Wednesday, May 27, 2009

UN's Holmes Expected His Comments on Tamils Would Not Be Reported, Access Conditioned on Air-Brushed Coverage?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/sri1holmes052309.html

UN PLANE / COPENHAGEN, May 24, modified May 26 at NGO request -- Nearing the end of UN Secretery General's Ban Ki-moon's 16 hour tour of Sri Lanka, during which twenty reporters were carted in two military helicopters from Colombo to UN-funded interment camps then over the shattered No Fire Zone, a question that arises is why does the UN take the Press with it?

While it should be so that the UN's work and world problems can be covered, some UN officials apparently feel its a quid pro quo for propaganda. Only what they say that casts them in a heroic light should be reported. If they do not like a story, they can shoot the messenger or try.

So it appears to some to be with John Holmes, the UN's erstwhile humanitarian coordinator. On the UN plane from Frankfurt to Sri Lanka, after Ban Ki-moon tpld the Press that Holmes and his Department of Political Affairs chief Lynn Pascoe would brief, clearly on the record, Holmes came back to chat with a photographer. Reporters gathered around and began some Q & A. At no point did Holmes say that it was off the record.

In fact, when Inner City Press asked him about UN envoy Vijay Nambiar's brother having written an op-ed praising Sri Lanka's assault on the Tamil north and the general who led it, Holmes said no comment. This strongly implies that answers that are given are on the record.

Holmes proceeded to make a series of statements that were telling and newsworthy. He expressed his view that Tamils in Sri Lanka long ago became disillusioned with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam. He said the LTTE or Tamil Tigers were "only supported by the diaspora," whose members barrage him with "a lot of email, I just delete them anyway."

Imagine for a moment a UN humanitarian coordinator saying, Rwanda's Tutsis besiege me with emails so I just delete them.

Imagine this said in front of at least a half dozen journalists. Several or all of them would report it. But Holmes appeared to count on the reporters on the trip to Sri Lanka all sharing his view, about what a burden it is to receive e-mails from members of a group that feels itself under fire.

Along with four other stories, none of which drew open complaint from any other UN official, Inner City Press ran a short piece about Holmes' comments, uploaded well past midnight from the UN-chosen hotel in Colombo. The comment above seemed newsworthy and reflective of an attitude wider-shared in the Secretariat. Holmes is thought to be among the more articulate officials of this UN, often saying things that others in the Ban administration cannot or will not.

Inner City Press chose to leave unreported Holmes' comments about Mahinda Rajapaksa and his Ambassador to the UN, and other comments about the Tamil diaspora. (Click here for Inner City Press' coverage of Holmes first 2009 visit to Sri Lanka)

The next morning in the hotel lobby, another reporter told Inner City Press that Holmes was angry that what he had said had been published, and was expressing this anger to all and sundry, including other journalists whom he correctly thought would do his bidding. While Holmes never said "on background" -- a term of art in journalist and at the UN which Holmes has used in the past -- Inner City Press nevertheless immediately that morning modified the story, excising the part about Holmes deleting Tamils' emails and other things he said. Click here the modified story; the original was replaced on InnerCityPress.com on Saturday before the UN trip to north Sri Lanka.

Hours later, after a Ban Ki-moon speech in an open air World Food Program warehouse in the Manik Farm interment camp for Tamils which the UN funds, Inner City Press approached Holmes with at least some contrition to tell him that the story had been changed. "I won't talk to you anymore," Holmes said preemtively.

"But you never said 'on background'" --

"It wasn't even on background," Holmes said. "It was a casual conversation. It is not serious, it is not professional." Then Holmes walked away, to be flown over the blasted "No Fire" zone where he had already said that no people remained.

Not only was Holmes speaking to the Press on the UN plane just after Ban said Pascoe and Holmes would brief on the record in his stead, Holmes also was or should have been on notice of the Press' understanding when, for example, Inner City Press asked for comment on a UNHCR staff member still jailed by the Sri Lankan government for his mother have rented a room to an alleged LTTE member. (Click here for the story, which Inner City Press told Holmes had been uploaded from the Frankfurt airport while waiting for the UN plane. A UNHCR official approached Inner City Press in Colombo with an answer, but following Holmes, who knows for now if it is on the record.)

Holmes said he hadn't previously heard of the the humanitarian UN system staffer's case -- typical -- but that "if the facts are as you say." Such legalistic constructions, and Holmes' "no comment" to the question about Satish Nambiar, implied that what Holmes said was on the record.

In any event, different understandings of whether a comment is on the record or not are common, particularly at the UN, where almost always a perfunctory apology resolves the matter, and nearly invariably a modification of the underlying articles does. Why is Holmes or this Tamil topic, or Holmes and this Tamil topic, so different?

