Monday, November 16, 2009

UN's Velvet Glove Censorship of Poster on Great Firewall of China, "Folded, Undamaged"

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unnet1censor111609.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 16 -- After the UN in Egypt removed a poster protesting Chinese web censorship from its Internet Governance Forum, at its headquarters in New York its Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq told Inner City Press the poster was "folded up... undamaged."

Haq said solemnly, "No UN official was involved in throwing the poster on the floor." He confirmed that the UN removed the poster, but said it was "on the floor, face up" when the UN demanded its removal. Video here, from Minute 20:26.

On the other hand, a delegate at the Internet Governance Forum has been quoted that "the poster was thrown on the floor and we were told to remove it because of the reference to China and Tibet. We refused, and security guards came and removed it. The incident was witnessed by many."

A more authoritative account: "The UN officials... asked us to remove it and one of our staff placed it on the ground for us to consider what to do. That's where we had the discussion. When we refused to remove it, their security guards bundled it up and took it away."

The UN's Haq explained the incident by stating that the group which unfurled the poster about censorship had, earlier in the conference, distributed an "unauthorized" flier for a movie about Tibet. Haq said this was prohibited by the UN, because it was a "political issue not related to the Internet Governance Forum."

But isn't web censorship an issue "related to the Internet Governance Forum"?

In fact, as Inner City Press has exclusively reported, the UN in New York uses filtering software which has blocked such web sites as (China's) Anti-CNN.com, click here for that story.

The poster contained the sentence: "The first generation of internet controls consisted largely of building firewalls at key internet gateways; China's famous 'Great Firewall of China' is one of the first national Internet filtering systems."

Inner City Press, which in full disclosure has its own experience with UN attempts to censor, click here, asked the UN's Haq at Monday's noon briefing to confirm that the above-quoted poster concerned internet censorship. Four hours later, no confirmation had been provided. Watch this site.

From the November 16 UN transcript:

Inner City Press: One more about the freedom of expression question. At this Internet Governance Forum (IGF), there has been an incident in which a poster about Internet censorship in China, about what they call the “Great Firewall” was taken down by the United Nations after the complaint by an unnamed delegation. It may seem like a small thing to you, but I’m wondering, given what you just said that the Secretary-General’s focus was on freedom of expression, does he think that that type of removal is consistent with his position?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: Well, in terms of that, I do have the facts of this from our colleagues in Sharm el-Sheikh. The Internet Governance Forum secretariat approved the request by a group called the Open Net Initiative for a room on the first day of the Forum to promote a book, and a room was allocated for that purpose. Subsequently, United Nations officials were alerted to a flyer being distributed at the event promoting a film on Tibet, which was not mentioned in the original request for the room. Officials from the Forum secretariat requested the organizers not to distribute the flyer or show the film, as this was not what the room was requested for, and concerned a political issue not related to the Internet Governance Forum. The IGF secretariat requested the organizers of the event not to distribute the flyers and they agreed.

Subsequently, other delegates complained to the Forum secretariat about a large poster displayed outside the room, which again was not pre-approved for posting outside the allocated room. In response to this complaint, officials from the Forum secretariat went to the room to discuss the issue with the organizers. Officials found that the poster was already on the floor of the room lying face up. No United Nations official was involved in throwing the poster on the floor. Following repeated requests from the IGF secretariat to remove the poster from the floor, United Nations security removed it from the floor and folded it undamaged. The organizers were told that they could pick it up anytime later that evening. And so that’s where we stand on that. But, the point to reiterate on that is that the request was made to the non-governmental organization involved not to distribute the flyers and they did agree to that.

Inner City Press: From the way that you say it, do you acknowledge that the poster had to do with Internet censorship in China and not Tibet, an issue that was related presumably to Internet governance?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: These are the details that were provided by colleagues in Sharm el-Sheikh. That’s what I’ve got.

Inner City Press: Can you ask them what the poster… just to confirm that the poster was about Internet censorship?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: Sure.

But eight hours later, no confirmation (or denial) was provided. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unnet1censor111609.html

UNHCR Poised to "Bluewash" Nestle on Child Labor, Water and Infant Formula Abuse

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhcr1nestle111509.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 15 -- The UN's refugee agency appears poised to announce a partnership with Nestle, despite a slew of concerns about the company's practices.

