Tuesday, May 19, 2009

In Sri Lanka, No Access to Carnage Until Victory Speech, UN Lowers Expectations

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un3may3srilanka051709.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 17 – As the brothers Rajapaksa declare victory in northern Sri Lanka, from the conflict zone closed to press come reports of thousands dead, and thousands more injured. There will be no access, it is predicted, until after President Mahinda Rajapaksa's speech slated for Tuesday.

Until then the injured will die, and some predict mass graves and cover up, pleading via sat-phone to Inner City Press to please get the UN to take satellite photographs to preserve the evidence. But the UN withheld even the photographs their UNOSAT already had.

A press briefing has been set up for May 18 in New York, not by Ban Ki-moon's envoy Vijay Nambiar but rather by humanitarian chief John Holmes, who was visited decidedly less bloody zones during Sri Lanka's final push into the conflict zone. People are asking, where is Vijay Nambiar? He used to answer, to his credit if not be responsive to, text messages from Inner City Press.

Now even to a question 24 hours ago of what the UN is doing for the doctors being interrogated by the Sri Lanka government he has not answered. On the plane headed to Colombo he did speak to two publications, both British, and delivered a decidedly resigned message, that he doubted the government would stop. Was he reducing expectations? Or once again would he be perceived as giving the UN's blessing?

As Inner City Press reported in recent weeks, most who Ban Ki-moon chose as his advisers counseled letting the Sri Lanka conflict “run its course,” and only going to visit “after the dust settled.” We predicted then that just such a visit would happen, and we intend to cover it. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un3may3srilanka051709.html

As Sri Lanka Holds Doctors Incommunicado, UN Deaf and Dumb

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un3may2srilanka051609.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 16 – Doctors who remained in northern Sri Lanka's bloody conflict zone are now being held incommunicado by the government in Omanthai, sources tell Inner City Press. Along with Doctors Varatharajah and Shanmugarajah, Dr.Thangamutha Sathiyamoorth, the regional director of Health Services in Kilinochchi whose May 13 dispatch about that day's the shelling of the last remaining hospital in the “No Fire” Zone was published in Inner City Press only yesterday, is being held without visits even from the International Committee of the Red Cross.

In New York, Inner City Press had asked top UN humanitarian John Holmes weeks ago if he had heard that the government had stopped paying doctors in the conflict zone, and was threatening them, if they provided casualty figures or other information, with interrogation, torture and even death when they were captured. Holmes said he hadn't heard of it.

In Sri Lanka, the UN provided assurances that it would provide security for the doctors when the time came, according to local sources. But now, even with Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar in the country, nothing appears to be being done about these doctors. The question has been asked, but no answer received.

The UN previously said nothing when its own staff members were interred in IDP camps, or in other cases incarcerated by the government for not speaking Sinhalese, or in the case of the UN refugee agency's protection officer in Vanvuniya, for having a mother who inadvertently rented a room to an LTTE member.

Targeting doctors is a war crime, complicity in it no less so. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un3may2srilanka051609.html

At UN, Retaliation On Press and Nurse for Expose of Illegal Drugs, Coverage

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1retaliation051609.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 16 – Three weeks after an expose by this publication that at the United Nations “a group of largely unlicensed doctors and nurses are dispensing and in some cases taking and self-medicating with Valium, Diazepam, Demerol, Ambien and other controlled narcotics,” the UN has responded, and retaliated, demanding the removal of evidence from the public record.

A UN Medical Service staff member, a licensed nurse whom UN Management apparently believe to have been the whistleblower for the expose, has been told to “surrender your grounds pass” and has been barred from entering the UN by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in a May 15 letter from the head of the UN's Office of Human Resource Management, Catherine Pollard. See copy of letter, obtained by Inner City Press and placed online here.

As the retaliated-against nurse points out, where narcotics are being dispensed illegally and without license, there is no confidentiality. In fact, issues might now arise whether the UN's Office of Internal Oversight Services, or even Ethics Office, have lived up to their applicable pledges of confidentiality.

The UN purports to have a policy of protecting whistleblowers against retaliation, but the policy seems to have been ignored in this case, by the very head of OHRM. The policy, about which UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has been questioned including by Inner City Press, is ostensibly enforced by the UN Ethics Office. Inner City Press asked Ethics Office director Robert Benson about the irregularities and retaliation in the UN Medical Services, which had been raised to Susan John of his office, but without yet receiving a response.

This extreme case of retaliation will be a test for the UN Ethics Office, which was discredited earlier by having its recommendations that back-pay be awarded for violating a whistleblower's due process rights ignored by the UN Development Program. Mr. Benson has told Inner City Press he is spending more of his time in Africa, giving trainings in such locations as Nairobi. Meanwhile, retaliation and the threat of retaliation have become routine at UN Headquarters in New York.

Relatedly, there is retaliation or attempted retaliation against the press at the UN. At 11 am on Saturday, May 16, the head of the UN's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit Gary Fowlie wrote to this reporter, three weeks after the article at issue

Subj: Medical record photograph
From: [Chief, Media Liaison and Accreditation at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 5/16/2009 11:10:42 A.M. Eastern Standard Time

Dear Matthew

I see that you have republished a photograph containing confidential medical records of UN staff on your website. See the link below to the story and photo of a 'sample sign-out sheet'. I ask that you please remove this photograph out of respect for the confidentiality of all staff concerned.