Inner City Press came to Sri Lanka to cover the recent slew of deaths and the inhuman UN-funded interment camps, not Holmes. In fact, it was advertised as a trip by Ban Ki-moon, with no mention of Holmes. One can cover humanitarian issues without any discretionary access to the emergency relief coordinator.

In public record press conferences, Inner City Press has in the past asked Holmes about such issues as OCHA losing $10 million to Myanmar's Than Shwe regime (and Zimbabwe) due to currency exchange manipulations and OCHA not advocating, at least publicly, for UN system humanitarian staff detained and arrested by the Sri Lankan government. Perhaps Holmes' advocacy on these issues was... off the record. Watch this site.

Footnote: the symbiosis between media and UN was shown again during the flight from Colombo. At first it was said that Ban would brief the gaggle of reporters during the refueling stop in Bahrain. Holmes came half way back and stood in the aisle. On the record? Off the record?

To ensure that Holmes' sensitivities wouldn't leave other reporters with fewer quotes, which is the coin of this realm, Inner City Press stayed in the back of the plane, awaiting Ban's appearance to ask about the status of the doctors who in the conflict zone had offered treatment and casualty numbers and are now detained, which Holmes said -- on the record? -- would be raised.

But Team Ban, apparently, went another way, summoning a few reporters for one on one interviews for their local markets. Such access can better be linked to positive coverage, they seem to feel.

For Holmes, most symbiotic is the British media, one outlet of which was heard musing earlier this month, Holmes says he'd like to come on at 1:15, but do we have any questions for him? Holmes is known to be closely following the British Parliament scandals.

While some in humanitarian circles say that ever since when at the UK government's nomination Holmes entered the UN's Ban administration he really wanted the Department of Political Affairs job, that might explain not only his comments assessing Tamil support for the LTTE in a way a humanitarian coordinator shouldn't but also his sensitivity to actual reporting of what he said without having uttered the required "off the record" or "background." Or, they wonder, does Holmes still have his eye on a future in the UK?

While he is at the UN, at least in the top humanitarian post, he shouldn't tell different stories to NGOs and the press, or if he does, he shouldn't be surprised it gets reported. The focus here is, after all, the protection of civilians, not politics.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/sri1holmes052309.html

As UN's Ban Leaves Sri Lanka, Questions Unanswered, Complicity in War Crimes?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may5srilanka052409.html

ABOARD UN PLANE, May 24 -- After Sri Lanka tried to compare the blown out "No Fire" zone with its barbed wire ringed interment camps for Tamils, and the UN's Ban Ki-moon offered praise and help, many troubling questions remained as the UN plane left Colombo. Is the UN assisting in war crimes?

At the canned press conference in Kandy, after meeting with Rajapaksa brothers who wear red sashes like blood across their chests, Ban's speech said "the Government is doing its utmost, I commend its tremendous efforts."

In the cut-off Q & A session, Ban took back what little criticism the UN had made of the killing of civilians, calling it a bloodbath. "I myself did not mention that the particular word, I want to make that quite clear," he said.

The Press was whisked by minibus from Kandy to the airport. (Inner City Press had asked for an extension of the two day visa given to cover Ban Ki-moon; it was never granted.) Along the route were hundreds of cult-like posters of Mahinda Rajapaksa. Everywhere there flapped Colombo's sword-wielding lion flag, as Tamil children in the Manik Farm IDP camp had been required to hold, along with UN flags while they sang an eerie song about Ban Ki-moon.

Imagine if Serbia had re-taken Kosovo, and invited the UN Secretary General to the retaken Pristina where it made Kosovar children save the Serbian flag.

At the airport the government had arranged another red carpet flanked by white-clad soldiers with machine guns with bayonets leading to the UN plane. Ban Ki-moon was late, having stopped with his entourage for a final dinner with the Rajapaska's.

Inner City Press paced the tarmac, threw questions at entourage members as they belated ran to the plane. The communications director said it could be a while, he would go to the plane to sleep. Vijay Nambiar's colleague confirmed that, yes, Nambiar would be leaving with the UN plane, his week-long clean up job complete. When finally he boarded, Inner City Press joked, welcome back. I haven't been on the UN plane in a while, Nambiar said with a smile.

Inner City Pres went to the front of the VIP terminal, where Sri Lankan functionaries waited with umbrellas in case the skies opened. A UN staffer said it might be a while, Ban was in the terminal doing interviews. When finally he emerged and saw Inner City Press, camera in hand, he asked, "Are you coming back with us?" Yes was the answer, due to denied visa extension, no help from UN.

Sri Lanka's Ambassador to the UN stopped and asked if Inner City Press had been "able to talk to people." To some degree, yes -- for example, the Sri Lankan civil society member whose application to teach reconciliation in Vavuniya and Mannar has not been acted on. In the camps, the Press could speak to some of those interred, both only under the watchful eye of armed soldiers and other government minders. Some reporters even concluded that it was the UN, more than the Sri Lankan authorities, which tried to dissuade approaches to those behind the barbed wire.

