Sunday, April 25, 2010

As UN Denies It Covered Up Kabul Murder of UN Workers, De Mistura Dodges, Nesirky Lashes Out at "Blog" Quoting Staff

UNITED NATIONS, April 21 -- With questions mounting about whether and why the Afghan National forces killed UN security officer Louis Maxwell in Afghanistan last October, and why the UN said nothing publicly about this until being repeatedly asked about it last week, things heated up Wednesday at the UN in New York.

After in Kabul Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's representative Staffan de Mistura dodged Afghan television questions about Maxwell's death, Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky, lashed out at Inner City Press' use in a "blog" of the word "cover up" This is how UN staff in Kabul who raised the issue to Inner City Press characterize the UN's response.

Inner City Press on Wednesday asked Nesirky if the UN has in its possession the weapon assigned to Louis Maxwell, or whether it was stolen during, and perhaps as the goal of, his murder. A witness has come forward about the

"people died in the guesthouse about forty yards from my door. One of those people was an American by the name of Louis Maxwell, a security guard for the United Nations...Louis Maxwell committed himself effectively and honorably and survived the Taliban attack. It was only after he came down from the roof, and after the ANP had secured the compound, that he was killed. According to video obtained by the UN, he was shot at point-blank range by Afghan police in the courtyard of the guesthouse. The reason? They wanted his gun."

Inner City Press asked Nesirky to state, yes or no, if the UN has Maxwell's gun in its possession. Rather than answer this question, Nesirky went into a seemingly prepared statement that, "let's be clear, you have written that' management of information is one thing, cover up and lies are another'... that is outrageous."

When Inner City Press explained that cover up and lies precisely the characterizations used by the UN staff in Kabul who have raised this to Inner City Press, Nesirky chided Inner City Press for not then putting the words in quotes and presumably identifying the speaker. But the UN has a history of retaliating against whistleblowers, so it is perhaps this request -- and misuse of the bully pulpit of the UN's briefing room rostrum -- which some find outrageous.

Once the UN became aware -- and more, with the video footage -- that Maxwell may have been executed by Afghan National forces, why did it say nothing publicly? Nesirky did not answer.

If this "Board of Inquiry," Ban Ki-moon's awareness of which his spokesman Nesirky would not describe, were to conclude that there is no definitive evidence Maxwell was killed by a particular member of the Afghan National forces, would the UN ever have disclosed the doubts and inquiry?

In Kabul, Ban's SRSG di Mistura was asked:

TV ONE [translated from Dari]: In view of recent comments by a UN spokesperson, I want to know your views on the UN staff member killed in the Bakhtar attack?

SRSG: Can I first reply to questions on the elections? Today we are focusing on questions on elections, but I will come back to you.

Before Inner City Press began asking questions about the death of Louis Maxwell, it received this and other requests:

Dear Matthew,

I wish to bring to your attention the disgraceful lack of action by the UN Secretary General in response to aspects of the tragic attack upon the Bakhtar Guesthouse in Kabul, Afghanistan on 28 October 2009 which resulted in the deaths of five UN staff members and injuries to many others. I am referring to the following facts which came to light during the investigation.

* UN Security Officer, Louis Maxwell, (US citizen), who heroically resisted the attackers thus allowing many others to successfully escape, was summarily executed at point blank range by an Afghan National Army member while in their custody, unarmed and not offering any resistance. The extra-judicial killing was captured on video by a staff member of the German Embassy and copies were provided to UN investigators. The video has since been posted on the German 'Der Spiegel' media site although they have failed to realise (or at least publish) what exactly it is they are airing. In the aftermath of the incident many Afghan security forces are interviewed on camera by the local Afghan media and one Army Officer admits killing an 'Arab' terrorist outside the guesthouse. (Mr. Maxwell was an African American). Irrespective of whether he was mistaken for one of the attackers, his killing was nothing short of murder. UN SG Ban has refused to allow the issue to be raised with the Afghan government for political reasons and wants the US authorities to handle the 'problem.'

* Three of the other staff members killed during the incident were actually shot by indiscriminate and undisciplined fire from the Afghan security forces. The only staff member to actually die from the attackers actions was the UNICEF staff member who burned to death.

SG Ban needs media pressure to explain his failure to follow up on this crime with the Government of Afghanistan to ensure that those responsible are held accountable for their actions.

Again, once the UN became aware -- and more, with the video footage -- that Maxwell may have been executed by Afghan National forces, why did it say nothing publicly? Does the UN have in its possession Louis Maxwell's weapon? Watch this site.

