Saturday, November 7, 2009

While UN Cuts Loose a Brigade in Congo, Leaked Memo Shows Other Knowledge

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/drc5doss110309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- Shortly after the scandal plagued chief of the UN Mission in the Congo Alan Doss dismissed reports of massacres by the Congolese Army units he works with, head UN Peacekeeper Alain Le Roy has committed not to work with unspecified units in the 213th Brigade. But a leaked MONUC memo shows knowledge of other Brigades' misdeeds, and questions remain unanswered.

In New York on November 2 and 3, there was bragging about this decision. At the November 2 noon briefing:

Spokesperson Michele Montas: MONUC has agreed on the launch of the investigation and I can assure you that the UN will not very easily abandon this. We will definitely make sure that the investigation is carried out.

Inner City Press: Recently here, the Special Rapporteur on Summary Execution, Philip Alston, said he named a massacre, he called it, of 50 civilians in Shalio, which seemed to be a different attack than this. At the time, Alan Doss was here and he said that there wasn’t sufficient evidence of that and they’d continue working. Are these two related, or is the UN looking into what Alston found, or…?

Spokesperson Montas: Every time there is an allegation, there is a follow-up. In this specific case, it’s because we had enough information to warrant an investigation, a full-blown investigation.

Inner City Press: On what Alston reported, is there not an investigation? Is there not enough evidence for what he said?

Spokesperson Montas: I can check for you what has been done on this.

More than 24 hours later, no information has been provided. A MONUC memo, however, has surfaced, showing UN knowledge of abuses beyond those it is belatedly acted on. The memo, signed by Doss' outgoing deputy Ross Mountain and put online here, states:

"the FARDC in Nyunzu are already accused of harassing the population"

UN staff are told to "avoid any gathering of locals" due to "anti MONUC sentiment"

in fact, "MONUC daily workers in Bunia" are deemed a "potential threat"

"the FARDC are misbehaving against the local population in Dungo Territory"

"Anti-Chinese sentiment continues in Katanga"

"two human rights activists were physically assaulted by soldiers in Punia"

"In Kasugho, the 112th FARDC Brigade completely looted the town" and "fired in the air all night long"

This last is not the 213th Brigade to which Le Roy referred. Is this acceptable? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc5doss110309.html

With UN Peacebuilding on Hold in Guinea, Munoz Steered from Pakistan by DSS

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unpbf1guineapak110309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- As the UN on Tuesday promoted its Peacebuilding Fund, and urged that people buy a Yoko Ono song on i-Tune as a way to support it, Inner City Press asked about the PBF's support to conflict ridden Guinea-Conakry. The chairman of the Peacebuilding Commission, Chilean Ambassador Heraldo Munoz, said "we may have had a project in the past." Video here, from Minute 17:41. One of his staffers said that Guinea was approved for eligibility, and the next step is the development of a priority plan.

But the PBF's web site already shows the plan, in April 2009 before the military government killed 150 protests and raped others. The PBF web site says that $6 million for this government was approved, and $100,000 already approved (it doesn't say for what).

Afterwards the staffer said that discussions "on the ground" in Guinea are conducted by the UN Development Program, as agent of the PBF. Inner City Press asked, How much overhead does UNDP charge? Eleven percent, said the staffer.

Inner City Press asked Munoz what UN Peacebuilding could bring to a crisis like Guinea. Munoz answered by switching countries, to Kenya. Inner City Press asked about Honduras, but it seems they have not applied.

Like the Security Council and the ICC, the agency of UN Peacebuilding is top heavy with African countries. Inner City Press asked Munoz why he thought this might be. Video here, from Minute 25:45. Munoz did not answer, except indirectly, that Honduras is being dealt with by a regional organization - the OAS. But Africa has the AU.

Is there some stigma in applying to UN Peacebuilding? An involved diplomat, after the briefing, told Inner City Press that some countries do not want to be among the four now only the Peacebuilding Commission's agenda, thinking it might undermine other funding. The example given was Haiti, which has taken Peacebuilding Fund money, but does not want to be on the agenda.

