Sunday, April 11, 2010

Amid Sudan Election Fears, UN Silent, As Visas Denied, EU Observers Leave

UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- Even as Sudan denies visa for UN pilot to fly ballot boxes around, even as the European Union withdraws elections observers due to a lack of safety, the UN has nothing to say about the polls slated for this weekend.

Meanwhile on April 7 a Security Council ambassador of a Permanent Five member bluntly told the Press, "Bashir is going to be re-elected, but he's indicted by the International Criminal Court. He cannot be our interlocutor. It is an awkward situation... but all African leaders will recognize the election and Bashir."

This same ambassador relayed that Ibrahim Gambari, the UN's envoy to Darfur, confided that Bashir might agree to a one week delay in the polls. There's an attempt, it is said, to set up a four way briefing of the Security Council by Gambari, Haile Menkerios, and Messrs. Bassole and Mbeki. "It is hard to get Mbeki to New York," the ambassador said.

The Security Council is slated to receive a closed door briefing by top UN Peacekeeper Alain Leroy about the impending election. It's said that US Ambassador Susan Rice will speak to the Press at 10:45, before an NSC call at 11. Watch this site.

From the April 7 UN noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: In the run-up to the elections in Sudan, there are reports that one of the opposition candidates, who is now boycotting the elections, has said that the UN was supposed to transport ballot boxes, and that visas for the UN’s pilots for the planes have been denied by the Government of Sudan. The European Union observers say that they may pull out of the country due to a lack of safety. So I have two questions -- one, can you confirm that the visas were denied and, if so, what is the UN going to do about that? And two, what is the UN and UNMIS’s [United Nations Mission in the Sudan] role in providing safety to election observers, albeit not UN but European Union elections observers?

Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe: Well on the European Union, the question about the European Union observers is a press report, so I do not have confirmation on that. And your first question about…

Inner City Press: …the denial of visas to pilots for the UN.

Deputy Spokesperson: …visas, I have not received anything on the visa situation, so I am going to have to ask DPKO [Department of Peacekeeping Operations] to look into that for you.

Inner City Press: But what is the, I guess we are really coming right up to the election, what is the UN’s assessment? You are having more and more opposition parties saying they are going to boycott it. More and more outside observers say it is, you know, I do not want to characterize it, but say that it is not credible. What is the UN, given its presence on the ground, what is its view?

Deputy Spokesperson: Well, while we respect the right of candidates and political parties to reach their own decisions, we continue to encourage all Sudanese political actors to recognize the importance of dialogue, for the full implementation of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA).

As you know, one of the prime facets of the CPA is the opening of democratic space in Sudan, so that the people and the wide variety of political forces in the country can represent and participate in the process of decision-making. Therefore elections are an important step, designed to revive the democratic institutions and processes, so we encourage the Government of National Unity, the Government of Southern Sudan, and the National Elections Commission to ensure that the elections credibly reflect the will of the Sudanese people.

And, as you know, the UN Mission on the ground is there with a mandate to assist the Government and the National Electoral Commission (NEC) by providing technical and logistical support in order to enable timely conduct of the elections and in advising and encouraging the Commission, the Government and all parties to address concerns that may jeopardize their credibility. Okay?

That credibility is already shot.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan1vote040810.html

In Congo Crunch Time, US Rice and Others Cancel Visit, Iran Prioritized, Post-Doss

UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- With new violence starting up and being discovered throughout the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the 15 countries on the UN Security Council arranged to travel to the DRC starting April 13. One goal is to negotiate with Congolese President Joseph Kabila, who has asked for the UN Peacekeeping mission MONUC to begin to pack up and leave.

While Security Council members, particularly the United States, say that the issues in the Congo -- systematic rape of women as a weapon of war, exploitation of conflict minerals by rebels and rogue Congolese Army units -- are of much concern to them, on April 7 it emerged that only half of the Council member states are sending their Permanent Representative or lead Ambassador on the trip.

US Permanent Representative Susan Rice, another Council Ambassador complained to Inner City Press on Wednesday, has dropped her initial plan to travel to the Congo, and will stay in New York for the beginnings of negotiations on a resolution to impose more sanctions on Iran.

"She wants credit for cracking down on Iran," a source said, analogizing her calculus to that of her predecessors Madeleine Albright and Richard Holbrooke when they wanted promotions from US Ambassador to Secretary of State.

