Saturday, April 17, 2010

At UN, Council Excludes Spokesman's Office Without A Fight, Ineptitude or Nationality?

UNITED NATIONS, April 15, updated -- A shift of power has taken place in the UN, with UN Secretariat staff now barred from Security Council consultations, and it is unclear what role ineptitude has in the power play.

Until now, when the 15 members of the UN Security Council met behind closed doors, representatives of the Secretary General's Office of the Spokesman, and UN Peacekeeping staffers, could attend.

Beginning earlier this month, the UN Spokesperson's Office and most Peacekeeping staffers have been barred from consultations. Several of these staffers have complained to Inner City Press, how can they implement or explain the Council's mandates if they cannot hear what members think?

But for Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson's Office to be barred raises other issues, several journalists say. Already, they say, new Spokesperson Martin Nesirky finds it difficult to answer questions, even if he wants to, due to lack of sources.

They marvel that Nesirky did not himself fight for access to consultations, but instead sent his Deputy Marie Okabe. Whether this was because Nesirky was away on travel through Central Asia, or because Ms. Okabe is Japanese like this month's Council president Yukio Takasu is not known. But the reporters slammed Nesirky for allowing his Office to lose power without even putting up a fight.

"Fred Eckhart would never have allowed this," one said, referring to Kofi Annan's long time spokesman.

"Even Stephane Dujarric," chimed in another, referring to the spokesman for the latter stage Kofi, now with UNDP.

In most mature political systems, separation of powers questions are not resolved in such ad hoc, incompetent ways. But perhaps the UN is not a mature political system.

Footnotes: Council president Yukio Takasu on April 15 was asked if there was any progress on restoring to the UN press corps at least as much access as they had on the second floor, before the Council moved to the UN's basement. Takasu called it a work in progress. Later, a UN Security official told Inner City Press, you have good news. Did it refer to access to the stairs, to be able to discourse with willing Ambassadors as they leave the Council? We'll see.

Update of April 16: while access has still not been granted to the stairs, the pen to which the press is confined has been made smaller. There are moves afoot to install a UN TV camera trained on the Council entrance. "There'll be five years of this," one Ambassador quipped to Inner City Press as he left the Council.

While the Office of the Spokesperson for the Secretary General was losing access to information with out a fight, its Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq was doling out response to questions asked at the UN's noon briefing to media other than the one that asked. Such selective propaganda is another low point for the Office, perhaps not unrelated to its increasing loss of access, relevance and credibility.

Update of April 16: At Friday's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Martin Nesirky if the work of his Office suffered due to exclusion from Council consultations. He responded that he is still trying to understand the changes. We will revisit this issue.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ossg1excluded041510.html

UN's Ban Met Otunbayeva Twice Before Bakiyev Was Toppled, Stealth Johnny Appleseed

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- Days after the UN refused to answer if Secretary General Ban Ki-moon met with Rosa Otunbayeva before she replaced President Bakiyev as ruler of Kyrgyzstan, then referred only to a meeting by Ban's political advisor Lynn Pascoe, Inner City Press learned that Ban attended two meeting with Ms. Otunbayeva, before Bakiyev's overthrow.

Sources told Inner City Press that Ban attended two meetings, one closed and an open one with parliamentarians, at which Otunbayeva spoke to him. While Ban did not do a projected media availability on April 15 after he briefed the Security Council on his Central Asia trip, Inner City Press caught up with Lynn Pascoe in his wake.

Inner City Press asked Pascoe to confirm or deny that Ban met twice with Otunbayeva. To his credit, Pascoe confirmed it. There were three things, he said. The first, the S-G with parties, opposition parties, Rosa Otunbayeva spoke. And then with the parliament. In the first, she raised the question of opposition folks who were demonstrating. The S-G said, I'm going to be taking meetings, I have Pascoe. So I did it.

Ban's associate spokesperson Farhan Haq, when Inner City Press asked in writing if Ban had met Otunbeyeva, said he would not comment on the new leader. Then when Inner City Press asked Martin Nesirky, Ban's spokesman, Nesirky mentioned only the Pascoe meeting. He used the word "singular," which no longer makes sense: there was more than one opposition leader met with, and more than one meeting, even with Ban.


On April 12, Inner City Press asked for a "readout on what opposition leaders did the UN delegation meet with while in Kyrgyzstan?"

