Saturday, April 18, 2009

At UN, Serbia Complains of UNMIK Budget Cuts, Russia Speaks of Law

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/unmik1budget041609.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 16 -- In a rare mix at the UN of the work of the Security Council and the Budget Committee, Serbia has put onto the Council's April 16 agenda “the fact that the UN Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo budget proposal for the next financial year provides for extensive cuts.”

In an April 15 letter to Council president Claude Heller of Mexico, not made public until this article and upload, Serbia argues that the proposed budget cuts would jeopardize UNMIK's ability to carry out the work Serbia and Russia say its has under Council Resolution 1244 (1999), and criticizes UN Envoy Lamberto Zannier for failing to sign the laws adopted by the Assembly of Kosovo. Such signing would not, it seems, require money.

Kosovo and its supporters, of course, disagree. Kosovo loudly said that it no longer needs UNMIK. Earlier this week, the Kosovar delegation walked out of a meeting of the Central European Free Trade Agreement (CEFTA) held in the Montenegrin capital, Podgorica, because it was told that the law required it to be represented by UNMIK, or under the name of UNMIK and not Kosovo. (The Serbian letter refers by name to CEFTA). The incident in Montenegro sparked something of a name-plate war, less gruesome than the renewed reports that the Kosovo Liberation Army took and traded in organs during the war, charges that EULEX now says there is not enough evidence to investigate.

Nothing so messy is on the Council's Thursday agenda. A Western diplomat told a handful of reporters that it involved a budget matter. Inner City Press later asked Russian Ambassador Vitaly Churkin if this was accurate. No, he said, it is about respect for the Security Council and its resolutions, about respect for international law. Could it also be about the name-plate? And how will the Council deal with a complaint about one of its Mission's budgets? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unmik1budget041609.html

UN Sends Nambiar to Sri Lanka, Quiet Diplomacy and Ships Off the Beach?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: Exclusive
www.innercitypress.com/bansri1lanka041609.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 16, published 11 am, updated 12:20 -- With even the UN now speaking of a “bloodbath on the beach” in Northern Sri Lanka, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has quietly sent his titular chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, a former Indian diplomat, to the region to try what the UN is calling “quiet diplomacy.” Inner City Press is told by well placed sources in and outside of the UN that at first the Sri Lankan government said no, as they have to proposed UK envoy Des Browne. Then they relented, and Nambiar set out.

At Thursday's UN noon briefing, when Inner City Press asked UN Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq to formally confirm that Mr. Nambiar is the envoy and is in Sri Lanka, Haq confirmed both, video here.

Some in Ban's inner circle wonder if it is wise to send an Indian for the job, given India's large Tamil population and response to the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi. But perhaps that, along with Nambiar's ties with the Chinese, is what has made Sri Lanka feel comfortable.

Separately, an idea is percolating to send or even rent boats to park just off the beach, so that if the Sri Lankan government undertakes the final offensive many are predicting, even in the UN, at least there are ships for some civilians. That such ideas are circulating in the UN, while Ban's chief of staff heads to Colombo, to many indicate that things are coming to a head.

In the 27 months of the Ban Ki-moon administration, even many of Nambiar's former colleagues in the diplomatic corps have expressed sympathy for him. On paper, he is Ban's chief of staff or chef de cabinet, a powerful position held, under Kofi Annan, by the UK's Mark Malloch Brown. But Ban's real chief of staff is Nambiar's deputy Kim Won-soo. The power lines are constantly evident, for example at a ceremony this year when senior UN official signed their Compacts with Ban and then a dozen got in line to speak to Kim while Nambiar stood to the side.

Could a mission by Nambiar to Sri Lanka rehabilitate his stature in the UN, show what he and not Kim is capable of? As Inner City Press noted with regard to the United States -- click here for video -- the death toll in Sri Lanka may be Barack Obama's and his advisors' “problem from hell.” That's the title of a book by Obama adviser -- and recent Hilary Clinton adversary -- Samantha Power, now on Obama's National Security Council. Her commitment to the principles in the book, given her continued silence, are being called into question by some. The UN, of course, is supposed to stand for and with civilians in harm's way, and with more than quiet diplomacy.

Sri Lanka loudly rejected the envoy named by the UK, Des Browne. In a government statement from Colombo on which Inner City Press yesterday sought comment from the UK Mission to the UN, the rejection of Des Browne is reiterated. Is Nambiar viewed differently? His supporters point out that he has “connections with the Chinese,” which might be helpful.

