Tuesday, April 6, 2010

At UN, Climate and Sanctions Offices Left Behind, of Two Lounges, Threats

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- Past the UN's stated deadline to have its headquarters building empty for gut rehabilitation, the last working day before Easter found UN offices and staff left behind on the 17th and 18th floors, with journalists threatened with destruction of their files down below.

Despite Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's professed focus on climate change, his advisory office on the matter remains languishing in room 1831. On April 1, Inner City Press asked, does Ban climate advisor "Janos Pasztor still work here?"" Yes, was the answer.

A floor below, the nepotism plagued "Umoja" office, of the UN's $300 million plus Enterprise Resource Planning project has also been left behind in the building. On the elevator, a staff member told Inner City Press that his Sanctions unit of the Department of Political Affairs is also still in the building.

Later at an ostensibly final retirement party held in the old Delegates' Lounge, sources told Inner City Press that the contractor Skanska is moving people into floors like 15 and even 2, into higher quality offices than those of seemingly senior UN staff. "Something weird is going on here," one long time and well-placed staffer said.

And indeed it is weird. As several revelers noted, while UN staff and diplomats have been banned since Christmas 2009 from the Delegates' Lounge -- a cement floored facsimile of which has belatedly been opened by a single window in the Temporary North Lawn Building dubbed by some Bantanamo -- an official of the UN Capital Master Plan told as Inner City Press source the old Lounge will remain untouched through at least September 2010.

It will be used for luncheons and events during the General Debate, and also until then, he said, "only for USGs and ASGs" - that is, high UN officials.

This same official is involved in the threats to journalists and their files. Not only is the whistleblower free zone established to monitor the press -- the real Bantanamo, some say -- a form of retaliation, now the false deadline to destroy all that is in the former journalists' offices is as well, some say.

Long time denizens of the Delegates' Lounge, including several member states' Permanent Representatives, have asked Inner City Press why the UN made its supposedly replacement Delegates' Lounge so drab, with the prices raised. Others say it better than nothing, a attitude of decreased expectations more and more prevalent in this UN. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/cmp1april040510.html

In Central Asia, UN Ban Blind to Corruption, Skips Prisoners Rights and Water Wars

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/ban1centas040310.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- As the UN's Ban Ki-moon traipses Central Asia, what of political prisoners, UN hiring scandals and simmering cross border conflicts? Apparently for the UN Secretary General, these don't exist. Before Ban started his trip, Inner City Press asked why the UN was not even to solve the dam-based conflict between Tajkistan and Uzbekisan. Don't call it a conflict, Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky said. What what should it be called?

As Inner City Press has reported, Uzbekistan opposes the Tajik dam so much it shut the country's border. Why isn't the vaunted Regional Center for Preventive Diplomacy for Central Asia involved?

A UN source alleging corruption in the UNRCCA notes

On the website of the Center, there is not a single word about the Dam. but there is a tender announcement for the fitness equipment for the gymnasium at the UNRCCA building - the former elite Demiryolchy Hotel. The question is whether the procurement of the fitness equipment is reconciled with the UN budget rules and regulations, or whether it is a good UN background for the unsolved Dam conflict.

http://unrcca.unmissions.org/ the left click Tenders http://unrcca.unmissions.org/Default.aspx?tabid=4319

At Tnders page you could see translation: The Regional UN Center (UNRCCA) announces the tender: Fitness equipment for the gymnesium)

http://unrcca.unmissions.org/Default.aspx?tabid=4319&ctl=Details&mid=4408&ItemID=8098

http://unrcca.unmissions.org/portals/unrcca/gym.pdf is set of pictures.

Meanwhile

Miloslav Jenca (Slovakia), SRSG and head of UNRCCA, has published an article “Developments in Central Asia and the role of the UNRCCA” in International Issues & Slovak Foreign Policy AffairsIssue no.02 /2009, Publisher: Research Center of the Slovak Foreign Policy Association (RC SFPA)

The curiosity is that it can be read only if the reader would pay 25 Euro (€) in advance (from each the price of Jenca’s article would be taken). Click here. the UN staff in general and of Jenca’s status in particular are not supposed to publish the UN related staff for money (not saying about other connotations).