From the UN's April 21 transcript, Inner City Press' questions and OSSG's Nesirky's responses:

Question: I wanted first to… I have a question about Sudan from yesterday, but I wanted to follow up on this Afghanistan Board of Inquiry questions. One is that a witness to the events has come forward and said that Mr. Maxwell was killed for his gun, that the Afghan national forces wanted his high-end assault rifle, and therefore killed him to take it. They say it’s a… the gun is a Heckler and Koch g36k assault rifle. What I wanted to know is, even as this is going on, does the UN have in its possession at the end of those events the weapon used by Louis Maxwell in defending the other staff members? And also, is the Secretary-General, I think I’d asked this in a written question I sent to you, before Ms. [Susana] Malcorra convened this Board of Inquiry, was the Secretary-General aware of this issue and did he approve of the composition and mandate of the Board of Inquiry?

Spokesperson: Well, let’s roll back a little bit. As I have said, the Board of Inquiry is finalizing its report. It has not yet done so. It has not yet been presented to those, as I outlined, who would be presented either with the report or with the findings, depending on who it is. So, I can’t say here and now what the findings are, because that report has not been finalized and has not been handed over. Therefore, on a very specific question such as the weapon, I cannot give you an answer to that. This is a Board of Inquiry…

Question: [inaudible] factual question [inaudible]

Spokesperson: It may be a factual question, Matthew, and let us be really clear about one thing, I seem to recall that you have written somewhere that management of information is one thing, but cover up and lies are another. Well, let me say here and now that this is pretty outrageous and also insulting. We’re talking about the death of one of our staff, a UN security officer who helped to save many lives. It’s our responsibility, it’s our duty to find out the facts. That is exactly what we are doing. And this is a Board of Inquiry; everything is being done as it should. And once this has been finalized and given to those who need to know first, there will be a briefing, I am sure, as I have said, this has been done in the past. And there will be an opportunity for you to ask further questions.

Question: That’s from a communication actually from UN staff in Kabul who, when they initially raised this, said that they had been asking the Secretariat to raise this to the Afghan Government for months with no action. So, just so, you can say it’s outrageous, but I am saying…

Spokesperson: No, that’s…

Question: …those who work there…

Spokesperson: Matthew, Matthew, let’s be really clear. Let’s be really clear: what’s outrageous is what you wrote in your blog, not what you’ve just put to me. And I have just quoted you this one…

Question: [inaudible] believe that the Secretariat has covered up the death of one of their colleagues because it is inconvenient to raise it to the Afghan Government. Your response is that it is outrageous. That’s…

Spokesperson: No, it’s outrageous what you wrote. It was not a quote, it was not a quote. It’s what you wrote in your blog.

Correspondent: Okay, fine.

Spokesperson: And it was not a quote from someone.

Question: I didn’t know that this was a forum for you to critique articles, but I just wanted to know [inaudible].

Spokesperson: No, it is, because it is possible for me to respond to you in the same way that it is possible for you to respond to me. What I am trying to tell you is that -- let me finish. The UN lost a number of people, including the security officer, Mr. Maxwell, who had saved many lives. We want to know what happened. We’re looking into this. We want to know what happened. There is a Board of Inquiry that has looked into this and it is finalizing its report. That’s the most important thing that we’re trying to find out. We want to know. You want to know, we want to know. And when the Board of Inquiry has finalized its report, then those who need to know first of all, would be told.

Question: When was the UN going to say publicly that they were aware of an alternative theory of the death of Louis Maxwell and three other staff members?

Spokesperson: There is a Board of Inquiry that has been working on this for a long time. You’ve seen the timeline.

Question: But you’ve also said that if only in cases where, depending on the finding, it may or may not be made public. If this inquiry were done, and I think this was the sense of staff in Kabul, if the inquiry were done and the UN decided to conclude that there wasn’t conclusive evidence that Louis Maxwell was killed by Afghan national forces, would the UN have ever said anything publicly about this?

Spokesperson: There is no need for the United Nations to -- let’s put it this way, the United Nations wants to know. Colleagues want to know. Friends want to know. Family want to know. We want to know. He was our guy. We want to know what happened. And the Board of Inquiry is doing, and has been doing, the job that it was asked to do, which is to find out. There is a due process here that is being followed.

Question: Due process for who? For the Afghan national, unnamed Afghan national forces, that’s what I know; I mean due process usually means the accused.

Spokesperson: It means following the procedure for, with -- as I have said to you -- standard operational procedure for these kinds of boards within the United Nations. And I have said here before, that if warranted, this will be taken up with the Afghan authorities -- the findings.