Gary Fowlie
Chief, Media Liaison and Accreditation,
United Nations, S-250, New York, NY 10017

As the retaliated-against nurse points out, where narcotics are being dispensed illegally and without license, there is no confidentiality. In fact, issues might arise whether the UN's Office of Internal Oversight Services, or even Ethics Office, have lived up to their applicable pledges of confidentiality. Nevertheless, Inner City Press responded the same (weekend) morning, less that one hour later, that it had

“received your email about an article Inner City Press published on April 23, three weeks ago, which gave rise to coverage in other media and, we understand, an inquiry by the US Drug Enforcement Agency.

"While troubled by your request that evidence in this matter be removed from the public record – and troubled by the timing of your request and its possible relation to other coverage by Inner City Press of the UN's performance, including in Asia and Africa – nevertheless in an abundance of caution, the photograph you refer to has been taken down less than an hour after your request.

"You are reminded that covering-up by the UN not only violates the Organization's stated principles, but has other repercussions. I would like to know who raised this matter to your office and when, and for a description of all communications.”

The background and reason for this counter-request is that Ms. Pollard's superior, the director of the Department of Management Angela Kane, is known to have send her staff to the Office of Media Accreditation and Liaison to inquire into the accreditation (or, Ms. Kane apparently hoped, dis-accreditation) of Inner City Press. Click here for May 7, 2009 article, "The Wrath of Kane."

Inner City Press was asked to “write nicely about Angela Kane.” It was not at the time spelled out what would be attempted if the coverage ended up not being positive.

The inquiry came in the context of a series of stories about matters under Ms. Kane's control, from procurement and hiring irregularities through asbestos and failure to do required Security Risk Assessments in connection with the UN's planned billion dollar renovations to allegations, widespread among UN staff, that Ms. Kane acts for the benefit of her country, Germany, in the cancellation (now, postponement) of the UN's National Competitive Exam, in the demotion of Tanzanian Anna Tibaijuka as head of the UN in Nairobi in favor of the German Aichim Steiner, etc..

Ms. Kane previously responded to questions Inner City Press had been directed to pose to her by saying she had no time to answer questions, that everything should be asked at the UN's noon briefing. From the transcript of Friday May 15, the day before the demand to remove evidence from the public record

Inner City Press: I had asked before about the contract with VSG that runs UNTV. Can you confirm that now the UN is actually paying their salary rather than VSG, but that neither pension nor health benefits are being paid by the UN? That the people that work in the UN and UN Television are now without pension payments and without health insurance, and what the UN’s plan is to deal with this now nearly bankrupt UN contractor.

Spokesperson Michele Montas: You can address your question directly to the people involved…

Inner City Press: Who are those? I had written to Ms. Kane in the past and she said ask at the noon briefing, so that’s why I am asking here.

Spokesperson Montas: Oh, she said ask at the noon briefing?

Inner City Press: She did.

Spokesperson: Okay. As soon as I get the answer for you, I’ll find out what the new situation is at this point.

Inner City Press is told by sources inside Ms. Kane's office that a desire to “set up” Inner City Press arose, and that the UN Medical Services story was belatedly viewed as providing such an opportunity. It appears shameful, certainly. But this is how the UN, or at least some at the top of the UN, work. [Click here for another continuing strand of retaliation for reporting on the UN's failure to discipline those involved, on UN time, in pornography, including an implicated staff member's crack down on and now stalking of the Press.]

Troublingly, these belated retaliation attempts take places in the context of persistent reporting by Inner City Press about the UN Secretariat's inaction as civilians have been killed in Northern Sri Lanka. A week ago, Inner City Press wrote an article noting that while Ban Ki-moon said he would accept the invitation to go to Sri Lanka if he thought it would have a single life, he stayed in New York to meet with China's deputy foreign minister and to celebrate the stealth wedding of his son.

Inner City Press has received numerous complaints about this article from senior Ban Administration advisers. Perhaps they will ask their Office of Media Accreditation and Liaison to take action, to demand the removal of any criticism of the UN from the public record. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1retaliation051609.html

With Sri Lankan Safe Zone in Flames, UN Fiddles, War Crimes Charged

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un3may1srilanka051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 – As the Sri Lankan government says it will overrun the so-called Safe Zone in 48 hours, at the UN in New York Secretary General Ban Ki-moon met with China's deputy foreign minister, and then attended a Republic of Korea-sponsored Buddhist event with, among others, Myanmar's representative. At the UN's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked about Ban's schedule, and for confirmation that he got to know Sri Lankan president Mahinda Rajapaksa while he was a South Korean diplomat, and has privately described Rajapaksa in glowing terms. Video here, from Minute 14:26.

“I don't know about that,” Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas said. “I can try to find out.” As deadline six hours later, no information had been provided.

In the face of the Rajapaksa administration's final solution, Ban sent his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, for the second time, rather than going himself. Nambiar's first trip was followed by accelerating civilian death. As Inner City Press reported at the time, his brother Satish served as a consultant to the Sri Lankan government, and went on to write an op-ed piece praising the government's deadly military campaign in the North and the general who led it. Click here to view Satish Nambiar's resume on the UN web site.

The UN has not answered on any of these issues, other than pointing out, on May 14, that Vijay Nambiar is not Sri Lankan.

Inner City Press asked if the World Food Program supplies which the UN on Wednesday said was going to be delivered to the conflict zone had in fact arrived. No, spokeswoman Michele Montas said, what WFP is doing is delivering food to the refugees and IDPs. As we will report on in more detail in the near future, the UN in Sri Lankan has a track record of delivering its aid only when and where the government says to, with the effect of ethnic cleansing.