Turkmenistan would be the first country in the SG tour – 2 April (would SRSG Jenca inform the SG of the fitness equipment tendered – especially of the ball to play at the beach?

In the Fall of 2009, Inner City Press asked and was given the run-around about a hiring scandal in this Regional Center for Preventive Diplomacy for Central Asia. Inner City Press posed this question in writing:

In a message dated 8/27/2009 3:50:47 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, montas [at] un.org writes:
Please refer your DPA questions to Jared Kotler

I've been referred to you for a response to the allegations below concerning hiring in the Regional Center in Turkmenistan (the United Nations Regional Center for Preventive Diplomacy for Central Asia).Also, please tell me when Jan Egeland's job with DPA ended, what he did during his tenure and how much he was paid.

on the RCPDCA, while here is more to this story, but let's start on deadline with confirmation or denial of the below:

During 2005-2007 Mr. Miloslav Jenca, Slovakia , worked in Tashkent as the OSCE Head of Office/OSCE Project Co-coordinator in Uzbekistan together with Ms. Polina Pomogalova , Uzbekistan , as his local general support staff:

http://www.osce.org/uzbekistan/photos.html?lsi=true&src=22&limit=6&pos=36

Mr.Jenca at OSCE, Uzbekistan

http://www.osce.org/documents/eea/2007/10/27048_en.pdf

Ms. Polina Pomogalova at OSCE, Uzbekisan, page 3

In December 2007 the UNRCCA ( United Nations Regional Center for Preventive Diplomacy for Central Asia) was inaugurated by Lynn Pascoe, DPA in Ashgabat.

In April 2008 Mr. Miloslav Jenca was appointed UNRCCA Head and SRSG, (“…Mr.. Jenca, currently the Director of the Office of Slovakia’s Foreign Affairs Minister, recently served as head of mission for the OSCE centre in Tashkent , Uzbekistan …”)

Soon after this Ms. Polina Pomogalova was appointed the Personal Assistant to the SRSG Jenca at UNRCCA: see the UNRCCA web site:

http://unrcca.unmissions.org/Default.aspx?tabid=1995


“…Ms. Polina Pomogalova, Personal Assistant to the Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General Ambassador Jenca…”

Question: How could it be that Polina Pomogalova without a single day of the UN experience was shortlisted for an interview by PMSS while other candidates with the extensive UN experience in Central Asia and technically cleared to the positions of this category were not included? How could it be that the UNRCCA interview board recommended exactly Polina Pomogalova? The answer seems clear: she was the protégé of SRSG Jenca and it was he who had arranged everything.

Again, there is more to this story, but let's start on deadline with what is the UN's / DPA's . the Center's response?

The majority of the above was simply never responded to, just as the UN's Department of Political Affairs refused to respond to or address nepotism and hiring scandals in its Africa II unit and the Central African Republic. This lack of accountability extends to the UN's approach to human rights.

As Ban left on April 1, Inner City Press asked his Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq if Ban would visit political prisoners:

Inner City Press: In terms of the Secretary-General’s trip through Central Asia, I’m wondering, various groups, including Human Rights Watch, have said this is an opportunity for him to address issues such as, in Uzbekistan, the failure to prosecute anyone for the Andijon massacre, as well as the abuse of political prisoners, religious minorities and others. What is the place of the issue of human rights in the Secretary-General’s trip, and specifically, is he going to raise Andijon while he is in Uzbekistan?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: I’m not going to get ahead of the Uzbekistan portion of the trip before it happens. What I will say is: it’s always clear whenever the Secretary-General visits countries that human rights, international humanitarian law and other norms are always part of what he discusses with his interlocutors. He certainly plans to do that over the course of his trip to Central Asia. And one of the things that he is going to do in the various countries that he visits is to reach out to civil society. As you know, civil society organizations have been developing in many of these countries. We will provide you with the details of those visits as they transpire. There is nothing really to say about them just yet.

Inner City Press: There are fairly high-profile, what are called political prisoners, although the Governments disagree in both Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, and I am wondering, does he have, when he says he’s going to reach out to civil society, can you say whether he’s actually asked to meet any imprisoned political figure?