The UN's top envoy to the Congo Alan Doss, already the subject of a nepotism investigation by the UN for urging the UN Development Program to show him "leeway" and give his daughter a job, is said to definitely be out in June.

To replace Doss several French names are being circulated, among them former UN Peacekeeping chief Jean Marie Guehenno and even former French Permanent Representative Jean Maurice Ripert, who while titularly employed as envoy on development to Pakistan is said to be in an office in the UN's nearly empty headquarters tower.

There is also an American, the former U.S. Ambassador to Kinshasa, and current UN envoy to Cote d'Ivoire Choi, both of whom speak French.

While the UN and its Security Council may show the Congo this idiomatic respect, sending lower level representatives on the upcoming trip at this time of crossroads is a bad sign. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc1unrice040710.html

On UN Press Restrictions, P-5 Wax and Wane as CPJ Decries Hypocrisy

UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- Two days after the Press was unceremoniously told to move back from the UN Security Council because two Permanent member nations wanted less "involuntary interaction" with reporters, Inner City Press asked last month's Council President from Gabon about the controversy.

He confirmed the complaints, but ascribed them to a lack of any controls when the Council first moved to its new location in the UN basement. Meanwhile the Council's 15 members met Wednesday afternoon and heard a proposal from three representative of the UN Secretariat.

Inner City Press stood alone in the still limited stakeout area when the three emerged at 4:15 on Wednesday. They heard our proposal and are discussing it, Inner City Press was told.

The proposal involves moving the stakeout back up on front of the Security Council, allowing a similar stake out by the first floor Delegates' Entrance, and trying to allow journalists to walk up the same stairs as diplomats. (Imagine that).

One of the Permanent Five ambassadors named as having triggered the restrictions backtracked and expressed support for press use of the stairs. The host country, which on Monday denied having begun the discussion, still refers to safety concerns.

The Committee to Protect Journalists released the following statement on the controversy, through its deputy director Robert Mahoney:

"We fully support the United Nations Correspondents Association in its opposition to proposed new restrictions on press access to UN Security Council members. The public will see straight through the argument that delegates’ safety is enhanced by keeping them shielded from the press. Both diplomats and reporters are already inside a secure zone with visible ID. The United Nations should be a beacon for the human rights it was established to uphold. Those include freedom of expression and a free media. To deny reporters access to public officials would be hypocritical."

But hypocrisy is sometimes the norm at the UN. We'll see -- watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc6unreform040710.html

At UN, Deal on Press Limits Faces Safety Block, Turf War Council Meeting Called?

UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- In the hall of mirrors that is the UN, it wasn't clear under whose authority the Press was pushed back from the Security Council's new basement home on April 5. After a day of reporting and fight back, April's Council President Yukio Takasu of Japan on April 6 told Inner City Press that media access should not be reduced, and would be negotiated. Video here.

Later on April 6, five reporters including this one accompanied the media liaison of the UN Department of Safety and Security and three Department of Public Information officials in front of and above the Security Council suite of rooms. The DPI representatives assented to access at street level, from the Delegates' Entrance to the stairs.

Then to an enlarged pen in the basement, shifting the non-Council member states to south of the stairs. But the UN Security representative, who previously told Inner City Press that "your table's gonna move," said that it was all subject to re-negotiation.

One of the DPI officials told Inner City Press after close of business on April 6 that the following day -- today -- they would meet with the Security Council members to "seal the deal." Which Council members, Inner City Press asked -- all 15 or only the Permanent Five?

A representative of the UN's Security Council Affairs branch on April 5 said that there was no reason to meet with the Council's president from Japan, since he and his country are transient members. But now, Japan is requiring that all 15 be met with, the DPI source told Inner City Press. Which members will stand for press access, and which against?

France, whose Ambassador Gerard Araud began the complaining about the press in the Council's consultations on April 5, now said it agrees the Press must have access to the staircase and both lobbies. The hang-up, it emerges again, is the United States, according to well placed sources. The US Mission has denied they first raised the issue. But who is keeping it going, under the guise of safety? Watch this site.

Footnotes: unaddressed by President Takasu is the question of who moved to bar from consultations UN Peacekeeping and Political Affairs staff, and the Office of the Spokesperson, and why? When Inner City Press asked Takasu this on camera at the stakeout, he turned the question back to press access, on which he promised action. Video here, penultimate question.

