Saturday, November 14, 2009

The UN on Protection of Civilians Dost Protest Too Much, 62 Speakers But What of Congo, Sri Lanka and Sudan?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1protciv111109.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 11, updated below -- To protect civilians should go without saying for the United Nations, given its rhetoric. Speech after speech will be given at a debate on the topic in the Security Council on November 11, covered below. But a decade and a half after the UN pulled out during the Rwanda genocide, and stood by during the slaughter in Srebrenica, the UN is still at odds with itself on levels large and small.

In the Congo for example despite a relatively small recent change, the peacekeeping mission under the charge of Alan Doss has provided support to Army units now known to have raped and killed civilians.

Even its own local staff, the UN is not protecting. This week, former MONUC staffer John Dimandja wrote to the Secretary General that his disarmament work for the UN with militias in Ituri put him and his family at risk and needs to leave the region. The UN focused on his desperate reference to stepping in front of the S-G's limousine, called the police and told Dimandja to stay away. Click here and here for Inner City Press' two exclusive stories; a third is in the works.

The Congo mission was created and is ostensibly overseen by the Security Council. But when Inner City Press asked a Council diplomat about Dimandja's plight, the answer was, "We don't really deal with that."

And this month's earnest Security Council president Thomas Mayr-Harting of Austria, which oversees today's debate, said he had not heard about Doctors without Borders days-old public statement that its vaccination drive in rebel controlled areas of Eastern Congo was used as "bait" by the Army to attack civilians.

The UN Mission in Sudan has said it cannot protect civilians from the Lord's Resistance Army; Darfur speaks for itself. These are the UN's largest peacekeeping forces. Then there are conflicts in which the Security Council declines to put on its agenda, such as the slaughter of tens of thousands of Sri Lankans, nearly all Tamils, earlier this year. China and Russia opposed discussing the matter, but the U.S., France, UK and others went along.

Instead of calling for a vote, they contented themselves with non-binding non-meetings in the UN's basement. The Council has not revisited the situation in Sri Lanka since May, despite hundreds of thousands of Tamil civilians being locked up in monsoon flooded camps.

So it is difficult not to think, in hearing these lofty UN speeches about protection of civilians, that "thou dost protest too much." We will review the days events below as the happen. Watch this space.

Update of 10:01 a.m. -- at the stakeout in front of the Security Council, correspondents are told that there will be 62 speakers in the "debate" on the protection of civilians. There is groaning. For the Secretariat, Ban Ki-moon, John Holmes and Alain Le Roy -- who strides in smiling -- will be there, as well as the Deputy High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Former French Ambassador Jean-Maurice Ripert comes to schmooze the press -- it's too early in his mandate for a briefing, he says, adding that sometimes the UN is constrained by member states. As he leaves, a Middle Eastern reporter quips, "The UN salary seems to be suiting him well."

As the Costa Rican Ambassador walks in, a reporter shouts, "Any problems with white powder?" The reference is to the anthrax scare, which started with three Missions to the UN and has proceeded from there. There are other countries with other white powders...

Update of 10:30 a.m. -- Austria's foreign minister mechanically thanks Ban Ki-moon for his "most interesting" speech. Now top UN humanitarian John Holmes is up. He mentions Yemen -- but apparently not Sri Lanka. He asks, have we narrowed the gap between rhetoric and action? Apparently not.

Update of 10:36 a.m. -- Holmes says "we need flexibility" to engage with armed groups (that is, non state actors), in order to protect humanitarian workers. It's a good point. But one wonders why Holmes is, for example, so reluctant to admit that the supposed investigation of the killing of 17 Action Contre La Faim workers led nowhere, with its advisory committee quitting due to its lack of credibility. Apparently, if a member state criticizes the UN or OCHA strenuously and persistently enough, the UN's message changes or goes silent. There's always another conflict, with less oversight, to move on to....

Update of 10:40 a.m. -- Sudan's deputy permanent representative groans and says, seventy speakers now! And Sudan is 53rd. We are ready for our election, he tells Inner City Press, then shakes his head at the UN's electoral snafus in Afghanistan. It's a shame, he says, entirely without irony.

Update of 10:44 a.m. -- and now, one expects the last Sudanese Mission update of the day, Sudan's Ambassador comes over to make, again, his double standard point. He said, those speechifying today, many voted against or abstained on endorsing the Goldstone report on Gaza. Now they talk about protection of civilians. He laughs and ambles into the Council.