In only the last month at UN Headquarters in New York, Nestle has been named in connection with child labor in Cote d'Ivoire and abusive water practices.

Tellingly, it is under the rubric of "water projects" and not nutrition that UNHCR is preparing to justify what some call its "blue washing" of Nestle.

On November 13, Inner City Press asked UNHCR these questions:

Has UNHCR been in communication with Nestle about some form of partnership? Please describe and quantify, including in dollars or Euros. Is the plan to announce this partnership next week? Which day?

Has UNHCR considered such issues as (1) Nestle being named, including in a recent UN press conference, as less than a leader on the issue of child labor? (2) Nestle being alleged to violate the UN International Code of marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes, violations of which have been recognized as violations of the child’s right to the highest attainable standard of health (Convention on the Rights of the Child)?

UNHCR's director of communications Melissa Fleming responded late on November 13, near midnight Geneva time, that

"Dear Matthew, This is all I have for you at this stage: We are in discussion with Nestle about cooperation on future projects that will help deliver clean water and support small scale farming initiatives for refugees."

Nestle, under fire for its participating in the UN's CEO Water Mandate as well as UN Global Compact, has a history of paying money to try to make problems go away. Previously it demanded compensation from Ethiopia for a subsidiary nationalized decades ago, then tried to diminish the backlash with a donation to UNHCR.

Campaigners note that UNICEF refuses Nestle's money due to the company's violations of the UN International Code of marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes.

Another UNHCR spokesperson put out a more detailed spin of accepting Nestle's money, "UNHCR have worked on and off with Nestle since 2003 when they funded a water project in eastern Ethiopia for refugees and local villagers. Nestle joined UNHCR's Council of Business Leaders in Jan. 2005. We are in discussions to expand a partnership on water, sanitation and livelihood development."

While UNHCR has refused to put a financial value on past and proposed payments to it from Nestle, the Ethiopia donation was reportedly in connection with the $6 million that Nestle demanded from Ethiopia. After backlash, Nestle said it would donate the money it had demanded. Oxfam refused to accept the "blood money." Then as now, UNHCR provided a bluewashing safe haven for Nestle. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhcr1nestle111509.html

Saturday, November 14, 2009

As Blair Lobbies for Wataniya, Do Kuwait and JPM Chase's Arranger Role Spell UN Conflict of Interest?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/blair1unjpmc111309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 13 -- When Tony Blair does business, who does he work for? He represents the Quartet, and thus the UN, on development in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. He has been paid by JPMorgan Chase as a consultant, and presumably works for them. When he acts in the West Bank for the Wataniya cell phone company, who is he working for?

The UN has repeatedly claimed that there would and could be no conflict of interest between Blair's paid position for JPMorgan Chase and his work in the Palestinian Occupied Territories. When Inner City Press asked Blair, after a meeting of the Quarter in the Conference Room 4 in UN Headquarters, about any safeguards in place for his UN and JPMorgan Chase roles, he scoffed. A Blair staffer confirmed that he continued in JPM Chase's employ.

This week, Tony Blair attended a press conference announcing the finalization of Wataniya's deal, which Blair "negotiated." At the UN noon briefing on November 11, Inner City Press asked about this last:

Inner City Press: yesterday, Tony Blair was in Ramallah, and he’s described as having negotiated on behalf of a cell phone company with the Israeli Government. There’s a whole press conference also that noted his role for the Quartet and for the UN. So I’m wondering, did he do this on behalf of the Quartet and the UN and what is the UN’s knowledge, do they have any knowledge on this business negotiating activity?

Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe: I have no knowledge of that.

Even forty six hours later, no answer has been provided. But even cursory research reveals that Blair's employer JPMorgan Chase served as a "mandated lead arranger" for the acquisition of Wataniya. Click here for the document.

So again, what safeguards are in place? Who is Tony Blair working for?

Tony Blair Associates has as a client Kuwait, and by implication its royal family, while Blair has met with the finance minister of Kuwait while representing JPMorgan Chase. Wataniya Palestine is substantially (57%) owned by investors from Qatar and... Kuwait. For the former, it's Qatar Telecom. But for the later, it's the Kuwait Investment Authority, which operates on behalf of the State of Kuwait -- Tony Blair Associates' client. So when Blair lobbies for Wataniya, who is he representing?