Nambiar was India's ambassador to China, and speaks fluent Chinese. China has resisted even discussing the deaths in Sri Lanka in the UN Security Council chamber, on the theory that is it a purely internal matter. UK diplomats publicly take a different view, but some question their commitment to stopping the carnage in Sri Lanka. Zimbabwe, like Sri Lanka, played an anti-colonial card when the UK raised its voice. But in that case the UK pushed forward with a draft sanctions resolution.

Here, the UK resists even criticizing Sri Lanka's detention of UN staff, offering justifications such as that perhaps the UN staff are able to continue to carry out their UN work while in detention in the camps.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/bansri1lanka041609.html

On Sri Lanka, UN Speak of Siege, Calls Cease-Fire Unrealistic, Only Private Diplomacy

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: News Analysis
see Sri Lankan government statement, Inner City Press update 4/18


UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- As military action recommences in northern Sri Lanka, the UN's top humanitarian John Holmes on Wednesday repeated government assurances that it would be in "siege mode." Inner City Press asked Holmes, given his estimate of 100,000 civilians trapped in 17 square kilometers, if the UN is asking for a cease-fire. Holmes said that "a cease-fire is not available, we are trying to achieve something realistic." Video here, from Minute 23:14.

Holmes acknowledged that UN staff members -- who he pointed out are "local" or "Sri Lankan national" staff -- are held without freedom of movement in the camps set up by the government. Inner City Press asked him why he and the UN did not speak publicly about these detentions until being asked about it. Holmes said that the UN chose "private diplomacy."

But see, Sri Lankan government statement, Inner City Press update

Asked twice if there are other countries in which UN staff are being similarly held but the UN is saying nothing, Holmes said "I can't think of a similar possibility at the moment." Video here, from Minute 6:26.

Left unexplained is why the UN is treating Sri Lanka's government different than, for example, those of Sudan or Israel, condemned by the UN for harming civilians while fighting armed opponents and for any detentions no matter how short in duration.

While the UN expends significant time and diplomatic capital seeking political solutions in Darfur and the Middle East, it is unclear what if anything is being done in the case of Sri Lanka. Inner City Press asked Holmes to comment on Sri Lanka's loud ouster of Norway from a mediating role. "I don't think it's a very helpful step," Holmes said, adding that Norway like anyone else if free to contract the LTTE Tamil Tigers if they wish. Video here, from Minute 17:58.

But it is for precisely such contact, combined with damage to a Sri Lankan embassy in Oslo, that Norway was denounced by Colombo. It is such denunciations which seemed to have worked to make the UN much quieter about abuse of civilians and even UN staff in Sri Lanka than the UN would be in any other country.

Inner City Press asked Holmes if the lack of media coverage has made his humanitarian coordination job more difficult with respect to Sri Lanka. He acknowledged that it has, saying that the lack of press access and of images from "major press outlets" limits knowledge and concern, but it's "beyond our control." The UN can presumably control what it says, for example speaking out about the detention of its staff and the exclusion of the press, much less control its funding of detention camps that violate international humanitarian law. We will continue to follow this.

Footnote: Inner City Press asked the UK Mission to the UN two questions on Sri Lanka early on Wednesday:

Does the UK believe that international law and the rights of UN humanitarian staff are being violated by the now-acknowledged detention of UN staff in the Sri Lankan government's “IDP” camps?

It has been reported this morning that Sri Lanka's “minister also told the British Foreign Secretary that there was concern that the LTTE would continue to consolidate its fortification of the No-Fire Zone.” Please confirm the accuracy of that, and of this and if so, does the UK interpret it as saying that an offensive on the No-Fire Zone and the civilians in it will begin? What did the UK Foreign Secretary say?

As of press time five hours later, the answer has been referral to Minister Miliband's April 12 statement. As more answers arrive we will report them on this site.

Click here for an Inner City Press YouTube video, mostly UN Headquarters footage, about civilian deaths in Sri Lanka.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ocha7srilanka041509.html

UN's Lack of Risk Assessment May Delay Capital Master Plan, Force Exit of Officials

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/uncmp1riskdss041509.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 15, updated -- The UN's multi-billion dollar relocation and rehabilitation Capital Master Plan may be delayed by the failure of the UN's Department of Safety and Security (DSS) to conduct risk analysis of the relocation spaces.