It is on that note, complicity in war crimes, that we are reduced to ending this dispatch. Ban Ki-moon this week got a message, cc-ed to Inner City Press, which ended: see you at the International Criminal Court. There is talk of an investigation of the UN's refugee agency, for conspiring with the government to set up housing only where the government wanted to move the Tamils. Eventually, with or without effect, accountability will be apportioned. But right now in Sri Lanka it is a crisis. We close with this message, from the conflict zone:

13 May 2009

Dear Sir / Madam,

Heavy battle started since 5.30 am. Many wounded civilians were brought to hospital and hospital is not providing services because hospital was under shell attack. Few staff reported duty. nearly thousand patients are waiting to get daily treatment. But even simple wound dressing and giving antibiotics problems. So many wounded have to die. In the ward among patients many death bodies are there.

Looking hospital seen and hearing the civilians cry really disaster. Did they make any mistake do the world by the innocent. But the important sta[keholders] are just listening the situation and not helping the people.

Dr.T.Sathiyamoorthy

Regional director of Health Services

Kilinochchi (Now at No Fire Zone)

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un3may1srilanka051509.html

At UN, Small Islands Want Climate Change in Security Council Agenda, NAM Push Back

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unclim1islres051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- From small states, big ideas can come. That is how the Pacific Ocean small island states are promoting a draft UN General Assembly resolution which would encourage the Security Council to address "climate change, including its possible security implication" for the "maintenance of international peace and security."

Their draft resolution, obtained by Inner City Press and placed online here, is a version watered down after push-back from the Group of 77 and Non-Aligned Movement, developing countries which oppose giving the Security Council and five veto-wielding members more power.

But the small island states, faced in some cases with the elimination of their land by the rising of the seas, are pushing to get climate change on the agenda of the Security Council, which alone among UN organ has the power to require all member states to take action, with resolutions under Chapter 7 of the UN Charter.

The draft resolution, "not[es] the open debate at the Security Council on 'Energy, Climate and Security' held on 17 April 2007" -- when the UK held the rotating presidency of the Council. The footnote in the draft then also refers to the push-back in 2007 from Cuba on behalf of NAM and Pakistan on behalf of the G-77.

A proponent of the draft said that its supports now include the Maldives and, significantly, the European Union, and that the plan is to introduce the draft on May 18 and vote the following week. Supporters were set up May 15 in the UN's Delegates Lounge, with small replicas of flags of their nations. Small nations, small flags, big ideas. A showdown is brewing: watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unclim1islres051509.html

At UN, Small Islands Want Climate Change in Security Council Agenda, NAM Push Back

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unclim1islres051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- From small states, big ideas can come. That is how the Pacific Ocean small island states are promoting a draft UN General Assembly resolution which would encourage the Security Council to address "climate change, including its possible security implication" for the "maintenance of international peace and security."

Their draft resolution, obtained by Inner City Press and placed online here, is a version watered down after push-back from the Group of 77 and Non-Aligned Movement, developing countries which oppose giving the Security Council and five veto-wielding members more power.

But the small island states, faced in some cases with the elimination of their land by the rising of the seas, are pushing to get climate change on the agenda of the Security Council, which alone among UN organ has the power to require all member states to take action, with resolutions under Chapter 7 of the UN Charter.

The draft resolution, "not[es] the open debate at the Security Council on 'Energy, Climate and Security' held on 17 April 2007" -- when the UK held the rotating presidency of the Council. The footnote in the draft then also refers to the push-back in 2007 from Cuba on behalf of NAM and Pakistan on behalf of the G-77.

A proponent of the draft said that its supports now include the Maldives and, significantly, the European Union, and that the plan is to introduce the draft on May 18 and vote the following week. Supporters were set up May 15 in the UN's Delegates Lounge, with small replicas of flags of their nations. Small nations, small flags, big ideas. A showdown is brewing: watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unclim1islres051509.html

EU Attacks UN Tax and Cyberspace Authority Proposal, D'Escoto Advisers Muse


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unpga1taxnet051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- Faced with the global financial crisis, the Sandinista, former and current Nicaraguan President of the UN General Assembly Miguel d'Escoto Brockman has convened a GA session for June 1, and released his own draft outcome document which proposes a UN Taxation Authority and body to regulate cyberspace.

"This is a subject I don't have any expertise on," d'Escoto said when Inner City Press asked. Video here from Minute 7:25. The European Union, Inner City Press has learned, has written to d'Escoto in protest of his draft, which they say ignores a text that was being negotiated.

Two d'Escoto advisers held a press conference on the topic on May 14, but instead of addressing the controversy, Michael Clark held forth at length on his ideas of the end of money. As Inner City Press confirmed during Clark's May 1 press conference -- video here from Minute 26:24 -- Clark previously served the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and then lobbied for U.S. companies to get more business in India, in the U.S. - India Business Council. So did he believe in what he was doing then, or now? Apparently it's been an evolution.

While the May 14 press conference lasted an hour, it was organized in such a way that not all questions, including one on the European Union letter, could be asked.

Some in the press corps think that d'Escoto is over-briefing about this financial session. But his Office is not even answering the obvious questions. The main spokesman for d'Escoto is away, which may explain it. Previously, Inner City Press has asked his office for d'Escoto's view on carbon offsetting his travel around the world, without receiving an answer.

D'Escoto himself seems a nice and gentle man. After his press conference -- at the most recent of which he took only three questions, refusing one about the contentious UN Gaza report -- journalists descend on him like locusts for, as one put it, "crazy quotes." Now security officers surrounded d'Escoto as he moves gingerly off the podium. It is all coming to a head: Watch this site.