While awaiting the UN's answers, we note that in June 2009, "Wataniya Palestine CEO Alan Richardson recently called on Middle East envoy and former British prime minister Tony Blair to intervene on behalf of Wataniya to get the frequency released. Richardson previously has been involved in controversial cell phone projects in Iraq, with Orascom and Iraqna, contracts which the U.S. Pentagon urged the Coalition Provisional Authority to cancel.

So to the degree Tony Blair is working for Richardson, this too is problematic. But beyond the UN and Quarter, is Blair working for Kuwait? With JPMorgan Chase's documented mandate lead arranger role for the acquisition of Wataniya, there is a conflict which, it would seem, will require action. Blair is dismissive, and the UN appears cowed. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/blair1unjpmc111309.html

In Congo, UN Fails to Act on MSF as Bait Attacks, After 4 Weeks, of Holmes and Mountain

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/drc1nochamsf111309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 13 -- In Masisi in the Congo four weeks ago, Congolese army forces attacked civilians who had gathered for vaccination by MSF Doctors without Borders. MSF subsequently put out a public statement and, the group told the Press on November 13, informed the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs both in New York and the Congo.

Still, the UN Mission in the Congo (MONUC) has neither said or done anything about the involved units of the Congolese Army. On November 13, Inner City Press asked OCHA chief John Holmes why the UN system's reaction has been so slow.

Holmes said "I saw the allegations" of MSF and have "no reason to disbelieve" them. Still, he said, "I don't know enough about what happened to comment on your specific point." But why not? Who in OHCA, or the wider UN, is responsible to acting on a group of MSF's description of atrocities by a one of MONUC's partners?

Holmes said that perhaps Ross Mountain, back from the Congo for a week and retiring that day, would address it. But on November 12 when Inner City Press asked Mountain, he said he didn't know much about it. He's only been in New York for a week. And if he doesn't know about it, who in the UN system does?

Finally Holmes said "it's easy to criticize," and that the Congolese Army might be worse if MONUC stopped working with it, leaving it "without any restraining influence." But by that logic, one might argue the UN should assist, in order to restraint, a group like the Lord's Resistance Army.

Holmes noted that Alain Le Roy "announced very quickly" that MONUC wouldn't assist some units of the Congolese Army, that MONUC "immediately" said it would withdraw support.

But that belated withdrawal is from units alleged to have killed month ago in May, unconnected with the MSF or Philip Alston allegations. Does MONUC give a six month grace period after atrocities, to continue receiving UN support? Is this what due process, or face saving, has become?

After Holmes' answer -- Mountain did not take a second bite at the apple -- the UN representative of MSF added that this was "the first time since the 1990s" when MSF concluded "our presence was used to kill people." Inner City Press has asked MSF for more information. It would seem the UN would take this seriously, four weeks after the incident and at least a week after a very public report. But apparently not.

What is wrong with MONUC? Another participant in the event, held at the International Peace Institute, put the blame on the UN's Congo envoy Alan Doss. "Things have gotten worse under Doss," Henri Boshoff of the Institute for Security Studies in South Africa told Inner City Press. But where is the accountability? To be continued.

Footnote: we would really like to write a less critical retirement piece on Ross Mountain. The November 13 press conference, at which whistleblower allegations where also blown off, did not allow for it. Nor did the November 14 IPI appearance. There is apparently at least one more UN Mountain event, at which Holmes said he will praise Mountain. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc1nochamsf111309.html

UN's Ban Says Let Bygones Be Bygones on Afghan Election Fraud, Timor Impunity

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1bygones110409.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 4, updated Nov. 5 -- As the cancellation of the fraud triggered run off election in Afghanistan was called illegal by challenger Abdullah Abdullah, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in London called on him to "let those bygones be bygones."

Some wondered how this reflected the UN's commitment to democracy and the rule of law, and bigger picture, to impunity. President al Bashir of Sudan for example, or indicted Timorese militia leader Maternus Bere, might say bygones should be bygones. But what if it's illegal?

