Thursday, October 22, 2009

Still Headless in Darfur, UN Has Sudan and Nigeria Mad, Airlifting to Juba

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unque1sudan102009.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 20 -- As the UN in Sudan warns of rebel and government troops massing in Darfur, and in the South airlifts an opposition figure's fighters from his stronghold to Juba, its Mission faces other troubles as well. The UN's envoy Rodolphe Adada has not yet been replaced. Interviews, Inner City Press is told, will take place the first week in November.

These sources say that the future of Nigeria's peacekeepers in Darfur is not certain. Nigerian Martin Luther Agwai is no longer the UN's Force Commander -- although he's still on the UN payroll -- and U.S. President Barack Obama's decision to visit Ghana and not Nigeria makes the latter less willing to help, including in Darfur. As the U.S. announces a new strategy of carrots, other pieces are not falling into place.

At the UN's noon briefing on Tuesday, Inner City Press asked about the troops massing in Darfur, and the UN Mission in South Sudan's airlift of the fighters of Paulino Matip to Juba. Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe said didn't have an information about either. Inner City Press asked how that could be.

Later in the briefing, a staffer came in and handed Ms. Okabe a sheet of paper. She read out a statement about the UN's concern about troops massing in Darfur. On South Sudan, nothing.

Khartoum sees the SPLA's "harassment" of Matip's fighters as an abuse, now abetted by the UN, both Peacekeeping and Political Affairs. Of the two, they prefer the former. They have particular scorn for the DPA official currently "preparing the ground" in Guinea for a board of inquiry, essentially ordered up by Bernard Kouchner of France, they say. They marvel at how the possible referring of the Goldstone report on Gaza can be kept away from even a vote on referral to the International Criminal Court, while their case got referred. The House of Double Standard, they call the UN. There's double dipping, too. But more on that anon. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unque1sudan102009.html

Is Sri Lanka Postponing Visit of UN's Caemmart Retaliation? UN Claims Photo-Op Was Disclosure

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/untrip9may5srilanka102009.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 20 -- The Sri Lankan government is already delaying the visit of the UN's Patrick Cammaert, announced a mere week ago as starting in early November. In response to questions from Inner City Press last week, UN Children and Armed Conflict expert Radhika Coomaraswamy disclosed for the first time that the government had agreed to an early November visit by Mr. Cammaert, formerly with the UN Peacekeeping Mission in the Congo.

Yesterday, Inner City Press reported that sources told it the visit would be delayed. Tuesday it was authoritatively and multiply confirmed to Inner City Press, that the government has pushed the date back to November 23 -- a time which currently doesn't work for Mr. Cammaert.

The government's pretext for the delay is that it is moving some of the youths from one camp to another. These moves are of course within the control of the government, and it is not at all clear that the government didn't know about its move last week.

To some, the postponement seems a heavy handed reaction to Ms. Coomaraswamy having said anything publicly about Cammaert's trip. Then again, Inner City Press' sources for yesterday's item now say that the government is dangling the possibility of reinstating Cammaert. It is called trying to control the UN's speech: quite successfully, of late.

Footnote: following yesterday's piece which questioned why Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson did not last week in lengthy noon briefing read-outs mention anything about Ban's meeting with the Sri Lankan minister, the Spokesperson points to the listing of a photo-op between the two. Inner City Press, which had seen that before publishing yesterday's not inconsistent piece, has asked for a copy of Ban's Daily Schedule for October 12, for an on the record answer as to why the Spokesperson's Office does not archive Ban's daily schedule and an explanation of how it is decided which of the S-G's meetings and calls are presented in the initial parts of noon briefings or in writing, and which are only summarized if someone knows to ask. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip9may5srilanka102009.html

UN's Ban Favors "Phantom Polling Stations" Decried by Fired Galbraith in Afghan Runoff

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unama2sideline102009.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 20 -- For the second round of Afghan elections now slated for November 7, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon favors keeping open what were described as "phantom" polling stations by the deputy envoy who Ban fired, Peter Galbraith.