On the plane, just before takeoff from Colombo, Ban stopped and spoke to the assembled Press about the suicide of his former boss in Korea, about the letter and white flowers that he sent. Inner City Press listened -- South Korea in those days was cutting edge in interactive media -- and then asked Mr. Ban, "Did you hear anything about the three doctors?" Ban stopped. Oh yes, I did, he said. I think they will address this issue.

But what about answering the questions: Why doesn't his Joint Statement with the government mention the interred doctors, or press freedom, or even the blocked NGO access to the camps? In an Orwellian construction, it has that "The Government will continue to provide access to humanitarian agencies." Why didn't Ban meet with any in the Tamil opposition or civil society? This UN is prejudiced toward governments, even when some say they turn genocidal. And Ban's UN so desperately wants to be relevant that regimes like Rajapaksa's can call Ban's bluff again and again.

During the flight from Colombo, at first it was said that Ban would brief the gaggle of reporters during the refueling stop in Bahrain. With the lights on and the engines off, a group assembled. But Team Ban, apparently, went another way, summoning a few reporters for one on one interviews for their local markets. Such access can better be linked to positive coverage, they seem to feel. Inner City Press was told that a Ban briefing when the plane lands in Copenhagen is not possible, as Ban has to run straight to a conference, late because of his dinner with the Rajapaksas, on which he took no Press questions. We'll have more on this.

The Rajapaksa regime, fresh from shelling and killed thousands of Tamils, used Ban Ki-moon's visit as propaganda. And Ban did not protest. As was as if, as one observer fearing death told Inner City Press, Ban's UN is so desperate to be able to say that a country wants it, "even a regime with blood on its hands," that it allows the UN "to be turned into a joke."

But perhaps today's UN system is often such a mirthless joke, speeding around what dictatorships still exist in white UNDP four by fours, sucking up to governments and excusing their massacres, even offering to clean up the death sites.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may5srilanka052409.html

UN's Ban in Kandy, Never Called It a Bloodbath, No Word on the Doctors

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may4srilanka052309.html

KANDY, May 23 -- At dusk after a fly-over the blasted No Fire Zone which many saw as ghoulish, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon went to meet Sri Lankan President Mahinda Rajapaksa at his palatial home in Kandy. The security was tight -- the cellphones of the Press were confiscated for the duration -- and all three Rajapaksa brothers were there: beyond the President, his senior advisor Basil and the Defense Secretary. Also present were the country's former and current ambassadors to the UN, and the Foreign Secretary, formerly head of the UN Treaty Division. On a side table in the ceremonial front room was a picture including the President with George and Laura Bush.

Ban Ki-moon arrived with the Foreign Minister, and took a seat as the photographers' flashes lit up the room, complete with ivory tusks and a wood carving of Mahinda. As the photograph surged to catch the handshake, Ban's humanitarian chief John Holmes reached across the frame to shake other Sri Lankan hands. "Sit down," more than one photographer hissed.

Ban chatted about his visit to the camps while the President smiled broadly. Then the photographers were hustled out into the front yard, with an enormous tree and a flock of Mercedes Benz. Soldiers with machines guns jaunted around and the cell phones were returned. The reason for Ban's delayed arrival was not explained. Earlier on Saturday, a UN official told Inner City Press that Ban had been pressured to visit Kandy's famous Buddhist relic temple. Had Ban given in, one reporter wondered? Why had Kandy been the venue?

Nearly an hour later, Ban and the Foreign Minister appeared together again, though briefly at a press conference in Kandy's Queen's Hotel. In the sweltering room, Inner City Press commisserated with Elmo Alles of the National Peace Council of Sri Lanka. He explained that his group applied two weeks ago for permission to go to Vavuniya and Mannar to train NGO workers in reconciliation. So far there has been no response. The group has been told that everything must go through the Defense Ministry.

Elmo Alles would have asked, he told Inner City Press, if there is any international monitoring of the conditions of the IDP camps. If the question had been allowed, the answer would surely have been vague. Before the sound system sputtered and brought the proceedings to a close, Ban went out of his way to emphasize that he never called Sri Lanka a blood bath. Inner City Press' questions, including about the detained doctors, were not taken or allowed. And then the visa expired. This is how it is.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may4srilanka052309.html

UN Shown Blown Out Land Devoid of People, UN Preaches Partnership Not Prosecution

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may3srilanka052309.html

OVER NO FIRE ZONE, SRI LANKA, May 23, updated -- On three Sri Lankan military helicopters, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, his entourage and the Press were flown over the so-called No Fire Zone. Beneath lay shattered buildings and expanses of torn tents and burned out vehicles, even a burned out ship. The approach to the No Fire Zone was eerily quiet, with white birds flying over farmhouses with no roofs and livestock running free and untended. The government of Mahinda Rajapaksa, clearly, is proud of its handiwork. But what to make of it?