But who on the Council is so concerned with leaks that they are willing to leave DPKO and DPA, which do the actual work, in the dark about the Council's views? The suspicion is the Council most upset about the North Korea leaks, later accused of leaking, perhaps only through Nairobi, the Somali Sanctions report. We will have more on this.

We end with this telling vignette. As the reporters and staff of DPI and DSS milled in the Delegates' Entrance, Sudan's Permanent Representative, his mandate just renewed, asked how he could help. Inner City Press asked him, "Do you support press freedom?"

His answer, "Not always," drew laugher from the UN officials. But this is what emboldens them.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc5unreform040710.html

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

In Haiti, UN's Kim Bolduc Is Out, Coke and Clinton Fete Citigroup, Siemens

UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- In the midst of the UN's response to Haiti's earthquake, it has removed its country representative Kim Bolduc, Inner City Press has discovered.

Told by a source that Ms. Bolduc was leaving Haiti, on March 31 on the sidelines of the Haiti donors' conference Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky, "do you know if Kim Bolduc is still performing her function as country coordinator in Haiti?" While Nesirky answered "Pass, don’t know," subsequently this came in:

Subject: Answer to your question on Ms Kim Bolduc
From: @un.org
To: Inner City Press

Dear Matthew, Kindly find hereby the answer to your question :Is Ms Kim Bolduc still performing her duties in Haiti?

"Kim Bolduc completed her assignment in Haiti on 30 March 2010".

It is certainly a strange time to have the country representative's "assignment" run out.

Also alongside the Haiti Donors' Conference at the UN, Bill Clinton co-hosted a corporate event for Coca-Cola, promoting a drink called "Haiti Hope."

While the Press was barred from the event, the UN Office of Partnership' roster of 135 invitees, subsequently obtained, lists Nestle executives Paul Bulke and Peter Braback, executives from Citigroup including Vikram Pandit, Siemens and Crescent Petroleum. And so it goes at the UN.

And here's from the April 1 transcript of the IMF, titularly a part of the UN system:

INNER CITY PRESS ONLINE QUESTIONER: At the U.N. yesterday, Mr. Strauss-Kahn said that the IMF has yet to forgive Haiti’s debt. By contrast, the IABD has already forgiven $479 million. Can you explain the IMF’s delay and exactly what Executive Board Meeting it will be when Mr. Strauss-Kahn will actually propose forgiving Haiti’s debt?

MR. RICE: In response to this question, I’d really like to refer you to the statement that we issued yesterday from the Managing Director when he attended the high-level conference in New York City. And on the issue of debt relief, what he had said was that there was a framework--staff was preparing a framework to be put forward for consideration by the IMF Executive Board on the issue of debt relief and the IMF...

Watch this site.
And see, www.innercitypress.com/haiti1kimcoke040610.html

As Press Pushed from UN Council, Protests to Ban, "Tear Down This Wall!"

UNITED NATIONS, April 6, updated -- "Mr. Ban, tear down this wall!" A long time UN correspondent said this Tuesday morning, loudly, in protest of the press corps being pushed away from the Security Council's new location in the UN basement. On Monday, Inner City Press was informed that in a closed Council consultation, a proposal was made to push non-Council member states out into the hallway, and push journalists even further back.

Following questions posed to UN Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe at Monday's noon briefing, then to April's Council president Yukio Takasu of Japan, the UN Correspondents Association put together a letter of protest, to be handed alongside Tuesday Council meeting on Iraq to President Takasu and the Ambassadors of the Permanent Five members of the Council.

But with the press corps penned in far back from the stairs, even the letters of protest could not be handed to Ambassadors as they entered. U.S. Ambassador Rice strode in. Even as reporters called out, "We have a letter for you," she smiled bemused and continued into the Council chamber. Later a spokesman accepted the letter.

UK Deputy Permanent Representative Parham came over and took the letter himself. Russia's Dolgov accept it, asking, "Is it in Russian?" Long after the meeting began, Council President Takasu had still not been served. Nor had the Chinese mission. This job was left to Inner City Press.