Question: Okay. I know, I understand. Just to be clear, I just want your quote. To those who feel that the lack of any public statement by the UN from -- since October -- about this issue despite their knowledge amounts to a cover up, what would you say?

Spokesperson: Absolutely not the case. Absolutely not the case. This is a Board of Inquiry that was set up to look into what was obviously an extremely tragic event, and to ensure that, to the extent possible, we find out what happened. My point was to you Matthew, very specifically, about one line in your blog that was not a quote from people, it was something that was just written there.

Question: [inaudible] I don’t quote them because they’re speaking off… they believe that the UN would retaliate against them. I mean, that’s… maybe you are unaware of those concerns. I wanted to ask about Sudan, because I think we may have exhausted this, at least for today.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unleak5afgh042110.html

IMF Claims that Icesave Commitments Were "Not Critical," Dismisses Citigroup and Deutsche Bank Role

UNITED NATIONS, April 21 -- The $160 million the IMF is disbursing to Iceland was delayed for months. In Iceland's Letter of Intent leading to the disbursement, the government commits" to ensure that the United Kingdom and the Netherlands will be reimbursed in respect of deposits of Landsbanki [Icesave] branches in those two countries."

When the IMF's IMF mission chief to Iceland Mark Flanagan held a conference call on April 21, Inner City Press asked him to discuss the commitment of the government to pay principal and interest, and "reimburse" the UK and Netherlands.

Flanagan argued that the above quoted Paragraph 20 of the Letter of Intent was "not from us." He said, "any language was fine with us" and that the language was "not critical."

Some may find this hard to believe, akin to other IMF claims that it does not impose conditions any more, but simply makes suggestions. Inner City Press followed up by asking Flanagan to describe the IMF's -- including the Executive Board's -- communications with the Netherlands and UK.

Flanagan replied that IMF staff are "not involved in bilateral disputes." But what about the Executive Board, which in turn communicates with the IMF staff?

Inner City Press asked Flanagan for the IMF's thoughts on Iceland Central Bank governor Mar Gudmundsson April 16 statement to state TV station RUV that "a bank could collapse without me knowing of it. There haven’t been any changes, and all the problems that arose in the run up to the collapse and in the collapse are unsolved."

Flanagan said he wouldn't respond to the Central Bank governor's quote, because he didn't know its context. It seems pretty clear -- "there haven't been any changes."

The most recent report on Iceland identifies Citigroup, Deutsche Bank and Morgan Stanley among others as having fueled the crisis. Inner City Press asked Flanagan about these three companies and what is being done to see it doesn't happen in the future. While not responding directly, Flanagan said that there is nothing in the new report he wasn't aware of, and that he is confident that the government is dealing with all of it. We'll see -- watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf2iceland042110.html

On Volcanic Ash, ICAO Has No Standards, No Answers of EU's African Blacklist

UNITED NATIONS, April 21 -- The expectation was of volcanic ash when the two heads of the International Civilian Aviation Organization arranged to speak to the Press on Tuesday. They had come to the UN to meet with Ban Ki-moon, amid ash-trigger flight cancellations which even killed off the UN Security Council's long planned trip to the Congo to try to save its peacekeeping mission.

But after meeting Ban, they claimed that ash was not among the three main issues discussed: climate change, security against terrorism, and the reconstruction of Haiti.

Inner City Press asked, about criticism of ICAOs lack of leadership during the six days of flight cancellations. It is up to member states to decide when to close their air space, was the answer. But shouldn't ICAO develop standards, for the effects of ash concentration? It is not easy, the president off ICAO's Council Roberto Kobeh Gonzalez said.

Inner City Press asked about the decision by the European Union to block -- "blacklist" -- all aircraft from 13 African nations, as well as about the U.S. decisions after the so-called Nigerian underwear bomber.

Raymond Benjamin, ICAO Secretary General, tried to chide Inner City Press for mixing the two issues, and said that the U.S. blockages have all been resolved. But what about the EU blacklist?

When Pressed, the two men insisted that their only focus was safety. But when Inner City Press asked for their response to many letters asking that ICAO let in Taiwan -- province of China! -- at least as an observer, given the number of flights in and out of Taipei, they shook their heads. So are the letters a waste of time? Yes they are, was the answer from Raymond Benjamin, ICAO Secretary General. Video here. Only at the UN. Leaving the stakeout, one correspondent muttered, "What ashes."

And see, www.innercitypress.com/icao1ashes042110.html

Amid Fraud in Sudan and Kidnapping by Bashir-Affiliated Militia, UN Cuts Off Questions

UNITED NATIONS, April 21 -- With fraud exposed, on film, in the Sudanese election to which the UN provided technical assistance, and with four UN peacekeepers still missing in Darfur, apparently taken by a government affiliated militia, UN Spokesman Martin Nesirky on Tuesday cut off questions about Sudan and the election in favor of a press conference on Guatemala. Video here, from Minute 11:28.