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas about the "let those bygones be bygones" quote, and if Ban and the UN are saying that the Karzai dominated IEC's decision is legal. "We are not passing judgment on that," Ms. Montas said. Video here, from Minute 12.

But the UN's Kai Eide, as soon as Abdullah Abdullah dropped out of the second round due to fraud in the first, called for "timely" conclusion. And the UN has de facto given its blessing since.

Citing Afghanistan, Ban Ki-moon went to the General Assembly seeking more money for security. But sources in the UN's Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions tell Inner City Press that the Secretariat didn't file a budget request for Security along with its other requests, and that a management report on DSS which was requested in the 62nd General Assembly two years ago still has not been filed.

"He shouldn't be too opportunistic," an ACABQ member told Inner City Press. Ms Montas on Wednesday refused to comment, saying, "I cannot get involved in the business of ACABQ." Video here, from Minute 17:20.

Footnote: Likewise on the issue of impunity, this time in Timor Leste, Inner City Press asked about the recent release of Maternus Bere, indicted for crimes against humanity by a UN-supported court. Did the UN try to stop him from leaving Timor for Indonesia? Video here, from Minute 21:33.

"There was nothing the UN could do," Montas said. "We learned of the transfer as anyone else did. I have to get more information before I give you the Secretary General's opinion." We'll be waiting.

Update of Nov. 5 -- subsequently, on Timor at least, the UN provided a canned statement, below from the transcript, for a Nov. 5 Afghanistan development at the UN, click here. Nov. 5 read out:

"I was asked yesterday about our views concerning reports that Maternus Bere, who was indicted for crimes against humanity allegedly committed in 1999 in what was then East Timor, has gone to Indonesia. The UN Mission in Timor-Leste (UNMIT) says that it has no information on the circumstances of Bere’s return to Indonesia.

The United Nations position that there should be no impunity, especially for serious crimes, including crimes against humanity, war crimes and genocide, is well known. In the case of Maternus Bere, it is our position that Mr. Bere should be brought to justice. We have made this position clear on numerous occasions.

We have seen the media reports indicating that Maternus Bere was transferred to Indonesia late last week. We were not aware of this transfer and have yet to receive official confirmation that such a transfer took place. For us, any act that undermines the rule of law, particularly with respect to accountability for serious crimes, is deeply regrettable.

I’d like to recall that the Secretary-General expressed his hope in last month’s report to the Security Council that 'the Governments of both Timor-Leste and Indonesia will ensure that Maternus Bere is brought to justice, taking into account the report of the Commission of Experts appointed in 2005.'"

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1bygones110409.html

UN's Upbeat Talk on Congo Evades Massacres and Whistleblower's Tales

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/monuc1mountain111309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 13 -- With mounting reports of the UN Mission in the Congo working with Army units which target and kill civilians, outgoing MONUC Deputy Ross Mountain on November 12 spoke of "extraordinary progress in us using innovatively the military we have to" protect civilians. Video here, from Minute 19:32.

Inner City Press asked, what about the report of UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston, that Army units commanded by one Colonel Zimulinda killed 50 civilians but nothing has been done? When MONUC chief Alan Doss was last in New York, Inner City Press asked him about Alston's report and Zimulinda, and Doss said there wasn't enough proof.

Now that UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay has called for action on Zimulinda, how does Mountain explain Doss' earlier statements? "I wasn't here for the earlier comments," Mountain said, adding "I haven't followed that."

Inner City Press asked about the case of MONUC local staff member John Dimandja, who was used the UN in disarmament until he and his family tell under threat. As exclusively reported by Inner City Press, he came to New York, told the UN about the theft and resale of UN jet fuel in Bunia. Ultimately, after he in frustration said he'd have to stand in front of Ban Ki-moon's car, the UN sent the NY Police to tell him to stay away.

"I heard of it last night," Mountain said.

He said that sometimes local staff are used as translator and interpreters, with "international counterparts and the military." Video here, from Minute 32:34.

But Dimandja, as demonstrated by a video tape he has provided to Inner City Press, was much more than a translator. "If there are allegations of theft, I'm sure that will be looked into," Mountain said. We'll see.