Shortly after Hamid Karzai announced he would accept the second round based on findings of widespread fraud in the first, Ban spoke with the Press outside the UN Security Council chamber in New York. Inner City Press asked him, "What about the phantom polling stations?" Galbraith said that polling stations in areas entirely under the control of the Taliban, where no verification would be possible, should not be open in the first round.

Inner City Press asked Mr. Ban if he thinks these "so-called phantom polling stations" should be open in the second round. Ban, after repeating the phrase, said "I'd like to make it clear... the purpose of the UN is assisting the electoral process last time" was to "ensure all Afghanistan people would be able to express their will by casting votes."

"The idea suggested by Mister Peter Galbraith to reduce the number of polling stations" just to avoid fraud was "not acceptable [under] the core values of democracy," Ban said.

Ban then argued this was why he fired Galbraith, "not about fraud," but on the principle of enfranchisement. While many correspondents after Ban's stake out interview expressed skepticism at this, noting that Galbraith was only fired when he publicly called into question the partiality of Ban's top envoy Kai Eide and thus of Ban himself, at a minimum Ban's statement might be interpreted as, going public with a call to limit the number of polling stations was "not acceptable."

Reasonable minds can disagree about whether polling stations that cannot be effectively monitored help or hurt democracy. Therefore to argue that any questioning of such stations is "not acceptable under the core values of democracy" might seem hyperbolic, or an attempt to spin what some see as another of the UN's firing of whistleblowers or critics.

As possible deals between Karzai and Abdullah Abdullah will be rumored to cancel the November 7 run-off, there is sure to be a debate about, among other things, the wisdom of the so called phantom polling stations. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unama2sideline102009.html

UN's Indigenous Expert Stymied in Russia, Does Not Engage in Myanmar, Will Visit Ecuador

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unhr1anaya101909.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 19 -- Russia blocked the UN's expert on the rights of indigenous people from visiting the site slated for the Evenki dam in Krasnoyarsk Territory, it emerged at the UN on Monday.

Inner City Press asked James Anaya, the UN's Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights and fundamental freedom of indigenous people, if he had in fact been allowed to visit the site. The Russian press had quoted Igor Kurtushin, deputy head of the territorial administration’s department for external relations that "it would not be easy to visit the Evenki sites due to peculiar weather patterns."

Inner City Press asked if Anaya had visit the contested site, from which indigenous people would be evicted. No, he said, it wasn't in the agenda we were able to negotiate. Video here, from Minute 30:53.

Was this, in fact, due to the weather, Inner City Press followed up. "The weather was good was I was there," Anaya answered, describing two flights in Krasnoyarsk and an outdoor meal of reindeer parts. Video here, from Minute 36:29.

This can be contrasted to Panama, where the government allowed Anaya to visit the site of a proposed dam. When Inner City Press asked about Ecuador and conflicts there, Anaya said he is going in December, invited by the government.

To some, Anaya seems too accommodating of governments. When Inner City Press asked about Canada's refusal to sign on to the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People, Anaya said Canada is moving in the right direction, that he doesn't criticize countries if there is the "possibility" of movement.

Likewise, when Inner City Press asked about the position of Botswana that nearly all people there are indigenous, Anaya responded that he hadn't seen a need to contest this position during his recent visit there. Given that the position almost derailed the Declaration, it seems strange to some to be so accommodative of it now.


But it is to and within the UN system that Anaya is most accommodative. Inner City Press asked about the UN's REDD program, which was protested earlier this month. Anaya said that the UN agencies want to address indigenous issues. When Inner City Press asked about indigenous people in Myanmar, Anaya responded that since there is another rapporteur on Myanmar, he does not engage in Myanmar. Video here, from Minute 49:22.