On April 19, when Inner City Press asked for a response to the view that the kidnappers of the UN peacekeepers are from a government-aligned militia, Nesirky dodged the question. On April 20, he simply did not take the question.

Meanwhile, "UNAMID spokesperson Noureddine Mezni said, 'The Sudanese authorities know the identity of the kidnappers.'"

Consider that on the UN's own ReliefWeb site, it is reported that

"NYALA – A new group calling itself the Movement for the Struggle of the People in Darfur claims to have kidnapped four South African UNAMID peacekeepers in South Darfur. They want a ransom of an amount equivalent to half a million US dollars (a billion sudanese pounds) and the release of their 'detained leaders'... the group is part of the Irada Hura (SLM Free Will), a mixed group that signed a Declaration of Commitment after the Darfur Peace Agreemnent in Abuja. Their leader prof. Abdelrahman Musa died. The new leader, Ali Majok, was apparently appointed with support of the government and became a minister. But a faction within the group disagreed with his leadership. Adam Salih, another member of the faction, called for a meeting to contest the leadership. He formed in the meantime a new Movement for the Struggle of the People in Darfur."

Adam Salih, aka "Ahmad Salah Abubakr Abdallah" was previously associated with the "SLA Free Will" movement. The leader of the "Sudan Liberation Movement - Free Will faction had joined the national unity government" in 2008. "Aid agency sources say that SLA-Free Will is the creation of the GoS delegation in Abuja, whose goal is to split the rebels along tribal lines" [source]

"Ahmad Saleh, a Birgid, is a former SLA-Minni commander who joined SLA-Free Will in September 2006 and is believed to be close to the GoS" [source]

Amnesty International has implicated Adam Salih in "Janjaweed militia attacks"... [source]

So were the UN peacekeepers taken by a government-affiliated militia?

Is the UN not only "liaising" but negotiating with the government for their release?

Inner City Press, which has been asking the UN about its role in the re-election of indicted war criminal Omar al-Bashir, sought to proceed with the question, or to have Mr. Nesirky return to the rostrum after the Guatemala presentation. While Nesirky said, "Let's do that," he left the briefing and did not return. But the questions will continue. Watch this site.

From the UN's April 21 transcript, Inner City Press' questions and OSSG's Nesirky's responses:

Inner City Press: On Sudan, the missing or kidnapped peacekeepers in Darfur, it is now being reported that South African Government has been negotiating with the group and the group has said that they will release the peacekeepers once the election results are released in Darfur. There are also reports that this group, both by the name of its founder and otherwise, are a somewhat Government-supported militia. What I wanted to know is whether the UN has had any involvement in these discussions between the South African Government and the hostage takers or, and whether, what it would say to a trail of evidence that seems to indicate that the hostage takers are in fact in some way initially created by or affiliated with the Government of Sudan?

Spokesperson: I have mentioned here before that the UN is concerned for the well-being of the four people, the four South African peacekeepers who are missing. And I have also said that the UN has been liaising with the Government of Sudan and, as in other such cases, it’s the responsibility of the host Government to ensure the safe return of people in such circumstances. And beyond that, I don’t have any comment at the moment.

Question: Of the concern that this liaising, that in fact, I mean, there’s also been, a UNAMID Spokesman has said that the Government knows who the hostage takers are, so that’s why I am assuming that that’s a UN-wide position.

Spokesperson: At the moment…

Question: Is that a matter of concern to the UN; that the host Government is aware of and allegedly is connected to the hostage talkers, is that of some concern?

Spokesperson: At the moment, there are two things. One is that the overriding concern is, again, for our people on the ground. And for that reason, I don’t have anything further to say.

Question: But you will, I mean once they’re released maybe you will…?

Spokesperson: The whole aim of the game is for our colleagues to be returned safely.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan2progov042110.html

At UN, Ban Chooses Limousines Over Indigenous Drums, NGOs Complain of Exclusion

UNITED NATIONS, April 21 -- It was a tale of two UNs on Tuesday night: there was drumming and dancing in the General Assembly lobby as the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues began, while in the roped off elite area of the cafeteria, Israel sponsored a high security reception. Inner City Press was asked, which one did Secretary General Ban Ki-moon attend? The latter, was the answer, sending not an Under but Assistant Secretary General to address the assembled indigenous.