Associate Spokesperson: I wouldn’t give the itinerary, the precise itinerary, of his meetings just yet, but we’ll provide those details as they arise. But certainly, he will be meeting with civil society, and the sort of concerns he brings on all of his trips he will also bring on this one.

But what, for example, of the HIV activist imprisoned by Uzbekistan which called his UNICEF-funded pamphlet blasphemous? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1centas040310.html

As HABITAT Meets in Brazil Before Sports Evictions, No Angola Follow-up

UNITED NATIONS, April 3 -- While the UN talks a good game, often neither neither the past or future's solved. Taking UN HABITAT, which bragged on April 1 about its World Urban Forum in Brazil. Inner City Press asked, what about the threatened evictions for the upcoming World Cup and Olympics? We talked about that, was the answer. But what if any commitments were obtained?

Previously, when HABITAT held an event in Angola, Inner City Press asked about evictions there. HABITAT responded that it chose to stay quiet, in exchange for a commitment that some percentage of Angola's oil would be devoted to poor housing.

But the evictions have continued, have gotten worse in fact. Click here. When Inner City Press raised this on April 1, HABITAT's presented implied that the purpose of the evictions was to create better housing for the poor. Video here. But in fact in these evictions, no replacement housing was promised, no recompense for that destroyed.

Twice, the HABITAT representatives highlighted that their conference was held in a previously derelict port area, and therefore did not itself displace people but rather "revitalized." One wonders of HABITAT's views on gentrification and other forms of displacement.

Just focusing on sports events, what did the UN or HABITAT do in the face of, according to the UN itself,

1.5 million people displaced for the 2008 Olympics in Beijing. "Residents were relocated on a large scale. Mass evictions were reported, sometimes conduced by unidentified men."

2010 - World Cup in South Africa

More than 20,000 residents have been removed and transferred to impoverished areas of the city. The minister for Housing noted that plans to build thousands of low-cost housing units could be affected by changes in the demands of the World Cup budget.

2010 - Commonwealth Games in New Delhi

In New Delhi, India, 35,000 families were evicted from public land in preparation for the games.

Where is HABITAT on this? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1evictions040310.html

IMF Dodges on Green Fund Stasis and Haiti Debt Relief Delay, Jamaica Question Ignored

UNITED NATIONS, April 1 -- The IMF remains a palace of spin. On most questions, IMF staff refer back to earlier evasive statements by "the Managing Director" Dominique Strauss-Kahn, which are even less responsive to the resulting follow-up questions. Thursday this happened on Haiti and the "green fund" proposal, while a timely submitted question about Jamaica wasn't even taken.

On March 31 at the UN in New York, Inner City Press asked Strauss-Kahn why the IMF had not yet forgiven Haiti's debt, and about the negative impacts of previous IMF conditionalities on Haiti, destroying among other things its rice industry. Strauss-Kahn's vague answer to the first question, and dismissive rejection of the latter, were reported yesterday.

As luck would have it, the IMF had its bi-weekly press briefing on April 1. Inner City Press asked, and IMF spokesman Gerry Rice read out in full without attribution, "At the UN yesterday Mr. Strauss-Kahn said that the IMF has yet to forgive Haiti's debt. By contrast, the IADB has already forgiven $479 million. Can you explain the IMF's delay, and exactly what Executive Board meeting it will be, when Strauss-Kahn will actually propose forgiving Haiti's debt?"

Thereupon Mr. Rice said, "I'd like to refer you to the statement we issued yesterday for the Managing Director" that IMF staff is preparing a framework for the Executive Board on the issue of Haitian debt relief.

But this does not, as request, say which Executive Board meeting Strauss Kahn is aiming at, nor does it explain the IADB's relative speed. The IADB's representative told Inner City Press the IADB could move fast because foreign ministers met in Cancun. But there have been IMF Executive Board meetings since the Haitian earthquake.

Inner City Press asked Rice to "confirm or deny" a media account that "member countries of the International Monetary Fund thumbed down March 25 a proposal to gather $100 billion a year starting 2020 to help poor nations adapt to the effects of climate change."

Rice putted out an "if-asked" sheet of paper and said that "as the Managing Director has repeatedly said, climate change is in important issue."