Footnote: in the final minutes of the briefing and afterwards, the talk turned to Munoz role on the panel investigating Benazir Bhutto's murder. Munoz on camera said he didn't want to answer. Off camera, he said that the UN's Department of Safety and Security has advised him and the panel not to travel there for now.

Inner City Press asked about an article reporting that Munoz panel is finding it difficult to put questions to Pervez Musharraf. Where is that article, Munoz asked. Inner City Press via laptop computer showed it. It's not accurate, Munoz then said. Has he has interviewed Musharraf? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unpbf1guineapak110309.html

IMF's Report Buries Its Icesave Conditionality, Enforcer's Duplicity?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/imf1iceland110309.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 3 -- While the IMF has acknowledged that its second round of disbursements to crisis-hit Iceland was delayed for months by the country's failure to placate those in the Netherlands and UK who did business with IceSave, the IMF's just released report on Iceland buries the issue on page 30 of the 98 page report. The IMF states that

"[t]he terms and conditions of Nordic loans, amounting to $2.5 billion, have been finalized. Their disbursement has been linked to resolution of the Icesave dispute with the U.K. and Netherlands over deposit insurance liabilities. After protracted discussions, the three governments have reached an agreement on this"

Once that agreement was reached, on October 18, the IMF then went forward with a letter of intent and memorandum of understanding for the second tranche of financing. But, as with the IMF's moves in Latvia for Swedish banks, some see the Fund operating as an enforcement or collections agent for creditors who even less would like to show their hand.

Since the IMF does not like to admit or reveal its degree of control over the countries it lends to, the de facto conditions for loans, such as paying off on IceSave, are often not explicit in what purport to be full agreements containing all express and implied terms.

In fact, the IMF has claimed that it "no longer" engages in conditionality. But the Iceland report has an entire chart about conditionalities. It's just that the most important one was left unsaid. Is this diplomacy or duplicity?

The IMF's Iceland report continues, about other loan requests including from Russia:

"A loan from the Faroe Islands ($50 million) has already disbursed, and a loan from Poland has been agreed ($200 million), and will disburse alongside the next 3 program reviews. A $500 million loan originally committed by Russia is no longer expected, but the $250 million in over-financing in the original program, an expected macro-stabilization loan from the EU ($150 million), and use of an existing repo facility with the BIS ($700 million, of which $214 million is outstanding) will more than offset this."

Offset may be the right word. Last year, in the midst of Iceland's abortive run for a seat on the UN Security Council, the country announced it had to seek a $4 billion loan from Russia. It was after that that the IMF loan commitment was made -- an "offset," some saw it -- and after talks in Istanbul, on October 15 the already whittled down loan request to Russia was formally rejected.

Then the deal with the UK and Netherlands, and the IMF's releasing. While the IMF calls these types of moves only technical, others call them power politics. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1iceland110309.html

At UN, As Climate Refugees Draw Oral Support, Tamil Asylum Seekers Still UN-Helped

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsys1refugees110209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 2 -- With refugees from armed government crackdowns in North Korea, Zimbabwe and Sri Lanka being rejected by countries they reach or try to reach, within the UN the talk of late is of a new kind of refugee, those caused by climate change.

Top UN humanitarian John Holmes on October 28 described the situation in the pastoralist Karamoja region of Uganda in such terms. Inner City Press asked, what about the Museveni government's own policies, in some cases abetted by the UN and UN Development Program, of forcible disarmament of cattle ranchers who feel they need their weapons? Video here, from Minute 29.

Holmes acknowledged problems with the disarmament programs, but also spoke of drought. Five days later at the International Peace Institute, Holmes appeared on a panel on "Monitoring disaster displacement in the context of climate change." During what was called the question and answer session, a representative of Bangladesh read out loud a lengthy prepared statement asking the UN for money. Then there was no time for questions from the Press.

Across First Avenue at the UN itself, while questions are taken, few answers are given. On October 19, and once before and two times since, including October 29, Inner City Press has asked the Office of the Spokesperson for the Secretary General what the UN system is doing about more then 200 asylum seekers from Sri Lanka on a ship diverted from Australia to Indonesia. Still there has been no answer -- and now another Australia bound ship has capsized, killing at least 11 people.