In attendance amid the drumming, despite many registrants being absent due to flights canceled by the Iceland's volcano's ash, were a range of what's called civil society and that stratum of the UN staff which serve them. Nearly uniformly there was dissatisfaction with Ban Ki-moon's lack of engagement with non governmental organizations and "regular people," and about the increasingly lack of access to the UN by civil society.

"He's taken the place back thirty years," a UN staffer said. Another wondered, even with the General Assembly building to remain open for the next two years, how long groups like the indigenous would be allowed to use the lobby. The Ban administration, an involved staffer disclosed, has asked that the exhibition walls in the lobby be removed so he can host a high level luncheon during this year's General Debate. The walls would not be reinstalled, and thus public exhibitions would cease.

A coalition on NGOs recently wrote to Ban to complain about deceasing access and got back what they called a mere form letter.

The UN, including under Ban, pays lip service to the value of civil society. But for the past three years, representatives say, it has been implemented less and less. For how much longer, they wondered Tuesday night, will this UN allow the drums to beat? Watch this space.

Footnote: the head of the Secretariat of the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, Inner City Press learned on Tuesday night, will be leaving the post this summer. The new chairman of the Forum, for the first time, was chosen by a government rather than civil society within his country. Things are changing at the UN, including at the Forum. Nothing, it seems clear, is Permanent. Reforms can be turned back as much as thirty years.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1pfii042110.html

At UN, Menchu Laments Rios Montt Impunity, Garzon Case, Free Press Letter Lost

UNITED NATIONS, April 20 -- The UN has a Commission against Impunity in Guatemala, but General Efrain Rios Montt still roams free in that country. On Tuesday in New York, Inner City Press asked Rigoberta Menchu if she thought Rios Montt would ever be brought to justice, and perhaps relatedly, what she thinks of the case in Spain against Judge Balthasar Garzon. Video here, at end.

Rigoberto Menchu said she doubted Rios Montt could be put on trial in Guatemala, at least not during her lifetime. She praised Garzon for pursuing the case, and said that the charges against him are probably political, noting that he also looked into the Spanish Civil War and aftermath. She lamented the changes in Spanish law that henceforth only cases involving Spanish victims, and perpetrators living in Spain, can be tried. So much for universal jurisdiction.

The Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala has a more limited mandate, and his involved going after the killers of bus drivers. Recently, however, it led the investigation into the national police chief, and identified the alleged killers of Victor Rivera, a Venezuelan security advisor killed in May 2008.

Carlos Castresana, the Commissioner of the International Commission against Impunity in Guatemala (CICIG), led the press conference, and described his role in the Victor Rivera and Baltazar Gomez cases.


Inner City Press' research found that the UN Development Program paid not only for his and Ms. Menchu's travel, but for a large delegation of current and past Guatemalan government and other officials.

Inner City Press asked Eduardo Stein, former Vice-President of Guatemala, if UNDP had paid for his travel. He launched into a justification of how much the delegation could teach as well as learn. Ms. Menchu, to her credit, chimed in on the follow up and said that if another organization could be found to pay for the tickets, let it step forward.

Gonzalo Marroquin, Vice-President of Inter-American Press Association, was asked about attacks on Guatemalan journalists and about a letter he wrote to the UN's Ban Ki-moon about the crack down on press freedom in Venezuela. Last week, Ban's spokesman Martin Nesiry merely confirmed receipt of the letter, but said to ask UNESCO for any response.

One wondered, has Ban Ki-moon outsourced press freedom to UNESCO, and human rights elsewhere? Is the idea or effect that people and organizations should stop writing him letters and petitions on these topics?

UNESCO, it emerges, has never heard of the letter. Something is wrong at and with the UN. But keep those cards and letters coming!

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1menchu042010.html

On Afghan Death of Louis Maxwell As UN Edits Board's Report, 11 Questions Pending

UNITED NATIONS, April 19, updated -- As the scandal grows about not only the presumptive execution of UN staffer Louis Maxwell by Afghan National forces in October 2009, but also the UN's cover-up, Inner City Press on April 19 delved into the particulars of the UN's supposed "high level Board of Inquiry" into the death of Mr. Maxwell, a U.S. citizen.

After having dodged Inner City Press' questions at the UN noon briefings of April 14 and April 15 by handing out answers to another media, on April 19 the UN took a series of questions and answered some of them by 6 pm. Inner City Press submitted follow up questions which, because of the history here, are set forth below. First, from the April 19 transcript:

Inner City Press: On Afghanistan, in continuing questioning on this death of Louis Maxwell and the other UN staff -- the guest house, you said last week that there was a high-level Board of Inquiry. I wanted to know what, and I had asked, somehow I didn’t… by high level, what’s meant? Are there any outsiders, an independent body? I’ve heard that it’s actually just DFS [Department of Field Support] employees, all of whom report to Susana Malcorra. Can you, if that’s not true, I would like to know. But, what does high-level mean, and will its report be made public or what will happen with its report? Under what mandate was it set up? I searched through various GA [General Assembly] and other documents, and there seems to be three kinds of boards of inquiry, none of which this one falls under. So I just, I guess I wanted to know…

Spokesperson Nesirky: What are the three?

