Sunday, March 21, 2010

UN Exposed Supporting Congo Criminals In 2010, Secret List, Using Haiti as Defense

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1zimu030910.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 9 -- The UN and its Mission in the Congo have been caught in a web on contradictory statements by and about Congolese warlord Innocent Zimurinda.

In October, UN special rapporteur Philip Alston charged Zimurinda with responsibility for mass rape and murder. On December 16, Inner City Press asked MONUC boss Alan Doss about the UN's logistical support to Zimurinda's units.

"We've set up a procedure," Doss said, "as needed we will suspend support." Video here, from Minute 4:09. Doss claimed that UN support through the Kimia II operation to all Congolese units, not only Zimurinda's, was being ended in 2009.

Now Zimurinda has been quoted that support continued into 2010; his deputy Dieudonne says that the UN is still willing to support Zimurinda's units. Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky to respond to Zimurinda's interview and explain Doss' December 16 claims.

Nesirky began by disputing that it was "just an interview" by Zimurinda. He spoke about the wider Washington Post article, saying it gave "an inaccurate impression." He claimed that the support Zimurinda's units got in 2010 has already been "in the pipeline" and couldn't be stopped. Video here, from Minute 55:02.

Even if one accepted this, why didn't Doss disclose it in December?

Doss was and is under fire for nepotism, having been exposed by Inner City Press urging the UN Development Program to show him "leeway" and give his daughter a job. To escape pressure, Doss claimed that the problematic support to Zimurinda was ending in 2009. But that turns about to be false.

Even now, the UN and MONUC split hairs. The Washington Post reports that even for the new Amani Leo operation -- the Post puts it in the future, but it has already quietly began -- two units of Zimurinda's command are on the list to receive UN assistance. Nesirky claims not. Inner City Press asked top peacekeeper Alain Le Roy to disclose which 18 battalions the UN will support. Video here. Le Roy said he would look into if that could be done, implying he saw no reason why not.

I'm sure Mr. Le Roy will answer your question, Nesirky to Inner City Press, adding acerbically of Le Roy that "today he's had other things on his mind." The reference was to Tuesday morning's memorial service for UN staff who died in the Haiti earthquake. Nesirky cited to this to explain Le Roy's or the wider UN's lack of response.

Nesirky also told a journalist his questioning of the UN in Haiti was "unfair." The UN's top envoy to Haiti Edmond Mulet, when asked about the condition and soundness of the Christopher Hotel, for which the UN in Haiti paid $94,000 a month in rent, said that he didn't know about the inquiry into the building's soundness, he was other things to worry about.

Some thought playing the Haiti earthquake trump card to cut off or not answer questions was distasteful. But the misstatements on the UN working with war criminals in the Congo is even worse. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1zimu030910.html

At UN, Friends Give Friends High Posts by Doctoring C.V.s, In $300 Million Delayed Umoja ERP

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/erp1recruit030810.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- Corruption and nepotism have infected the UN's $300 million plus Enterprise Resource Planning computer project, sources and documents indicated.

After Paul van Essche came in as head of the ERP at the D-2 level, he immediately moved to bring in colleagues and friends from Geneva, doctoring their Personal History Profiles to do so.

Jon Solem had applied for a P-5 post in ERP, listing van Essche as his supervisor, but hadn't been selected. Aftr van Essche became the D-2 in charge, Solem applied for a D-1 post, one step down from Van Essche's D-2, but a step up from the P-5 he hadn't gotten.

Suddenly Solem's PHP was doctored to delete references to Van Essche as supervisor. Van Essche served on and chaired the selection panel, and selected his friend Solem, without leaving any paper trail.

The UN's ERP program is behind schedule and over budget. What has been the UN's response? To rename it Umoja, Swahili for "unity." More than a year ago on January 19, 2009, the UN announced

The UN has decided to award a contract for Enterprise Resource Planning software to a European software company called SAP. The awarding of the contract is subject to successful negotiations, which will start immediately and are projected to wrap up within three months. As of now, no contract has been awarded, and the value of any such contract is as yet undetermined.