Where is the line drawn between climate refugees and those fleeing ethic discrimination? Or between green and economic refugees? When people leave an arid town in Mexico, or Somalia, why are they leaving?

From the audience came the proposal to place the issue under the rubric of migration. A panelist, from Norway, replied that those impacted by climate can be distinguished. So are some forms of suffering political correct? She said that Sweden provides protection for climate refugees. What about North Koreans? Zimbabweans? Tamils from Sri Lanka?

Footnote: speaking of displacement, Holmes on October 28 explained his delayed appears on the long trek from Madison Avenue, to which he and OCHA have been relocated. Upstairs, there's a locked office newly fixed up for Mr. Holmes' use. That was during the General Debate, Inner City Press was told, he needed a place to wait. And now?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsys1refugees110209.html

UN's Af-Pak Contradictions, on Threat Levels and No Bashardost Run-Off

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unama7sideline110209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 2 -- As in Kabul UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon assured Hamid Karzai that UN staff will stay in Afghanistan, the UN announced that it is pulling its international staff out of Northwest Pakistan, declaring the area at the UN's "Phase IV" security threat level. Is it safer in Afghanistan, where five UN staff as well as at least two others were killed last week before the second round of voting was canceled?

Inner City Press asked UN spokesperson Michele Montas, who declined to provide the UN's threat level for Afghanistan. The UN press office in New York routinely refuses to discuss issues it deems about security. Why then did the UN in Pakistan, in a press release, declare the rise to Phase IV?

The press release, by Isharat Rizvi of UNIC Islamabad, says that Mr. Ban "has declared Phase IV (Emergency Operations) in NWFP and FATA." When Inner City Press asked about it, Ms. Montas replied, "That should not have happened." Video here, from Minute 17:27.

But again, why not? The UN has been criticized in Algeria for giving in to the government's desire that the threat level be kept low, in the run-up to the bombing of the UN in Algiers. So does the UN withhold its threat assessment levels to placate governments? The U.S. State Department, for example, issues public travel advisories for certain countries. But the UN is "owned" by its member states. Did Pakistan complain about the public raising to Phase IV?

Inner City Press also asked, for the second time, if the UN had contacted the third place finisher in the first round of Afghan elections.

Back on October 22, Inner City Press asked UN Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe

Inner City Press: the number three candidate in Afghanistan, I know you’ve said we may get this hook up, so I wanted to ask you this now. The candidate who came in number three, Mr. Bashardost, has said that he may tell those who voted for him -- 10 per cent of the voters -- to boycott the second round due to continuing concerns of fraud. I wanted to know, in all this, in the UN’s engagement both with Abdullah Abdullah and President Karzai, is the UN speaking to this number three candidate and what do they make of his critique of the second round in advance?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: I’m sure that the UN is supporting all efforts by the Afghan authorities in ensuring that a successful second round takes place.

Now the second round has been canceled, after Abdullah Abdullah withdrew, and the UN apparently never contacted the number three candidate, Ramazan Bashardost. Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas on November 2; she replied that the decision to cancel was up to the Independent Electoral Commission, which most see as dominated by Hamid Karzai.

But even before the IEC announced its decision, the UN's Kai Eide called for a "timely" conclusion. Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas to respond to those who see Eide's comment as indicating a preference, shared by the U.S., that the second round be canceled, not least for security of their people. No, Ms Montas seemed to claim. The UN had no preference. Video here, from Minute 17:27. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unama7sideline110209.html

UN Suspends Two for KFC Photos, But Did Treki's Daughter Invite the Colonel In?

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un2kfcgate110209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 2, updated below -- The UN confirmed on Monday that in the wake of the embarrassing photo op by UN General Assembly President Ali Treki with a man advertising KFC chicken by impersonating Colonel Sanders, it has placed to UN Security officers on administrative suspension.

Inner City Press asked for the confirmation, and relatedly if President Treki's daughter, who is working in the Office of the President of the GA, had invited the Colonel Sanders to the UN's second floor, where he stood and spoke some words at the Security Council stakeout. Video here from Minute 24:21. Debate here.