He then said that the IMF staff position published is an idea "purely for consideration by the international community," the IMF's "contribution to the broader public debate." With contributions like that, and (for now) $2.25, you can get on the subway in New York.

Inner City Press thrice submitted, but got no acknowledgement of much less answer to, this question: "Jamaica's finance minister has said the country has "met all of the IMF's conditions." Is that accurate? What happens next?" Watch this site.

From the IMF's transcript:

INNER CITY PRESS ONLINE QUESTIONER: At the U.N. yesterday, Mr. Strauss-Kahn said that the IMF has yet to forgive Haiti’s debt. By contrast, the IABD has already forgiven $479 million. Can you explain the IMF’s delay and exactly what Executive Board Meeting it will be when Mr. Strauss-Kahn will actually propose forgiving Haiti’s debt?

MR. RICE: In response to this question, I’d really like to refer you to the statement that we issued yesterday from the Managing Director when he attended the high-level conference in New York City. And on the issue of debt relief, what he had said was that there was a framework--staff was preparing a framework to be put forward for consideration by the IMF Executive Board on the issue of debt relief and the IMF...

INNER CITY PRESS ONLINE QUESTIONER: Can you please confirm or deny that member countries of the IMF thumbed down on March 25 a proposal to gather USD100 billion a year starting 2020 to help poor nations adapt to the effects of climate change?

MR. RICE: On this one, what I’d like to say is as the Managing Director has said many times, climate change is an important issue of global concern. Our contribution is that we look to the particular issue of how to help developing countries finance the challenges posed by climate change. And the recently published staff position note outlined a potential staff proposal, and the ideas set out in this note are being offered purely for consideration by the international community and as a contribution to the broader public debate.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1greenjam040110.html

At UN on Haiti, EU Ashton Dodges, Cannon Fires at Fowler, French Jet Unaddressed

UNITED NATIONS, April 1 -- Amid the self-congratulatory Haiti fest at the UN on Wednesday, there was bragging by the European Union, Canada and others, corporate plugs for Coca-Cola, and many Haitian excluded from the conference.

The EU's High Commissioner Catherine Ashton closed with the dramatic phrase about the scale of death "in 35 seconds." But earlier on Wednesday, when Inner City Press asked her about what's described as her powerplay to get EU development aid under an External Affairs Unit she is setting up, she dodged as in a quake. There's no controversy, she said. But that's not what development and poverty experts say.

Inner City Press asked Ashton about two EU members, Germany and France. The former's been called stingy by German Agro Aid. French development minister Alain Joyandet spent over 116,000 Euros taking a private jet to a meeting about poverty in Haiti. Ashton smiled as that question was asked, but did not answer it. The German question she left to her Eastern European co-panelist.

Upstairs at the stakeout in front of the Trusteeship Council Chamber, high profile participants praised the meeting and themselves. Canadian foreign Minister Cannon lauded his country's response. Inner City Press asked about the criticism by former Canadian (and UN) diplomat Robert Fowler, that the conservative Canadian government has turned more and more inwards, and taken sides in the Middle East.

Cannon said he would not respond to Fowler, only that he is -- and by implication Fowler should be -- grateful to the countries which helped get Fowler released from Al Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb, after he was scooped up in Niger working for the UN and perhaps Canadian mining interests.

Back downstairs the press spokesman of Japan's foreign minister Okada described his boss' trip to Washington, Ottawa and New York in seemingly great detail. But he omitted the discussions of the relocation of American forces on Okinawa. When asked by Inner City Press, he dutifully described the issue for the few representatives of Japanese media in the briefing room, as if they'd never heard of it. And then the briefing was over.

It all concluded with an unwieldy seven person press conference in the UN's basement. Only three questions were allowed, each apparently pre-selected. Ban's spokesman called on Spanish wire service EFE, which he had left off Ban's first trip to Haiti, whose president's spokesman called on a Haitian journalist from "Scoop." The U.S. State Department called on Reuters, which asked Hillary Clinton about Iran and the UN Security Council.

While Haitian President Rene Preval rolled his eyes and Ban urged that only Haiti questions be asked, Hillary Clinton, France's Bernard Kouchner and Brazil's foreign minister each answered the question. Brazil said as a non permanent member of the Council, it was not in the loop.