More than a year later, the contract has still not been finalized. Related, Inner City Press has asked what is the status of the implementation of the International Public Sector Accounting Standards? Four years ago, in November 2005, the High Level Committee on Management recommended system-wide adoption of IPSAS by 2010, and in 2006 the GA passed a resolution (60/283) which set the 2010 deadline. But it now appears that the Secretariat is running four years late, and does not expect to implement IPSAS until December 2014.

Consultants from PriceWaterhouseCoopers are swarming, their meters running, while as one member of the UN's budget committee told Inner City Press, "nothing is being accomplished except high officials hiring their friends."

Sources paint this picture, on which both Mr. Van Essche and Mr. Solem were asked to comment prior to publication of this story, without response:

* In early 2008, several ERP-related Vacancy Announcements (VAs) were announced by the UN including: D2 Project Director, D1 Business Process Reengineering Coordinator and P5 Senior Change Management posts.

* Mr. Jon Solem applied to the P-5 Senior Change Management post and Mr. Paul van Essche applied to D2 Project Director post.

* Mr. van Essche was selected for D2 post and started in September 2008. In October 2008, he canceled the VA for the D1 Business Process Reengineering Coordinator, changed the title to Organizational Change Manager and re-advertised it.

* Mr. van Essche chaired the interview panel for the P-5 Senior Change Management Officer post. Mr. Solem was not selected. These are extracts from the PHP, in which he names Mr. van Essche as his previous supervisor. At the time, he was not sure if Mr. van Essche would be selected Project Director.

Application for P5 (Mar-May 2008, VA 417551)
Employer Type of Business Year Supervisor Location
UNHCR Snr CM Officer 05/2006-06/2008 Colin Mitchell Swiss
UNHCR Snr Business Analyst 02/2005-03/2006 Colin Mitchell Swiss
ILO Snr.CM Officer 05/2004-12/2004 Paul van Essche Swiss
UNHCR Snr.CM Officer 07/2003-05/2004 Michael Malecha Swiss
Public relations firm Indp. Cnslt. 08/2002-07/2003 Illa Thompson South Africa
LeftBrain Consulting 01/2002-08/2002 Paul van Essche Swiss
Health Online Clinical Laboratory 04/2000-12/2001 Paul van Essche Swiss
SGS Testing & Quality 08/1993-04/2000 Robert Collier Swiss

Mr. van Essche also chaired the interview panel for the D1 Organizational Change Manager. The panel selected Mr. Solem, this time. Mr. Solem however doctored his PHP to conceal his relationship with Mr. van Essche.

Application for D1 (Oct-Dec. 2008, VA 419603)
Employer Type of Business Year Supervisor Location
Michael O'Neill Change Consulting 06/2008-11/2008 Michael O'Neill Swiss
UNHCR Snr CM Officer 05/2006-06/2008 Colin Mitchell Swiss
UNHCR Snr Business Analyst 02/2005-03/2006 Colin Mitchell Swiss
ILO Snr.CM Officer 05/2004-12/2004 Steven Townley Swiss
UNHCR Snr.CM Officer 07/2003-05/2004 Michael Malecha Swiss
Public relations firm Indp. Cnslt. 08/2002-07/2003 Illa Thompson South Africa
LeftBrain Consulting 01/2002-08/2002 Richard King Swiss
Health Online Clinical Laboratory 04/2000-12/2001 Miguel Payrot Swiss
SGS Testing & Quality 08/1993-04/2000 Robert Collier Swiss

* The questions are why did Mr. Solem doctor his PHP? Did OHRM conduct a background check? Why did Mr. van Essche cancel the previous VA and allowed to rename the post. The GA approved the post as D1 BPR Coordinator.

* Mr. Solem was a P-4 at UNHCR and became a D1 with Umoja.

* A review of Mr. van Essche’s PHP show that he and Jon worked for SGS (Switzerland) at around the same time.

We will have more on this.

On March 8, when the UN took no non-Iraq or non-Police questions at its noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon about hiring irregularities at the UN, in this case the foreign minister of Sri Lanka asking a high UN official to give his son a job. Mr. Ban said that the UN is transparent. From the UN's transcript of the Q & A:

Inner City Press: the Foreign Minister of Sri Lanka, also over the weekend, confirmed that he sought a job for his son with the UN. I wonder if you think that is appropriate, and is such a job going to be given?... Do you think that it’s appropriate for the Foreign Minister of a country with which you are dealing with on possible war crimes to be seeking a job for his son with the UN?