UN Spokesperson Michele Montas confirmed the two suspensions "while investigating" the matter, but referred the other question to Treki's spokesman Jean-Victor Nkoko, who acknowledged on camera having seen a photo of Colonel Sanders with Treki's daughter. On the rest, he said it is under investigation and would not comment. Video here, from Minute 27:33.

But since two UN Security officers have been placed on administrative leave, Inner City Press asked Nkolo to get a yes or no answer whether Mr. Treki's daughter was involved, and if so why she too was not suspended. "That's a lot of if's," Nkolo responded.

Inner City Press asked, is she subject to UN (Office of Human Resources Management) discipline? Or does she have some special status? She is a diplomat seconded by the Libyan mission, Nkolo answered, adding that everyone who comes into the UN "even as a visitor" is subject to some rules.

But visitors, and apparently the daughter of the GA President while working in the GA President's Office, cannot be suspended. And one wonders if the Secretariat can truly let the chips or nuggest fall where they may while investigating the General Assembly President's Office and daughter. These are UN questions larger or separate than the commercial punking of the UN by KFC and its parent, Yum! Brands. Watch this site.

Foodnotes: While Officers Herring and Rodriguez have been suspended, Inner City Press is informed by a person present at the scene that the Colonel Sanders went into the Security office on the UN's first floor and photos of taken with him with higher level Security Officer David Bongi. Within the ranks of UN Security, there is talk of scapegoating of the two officers, and particular interest in what some call nepotism within the Office of the President of the General Assembly.

While UN spokesperson Michele Montas was dismissive when Inner City Press asked what the repercussions of the incident for Yum! Brands' partnership with the UN World Food Program might be, arguing that its was KFC, not its parent, KFC's letter to Ban Ki-moon came from the Yum! Brands' public relations firm.

Here is what Yum! said upon opening a restaurant in India:

"One of Yum! Brands’ four key business strategies is to drive aggressive international expansion and build strong brands everywhere 'The number of people who can afford our food will reach 200 million people within five years and we are very excited about serving Pizza Hut, KFC and soon Taco Bell to them'... In 2007, the company launched World Hunger Relief, the world’s largest private sector hunger relief effort to raise awareness, volunteerism and funds to benefit the United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) and other hunger relief agencies."

What was that again, about a prohibition on using the UN's name for commercial purposes?

After a phone call to WFP, Ms. Montas said in the UN briefing room that this is about KFP, not Yum! Brands, which is the parent company and is responsible Then Ms. Montas told Inner City Press to stop asking about the incident, ostensibly so that KFC would not get more publicity, and that she would herself return to the incident when there was new information. That was said in response to Inner City Press' question of if any Security officers had been suspended.

But, after a colleague confirmed the suspension of two unnamed officers, Ms. Montas went through more than ten minutes of announcement without providing the update. Only after Inner City Press asked did she confirm, while declining to provide any further information. As in the ongoing nepotism scandals, the UN's refusal to answer questions and attempts to bury issues in investigations only ensures that the issues are drawn out, some predict toward explosive conclusions. The cover up, as is said, is often worse than the crime. Watch this space.

Click here for Inner City Press' October 30 debate on 'KFC-gate.'

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2kfcgate110209.html

At UN, Of Ransacked Banks, Drinking and Dining Shutdowns As CMP Proceeds

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/cmp1banks110209.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 2 -- As UN Headquarters is being emptied out, it takes on the aura of a ghost town. On the first floor under the Economic and Social Council chamber, the Chinese verbatim offices are in shambles with file cabinets tipped over. Out the windows of the vacant riverfront offices one sees the changing leaves on Roosevelt island, by the long empty building on its tip. Ruins to ruins.

The UN Federal Credit Union sign was pried off the wall of its flagship branch on October 30, with even its automatic teller machines to be closed down. According to the UN's intra-net, "UNFCU, which also operates a branch in the DC-2 Building, will relocate their Secretariat office to the 20th floor of 380 Madison Avenue and decommission its ATM terminals on the 1st and on the 4th floors."