Update of 10:49 a.m. -- the Deputy High Commisioner for Human Rights, after touching on the Goldstone report, which she says has been transmitted to the Security Council, which is not entirely clear, and on Eastern Congo, turns to Darfur. Next to her the Libyan Deputy looks glum. She does it quick, and moves on to Kabul.

Update of 10:58 a.m. -- as the minister of Croatia reads his speech, Inner City Press is told that even the word "UN" now makes people mad in Croatia, since their most recent Ambassador to the UN "misappropriated" national funds. They didn't call him "the gambler" for nothing...

Update of 11:14 a.m. -- during the UK's speech, at the stakeout it is asked if this is the country's new Ambassador. No, Minister Taylor is a woman, and Mark Lyall Grant is man, who is yet to be seen at the stakeout. Yesterday, Deputy PR Parham told Inner City Press he was not aware of any plan to keep British troops in Afghanistan "out of harm's way" pending the UK elections...

Update of 11:20 a.m. -- As France's Araud speechifies, he uses four examples: Sudan, Gaza, Sri Lanka and Guinea. Before this can sink in, a correspondent notes that Araud got a lot of laughs yesterday morning, referring to the letters from Dallas containing white powder: "Don't mess with Texas," he quipped. Now he's speaking on the Congo.

Update of 11:23 a.m. -- okay, more seriously, it is explained to Inner City Press that the inclusion of language about humanitarian access in the resolution is something that can be pointed to in the future. But how much more access will it lead to?

Update of 11:26 a.m. -- as the Austrian minister thanks "Excellency Araud" and hands it off to Russia's Vitaly Churkin, Ban Ki-moon is still in the room, dutifully checking off on a paper in front of him. France, done. Russia, now. Four minutes until the Austrians' stakeout is scheduled. But the text of the Austrian minister's opening statement is not available. Churkin is denouncing one sided approaches, and saying that private security companies, too, are subject to international humanitarian law.

Update of 11:33 a.m. -- First Holmes leaves, grim faced, then the smiling Alain Le Roy. Then Ban Ki-moon and Vijay Nambiar, flanked by security. Mr. Ban waves. The Austrian stakeout can't be far behind.

Update of 11:53 a.m. -- Inner City Press asked Austria's minister three questions, and will report on the answers, probably in a separate piece -- after the day's UN noon briefing.

Update of 3:45 p.m. -- the separate piece on Austria's minister's answers is now online here...

Update of 8:11 p.m. -- Iran, thankfully, says it will summarize its more lengthy prepared remarks. The Georgians are hanging around, to see if Russia asks to reply to what they've said. The Council President tells Inner City Press that no one has yet requested the "right of reply." Remaining speakers: Rwanda, Pakistan and the "Sovereign Military Order of Malta." We'll see.

Update of 8:21 p.m. -- Iran says Israel's ship hijacking was just a "distraction" from the Goldstone report. Pakistan is apparently a no show, or spoke earlier. Malta is up, Holmes still in his chair. Has he prepared a response to all the comments?

Update of 8:31 p.m. -- Holmes is delivering a fast reply, which we'll review later. But here comes U.S. versus Venezuela! And it's a wrap!

Update of 8:36 p.m. -- Holmes on his way out tells Inner City Press he's going to Sri Lanka on Sunday, through Tuesday. It's announced, c'est fini.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1protciv111109.html

As UN Master Plan and Planner Hit for Waste, Skanska Settles Asbestos Suit

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/cmp3banks111009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 10 -- As the UN Capital Master Plan, headed by Michael Adlerstein, was criticized Tuesday in the UN Budget Committee, Adlerstein's general contractor Skanska was settling an asbestos lawsuit in California, one that Adlerstein had claimed didn't exist.

In the Budget Committee, cost overruns and planned snafus like the on again, off again relocation of the Security Council outside of the Heaadquarters building were fodder for coutnries and regional groups.

The eighth floor, a person working there says, is now full of mice. The UN Journal is slated to move into a four desk room above the Innovation Luggage store on Second Avenue. The move of the UN press corp to the second floor over the library was on Tuesday delayed for another three weeks, to December 11. Meanwhile on the 4th floor, the former JPMorgan Chase bank branch is being stripped down to the walls.