SG: First of all, I am not aware of that particular case of job application of the Foreign Minister’s son. As a matter of fact, any recruitment process will have to be dealt with in a most transparent and objective manner by the selection committee members. That is what the United Nations has been [using] as a principle.

Has the UN been using transparency in recruitment and assessment as a policy? Again, we will have more on this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/erp1recruit030810.html

On Iraqi Elections, UN Has Two Positions, Afghanistan Redux?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un2melkraq030810.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- While there is much to be said about the Iraqi elections just held, the UN can't seem to get it act together on what to say, or even what it should be talking about. Top UN envoy to Iraq Ad Melkert spoke for the second time in a month to correspondents at UN headquarters Monday, this time by video, and painted a rosy picture of the election.

Inner City Press asked about the sample complaints of Ayad Allawi, about irregularities and confusion at polling stations, and his call for an investigation. We are aware of points of various candidates, Melkert said. It is is not my task to comment on particular statements. Video here, from Minute 10:42.

But how could Melkert's rosy assessment not be seen as an implicit rejection of Allawi's complaints, Inner City Press asked. Video here, from Minute 11:52. It is not my task or UNAMI's task, Melkert replied, to assess complaints. I did not refer to fair elections, only that turn out was good, that it was a big day, Melkert said. "You cannot attribute to me any assessment."

But the UK Telegraph did attribute an assessment to Melkert, specifically as a rebuttal to Allawi, directly by this quote: "The polling process was well-organised, orderly, and polling procedures were properly applied."

So Melkert made that statement to the Telegraph, and then told UN correspondents that it is not his or UNAMI's job to make such assessments. Which is it?

To some, this is reminiscent of the UN's performance during the Afghanistan election, downplaying complaints until a whistleblower emerged to denounce Kai Eide's praise. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2melkraq030810.html

UN Mis-Claims Its Sex Abusers "Will Be Charged" While Asserting Immunity

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unpol1lubbers030810.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- While the UN speaks of women's rights, it often does not promote them, especially from abuse by the UN's own personnel and peacekeepers. On March 8 UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon told the press, "today is International Women's Day....or that reason, I am pleased to announce that Ms. Ann-Marie Orler will be the new Police Adviser for the Department of Peacekeeping Operations."

Inner City Press asked Ms. Orler for her position on the UN's policy in cases of sexual abuse or exploitation by UN Police and Peacekeepers of only sending the perpetrator back to their country, which is free to not prosecute.

Ms. Orler began by acknowledging "there is an immunity for peacekeepers," adding confusingly that "if they've done something without the mandate." She then said without equivocation, "If it's serious, they will be charged for it." Video here, from Minute 12:22.

Inner City Press asked, isn't it true that the UN only repatriates, and cannot assure prosecution, that "they will be charged"? Ms. Orler admitted, "the country has to follow up... if the country neglects it, it is more difficult." Video here, from Minute 14:37.

So, it is not true to say of sexually abusing UN personnel that "they will be charged."

The lack of clarity comes from the top. On Monday Mr. Ban was asked

"we recently had this case of sexual harassment by a UN employee – [Cynthia] Brzak I think is her name – who was dismissed because your predecessor had not lifted the diplomatic immunity of the man in question. Is that not a policy you think you should tackle, to really put some teeth into your commitment to women's rights, lifting this policy of diplomatic immunity in the case where UN officials are accused of sexual harassment?"

Ban's response left many in the press corps, and those who heard it, shaking their heads:

SG Ban: I think that, as far as the United Nations is concerned, we have taken right and correct measures in that case. Now it is in the hands of the judiciary process. I have taken note of the decision of the US court here, not allowing for her to pursue this case by reason of immunity and privileges. That is the court's decision. We had taken all necessary administrative and legal measures at that time, when it had happened. But it will continue to be the firm policy and position of the United Nations.