Footnote / analysis: clearly, there is a need to re-think the under-regulation of finance. But grandstanding and pontificating, and ignoring major blocs drafts of document and then refusing to take questions, seems unlikely to be effective. There are still two weeks to be more effective. Given the importance of the topic, here's hoping.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unpga1taxnet051509.html

At the UN, Ban's Schedule Tells of Niger Secrets, Sri Lanka Lack of Will, Chiselers and Consultants

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1schedule051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15, updated -- A perusal of Friday's appointments of UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon is a profile in lack of accountability, lack of transparency, lack of independence and lack of will. At 11:30 is listed former chief UN lawyer Nicolas Michel, who was exposed as taking $12,000 a month in housing subsidy from the government of Switzerland while ostensibly working only for the UN, and then not including the payments on his UN public financial disclosure. Still he reappears, with UN benefits, as Ban's adviser on Equatorial Guinea and Gabon.

In terms of lack of transparency, while we are glad that Ban's stealth envoy to Niger Robert Fowler was released, no one -- including on May 14 Canada's Ambassador to the UN -- had been wiling to address the statement by Al Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb that Fowler and colleagues were released in exchange for AQIM prisoners, nor what Fowler was doing visiting a Canadian-owned mine in Niger on the day he was kidnapped. Perhaps there'll be a press availability.

Update: at the May 15 noon briefing, when Inner City Press asked, Ban's Spokesperson said it's up to Fowler, and that no press availability was planned.

Zalmay Khalilzad, former US Ambassador to the UN, shows up at 5:45, identified as "CEO of Khalilzad Associates." Certainly this publicly-listed face time will help his consulting business. But what's in it for the UN?

Update: at the May 15 noon briefing, when Inner City Press asked, Ban's Spokesperson said it's a courtesy call. [On May 19, the Deputy Spokesperson declined to give a read-out.]

A week ago, Inner City Press asked if there was any change of Ban Ki-moon going to Sri Lanka before what the government is calling its final assault, given Ban's desire to attend the May 11 Security Council session on the Middle East hosted by Permanent Five Council member Russia, and to meet on May 15 with a minister of follow P-5 member China. The latter meeting hadn't been announced, but Inner City Press was told by well placed sources that talking points for Ban had been ordered up.

And now it is confirmed: a meeting at 3:20 on May 15 with He Yafei, Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs of China, the country which most blocked Council action on the carnage in Sri Lanka.

A long and telling day at the UN, and a worse -- at least in Sri Lanka -- weekend to come. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1schedule051509.html

At UN, Lockheed Took Millions for Services Not Rendered, Budget Wars Ignored

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un5lockheed051509.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- While there has been little press coverage of the UN's budget committee this May session, down in the UN's basement on Conference Rooms 3 and 5, things are coming to a head. On May 14, the Secretariat's use of a $250 million no-bid contracts to Lockheed Martin's PAE subsidiary in Darfur was roundly criticized. Upstairs in the briefing room, Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe said she had heard nothing it.

More generally, sources tell Inner City Press that "the Westerners" are trying to jam budget items through under unrelated agenda items, and that Brazil and others in the Group of 77 and China are preparing their own alternative program of work for the rest of the month. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said he would focus on running the UN right. But of the budget committee, which funds it all, Ban's Spokesperson's Office has apparently heard nothing.

From the May 14 transcript:

Inner City Press: I wanted to ask, in the Fifth, in the Budget Committee today, Inga-Britt Ahlenius of OIOS (Office of Internal Oversight Services) read out a report about the Lockheed Martin or PA&E contract for Darfur. She was harshly critical of it. She said that $4.3 million was for construction services where no construction took place, and she specifically criticized the Secretariat’s response to her audit and said that it was published without it being checked with her. So I wanted to know, I am sure the Secretariat is aware of this OIOS... Is this money going to be recouped? Can we get a press conference by Ahlenius and an explanation by the Secretariat of why they’re rejecting her findings?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: We can ask her to try and come and speak to you, but, as you know, you have to take that request directly.

Inner City Press: Is the money going to be recouped? She said that she found $4.3 million paid by the UN for services never rendered.

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: This is the first I have heard of this. So I don’t have anything beyond what you’ve heard about the... OIOS report.

Question: Maybe Angela Kane as the head of the Department of Management will be the one to respond to this.

Deputy Spokesperson: She will be coming; there is a date already set, as will Michael Adlerstein.

The UN official who pushed through the ill-fated Lockheed / PA&E no bid contract, Jane Holl Lute, is now the number two official in the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. As usual at the UN, there has been no accountability at all, a theme to which we will soon be returning. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un5lockheed051509.html

At UN, Sweden Links EU Tariffs to Sri Lanka Carnage, Ban Again Sends Nambiar

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may9srilanka051409.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 14 -- As the deaths of civilians continued in Sri Lanka, and UN Security General Ban Ki-moon ducked his invitation to the country by sending again his India chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, one of the last pieces of leverage against continued bombing was was raised in the UN. Sweden's Minister for International Development Cooperation Gunilla Carlsson told Inner City Press that the European Union, of which Sweden will next assume the presidency, should and will link human rights to the renewal of agreements like the EU's tax-free treatment of textiles from Sri Lanka.

"The EU has a lot of instruments at hand," Minister Carlsson said. "We also have to see when we renew agreements and things like that, that we as a global player need to see the human rights perspectives. So we need to link it, and often what we do, different ways now, because people would like to have trade agreements with us."

At the UN's noon briefing on May 14, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe why he is sending Vijay Nambiar, for the second time, rather than going himself.

From the UN's transcript:

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: ...the very fact that he’s sending his Chef de Cabinet again to underscore his message I think speaks loudly on what the Secretary-General in his personal capacity is trying to do to bring an end to the situation on the ground.

