Saturday, November 7, 2009

On Sri Lanka, UN's Alston Probes Execution Video, Kaelin Says His Praise Was Misquoted

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1srilanka102709.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 27 -- As Sri Lanka announces another internal investigation of the war crimes charges against it, at the UN on Tuesday the Special Rapporteur on executions Philip Alston told the Press he has "begun to commission some analyses of that video tape" depicting Sri Lankan soldiers shooting bound and naked prisoners. Video here, from Minute 6:56.

Inner City Press asked Alston about the reports that people seeking to surrender in May, waving white flags after in some cases speaking with UN officials, were shot and killed, reportedly on orders from the highest ranks of the Sri Lanka military. Video here, from Minute 11:13.

"Let's have an independent inquiry," Alston said, noting that past "investigations" by the government were not independent. He used as his example that two Sri Lankan military figures were charged with investigating the execution video. The government of Sri Lanka cannot be proud of its track record, Alston said.

Before commissioning his own analysis of the video, Alston said he "would have liked the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights" Navi Pillay to have undertaken an investigation, as was done for example by Justice Richard Goldstone of the conflict in Gaza this year.

Inner City Press asked Alston about the countries on the Human Rights Council which have rebuffed his requests to visit, including both China and Russia, which blocked Security Council consideration of the conflict in Sri Lanka this Spring. Alston said "there has to be a limit," presumably to what members of the Human Rights Council can do. But for now, there are no limits. Alston's mandate expires in August 2010 and will no be renewed.

Two other Rapporteurs, on Internally Displaced People and freedom of religion, also took questions about Sri Lanka on Tuesday. Inner City Press asked IDP expert Walter Kaelin about a headline in Sri Lanka, "UN envoy pleased with progress," in the Sunday Observer of September 27.

Kaelin said he'd never spoken with that newspaper, and went on to criticize the conditions in the Manik Farms camps. He said people were being moved out. Inner City Press asked if the so called transit camps also restrict movement. He said that they did, and that this did not comply with international humanitarian law. Video here. But the UN keeps funding it, apparently.

Inner City Press asked about IDPs' right to return to their homes, and not be displaced, as some say is planned in northern Sri Lanka east of A9, by members of other ethnic grounds. While Kaelin said there is a right to return which the government of Sri Lanka has not disputed, he acknowledged that he is not able to closely monitor what happens on the ground. And therein lies the problem.

Inner City Press asked the Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief Asma Jahangir about this same issue, Sinhalese versus Tamils, the Buddhist triumphalism some see in Sri Lanka. She acknowledged she'd heard of it, ascribing it to political fights "long ago." Video here. But these fights continue. The UN system, even its special rapporteurs, may appear out of touch. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1srilanka102709.html

After KFC's Photo Op with UN's Treki, No UN Action on Parent Yum! Brands

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1yum102609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 26 -- In a breakdown of security in UN headquarters, a man off the street impersonating fried chicken magnate Colonel Sanders on behalf of KFC had a photo op with UN General Assembly President Ali Treki on October 22, before as Inner City Press first reported going to the UN Security Council stakeout microphone where Council Ambassadors speak.

The publicity stunt was carried out by KFC and its parent, Yum! Brands, which has a partnership with the UN World Food Program. On October 26, Inner City Press asked UN spokesperson Michele Montas what the UN system will do about being used by Yum! Brands. She said the Office of Legal Affairs is looking into it. But OLA chief Patricia O'Brien has refused to answer questions about past corporate uses of the UN and its name and logo, including in corporate press releases.

While the UN is saying that "an NGO" signed him in, and a security officer erroneously escorted him around, mistaking the white suited imposter as a visiting dignitary, Ali Treki has his own security detail, paid by the UN. How could Colonel Sanders get in?

Inner City Press on October 26 asked Treki's spokesman Jean Victor Nkolo:

Inner City Press: Jean Victor, I’m sorry this is one more on this whole “KFC-gate” situation. Is it… Can you, I mean, can you confirm that [inaudible] impersonator or advertising man actually met with the President of the General Assembly Treki and if so what does that say about his own security?

