambassador recently traveled to the International Criminal Court conference on the Crime of Aggression, his Mission told Inner City Press, still beating the drum for “accountability” for that war.)

Ms. DeFranz took questions about rules on ambiguous gender and the IOC's reliance on national identification documents to resolve disputes about underage gymnasts. Ms. DeFranz is a lawyer, and her answers showed it. Video here.

A loaded question about participation by countries “where women are brutalized,” Ms. DeFranz answered with her own question: “the United States?” She said the beach volley ball players are not required to wear such small swim suits, and that boxers have agreed to forgo beards, without it being formally required.

“What the benefit for the IOC of becoming an Observer?” Inner City Press asked. “Now we can talk,” said Ms. DeFranz. She said the UN flag has flown over the Games since 1992 in Barcelona.

Footnote: in audience was another Olympic athlete, swimmer Donna de Varona who spoke to Inner City Press about the U.S. Title IX. More countries should have it, she said. When asked about a case in Connecticut where Quinnipiac is defending closing its women's volleyball program by saying that cheer leading is a sport, she shrugged. It is if they compete, she said. Follow the money: hiss boom bah.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ioc1women062910.html

UN Hides Behind Russian After Failing to Speak Up for Ethnic Uzbeks on Kyrgyz Constitutional Cleansing

UNITED NATIONS, June 29 -- With the UN slavishly supporting a Kyrgyz Constitutional referendum from which the Uzbek minority was disproportionately excluded due to ethnic cleansing, it has chosen to hide behind Russian. Not the Russian government, which like the US backed the flawed referendum to defend its Kyrgyz base, but the Russian language.

Last week, Inner City Press twice asked the UN to confirm that the constitution would outlaw the formation of ethnicity based parties: that is, any Uzbek party. Only after a third request on June 28 did the UN respond, with this:

Further to your exchange with Martin at the Noon Briefing, just wanted to help point you to the relevant part of what you'd asked about...

The reference you seek is under Article 4., point 4.3:

4. В Кыргызской Республике запрещается:
.............
3) создание политических партий на религиозной, этнической основе, преследование религиозными объединениями политических целей;

I realize this is in Russian but am sending in case it's of any help to you.

Now it seems strange that the UN, sometimes called translation central, could or would not provide an English version of this single line of Russian, requested three times in a week. In fact, the UN provided Inner City Press with a translation of other material it had not requested. But when Inner City Press sought among its network a translation of what the UN provided only in Russian, this was the result:

4. In the Kyrgyz Republic it is forbidden:

3) to create political parties on the basis of religion or ethnicity, or on any attempt to, by religious gatherings or parties, achieve political goals.

So the answer was and is yes, the UN backed a referendum from which the Uzbek minority was disproportionately excluded on a constitution which will now bar the Uzbeks from organizing to defend themselves.

On June 28 Inner City Press also asked:

Inner City Press: I heard the statement both by Mr. [Miroslav] Jenca and then reiterated by the Secretary-General this morning about the referendum in Kyrgyzstan. I was wanting to ask: what is the UN’s estimate of the turnout of ethnic Uzbeks? There are some reports that, for example in the border town of Suretash, only a hundred to 4,000 people were able to vote. So, I’m just wondering, what does the UN statement mean when compared to such low turnout numbers reported for ethnic Uzbeks?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, reported by whom?

Inner City Press: Associated Press.

Spokesperson: Right. Well, there are a number of things here. First of all, the UN is not observing, and the UN is not counting votes or voters.

Inner City Press: Then why are they praising?