Spokesperson Nesirky: I think it is singular rather than plural, and it was Ms. Otunbayeva. This was a meeting with about half a dozen representatives, mostly journalists and including Ms. Otunbayeva. This took place during the Secretary-General’s visit. The Secretary-General was in other meetings, and he asked Mr. Pascoe and a number of other advisers who were travelling in that delegation to Central Asia to meet with them and they were then able to report to the Secretary-General on the conversation.

Inner City Press: Did they make any predictions? Or is it possible to get kind of a readout of what was discussed at the meeting?

Spokesperson: No, I do not think it is possible to have a readout of that meeting in itself, because that goes beyond normal diplomatic practice.

Inner City Press asked Pascoe about this on April 15, that his meeting was with "mostly journalists." Pascoe said, "I saw that and I cringed a little bit, there were several opposition figures."

To some it appears that the UN is playing down -- to put it diplomatically -- Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's pre-overthrow meetings with opposition leader Rosa Otunbayeva.

But why? Some point to the obvious double standards of having denounced the ouster of President Zelaya from Honduras and the leader of Niger, but not this. On that, we will continue to report. Watch this site.

Footnote: the split between Pascoe and the UN spokespeople is highlighted, not to discourage Pascoe from saying what happened, but to encourage the spokespeople to.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un3kyrgyz041510.html

For UN Climate Job, 11 Candidates Including from Barbados and UN, Pasztor's Only Partial Recusal

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- With the UN's approach to climate change under fire, both politically and scientifically, the race is on to replaced Yvo de Boer as head of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. So far two candidates have come to UN headquarters and held press conferences: Costa Rica's Christiana Figueres and, on April 15, Barbados' Elizabeth Thompson.

Inner City Press asked Ms. Thompson for her position on the widespread criticism of how the Copenhagen summit was run. She replied that there were both positives and negatives.

She declined to comment on IPCC chairman Rajendra Pachauri's refusal to disclose how much is paid by Deutsche Bank and Credit Suisse, among others, for his climate advisory services. She said she would comply with UN rules. Video here.

Later on April 15, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky how many candidates there are, and whether Janos Pasztor, Ban Ki-moon's main climate advisor, is one of them:

Inner City Press: how many candidates have been put forward? And can you say either by country or region? What can you say on that topic? And can you confirm that Mr. [Janos] Pasztor is actually one of the candidates, the current advisor to the Secretary-General on climate change?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, two things. One is that, as we have mentioned before -- and it is standard practice, not just for this job but for any job -- we do not reveal the names of candidates. But I can tell you that there are 11 candidates from 11 different countries. And although we do not normally comment, as I said, on individuals, we obviously understand the interest in a candidate that works for the Secretariat and therefore we can confirm that Mr. Pasztor has been nominated by the President of Hungary. The appointment will be made following a normal competitive process run by a selection committee and in consultation with the bureau of the UNFCCC. All candidates will go through the same process. I should tell you -- and this is important -- upon the announcement of his candidacy, Mr. Pasztor was asked to dissociate himself from activities relating to the UNFCCC with immediate effect.

Inner City Press: But how is that possible, to perform the job that he is conducting without in some way dealing with the UNFCCC? Can you explain that?


Elizabeth Thompson on April 15, UN rules and Pasztor not shown

Spokesperson: What I can tell you is that it will be dealt with in a transparent manner and Mr. Pasztor’s office is clearly not involved in the process of selecting a successor to Yvo de Boer. And, as I say, he has been asked to dissociate from activities that relate to the UNFCCC, and that is with immediate effect. And that is what is happening.

This seems like a fake and flimsy safeguard. How can one function as the UN Secretariat's main climate advisor while "dissociat[ing one]self from activities relating to the UNFCCC"? For that, with all due respect for the affable Mr. Pasztor, one should quit or take a leave of absence. It's what Shashi Tharoor did, for example, while he ran unsuccessfully for Secretary General.

It is not enough to says like Ms. Thompson one would abide by UN rules -- because, in essence, there are no UN rules. Watch this space.

Footnote: even to the use of the UN's press briefing room, the stated rule is, questions only by journalists. But at Thursday's session, various Caricom Ambassadors spoke up with prepared statements endorsing Ms. Thompson and nothing was said about it. It's not the ambassadors' fault -- it's the fault of Media Accrditation, which in turn fingers the UN Spokesperson's Office. So when the UN cites its suppposed rules against journalists...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/fccc1pasztor041510.html

Condi Rice and Saudi Spy Chief Refused to Talk with UN Bhutto Panel, No Khalilzad Either

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- In investigating the murder of Benazir Bhutto, the UN Commission of Inquiry lead by Chile's Heraldo Munoz was urged to interview Condoleezza Rice, Hamid Karzai and the intelligence chiefs of the UAE and Saudi Arabia.