Consider, for a moment, if the Sudanese government offered tours of South Darfur, showing where it had routed the Justice and Equality Movement and burned out all the buildings, and then moved all civilians to interment camps surrounded by barbed wire and soldiers. Even more than now, advocates and Western countries would call "genocide."

But Ban Ki-moon on Saturday said, we must help the Sri Lankan government. He pledged aid for the interment camps. He came close to saying the pounding in the north was a cause for joy for many. What is the difference? Was this not a war crimes tour?

Strangely, there were some people down in the shattered Zone. They stared up at the helicopter and waved their arms. The copters did not stop. The excuse given, by or about the UN's Vijay Nambiar, was that the Zone is too dangerous to visit. But there were people walking there, among the tattered tents and running wild dogs.

After the mind numbing helicopter tour, reporter gorged on Sri Lankan Air Force curry and looked at the photos they'd taken. These are war crimes on a platter, said one, as another reporter returned for a second round of cashew curry.

The next stop, before any Internet, would be President Rajapaksa in the historic city of Kandy. It contains a famous Buddhist temple, and one UN official admitted to Inner City Press that Rajapaksa was adament that Ban come to Kandy, and wanted to parade him through the Buddhist temple of the tooth. Rajapaksa's really rubbing our noses in it, the official said.

When the UN is desperate to be relevant, this is what can happen.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may3srilanka052309.html

In Manik Farm Camp, Children Forced to Sing to Ban Ki-moon, No Questions

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may2srilanka052309.html

MANIK FARM, SRI LANKA, May 23 -- Beside printed banners welcoming the UN's Ban Ki-moon to "the motherland," Tamil children were paraded on Saturday with Sri Lankan flags, singing a high pitched chant, "Ban Ki-moon, Ban Ki-moon." While many found it ghoulish, given that these children are interred in these UN funded camps along with their families, Mr. Ban gamely smiled through it, taking a tour of the militarized camp with Sri Lanka's foreign minister.

Later he was taken to an open-air hospital, where severely ill elderly people lay writhing in pain, flies all over them. Ban bent down and held a woman's hand, while the woman next to her looked, frankly, dead. A cameraman on this gruesome tour stepped on woman lying with an IV on the ground, without noticing. Ban stood and whispered an interview to the BBC. "We need to go for the fly-over," a security officer hissed.

"He's speaking to the Press," a Ban handler replied. This is important. The fly-over was pushed back. The now-empty lands from which these people came could wait.

A husband stopped the Press to show his wife's thigh, cut by a government artillery shell. We need help, he gestured. But to name him might result in even more problems. A woman gave an interview through barbed wire to a gaggle of reporters, translated by a UN staffer from New York who helpfully spoke Tamil.

She gave her first name, and complained that they can't leave the camp. Then the soldiers told her and the crowd around her to back away from the fence and media. A reporter called after her, "what is your last name?" She looked worry before giving it, so Inner City Press does not print it.

What is the UN's role in these camps? Why do they let the Sri Lankan government use UN Photos of Ban and Rajapaksa for propaganda banners? How should Ban react to the forced singing of his name?

Earlier on Saturday, Ban Ki-moon and his officials received a one-way briefing from Sri Lankan interment officials. In a meeting room with two slow turning ceiling fans and a multitude of armed guards, three speakers berated Ban and his top humanitarian and political officials about how much they are doing for the people they displaced, in large part.

The government speakers chided the West for lack of aid, said that India (and in one previously reported Kouchner case, France) were alone with medical help. Later Ban was shown some blue tents and told, these were given by China. Ban nodded and later said, we have to help the Sri Lankan government.

During the one-way briefing, Inner City Press said after one speaker, "Can we ask questions?" Ban's officials turned and looked, but the government continued with its endless Power Point presentation, about bank branches and book sales.

Then a Ban handler told Inner City Press to leave the hall and go to the minibus. Outside, soldiers told photographers to put down their cameras. When one reported approached the barbed wire to speak to those behind it, it was representatives of the UN who said not to do it. Perhaps this was wise and protective. But why then is the UN funding these camps?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may2srilanka052309.html

On UN's Sri Lanka Trip, Holmes Did Not Favor It, NGOs Phase Out Work

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may1srilanka052309.html

SRI LANKA, May 23, modified May 26 at NGO request -- As UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his top humanitarian official John Holmes are whisked via military helicopter to government selected camps for Internally Displaced People and a mere fly-over the beach-front Zone of Death, minutes of a meeting earlier in the week in New York between Holmes and non-governmental organizations show that Holmes did not favor the trip.