Spokesperson: Let me finish, first of all, to try to answer your question. First of all, there is the Central Election Commission. That’s the body which is compiling the figures. So, the figures on turnout will be coming from the Central Election Commission. And I checked their website before I came here; it’s in Kyrgyz and Russian, and there are very detailed figures by each province or district showing the turnout and absolute figures in each case. And of course, overall figures. And that’s the first thing. So I would encourage you to take a look at that. And the second thing is, perhaps more helpfully for you in English, as well as Kyrgyz and Russian; the OSCE’s [Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe’s] office for democratic institutions and human rights has put out a fairly detailed overview in a statement of its preliminary findings and conclusions. This is, as I said, this is preliminary findings, as you might expect, given this is less than 24 hours after the vote itself. But they are quite detailed, and as Mr. Jenca and the Secretary-General have said, they have taken note, and the Special Representative of the Secretary-General has taken note of this preliminary assessment by the OSCE and others where it’s clear that there were some shortcomings. That’s clear. That’s obvious. But what they believe is, and this is the assessment that this was largely transparent. And the turnout; again, it’s for the Central Election Commission, firstly, to give those figures. The turnout that seems to be evident, not only from the Central Election Commission in concrete numbers, but also from the more anecdotal evidence, if you like, of the international observer, that there were long-term observers that would tend to suggest that this was a sizeable turnout. And most importantly, that it was peaceful. There weren’t any violent incidents.

Inner City Press: Just a quick follow-up. If these were the two bases for the UN’s praise of the election, does the Central Election Commission — apparently you’ve read them in Russian — are these turnout numbers done by ethnicity or simply by geography?

Spokesperson: Not by ethnicity. It’s done by geography; by the region. Yeah.

Inner City Press: Does the UN have a particular concern or, I don’t know, maybe “duty” is the wrong word, to the ethnic Uzbeks who were being targeted by violence, left the country, many of them had their ID cards ripped up — is that something, does this statement today mean that they feel, that the UN feels, that the turnout and the ability to vote of the ethnic Uzbeks of southern Kyrgyzstan was sufficient, from the UN’s point of view?

Spokesperson: What we’ve said is that it really does demonstrate the aspiration of the people of Kyrgyzstan for peace and stability and democracy. That’s what we’ve said. That’s the first thing. The second thing is that we’re not suggesting that this is the end of the story, and that somehow this is perfect. It was not. There is work to be done, and the United Nations will continue to provide the technical support that’s required, not least by the Central Election Commission, so that they can improve further and not least so that when we get to the parliamentary elections at the end of this year, they will be in better shape to ensure that it’s as inclusive as possible.

Inner City Press: One last one on this, and thanks a lot. I think I had asked last week whether you could confirm what a UN official had told me — which is that the Constitution that was voted on and approved over the weekend on Sunday outlaws political parties based on ethnicity. And if so, that’s why I guess I’d be concerned, I’m wondering if the UN sees any connection between a group being targeted by violence, probably if the Associated Press can be believed, having a lower turnout than other groups and, therefore, in the future being prohibited from organizing around, I guess to protect their rights on the basis of their minority status. Were you able to confirm that that is in the Constitution?

Spokesperson: Not personally. But I am sure that my colleagues in DPA [Department for Political Affairs] can help me with that, and also my colleagues in Bishkek.

And then they gave it only in Russian...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/vote6kyrgyz062910.html

At UN, UK's Mitchell on Lack of Ethiopian Entrepreneurs, Ogaden Constituents

UNITED NATIONS, June 28 -- The new UK government has cut all aid to China and Russia, while contrasting the entrepreneurial spirit of Somalis with the lack of such drive in Ethiopia. This Inner City Press gleaned in ten minutes of questioning of David Cameron's minister for International Development Andrew Mitchell on Monday, on topic ranging from North Korea to Gaza to corruption. Video here, from Minute 4:33.

Inner City Press began by asking about Mitchell's review of the UK's existing aid programs, to China and also the UN Development Program, which maintains programs in China, North Korea and Myanmar. Mitchell maintained that the “best” approach is budget support to governments, but only if you can trust them.

He said reviews of “multilateral agencies” have begun. One wonders: if the UK has cut aid to China, will it cut aid to UNDP which spend in China? Or will it earmark it aid, to only some countries?

Mitchell went out of his way to praise the governments of Ghana and Rwanda. One wonders if the latter doesn't further the UK's move to “take” Rwanda away from the Francophonie. Because the UK's own BBC over the weekend reported how Hutu refugees in Uganda are afraid to go home, based on how they are treated -- with UK aid funds?