So -- is is the firm policy and position of the UN to assert immunity when one of its officials is charged with sexual harassment? Ironically, when UN system staffer Nicolas Baroncini, having been pepper sprayed after his job was given to the daughter of UN Congo boss Alan Doss, bit a security officer, he had no immunity, and faces a continuing trial.

But when a high UN system official is charged with sexual harassment, the UN aserts immunity all the way. Firm policy, that... Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unpol1lubbers030810.html

At UN, Questions of Settlers in Israel's OECD Statistics, Two U.S. Positions

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/oecd1israel030810.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- While Israel's Vice Prime Minister Silvan Shalom predicted to the Press on Monday that his country with "finally join" the OECD at its meeting in May or June in Paris, he would not provide Israel's response to OECD's critique of including settlers but not Palestinians in Israel's statistics.

Inner City Press asked Shalom, twice, if both groups were and would be included in Israel's submission to the OECD. Shalom said, we will comply with the rules, and then referred to other issues that have arisen in the last few years. Video here, from Minute 21:27.

Another issue is whether wine and other products coming from Israeli settlements should be labeled as such. As one pro-Israel source told Inner City Press after its questions, "it's all politics."

Following up on Friday's Security Council meeting and press statement, Inner City Press asked Shalom if he understand, as the Palestinian Observer put it, that the "provocations" decried in the Council's press statement includes Israel's National Heritage List.

Shalom took this as an opportunity to hearken to the Bible, with its "first chapter" referring to patriarchs as in the Cave of the Patriarchs. We have been there 3700 years, he said, not 130. And then he left the stakeout.

Later, it was argued to Inner City Press that the United States delegation had not agreed to the Council's press statement of March 5. An even more pro-Israel source, however, blamed the U.S. not objecting on the fact that the "U.S. number one Ambassador was not there. The number two, who closely follows the Middle East, was not there either. The number three is sharp about Kosovo, but not the Middle East."

The source compared the two U.S. positions -- not objecting to the press statement and then claiming that it had -- to "Obama's record in the Senate, of not taking positions on some hard votes." That's what the source said. But if the U. S. Mission wants to claim it didn't agree, and blame the "inexperienced" Gabonese presidency, it should come forward with facts. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/oecd1israel030810.html

On Sri Lanka, UN's Ban Restates Concern on Lack of Progress, Unaware of Job Request

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/lanka3unfollow030810.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 8 -- After a weekend during which Sri Lanka's president and ruling party attacked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon for saying he will name a panel to advise himself about possible war crimes in Sri Lanka, Inner City Press asked Mr. Ban for his side of the story.

Ban said " I am concerned with the lack of progress of the joint statement which both I and President Rajapaksa had agreed during my visit last year." Ban declined to provide any further description of the panel or when he will name its members. Transcript here and below; video here.

Inner City Press also asked about the acknowledgement over the weekend by Sri Lanka's foreign minister that he has sought a UN job for his son.

While the same sources who first told Inner City Press about the minister's letter say it was addressed to Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, Ban replied that he is unaware of the request. He said that the UN has transparent recruitment procedures, an assertion that many dispute, including as to the children and sons in law of the top UN officials.

Here is the UN's transcript of the Q & A:

Inner City Press: Mr. Secretary-General, late last week you spoke with the President of Sri Lanka, and said that you are going to name a panel, to advise yourself, on accountability. Over the weekend, the President said that you had no right to do it and had a very different read-out of the call than we received, at least the way I hear it. Can you explain what the purpose of the Panel is and when you think you’re going to name it? And also the Foreign Minister of Sri Lanka, also over the weekend, confirmed that he sought a job for his son with the UN. I wonder if you think that is appropriate, and is such a job going to be given?

SG: As you said, I had a frank and honest exchange of views with President [Mahinda] Rajapaksa, Thursday night, last week, over issues that were of concern to both of us. This included moving forward on political reconciliation, further movement on the condition of internally displaced persons, and the establishment of an accountability process. I am concerned with the lack of progress of the joint statement which both I and President Rajapaksa had agreed during my visit last year. I raised this issue and discussed [it]. I made clear to President Rajapaksa that I intend to move forward on a Group of Experts which will advise me on setting the broad parameters and standards on the way ahead on establishing accountability concerning Sri Lanka. For that purpose, we have agreed that I dispatch[Under-Secretary-General of Political Affairs] Lynn Pascoe in the very near future.