Inner City Press: A follow-up on the Chef de Cabinet. There has been substantial criticism, not just that because Mr. Nambiar comes from India, but because his brother, an Indian General [Satish] Nambiar recently wrote an op-ed praising the offensive of the Sri Lankan Army in the north and General [Sarath] Fonseca who’s led it. Is the Secretariat aware of this criticism and how does it address it? Also, that Mr. Nambiar went before he got a commitment to visit an open conflict zone and it never took place. What’s the, I guess, the response and why isn’t Ban Ki-moon himself going if he’s invited and the French and others have said he should go ASAP?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: Matthew, as you know the Secretary-General’s position on going to Sri Lanka has been reiterated from this podium many times this week. And the fact that Mr. Nambiar happens to be of a nationality does not in any way get in the way of his work as a UN official. As you know, everybody from the UN does come from one country or another; but once they sign on to work at the UN they go as UN officials.

Inner City Press: Isn’t there generally a sort of an unwritten rule of not, for example, I mean, when Mr. Gambari was going to do Nigeria, are you unaware that they see that... within diplomats in the UN often say that a person from a country too close to a conflict is not the right person to be sent.

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: Mr. Nambiar is not from Sri Lanka.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may9srilanka051409.html

UN and Congolese War Criminal Bosco, No Pictures, Please, As Council Approaches

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2bosco051309.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 13 -- The UN in the Congo claimed that it would not work with the Congolese Army if indicted war criminal Jean-Bosco Ntaganda was a part of it. Then the UN reduced the claim to that it would not work on Congolese Army operations in which Bosco played a part. Now, faced with Army minutes showing Bosco as a deputy commander in an operation MONUC works with, the claim is further reduced. The permanent representative of a Congo-interested country, part of the Contact Group, told Inner City Press on May 12 that at least the UN will not "sit down and take a photo with Bosco Ntaganda." That's not saying much.

On May 13, in advance of a Security Council trip to the Congo led by France's Jean-Maurice Ripert, Inner City Press asked Ripert for his and France's position on how the UN should distance itself from indicted war criminal Bosco Ntaganda. Ripert said, "France is very clear on that: we are a party to the Rome Stat[ute], we will not meet with people who are involved or indicted." Video here, from Minute 7:45.

But should the UN be working with the Congolese Army and its operations in the Kivus in which Bosco is listed in minutes as deputy coordinator? "This is a question you have to ask to the UN," Ripert answered, "not to France."


Alan Doss of MONUC, April 4 minutes show below

He went on, in response to another question, to say that the purpose of the Congo leg of the trip is to "monitor" the UN Mission. Doesn't monitoring include determining, factually, whether the UN Mission is working in an operation in which a war criminal is deputy coordinator?

Footnote: In the interim, in the run-up to the Council's visit to the Congo, Inner City Press did "ask to the UN," as Ripert suggested, and got back this, which drops the UN's claim that it hadn't seen the April 4 FARDC minutes in question:

Subj: Your question on Jean-Bosco Ntaganda

From: unspokesperson [at] un.org

To: Inner City Press

Sent: 5/13/2009 12:48:40 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time

1.) We stand by our 30 January statement, that MONUC will not support operations with the FARDC in which Jean-Bosco Ntaganda plays a role.

2.) Both the MONUC Force Commander and SRSG have made this clear to their interlocutors at senior levels of the DRC Government and military. These interlocutors have assured MONUC that Bosco does not figure in the chain of command for operations in the Kivus.

3. MONUC has no executive law enforcement powers to execute the arrest warrant but is on record that it is prepared to assist the DRC Government in arresting Bosco should it decide to do so.

So what to make of the April 4 FARDC minutes? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2bosco051309.html

UN's and Norway's Roles in Somalia's Law of Sea Filing, India's in Myanmar's, Questioned

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/los2somalia051309.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 13 -- Norway's role in Somalia's Law of the Sea filing, arranged by the UN's envoy Ahmedou Ould Abdallah, continued to be questioned Wednesday at the UN. The Secretariat's Hariharan Pakshi Rajan was asked what safeguards are in place that an oil-interested state like Norway does not benefit from its assistance to the filing of a poorer state like Somalia. He did not answer about any safeguards, but rather referred to a UN trust fund that poor countries can apply to. Video here, from Minute 15:31.

But this simply raises more question: why would a UN envoy like Ould Abdallah, rather than looking to the UN's own trust fund, seek out or accept the potentially self-interested assistance of a state like Norway?

Inner City Press asked this question at a UN noon briefing, and was then questioned in turn by a member of the UN spokesperson's office, who rather than answer suggested that Inner City Press should "ask Norway." Inner City Press did, and on May 13 received from the the Press Counselor to Norway's mission to the UN a statement that

"How much Norway has used on assisting Somalia to lay forward preliminary information indicative of the outer limits of its continental shelf to the UN; We don’t have a separate budgetary item for this, because the work is a part of Norwegian assistance to several African countries in this matter."

How much was the assistance? Which other African countries? The questions Inner City Press submitted to Ould Abdallah's spokeswoman have yet to be answered.

Ould Abdallah's boss, in a way, the head of the UN Department of Political Affairs Lynn Pascoe, said on Wednesday when asked that he had read Inner City Press' story on this, but didn't "see the connection here." Video here, from Minute 8:26.

What safeguards are in place when the UN arranges for a rich, oil-interested state to assist a poor country with its legal filings? Beyond the UN, when India assists Myanmar with its filing, does anyone thing that India doesn't have an interest in Myanmar's energy resources, on and off-shore? While that may be between India and Myanmar -- where Aung San Suu Kyi now faces more punishment, for an uninvited visit to her in house arrest -- when the UN sets up the deal, it should answer the questions. Watch this space.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/los2somalia051309.html

At UN, Sri Lankan Carnage Boiled Down to 9 Paragraph Press Statement, Starvation

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may8srilanka051309.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 13 -- In a compromise heavily dominated by China, the European Union's UK, Austria and France congratulated themselves Wednesday on the passage of a nine-paragraph “Press Statement” by the Security Council on Sri Lanka.