First, this deference is not required: for example, the UN's expert on children and armed conflict engages with Myanmar, rather than deferring. Particularly given the issues that have arisen about the UN's special rapporteur on Myanmar, for Anaya to say he'll do nothing in or about the country ill-served indigenous people. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhr1anaya101909.html

As France is Asked about Evictions in Calais and Chad, UN Cuts Off Questions, Jumps for Kouchner

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1poorfrance101909.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 19 -- In his first media availability at the UN, new French Ambassador Gerard Araud marked the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty with a press conference on October 19.

Inner City Press asked Ambassador Araud about his country's eviction of immigrants from a camp near Calais last month, about the drowning of residents of the Comoros trying to get to the French island of Mayotte, and about mass evictions in the capital of Chad, where the Idriss Deby government receives substantial French support. Video here, from Minute 25:32.

Ambassador Araud said immigration is an issues throughout the developed world, quickly equating the drowning of those seeking to get to Mayotte with deaths of African in the Mediterranean.

He said that the "dismantling" of the camp was because immigration should be restricted to that which is legal, so that Europeans don't "become violent." He said it was fair to be critical, he has seen such criticism of U.S. policies as well, but these countries are democracies.

Araud said that "answering about Chad is the easiest," and then proceeded to say that his Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner, the moment he got the post, took in the lead is setting up peacekeeping mission in Eastern Chad, first through the European Union and then the UN.

A follow-up question was cut off by the UN's moderator, Rachel Mayanja. She said, "before we proceed... I am surprised none of you want to take advantage" of the boy on the panel, from Dominica, to "expose his journey." Video here, from Minute 31:55. But she had begun by saying that the youth would be accompanied by a chaperrone from ChildFund Caribbean, who was not on the podium.

After a more compliant correspondent dutifully asked the boy about photography -- ChildFund saved him from being a criminal, he equally dutifully said -- Inner City Press asked Ambassador Araud about the evictions done by French ally Idriss Deby, did he have any answer? He shook his head no. And the press conference was over. Video here, from Minute 34:49.

Afterwards, one of the French journalists opined that Ms. Mayanja may have been trying to protect or please France, a Permanent Five member of the Security Council, by shifting from questions about France's record to what she wanted journalists to ask and write about. This has become more prevalent at the UN.

We note that Ms. Mayanja's cutting off of questions cannot necessarily be ascribed to Araud. The UN may offer protection where none is even requested. If Ms. Mayanja wanted to play up the boy's story, why have him appear at the French Ambassador's first press conference?

Another reporter told Inner City Press that Bernard Kouchner called Ban Ki-moon recently and told him the UN should launch an investigation of the recent killing of some 150 protesters in Guinea Conakry. Ban did just that; when Inner City Press asked, his spokesman said that it was at the request of ECOWAS. But why didn't the UN launch any inquiry into the tens of thousands of civilians killed in Sri Lanka earlier this year?

Just as the UN on Monday sought to limit questions to the right kind of poverty, it will only investigate the killings of the right victims: it all depends on who the perpetrator is, and who provides protection.

Footnote: also on the Chad evictions, Inner City Press asked this question last week to Habitat's New York representative, and for an update on what if anything Habitat did to follow up on supposed commitments by Angola not to continue evictions. Video here. A response was promised, but has not been received. What was that again, about eradicating poverty?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1poorfrance101909.html

Saturday, October 17, 2009

At UN, Vietnam Is Asked About Beaten Monks, Says No Grounds To Bring It Up

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1monksviet101609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 16 -- Nearly three weeks after some 400 Buddhist monks in Vietnam were evicted and beaten, and Vietnam took over the Presidency of the UN Security Council, on October 16 Inner City Press asked Vietnam's Ambassador and Council President Le Luong Minh about the incident. Video here, from Minute 3:09.

Ambassador Le Luong Minh at first look puzzled, then smirked. Inner City Press explained the "hook" to the Security Council, a report that "supporters are also asking the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations to help them arrange a meeting with Vietnam's U.N. ambassador."