When Munoz unveiled the report on April 15, Inner City Press asked him pointedly if he had, in fact, been rebuffed by Condi Rice and by Saudi Arabia's Mugran bin Abdul Aziz. Munoz said that while some had declined to be interviewed, the Commission had received information that it needed.

Inner City Press insisted -- did he interview Condi Rice or not? No, Munoz conceded. Condoleezza Rice had said she was "not available." Video here, near end.

Why would a former U.S. Secretary of State refuse to meet with the UN Commission of Inquiry into the death of an icon like Benazir Bhutto? Condi Rice's spokeswoman Carolyn Beswick has said that Mr. Rice "does not give interviews."

After the press conference, Inner City Press asked Munoz fellow panelist Marzuki Darsman, the former attorney general of Indonesia, if he had interviewed Mugran bin Abdul Aziz. The answer was no, and also no for former US Ambassador to the UN Zalmay Khalilzad, intimitately involved in negotiating Benazir Bhutto's return to Pakistan.

As Inner City Press told Pakistani television channels after the press conference, the report thus raises more questions. Watch this site.

Footnote: Pakistan's Ambassador Haroon, who had be slated to speak with the Press at 5:15 at the Security Council stakeout, canceled that appearance at the last moment -- but not before the 15 Council members' flags had been moved to cover up the words "Security Council" on the backdrop behind the microphone. Is Pakistan worried about being put, like Afghanistan, on the Security Council's agenda?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/bhutto1norice041510.html

UN Silent on Haiti Evictions, Says Rented Love Boat is Not a Luxury

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- While the UN speaks of the humane relocation of Haitians, on April 9 the Haitian National Police summarily evicted over 7000 people from the Sylvio Cator soccer stadium in Port-au-Prince. The stadium's managers said that "the Taiwanese are planning to repair the bleachers and replace the artificial turf," which the earthquake survivors had reportedly damaged.

The UN had send Deputy Secretary General Asha Rose Migiro to Haiti for the three month anniversary of the January 12 earthquake. On April 15, Inner City Press asked DSG Migiro if the UN had planned any role in the eviction, if the UN had been informed by the HNP, which UN officials have described as a "partner," prior to the evictions.

DSG Migiro said that despite her visit, she was unaware of the eviction. She said that some relocations are involuntary, but are intended to move people to higher ground before the rainy season. Those in the soccer stadium, however, were merely given one small tent per family, and were otherwise left to fend for themselves.

By contrast, the UN system has rented luxury cruise ships on which to house its international staff. Inner City Press asked Ms. Migiro about these ships. She disputed that they were luxury liners, despite the ship's owner's own photographs. She said she had been aware of the controversy, but had not visited the ships.

After her press conference, several correspondents remarked how her presentation style has improved since the halting and hurried MDGs presentations earlier in her tenure. The Secretariat's communications arm, on the other hand, seems to be moving backwards. Wednesday that Office said it would explain why Ms. Migiro's predessessor Mark Malloch Brown was at the UN Chief Executives Board meetings last week in Vienna. But a day later, no answer has been provided.

Footnotes: Later on Thursday, as SG Ban Ki-moon marched with his entourage into the Security Council, Mr. Ban asked Inner City Press about the new press arrangements. We still have less access that before, Inner City Press replied, but pointed out that after a fight, the press was allowed in a pen in front of the Council entrance. Mr. Ban indicated, seemingly joking, that this made him more vulnerable. But there are questions to be answered.

Among them is why the UN said nothing when it learned that its U.S. staff member Louis Maxwell and other colleagues in Kabul were quite possible killed by Afghan National forces and not the Taliban. Already this week Mr. Ban has said he was unaware of the case of Al-Tijani Al-Sissi Ateem, who was recruited as a pro-government Darfur rebel leader by the UN-AU mediator Djibril Bassole while Ateem was being paid as a UN staffer. (Inner City Press has been promised both contact information for Mr. Bassole, and a further answer about his activities, neither of which has yet been provided).