From the ACABQ report on the Capital Master Plan:

"The Committee regrets that security concerns and space requirements were not duly considered at an earlier stage, and that the decision to maintain the Security Council within the main complex of Buildings had not been part of the initial planning. The timing of that decision demonstrates a lack of sound planning and coordination, which has resulted in delays and additional costs being incurred. The Committee emphasizes the need for intensified coordination and consultation between the Office of the Capital Master Plan and all other key stakeholders in order to ensure effective planning of the project and to avoid, to the extent possible, unforeseen delays and resulting cost escalation."

The Committee remains concerned by the risks posed to the project and urges the Secretary-General to continue to closely monitor the situation and to ensure that the activities related to the migration and running of the secondary data centre are completed in accordance with the time frame of the capital master plan."

The member states began to beat the drum on Tuesday, promising to follow it up into closed door consultations. We'll continue to follow this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/cmp3banks111009.html

Congo Staffer, Barred from UN, Describes Fuel Thefts, Videos of Warlord Work

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un2dimandja111009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 10 -- Months after the plight of Congolese UN local staff member John Dimandja was raised to the top levels of the UN, and the day after Inner City Press wrote about it, UN Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq said first that "we're looking into that question" then that "the Department of Field Security is deeply concerned." Video at Minute 7:55 then 10:57.

As of November 9, the UN's concern was that Mr. Dimandja not follow through on his desperate threat to stand in front of the vehicle Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, in order to deliver to him a letter asking that his family, put in danger by Dimandja's work for the UN, be helped to escape to safety.

As reported, the UN called the New York City Police Department threats unit on Dimandja. NYPD officer, in front of Inner City Press, told Dimandja to stay away from the UN.

NYPD officer John C. Fernandez of the Threat Assessment Unit suggested to Dimandja that he try contacting the Congo's Mission to the UN. Dimandja laughed and said the Congolese government is made up of former militias.

Out of First Avenue, Dimandja gave Inner City Press a video tape of his work in Eastern Congo. It consists of speeches Dimandja gave to groups of warring ethnic militias, some of whose leaders like Mathieu Ngudjolo were later indicted for war crimes. (Significantly, Ngudjolo's trial begins November 24 along with Germain Katanga's at the International Criminal Court in The Hague.) That Dimandja had filmed these defendants led to death threats against him and his family, he says.

Dimandja adds that he witnesses international UN staff engaged in theft and re-sale of airplane fuel in the Congo. He surmises, and told the NYPD officers, that this and other knowledge led some in the UN to refuse him protection, even to wish him harm.

But when he fled to New York to ask the UN for help, he was given the run around, told to come back in a week for appointments when he had nowhere to stay. Only is desperation did he write to Ban Ki-moon, and this resulted in his photo being put in an array of mugshot of people not to be let into the UN complex. On November 10, Dimandja asked that this be rescinded.

Also on November 10, after Inner City Press' story and questions at the day's UN noon briefing, Dimandja received a call from the Administrative Office of the UN's Division of Safety and Security Services Joseph Martella. Inner City Press, meanwhile, asked the head of the Department of Field Support Susana Malcorra about Dimandja's case. She said it is sensitive, and seemed to gently imply some instability of Dimandja's part. But who wouldn't be?

One wonders about the role of the UN Mission in the Congo, headed by Alan Doss. One wonders why the Office of Internal Oversight Services, which Dimandja first approached, has not acted on the theft of airplane fuel. One wonders at the different treatment the UN gives to its international versus national staff. Will Mr. Dimandja's family be offered protection? The UN has promised answers. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2dimandja111009.html

As Colombia Calls UN Council About Chavez, Silence on Korean Ships Shooting

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1colnoko111009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 10, updated -- A war of words between Venezuela and Colombia is on the radar of the UN Security Council, with contacts begun with the Colombian side. But the actual exchange of fire between South and North Korean ships "has not been raised in the Council," this month's President Thomas Mayr-Harting told Inner City Press on Tuesday. Video here, from Minute 3:37.

The Security Council ostensibly deals with threats to international peace and security. Shooting between ships, involving a country which has ostentatiously tested what it calls nuclear missiles, would seem to be a bigger threat than the most recent spat between Hugo Chavez and Alvaro Uribe.

But just as the UN's approach to war crimes in selective, the range of conflicts which never make it to the Council versus some countries no longer in armed conflict which continue under a Council mandate and mission is striking.

Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's Associate spokesman Farhan Haq about the Korean shooting, and he read out a bland statement. Video here.
Inner City Press followed up asking if there is any thought to replacing Maurice Strong with a new UN envoy to North Korea. Apparently not, at least for now. But Venezuela and Guyana have a UN envoy / expert. Go figure.