While U.S. Ambassador to the UN Susan Rice was present in the Council on Friday, when Inner City Press asked if the matter had been raised, Le Luong Minh said "no one has raised it, and there are no grounds for anyone to raise it."

When monks, admittedly a larger number, were cracked down on in Myanmar, the matter was quickly raised in the Security Council, and Myanmar is now on the Council's agenda. There are other less than reasonable exclusions from the Council's agenda, such as the tens of thousands of ethnic Tamils killed in Sri Lanka earlier this year. But when events like this take place in a country holding the presidency of the UN Security Council, it should not be surprising that they are raised.

Only this week, five countries ran for and won seats of the Security Council. When Inner City Press asked Brazil's Ambassador if she envisioned bringing up Honduras in the Council when she joins it in January, if it is still needed, she referred only to "regional organizations."

When Inner City Press asked Nigeria's foreign minister if Nigeria would like to bring up Guinea in the Council, he also referred to regional organizations. When Ban Ki-moon on October 16 announced a UN inquiry into the killings and rapes in Guinea, Inner City Press asked his spokesperson if the inquiry had the consent of the government, as the UN implied would be necessary in Sri Lanka. His spokesperson replied that a regional organization had asked for the Guinea inquiry.

ASEAN's inward gaze condemn many victims to suffer in silence. While often the Council accomplishes little for those on its agenda, it does let a government know it is being watched. In the case of Vietnam, the response was just a smirk. And so it goes at the UN.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1monksviet101609.html

At UN, Americas Videos and U.S. Soldiers, Trooping Off to High Schools and a Moving Speech

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/undpi1comms101609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 16 -- To many the UN seems stand-offish, not connected with its host city New York, viewing the Internet as a one-way medium for propaganda. On Friday the UN announced that in the coming week, ten of its top officials will go speak in New York schools. It announced the five winners of its YouTube competition for videos addressing world leaders. And Secretary General Ban Ki-moon spoke to student, at the UN's own school, and said he'd like to move his office there, the applause was so loud.

Even in this there was criticism. A commenter on the UN's YouTube channel page wrote

"TO UN: I can't understand why all the winners are from North, South of America. Do yo think that's fair? How about other continents such as Africa, Asia? Sorry but I am totally disappointed about this judgment. It's not about me, but If you had any winners from any dictator countries, It would encourage people of these countries to have better feeling that they can spread their voice through the world."

At a press conference announcing the winners, Inner City Press read out the above and asked for the UN's response. Eric Falt of the UN's Outreach Division replied that he didn't disagree -- in naming the Canadian winner, he'd said the person lives in Tokyo -- and later provided these criteria:

• How relevant is it to the challenge: “how do we make this world a better, safer place”?

• How creative is the entry in form and content?

• Do you feel the entry merits attention from “world leaders”?

• Bonus points for aesthetic value and originality

Each was worth a maximum of five points.

Inner City Press asked if, unlike in some UN hiring, geographic balance played no part. Falt subsequently answered that "We were certainly hoping for geographic balance and hope that, next year, with more advance publicity through our network of UN Information Centers and perhaps peacekeeping operations, we can have more videos from more countries and therefore a better balance at the end."

Meanwhile, Inner City Press was among the only UN correspondents of any kind covering Ban Ki-moon's "Stand Up Against Poverty" speech at the UN International School on Friday morning. The head of the Department of Public Information Kiyotaka Akasaka was waiting in the school for Mr. Ban, along with Ban's speechwriting Michael Meyer. Ban arrived in a black luxury car, trailed by a 4 by 4 of security. Ban stopped and greeted the Press, then proceeded up to a second story auditorium. The students burst into applause. Ban said it was nice to start the day this way.