Then again, it also reported that

"24 December 2009 will be the last day of service as we know it at the Main Cafeteria, the Delegates Dining Room, the Staff Café and the Delegates Lounge, though it is currently under consideration to keep the Delegates Dining Room open for special events until the end of February 2010. While the Main Cafeteria will undergo remodeling in order to function as a scaled down cafeteria as well as the temporary Delegates Dining Room, the Staff Café and the Delegates Lounge will remain closed until the completion of the renovation of the Conference Building, which is projected for early 2012. Information on food service options during the remodeling of the Main Cafeteria and the date of the reopening will follow. "

Until recently, staff in the Delegates' Lounge has said discussions were ongoing to keep the Lounge open. After the above announcement, this was modified. On November 16, a winner of what is now Aramark's contract is to be decided, those involved in the process tell Inner City Press. The winner, which may or may not be Aramark, might be in a position to modifying the Lounge's closing date.

On the night of October 30, the Lounge was jumping, with talk of the Kentucky Fried Scapegoats and even the Goldstone report. The jewel of Santo Domingo arrived with a rolling cart full of chicken and pork rolls. The political advisor of a mission from a Muslim country took a bite and spat it out -- pork! -- and replacement chicken was quickly provided. Someone asked, Kentucky Fried? That story still has legs. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/cmp1banks110209.html

At UN, Ban Asks $86 Million for Security, No Answers on Budget in Kabul's Wake

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unama5sideline103009.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 30 -- In the wake of the killing of five UN staff members in Kabul, in New York Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Friday told the General Assembly he will ask for at least $86 million on top of the budget he presented earlier this week. The requests include a new $25 million emergency fund for security, and $50 million for a second Access Control Project -- which it is not clear would have covered the attacked Kabul guest house or facilities like it.

Ban's prepared remarks asked for "expanded authority to undertake new financial commitments in time of crisis. The current level of authority -- $1 million -- is simply not enough."

Earlier, when Inner City Press asked whether Ban would be funding his new three person investigation panel for Guinea from a $8 million fund for "unforeseen" expenses, Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas said she didn't know. A UN budget official said that the Secretary General can use this fund and simply report on its use at year's end. Inner City Press has asked for previous reports.

Meanwhile at press time in Afghanistan, Karzai's main rival Abdullah Abdullah is reportedly prepared to announce a boycott of the second round. Inner City Press has asked Ms. Montas, without answer, if the UN was in touch with the candidate -- not Ashraf Ghani -- who came in third. Would his name now be entered in the run off?

At what was billed a a "town hall" meeting with UN staff about the killing of their colleagues, Ban and the two other speakers, Ann Veneman of UNICEF and the elusive Helen Clark of UNDP, did not take any questions from staff.

Afterwards, some staff stopped and told Inner City Press the budget request smacked of opportunism. One argued that the deaths in Algiers and now Kabul were more the product of UN staff being put in places their shouldn't be, rather than a lack of money.

In Algiers, a UN security official has recommended beefing up security and raising the threat level, but the UN didn't, in deference to the government. In Kabul, UN staff ere in a guest house, to which ISAF didn't respond for an hour.

More resources may be needed, but there are not sufficient if UN leadership does not have the will, including the willingness to stand up to host countries, to protect its staff. But as with the USA Patriot Act, who will dare to vote against these requests, in the wake of a bombing?

While to some this skepticism seems harsh, it is significant - and newsworthy - that is circulating in the UN, and at a not-low level. One wonders when the Secretariat will come forward with the specifics of its DSS budget, particularly the items aluded to on Friday, and if it will forthrightly ties or compare the requests to what happened at the Kabul guesthouse, or Algiers before that. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unama5sideline103009.html

In Ban's UN, Tinker Bell and Bolton, Kentucky Fried Scapegoats

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 30 -- This week a diplomat of a country under UN sanctions stopped just outside the Security Council and told Inner City Press, "The UN has become a joke, all they have now are seminars and panels for discussion, with no knowledge of the ground." He missed one of the more incongruous UN events of October, the naming of Disney's Tinker Bell as Goodwill Ambassador, after the UN screening of the straight to DVD film

Only this week, John Bolton was at the UN with other conservatives, promoting a book about UN reform. Another group held a working lunch about the defamation of religion. The Office of Internal Oversight Services held another celebration of itself, this time complete with former UN journalistic talent, at which it was finally said in the open that the 38th floor is seeking a new Communications strategist.