Hillary Clinton said that the U.S. viewed seeking Council sanctions as diplomacy, even negotiations. Kouchner said that "we did try to talk to the Iranians, we did." Why not allow a question or answer about his development minister's 116,000 Euro private jet trip about Haiti, then? And so it goes in the UN.

Footnotes: Some, including Haitians who had traveled to New York in good faith for the conference, could not get in. A misleading UN web site allowed people to register and even receive confirmation. They appeared prior to the conference but were told another step had been needed, and that the event was "for donors."

This contrasted to Bill Clinton's statement, following his high security hobnobbing with Coca-Cola which has tried to brand the earthquake, that the conference "heard from Haitian civilian society, and not just from me."

Inner City Press also questioned the IMF's Dominique Strauss-Kahn at the stakeout, on the IMF's failure to yet forgive Haiti's debt, in contrast to the IADB. After reporting Strauss-Kahn's answer yesterday, Thursday morning Inner City Press asked for more detail at the IMF's bi-weekly briefing, on this it will report before the IMF's 10:30 a.m. embargo time. Watch this site. www.innercitypress.com/haiti1euca040110.html

And see, www.innercitypress.com/haiti1euca040110.html

On Haiti, IMF's Strauss-Kahn Dodges on Debt Forgiveness, Past Conditions' Harm

UNITED NATIONS, March 31 -- Amid the congratulatory talk about help to Haiti at the UN on March 31, it emerged that the International Monetary Fund has yet to forgive Haiti's now over $270 million in debt to the IMF, while by contrast the Inter American Development Bank has forgiven all of its $479 million in loans to Haiti.

Inner City Press asked the IMF's Dominique Strauss-Kahn why the IMF's loans had yet to be forgiven, and to address the IMF's previous conditionalities on Haiti which results, experts say, in the destruction of the country's rice industry.

Strauss-Kahn scoffed at the latter question, saying that this -- a press stakeout in front of the pledging conference in the UN's Trusteeship Council Chamber -- was not the place to discussion conditionality. On the still unforgiven loans, he argued that they are not due until 2012, and bragged that Rene Preval is happy with the IMF's, and presumably his, performance.

After the stakeout, Strauss-Kahn made a point of hanging around with President Preval in the hallway in front of the Trusteeship Council.

Soon, the representative of the IADB came out, and confirmed that full forgiveness of $479 million in loans. Inner City Press asked, what explained the IABD's fast forgiveness, and the IMF's continued delay?

The IADB representative diplomatically mentioned the meeting of finance ministers in Cancun. But there are been a number of IMF Executive Board meetings and/or actions since Haiti's earthquake.

Some question whether Strauss-Kahn's perhaps related fixation on Greece -- where he's said the IMF would "intervene" if asked -- and his personal political trajectory, not only vis a vis Nicolas Sarkozy but also Martine Aubry, have made him and the IMF slow on Haiti. One wouldn't know it from Wednesday's bluster, but facts... are facts. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf2haiti033110.html

"No Correlation" of Labor Rights and Supermarkets in UN Global Compact, Kell Says No Quotes

UNITED NATIONS, March 30 -- A study of whether European supermarket chains take seriously labor rights in the developing world was presented at the UN on March 30, and some of the companies scoring lowest turned out to be members of the UN Global Compact, through which companies claim to sign on to labor rights principles.

Inner City Press asked the presenter of the study, Catherine Nicholson of Consumers International, about the UN Global Compact. She replied that in the study, each firm was asked if it had signed on to the Compact. The study looked at this, compared to operations policies of "real benefit on the ground," and found "no correlation." Video here, from Minute 14:20. Ms. Nicholson said, "that needs to be fed back."

But who in the UN is listening? Outside a meeting of the Global Compact's board of directors on March 25, Inner City Press sought to get some answers from board members. "You can't quote anything said here," the Compact's Georg Kell said.

Inner City Press asked Kell if there would be any media availability by the Compact's directors. No, he said. Despite later complaints to Compact staff, and what seemed to be a commitment to provide some answers, including on Compact members' investments in Myanmar, nothing came.