On camera, Inner City Press finished with a question about the UN “Gender Entity,” and the controversy about Syria's language on women under occupation. Mitchell jumped right in, saying that Gaza is troubling and the lifting of restrictions is heartening.

As he left the stake out, he greeted Inner City Press and mentioned reading it. With cameras off but still on record, he explained the David Cameron left people in posts for five years, to really learn their jobs. He said he visited 38 poor countries and produced a “green paper.”

Our conclusion is, he said, that conflict is what mires people in poverty. A country with entrepreneurs is not poor.

Inner City Press mentioned the entrepreneurialism of the Somalis. Yes, Mitchell said, contrasting it with Ethiopia, where he said the “sinews” of government are good, but where “perhaps because of Ethiopian history, there is not history of entrepreneurship.”

Inner City Press asked about the Ogaden region. “I have a large Ogaden constituency near me,” Mitchel said. Then why did he so fulsomely praise the sinews of Meles Zenawi's government? Perhaps we'll get an answer. Mitchell's candor was, to paraphrase something he said, a breath of fresh air.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uk1mitchell062810.html

At UN, Hyper Sexual Portrayal of Women Hit by Geen Davis and Ahmadinejad

UNITED NATIONS, June 28 -- With the UN abuzz with talk of women's rights, actress Geena Davis spoke to the Press Monday about the “hyper sexualized” portrayal of female characters in the media. She spoke of the showing of too much skin, of unrealistic curves.

It was somehow reminiscent of a UN appearance the previous money by Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who when Inner City Press asked about women's rights in Iran said that the West is worse, in its portrayal of woman as sex objects. Click here for that.

Inner City Press asked Geena Davis is she saw any overlap between her critique of media objectification of women and that of Ahmadinejad. Ms. Davis did not directly answer -- understandably, one of her UN handlers afterward said -- but rather turned her answer to the topic of Halloween, and the inability when getting a witch costume to get anything but the sexy witch. Video here, from Minute 29:58.

The UN hook, if there was one, was Ms. Davis' statement that she is partnering with UNIFEM. Inner City Press asked her to describe this partnership, what they work on together. “We haven't developed any specific projects,” Ms. Davis answered, adding that perhaps the new UN Gender Entity would.

On a big screen in the ECOSOC chamber, the image of former Chilean president Michelle Bachelet “live” from Johannesburg was frozen. Ms. Bachelet, to whom the top Gender Entity post was offered, Inner City Press is told, but rejected after the UN turned her down for UNICEF, deeming it an American job, was supposed to be in New York to appear in person. But that was conditioned on Chile already having lost in the World Cup. That wouldn't be until Monday afternoon, 3 to 1...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/gender1geena062810.html

Sri Lanka Block of Visas Unfortunate, Darusman Says, UN Says Visit Not Needed, How Panel Staffed Is Unclear

UNITED NATIONS, June 25 -- The UN panel on war crimes in Sri Lanka does not need to go to that country, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman has said. But the chairman of the panel, Marsuki Darusman, has now called Sri Lanka's decision to deny him and his two panel-mates visas “highly unfortunate” and a barrier to finding out the truth.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if Ban agrees that the denial of visas to the UN panel is unfortunate. Nesirky would not answer, but rather emphasized again that going is “not necessary... not required.” Video here, from Minute 22:24.

To some it seems that Mr. Ban is back to accommodating Sri Lanka. If a country like Sudan were to deny visas, the UN would condemn it. But because Sri Lanka has blustered every move, Ban is undercutting the panel and its chairman.

Inner City Press asked when the three panel members will meet, which will start ticking the four months until their report is due. In the coming month, Nesirky said, in July.

How will the panel be staffed? Nesirky said that these “finer points” have yet to be worked out. This is hard to understand, given that it was back on March 5 that Ban said he would appoint the panel “without delay.” What has the UN been doing? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri8bantor062510.html