Q: Do you think that it’s appropriate for the Foreign Minister of a country with which you are dealing with on possible war crimes to be seeking a job for his son with the UN?

SG: First of all, I am not aware of that particular case of job application of the Foreign Minister’s son. As a matter of fact, any

recruitment process will have to be dealt with in a most transparent and objective manner by the selection committee members. That is what the United Nations has been [using] as a principle.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/lanka3unfollow030810.html

Sunday, March 7, 2010

UN Confirms Fighting in Darfur, Says JEM Not Exclusive, Deby Says UN Spies?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/darfur2sla030510.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 5 -- After days of the UN saying it had no access to Jebel Marra in Darfur, and could not confirm the fighting there, late Friday top UN peacekeeper Alain Le Roy told Inner City Press that yes, we confirm confirm fighting between the SLA Abdul Wahid and the government.

Inner City Press asked for the response of the UN, which praised the deal between Khartoum and JEM, to JEM's later statement that it would renounce the deal if similar offers were made to other Darfur rebel groups. Video here, from Minute 3:19. Le Roy sputtered that JEM "has not repudiated the framework agreement."

Le Roy claimed that the Security Council was clear that "no one will have exclusivity of signing anything with the Sudanese authority." But who from the UN spoke with JEM's Khalil Ibrahim?

Inner City Press also asked Le Roy about his agreement with Chad's Idriss Deby, that the UN mission can remain only two more months and then must start leaving. How would this be possible, in the rainy season which begins in May? It will be difficult, Le Roy said. Video here, from Minute 11:40.

Also on Chad, Inner City Press asked about Deby's anger at those who say he did not want any observers to his upcoming election. Le Roy quickly responded that elections observations were not in MINURCAT's mandate. Even in the most egregious cases?

So it's like the UN's UNAMA in Afghanistan, snarked one cynic.

A Sudanese Mission source later told Inner City Press that the backdrop to Chad's President Deby ordering the UN to start leaving was his accusation that the MINURCAT mission was "spying." This was said with a certain glee.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/darfur2sla030510.html

As UN Criticizes Media in Liberia, No Answers on Somalia or Afghan Censorship

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1libafsom030510.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 5 -- The UN has reacted angrily to reports that its peacekeepers in Liberia's Lufa County "acted partially in favor of Mandingoes when they (peacekeepers) mounted their tanks in front of the mosque to prevent angry Lormas from attacking it."

The UN's top envoy in Monrovia Ellen Loj told a reporter that he should go to Lofa County before asking any question.

At the March 5 noon briefing in New York, Inner City Press asked spokesman Martin Nesirky about the reports and about the envoy's response to the media. Of this Special Representative of the Secretary General,Nesirky said he wouldn't second guess "him, who is on the ground." But what about the UN trying to discourage questions about its operations?

Recently Inner City Press asked Nesirky if the UN has any response to Afghan President Hamid Karzai's new prohibition on the media covering attacks by the Taliban. At first Nesirky said he hadn't heard about it, but that "generally" the UN favors free press coverage.

But when the UN's top envoy to Somalia Ahmedou Ould Abdallah criticized journalists who reported on the killings of civilians by peacekeepers in Mogadishu, and said there should be a one more moratorium on such reporting, the UN did nothing to discipline him. How then could it speak against Karzai's censorship?


UN's Ban and Peacekeepers in Liberia: no questions please

On March 4, Inner City Press asked Nesirky to explain Ould Abdallah's recent call for UN agencies to return to Somalia when he himself can't or won't move to Mogadishu, but rather works out of Nairobi. Nesirky acknowledged it look contradictory and said he would get an answer. But thirty hours later, there was no answer.

On Liberia, after Nesirky's first non response and deference to an SRSG of the wrong gender, a note was brought into it him. He read it out, and this summary was placed in the UN's own "highlights"

U.N. MISSION IN LIBERIA STRESSES IMPARTIALITY IN LOFA COUNTY VIOLENCE

In response to questions, the Spokesperson noted that the United Nations Mission in Liberia (UNMIL) has refuted claims that its forces were partial in last weekend’s violent incident in Lofa County.