Footnote: when Inner City Press asked Mayr-Harting if as Council president he had heard from Colombia, he said "we have been in formal contact". Reporters afterwards asked, "in formal or informal"? The latter seems more likely, but it sounded like the former. Go figure.

Update of November 11 -- Ambassador Mayr-Harting approached Inner City Press during the protection of civilians debate presided over by his foreign minister, and clarified that he meant "informal." And there you have it.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1colnoko111009.html

On Lebanon, Russia Resists Calling for Implementation of 1701 Resolution

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1leb1701russia111009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 10 -- When the UN Security Council met behind closed door Tuesday about its Resolution 1701 and the situation between Lebanon and Israel, there was a surprising blockage to even calling for implementation of the Council's own Resolution 1701. Diplomatic sources in the consultations meeting tell Inner City Press that Russia opposed even the use of the word "implementation."

When the UN's Michael Williams emerged to brief the Press, he repeatedly took issue with reporters who asked about what opposition parties in Lebanon call his report's lack of balance. Every over flight of Lebanon, he insisted, is a violation of 1701.

Of the ship stopped by Israel, Williams said it is beyond his mandate to comment on the legality of the cargo or its seizure. Regarding the Israeli Army chief of staff's comments that Hezbollah has rockets that can reach Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, Williams answered that he has no way to know of their range.

Inner City Press asked Williams about reports that Israel has asked for Italy to continue to force commander of the UNFIL peacekeeping mission, rather than pass the mandate to Spain.

Like you, Williams replied, I read colorful media reports. But it is up to the Secretary General and the decision should be made in a few weeks. We'll see.

Footnote: Russia also, behind the scenes, raised issues recently about the UN's panel of inquiry into the killing of civilians in Guinea. As with the strange pattern of the UN Mission anthrax scare, people are trying to find a pattern here.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1leb1701russia111009.html

Diplomatic "Anthrax" Postmarked from Texas, France Says, UN Terror Defenses Misused

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1anthrax111009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 10 -- At the UN Security Council stakeout the morning after the anthrax scare at the French, Austrian and Uzbek embassies, French Ambassador Gerard Araud told the Press that the letters had been mail from Dallas. "Don't mess with Texas," he said in an exaggerated drawl.

He recounted how the staff of the French Mission to the UN had been decontaminated until 3:30 in the morning in a truck outside the Mission. Women first, men after, he said, describing how people passed their clothing into a small hole, and after decontamination put on plastic suits.

The geo-political logic (of the three countries targeted) makes no sense, he said. Austria has the Council presidency this month, and has its big event, a debate on the protection of civilians, scheduled for November 11. Others mused to Inner City Press about American bases in Uzbekistan. It is a country known for torturing political opponents, and shooting them in the street.

The NYPD quickly concluded that the substance was not, in fact, anthrax. Because the common denominator is the UN, missions to, in this publication it will be called l'affaire Banthrax.

Meanwhile, the UN Secretariat used the NYPD's anti-terroristic threat squad to try to silence or back off a former UN staffer in the Democratic Republic of Congo who wrote to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon among other things that his family is still threatened in the region due to the work he did for the UN. Click here for that Inner City Press exclusive story, and watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1anthrax111009.html

UN Calls NYPD On Congo Staffer They Used Against Rebels, "UN Put My Family in Danger"

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, November 9 -- While the UN Security Council held consultations Monday about its peacekeeping mission's involvement in the armed conflict between rebel groups and the Congolese Army, a related but more personal drama played out just outside the UN on First Avenue.

The UN summoned New York City police officers to deal with John Dimandja Wembalonge. John C. Fernandez of the NYPD's Threat Assessment Unit counseled Mr. Dimandja to "stay away from the UN," following an e-mail Dimandja had sent to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, reproduced in full below.

In it and related correspondence to the UN, Dimandja explained that he was a national staff member of the UN Mission in the Congo who had fled death threats after helping the UN disarm rebels in Ituri in Eastern Congo.

Now Dimandja's family remains in the region at risk. "The UN is doing nothing," Dimandja told Inner City Press on First Avenue on Monday night. He said that the chief of the UN's Department of Field Services Susana Malcorra had, though an intermediary named Cedrick, told him to bring in his internal UN employment file, called at PHP, that perhaps a job could be found for him in New York and then his family brought.

"But that will be too late," Dimandja told Inner City Press, and Officer Fernandez.