Will Ban say he is unaware of the troubling case of Louis Maxwell? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/haiti1dsg041510.html

IMF Coy with Ukraine Numbers, Denies Pakistan Conditions, Ignores Haiti Question

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- While the IMF on Thursday proudly announced Greece's request to discuss IMF "fund program engagement," questions emerged about conditions the IMF imposes and how transparent they are.

Inner City Press asked for confirmation that the IMF is "pressuring Ukraine's government to set a budget deficit goal of six percent of GDP -- did Managing Director Dominique Strauss Kahn discuss this issue, and this number, with Mr. Yanukovych on Monday?"

IMF spokesperson Caroline Atkinson, who like her colleagues often denies that the IMF pressures any government to do anything, this time replied that "we do not go public with numbers until we're closer" to a deal.

Inner City Press also asked "In Pakistan, there have been protests against the Value Added Tax the protesters say the IMF is requiring be imposed. What is the relation of the VAT to what the IMF will propose to the Executive Board on May 3 regarding Pakistan?"

Ms. Aktinson said "governments decide what measures to implement... we help [with] the size of the adjustment measures."

But Colombia is being offered a facility with no conditions. Inner City Press asked, comparing it to Ukraine and Pakistan, "Would the facility to Colombia which Mr. Lipsky has spoken in favor of come with any similar conditions, or any conditions or recommendations at all?"

Ms. Atkinson said that no conditions are required if "policies are strong." Clearly this would not apply to Greece.

It is also unclear how the IMF decides which opposition parties to meet with, and what instructions it gives them. Inner City Press asked a question which Ms. Atkinson summarized rather than directly answer. The question was, "Following the IMF's Bakker's meeting w/ Bulgarian opposition parties, it appears that IMF disagrees with their characterization of the meeting. Does IMF tell its interlocutors how to describe such meetings, or not to describe them? Will there be any changes in IMF meetings with opposition parties?"

Ms. Atkinson, after her summary, said that "we have different exchanges" with opposition parties "when relevant." She did not answer what instructions or conditions the IMF imposes on such meetings.

Inner City Press asked, The "Haiti Recovery Act" passed by the U.S. House of Representatives calls for the IMF to forgive all outstanding debt of Haiti. Why has the IMF not done so yet, and when will the Managing Director finally make his proposal to the Board?"

But this question, a follow up to an inconclusive Q&A with Mr. Strauss Kahn at the UN on March 31, was not even acknowledged, must less answered. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1ukhipak041510.html

As UN's Doss Hit by OIOS, Council Tries to Save MONUC, Rice Defended, NGOs on Tap

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/doss9boot041410.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- The day after the UN's top envoy to the Congo Alan Doss dodged the Press by canceling a scheduled question and answer session, it emerged that Doss is named as a wrongdoer in the long delayed Office of Internal Oversight Services probe of his e-mail urging the UN Development Program to show him "lee-way" and give his daughter a job.

Inner City Press first published Doss' nepotism e-mail, and reported on the macing and arrest of the UNDP staffer whose job was given to Rebecca Doss, Nicola Baroncini. Mr. Baroncini remains waiting for his day in court.

Earlier this week, Inner City Press asked chief UN spokesman Martin Nesirky how it could take nine months to investigate Doss' six line e-mail, and Nesirky did not explain. Now Nesirky's associate Farhan Haq has said to Turtle Bay that "There is a draft investigative detail, provided only to Mr. Doss for his comment before a report is finalized. Once finalized, the report will be sent to the secretary-general."

Inner City Press has in the past asked both Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his top Peacekeeper, Alain Leroy, about l'affaire Doss. Now with the Security Council headed Friday to Kinsasha to try to save the peacekeeping mission Doss has overseen, the negative finding against Doss hurts not only him but the UN.

On this trip, the French mission has said that eight of the Council's 15 members are sending their top representatives, five are sending "Deputy Permanent Representatives" and two, only advisors. While the U.S. seems to qualify for this last designation, since DPR Alejandro Wolff is not going, it emerged on Wednesday that France was considering the U.S. Brooke Anderson as a DPR, despite her current "number four" (at best) status in the U.S. Mission.

While the Mexicans and Chinese were targeted by France as only sending advisors, from these quarters came a cry of double standards, that the U.S. would be let off the hook. China has no sitting DPR at present, unlike the US. And Mexican Perm Rep Heller is in fact going to more countries in Africa at the same time, for the Somalia Sanctions Committee.