Update of 2 p.m. -- Inner City Press gave the letter to President Takasu, when he came to speak to the Press after consultations on Iraq, Guinea Bissau, the DRC and Somali piracy. After the issue was raised to other non-Permanent Council members like Brazil and Uganda, it was said that Ambassador Takasu as President raised it as a "housekeeping" matter.

At the stakeout, he said again therre should be equivalent access. Inner City Press asked President Takasu, and before him UN Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe, about even UN Peacekeeping staffers being now excluded from the Council consultation room. Ms. Okabe conceded that such presence had been "useful." Ambassador Takasu did not ask that question when asked, reverting to the Press question, saying further consultations will be had. Only at the UN. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc4unreform040610.html

As UN Bans Press from Council Hall, Demand Tracks Back to Gerard Araud of France?

UNITED NATIONS, April 6, updated -- The controversy over which Permanent Five member of the Security Council was most responsible for Monday's move to push the Press back to avoid "involuntary interaction" has taken a new turn. On April 5 the lack of clarity about who controls the UN building, and to some degree the press, came into focus when one or more Permanent members of the Security Council said reporters should be barred from hallway outside the new Council.

At Monday's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked UN Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe who controls this space, the Council, the General Assembly, or the Secretary General. Ms. Okabe dodged the question, then said "the Member States, as you know, have a great say in this. This is their building. So, let’s leave it at that." Transcript here and below.

But which member states -- the full 192 members, the 15 members of the Council, the Permanent Five -- or just a single one of the P-Five? While Inner City Press initially also named the United States, which called to deny involvement, multiple sources now identify French Permanent Representative Gerard Araud as the one who raised the issue in the Council's closed door session.

It is perhaps not surprising. Of the Permanent Five ambassadors, Araud has gone the longest without taking questions from the Press at the stakeout or in a press conference. The UK's Mark Lyall Grant spoke most recently about Myanmar; Araud did not speak. The US' Susan Rice spoke about Sudan; Araud did not speak.

China's recently arrived Li Baodong spoke on the Middle East and Iran, and took a question about Sri Lanka. (Araud spoke on this topic, but only outside of the UN at the French consulate on Fifth Avenue.)

Russia's Churkin held a press conference, ostensibly about road safety, but answered questions about NATO and Georgia, among others. But where is Araud? He does not lack wit and combativeness, so perhaps he will speak on the record now.

From the beginning of his time at the UN in 2009, Araud has made a mark both with his caustic humor and his rudeness, which those invited call candor. In closed door sessions with chosen media, Araud has trashed a Middle East leader as "not all there." Of Guinea's military leader Dadis Camara, Araud said he "sleeps all day and drinks all night."

When challenge by some media, he said "you are small people."

Some French reporters say they welcome Araud's off the record candor. But to other French journalists, who along with Inner City Press have challenged him, Araud turns up his nose and walks by without a word. Then when it is written about, as Inner City Press did in a live blog of the opening of the UN's new North Lawn building, the French Mission to the UN takes to the phones to defend their boss' reputation.

The next day at the (old) stakeout, Araud made a sarcastic point of saying hello. Perhaps then the seed was planted to try to use the Council's move as a pretext to avoid having to face or even see and be seen by the press before each Council session.

Update of 9:40 am, April 6 -- already chairs and tables for non-Council member states are being put where the stakeout should be, with a penned in area further back for reporters. At the UN, too, apparently, possession is nine tenths of the law. Media Accreditation late on April 5 asked reporters to respect the lines drawn while this is all worked out. But on the other side, construction -- settlement -- proceeds.

Update of 10:22 a.m.-- with the press corps penned in far back from the stairs, even the letters of protest could not be handed to Ambassadors as they entered. U.S. Ambassador Rice strode in. Even as reporters called out, "We have a letter for you," she smiled bemused and continued into the Council chamber. Later a spokesman accepted the letter. Tellingly, neither French Ambassador Araud nor his spokesman came to the tense stakeout. A member of the French mission blew the press a kiss, dramatically, and walked into the chamber.

UK Deputy Permanent Representative Parham came over and took the letter himself. Russia's Dolgov accept it, asking, "Is it in Russian?" Long after the meeting began, Council President Takasu had still not been served. Nor had the Chinese mission. This job was left to Inner City Press.