Inner City Press: I have them written down here. Do you…

Spokesperson: We don’t have to go into it right now, but there are three different types…

Inner City Press: I’ll send these to you, but it wasn’t, you said, I think last week, you’d said that you know these are set up. So, I have to admit, maybe to my detriment, I don’t know actually know how they’re set up. But on this one, I would like to know whether it’s all DFS employees and whether it will be made public when it concludes its investigation.

Spokesperson: Three things: one is that the Board of Inquiry’s draft report has been completed, the draft. But that does not mean that it is finalized to go the Secretary-General. That’s the second point. The step after it is finalized would be for it to go the Secretary-General. Whether it’s subsequently made public is something that I can’t answer here and now. I would need to find out. I don’t know the answer to that right now. Clearly, there is a lot of public interest in this, and I’m sure that that would be taken into account. And as for the make-up of the board, who is on the board, I can’t give you names and numbers. What I can tell you is that, my understanding is that it is not exclusively in-house.

This is what I can tell you now -- to my understanding, as far as I know, this is not exclusively a board with in-house members. But the most important thing here is that regardless of the Constitution, the way that it is set up, it has the very clear aim of trying to understand precisely what happened. These are very tragic circumstances, and this was aimed to do an extremely thorough job to find out exactly what happened.

Inner City Press: When this first came up last week, it was said that there is a Board of Inquiry and that it will be done in due course. When was this draft completed, and what are the steps between where it stands now -- the draft? Was it completed over the weekend, or had it already been completed before these questions arose last week, and what steps between now and the Secretary-General getting it?

Spokesperson: When a draft report is completed, then it is clear that it is reviewed. And, then, before it is submitted to the Secretary-General, it is reviewed. That’s a normal, if you like, checks-and-balance kind of procedure that you would have with any report. Other people look at it and then it is finalized to go to the Secretary-General.

Inner City Press: [inaudible] because, like when you say reviewed, I had asked, by who, just because last week we had the experience of the [Heraldo] Muñoz Bhutto panel; they did their report; they didn’t show it to anyone until they gave it to the Secretary-General. So, it was an outside report…

Spokesperson: That’s right.

Inner City Press: In this case, is it Susana Malcorra reviewing it? Is it UNAMA [United Nations Assistance Mission for Afghanistan]? Is it the Afghan national forces? Who reviews it?

Spokesperson: I cannot give details to you on that right now. I am sure I will be able to. I need to establish exactly what hoops I jump through.

The UN later added to its transcript this "note" --

[The Spokesperson later added that it is standard procedure to convene a board of inquiry in cases such as this. This particular board was convened under the authority of the Under-Secretary-General of the Department of Field Support and was comprised of external and internal senior personnel with relevant backgrounds and Afghanistan expertise (security; investigations; agencies, funds and programmes). It was led by a former senior Australian Federal Police Officer.

The procedure for the conclusion of the board of inquiry is as follows: the board finishes and submits the draft report for legal comment. The report is then given back to the board for further action (as required) and/or sign-off. Once the report is signed off on by board members it is considered finalized and it is presented to the convening authority, in this case the Under-Secretary-General for Field Support, for further action as warranted. The actual boards of inquiry are not made public in order to protect the confidentiality of the investigation.]

Receiving this, Inner City Press submitted follow up questions, which are printing here because last week, when Inner City Press asked questions on the record in the noon briefing, Nesirky's Office and his Associate Farhan Haq chose to give the answers to another media.

Here are the new questions, we'll see to whom if anyone the UN Office gives answers:

Hello. Regarding the UN's answers, below, please answer these follow up questions, providing answers as they become available--

1. What is your reference when you say "standard procedure"? Can you please provide the citation for DFS BOIs which examine the death of a UN Security Officer?

2. In the event that the BOI finds the Host Government (Afghanistan) or an agent thereof responsible for the death of Mr Maxwell, will your office make this fact known to the UN Press Corps? Or would the UN consider this "confidential" as well?

3. Prior to Ms Malcorra "convening" the BOI, was the Secretary-General aware of her intention to do so, and did he approve the composition and mandate of this particular BOI?