Substantively, Austria has pushed to have Congolese NGOs flown from Goma to Kinshasa to brief the Council. A US Mission representative, reflexively defensive of Susan Rice's non attendance on family issues grounds, nevertheless trashed the Council for not traveling to Goma. But others asked, if you send your Number Four, who are you to criticize? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/doss9boot041410.html

UN Slammed for Bias by Darfur Rebels, Deferred Answer About Rebel UN Selected

UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- Questions about the UN in Sudan focus not only on the dubious quality of electoral technical assistance, but also impartiality. Most recently the Justice and Equality Movement has criticized the UN's handpicking of representatives of internally displaced people, arguing that the selections are intended to make Omar Al Bashir look good.

The UN feigns surprise, and then offers vague denials. From the April 14 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: on Sudan, the Justice and Equality Movement [JEM] has raised concerns about the way in which UNAMID [African Union-United Nations Hybrid Operation in Darfur] and the Joint Mediator [for Darfur], Mr. [Djibril] Bassolé, are selecting IDP representatives for the Doha process. They are saying, I guess according to them, that the selection is untransparent and is being done in a way that is pro-Government and slated to make things look better than they are in Darfur. I wanted to know… and you can read it; it is by Ahmed Hussein, the spokesman of JEM. What I am wondering is what is the UN, UNAMID, and Mr. Bassolé’s criteria for selecting IDP representatives? And I also wanted to just follow up of yesterday’s -- how do we get questions answered by Mr. Bassolé, including his recruitment of a seeming UN staff member to be a representative in the Doha process?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, Mr. Bassolé’s office has informed us of the following: Dr. Al-Tijani Al-Sissi [Ateem] is a former employee of the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa (ECA). He has never been employed by any UN entity headed by the Joint Chief Mediator. He is taking part in the negotiations now in his personal capacity and no longer has any institutional links to the United Nations. The Mediator is aware that Dr. Tijani was a UN staff member and that he has resigned. That is what I have for you from Mr. Bassolé’s office.

[The Spokesperson later added that UNAMID has taken note of the criticism from JEM and believes that its approach to civil society selection is methodical and well thought out.]

Inner City Press: The reason it would be good to be in touch with that office is that ECA has said that in February of this year, that when he travelled to Doha, he was still an ECA staff member. He was invited by the Joint Mediator. So the question really is, in what capacity was he invited? Was he already invited as a participant in the talks reportedly representing the Fur people, or was he invited as a UN staff member? And if he was invited as a participant, how does it square with the UN staff rules, because he did not stop getting paid until March? Who paid for his travel?

Spokesperson: Matthew, you asked me that question after the briefing yesterday, and you also asked Nick Birnback the same question, and both of us have said we will find out and give you the information. If I had had it to give to you now, I would have given it to you. What I have given is what I have.

And so we'll wait for more. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan4vote041410.html

UN Science Under Fire, Pharma Role in Swine Flu to Pressure on Lancet on MDG 5

UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- The UN system and World Health Organization made much of swine flu, and pharmaceutical companies made much money selling vaccines. On April 14, Inner City Press asked WHO's Margaret Chan how she could accept as a major advisor a man who heads a group lobbying for vaccine makers. Video here, from Minute 32:58.

WHO's Doctor Chan said "I respect the media" but "we have to work together to get the right information out." Next to her, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon nodded. He was headlining a press conference about material mortality. While the UN says that the situation has not gotten better, The Lancet has reported a 35% decrease in the past 28 years.

The Lancet's editor has said he was pressure not to release this positive news while the UN is seeking to raise funds. Mr. Ban denied this, calling it "speculation and rumor." It was unclear if he meant that the Lancet's editor had been misquoted, or was simply wrong.

Earlier, the UN's flu coordinator David Nabarro had told Inner City Press that only Doctor Chan would answer for WHO. He disclosed, however, that the UN's humanitarian coordinator John Holmes is no longer on food security. One wondered where John Holmes is, as the UN falls under fire for renting luxury cruise ships for its staff members in Haiti.

These officials are part of the UN's Chief Executives Board which met in Vienna last week. Inner City Press was told, and Mr. Ban's spokesman confirmed, that former Deputy S-G Mark Malloch Brown was at the Vienna meeting, providing an "outside view." The spokesman committed to find out who invited Malloch Brown. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/mdg5who041410.html

Afghan Gov't Role in Guesthouse Killings Was Left Undisclosed by UN, Execution of US Citizen Alleged

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/unleak2afgh041410.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- After the killing of five UN staff at the Bakhtar Guesthouse in Kabul last October and since, the UN has cast the blame for all the deaths on Taliban insurgents, who attacked the guesthouse.