The John Bolton gab-best at least was interesting. It was sponsored by Fiji, and headlined by C-FAM, which denounced Special Rapporteur Martin Scheinin for "redefining gender" and addressing gay rights. Inner City Press asked, did this mean they were on the same side of Eygpt and Syria? Apparently it did. What about Belarus, which fought off and get canceled its own Rapporteur? Bolton handled this one, saying he likes country specific rapporteurs, the thematics not so much.

To salad with walnuts and grilled breast of chicken, the Becket Fund denounced moves by the Organization of Islamic Conference to get language in the UN against the defaming of religion. It was mentioned that the Dutch director of Fitna got a screening this month down on Capitol Hill.

In a mockery of due process, two UN Security officers have been placed on administrative leave for the entry of a KFC Colonel Sanders impersonator last week, rather than highers-up who knew all about it. We'll have more on this.

UN's Ban To Ask For Money for Afghan Security, of PMCs and Phantom Polling Stations

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unama4sideline102909.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 29 -- In the aftermath of the Taliban's attack on UN staff in Kabul, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon briefing the Security Council and the Press about a plan to allocate and spend more money on security. Mr. Ban arranged with General Assembly President Ali Treki to brief the Assembly on October 30. His Office said that a dollar figure will be released then and only then.

Earlier on Thursday, Ban's Spokesperson declined to respond to an accusation by the developing countries in the Group of 77 that Ban has been making budget moves impermissibly without General Assembly approval. Inner City Press asked about G-77 testimony that morning in the Fifth (Budget) Committee, but Spokesperson Michele Montas said no response would be given, she "will not intervene in this." Video here, from Minute 13:48.

Does the subsequently arranged General Assembly appearance by Ban imply a recognition that Assembly approval must be sought and obtained? Inner City Press on Thursday asked the spokesman for President Ali Treki if it is Mr. Treki's view that Ban needs General Assembly approval, and has been told an answer will be given. Video here, from Minute 20:37.

Speaking to the Press after the Council, Ban was asked if the increased security might include private military contractors. To many of the assembly reporters, Ban appeared to say yes, and then to smile when the name "Blackwater" was shouted. There are issues with the UN using mercenaries -- as Inner City Press was the first to report, the UN used them in Iraq, but borrowed them from the UK and left it on the UK's budget, not the UN's.

Ban was also asked for the UN's response to the announcement by the Hamid Karzai-dominated Independent Elections Commission that it will open 155 more of the phantom polling stations that resulted in findings of fraud in the first round.

While Ban has said that polling stations that cannot be monitored should not be opened, the IEC now reportedly intends to increase the number of stations from 6167 to 6322, in an atmosphere less secure and harder to monitor than before.

And if the second round, too, is fraudulent, will there be a third round? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unama4sideline102909.html

In Run-Up to Copenhagen, of UN Web Sites Lost and Posts Empty by U.S.

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope2offmessage102809.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 28 -- On climate change, while even Yvo de Boer of the UN says it's unlikely the deal will be sealed in Copenhagen in December, the UN Secretariat still maintains that there is no Plan B. And apparently that is true: while they got "SealTheDeal2009.org" to advocate for an agreement, "SealTheDeal2010.org" was recently obtained by another, through GoDaddy.com.

With all the resources the UN is devoting to Copenhagen, one might have expected them to at least take the 2010 domain name off the table. But perhaps they thought it would show a lack of faith.

Meanwhile, as a response to Inner City Press' article documenting nepotism in the Office of the President of the UN General Assembly, including PGA Ali Treki bringing his daughter and a cousin into the Office, Inner City Press has been informed that Treki asked the United States to second a staff member to his office on the climate change issue. The Obama administration has yet to come through.