The Head of UNMIL, Ellen Margrethe Løj, said UNMIL troops acted promptly and supported no side in the violence, he noted.

Having first heard about a violent demonstration in Konia Town, a batch of UNMIL Formed Police unit was quickly deployed in the Town. On the morning of the violence in Voinjama, both military and police forces intervened to restore calm.

She described the incident as unfortunate and said it was based on what she called unfounded rumours that spread from Konia to Voinjama. Løj said the Lofa incident, which has ethnic undertones, shows that more challenges still remain despite the progress made so far in maintaining peace and security in Liberia.

She said while the United Nations is in Liberia to keep the peace, it is up to Liberians themselves, regardless of religious and ethnic affiliation, to decide whether they want peace.

Nesirky added that UNMIL has confirmed that shotguns and firearms were actually used in the violence by the mob, resulting in four deaths.

He also said that all UN peacekeeping mission work impartially to serve all the people in the countries where they are deployed.

And questions should not even be raised about their impartiality, apparently...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1libafsom030510.html

On Sri Lanka War Crimes, UN's Ban to Name Panel to Advise Only Him, No Pascoe, Nambiar Nepotism Follow Up

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/lanka2unfollow030510.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 5 -- UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has informed Sri Lankan President Mahinda Rajapaksa that he will "name a panel of experts to advise him, the Secretary General, on the way forward on accountability issues related to Sri Lanka."

Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky included this information in a March 5 response to questions from Inner City Press, about war crimes, attempted nepotism and the UN's seeming failure to follow through on the statement that Lynn Pascoe, top UN political advisor, would visit Sri Lanka in February. Video here, from Minute 7:49.

Pascoe is traveling next week to India and Nepal, but not nearby Sri Lanka. On the night of March 4, when Inner City Press asked French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud why Ban has been so slow to act on Sri Lanka, Araud said this was due to pressure from member states.

Araud named India first, then China. He also said that France viewed the Rajapaksa administration's military offensive in Northern Sri Lanka as a "welcome" crushing of terrorism. Click here for that Inner City Press report.

Following what even the UN called the "bloodbath on the beach," Ban visited Sri Lanka in May 2009 and issued a statement about reconciliation with the Tamils and accountability for war crimes. But in the months that followed he took no action.

UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston publicly urged Ban to appoint an international panel to investigate presumptive war crimes in Sri Lanka. These include the urging of LTTE leaders to emerge with white flags, after which they were executed. Ban's chief of staff, the Indian diplomat Vijay Nambiar, was a go between conveying the Rajapaksas' message that emerging with a white flag held high would ensure safety.

On March 5, Inner City Press also asked Nesirky about reports in the Colombo press that Sri Lanka's foreign minister wrote to a senior UN official, identified as Nambiar, seeking a job for his own son with the UN Secretariat. Nesirky said "I'll find out." We'll see.

Just as Nesirky emphasized to Inner City Press that the panel will only advise Ban, and not Sri Lanka, it is important to note that what Ban is belatedly doing about 30,000 deaths in the first half of 2009 is less and later than what he did for 160 deaths in Guinea in September.

Friday at the UN many people asked Inner City Press why Ban was doing so little, so late, why he is "running scared," as one put it. On Thursday night, France's Gerard Araud attributed Ban's reticence to pressure from India and China. Did Ban check with these and other states before belated announcing a self-referential panel of experts? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/lanka2unfollow030510.html

Araud of France Gives Economic Read of Iran Sanctions, Ban's Sri Lanka Inaction

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/framb1sriran030410.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 4 -- "The United States for historical reasons has almost no economic relations with Iran," French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud said on Thursday night, explaining the U.S. push for sanctions on Tehran. In a dig at the U.S. position, Araud paraphrased a French philosopher, that "you are always ready to accept the sacrifice of your neighbor."

Speaking under the high painted wood ceiling of his country's consulate across from Central Park, Araud said that because of the invasion of Iraq purportedly to find weapons of mass destruction, now the "legitimacy" of Russian and Chinese support is needed for the next moves on Iran. Araud urged against a "black and white" view, saying for example that "economic interests are good reason" for a country's position.