Spokesperson: I wouldn’t call that a meeting. There was no meeting, no appointment scheduled with the actor impersonating Colonel Sanders. But I can confirm that he, that Colonel Sanders was wandering about the second floor and there was a brief encounter with the President of the General Assembly. Yes. Any other question?

Inner City Press: On the Internet, there is a picture of the two of them shaking hands with the UN flag there, so have you seen this photo?

Spokesperson: I have seen these photos. I just cannot really add much on what Michele has already told you. The commercial exploitation of the UN emblem, and logos and flags is definitively unacceptable and, you know, the President of the General Assembly, somebody walked into his office and wanted to shake hands and he shook hands because he is a very polite man in a sense.

As Inner City Press was also first to report, Treki when asked called homosexuality -- and by extension homosexuals -- "not acceptable." Some now joke: but a photo op with Colonel Sanders is acceptable?

In terms of the UN standing up to corporations, at least those which openly abuse it, Inner City Press on October 26 asked UN Spokesperson Michele Montas:

Inner City Press: I’m wondering from, I mean, Kentucky Fried Chicken or KFC is owned by something called Yum Brands, a conglomerate. It actually has a kind of a partnership deal with the World Food Programme and puts out press releases saying we work with the World Food Programme obviously trying to advertise itself. What’s the UN going to do on it, because KFC also wrote a letter supposedly to the Secretary-General. Are you aware, they’ve put on their website a letter they claim…

Spokesperson Montas: I can tell you that the Secretary-General never received that letter.

Inner City Press: Okay.

Spokesperson: And, at any rate, that letter is void to us. It has absolutely no meaning whatsoever. The UN cannot be involved in a commercial venture, period.

Inner City Press: But then, so what are the repercussions for Yum Brands or KFC for having kind of used the UN somewhat effectively to advertise themselves.

Spokesperson: Well this is being, being touched upon by our legal department.

While under the previously UN administration, some fight back at corporations which used and abused the UN was undertaken and describe, now under OLA chief Patricia O'Brien, questions in this regard aren't taken or answered. Should KFC and Yum! Brands' taking things to the next level, openly making a mockery of the UN a la Ali G, be any surprise? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1yum102609.html

At UN, Col. Sanders of KFC Promotes Chicken As UN's Laxity on Corporations Discussed

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1kfc102209.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 22, follow up here -- At the UN Security Council stakeout on Thursday, Kentucky Fried Chicken was promoted by a visitor to the UN dressed up as KFC figurehead Colonel Sanders. As the Security Council discussed, among other things, the plight of refugees from Darfur in camps in Eastern Chad, KFC's Sanders stood before the flags of the 15 Council members, at the UN microphone.

Ironically, just next to the Security Council in the UN's briefing room, the UN's expert on transnational corporation and Human Rights John Ruggie explained his mandate to the Press. Inner City Press asked why the UN is so soft on corporation, through its UN Global Compact, including Deutsche Bank which holds the funds of Turkmenistan's dictators and Nestle which is reported to be involved in the production of chocolate by children trafficked from Mali into Ivory Coast.

One might have added KFC, whose Col. Sanders as one wag joked bitterly may have killed, through heart congestion and attacks, as many people as some of those indicted by the International Criminal Court, despite not being a military and therefore not a war criminal despite the Colonel in his name. The wag imagined a sign board or campaign, "Send KFC to the ICC."

Inner City Press has asked the Office of the Spokesperson for Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to provide information on how the KFC Colonel Sanders impersonator was allowed into the UN, and to the Security Council stakeout area, from which even UN staff members are often prohibited.

"Maybe they got observer status -- why not KFC, if they gave it to IOC?" asked the wag, referring to the International Olympics Committee, which joined the Holy See and Palestine in UN Observer Status this week. Watch this site.

Update of Thursday evening: Despite the Office of the Spokesperson for Ban Ki-moon being asked about KFC's presence in the UN at the stakeout both at the noon briefing and, again, by Inner City Press just after, no explanation was received, nor yet to these submitted questions:

1. Did any United Nations staff person facilitate the entry into the HQ of a character portraying "Colonel Sanders" on Thursday Oct 22nd?