Inner City Press was told by sources in Afghanistan that, in fact, Afghan government security forces were responsible for most of the deaths, including the "summary execution" of UN Security Officer, Louis Maxwell, a U.S. citizen.

Wednesday in response to questions from Inner City Press, the UN Spokesperson's Office confirmed the UN's heretofore undislosed awareness of the controversy, and later said that a board of inquiry has been established and Mr. Maxwell's family consulted.

Inner City Press' sources in Afghanistan, however, say that the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has shown a decided lack of enthusiasm to raise the issue to the Afghan government. Three of the four other UN staff killed, in this account, were killed by Afghan national security forces.

At Wednesday's noon briefing, Mr. Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky said that Ban has raised it to Afghanistan. Inner City Press asked, why didn't Mr. Ban or the UN publicly say that their previous account, that all five deaths were caused by the Taliban, had been called into question, including by a video shot by Germans in Kabul and shown on Der Spiegel's web site?

Inner City Press is told that Louis Maxwell, who resisted the attackers and thus allowed many others to successfully escape, was summarily executed at point blank range by an Afghan National Army member while in their custody, unarmed and not offering any resistance. The extra-judicial killing was captured on video by a staff member of the German Embassy and copies were provided to UN investigators. The video has since been posted on the German Stern media site although they have failed to realize (or at least publish) what exactly it is they are airing.

"In the aftermath of the incident many Afghan security forces are interviewed on camera by the local Afghan media and one Army Officer admits killing an 'Arab' terrorist outside the guesthouse. (Mr. Maxwell was an African American). Irrespective of whether he was mistaken for one of the attackers, his killing was nothing short of murder.

The source continues, UN SG Ban has refused to allow the issue to be raised with the Afghan government for political reasons and wants the US authorities to handle the 'problem.'"

While the UN is now belatedly saying they are investigating, the approach seems at odds with the stated commitment to staff safety, and to truth. We will continue to pursue this. Watch this site.

Update: while, after the noon briefing, the UN Spokesperson's Office read out a statement that the FBI is involved and nothing more will be said, the question remains why false impressions were left -- and also, what was known when, and what was done. Developing.

UN's response to Inner City Press after the April 14 noon briefing:

From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply

Subject: Your questions on Louis Maxwell

To: Inner City Press

Date: Wed, Apr 14, 2010

(further response on Louis Maxwell)

The United Nations has followed due process in investigating the death of staff in Afghanistan last October by instituting a Board of Inquiry after an initial fact-finding by staff in Kabul and New York. The United Nations has been in contact with the responsible Afghan authorities in the course of its inquiries. The Board will submit its report in due course. Further actions by the United Nations will depend on its findings. The specific circumstances in which Louis Maxwell died are currently being investigated and it would be premature to comment further at this stage.

The United Nations is also cooperating with the Federal Bureau of Investigation in its inquiries into the incident. The United Nations has briefed the Maxwell family on the progress of its initial inquiries and is determined to support the family.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unleak2afgh041410.html

As Sudan Vote Marred by Technical Snafus, UN Assistance Questioned

UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- With even the Sudanese government admitting widespread "technical" problems with its elections, questioning turned Tuesday to the value and quality of the UN's "technical assistance" to Sudan for its polling.

When opposition parties said that the ballots were being misprinted by the government, the UN declined to take a position, saying that the UN's role was technical and logistical, not to be observers. When the European Union observers left Darfur as unsafe, the UN had little to say.

On April 12, Inner City Press asked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon if the UN thought polling should be extended in light of the snafus. Mr. Ban replied that "the United Nations has been providing technical assistance and logistical support."

Shouldn't the UN, then, have to respond to have logistically ballots weren't delivers, and technically, ballots were misprinted, with wrong names and wrong party symbols? What kind of technical assistance is this?