While the government shells the civilians trapped in a dwindling area now smaller than New York's Central Park -- more like Tompkins Square Park, said one wag -- paragraphs two and three of the Statement condemn the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam.

Paragraph four expresses concern about “the continued use of high caliber weapons in areas with high concentrations of civilians,” without directly saying who is responsible for the shelling. From paragraph nine, the word “political” in the phrase “find a long term political solution” was taken out.

Inner City Press asked Council President Vitaly Churkin of Russia about this change. I am not discussing previous versions, Ambassador Churkin said. Video here.

After UK Ambassador John Sawers emphasized that the press statement kept the Council unified, Inner City Press asked him why it didn't mention access to the conflict zone by journalists, particular the reporters from UK Channel 4 who were expelled by the government after broadcasting exposes of rape allegations in the camps for “Internally Displaced People.” Sawers said it was a good point, but another Council diplomat soon told Inner City Press that no delegation, so including the UK, had felt strongly enough about journalistic access to raise it as an element.

Austria's Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting explained that there are underlying causes of the LTTE's fight, and that there is long term concern about how the government will run the IDP camps. Inner City Press asked why the EU hadn't pushed to put Sri Lanka on the Council's agenda, if there is long term concern. We didn't have to, he replied, we got the press statement. But what will this press statement do?

At Wednesday's UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked UN Spokesperson about the UN's statement earlier in the week that food was getting into the conflict zone. Later in the day came this reply:

Subj: Your question on ICRC and Sri Lanka

From: unspokesperson [at] un.org

To: Inner City Press

Sent: 5/13/2009 12:40:26 P.M. Eastern Standard Time

Earlier today, an ICRC-flagged ship carrying 25 metric tonnes of food turned back due to fighting in the conflict zone, after the ship was also unable to reach its destination yesterday. An additional 500-tonne shipment of mixed food commodities is ready for departure from Trincomalee this evening. Another shipment of 25 tonnes of food is planned for tomorrow.

We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may8srilanka051309.html

On Sri Lanka, Uganda Says Urgent, Dutch Dodge EU Tariffs and Rights, Ban Waits

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may6srilanka051209.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- As the bombs fall in northern Sri Lanka, the assumption is that the Western members of are doing what they can to help civilians, while developing countries don't care. While it may be, as it seems, that neither care enough, on Tuesday night the Permanent Representative of Security Council member Uganda told Inner City Press of Sri Lanka that for his country "there would be no problem to discuss it in the Council... There is urgency to do something about it."

This is counter to the common wisdom at the UN, that those Council members opposing addressing Sri Lanka include not only China, Russia, Viet Nam and Libya, but also Burkina Faso and Uganda, and Turkey and Japan (the latter two, it is predicted, would abstain). Now, Uganda has said it would have not problem having Sri Lanka on the Security Council's agenda. So why are those countries which supposedly care waiting?

At a panel discussion Tuesday on the European Union and Human Rights, Inner City Press asked the Netherlands' deputy Permanent Representative Piet de Klerk what the EU is going about following up on its favorable tariff treatment to Sri Lankan textiles under the GSP Plus program, on which the EU purportedly considers human rights. DPR de Klerk said he didn't think that human rights were "applicable to this sort of situation." If the killing of thousands of civilians, hundreds in the last weekend alone, does not implicate the EU's notions of human rights, perhaps these notions are bankrupt.

In fact, the EU session was sponsored by and held in a facility of Banco Santander, which beyond financial problems was identified as having laundered money, with Riggs Bank, for Chilean human rights violator Agusto Pinochet.

And while the Ugandan Ambassador speaks of the "urgency" of the situation in Sri Lanka, well placed sources tell Inner City Press that while Ban Ki-moon still says he is considering going to Sri Lanka, it would be in days or weeks, when the final offensive is done. As Inner City Press has told senior Ban advisers, that would be too late. If Ban wants to turn over a new leaf or be perceived differently, now is the time.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may6srilanka051209.html

At UN, Beneath the Glitz a Trust Fund for Victims in Uganda and the Congo

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: News Analysis
www.innercitypress.com/tfv1unodc051209.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- Complete with Alec Baldwin and a slew of fashion designers, Tuesday night at the UN saw the type of hype event that often debases the Organization. In the name of the children of Uganda, a country where the UN Development Program funded a forcible disarmament program which resulted in burned villages and children chained until exchanged for guns, the UN held a fundraiser, $250 to enter. The honored guest was painter Ross Bleckner, who garnered praise from Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.

The UN Office of Drugs and Crime had issued a press release puffing a "group of distinguished leaders in the arts, entertainment and business communities to serve on the Benefit Host Committee for the exhibition opening, including: Graydon Carter, artists Jeff Koons, Chuck Close and Brice Marden, designers Donna Karan, Calvin Klein and Rachel Roy, Harry Belafonte, Academy Award winning actors Nicholas Cage, Rachel Weisz and Mira Sorvino; actors Alec Baldwin, Carey Lowell, Candice Bergen and Ashley Judd, Russell Simmons" -- and that was only on the front page.

There was sushi and fashion photographers, a slew of UN high officials drinking in the scene. But the cause, as it turned out, seemed to be a pure one: the Trust Fund for Victims (TFV), which works in Uganda and the Congo, and is trying to get into Sudan.