Footnote: Mountain provided a rosy overview, which if it weren't for current massacre reports and retaliation we'd like to report. He will speak again in New York on November 13 and we have asked to cover it, without response. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/monuc1mountain111309.html

In Deby's Chad, UN Is Shot At and Speaks Softly on Elections

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/chad1unhum111209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 12 -- In Abeche in Eastern Chad in early October, a security officer of the UN Mission in Chad, MINURCAT, was shot at as she came out of the Mission's headquarters. This incident, scarcely reported at the UN in New York, was described to Inner City Press by Michele Falavigna, UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator for Chad, in response to a question about another killing in the country. Falavigna asked, "Was it deliberate provocation?" Video here, from Minute 23:23.

Inner City Press asked Falavigna about a refugee camp near the border with Sudan which the government and now UN are trying to move. Falavigna said because it is near the border, the men go back to tend their fields in Sudan, and return at night. He also described the janjaweed militias coming across the border, twenty on horseback "with heavy weapons," hard to track. This too is not much discussed at the UN in New York.

Even less discussed are elections in Chad, where Idriss Deby took power by a coup but now enjoys support from France and the UN to stay in power. Falavigna said that unless amendments are made to the peace agreement and electoral code, there can be no election in 2010. Which is just how Deby likes it.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/chad1unhum111209.html

Were Galbraith's Oil Interests As Undisclosed at UN as at Opinion Pages He Wrote For?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uneth1galbraith111209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 12, updated Nov. 13 -- Following reports that former UN Deputy Special Representative to Afghanistan Peter Galbraith's oil investments are worth up to $100 million, Inner City Press on November 12 asked UN Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe if Galbraith disclosed this interest in his financial disclosure form.

Ms. Okabe stated that such forms are filled out when a person joins the UN at the level Mr. Galbraith did, and are "vetted by a professional firm," namely PriceWaterhouseCoopers. But did Galbraith make the disclosure which it's now clear was required?

Ms. Okabe refused to answer, instead referring the question to UN Ethics Officer Robert Benson, who oversees the financial disclosure regime. Inner City Press asked Mr. Benson by both e-mail and telephone, early and late on the afternoon of November 12, but received no answer by the evening.

Update: on November 13, UN Ethics Officer Robert Benson wrote to Inner City Press that "The Ethics Office can confirm that although Mr. Galbraith is no longer with the United Nations, he was a participant in the United Nations Financial Disclosure program following his appointment; however, as provided for in GA Resolution A/RES/60/238, the information disclosed remains confidential."

Inner City Press is informed that Galbraith is now being barred from the op-ed pages of major American media based on his failure to accurate disclose his financial interests. The New York Times confirmed this on November 13. Galbraith is arguing that he didn't read the form, a strange argument for a diplomat who argued that the U.S. didn't have to comply with UN Security Council resolutions regarding the Balkans as long as they were under Chapter VI and not VII of the UN Charter.

Earlier, just after Galbraith was fired by Ban Ki-moon, Ban's deputy chief of peacekeeping Edmond Mulet told the Press that Galbraith had some ulterior motive which would soon become clear. On November 12, Inner City Press asked an involved UN official if Mulet had meant the oil investments, or that he might want to run for lieutenant government of Vermont. "The latter," the official said. Only at the UN.

From the November 12 transcript:

Inner City Press: ...about Peter Galbraith, former Deputy UNAMA representative and his interest in oil contracts in northern Iraq. I wanted to know when he became a Deputy Special Representative, did he fill out the financial disclosure forms, and I’d also like to know whether this investment was disclosed in those forms.

Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe: As you know, the financial disclosure forms are something that the Secretary-General has instituted, it’s part of his UN reform, and all staff, once they’ve joined the Organization as senior staff and those in positions that require financial disclosure, are required to fill that form out upon entry into the Organization. So it’s a requirement.

Inner City Press: [inaudible] It seems, this article would make it important to know whether this, they say the investment is worth up to $100 million, whether that was disclosed in the form and if it wasn’t, what were the reasons…?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: As you know, these forms are vetted by a professional firm and if they see fit that they need to follow up on any questions that they have, that is done. I think Robert Benson, when he was here last time, gave you a briefing on how that procedure works. And just because they are not made public, it does not mean that they have not been vetted, and the firm that goes through it does the vetting and if they have any questions, they do get back to the staff member and do the follow-up on that.