He spoke, barely looking at notes, about how lucky the students were to be able to go to school, to be in the greenhouse of primary school and then college's ivory tower. But then you must face the world, he said. He led the students in a pledge about poverty. It was not unmoving.

Four of Ban's Under Secretaries General, and six Assistant Secretaries General, will speak in schools next week:

Top lawyer Patricia O'Brien and investigator Inga-Britt Ahlenius, both of whom rarely speak to the press, will speak in Brooklyn and Manhattan, respectively. Ibrahim Gambari, arriving one imagines on Metro North from Westchester, will speak in Manhattan. Sergio Duarte will speak in The Bronx.

Among ASGs, Controller Jun Yamazaki will speak in Brooklyn, as will Warren Sach. Manhattan gets Franz Baumann and Peter Taksoe-Jensen. The Bronx claims Capital Master Planner Michael Adlerstein and Thomas Stelzer. All told, 44 schools in all five borough will have UN staff speaking. Outside of New York, children and armed conflict expert Radhika Coomaraswamy will be speaking in Kansas City, albeit at the university along with Newt Gingrich and others.

Inner City Press asked Mr. Akasaka where he would be speaking. He will be in Kuala Lumpur. What about the peacekeepers, or Political Affairs' Lynn Pascoe? Or Angela Kane who will, it's said, appear for a press conference next week?

Another Friday event at the UN about communication was an informal briefing to twenty some U.S. military personnel on their way to be spokespeople in Iraq. A representative of the U.S. mission spoke -- it is not entirely clear how the event was set up, or if all member states could do it -- along with invited journalists including Inner City Press. The questions ranged from how to deal with "bloggers" -- which the UN staffer directed to Inner City Press, while saying that the UN does not accredit bloggers, only online media -- to how to make friends with "the Arab press."

The answers involved occupation and Guantanamo Bay. Inner City Press advised the prospective spokespeople to, unlike some in the UN, actually provide answers to questions. Just another day at the UN, trying to avoid what Israel called the Goldstone report on Gaza, a tale of sound and fury -- told by an idiot -- signifying nothing.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undpi1comms101609.html

UN in Congo Accused of Whoring and Working with War Criminals, Doss Blames Victim's Family, Cites Due Process

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/drc2doss101609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 16 -- The UN's Mission in the Congo, MONUC, faces accusations from its host and a rapporteur. The UN's expert on summary executions Philip Alston in a October 15 report detailed, among other things, that a unit of the Congolese army in Shalio killed 50 refugees and raped 40 women.

Inner City Press on October 16 asked MONUC chief Alan Doss about the unit and its commander, Colonel Zimulinda, who is still serving with the Congolese Army with which MONUC works. Doss replied that there is an investigation, as he did about charges about his own scandals, click here for Inner City Press' other story on this today.

The Congolese Ambassador Ileka Atoki told the Security Council that on July 31 - August 1, UN blue helmets under Doss' command engaged in "sexual deviance," turning a spot near Congo's N'djili International Airport into a "baisodrome."

This was chastely translated as brothel, but the connotation is larger. He asked the Council and Inner City Press asked UN Spokesperson Michele Montas, what about the UN's vaunted 2005 "zero tolerance" policy on sexual abuse and exploitation​?

While on his own scandals Doss simply refused to comment, on this he blamed the victim, or the victim's family, saying that her brother asked for money. In the United States, a civil suit or request for a settlement does not prove that the underlying wrong did not occur, not does it absolve the UN under its own rules and proclamations. We will await the UN Secretariat's response, which was requested.

Doss said in the Council and to the Press that in the right circumstance his MONUC would withdraw support from Congolese Army units engaged in abuse. But he has never done so. Alston's report contains other abusive FARDC commanders' names: Sultani Makenga, Bernard Byamungu and Salumu Mulenda . What if anything will Doss do? Watch this site.

Admittedly, MONUC's job is not easy. But of late even some of Doss' supporters have begun to voice more loudly that he may not be the right official for the job.