Inner City Press' introduction to Araud took place in a press conference on poverty in the Fall of 2009. Araud held forth about Sarkozy's and Kouchner's work. Inner City Press asked about France's eviction of asylum seekers in Calais, and treatment of the poor in Mayotte. Araud refused to answer, and afterwards complained. After he stormed by the table, outside the Security Council, where other Ambassadors stop to interact with the Press.

Now, taking advantage of the Council's move to the basement, he has requested that the Press not be so close. While the U.S. denies agreeing to the request, it could have spoken up. As it is, a representative of the Secretariat's Security Council Affairs unit came out and said that in the consultations, the exclusion of the Press had been decided on.

This has triggered an appeal to this month's Council president Yukio Takasu, copied to Ban Ki-moon, Ali Treki and all Permanent Five members. When Araud gets it, what will he do? Watch this site.

From the April 5 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: this morning in front of the Security Council, a representative in the Department of Political Affairs or the Security Council Affairs Unit said that the Council had decided that the press can’t stand in front of the Security Council; it should be pushed back, and that non-Council Members will be also in the hallway, in this area by the stairs. And that Security will enforce this. So, one, I wanted to know whether that’s a final decision by the Department of Political Affairs; and two, who controls safety and security here? Is it, does the Secretary-General, or do the Security Council Members, can they direct Security to make those moves?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: I was just walking in here together with the head of the Media Accreditation Unit; and well, I didn’t have time to talk to her in detail, she has just had a meeting with Security and the Security Council Affairs Unit, and I think she has worked out something that enables closer access by the press to the Security Council members. So, she will give an update to Giampaolo, who I think just walked in.

Inner City Press: But is it possible, I guess I’m just…the whole incident, the whole back and forth this morning, made me wonder kind of who is, I mean, obviously the Security Council can vote things about the world at large, but in terms of the building and space, is, does the Security Council control the building, or does the Secretariat and the Secretary-General control the building?

Deputy Spokesperson: The Member States, as you know, have a great say in this. This is their building. So, let’s leave it at that. And [interrupted]

Inner City Press: Does that mean the 15 or the whole, all 192? That’s what I am wanting to get at.

Question: We have to find out those things.

Inner City Press: Yeah, it’s very important. When you say Member States, is it only 15 or the full contingent?

Deputy Spokesperson: The full contingent of what?

Inner City Press: Of all Member States. I was told this morning that countries like India and Germany might have to, the new quiet room will be out by the staircase, not inside the room. So, I just wanted to know who decides that.

Deputy Spokesperson: I think the arrangements, my understanding right now, Matthew, is that the Security Council has just moved from the traditional premises to the new ones. And I think a lot of the arrangements are in the middle of being worked out. So, until they do, I really don’t have enough information to comment further on the decision-making process. But, I do know that Media Accreditation is, was just talking to Security Affairs about this particular issue that came up this morning.

Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc3unreform040610.html

On Myanmar, Japan "Disappointed" by Election Law, But Not on Council Agenda

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- Myanmar is not on the UN Security Council's April work plan presented to the Press on Monday by Japan's Yukio Takasu, this month's Council President.

Given the professed interest of Council members the U.S., France, UK as well as Japan, Inner City Press asked Ambassador Takaso what the Council or Japan will do, following the National League for Democracy's decision to boycott this year's election, from which Aung San Suu Kyi and other political prisoners are excluded. Video here, from Minute 36:56, non-verbatim transcript below.

Ambassador Takasu said "we were hoping the general election would be inclusive, meaning that people are entitled to participate. It is up to Mrs. Aung San Suu Kyi or some individual to participate or not. But with this legal impediment, it cannot be considered inclusive." Video here, from Minute 38:50.

"We were very disappointed" with the electoral law, Takasu continued, saying this was communicated by Foreign Minister Okada to either senior Secretariat staff, senior Myanmar leaders or both, the former to the latter.

With Secretary General Ban Ki-moon yet to replace former Myanmar envoy Ibrahim Gambari, who left the position in December, some wonder at the UN's and international community's commitment.

Others say that the U.S. Mission to the UN favors leaving interim envoy Vijay Nambiar in place until after the boycotted elections.

Could this be similar to the US's strange acceptance of Sudan's flawed election, on which it has requested a Council briefing this week, while on the ground Scott Gration praises it? And given Japan's initial disinterest in election flaws and violence in Iran, how seriously can we take its commitment to an inclusive and credible election in Myanmar? We'll see, this month. Watch this site.