At the April 13 UN noon briefing, Inner City Press pursued the issue:

Inner City Press: now that the Sudanese Government has acknowledged some technical problems with the election and has extended the voting… I remember, I went to a background briefing here where it was said that the UN was providing technical assistance. I understand that the UN, because it is providing technical assistance, is not observing the election or commenting on its fairness. But what does it say about the UN’s technical assistance that there are these wide-spread technical problems with the election?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, it was not just at a background briefing that you heard that the UN is providing technical assistance. I think that it has been said many times from here. The UN welcomes the National Election Commission's decision to extend the voting period. This would allow the Commission to overcome the various technical difficulties encountered in the first two days of the voting. And the UN also hopes that, precisely because there is now this extension by two days, it will enable more Sudanese voters to cast their vote, especially in areas and constituencies where the technical errors caused delays to the voting process or where voters have been unable to determine which polling centre they are registered in.

As we have said, the UN Mission in Sudan (UNMIS) is providing technical assistance and logistical support to the National Election Commission, upon request from the Commission, and will continue to do so, within the Mission’s capability. And I think that is an important point -- within the capability of the Mission. This is in order to assist the Commission in coping with the remaining technical problems and the logistical challenges.

So this is, precisely, providing assistance. It is down to the Commission, if you like, the National Election Commission, to deliver. The UN Mission in Sudan has been providing technical and logistical support to allow the Commission to deliver. Clearly, there have been huge challenges, which we have talked about here and have been talked about a lot obviously in Sudan, too.

Inner City Press: One thing I want to understand is this usage of technical problems, technical assistance. It seems like one of the problems is like ballots that have the wrong names on them, ballots that have the wrong party symbol attached to names. I am just sort of wondering: what did the UN’s technical assistance consist of? Were they supposed to look at these ballots that were going to be mass distributed to make sure that they did not have the wrong party affiliations next to the names? What was the technical assistance? If these problems took place, I am struggling to understand what…

Spokesperson: There were all kinds of layers of assistance that was provided. But I think that the most important point here is that the assistance is provided to the Commission, and it is the Commission that then delivers. It is not for the UN to scrutinize every individual ballot slip in advance of them being distributed, for example. It is providing the technical know-how -- how do you conduct an election, how do you put in place the materials that are required.

The "materials that are required" were not, in fact, in place. Some see the UN, at least its peacekeeping missions run by the Secretariat, as too close to the government. This sense is multiplied by the UN having paid a salary to pro government rebel leader Al-Tijani Al-Sissi Ateem, and then refusing to answer basic questions. On this, Inner City Press asked Spokesman Nesirky:

Inner City Press: does the Joint Mediator [for Darfur], Djibril Bassolé… is he paid by the UN and who speaks for him? Does he have a separate spokesperson or are you, in a sense, his spokesperson? Or is DPKO [Department of Peacekeeping Operations] his spokesperson? To whom would I direct questions to Mr. Bassolé in his UN capacity?

Spokesperson: Let me find out.

The question has also been put to the spokesman for the Department of Peacekeeping Operations. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan3vote041310.html

At UN, Labor Lows from UNODC to Elevator Stand-In, No Room for Union

UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- While the UN's Ban Ki-moon traveled to Central Asia, Austria and now DC, there are troubles on the home front. The UN's own Dispute Tribunal has issued a series of orders calling for disclosure of reports to whistleblower, and for senior officials like Shaaban Shaaban to be held accountable for mismanagement. Mr. Ban's response has been to appeal, appeal, appeal.

The UN Staff Union, which the Ban administration had tried to divide and conquer, was recently denied in its request for space to hold a meeting. First they were told that space was available, then from higher up via one Tony Di Lanzo that it was not: "I am sorry to inform you that your meeting has been moved... a large number of requests have been received for large room [sic] on this day." But a check of the UN's e-Meets site showed that the space was empty. We will have more on this.

While he was in Austria, Ban held a town hall meeting. He was told by Preeta Bannerjee, who took the for-now defunct G-to-P test in 1994, of low staff morale in UNODC. But what did he do?

Meanwhile, the UN's investigation into pre-predicted promotions in the Department of Safety and Security, exposed by Inner City Press, has resulted sources say in a whitewash.

While some say this was out of empathy for Headquarters security chief Bruno Henn, others say Henn -- who already tried unsuccessfully to move laterally to the Capital Master Plan -- is set to transfer to Nairobi, into a post opened by another scandal.

The discontent sinks all the way down to those who cannot sit. The elevator operators left in the UN building, who used to sit when there were no customers, have now been ordered to stand. They complain of discrimination against Latinos. And if it was, what would happen?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unban1labor041310.html