Now Doss' deputy Ross Mountain is leaving, as talks about the future of MONUC have begun, in Washington. Perhaps a fresh beginning in both posts would work best.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc2doss101609.html

UN's Congo Chief Doss Won't Explain Nepotism E-mail, Dodges Cook as Engineer Question

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/doss5boot101609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 16 -- The UN's envoy to the Congo Alan Doss declined comment Friday on his leaked e-mail asking that the UN Development Program show him "leeway" and give a job to his daughter, and on allegations by UN staff in the Congo that he brought his cook from his previous assignment in Liberia to Kinshasa as a UN engineer.

The nepotism scandal broken in July, when Inner City Press obtained and published the e-mail which openly asked that the UN's rules be bent or broken to hire Doss' daugther Rebecca. Click here for that.

Friday in front of the Security Council, after relegating questions about his own conduct to the tail end of a stakeout question and answer session with the Press -- we follow his logic and will report on the Lord's Resistance Army and Kivus elsewhere -- Doss claimed that the e-mail line was taken out of context. But Inner City Press published the entire email.

Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, those his deputy spokesperson, said he was concerned and expected to receive a report, when he returned to New York. That was two months ago. Now Doss says he won't comment until the report, half down by UNDP itself, is finished. Thus it is at the UN, several observers have opined, there is no accountability, internal investigations are just a way to bury problems.

Similarly, when Inner City Press asked Doss about the letter by the head of the MONUC national staff union in the Congo to Ban Ki-moon about problems at MONUC, including his being barred from MONUC premises and threats against his life, all Doss responded was, that too is under investigation. There is a pattern here.

Doss' answer on the allegation, by UN staff in the Congo, that he brought his cook from Liberia to the Congo was that he didn't bring anyone from Liberia "under false pretenses." But what does this mean? That he told someone, even sotto voce, that this was a cook?

Inner City Press asked the UN to confirm or deny this more than two weeks ago. A spokesperson for the Department of Peacekeeping Operations told Inner City Press she sought a response from Doss' MONUC office, repeatedly, but couldn't get one. Friday at the stakeout Doss asserted that MONUC had in fact answered: he did not bring anyone under false pretenses. What does that mean? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/doss5boot101609.html

At UN, Serbia on Churches Paved Over, Kosovo Calls World Court Merely Advisory

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/icj1kosovo101509.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 15 -- Even in the run up to the International Court of Justice's proceeding on the legality of Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence, at the UN Security Council the issue has lost its juice. As the Council on Thursday debated whether or not to let Kosovo speak, the stakeout outside was as empty as for Nepal. When the principals emerged, only the Kosovar spoke. Lamberto Zannier, who cashes checks at the UN's envoy to Kosovo, did not speak to the Press.

Vuk Jeremic, when he emerged, walked slowly by the stakeout. There was no other reporter waiting other than Inner City Press. Further up the hall he graciously stopped and answered three questions. Inner City Press asked, what can the ICJ case actually change, on the ground?

Jeremic said it's the biggest ICJ case in history, with 31 countries participating including each of the Council's Permanent Five member. What about cultural damage? Jeremic spoke of a church demolished, paved over and turned into a park. It must be reversed, he said.

Zannier in his testimony complained that until the eve of his flight to the Council in New York, the Kosovo authorities refused to meet with him. Jeremic afterwards told Inner City Press the meeting only took place between the Kosovars were embarrassed. But what is the future of UNMIK?

Inner City Press asked Kosovo's representative if he wants the UN to leave. He spoke highly of the EU and EULEX. And that may say it all.