There was no time, it was explained to Inner City Press. But the Compact had professional video and still photographers posing the Compact board members in the UN lobby, to some future promotion. No time?

Of Compact member Casino, the French supermarket firm, Ms. Nicholson said "there is not enough information" and "they are not willing to share it." She might well have been speaking of the UN Global Compact itself.

Consumers International's web page for the study, here, ends with the tease, "an in-depth investigation into one supply chain is currently under way. This will be presented in the form of a documentary film in late 2010." Inner City Press asked what type of supply chain -- "fruit or vegetable?" Video here, from Minute 25:41.

Ms. Nicholson replied, "Tropical." She added, "fruited," and committed to send more information later. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ungc1smarkets033010.html

As UN Makes Appeal for Niger, Dodges on Role of China and France, Face of Coup like Guinea

UNITED NATIONS, March 30 -- Niger, the world's sixth largest producer of uranium and the venue of a recent coup d'etat led by a former UN peacekeeper, Salou Djibo, faces a severe drought. The UN's Central Emergency Relief Fund has put up $6 million, and on March 30 a press conference for the purpose of fundraising was held by the UN's Resident Coordinator for Niger, Khardiata Lo N'diaye.

Did the seizure of power by force have any impact on the humanitarian situation, Inner City Press asked. Khardiata Lo N'diaye replied that the "de facto authorities have put the humanitarian issues at the top of their priorities." Video here, from Minute 3:48.

Cursory research finds that "state-owned China National Petroleum Corporation... paid a $272 million signing bonus to the administration of Tandja, who had appointed his own son Ousmane as commercial attaché to the Nigerien Embassy in Hong Kong, a move NGOs say helped Chinese companies curry favor with the African ex-president."

Inner City Press asked, with all due respect, if any contribution had been sought or received from China, and whether the ostensibly diplomatic UN mission of Robert Fowler, as a bridge between the government and the Tuareg, had been in touch with the UN Country Team, and was in any way still active. Video here, from Minute 12:08.

Khardiata Lo N'diaye responded with a series of buzz words -- chronical vulnerability, development trends, sub regional Sahelian security issues. She did not answer if China has made any contribution, only emphasizing the the appeal for funds "is open."

Where is former colonial power France? Only days before, the UN's Resident Coordinator for Guinea held a similar press conference, asking for funds, although in Guinea's case some funds would go for elections. The OCHA spokesman denied that was any connection between these two humanitarian press conferences about countries with recent coups.

The UN is fumbling elections in Afghanistan, Iraq and Sudan. Could the answer be putting a humanitarian face on military rule? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncoup2niger033010.html

As UN's Ban Delays Bhutto Report 15 Days for Pakistan, Amid Dodges on Who Sees It, Doubts Grow

UNITED NATIONS, March 30 -- The release of a UN panel's report on the murder of Benazir Bhutto was stopped on Tuesday, based on a request from the President of Pakistan to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky told the Press that the report will now be released on April 15.

Inner City Press and others asked if the report would in the interim be shown to Pakistan, and if it could be changed before April 15. Video here, from Minute 11:15.

Nesirky said, and his associate Farhan Haq later reiterated, that the report had not and will not be shown to Pakistan before April 15. But already there are quotes from "a U.N. official who has been briefed on the independent commission's report" that it faults the Pakistani "government for scrubbing down the crime scene after the killing."

Inner City Press asked Nesirky if anyone in the Secretariat has seen the final or a draft of the report. "Pass," Nesirky said. "I don't know." Inner City Press asked if he would find out. He said he would "if the information is available to be publicly disclosed." Video here, from Minute 26:51.

In these circumstances, of quotes from UN officials "briefed" about the report, and a refusal to answer which UN staff have seen or been briefed on the report, suspicious grow that the report will be changed, that such changes are the purpose of the 15 day delay.

In the case of Sri Lanka, Ban allowed the protests of Sri Lanka to delay, and then give a seat to Sri Lanka's ambassador, in setting up a panel of experts to advise him about war crimes in Sri Lanka.

In the case of Pakistan, even once a report was finished, Pakistan's president was able to get release delayed for two weeks, and no assurances have been given that the report will not be changed.