2. Did KFC, its parent YUM! Brands, or its PR agency Weber Shandwick solicit and receive permission from the United Nations to use the the Secretary-General's and/or the UN's name in its corporate press release and advertising campaign?

3. Has the Secretary-General received the letter cited in KFC's corporate press release and advertising campaign?


4. Will the UN's Office of Legal Affairs take steps to inform YUM! Brands or its agents that it is misusing the UN's name, in violation of applicable General Assembly resolutions?

5. Has the UN's Office of Legal Affairs previously given permission to YUM! Brands or its agents to use the UN's name in other advertising materials?

6. Does the UN think that the UN Security Council should be used as a backdrop for the sale of grilled chicken?

Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1kfc102209.html

On Copenhagen, Un's De Boer and Sachs Dubious, Off Message on Upbeat Seal the Deal

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope1offmessage102609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 26 -- UN climate negotiator Yvo de Boer was quoted in the Financial Times last week that "a fully fledged new international treaty under the [UN framework] convention [on climate change] - I do not think that will happen. If you look at the limited amount of time remaining to Copenhagen, it's clear."

Monday at the UN, Inner City Press asked Janos Pasztor, Director of the Secretary-General's Climate Change Support Team, how what de Boer said is consistent with the more upbeat "Seal the Deal" message emanating from the 38th floor. Video here, from Minute 50:05.

"We discussed it with Mr. de Boer extensively afterwards," Pasztor replied. "Not everything he said was quoted. His message is total consistent." Pasztor added that they will go for an ambitious agreement in Copenhagen. We we cannot get a legally binding treat, he said, they we'll do it later.

When Inner City Press asked Pasztor if the UN is claiming de Boer was misquoted by the FT, he did not say yes; So apparently de Boer was read the riot act, and told to get back on message.

Some say de Boer is lucky -- Ban's deputy envoy to Afghanistan got fired for going public with his claims of electoral fraud in Afghanistan being covered up.


UN's Ban and de Boer: on the same page on deal being sealed?

On October 6, another Ban advisor Jeffrey Sachs told an audience including the Press that he doubts the deal can be sealed in Copenhagen. When Inner City Press asked Pasztor about this, he replied that Sachs represents and advises Ban only on the Millennium Development Goals. But perhaps Sachs too has now been read the riot act. If even the UN's small "global goods" team cannot stay on its polyanna message, can they be surprised as other fall away?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope1offmessage102609.html

At UN, Line on Egypt and Gays Triggers Indian Response, Looming Culture War

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1scheinin102609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 26 -- The president of the UN General Assembly Ali Treki in a statement last month first reported by Inner City Press called homosexuality "not acceptable" to him and, he said, "two billion Muslims." On Monday, UN Special Rapporteur Martin Scheinin presented to the General Assembly's human rights committee a report stating, for example, that

"in Egypt, Government targeting of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex individuals has been a way of shoring up religious legitimacy and signifying to opposition movements that the State is 'the guardian of public virtue.'"

Inner City Press asked Scheinin about fight-back to his report from Egypt and other delegations, including India. Scheinin said that such moments in the Assembly's Third Committee "can't be controlled." Video here, from Minute 20:09.

He said his quote about Egypt was from a "half academic NGO" (the footnote reads, "See Hossam Bahgat, “Explaining Egypt’s Targeting of Gays”, Middle East Report, 23 July 2001" -- that is, before 9/11/01).

Inner City Press asked Scheinin about Treki's quote. Scheinin said that UN is an inter-governmental body with no single voice. He said he only hopes that UN Special Rapporteurs respect rights without regard to gender identify or sexual orientation. He highlighted the threat of sexual humiliation directed at men with homosexual fears, including by "civilized countries." Inner City Press asked, Abu Ghraib? That is one example, Scheinin replied.

As cited in the UN's summary, "India's delegate said that it was unfortunate that the Rapporteur [Scheinin] had redefined the notion of a 'gender perspective.' In trying to give a comprehensive assessment, he had taken the Committee away from a meaningful debate, which was academic in nature and did not fall within the terms of his code of conduct."