Inner City Press interviewed TFV director Andre Laperriere, who described soliciting the art work from former child soldiers, and paying villagers in seeds to rebuild roads to their communities. He took great pains to distinguish the TFV from the International Criminal Court, headed by Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo, who was also in New York on Tuesday, chatting with US deputy ambassador Alejandro Wolff. Moreno Ocampo has become a controversial figure, leading the ICC to be fine for retaliation against a whistleblower and living only for the press.

Laperriere, on the other hand, seemed focused on the victims, on raising money to help better their lives. He said Germany's a major funder, and two corporations - then the head of UNODC, Antonio Mario Costa, swept him away, with talk of an after-party dinner, and of tomorrow's press conference. Watch this site.

Footnote: on the sidelines of the night of hype, the Permanent Representative of Security Council member Uganda told Inner City Press of Sri Lanka that for his country "there would be no problem to discuss it in the Council... There is urgency to do something about it."

This is counter to the common wisdom at the UN, that those Council members opposing addressing Sri Lanka include not only China, Russia, Viet Nam and Libya, but also Burkina Faso and Uganda, and Turkey and Japan (the latter two, it is predicted, would abstain). Now, Uganda has said it would have not problem having Sri Lanka on the Security Council's agenda. So why are those countries which supposedly care waiting? Again, watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/tfv1unodc051209.html

Dow and Pinochet Connections to UNA-USA, Questions for Tom Miller

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/una3usajobs051209.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- The UN Association of the USA is, of course, a venerable group, seeking to educate residents of the UN's "host country" on the benefits of the World Body. But where, some ask, is accountability? Last month at a UNA-USA event, participants were charged $10 to hear from two UN staffer members how to get a job at the UN.

When Inner City Press asked how this complied with the UN's statements that money is never requested in connection with a search for a UN job, the UN speakers said that UNA-USA would answer. But they have not. A staffer, at a human rights event earlier this month, said "that was a local chapter." But what is the answer?

Now, journalists at the UN including Inner City Press are asked to attend a "meet and greet" with UNA-USA's new president, replacing longstanding William Luers: Tom Miller, described as a former US Ambassador to Greece. But a cursory Google search finds a 2006 Irish Times article entitled "Watering down of EU regulations on chemicals proves power of lobbyists," which reported that

"the US ambassador in Greece, Thomas J Miller, met Dow Chemical executives 'to discuss how to engage the Greek government.' According to an internal State Department cable, the embassy 'advised them that they should activate their European industry colleagues' and 'identified appropriate Greek government officials for industry contact and explained how best to approach them based on their political and philosophical orientation.'"

While lobbying for US companies like Dow on how to "watered down EU regulations on chemicals" might be a plus in US diplomatic circles, how it plays in the realm of the UN remains to be seen. Then again, Miller's predecessor Luers was linked to the pro-Pinochet "Operation Condor," click here for that.

The post pays over $200,000 a year.

And when a journalist asked the UN to back up the statement, made in Washington in March, that the US owns over $1 billion to the UN, the spokesperson first said, come upstairs for the evidentiary support -- and then said, it's UNA-USA's number. These are the questions for Mr. Miller, this week and going forward. And this, some advice that UNA-USA, which doubles as the "Business Council for the UN," offers online:

Once a supplier has researched the United Nations market and has identified the agency or agencies with which it wishes to conduct business, it must commit itself to establishing long-term relationships with U.N. officials and procurement officers at an agency's headquarters and field offices. Frequently, these relationships provide valuable additional information to suppliers about upcoming contracts, technical specifications for these contracts, and existing competition for a contract award that would not otherwise be available.

While there does not yet exist a public advertising system that notifies suppliers of all or most upcoming contracts throughout the U.N. system, individual agencies increasingly rely on their websites to publicize contracts. Nevertheless, there is no substitute for personal relationships with procurement officers, who can provide added insight to the procurement process.

This does not seem to be the sort of policy the UN should be recommending. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/una3usajobs051209.html

As US Joins UN Rights Council, Washington Post Mulls Closing UN Bureau

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unhrc1wapo051209.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 12, updated -- Amid the modulated hoopla Tuesday morning surrounding the election of the United States to the UN Human Rights Council, Inner City Press learned of an opposite trend of pull-back from the UN by American, or at least American-based media. The venerable Washington Post is moving to close its UN bureau, by the end of 2009 at latest, sources said. Post correspondent Colum Lynch, who has broken stories about abuse by peacekeepers and procurement corruption, will no longer daily be covering the UN "from inside."

While the financial crisis, globally and of newspapers, is sure to be presented as the rationale, others wonder if the drop-off in charisma and flash in the transition from Kofi Annan to Ban Ki-moon does not also play a factor. CNN, for example, no longer opens its UN office every day. Correspondent Richard Roth, after man in the street interviews about the global financial crisis and some spring baseball stories, is said to be trying to get the Human Rights Council story a spot in the network's Situation Room. The World Body, some says, just doesn't rate anymore.

Another network correspondent mused, of the Washington Post's plans, that the work space in the UN is free: why would they be closing? Ban Ki-moon's head of management Angela Kane has floated and conflicted a draft proposal to charge rent to the press in the future. With major media pulling back from the UN, some wonder why the UN would try to make it more difficult to cover the organization and its work.

While we report further on this story, for now we wish to note Lynch's unassuming but fact-uncovering style, both at the Security Council stakeout and in the UN briefing room... Lynch has not settled for political correctness, has not left facts unreported. Hence this interim piece.