The minutes also show that some of the NGOs, including convener Crisis Action, plan to "phase out" their work on Sri Lanka. Doubts about the UN's and international community's including civil society's commitment to those who suffer in Sri Lanka, Tamils and others, can only grow.

Before the phase out, and after the Government of Sri Lanka barred NGOs and the UN from using any vehicles to service IDPs in the large camps of Menic (or Manik) Farms in north Sri Lanka, a joint statement calling for access was issued May 21 by a group of NGOs including Oxfam, ASB/Solidar, Acted, Danish Refugee Council, ZOA Refugee Care, Forut, UMCOR, Relief International, Handicap International, Save the Children, Welthungerhilfe, CARE, World Vision Medical Teams International.

Further below the radar, there are Tamil NGOs which face dissolution or not working in Sri Lanka.

Before the 24 hour trip to Sri Lanka, Holmes met with a hand-picked group of NGOs in New York. Afterwards an internal summary was issued, which attendees leaked to Inner City Press, ostensibly disturbed by the approach taken at the meeting and by the UN. The memo began, "please find below notes from yesterday's meeting with John Holmes. Let me now if you have any questions. This is true especially in light of some of us (Crisis Action included) phasing out our Sri Lanka work very soon."

There followed a summary of what John Holmes told NGOs behind closed doors, which even filing from Sri Lanka we'll run in full:

John Holmes

Timing of the trip is "tricky," point is not to "join the celebrations"; will have to be careful. [In-house, JH had objected to the trip, as many of you know];

Trip will be de facto a 12-hr day; he cannot extend;

Plan is to go to camps; overfly conflict zone, depending on weather conditions; meet President and other high-level officials; speak to press; hopefully meet with civil society (not certain that would happen);

It's "pretty clear there's nobody in the conflict zone, other than soldiers." UN has flown over, nothing to be seen from helicopter. Still, possible to have bodies/people in hiding;

On overcrowding in camps: NGOs/UN has to be clear about what we want. Do we want to move them to another camp or not? Clearly we want quick returns but in the meantime...

Have not heard anything about [threat of] suspension of humanitarian activities; just got off the phone with UN in SL; ICRC had raised possibility but backed down;

On disappearances: not clear how many are sinister. Known that hard-line cadres are given over to police and are sent to rehabilitation centres. Reasonably clear that GoSL will try to make sure remaining LTTE top leadership won't make it out alive;

LTTE lower cadres are not really separated from civilians, all enter camps together, which is not necessarily a good thing, because all are then viewed as suspects;

Will be pretty hard to get UN political presence in country; govt very resistant, uses "home-grown solution" language very deliberately;

On the doctors: they are in detention but are 'healthy' and 'ok, as far as one can be ok in detention' ;

On UNSC: we have not focused on that, happy to brief if requested;

The strategy is still to keep on with high-level visits, but will see how this will happen;

On numbers: we have no idea how many have died in the last three days. Generally, hard to verify numbers, so have been using "some

thousands."

[Later on, an OCHA staffer advised NGOs to press the issue of MoUs, also to create more space for the pro-active Holmes.]

...There is no real push-back to the exclusion of vehicles from the IDP camps. The minutes say that ICRC (the Red Cross) "backed down." While some UN sources have told Inner City Press that UN staff are threatening a de facto boycott, Holmes told the Press on the plane ride to Sri Lanka that this is not the case, that access and work continues.

It appears that the Secretariat may not even push to have Ban Ki-moon briefing the Security Council upon his return to New York. Then again, in April Ban Ki-moon was only in New York three times, for a total of five days. A lot is being "phased out."

Inner City Press will be accompanying Ban and Holmes on their whirlwind tour May 23 and will report on it in real time to the degree possible given the host country's control of the tour and the lack of internet access. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip2may1srilanka052309.html

In 16 Hours in Sri Lanka, UN's Ban To Overfly Zone of Carnage, Dine with President

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may9srilanka052309.html

COLOMBO, May 23 -- In the wake of what UN officials called a bloodbath on the beach, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and the Press are set for a sixteen hour jaunt around Sri Lanka on Saturday, which some call the victory tour. On military helicopters the entourage will travel to Manik Farm, which the UN's John Holmes has repeatedly called the largest camp for Internally Displaced People in the world. Only Zones 1 and 4 will be toured.

Currently, neither the UN nor non-governmental organizations are allowed to enter the camps with vehicles. A briefing will be given by, among others, Major General G A Chandrasiri and a hospital will be visited.

Next from Manik Farm's helipad, the group will "over fly [the] No Fire Zone," the scene of much firing and dying, including in the days after the government declared victory but neither the Red Cross nor UN were allowed into the zone to search for or help the wounded.