This last, "code of conduct," is a code word for seeking to attack the Rapporteur's mandate or even the position going forward. The UN representative of a major NGO last week told Inner City Press the group is concerned that Egypt and Syria and even "some Catholic countries in the EU" will try to use Scheinin's report as a way to attack all of the Rapporteurs and special procedures. But what of pro-Scheinin advocacy? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1scheinin102609.html

At UN, Bombs In Iraq and Iran Draw Near-Identical Boiler Plate Statements, Orwellian Outrage

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1boilerplate102509.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 25 -- Suicide bombings on successive Sundays in Iran and Iraq drew nearly identical press statements from the UN Security Council in New York. Beyond the boiler plate, the difference was speed: the bombing in Baghdad was immediately condemned by the United States, via a statement in the name of Ambassador Susan Rice, following by a press statement emailed out in the name of the Council's 15 members.

The Council's more delayed response to bombing in Iran, which killed Revolutionary Guard officials among others on October 18, was in the form of a four minute press stakeout on October 20 by this month's Council president Le Luong Minh, the Ambassador of Viet Nam.

Inner City Press asked him if the Council had discussed Iran's accusation of involvement by the U.S. and United Kingdom, and request for permission to pursue Jundallah into Pakistan. Video here, from Minute 3:04.

"We did not discuss that particular attack," said Le Luong Minh. But then what attack was the Council discussing? Perhaps that is the problem with the Council's cookie-cutter press statements about bombings. As George Orwell might have said, a failure to consider new words leads to a lack of thinking.

A correspondent asked if the phrase about human rights was added with specific reference to Iran. But the phrase is just part of the boiler plate template, repeated word for word five days later about Iraq.

Inner City Press also asked Le Luong Minh, "Who wrote the statement?" He replied, "The Presidency did." But which Presidency? How far back?

These two bombings are significant, as well as tragic for the victims and their families. The boiler plate only devalues them.

Footnote: After the Iran statement stakeout, a European Council member's staffer handed out copies of the statement. "On behalf of the Vietnamese Presidency," he hastened to point out, smiling.

More seriously, some pundits are so eager to see the government in Tehran under fire that they have portrayed the bombing of the Revolutionary Guards as related to the street protests of the contested election. But sometimes the enemy of one's enemy shouldn't be presented as a friend...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1boilerplate102509.html

UN Sings For Its Supper as Sponsors Strut in Green Room, Pay for Play on UN Day

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unday5paytoplay102409.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 24 -- As the UN celebrated itself with a concert in the General Assembly Friday night, the sponsor it took $110,000 from lurked around trying to get pay-back.

On stage, UN peacekeepers were praised, even for their work in Rwanda. Across First Avenue, after an open photo op with the sponsors by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon had become untenable, or at least unsavory, Under Secretary General Ibrahim Gambari arrived in at the UN Millennium Hotel to take photos with the Chinese businessmen who paid money for access to the UN.

Still, this wasn't enough. Ban's pre-concert photo op, it emerged, had initially had three phases: artists, member states then sponsor. The last was officially cut out. But witnesses at the photo op, with the exception of the UN's organizer, tell Inner City Press that sponsor Frank Liu of the World Harmony Foundation and six of his associates still managed to get access.

In the green room behind the General Assembly rostrum, Inner City Press spoke with Frank Liu. He complained about being excluded. They come and ask you for money, he said, and then this. Without apparent irony, he said that he perhaps shared Inner City Press' desire to "reform the UN."

Head UN peacekeeper Alain Le Roy strode into the green room. He spoke with the director of the Culture Project, and with Mr. Frank Liu, to whom he had written in July offering a full tour of DPKO's 24 hour Situation Center, in exchange for sponsorship of the concert.

The UN, at the pre concert press conference, claimed that despite the wording of Le Roy's letter, there was no quid pro quo. The UN admitted that these same sponsors, the World Harmony Foundation, took photos with Ban Ki-moon after an event they paid for in March, but called the photos "ad hoc." These arguments wouldn't stand up in a New York City vice raid, or subsequent court appearance.

Rather than reflect on how bad the March pay to play incident in the General Assembly lobby made the UN look, the UN decided to try to take Frank Liu's money without openly being dominated. So, for example, it told Liu he couldn't bring onto the stage or even in the building the harmony bell he stores, during the year, in a garage in Queens.