Footnote 1: Seemingly connecting these two competing trends, Lynch was Tuesday morning at the stakeout in front of the General Assembly vote asking US Ambassador Susan Rice a question -- or seemingly trying to. As he asked three minutes into Amb. Rice's stakeout, she walked away. Apparently, he did not shout loud enough. We report, you decide: video here, from Minute 3:30.

From the mea culpa department, it has been pointed out that in an earlier version of this story, a journalist who Amb. Rice said was mumbling was identified as Lynch. (Since he was mumbling, the mis-identification occured, and was repeated at the noon briefing.) "You're mumbling," Ambassador Rice told the jounalist. Video here, from Minute 1:21.

"Mumbling? Oh my God," he said, and then continued to ask Rice to respond to charges that given the membership of human rights abuses, the Council cannot be effective. We do not agree, Rice said, and then seemed to refuse Lynch's question: video here, from Minute 3:30.

Footnote 2: Craig Mokhiber also said, of the UN in Sri Lanka, where interment camps alleged to be site of sexual abuse by soldiers and even of starvation are funded by the UN, that the UN must itself abide by international law. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unhrc1wapo051209.html

For UN Human Rights Council, 20 Countries for 18 Seats, Nigeria, Azeris on the Cusp

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/hrc1fixed051209.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 12, updated -- The 2009 elections for the UN Human Rights Council, while drawing last minute outrage from a range of non-governmental organizations, seems largely a foregone conclusion. Most regional groups, including the oft self satisfied WEOG, Western European and Other Group, presented consensus slates with the same number of candidates as seats. New Zealand backed down for the U.S., perhaps in exchange for the U.S. dropping its candidates in the face of new UN Development Program Administrator Helen Clark.

Freedom House, a now hybrid group, sponsored a session with Saudi and Cuba dissidents in the office of Bahai. Afterwards, Inner City Press asked why Freedom House, unlike co-sponsor UN Watch, had joined a wider, mostly liberal coalition. It is good to work together was the answer. But the liberal coalition complained last time that despite their endorsement of Zambia, Freedom House broke ranks.

UN Watch, speaking truth to power, noted that some groups it left unnamed have a revolving door with the UN system. They were diplomatic, not wanting to attack their Geneva colleagues. But it is not rocket science: Human Rights Watch in Geneva has a director from the UN. The door spins the other way, too: to be appointed a special rapporteur now requires the support of member states, “the Pakistan's of the world,” as one NGO put it. Those seeking careers in human rights are holding their tongues. Careerism is a killer, in this field as others.

The slates, for election on May 12, include only 20 countries running for 18 seats. The only contested regions are Africa (six candidates for five seats; only Nigeria did not submit a voluntary pledge, according to the GA; Mauritius or more likely Djibouti may end up with the short end of the stick) and Eastern Europe (three for two, with Azeris on the cusp).

Only two will lose out -- if they don't drop out in advance in the secret balloting. Freedom House has denounced Azerbaijan, Cameroon, China, Cuba, Djibouti, Russia and Saudi Arabia. This last, at a Freedom House event last week, was said to receive UN / UNDP electoral assistance for an election that excluded women. There are other UN silences that we will cover. Watch this space.

Update of 11:11 a.m. -- the vote was taken, and a 45 minute adjournment was announced. In the upper deck, Susan Rice was in the US seat. It wasn't clear if she would speak and take questions afterwards. Mexico's Claude Heller spoke with the Press for ten minutes, while he took congratulations in advance from other Ambassadors. A senior UN political adviser was unwilling, when asked, to commit himself to a prediction. He said there might be a sympathy vote for Djibouti due to their problems with Eritrea. Then again, Djibouti has both French and US bases.

The African backstory is that Kenya horned in, but if both Mauritius and Djibouti are elected along with Kenya, one of the three Regional Group-endorsed candidates from West Africa will lose out...

Update of 12:26 p.m. -- news flash: Djibouti and Mauritius both made it, Kenya bounces, for breaking protocol, it seems. Aberbaijan, as we predicted, lost. But Kenya? Mea culpa...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/hrc1fixed051209.html

Turkey Says UN Must Cooperate with Sri Lankan Army, PKK Off-stage

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may5srilanka051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- New Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu on Monday said the UN should “cooperate with the government of Sri Lanka because we have to cooperate in all efforts against terrorism.” After a weekend in which the UN acknowledges over 400 civilians were killed in north Sri Lanka in the government's assault on the Tamil Tigers' refuge, Inner City Press asked Minister Davutoglu, called by some the “Turkish Kissinger,” if Sri Lanka should be put on the Security Council agenda and if not, how the international community should deal with the mounting crisis there.

“We have discussed this,” Minister Davutoglu began. He had met, among others, with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov at 3, and Ban Ki-moon at 4. “With us, the humanitarian situation is very important and should be improved. We support the UN Secretary General's position and efforts in this sense. But at the same time, it should all be within the rule of law,” meaning cooperation with the government of Sri Lanka.

Inner City Press followed up, would Turkey vote to put the situation in Sri Lanka on the agenda of the Security Council? “We will see,” Minister Davutoglu said, before turning to the question of Cyprus.

Turkey's fight with the Kurdish PKK, just as Russia's Chechen experience, was the elephant in the room or at the stakeout. Some said that the PKK are among very few non-Tamil supporters of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam.

The LTTE's foreign policy, such as it is, seems to be making or justifying the international community's (non) response to the bloodbath on the beach in north Sri Lanka.

Earlier on Monday, Inner City Press asked Austria's Ambassador to the UN what if anything had been accomplished by the European Union ministers' near secret meeting on Sri Lanka. The EU ministers believe it [Sri Lanka] should be addressed by the Council, he said, adding that they are still not sure how. It is getting late....

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may5srilanka051109.html