According to Dimandja, while working for the UN in Ituri he was sent in to meeting of Lendu militias to convince them to disarm..Dimandja took pictures and video, and had, he says, much success in disarmament. But when militia leader Mathieu Ngudjolo was indicted for war crimes, Dimandja's video footage put him in danger.

"They were trying to kill anyone who had taken pictures," he told Inner City Press. Who? "The militias had become soldiers in the Congolese Army," he said. It was the same government soldiers who the UN assists who were trying to kill him.

Dimandja says a UN official, Philip Toulet, advised him to pay a bribe to Congolese police, and to get paperwork to flee to the U.S. and seek asylum. He arrived in New York a year ago, and went straight to UN headquarters. He says the UN Office of Internal Oversight Services, ostensibly in charge of investigations, referred him to the staff counsel. He got nowhere, and lacking the funds to stay in New York City, he went upstate to Rochester for three months.

Since being back in New York, he has sought to meet with Ban Ki-moon. But his e-mails, culminating in a threat to step in front of Ban's motorcade, resulted only in interventions by NYPD. "Stay away from the UN," Officer Fernandez advised him Monday night. "Perhaps this gentleman can help you." Here's hoping.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1dimandja111009.html

At UN, Obasanjo Brags of Deadly Kimia II, LRA Not in Mandate, Mountain in the Dusk

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc2msfobasanjo110909.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 9 -- Only days after human rights groups documented hundreds of killings of civilians by the UN-assisted Congolese Army as part of Operation Kimia II, former Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo told the Security Council that "Operation Kimia II is achieving reasonable success."

After the Council meeting, Inner City Press asked Obasanjo how this squares with the killed civilians, which had so far led even the UN Mission in the Congo to say it is suspending work with elements of the 213th Brigade, for the killing of 62 civilians.

"I'm telling you what people told us," Obasanjo said, "operation versus the FDLR is welcome."

What about the 600 civilians who have been killed by the Congolese Army, documented by Human Rights Watch? Obansanjo, rather than disputing the number, played the ad hoc democracy card. "If the Congolese people says its necessary, why should I say to MONUC, or to anyone else for that matter, that what the Congolese people want they shouldn't get?" Video here, from Minute 7:19.

Given the argument that popular will trumps or supports the killing of civilians, Inner City Press asked what Obasanjo's report was based on: a poll? "I was there," Obasanjo said, as a staffer gestured for the stakeout microphone to be taken away from Inner City Press.

Since Obasanjo, even inside UN headquarters, walked surrounded by bodyguards and entourage, it's difficult to imagine him conducting a scientific man and woman on the street poll in the Kivus. But as they say, you hear what you want to hear. Obasanjo is stepping back from his UN Great Lakes gig. We will follow his next moves.

As he left, Inner City Press asked, "What about the LRA," Lord's Resistance Army? Video here, from Minute 11:08. "The LRA is not part of my mandate," Obasanjo said, even though the Great Lakes include Uganda. If you design a mandate narrowly enough, success is not so difficult. Many say -- another scientific poll -- that Presidents Kabila and Kagame would have spoken anyway. But for Obasanjo, next stop: Mo Ibrahim prize?

This month's Council president Thomas Mayr-Harting of Austria read out a press statement congratulating Obasanjo, as well as MONUC. Inner City Press asked about the 600 dead civilians, and the report by MSF that the Congolese Army used them as bait to attack civilians. Video here, from Minute 1:58. He referred to the press statement on the first, and said he hasn't seen reports of the second. We trust he will.

Footnote: When Inner City Press asked UN Spokesperson Michele Montas about the MSF as bait story, she didn't answer, except to say that outgoing MONUC deputy Ross Mountain would be in town this week and should answer questions. Mountain was seen in the dusk outside the UN on Monday night. When will the questions be answered?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc2msfobasanjo110909.html

In Kabul Chaos, UN Pull Out Doesn't Add Up, Transcript Held Back, Budget Delayed

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsec2afpak110909.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 9 -- While Afghans and aid agencies criticize the UN for a lack of clarity in its partial pull out announcement after the Taliban killed five UN staff, in New York the UN insists its messages have been clear.

Inner City Press asked, for example, if the UN's figure of 200 people leaving the country included the reported 14 UNICEF staffers who are leaving. "We have answered that "we have already answered," that the 200 include "all agency and UNAMA" personnel. Video here, from Minute 14:40.

Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on November 6 gave a rambling answer in response to what "red lines in your head" would have to be cross for the UN to pull out completely, as it did from Iraq after the bombing of its Canal Hotel headquarters there. He said, in part, that "no UNAMA election officials will be moved out... No UNAMA field staff will be moved out."