Lui, who complained to Inner City Press about this, had the bell brought to the Isaiah Wall across the street, and rang it along with personalities from South Korea. Take that, thirty eighth floor, was the message. Then USG Gambari made his appearance, ostensibly in a personal capacity, on the 29th floor of the UN Millennium Hotel. In the group's program, Gambari was listed as Deputy Secretary General, but Gambari later told Inner City Press this was "their fault," and Liu ascribed it to translation.

So the UN tried to be able to say they had taken Frank Liu's money without taking anything from him. But he and his associates were given passes into the UN, used the Delegates Dining Room, got access to the Green Room and the top UN officials. The staged denial or withholding of certain accesses and acts took on the flavor of the client or "date" negotiations often broken up on shows such as Police Women of Broward County. But who will go undercover and expose some current UN officials? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unday5paytoplay102409.html

Friday, October 23, 2009

As China Disappears Uighurs, UN Delays Comment, Then Outsources to Geneva

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/hchr1uighurs102209.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 22 -- As the UN like the United States because less willing to speak about human rights and China, questions at UN headquarters about the treatment of minority Uighurs have gone unanswered until now. Last week, Inner City Press asked about Uighurs sentenced to death without having lawyers. There was no response.

On October 21, Inner City Press asked about reports that over 40 Uighurs including children have been disappeared by the government. The Deputy Spokesperson for Secretary General Ban Ki-moon responded that the UN High Commissioner on Human Rights would be saying something on the issue later that day.

Three hours later, Inner City Press asked High Commissioner Pillay about the missing Uighurs. She shook her head, nothing to say, at least not at a press conference on human trafficking. A staffer said a statement might come out later and be provided.

Nothing having arrived, at the noon briefing on October 22, Inner City Press asked again. Still nothing. Another staffer said that the Office is doing a lot behind the scenes. But why treat China so differently than other countries?

Finally, a statement was provided to Inner City Press, below

Subj: Your question on China
From: unspokesperson-donotreply [at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 10/22/2009 2:40:31 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time

While recognizing that those who committed crimes in Xinjiang -- just like anywhere else -- must be brought to justice, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) says it has concerns about the reported disappearance of some of those arrested. In July, OHCHR expressly requested information from the Government of China about the whereabouts and status of the detainees and will continue to pursue this matter with the government.

During the unrest, the High Commissioner for Human Rights called publicly for an independent investigation into the causes of the rioting and the reasons why it escalated to the point of causing injuries or loss of life to around 1,000 people. Since then, OHCHR has encouraged the Government of China to facilitate an open and transparent investigation by independent international parties in order to produce a fuller narrative of what actually happened. OHCHR believes this type of investigation is extremely important after events of this nature -- it made a similar call, for example, after the recent killings and rapes in Guinea.

OHCHR says it will continue to discuss all these issues with the Chinese authorities.

For any follow-up questions, pls contact OHCHR

That is, don't ask Ban Ki-moon or his spokespeople to comment on China and human rights. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/hchr1uighurs102209.html

UN's Quintana Soft on Myanmar, Praises Regime's Rohinga Ruling, in Total Denial

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1myanmar102209.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 22 -- As two repressive countries were reviewed Thursday at the UN, the different approach of the two UN rapporteurs emerged through torture as a story in itself. Both Myanmar and North Korea have country specific rapporteurs, to which the UN's other human rights experts defer on events in the two nations. For example, when Inner City Press asked the UN's expert on the rights of the indigenous James Anaya about the plight of Rohinga and other ethnic minorities in Myanmar, Anaya said he defers to the country expert, Tomas Ojea Quintana.

Likewise when Inner City Press asked the UN's expert on business and human rights, John Ruggie, about Total's investment in Myanmar, Ruggie said he deferred to Quintana.

But Quintana on Thursday appeared to some to defend the regime of Than Shwe. When Inner City Press asked about the Rohinga, rather than speak about the denial of citizenship and mass exodus as boat people, Quintana praised a Burmese court decision that Rohinga can marry each other.