Inner City Press: [inaudible] is it possible to just, and I don’t expect you to do it right this moment, but to get a yes or no answer, whether that investment was disclosed in the forms. Is that going to be possible?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: You know, you can ask that to Robert Benson, but that’s his call.

But Benson has yet to return a call, nor an e-mail asking the above and the following questions, below.

Update of November 13, 2009 -- the following was received:

Subj: Re: Press questions,Galbraith, whisteblowers etc, thanks in advance
From: Robert Benson [at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 11/13/2009 9:23:56 A.M. Eastern Standard Time

Dear Mr Lee:

Responses provided:

Hi. At today's noon press briefing, I asked if Peter Galbraith (until recently Deputy SRSG in Afghanistan) had filled out a UN financial disclosure form, and separately if he had disclosed the oil interests in Iraq reported in today's NY Times.

Marie Okabe referred me to you on both questions.

A1 -- "The Ethics Office can confirm that although Mr. Galbraith is no longer with the United Nations, he was a participant in the United Nations Financial Disclosure program following his appointment; however, as provided for in GA Resolution A/RES/60/238, the information disclosed remains confidential."

Q2 -- I have also been told that in a recent UN Dispute Tribunal hearing, about the UNDP - North Korea whistleblower case, that OLA said they would not "allow" you to testify in the case. Are you aware of this? What do you think of UNDP's failure to follow your recommendation?

A2 -- "Since this is a matter that is before the UN Dispute Tribunal, I prefer not to make any comment regarding the matter."

Q3 - How many whistleblowers deserving protection have you certified / found in the past two years? Based on how many applications / approaches?

A3 - "The detailed information regarding the number of requests for protection against retaliation received by the Ethics Office and their disposition can be found in the Office’s Annual Reports for the previous two (2) years; that is, paragraphs 59-66 of A/64/316 and paragraphs 47-53 of A/63/301."

Q4 - Finally, does your Office cover local staff of UN Peacekeeping Missions? There is a recent case of a former MONUC local staffer, alleging MONUC involvement in / knowledge of diversion of jet fuel among other things, who has told me he feels retaliated against. Would your Office have jurisdiction?

A4 - "Yes, our Office would cover a request for protection against retaliation by local staff member from a UN Peacekeeping Mission. May I suggest that you have the individual contact our Office, in that way we would be able to advise the him/her directly."

Q5 - How long more do you remain in Office?

A5- "My three (3) year appointment as the Director of the Ethics Office will end on 30 April 2010, following which I will retire. During my tenure as the United Nations first Director of Ethics, I have indicated on numerous occasions that I considered it important, particularly in relation to the independence of the Office, that I serve for a fixed term and that I leave at the conclusion of that term. The Secretary-General has been informed and has accepted my plans to retire."

While the answers, even the next day, are appreciated, one wonders in light of Q&A 2, above, who would want this job after the retirement announced in A5 takes place. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uneth1galbraith111209.html

In UN Security, Henn Won't Talk to Panel, DM on KFC, Gun Removed?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/undss1hennkfcgun111209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 12, updated -- With two UN Security officers still on suspension for KFC's Colonel Sanders' impersonator having a photo op with the President of the General Assembly Ali Treki, it has emerged that the Chief of Headquarters security, Bruno Henn, has refused to appear before the panel investigating the promotions scandal exposed by Inner City Press. Story here, leaked memo here.

Henn has said he will only answer questions in writing, according to multiple sources, none of them on the panel. This is similar to a police officer refusing to take a Breath-a-lyzer test. But within the UN Department of Safety and Security, some avail themselves of due process, while others cannot.

Sometimes the pressure comes from outside of DSS. It has emerged that it was not the DSS which initiated the two KFC suspensions, but the Department of Management. The disciplinary action was taken quickly, before review, so that the UN could say that something was done, staff union sources tell Inner City Press. The UN Spokesperson has said to not ask anymore questions about KFC, ostensibly to not give publicity, but most people say, from shame. There has still been no press conference by DSS chief Gregory Starr.