4. Did this BOI include any staff member or nominee from any department other then DPKO and/or DFS?

5. You say below that the report has been "returned to BOI members." When will the report been/be provided to the Secretary-General?

6. Has or will the report been/be provided to the Host Government (Afghanistan)?

7. Has or will the report been/be provided to the US FBI?

8. News reports indicate that the video was provided to Stern "by the United Nations." Can you confirm or deny this assertion.

9. Did the BOI consider the wider issue of whether or not the initial attack was actually perpetrated by the Taliban, as originally reported by the UN, as opposed to having been perpetrated by another entity?

10. Has or will the report been/be provided to the family of Mr Maxwell.

11. Did the Government of Afghanistan cooperate fully with the BOI?

While as of press time no answers were provided by the UN, Ms. Malcorra herself may have an excuse, auto responding that

"I will be out of the office starting 17/04/2010 and will not return until 27/04/2010."

Note that the head of DPKO Alain Leroy is, one assumes, still on the ten day leave the UN said began on April 9. Others say they saw Leroy squiring Kofi Annan around on April 19. Welcome back, Kofi? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unleak4afgh041910.html

At UN, No Answers on Sudan Election Flaws Hostage Takers of Peacekeepers

UNITED NATIONS, April 19 -- On Sudan, the UN on Monday dodged questions not only about irregularities in the elections to which it ostensibly provided technical assistance, but even about its own peacekeepers taken hostage.

While it appears that the hostage takes are government affiliates faux rebels in Darfur, UN spokesman Martin Nesirky doggedly maintained that the UN is working with the government to secure their release. He did not disclose whether the UN or South Africa, from which the peacekeepers come, is considering paying ransom, financial or political.

From the April 19 UN noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: the so-called Sudan troika -- it’s the United Kingdom, Norway and the United States -- they put out a statement this morning by the United States State Department, saying that the elections in Sudan failed to meet international standards, and this, the quote I wanted to ask you about: “We regret that the National Elections Commission (NEC) did not do more to prevent and address such problems prior to voting.” Since it was described that the UN was providing technical assistance to the NEC, what does the UN say of this criticism implicitly of its own work, working with the NEC and the statement that elections didn’t meet international standards?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I think there are two things here. One is that, most importantly, the elections, despite the reported irregularities and other difficulties, took place without any major incident of violence. I think that’s important to note. The second is that, you’ve mentioned it yourself, the UN’s role was indeed to provide technical assistance. And the UN did so. It was for the National Election Commission actually to conduct the elections and that’s what they did. Anything beyond that is trying to divide things a little bit, and I don’t think that that’s the way that we would see it. We would see it as the UN providing electoral assistance, technical electoral assistance, and then it was for the National Election Commission to then conduct the elections.

Inner City Press: But how does the UN judge the efficacy of its technical assistance other than by the performance of the entities to which it provides technical assistance, you know what I mean? I am not actually trying to divide it. I am trying to say, if you’re in the business of helping the entity, what’s the response to the criticism of what they, are you saying that the NEC didn’t follow the advice of the UN or…?

Spokesperson: No, I said what I said. Matthew, I think one of the points here is that we’ve said all the way along that this is extremely complex and an extremely challenging exercise for all concerned. And what we’ve been providing is advice on fairly technical matters, including voter registration, and the counting, and tabulation and announcement of results, and training plans and materials, this kind of thing -- and helping to provide assistance, technical assistance for voter education. But ultimately, it is the National Election Commission that makes the decisions and then runs the process.

Inner City Press: Also on Sudan, I wanted to -- last week there were these reports of a ransom demand for the missing peacekeepers, and the group that’s listed as making the demand turns out to apparently be kind of a Government proxy; it’s really a rebel group. It was accused of being a pro-Government entity in Darfur. I’m wondering, since this time has gone by, what can you say about the status of these peacekeepers? And there is one South African media account saying that the UN has requested a media ban of any discussion of this hostage taking. Is that accurate or not accurate?

Spokesperson: What I can tell you is that our colleagues on the ground there are clearly very well aware of the fact that four of our peacekeepers, police officers as you pointed out, South African nationals, are missing. We are clearly in contact with the Government of Sudan and, as in all such cases, it’s the host Government that is the one that is responsible for helping to ensure that people being held or missing are returned safely.

Inner City Press: Okay. So, I mean, this idea that there is a media ban, is there a media ban?

Spokesperson: I have told you what I’ve told you, which is that the United Nations is working with the host Government; it’s for the host Government to do its utmost as in all such cases to help to ensure that people who work for the United Nations are returned.