From the October 27 UN transcript:

Inner City Press: I’ve been told that the, the Office of President Treki asked the United States to appoint a staff member to cover the issue of climate change, I guess to second a staff member from the United States Mission or the United States State Department to serve in the Office. Is that something you’re aware of? Is that true?

Spokesperson Jean-Victor Nkolo: Well, I don’t think I would like to go into staffing matters in a specific office at the United Nations. I don’t think that would be proper. But what I can tell you is that the Office of the President of the General Assembly is definitively staffed by a wide array of personnel coming from all horizons -- Africa, Europe, the Middle East, Latin America. It’s a very international team and I think that it will be good that the international profile of this team continues to be reinforced. What I wouldn’t like to comment on are specifics regarding staffing matters.

Inner City Press: Is there currently somebody, I mean maybe you can comment on this one, is there, on the issue of climate change, is there currently a staff member of the Office covering that issue?

Spokesperson Nkolo: What I can tell you is that we are only a few a weeks after the General Assembly started its session, and as you know, the work of any session of the General Assembly starts in mid-September. It takes some time, usually, to actually have all the positions filled and this process is still ongoing and it does not, it’s not limited to the climate change issues. There are other areas that are being filled and the cabinet of the President of the General Assembly is working hard to make sure that all areas are filled quickly, but as efficiently and professionally as possible.

So they haven't filled the climate change post, this close to the Copenhagen meeting? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope2offmessage102809.html

In South Sudan, UN Defers to Government on LRA, Shuttles Its Enemies

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/sudan1qazi102809.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 28 -- Two of the UN's largest peacekeeping missions ever are in Sudan, spending upwards of $2 billion a year. The head of the UNMIS Mission Ashraf Qazi came to the UN on Wednesday painting an upbeat picture in the run up to April 2010 elections, and then referendums if South Sudan will break away. But on the ground, Qazi's and the UN's air force had to evacuate forces loyal to Paulino Matip when they were engaged by the Sudan People's Liberation Army.

When Inner City Press first asked UN spokespeople in New York about it, they knew known. Inner City Press asked Qazi and he put a positive spin even on this, saying the evacuation was at the agreement of both parties, that the evacuated forces will be integrated. There are "different versions," he said, of what happened. Sudanese sources tell Inner City Press the SPLA fired on Matip's compound. Video here, from Minute 4:46.

Inner City Press asked Qazi what UNMIS is doing to protect civilians from the Lord's Resistance Army. Qazi said their mandate is limited, that mostly they train the SPLA. He spoke of managing expectations -- meaning, apparently, don't expect the UN to protect you.

Nor has Qazi heard of the incident in which the plane bearing Nigeria Senate President David Mark was turned back from Khartoum. A Sudanese diplomat told Inner City Press it was not, as reported, about President Bashir's on again, off again trip to Abuja. Rather, he said, Nigeria had sent the paperwork for the flight and landing, rather than to the Civil Aviation Authority, to the Foreign Ministry. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sudan1qazi102809.html

On Somalia, UN's Pascoe Blames Shabaab for Marketplace Shelling, Hiring Hush Up

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/dpa1somaliajob102709.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 27 -- Having been turned back from Somali airspace during a mortar attack on the Mogadishu airport, the UN's political chief Lynn Pascoe on Tuesday presented to the Press a rosy picture of successful peacekeeping by Burundi and Uganda. Inner City Press asked about reports that these African Union peacekeepers fired into a marketplace and residential neighborhoods, killing at least twenty civilians.

"It depends on what kind of story you're trying to write," Pascoe answered, repeating the claim that Al Shabaab has been shelling the neighborhoods it controls in order to blame the AU peacekeepers. Video here, from Minute 12:15.

Al Shabaab has threatened to target Burundi and Uganda for the incident. Inner City Press asked Pascoe if that might impact his upbeat story of a growing AU force in Somalia. "Threats and statements are just threats and statements," Pascoe said. Video here, from Minute 20:08. He said that the two countries are there because they perceive a threat from Somalia to their own peace and security.