Ban's chief and staff and envoy Vijay Nambiar received a similar fly-over on May 22 and concluded from the air, according to UN officials, that no civilians remain in the Zone. Inner City Press has a camera with a zoom, but there's talk of bodies in bunkers, bodies buried, evidence destroyed.

The group will lunch at the government Air Base in Anuradhapura, the site of a prison in which as Inner City Press has reported UNHCR staff member Mr. Ragushankar Kulathaivelu has been imprisoned since last Fall. He and his mother were arrested on October 5, 2008.

From where he worked for UNHCR, in Mannar, he was visiting his mother in Vavuniya, when the authorities came to arrest his mother for renting a room to an alleged LTTE supporter, who had identified himself as a student.

The mother died in December, in jail. Ragushankar Kulathaivelu nevertheless remains in prison in Anuradhapura. Reportedly, even after the wipe out of the No Fire zone, conditions for such prisoners have grown worse, with verbal and other abuse.

This is a UN system staff member, arrested along with his mother for no reason, and still in custody. UNHCR's country representative has said nothing publicly about it, and has not responded to written questions on the matter. Inner City Press on the plane to Sri Lanka asked the UN's Holmes about the case. What will be done? Perhaps it will be a working lunch.

Ban's entourage includes not only Holmes and Nambiar but also the head of the UN Department of Political Affairs Lynn Pascoe, Ban's spokesperson Choi Soung-ah and Director of Communications Michael Meyer, as well as Department of Public Information staff. Much administrative work has gone into the trip, but its outcome is far from certain, in fact is heavily maligned from many quarters.

The group then flies en masse to Kandy, where Ban will meet with President Mahinda Rajapaksa then hold a half-hour press conference in the Queen's Hotel. Then Ban will dine with President Rajapaksa, as Ban told Inner City Press the two did in Seoul, before that sharing a helicopter ride over a port since re-development by the Chinese.

At the Sri Lankan Mission to the UN in New York, an official who restricted this reporter's passport to two days and said for any longer, a background check would be performed in Colombo told Inner City Press of the mixing of Sinhanese hoppers with Tamil those, "in food you see we fix," she said. What or who is on the menu and agenda at Ban's and Rajapaksa's dinner is not known.

Will Mr. Ban raise the incarceration of the doctors who remained in the No Fire zone offering treatment and casualty figures? Will he ask about Tissainayagam, a journalist held without charges for more than a year? Will the two discuss Amendment 13 to the Sri Lankan constitution, which promised too-limited devolution or powers but nevertheless was never implemented, and reportedly might now be further undermined?

What about the long-promised investigation into the killings of newspaper editors and aid workers, from Action Contre la Faim and elsewhere? What about what's called the government's blacklist of 837 internationals?

What about the Memorandum of Understanding now being demanded from NGOs by the government of Sri Lanka, which requires them to provide "all information" to the government? (See Inner City Press' exclusive report. here.)

What about Bousa prison, where witnesses tell of routine torture of those detained?

Unless something changes, the whole group will be packed back on the UN plane, at Katunayake International Airport, and will leave the country before Saturday at midnight. Watch this site for updates, whenever and wherever the Internet can be found.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may9srilanka052309.html

At Colombo Airport, UN's Ban Declares Reconciliation Begun, Omits Joyous Reference

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may8srilanka052209.html

COLOMBO AIRPORT, May 22 -- As UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon arrived in Colombo, he delivered prepared remarks to a crowd assembled at midnight. Soldiers with machine guns lined a rain-drenched red carpet. Inside a VIP terminal, Mr. Ban signed a guest book the message of which was pre-written. Flanked by Sri Lanka's foreign minister and UN envoy Vijay Nambiar, before a jostling crowd of photographing media including Inner City Press, Ban recited from his speech.

At the last minute, a line was removed from his remarks: "A great many Sri Lankans are understandably joyous that a long conflict is over." This was distributed to the Press accompanying Mr. Ban and his officials on the UN plane, and then crossed out in ball point pen. What to make of the deletion?

Left in, however, was the line "I hope my visit today can help begin a process of national recovery, renewal and reconciliation for all Sri Lankans." One wag on the plane joked, "No, Mister Nambiar has started that process."

No questions were taken after the foreign minister spoke. The Press was hustled out to a waiting mini-bus and sped out of the airport, into the darkness of a neighborhood full of textile plants.

Ban's schedule for Saturday begins at 8 am with a meeting with the Sri Lankan foreign minister. From there, the group will be taken, seriatim, to a hospital, then to the Manik Farms camp for internally displaced people. The visit, Inner City Press is told, will be to Zones Two and Four.