More than seventy hours after Mr. Ban's comments, the UN had not put the transcript online on its "Off the Cuff" comments web site, nor emailed it to the Press, as usually happens one or two hours after a public statement by Ban.

Inner City Press, which questioned Ban on November 6 and published quotes that day about it, here, on November 9 asked Ban's spokeswoman Michele Montas why the transcript had not been put online. Video here, from Minute 30:27.

"Mostly technical reasons," Ms. Montas replied. But Inner City Press has seen a copy of the transcript which her Office prepared before six p.m. on November 6. Notably, as Ban was answering the "red lines" question, his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar arrived at the stakeout and gestured to end it, telling Inner City Press, we cannot tell them how to attack us. Then the transcript was not put on line, and still has not been.

But the streaming video is online, Inner City Press' questions here (from Minute 6:42) and Ban's "red lines" answer here (from Minute 12:40). The transcript which the Spokesperson's Office prepared but then did not put online has Ban saying "There will be around 200 staff in a phased way - I would like to tell you -- 120 administrative staff will be relocated in six to eight weeks, and 30 development staff in six to eight weeks and 50 administrative officers will be rotated between Kabul, Dubai and Kuwait..".

What is the difference between "administrative staff" (120) and "administrative officers" (50)? Mr. Ban went on, "UNDP level officers -- they have ended their assignment - 30 out of 125 are now remaining in Kabul." Are the 95 who left included in the UN's evacuation count? Are the 30 who, it seems, will leave included?

Mr. Ban on November 6 said, "there was unfortunately a misunderstanding of our positions." Neglecting to put online the transcript of the Secretary General's answers on Afghanistan for more than 70 hours doesn't help.

The UN claims this is all clear, but it is not. In fact, Kabul is full of rumors of UN pull out of more than 200 system staff. The price of food has shot up. As one international aid NGO was quoted, "the UN should have offered the option for its staff to relocate, rather than issue a blanket relocation. 'That's a bad signal to everyone: The perpetrators are getting what they want and are encouraged to continue, and the population feels more and more abandoned, realizing how little it takes to frighten us away, and to leave them alone to fend for themselves, in every possible field.'"

On behalf of the UN, Ms. Montas refused to comment on or reply to this on November 9, saying that it is all clear. But is it?

Footnote: even the budget is not clear. After announcing he was seeking money after the five staff were killed, now the spokesman for the chair of the UN Budget committee tells Inner City Press that no proposals have yet been submitted to the committee, they are anticipated as "an add on to the budget fascicle" of DSS at the end of November. The ACABQ is said to have a folder, but got the DSS management review on a much delayed basis. Fast to pull out, slow to follow through, some say. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsec2afpak110909.html

As UN Descends Toward Slopenhagen, Of Vattenfall's Abuse and Stakeout Post Hoc Games

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope4offmessage110909.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 9 -- If an agreement is not binding, can you be said to seal the deal? This question was put Monday to the UN's climate change advisor Janos Pasztor, who until recently was calling for a legally binding agreement at the Copenhagen talks in December.

Now Pasztor echoes Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's retreat to a "politically binding" agreement, as phrased most recently in London: " if we agree on a strong politically-binding commitment that will be I think a reasonable success." Toward that goal, apparently, Ban travels to Washington on November 10.

Inner City Press asked Pasztor when it occurred to the UN Secretariat that a legally binding -- that is, a binding -- agreement would not be possible: before or after they said Yvo de Boer was incompletely quoted when he said precisely that? Video here, from Minute 26:12. There was not a specific month, Pasztor answered genially. A few weeks ago.

It's been a slippery slope, one commented, from Jeffery Sachs to Yvo de Boer to this. A slippery Slopenhagen indeed.

Inner City Press asked about the reported walk-out by African countries from the last negotiating session in Barcelona. Pasztor was, as always, relentlessly upbeat, saying they did not walk out of Barcelena (certainly not the city, one wag whispered) but only some meetings -- and then they "walked back" in. So all's fine?

Noting that the SealTheDeal2010 web site, unlike its 2009 version, is not in UN hands, Inner City Press asked if the campaign would morph. Video here, from Minute 30:30. No, Pasztor said, we must have a deal in 2009 in Copenhagen. But is a deal that is not legally binding a deal at all?