Footnote: that Kosovo even spoke, inside the chamber, may create a precedent. Others wondered by South Ossetia and Abkhazia can't do it. The answer is the power of the U.S. as host country. They have to let in representatives of any member state. But on the cusp states like Kosovo and Abkhazia, they are not required and can choose. Some power.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/icj1kosovo101509.html

UN Assembly President Treki Hires Daughter and Cousin, For Family Values

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/untreki1office101409.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 14 -- While the occupant of the Office of the President of the UN General Assembly changes each year, the same cannot be said for practices like nepotism and lack of transparency. Under the previous President, Nicaragua's Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, Inner City Press found and reported the hiring of two of his relatives, nephew Michael Clark and niece Sofia Clark, in the Office.

Now, new President Ali Treki of Libya lists on the web site of his Cabinet a relative named Ali Mohamed Treki. When Inner City Press asked the Office's spokesman and chief of staff for the precise familial relation, the talk got vague and went off the record.

Then Inner City Press discovered that Ali Treki's daughter Amal Ali Treki is working in the Office, and got this confirmed by Treki's thus far fair spokesman Jean-Victor Nkolo. Several other questions remain outstanding; the responses will be reported upon receipt.

The post of President of the General Assembly is the highest, at least technically, in the UN system. But it is run like a family business.

Inner City Press has also asked by whom and how much President Treki gets paid. This seems like a basic and fair question, but it has yet to be answered. It has been implied that Inner City Press should assume that Treki is paid by his government, Libya, but it has also been argued that he is and will be independent from Libya and its leader, Colonel Gaddafi. Which is it?

Two presidencies ago, Srgjan Kerim left unanswered who paid him -- a private company called WAZ Media -- and how much (reputed at $400,000). Inner City Press was asked, how many should Treki be paid, without being told by whom.

Treki has been embroiled in controversies, some by choice and some by happenstance. He did not write Gaddafi's disjointed General Debate speech: perhaps no one did. And continued reporting by Inner City Press about the Assembly's overruling of Treki's decision to give the floor to Madagascar's coup leader find that Treki was misled, to some degree, by those who called the question and the vote.

But Treki's decision on September 18 to answer a stray question about gay rights by calling homosexuality "not acceptable," not only by him but by "two billion Muslims and... Buddists and Jews," was his own choice. Inner City Press reported the comments, then asked Treki about the resulting condemnation by Congressman Barney Frank and counterparts of his in the UK and Australia. Treki stood by his comments, which Inner City Press understand that many of his own staff counseled him against.

To his credit, Treki has attracted some savvy UN staffers, using the professional level UN-paid posts available to him. His chief of staff Jamal Benomar, an expert on the rule of law, has his work cut out for him. His economic adviser Yasser Elnaggar has been around the UN block. Some say that Treki's daughter is among his best staff members. That's what every small businessman says...

Footnote: Inner City Press held publication of this article for several days seeking additional answers and comments from PGA Treki's office. If and when these are received, they will be published in future articles on Dr. Treki, his Office and the General Assembly.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untreki1office101409.html

At UN, Study of Organ Harvest in "Asian Country," China Not Named, Encouraged

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/un1organs101309.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 13 -- The UN launched a report on the trafficking of organs on Tuesday, but declined to name the countries which most allow for this grisly trade. At a press conference about the report, by the UN and Council of Europe, Inner City Press asked the authors about this line from page 59 of the report:

"There is a well known example of an Asian country where organs from executed prisoners have allegedly been used for the majority of the transplants performed in the country."

Inner City Press asked, "Is this China? And if so, why did you decided not to name names?" Video here, from Minute 27:56.

For the panel, the answer came from co-author Arthur Caplan, Director of the Center for Bioethics at U Penn. He nodded when the name China was mentioned, then said, "we could only rely on the media." He said "situations are changing... attempts at change in China and other countries are underway and we want to encourage that."

But isn't refusing to name the country engaged in organ harvesting after executions going a bit far, in terms of encouraging better behavior? Maybe the reticence to name names only encourages the abuse.


Inner City Press asked the authors to distinguish the sale of organs, which they oppose, with the sale of eggs and surrogate motherhood. Video here, from Minute 30:01.