Non-verbatim transcript by ICP's UnFriends On Myanmar of Ambassador Takasu's response to Inner City Press' Myanmar question:

Takasu ... There is very broad support of the role of the Secretary-General's good offices, and the message that the Secretary-General has been conveying to Myanmar's leaders and government has the full support of all of us. Myanmar has been making progress in democratization ... but now at this moment, this general election, they promised to do it this year. It is an extremely important occasion. So it's not only that it be free and fair ... but it should be inclusive and credible. I think there is broad support for that. What has happened since the publication of the electoral law including this disqualification of certain category of people. ...

It will not be a good basis for an inclusive and credible election. As far as Japan is concerned, we regret very much, because at a very senior level we have been talking very closely and we were hoping that this forthcoming general election would be not only free and fair but inclusive. Inclusive means that at least they are entitled to participate. ... However because of the legal impediment ... I don't think this is inclusive.

We are therefore very disappointed and this disappointment has been communicated very straightly from FM Okada himself, and that was conveyed to the very senior people in the Myanmar leadership. ...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/japan1myan040510.html

On Iran, Japan's "Only Disagreement" Is Nuclear, Arrests and Press Crackdowns of Less Import?

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- With Iran, "Japan has extremely good bilateral relations," Security Council President for April Yukio Takasu told the Press on Monday. "The only disagreement is this nuclear issues." Video here, from Minute 31:17.

Inner City Press asked Ambassador Takasu is this meant that Japan did not share the concerns about the arrests and disappearances that followed Iran's last contested election.Video here, from Minute 37:17.

Ambassador Takasu backed off this previous statement. "I try to emphasize... Of course there are many issues which Japan is involved in discussing with Iran. It doesn't mean all other issues, human rights, we agree with. Just the major issues... the Security Council is now involved in the nuclear issue."

While some interpreted this as saying that only nuclear issues, and not human rights, are "major issues" to Japan, others analyzed that Japan is so concerned about North Korean nuclear threats that the precedent of Iran, it must fight.

But Japan's less than human rights focused engagement with the Sri Lankan government, for example, of Mahinda Rajapaksa as it killed civilians along with Tamil Tigers in April and May 2009, as well as domestic treatment of women and immigrants, calls into question for some Japan's stance on human rights.

It is one thing to prioritize nuclear issues over human rights. But to trade laxity on the latter for uncertain safeguards on the former is cynical. We'll see.

Footnote: The timing of any Council vote this month on Iran sanctions may be impacted by the Council members' trip to the DR Congo, Uganda and Rwanda, from April 16 through 23. In the Council consultations Monday morning, it was emphasized how important the DRC leg of the trip is, given President Joseph Kabila's move to push the UN Mission out of the country in connection with the nation's 50 years of independence. When you subtract a full from a Council's month, it makes it marginally less productive. Marginally. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/iran1jnuke040510.html

Press Restrictions by UN Security Council Come from 2 Permanent Members, UN Source Says, US, France and Russia Eyed, Even Ban Excluded

UNITED NATIONS, April 5, updated -- Following complaints Monday by at least two UN Security Council members about "involuntary interaction" with the media and non-Council member states, incoming Council president Yukio Takasu of Japan faced a series of questions about restrictions on press access.

Inner City Press asked Takasu to confirm that in the morning's consultations, two Permanent members had said non-Council member states should wait out by the staircase, and the press be confined behind the staircase. Video here, from Minute 18:06.

Ambassador Takasu, who had earlier spoken about the need for transparency, did not answer about the meeting, but said access should be "equivalent" at before the Council moved to the UN basement from its longtime home on the second floor.

But Ambassador Takasu, tellingly, also spoke of Council members' desire to leave the consultation room "without being seen." Is this transparency or invisibility, one wag questioned.

Inner City Press, which reported exclusively Monday morning on the Council's closed door meeting and move to push the press further away, has since learned that the concerned raised in the meeting including a move to bar representatives of the Office of the Spokesperson for the Secretary General from the consultations room.

Beyond press freedom and access, then, this is a question of separation of powers. Inner City Press at Monday's noon briefing asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe who controls UN Security and the building: the Secretariat or the Security Council? Video here.