The UN's top humanitarian John Holmes told the Press that Zone One, the first built, has semi-permanent houses with roofs of tin or some local equivalent. The plane-wag asked, what are they hiding in Zone Three? Much more seriously, there is talk of a post mortem of a woman who died in the camps, reportedly of starvation.

Then Ban and the Press will be taken for a fly-over of the conflict zone. Somehow from these heights, Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar was able to conclusively determine that no more civilians remain in the Zone.

Ban's day, and trip to Sri Lanka, will end with a private dinner in Kandy with President Mahinda Rajapaksa, followed it is said by a press availability. Then Ban will fly onward to Copenhagen. Can these 24 hours "begin a process of national recovery, renewal and reconciliation for all Sri Lankans"? Watch this site.

And see,
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may8srilanka052209.html

UN's Holmes Speaks of Tamils and then Stops, On Satish Nambiar, No Comment

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may7srilanka052209.html

UN PLANE, May 22, modified May 23 -- Taking off toward Sri Lanka on Friday after a refueling stop in Bahrain, UN humanitarian chief John Holmes said that he has been besieged by e-mails from the Tamil diaspora. His subsequent comments, he clarified on Saturday morning, were meant to be "on background."

Holmes and other UN officials, from Secretary General Ban Ki-moon through his chief of staff and envoy Vijay Nambiar to High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay all receive emails beseeching action on Sri Lanka, many of which are copied to Inner City Press. As the shelling of the No Fire zone increased, the tone of the emails grew more shrill, including one which said Ban Ki-moon should be sent to the International Criminal Court for complicity in genocide. That a UN official might delete such a message and subsequent ones perceived to be of that nature is, one supposes, understandable.

Inner City Press asked about the op-ed written by the brother of Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, praising Sri Lankan General Fonseka and his campaign in the North. Holmes declined to comment.

When Holmes was in Sri Lanka in mid 2007, he called it a very dangerous country, in the aftermath of the shooting of a group of Action Contre la Faim aid workers. A government minister called Holmes a terrorist for his comment. This minister was later blown up. He was running a marathon or race and got blown up. What more can we say? Apparently, nothing.

Click here for NGOs' summary of Holmes comments in New York just prior to the trip.

On other matter, Holmes predicted that Ban will go to Myanmar in July, that he'd told that to CNN. Holmes admitted that while in Myanmar, he had been taken to a "model village." Not so in Sri Lanka he said, admitting again that in his first trip he has used government supplied translation. He said that wasn't a problem. But wasn't it?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may7srilanka052209.html

UN's Ban Remembers Flying and Dining with Rajapaksa, Roots in NAM and Tsunami

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may6srilanka052209.html

UN PLANE, BAHRAIN, May 22 -- Parked on a runway in Bahrain refueling on his way to Sri Lanka, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon told the Press he had been to Sri Lanka only once before, in the early 1980s as part of South Korea's diplomatic unit on the UN. He said that North Korea was making inroads with the Non-Aligned Movement, which he tried to counter on behalf of Seoul. Inner City Press asked, weren't you also in Sri Lanka after the tsunami?

You're right, Mr. Ban said sheepishly. I had forgotten. He recounted how he and now-President Mahinda Rajapaksa flew in a helicopter over the then-destroyed port of Hambantota, where now the Chinese are constructive a massive port as part of their String of Pearls strategy. He described another dinner, this time in Seoul, with Mahinda Rajapaksa. Ban said he gets along well with President Rajapaksa. More on this shortly.

Ban said that in April he was only in New York three times, for a total of five days. Inner City Press asked where he does his laundry, and if he'd seen the previous day's Wall Street Journal expose of the UN's questionable handling of sexual harassment cases. Ban nodded and acknowledged that the topic had come up in his visit to Washington just prior to the Sri Lanka trip. We have a zero tolerance policy, he said.

Inner City Press asked what he would do about making public what Troop Contributing Countries do when their soldiers are repatriated from UN Peacekeeping missions charged with sexual abuse or exploitation. Ban said that whole groups of soldiers are sent home. Like to Sri Lanka, Inner City Press said, referring to the charges against more than 100 Sri Lankan soldiers while in Haiti with the UN.

Ban indicated that this particular repatriation shouldn't be asked about at this time. He mentioned the Moroccans, who were repatriated from the UN Mission in Cote d'Ivoire.

Ban looked around the plane and said this is the second largest group of journalists to accompany him. There would have been more, Inner City Press told him, if he had come before the No Fire Zone was over-run. Concluding the conversation on a high note, Ban said he had read in the Press the story of the Security Council ambassadors who had to travel by bus from Congo to Rwanda after a UN staffer shot his pistol in this same white UN plane while trying to show that his weapon was empty. I read about that, Ban said. And then he returned to the front of the patched-up plane.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may6srilanka052209.html

In Sri Lanka, Will Ban Address Blacklisting, Boosa Prison, Detentions and Right to Return?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may5srilanka052209.html

UN PLANE, BAHRAIN, May 22 -- While for his trip to Sri Lanka UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon speak of listening to the "plans and visions" of President Mahinda Rajapaksa, local sources tell Inner City Press there are a number of more concrete places and abuses he should check into.