But the kidnappers, it appears clear, are a government affiliated militia... Watch this site.

Footnote: US President Barack Obama was meeting Scott Gration on April 19 about the elections, but nothing has yet been announced. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan5vote041910.html

At UN, Sri Lanka Gets $3M from Ban, Fixes Panel and Pushes Its Troops, Protests and New School DPR

UNITED NATIONS, April 19 -- As the UN's Ban Ki-moon talks about but has yet to establish a group of experts to advise him on war crimes in Sri Lanka, he quietly decided earlier this year to give $3 million in UN funds to government approved projects.

On April 13, Inner City asked German Ambassador Peter Wittig, Chairman of the UN Commission, about the UN's $3 million grant, and whether the war crimes, reconciliation and other issues mentioned by Secretary General were taken into account.

Ambassador Wittig referred the question to a Peacebuilding Support Office staff James Otobo, who confirmed that it was the Secretary General, ultimately, who declared Sri Lanka eligible for the funds and disbursed them. He said "we were torn" because there are "still some of the issues you talked about." But were or are there any safeguards?

Likewise, what safeguards are there as the UN uses, and Sri Lanka now offers more, soldiers for UN peacekeeping missions, including many who served in the final phase of the war in northern Sri Lanka? Inner City Press asked on April 5

Inner City Press: the Government of Sri Lanka has said that it’s gonna up its contribution to UN peacekeeping from the current 950 to 5,000 troops. Since the Secretary-General has said there are these open questions about accountability for the conflict there, one, has DPKO agreed to this five-fold increase? And two, what safeguards are in place to make sure that the troops that may have engaged in crimes of war don’t become peacekeepers?

Deputy Spokesperson: This is a report that I am hearing about for the first time. DPKO, I am sure, is listening, and I am sure they will get back to us with an answer.

And later, surprisingly, they did:

Subject: Answer to your question on Sri Lanka offer to increase its contribution to UN peacekeeping
From: DPKO @un.org
To: Inner City Press

Dear Matthew, Kindly find hereby the answer to your question on Sri Lanka's offer to increase five-fold its contribution to UN peacekeeping: Does DPKO accept this offer?

Are there safeguards in place, considering concerns about human rights in Sri Lanka?:

"Sri Lanka has been a regular contributor to peacekeeping operations. It has a battalion in United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), since 2004. Recently, Sri Lanka has also deployed an aero-medical evacuation team to the United Nations mission in the Central African Republic and Chad (MINURCAT) and is yet to send a second aero-medical evacuation team to the same mission. Sri Lanka has shown interest in contributing additional forces to various missions like United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) and any future missions. But offers have not yet been accepted. In this case, like in various other cases, the danger of soldiers accused of human rights violations being part of contingents put at the disposal of the UN peacekeeping does exists. The UN has no means of vetting individual contingent members. The UN rely on the national government authorities to ensure that such elements are not deployed. This aspect will furthermore be highlighted to the national authorities prior the future deployment of their contingents to the various UN peacekeeping missions".

As the UN doles out $3 million to Sri Lanka, and prepares to give more for unvetted peacekeeepers, Inner City Press hears that the country's Attorney General has come to meet with Team Ban, to put in the fix on the advisory committee. Still, nothing has been announced.


Rather, on April 16 students from schools in more than three states protested in front of the Sri Lankan Mission, on Third Avenue by the UN, demanding justice for J.S. Tissainayagam. No one deigned to come down from the Mission office to address the students.

But, on April 19, Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative to the UN Palitha Kohona invited Inner City Press and others to his 38th floor residence, to meet his new deputy Bandula Jayasekara. Present were DPRs from South Korea and Norway -- Mona Juul, perhaps out of penance -- and a contingent from Japan.

Bandula Jayasekara came three weeks ago from Toronto, and already spoke out in favor of Israel leaving its Occupied Territories. Some saw the irony, but Bandula Jayasekara told Inner City Press he is a "new school" diplomat, nothing off the record, nothing that can't be asked about. How about the popular musician MIA? "She's not popular," he answered, adding "we all have our jobs and should all have fun." The dead don't find it so funny. What was that again, that Ban Ki-moon said about accountability? Watch this site.

Footnote: on the Non-Aligned Movement's Kohona-procured letter protesting the group of experts to Ban on war crimes in Sri Lanka, Inner City Press asked Egypt's Ambassador last week if, with his second letter essentially withdrawing the first, the issue was over. He nodded and headed up the stairs away from the Security Council. But the first NAM letter was helpful to Sri Lanka - and perhaps to Ban Ki-moon, to explain or defend his delay and inaction. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/lanka8unfollow041910.html