Caplan and UN representative Rachel Mayanja both said that better definitions are needed. Mayanja, the Special Adviser to Ban Ki-moon on Gender Issues and Advancement of Women, had earlier said that she hadn't been sure, in co-sponsoring the study, if women are disproportionately impacted by organ trafficking. Eggs sales and surrogate motherhood, they obviously are. Should we exchange another study? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1organs101309.html

UNDP Reports on Clark's Kiwi Concerns, Doss Probe In Limbo, Ryan on Sri Lanka

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/undp2hclark101509.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 15 -- The no longer so new Administrator of the UN Development Program, Helen Clark of New Zealand, has still not done a UN press conference. On Thursday one of her duputies, Jordan Ryan of the Bureau for Crisis Prevention and Recovery, was announced as the guest at the noon briefing, with no topic listed. [Inner City Press previously covered Ryan's work in Vietnam, click here.]

Once Ryan arrived on Thursday, the scope of the briefing was limited to UNDP's work in Tonga and Samoa. Inner City Press asked if this had anything to do with the interest of Helen Clark's native New Zealand in these two. Why not a briefing on the Philippines and Indonesia? Mr. Ryan did not directly answer. He described three big waves.

Since UNDP never comes to the UN briefing room anymore, Inner City Press asked Mr. Ryan a few outstanding UNDP questions. Is it true that UNDP was the agency charged with relocating the World Food Program in Islamabad to a common premises in the diplomatic zone, before the recent bombing? When will UNDP's internal investigation of Alan Doss' written request that he be shown "leeway" -- that rules be broken -- and a UNDP job given to his daughter? Ryan said there is an investigation. But it's been months.

As the moderator tried to cut off questions, Inner City Press returned Tonga and Samoa -- how much notice was given? half an hour -- then Guinea and Sri Lanka. Ryan, who has visited Sri Lanka, talked about building housing. Inner City Press asked about the view of some Tamils that the rehousing may involve changing the ethnic make up in Northern Sri Lanka. Video here.

Ryan said that not what he saw during his visit, but acknowledged that in some cases in Sri Lanka, people are moved to places other than where they came from. This could be done in the name of safety. But it could having intentions and / or effects.

Afterwards, several other UN correspondents marveled that Helen Clark, the UN system's third highest officials, has yet to come do a press conference at the UN. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp2hclark101509.html

New on UN Council, Nigeria and Brazil Not Keen to Use It, Lebanon Won't Recuse

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/ungasc1elections101509.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 15 -- In five uncontested elections, the UN General Assembly put five countries on the Security Council for the next two years: Nigeria, Lebanon, Brazil, Bosnia and Gabon. Inner City Press asked the Foreign Minister of Nigeria Chief Ojo Maduekwe if his country would use the seat to address problems like the killing and raping of protesters of the coup leader in Guinea Conakry.

He responded indirectly, speaking of an ECOWAS meeting being convened in Nigeria. Video here. So, Nigeria would not use the Security Council.

Inner City Press asked the Ambassador of Brazil Maria Luiza Ribeiro Viotti if she would like to use the Council on the problems on Honduras, if they remain in January. She referred to regional solutions. Video here. So, like Nigeria, would not use the Council. Gabon did not even come to the stake out.

Lebanon is a country that is on the agenda of the Council. But its Ambassador Nawaf Salam refuse to answer any questions on Thursday, saying there would be two years to do so.


Inner City Press asked Sudan's Ambassador, representing the Arab Group, if Lebanon would recuse itself from votes and consultations on UNIFIL and Resolution 1701. No, he responded, adding that the Permanent Five are involved in nearly every agenda item, and yet they still vote.

After the stakeout was taken down, Inner City Press ran to the noon briefing and asked the General Assembly spokesman what rules or precedents apply to member states on the Council being on the agenda, and voting on their items. The election is over, he replied, your question may be moot. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ungasc1elections101509.html