Member states, Ms. Okabe answered. But, Inner City Press followed up, does this mean merely the 15 states on the Council, just the Permanent Five members, or the full UN membership of 192? Ms. Okabe declined to answer, saying that meetings were being set up.

But from the first of these meetings, the UN correspondents were banned. And a request to meet with the Japanese Mission, since they hold this month's Council presidency, was rejected by the Secretariat's Security Council Affairs unit, which said both that the complaints came from among Permanent members, and that these members are the ones to decide, since they remain on the Council.

Several correspondents guessed that the move to restrict access came, perhaps surprisingly, from the U.S. Mission. Ambassador Susan Rice is known to have been incensed at the leak last year -- again, to Inner City Press -- of a draft resolution to impose sanctions on North Korea. Correspondents note that unlike other P-5 Ambassadors, Susan Rice keeps a number of body guards between herself and the press corps.

France's Gerard Araud is at times acerbic toward the press. The UK's Mark Lyall Grant is businesslike, conducting recent stakeouts on Myanmar -- which he called Burma -- and Sri Lanka. Russia's Vitaly Churkin often jokes, how ever gruffly, with the press, and Chinese's recently arrived Ambassador Li Baodong has already held a free wheeling stakeout. These could all be public faces for closed door push-back at the press. One reporter surmised that the complaint may have been triggered by questions -- or rather, "good mornings" -- directed Monday morning to Ambassadors Li and Araud. We will crack this case. Watch this site.

Our take: whichever of the Permanent Five is trying to push non-Council membes and the press away, they should step forward, and not use mid-level UN Secretariat staff as their mouthpiece. If the U.S. Mission, as the U.S. Constitution, is committed to freedom of the press and access to public servants, the U.S. should become the most vocal in ensuring continued press access. The UK and France also speak about press freedom. And where is Ban Ki-moon and his team on all this?

Update of 4:20 p.m. -- Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar is said to have inquired what the Press' next move will be. While there's talk of a "sit in at the stakeout," watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc2unreform040510.html

At UN, Security Council Moves to Push All But 15 Nations into the Hall, Cut Press Access: Turf Wars

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/sc1unreform040510.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- Outside the first consultation meeting in the new UN Security Council chamber, both reporters and members states not on the Council were Monday in disarray, on the verge of losing even more access.

A representative of UN Security Council Affairs told Inner City Press that the media will be moved further back, where they can't even see Council members enter. And member states other than the 15 Council members will be relegated to an open hallway by the stairs, under the plan.

The UN representative said that Council members complained of "involuntary interation" with the press and even other member states "like India and Germany," wanting a way to leave without seeing either. Inner City Press countered that the media, and non-Council member states, must be consulted, but was told to quiet down.

In what passes for news, in the beginning of the month consultations led by April's Council president, Yukio Takasu of Japan, the U.S. asked for a briefing about the elections in Sudan. Since U.S. envoy Scott Gration is in Khartoum appearing to praise the process as "as fair as possible," the U.S.'s request struck some as strange.

Nigeria requested a briefing about the chaos in Guinea Bissau, in which the police arrested the Prime Minister last week. Apparently Myanmar will not be discussed. Ambassador Takasu will hold a press conference later on Monday. Watch this site.

The background: After its final March meeting, the Council was moved from its longtime location on the second floor to a suite of rooms in the UN's basement.

There are no windows, but the UN says it is secure, safer than Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's office atop the boxlike Temporary North Lawn Building.

But outside the Council, everything has changed. The suite of rooms has a closed metal door and a sign, "Consultation in session, Security Council members only."

This seems to mean that Permanent Representatives of member states not among the Council's 15 members -- including for example India, Germany and South Africa, to name a few -- can't even go into the Council's lounge, as for years they did upstairs.

Some Security Council reform -- getting less rather than more inclusive.

A stakeout with the 15 Council members' flags has been set up where the Vienna Cafe used to be. It is at some remove from the Security Council doors; members can leave by the stairs or garage without walking by the stakeout.

Monday morning, reporters milled around between the stairs and the Council doors. Spokespeople of only two of the Council's members, one permanent and one in its second of two years on the Council, deigned to speak to the press scrum. By 10:15, Inner City Press was the only media left, on a rickety chair without a table by the stairs. Several Permanent Representatives asked Inner City Press how to get into the Council. "Through the General Assembly," was the reply. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sc1unreform040510.html