Araud said the the UN is only a player where no one else wants to go. In the "Middle East conflict, the UN is hardly doing anything," he said. He was France's Ambassador to Israel. "If and when there is a peace process," he continued, the UN will be called in to provide the legitimacy of a Security Council vote, he said. Until then it can continue its humanitarian work in Gaza.

Inner City Press asked Araud to assess the the action or non-action of the UN, specifically the Secretariat of Ban Ki-moon, on the slaughter of civilians in Sri Lanka in 2009. You know the reason, Araud said, in a manner that more than one observer later described as angry. "The Secretary General can't go against member states" which did not want to intervene.

But a UN Secretary General is not entire the slave of the member states: he or she has an independent moral duty and diplomatic role. And if Ban Ki-moon couldn't do anything, why did he travel to Sri Lanka and then issue proclamations that he would follow up on accountability for war crimes, and reconciliation?

Araud said that there was a sense of relief that the Sri Lankan government killed off the LTTE. The price for civilians was high, he said, perhaps too high.

Araud was speaking, refreshingly candidly, after his country's consulate's screening of a pro-UN documentary by French filmmaker Romuald Sciora. As it turned out, Inner City Press has already seen and reviewed the film, Planet UN, click here for the review. But after this screening, James Traub lobbed questions to Araud and Sciora. When Inner City Press asked about Sri Lanka, Sciora merely said that he "agrees with Ambassador Araud."

Afterwards, Sciora told Inner City Press that the book version of Planet UN is more nuanced. His introduction begins with a day in 2003 he spent with UN official Staffan de Mistura, most recent named top UN envoy to Afghanistan.

Earlier on Thursday de Mistura complained loudly at the stakeout in front of the Security Council about Press coverage of his hiring of the Secretary General's son in law, and the role his may have played in the Secretary General naming him to the Kabul post.

(In fact, this son in law also served in India's Peace Keeping Force in Sri Lanka, policing Tamil lands, which some connect to his father in law's later inaction -- but that's another story.)

Inner City Press asked the UN spokesman if de Mistura could come to answer questions on the record later on Thursday. No, was the answer, he would not be answering questions. And from Planet UN, so it goes.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/framb1sriran030410.html

As Ban Heads to Chile, UN Praises Chile Despite Protests, MassiveGood Spin

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un2chile030410.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 4 -- With the UN's Ban Ki-moon now flying off to Chile, his officials' slavish praising of the government of President Michelle Bachelet has become more and more questionable.

First Alicia Barcena, head of the UN office in Santiago, told Inner City Press that no looting was occurring, contrary to TV images on BBC and France24. This UN official, who served for years in New York, asked "What is looting?" She said there was no violence or problems between the government and the people.

Next, the UN's deputy humanitarian chief Catherine Bragg told a press conference that Chile is a strong government that is doing a good job. But when Bachelet traveled near Concepcion on March 4, she didn't go into the downtown due to protests of her performance.

Inner City Press asked Bragg, why was the UN going out of its way to praise Chile's government? Why was there such a stigma on receiving UN aid? Bragg said she was just telling it like it is. This is how the world appears to the UN: governments good, critics invisible.

Ban is traveling with only seven other people -- two of them guards -- on a commercial flight. He learned of the available seat on Thursday morning. He also publicly clicked a two dollar donation to MassiveGood, along with Bill Clinton. What is Clinton doing these days for Haiti? Bachelet was serving as UNIFEM spokesperson for Haiti until her own earthquake hit. And now?

Footnote: On MassiveGood, after Ban's clicking, UN official Philippe Douste Blazy appeared to describe the program. Inner City Press asked Douste Blazy how transparency in how the money is spend will be ensured, and about his earlier idea of a UN Lottery to raise money.

Douste Blazy did not say much about transparency -- a French observer described high costs, that is, MassiveOverhead -- but he again praised the lottery idea. Inner City Press asked, but doesn't that take money from the poor? We're not doing it yet, Douste Blazy answered. Oh, good.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2chile030410.html