Pasztor on November 6 attended a meeting of the Secretary General's Advisory Group on Energy and Climate Change, in the UN's basement. Yvo de Boer was listed as "not participating," and Mexican tycoon Carlos Slim Helu as participating only by teleconference. That was better than the CEO of Vattenfall, a company which has said publicly its use of coal will actually increase in the next few years.

As Inner City Press has raised to Pasztor and UN global goods guru Bob Orr, Vattenfall put out a press release stating that CEO Lars Josefsson's selection by Ban meant the company has a good environmental record. Both have said such claims are inappropriate, and the CEOs are selected and must attend in their personal capacity.

Apparently, Vattenfall has never been disciplined or retracted its claim using the UN. And on November 6, the list of participatants lists "Arne Mogren (on behalf of Lars Josefsson)." What was that about CEOs attending personally?

Listed among "additional participants (consultants and advisors to principals)" was Reid Detchon, a vice president with an NGO, the UN Foundation. Who would he -- or they -- be advising?

Footnote: While some NGOs are invited in, another was escorted away from the General Assembly stakeout on November 5, and had UN passes stripped. On November 9, Inner City Press asked UN Spokesperson Michele Montas when NGOs can speak at the stakeout. Video here, from Minute 17:31.

When they are sponsored by Member States, she said, then added "or Observer Missions," a reference to Palestine's Riyad Mansour and his guests from Jerusalem who spoke at the Security Council stakeout on November 6.

Montas even defended the stakeout of Mia Farrow, as a "UNICEF Special Ambassador." But what about Polisario, which had the plug pulled while it spoke? What about HRW, after the Human Rights Council elections? Which Member States invited them to the stakeout? And was that known in the heat of the moment, or only made up afterwards?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope4offmessage110909.html

On UN, Congo Says All or Nothing, Silence on MSF "Bait" Accusation, New P-5ers

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1msfdrc110909.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 9 -- While the UN Mission in the Congo will stop assisting some units of Congo's 213th Brigade because they killed 62 civilians, according to top UN Peacekeeper Alain Le Roy, evidence mounts of far more extensive murder by other brigades and units of the Congolese army.

In this context, Inner City Press on November 5 asked the DRC's Ambassador to the UN Atoki Ileka what he thought of Le Roy's announcement. Ambassador Ikeka turned the question around, asking "how can you work with only parts of an army?"

Inner City Press noted to him that this was similar to Human Rights Watch's position, that MONUC should stop working with the Congolese Army as a whole, at least as regards the Kimia II operation. Yes, Ambassador Ileka said, on that we have the same position. Only at the UN.

Unprompted, standing outside the UN General Assembly after the debate and vote on the Goldstone report on Gaza, Ambassador Ileka told Inner City Press, Alan Doss, he has his own problems, I'm not going to add to them.

At the November 6 noon briefing, Inner City Press asked

Inner City Press: Medecins sans frontieres has said in great detail that a vaccination campaign they conducted in October in FDLR-control areas of [the Democratic Republic of] the Congo was used as “bait” -- that is the word they used. So that FARDC [the Congolese Armed Forces] attacked the vaccination sites, killed some civilians and sent others into the bush. It’s such a graphic allegation on their part, I’m wondering what is MONUC -- is this a unit MONUC works with? Does MONUC deny that it happened? What’s MONUC going to do about that?

Spokesperson Michele Montas: I’m going to get more information -- in fact, we are going to have someone from [MONUC] coming to brief you on the Congo shortly. Mr. Ross Mountain [Deputy Special Representative of the Secretary-General for the Democratic Republic of the Congo] is supposed to come next week and he will be briefing you on the Congo, so I would suggest that you ask him the questions.

Ross Mountain will immanently leave the MONUC mission, and more and more people say Alan Doss should. Is there accountability in the UN system?


On November 9, former Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo strode into the Security Council with an entourage, to brief about the Great Lakes region: how many trip to how many heads of state. Some mused that one of his last times at the UN, he was questioned about his role in now controversial Chinese infrastructure deals in Nigeria, if that gave him a conflict in deal with Congo's similar -- although now somewhat shrunken -- deal. Didn't he get mad? a correspondent asked Inner City Press, the poser of the Chinese dealing question. He should have seen it coming. And this time? Watch this site.

Council footnotes, or bookends: The grandly named new UK Permanent Representative, Ambassador Mark Lyall "No Hyphen" Grant, is said to have arrived in New York "at the weekend." He will get accredited, some face time with Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, and then assume his position in the Council. There are some hoping he's adopt a less exclusive approach, at least to the media, than those before him.