When Inner City Press asked about Total's and others investment with the Than Shwe government in the gas and oil sector -- payments from which are said to make up the 41% of the regime's budget which goes to military spending, Quintana referred the question back to Ruggie -- who not three hours earlier, sitting in the same seat as Quintana, had said he has nothing to say on company-specific questions.

Inner City Press asked Quintana point blank if when he goes to Myanmar, he is escorted by the military. Quintana said "there are limitations," but would not describe them.

By contrast, the outgoing rapporteur on North Korea Vitit Muntarbhorn, called Kim Jong-il's a dictatorship, described the punishment of those who seek to flee, and noted that the World Food Program can't inspect its programs except on one week's notice. Click here for that.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1myanmar102209.html

UN Expert's North Korea Swan Song Questions UNDP and UNHCR, One Week Notice by WFP

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1dprk102209.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 22 -- After six years of reporting on North Korea, Vitit Muntarbhorn has had enough. He was never allowed into the country, only interviewed refugees who left. At the UN on Thursday, Inner City Press asked him if the UN's refugee agency is defending the rights of those who flee, especially to China.

Muntarbhorn was diplomatic, saying that is UNHCR's job, and that his mandate stops at the border. About the UN Development Program re-opening in Pyongyang, he said that UNDP would not -- as it did in the past -- pay for Kim Jong-il officials' foreign travel and training in the name of development. We'll see.

He described brutal prison conditions, and crackdowns on women who wear pants, leading to rare and courageous demonstrations. Unlike his counterpart on Myanmar Tomas Quintana, he had no problem saying that the money the government gets does not sufficiently go to the people. He said that abductees were not only Japanese, but also from South Korea and elsewhere.

Inner City Press asked Muntarbhorn what the Universal Periodic Review -- described by High Commissioner Navi Pillay as a jewel of the UN's human rights system -- could accomplish.

Muntarbhorn called the UPR "middle pitch," saying there is also a need from some higher pitch name and shame reporting. His successor, he said, will need to study politics as well as human rights. He himself has another job in waiting, he told reporters are the end, without naming it. We wish him well.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1dprk102209.html

IMF Plays Ukraine, Zim and Pakistan As "Technical" Questions, Pushes Tax Hikes in Serbia

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/imf1ukzimpak102209.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 22 -- Are the International Monetary Fund's negotiations with countries about the level of taxes and salaries for public sector employees, the pricing of electricity and the privatization of social services political, or merely "economic and technical"? The questions arose Thursday in connection with Ukraine, Zimbabwe and Pakistan, among others, in the IMF's first press briefing since its annual meeting in Turkey.

IMF spokesperson Caroline Atkinson fielded questions for half an hour, leaving unanswered one submitted by Inner City Press about Serbia, where the IMF's Paul Thompson has been quoted that "if the Serbian delegation has a concrete pan for decreasing expenses, we will support it, if not, they will have to agree with us and think about increasing taxes." Left unanswered: how is raising taxes merely "technical"?

Ms. Atkinson did respond to Inner City Press' questions about Ukraine, Zimbabwe and Pakistan. While a full transcript is available online here, and video here, in sum the Q & A went as follows:

Inner City Press asked, In Ukraine, the opposition party is critical of the IMF as funding the campaign of Tymoshenko. What is the IMF's response to the opposition's criticism? Ms. Atkinson replied that IMF funds go to the central bank, and that the IMF has a team on the ground in Kiev for a third review.

The opposition was not, it seems, saying that money from the IMF is being used by Tymoshenko for advertisements or to pay poll workers, but rather "MP and opposition government's finance minister, Mykola Azarov, said this at a meeting with delegates of an IMF mission, 'We must say that the program of cooperation with the IMF has turned out to be ineffective, and nothing is left but to consider the IMF's assistance as politically motivated, as funding of one of the candidates running for the presidency.'"

When another reporter asked a follow up question about Ukraine, wondering if with the IMF mission on the ground, the upcoming election "is an issue," Ms. Atkinson said the IMF does not comment while a mission is in the field, negotiating a program, but that information -- and one hopes some questions and answers -- will be provided once the mission is completed


On Zimbabwe, Inner City Press asked, "NGOs are critical of the IMF for, they say, pushing Zimbabwe to privatize its social services system. Has the IMF pushed for that, and how does it respond to the criticism?" Ms. Aktinson, while saying she can get back to Inner City Press with more information, argued that the IMF does not favor or disfavor particular privatizations, but must be pushing to strengthen the social service sector to help the poor.