This UN loses credibility daily, on these panels and reports, and also on elections, to which we will shortly turn. Watch this site.

From the UN's transcript:

Inner City Press: Has anyone in the Secretariat, not just the Secretary-General, has anyone in the Secretariat seen either the final or draft report? And will you tell us between now and 15 April if anyone in the Secretariat, the Secretary-General or otherwise, sees the report? Is that something that you can, given the doubts that may come to exist about whether it was changed?

Spokesperson Nesirky: If I am at liberty to tell you, then I will.

Inner City Press: If you are not at liberty, will you tell us that you are not at liberty? I mean… [laughter]

Spokesperson: That’s called the moral maze. What I mean is, if I am told I am at liberty to tell you, then I will of course tell you. Do you understand what I mean?

Inner City Press: I suppose so. But then, so then… So, on the 15th then we’ll ask you, did anyone see it, and then you will answer that?

Spokesperson: Sure. Look, as you know, the commissioners have been working to put together the report, and they have worked extremely hard to put it together. They have worked with a team, and those people have been providing the technical assistance, if you like, to compile the report. Okay.

Inner City Press: And the team are paid by the UN or are UN staff? Who is the team?

Spokesperson: Pass. I don’t know.

Inner City Press: Can you find…?

Spokesperson: This is an independent inquiry… [interrupted]

Inner City Press: Staffed by the UN or DPA or no…?

Spokesperson: As I said, the three commissioners, as you well know, they have travelled to the region; they have had support in doing so.

Inner City Press: Right. But I just want to be like… is it, has there been any UN Secretariat staff involvement in staffing their work or arranging their travel? You see what I mean? It’s called independent, but who is actually doing the background for them?

Spokesperson: The Commission is independent. It was established by the Secretary-General, at his request. And the report is being provided to him. So, clearly, assistance will have been provided to help them to provide the report. The exact details, I don’t know the exact details. I am just telling you that they have been helped with the logistical support to compile the report.

Inner City Press: [inaudible]… maybe, you may not know it right now. But has anyone -- just the same question that I asked -- has anyone in the Secretariat seen the final report ready to be delivered, or a draft of the report?

Spokesperson: I don’t know that.

Inner City Press: Will you commit to find that out or say if you can say it?

Spokesperson: If the information is available to be publicly shared, then I will do so, okay? I think you understand what I can do and what I cannot do. I try to do my best, okay? Yes.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1bhutto033010.html

On Uzbek Human Rights, UN Won't Compare, Sting Sings, But Not For UNICEF

UNITED NATIONS, March 29 -- When the UN's Human Rights Committee reviews the record of a country like Uzbekistan, of what value is it? Uzbekistan persecutes political opponents and religious minorities: for example, it has locked up a UNICEF-funded AIDS activist by calling his pamphlets blasphemous.

Last week Inner City Press asked Committee members if Uzbekistan's record was getting better or worse. "That's not the way we address it," replied Krister Thelin, a Swedish member of the Committee. "I will not engage at this time in any grading exercise. I hope you can respect that." Video here, from Minute 32:43.

Is Uzbekistan's record better or worse than New Zealand, which was also being reported on? We don't compare, was the answer, along with a coy pointing to the fact that Uzbekistan has been asked to report again in three years, while New Zealand has been given five years, the "top grade."

Perhaps it's this garbled or non-speak which for example allowed former Police bassist Sting to recently take money to play a concert for the daughter of Uzbek strongman Islam Karimov.

When confronted, Sting said he thought the concert was "sponsored by UNICEF."

But Inner City Press asked UNICEF spokesman Chris de Bono, twice, and both times was told the UNICEF had nothing to do with Ms. Karimova's concert featuring Sting.

With so little said at the press conference, one had to go back to the UN's own write up of the Committee's proceedings on Uzbekistan. Therein, at page 9, one finds the blissfully unaware comments of one "Hellen Keller" of Switzerland who "said she was particularly impressed by the blue booklet the delegation had provided to the Committee." You might ask, how did she know it was blue? Or, what would have has thought of the requirment by neighboring Turkmenistan that all children read the leader's book, Ruhnama?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1uznz032910.html