The threat Somalia poses to Burundi is not entirely clear. Nor is the legality of Uganda's new screening of all Somalis in its territory, as an anti-terrorism measure. On that, Inner City Press asked Charles Petrie, now the deputy to Ould Abdallah at the UN's mission to Somalia, based in Nairobi, if it is true that the U.S. is withholding $50 million in food aid in connection with an internal investigation by the UN World Food Program of alleged diversions.

Petrie said to "ask the State Department," and claimed it is not really about WFP. But WFP has admitted it it investigating itself. So which is it? Petrie dismissed claims by Somalis that food is being used as a political weapon, saying that there are spoilers in Somalia who are "on lists." Video here, from Minute 21:59.

Later on Tuesday, Inner City Press asked Richard Barrett of the UN's Al Queda / Taliban Sanctions committee about this withholding of aid, and if there is any proof linking Al Shabaab to Al Qaeda. Barrett repeated what he had said in July, that Al Shabaab praises Al Qaeda. Video here. But is that the standard of proof? Recently, his committee de-listed that Barakaat financial institution, which had many remittances to Somalia frozen without any due process.


The Chairman of this Resolution 1267 Committee, Austria's Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting, said that those sanctions are not punitive but preventive, and some are taken off once they no longer pose a threat. Video here. But did they ever? And how are they made whole? As in the Congo, the UN has taken sides in a conflict, and now suffers the consequences, including to the dwindling perception of its impartiality.

Footnote: Inner City Press, which first reported on what many in and out of Pascoe's Department of Political Affairs view as a hiring scandal in which Pascoe laterally moved into a Sanctions Branch position an Irish woman -- said to have long been pushed within DPA, back to two directorships ago under British management -- after a full recruitment process had been done, asked Pascoe about it.

Pascoe refused to comment. At first he said his answer would be boring. Then he said he would not comment on "my internal relations with my staff." But it is a UN reform issue. The UN preaches transparency and accountability but refuses to practice either.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dpa1somaliajob102709.html

UN's Alston Critiques MONUC's Doss As Lax on Rights, Nepotism Biter Case Continues

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/doss6boot102709.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 27 -- The UN Mission in the Congo under its chief Alan Doss is "mistakenly" dismissive of reports of massacres by the Congolese army units it works with, the UN's Special Rapporteur on executions Philip Alston told the Press on Tuesday.

After Alan Doss delivered a self congratulatory briefing to the Security Council on October 16, Inner City Press asked him about Alston's report about the Congo, and the other nepotism and misuse of UN resources scandals surrounding Mr. Doss. He was dismissive of both, saying that he wasn't convinced by Alston's report, and that the scandals were being investigated so he would not comment.

When Inner City Press asked Alston about Doss' response, Alston noted that even the Congolese minister for communications essentially admitted the massacres took place. "Where does that leave MONUC, saying we don't have evidence," Alston asked. Video here, from Minute 12:54.

Speaking specifically about Doss, Alston said while he understands the reluctance of a Special Representative of the Secretary General not wanting to derail his mission with what seem "minor human rights" violations, Doss' is a "mistaken way of looking at it." In fact, Alston said this approach makes MONUC unsustainable.

Doss claims to get assurances from the Congolese government of Joseph Kabila, but Alston said that such behind the scenes talks do not "leave the UN looking very good." He mocked the responses of MONUC "at a high level," saying, "rest assured, we speak to the Congolese Army." "Assurances are not the answer," Alston said, until there is "something on paper," for example MONUC actually stopping working with specific units of the Congolese Army. Don't hold your breath, at least not under Alan Doss.

Footnote: the case of the UN versus Nicola Baroncini, the UN Development Program worker whose job was give to Alan Doss' daughter Rebecca after Doss wrote to UNDP asking for "leeway, is scheduled to continue in criminal court in New York on October 28.

According to the defendant, the UN says it can't or won't drop the charges -- against a man who was pepper sprayed before he reportedly bit Security Officer Peter Kolonias -- because he had tried to contact Officer Kolonias. But if the UN can press charges in court, why can't charges be pressed against it? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/doss6boot102709.html