But speaking just ahead of civil society's consultative meeting with an IMF team under Article IV of the Fund's Articles of Agreement, NANGO said "'we are opposed to some IMF polices such as privatization of basic social services. We know it from the past that some IMF policies have worked against people in this country. They have affected the social services sector and their polices are anti-people and negative'... [NANGO] said some of the IMF instigated polices which had brought suffering to the people were the Economic Structural Adjustment Programme (ESAP) and Zimbabwe Programme for Economic and Social Transformation (ZIMPREST)." It's a pretty specific critique, and we'll publish the IMF's response upon receipt.

Following up on Inner City Press' questions and article from August 2009, it asked "in Pakistan, the IMF in August extended for a year the country's time to eliminate electricity subsidies. Now, while the IMF says 2 price increases will be implemented, others say this is not possible politically. What is the IMF's thinking on consumer power pricing in Pakistan?"

Ms. Aktinson replied that "as I believe you know, the issue of issue of electric subsidy is typically done by the World Bank and Asian Development Bank," that IMF gets involved due to the budget."we will be having another review of the Pakistan program in early November." We'll be there....

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1ukzimpak102209.html

On UN's Guinea Investigation, Russia Balks At Process and Cost, UN No Answers on China

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1guinea102109.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 21 -- When the UN Security Council held a closed door meeting Wednesday about Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's announcement of a UN international commission of inquiry into the killing and raping of protesters in Guinea, sources tell Inner City Press that Russia raised questions and objections.

By what right, Russia asked, did Ban decide to send such a commission? (We noted, while Russia didn't, that the UN has failed to send any commission to look into a much higher number of deaths this year in Sri Lanka).

When Ban's representative in the Council meeting, Haile Menkerios, came to the stakeout, Inner City Press put to him, on camera, the questions Russia had asked. How was the decision made? How will the commission be paid for? Video here, from Minute 6:09.

Tellingly, Menkerios said that "ECOWAS in its last meeting requested -- we understood from Doctor Chambas that ECOWAS was going to ask... that it would be difficult for them." He went on to say that Ban consulted informally with members of the Security Council.

Inner City Press has been told that French foreign minister Bernard Kouchner was most forceful in demanding a UN commission of inquiry. But it appears that Ban did not sufficiently consult with all of the Permanent Members of the Security Council, in light of Russia's objections on Wednesday.

The rest of Menkerios' answer implied that ECOWAS may send military or security observers, if security is not assured to the commission and to Guineans. Burkina Faso's president will first try to get the security commitments. So, some wonder, would this be a peacekeeping force?

As to why Russia took the position it did in the Guinea consultations, some say Russia would have liked a UN inquiry into Georgia after its attempt to take back South Ossetia by force. Some speculate on other Russian reasons.

On the question of who would pay for the commission, Inner City Press asked France's Ambassador Gerard Araud at the stakeout. As he walked away, he said, "That's one of the questions, we don't know." Video here, at end.

In a similar walk away from a question, when Inner City Press asked Menkerios for the second time about China's multi billion dollars investment with the military leader of Guinea in the midst of the crisis, and whether they was helpful, Menkerios said to "ask Guineans or others." Video here, from Minute 10:39. It appears the UN is reluctant to criticize China.

Footnotes: on this, when Inner City Press asked Ban's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe at Wednesday's noon briefing if he or the UN have any response to the report that at least 43 Uighurs have been disappeared by the government in Xinjiang, Ms. Okabe said she had been told that UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Navi Pillay would be speaking on that later on Wednesday.

But when Inner City Press asked Ms. Pillay, on camera, about the disappeared Uighurs, she said nothing. (On another Inner City Press questions, about the Sri Lankan asylum seekers diverted from Australia to Indonesia, and those in Canada, she let her co-panelists answer, and said nothing as well). Her staffer said a statement on the Uighurs might be provided later on Wednesday. We'll see.