Meanwhile, UN Security sources have been abuzz for day saying that Captain Mark Hoffman has had his pistol revoked or placed on restriction. The UN Spokesperson's office was asked, in writing, if as some in Security are saying it involved a law enforcement incident -- reminiscent of Winona Ryder -- in Florida. This was denied, and Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq added that Hoffman was in Florida looking at colleges. Thou dost protest too much?

At Wednesday's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe on the record the more limited question of if Mark Hoffman's gun has been suspended. We looked into that, and no, she said. The UN transcript claimed that Hoffman's name was inaudible:

Inner City Press: Security sources here say that Captain [inaudible], who has had his gun removed. I’d like to know if that’s true and if so why.

Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe: I have not heard anything of that sort.

Inner City Press: Can you check?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: We did. Okay. Thank you very much.

Compare to video, here, at Minute 14:50. And multiple sources, including within DSS, say Hoffman's gun is on suspension, contrary to what Ms. Okabe said at the November 11 noon briefing. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undss1hennkfcgun111209.html

As Sri Lanka Announces UN Holmes To Visit, Is UN's Silence the Silent Deal?


By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc2sriciv111109.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 11, updated -- Sri Lanka has invited top UN humanitarian John Holmes to "visit Colombo later this week" to witness the removal of some of them interned in the Manik Farm camps. In an ill-attended speech by Sri Lankan Ambassador Palitha Kohona past six p.m. on Wednesday, with John Holmes at his side, Kohona called it one of the "fastest resettlements in history."

Earlier on Wednesday, the Washington Post reported that people are being moved from Manik Farm to other closed camps, or simply disappearing. Kohona told Inner City Press that the Post article "made many errors," without specifying them. Can we expect a letter to the editor?

Seeming ever stranger in retrospect, Holmes' speech earlier on Wednesday did not mention Sri Lanka, but rather Yemen. If Holmes is still engages on Sri Lanka, why not mention it? Some surmise that Sri Lanka is once again conditioning access on silence. If the UN will stay quiet, it will be allowed to come and take some credit.

Kohona has been quoted, regarding Sri Lanka's expulsion of UNICEF spokesman James Elder after he spoke out about conditions in the camps, "I do not think it is UNICEF's role to advocate anything, they are an aid agency...It is not for them to go out making statements which could embarrass a host government.''

Apparently Sri Lanka feels the same about John Holmes, the coordinator of UN aid agencies. Some wonder, is Holmes playing along? What does he think of Kohona's statement about the right of aid agency to advocate in some circumstances? Perhaps he'll say -- or perhaps not.

Footnotes: Some found it strange that the UN never announced this trip. Now, Inner City Press is informed that after Sri Lanka disclosed it in Kohona's "protection of civilians" speech on November 11, the UN will announce it on November 12. We'll see.

Update of 8:36 p.m. -- Holmes on his way out tells Inner City Press he's going to Sri Lanka on Sunday, through Tuesday.

Kohona also maligned the asylum seekers marooned off Indonesia at Australia's request, stating that ""They are economic refugees looking for greener pastures elsewhere... It is wrong for anybody to go to a strange land and then exert emotional pressure of this kind on the intended destination and expect people to react positively. I think this is emotional blackmail.''

But some think Sri Lanka is blackmailing the UN. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc2sriciv111109.html

As Theft of UN Jet Fuel Alleged By Congo Ex-Staffer, UN Calls Him Unstable, a Trend with UN Whistleblowers

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un3dimandja111109.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 11 -- In Eastern Congo UN vehicles were used to transport jet fuel stolen from the UN in Bunia, former UN staff member John Dimandja has told Inner City Press, after having submitted his evidence and photographs to the highest levels of the UN.

The response of the UN to date has been to send New York City Police Department officers to tell Dimandja to stay away from the UN, after he said he would step in front of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's vehicle if he had to in order to deliver his letter.

Mr. Dimandja has written, "I keep the pictures of fuel-JA1... the plates of UN vehicle that transported fuel-Jet-A1 can be identified... MONUC administration sustained by putting out all those that condemn its acts of UN fuel Jet-A1 robbery, in this cases MONUC put out some colleagues from MONUC Bunia security section so that to remove all traces. The real fuel Jet-A1 robbery managers are supported by MONUC administration and continue to their work."