Why for example are UN vehicles not being allowed into camps the UN paid to build? Where are young men who left the conflict zone being taken, and for what? What are the Rajapaksa's commitments in terms of granting displaced Tamils a right to return in a reasonable period of time and full granting full access both to the camps and former conflict zone?

Even more specifically, what about Tissainayagam, a journalist held without charges for more than a year? What about the long-promised investigation into the killings of newspaper editors and aid workers, from ACF and elsewhere? What about the doctors who stayed in the conflict zone to offer treatment and casualty firgures, and are now in government detention?

What about Bousa prison, where witnesses tell of routine torture of those detained?

What about what's called the government's blacklist of 837 internationals? What about the Memorandum of Understanding now being demanded from NGOs by the government of Sri Lanka, which requires them to provide "all information" to the government?

We could go on and on. But Ban Ki-moon could start with these. But will he start at all? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may5srilanka052209.html

Headed to Sri Lanka, UN's Ban Hungry for Visions, Nambiar's and Pascoe's Helping Hands

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may4srilanka052209.html

UN PLANE, BAHRAIN, May 22 – Speeding toward Sri Lanka in the UN's Sudan plane, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon described to the Press his mission as listening to President Mahinda Rajapaksa's “plans and visions.” Asked if he would “meet with the Tamil minority,” Mr. Ban said, “I am discussing with the Sri Lankan government.

"As you know, I am visiting only twenty four hours. I have to spend a lot of time on the road, traveling. Therefore as for detailed programs, [chief of staff Vijay] Nambiar is discussing with the Sri Lankan authorities.” With that, Ban referred the Press to his “very senior advisors” John Holmes and Lynn Pascoe, directors of the UN's humanitarian and political operations respectively.

Holmes, speaking on the record, chided a report who said the UN “hasn't had access for ten days.” He said, “we have had, all the way through, access to the camps.” He said that a few days ago, the government stopped letting the vehicles of the UN as well as non-governmental organizations go into the camps.

Is access on foot the “unimpeded” access that Ban says is the key “deliverable” he expects from this whirlwind trip? Well, said one wag, the meme “ped,” meaning foot, is in the word “unimpeded.”

Inner City Press asked Holmes what the UN has done in light of the expose on UK Channel 4 in which people detained in the government camps spoke of women being disappeared and then their bodies dumped. “We don't have hard evidence of that,” Holmes said, adding wisely that it doesn't mean it isn't true. He said that disappearances are not as much of a problem as they were before.

Holmes said that there are no more civilians in what was the conflict zone. Lynn Pascoe jumped in and specified that this UN position is based on the visual observation of Vijay Nambiar, who was taken by the government on a fly-over of the conflict zone. Then Holmes qualified that no large groups of civilians remain. He might have added: over-ground.

Inner City Press asked if the UN would provide aid to Sri Lanka without conditions. Holmes first said that “the political situations has to be right,” and the camps in compliance with international law. Then he spoke of raising more money from donors. It was, inevitably, a mixed message. Or as several close Sri Lanka observers have told Inner City Press, the Rajapaksas know that the UN will never stop funding, will never stand up, and so they ignore what the UN says.

The government has confirmed that it has arrested doctors who stayed in the conflict zone offering treatment and casualty figures. Inner City Press asked Holmes if Ban would raise the issue of these arrests to President Rajapaksa. I'm sure he will, Holmes said. We'll see. Ban told the Press that, in the run-up to the trip, he spoke with Golden Brown, Hillary Clinton and Bernard Kouchner. None now seems able to block or even delay the $1.9 billion loan the International Monetary Fund wants to give to Sri Lanka. So why should the Rajapaksa's listen?

As Holmes and Pascoe left, going back up to the first class section in front of the UN plane behind the Velcro-ed curtain, Inner City Press asked Pascoe for the UN's view of the Sri Lankan Constitution's 13th Amendment. It was enacted in 1987 as part of the Indo-Lankan Accords, and provides for some devolution of powers to local, Tamil areas.

A senior Ban adviser, not present on the trip, told Inner City Press that while Amendment 13 “does not go far enough,” the Rajapaksa are thinking of going back on it. Inner City Press asked Pascoe to comment on this and Pascoe agreed that some say Amendment 13 doesn't go far enough. But are the Rajapaksa's trying to back away even from it? Are these the “plans and visions” that Ban has come to listen to? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/untrip1may4srilanka052209.html