Finally, on how the Guinea commission of inquiry would be paid for, Menkerios said, "This would not be the first commission."
Later, a UN financial official told Inner City Press that the Secretary General has a budget, likened to a slush fund, of $8 million for unforeable expenses related to peace and security. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1guinea102109.html

Thursday, October 22, 2009

On Food Speculation, UN's Expert Says Nothing's Being Done, S. Korean Land Grabs from Madagascar to Sudan, Brazil on Ethanol

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1food102109.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 21 -- After many speeches at the UN about the need to crack down on financial speculation in food, nothing has been done, the UN's expert on the right to food told Inner City Press on Wednesday.

Olivier de Schutter, a Belgian law professor just back from a visit to Brazil about, among other things, the loss of land for food to ethanol, replied that "nothing is moving at the inter-governmental level." This despite a statement by the G-20 in April favoring the regulation of hedge funds which present systemic risk. The argument is that commodities index funds which speculate in food present systemic risk to net food importing countries. But nothing has been done.

De Schutter spoke about the monopolization of the seed industry, and made a slew of recommendations for governments. The three top monopolizers -- Monsanto, Dupont and the Swiss-based Syngenta -- are all members of the UN Global Compact, and claim to comply with human rights. De Schutter pointed out the antitrust law is directed as national and not global or subnational markets. It is all very heady but one wonders what effect it has.

Brazil might be one of de Schutter's claims to impact. He spoke glowingly of President Lula, saying that Brazil has said that only 19% of land can be used for sugar cane for ethanol, and has committed to monitor labor rights. But what about, for example, Indonesia and Malaysia?


After De Schutter's briefing, Inner City Press asked his staffer for an update on the proposed land grab in Madagascar by South Korea based Daewoo, which was reputed after the coup in that country. De Schutter had been scheduled to visit, but it was put off by the coup. The same thing happened in Honduras. So perhaps De Schutter does have an effect after all, mused one wag.

Footnote: immediately after De Schutter's briefing, the UN's Haile Menkerios was scheduled to speak to the Press about Madagascar. While the UN usually compartmentalizes its work such that a rapporteur looks at land grabs, while the Secretariat remains on "political affairs" narrowly defined, this land grab played a role in the change of government. Now it's said the South Korean deal is being pursued from India, while South Korea appears to have moved on to 690,000 hectares in Sudan. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1food102109.html

Still Headless in Darfur, UN Has Sudan and Nigeria Mad, Airlifting to Juba

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unque1sudan102009.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 20 -- As the UN in Sudan warns of rebel and government troops massing in Darfur, and in the South airlifts an opposition figure's fighters from his stronghold to Juba, its Mission faces other troubles as well. The UN's envoy Rodolphe Adada has not yet been replaced. Interviews, Inner City Press is told, will take place the first week in November.

These sources say that the future of Nigeria's peacekeepers in Darfur is not certain. Nigerian Martin Luther Agwai is no longer the UN's Force Commander -- although he's still on the UN payroll -- and U.S. President Barack Obama's decision to visit Ghana and not Nigeria makes the latter less willing to help, including in Darfur. As the U.S. announces a new strategy of carrots, other pieces are not falling into place.

At the UN's noon briefing on Tuesday, Inner City Press asked about the troops massing in Darfur, and the UN Mission in South Sudan's airlift of the fighters of Paulino Matip to Juba. Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe said didn't have an information about either. Inner City Press asked how that could be.

Later in the briefing, a staffer came in and handed Ms. Okabe a sheet of paper. She read out a statement about the UN's concern about troops massing in Darfur. On South Sudan, nothing.

Khartoum sees the SPLA's "harassment" of Matip's fighters as an abuse, now abetted by the UN, both Peacekeeping and Political Affairs. Of the two, they prefer the former. They have particular scorn for the DPA official currently "preparing the ground" in Guinea for a board of inquiry, essentially ordered up by Bernard Kouchner of France, they say. They marvel at how the possible referring of the Goldstone report on Gaza can be kept away from even a vote on referral to the International Criminal Court, while their case got referred. The House of Double Standard, they call the UN. There's double dipping, too. But more on that anon. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unque1sudan102009.html