France's Gerard Araud, who's said in French-only briefings to rebuff questions about poverty and spending, for example Sarkozy's on his EU Presidency stint, is still settling in. And so Russia, with the longest serving Ambassador, and China, which reportedly blocked consensus on the most recent Sudan sanctions report, will some say have the P-5 upper hand for a while. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1msfdrc110909.html

In UN Water, Questions of Coke and Nestle by Press Prove UN Is Fair, UN Claims

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncorp1water110809.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 8 -- "Water is the new carbon," the UN's Nikhil Chandavarkar told the Press on November 6. Following a debate in the UN General Assembly's Second Committee, he told a press conference that it is important to "set a price for water."

Inner City Press asked him about criticism of UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's "CEO Water Mandate" for inviting in corporations like Coca-Cola, Suez and Nestle which are accused of negative impacts on lower income people. Video here, from Minute 38:56.

Chandavarkar said the while the CEO Water Mandate came out of the UN Global Compact, it is not the UN's role to assess particular corporations' behavior, including with respect to water. He said that the UN views the private sector of "one of the nine major groups" and tried to give corporations' view an airing.

When Inner City Press followed up asking if corporations really get only one-ninth of the voice and power on the issue, Chandavarkar turned the questions around. That NGOs protested to Ban about his CEO Water Mandate, he said with a smile, is "a tribute to the UN." Video here, from Minute 41:18.

Chandavarkar went further, telling Inner City Press that the "very fact that you are able to raise the issue shows that we are getting the airing from them."

Apparently the argument is that Inner City Press should be so grateful for being "able to raise the issue" that... it shouldn't raise the issue. And the NGOs who wrote to Ban Ki-moon should realize that this is being used by the UN against their position.

They said that "through the CEO Water Mandate, the U.N. is helping to advance corporate control of water.” The UN says that the letter proves that the UN is fair. Only at the UN...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncorp1water110809.html

UN's Ban Criticized for "Interfering" in Nepal, Envoy Won't Speak, Council Won't Distinguish

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/banrep2nepal110809.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 8 -- On the eve of a UN Security Council session on Nepal, the ruling alliance of parties of that country lashed out at UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's statement in his report to the Council that "a government of national unity remains desirable."

The parties called this a violation of Nepal's sovereignty. "The United Nations has no right to meddle in our internal political affairs," said Pradeep Gyawali, a senior party leader.

Inner City Press has learned that things could have gone worse: the penultimate draft of the UN's report on Nepal called a national unity government necessary. At the last minute it was changed to desirable, and still drew fire.

Ban's envoy to Nepal Karin Landgren briefed the Security Council on the morning of November 6. Inner City Press waited outside at the Council stakeout microphone, where briefers take questions from the press. But Ms. Landgren didn't stop, instead heading into the elevator and leaving. Under previous envoy Ian Martin, one wag mused, there was less of a problem of too little information.

Later at the UN's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Ban's outgoing spokesperson Michele Montas to respond to the criticism from Nepal. . Video here, from Minute 11:32. From the transcript:

Inner City Press: On Nepal, several parties have issued statements criticizing the Secretary-General for what they say is “meddling in their internal affairs” by issuing a statement. Have you seen that? She didn’t do a stakeout, the SRSG. What is the Secretariat’s response to this pushback by the Nepalese Government?

Spokesperson Michele Montas: It was the ruling alliance of parties; they were criticizing the Secretary-General’s report to the Security Council. And the observation of the Secretary-General is consistent with his repeated calls for unity and consensus among the political parties in order to assure the success of the peace process. They are quoting extensively what the Secretary-General said in the report. But the report is intended to encourage Nepal’s political parties to achieve what they themselves have expressed about the desirability of a unity Government and does not in any way represent a form of interference.

Ironically, earlier in the week Ms. Montas told Inner City Press that the UN does not respond to statements by member states. Inner City Press asked this month's Council president, Austria's Thomas Mayr-Harting, if the Council's carefully worded press statement on Nepal is a position different than Ban's. "Ask the Secretary General," was his response. Video here, from Minute 1:49.

Later on November 6, Ban's chief of Political Affairs B. Lynn Pascoe, leaving the Security Council during a briefing on Afghanistan, told Inner City Press of Ban's report on Nepal that "it's the same" as previous report. But things on the ground change, and one expects the UN to be paying attention. As noted things could have been even worse, and only weren't due to luck or a last minute change.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/banrep2nepal110809.html