Dimandja states that when he arrived in New York after fleeing death threats in the Congo for his work for the UN disarming militias, he made the UN aware of these irregularities, but "nothing was done."

Dimandja has written, "UN air crafts Fuel Jet-A1 file is very sensitive, that continues to put me and my family again in an other insecurity, I am requesting again the Nations United to assist us by securing my family, I did not travel to USA with a purpose to accuse MONUC of its misbehaviors but to save my life as well as of those of my family."

On November 10, a senior UN official implied to Inner City Press that Mr. Dimandja is unstable and needs counseling.

We note that the whistleblower about the UN Development Program's financial irregularities in North Korea had his photo put in the same "do not let enter" photo array as Mr. Dimandja is now in. Most recently, in this whistleblower's case in the UN Dispute Tribunal, he states that the UN's lawyer said that UN Ethics Officer Robert Benson, who ruled he was presumptively retaliated against and then denied due process, would not be "allowed" to testify to the UNDT.

Nicolas Baroncini, who exposed an e-mail by Alan Doss, the UN's top Congo envoy -- and Dimandja's boss -- in which Doss asked UNDP to grant him "lee-way" and hire his daughter for Baroncini's job, after being pepper sprayed and biting out at Security Officer Peter Kolonias was taken to Bellevue Hospital to mental observation, and now faces trial in Criminal Court in lower Manhattan.

There is a pattern, then, of the UN describing many recent whistleblowers as mentally unstable or threatening. We will continue to follow this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un3dimandja111109.html

With Sri Lanka Ignored in UN Debate, Austria Speaks of Proposal, UN's Holmes Moves On

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1sriciv111109.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 11 -- Austria's foreign minister Michael Spindelegger, answering questions Wednesday from Inner City Press outside the Security Council debate he presided over on the protection of civilians, proclaimed that Austria has "made a proposal" to Sri Lanka to bring "the government side and the Tamil side together" at one table. "We have not real answer at the moment," he said.

In his initial comments, Minister Spindelegger praised the UN's work in Africa, without mentioning the controversy now surrounding the UN's work with the Congolese Army. Inner City Press asked about Asia, not only Sri Lanka but Myanmar, where armed conflict continues, with child soldiers and Rohingya people taking to the sea.

Spindelegger said, "This was not part of the discussion, especially Sri Lanka, during our meeting of the Security Council." Then, "as Foreign Minister of Austria," he said "we are very concerned about the situation in Sri Lanka... huge numbers of refugees still in camps and not allowed to go home." Video here, from Minute 4:43.

Even those who leave the Manik Farm camp in Vavuniya, it was today confirmed, are taken to other closed camps, or quickly picked up again by the authorities. So what is the UN doing to protect these civilians?

As Austria, Spindelegger said, they are offering a "platform" for "the Tamilian side" to speak with the government. Another journalist asked for more detail and Spindelegger spoke about bringing the parties to "one table... we try to do our best." Video here, from Minute 7:05. There was no mention of what Austria's position is, for example, on suspending favorable entry of Sri Lankan goods into Europe under the GSP Plus program, which is subject to a human right review.

After Foreign Minister Spindelegger's stakeout interview, Austria's Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting genially advised Inner City Press not to read too much into Foreign Minister Spindelegger's statement about having made "a proposal" to the Sri Lankan government.

Given the way the Norwegians, for example, feel they were burned by the process, this is perhaps understandable.

But the fact remains, at the UN on Sri Lanka, there is double talk, there are claims of assistance and concern that are not back up, and increasingly there is silence. Protection of civilians indeed.

Footnotes: In his speech to the Council on the topic, top UN humanitarian John Holmes mentioned Yemen but not Sri Lanka. He asked, have we narrowed the gap between rhetoric and action? Apparently not.

Holmes remains reluctant to admit that the supposed investigation of the killing of 17 Action Contre La Faim workers led nowhere, with its advisory committee quitting due to its lack of credibility. Apparently, if a member state criticizes the UN or OCHA strenuously and persistently enough, the UN's message changes or goes silent. There's always another conflict, with less oversight, to move on to....

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1sriciv111109.html