In the third of a series of resolutions complaining about DSS, the Staff Council has unanimously "not[ed] the multiple failures of the Chief of the Security and Safety Services at Headquarters to follow mandated procedures" and has now "request[ed] the Secretary General to suspend all scheduled staff transfers to the new office spaces until such time as the mandated Security Risk Analyses have been properly executed." [Since on-camera UN Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq said this Resolution 43/5 is not known, Inner City Press puts it online here.]

In recent months, DSS has increasingly been surrounded by scandals, from promotion and placement irregularities exposed in memo leaked to Inner City Press to the death of staff member Jesmel Navoa due to DSS failure or delay in calling New York City's 911 emergency services providers, and to allow them access to UN Headquarters, click here for that story.

The chief of DSS, David Veness, ostensibly resigned in the wake of the deadly December 2007 bombing of the UN in Algeria. He is still however in his office on 45th Street across First Avenue from UN Headquarters -- the only UN building in New York for which a Security Risk Analysis had been conducted. Inner City Press is told by sources that Veness will finally be leaving at the end of April, and that the internal short list process has focused on an American from the U.S. State Department's diplomatic security service.

The man responsible for security of the UN in New York is Bruno Henn. Many DSS officers say Henn is rarely present, and for some time used his official car to drive back and forth to him home in the suburbs. Questions about his educational background and previous employment have gone unanswered by the UN. Now he is being targeted by name by the Staff Union, and blamed for the potentially expensive delay in implementing the Capital Master Plan.

The argument is that a Security Risk Management System complete with SRAs was mandated by the UN Chief Executives Board in October 2004, then by the General Assembly in January 2005. It was implemented at other UN headquarters, in Geneva, Vienna, Nairobi and regional hubs in Thailand, Lebanon, Ethiopia and elsewhere. Only in New York was it not carried out -- and Bruno Henn is blamed.

The counter-argument, as best as Inner City Press can make it out, is that the UN in New York relies on the City's government and its Police Department. But Article 100 of the UN Charter states that "In the performance of their duties the Secretary-General and the staff shall not seek or receive instructions from any government or from any other authority external to the Organization." [Click here for the Charter sections 99 and 100; the former Inner City Press has been citing of late in light of Ban Ki-moon's failure to raise the "bloodbath" in Sri Lanka formally to the Security Council.] More practically, NYC officials have been less than enthusiastic about the UN's security and construction plans.

It is anticipated that the Staff Union, pursuant to its recent resolution, will further brief the Press on April 16. Even before that, Inner City Press will be seek responses from the UN Secretariat, including on specific risks in the current and prospective UN buildings. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncmp1riskdss041509.html

In Sri Lanka, UN Staff Denied "Freedom of Movement" But UN Won't Name Them


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: News Analysis
www.innercitypress.com/ocha6srilanka041409.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- The UN on Tuesday refused to confirm the names of UN staff members held "without freedom of movement" in Sri Lankan government camps, and refused to explain why the UN said nothing about their detention until asked about it by Inner City Press on April 13. UN Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq said that "while the government repeatedly assured" that freedom of movement would be restored, the UN "staff remain in the camps."

Inner City Press asked if this does not violate international law, in that UN staff have functional immunity. Haq did not answer this question, nor explain why the UN had said nothing. He began his reading of his response to Inner City Press' question by saying, "the UN does not disclose the name or location of its staff of their dependents."

But in other cases where UN staff have been detained -- while high profile, consider the UNHCR official taken in Pakistan -- the UN loudly demands their freedom of movement be restored, and in doing so provides their names if not locations. One reporter listening to Haq on Tuesday wondered if he was in fact saying that the UN fears that the Sri Lankan government would affirmative target it UN staff members it holds, if it were sure who they were.

Since Haq on Tuesday acknowledged that assurances the UN has "repeatedly" gotten from the Sri Lankan government have been false, one wonders how Ban Ki-moon and other UN officials have continued to recite the assurances they have gotten that the government is not or will not use heavy weapons in the so-called No Fire Zone.

The spokesman for UNICEF director Ann Veneman sent Inner City Press a written response on Tuesday, that

Subj: Re: Q re if there are staff in "IDP" camps in Sri Lanka
From: [Spokesman at] unicef.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 4/14/2009 5:09:12 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time

Re. your questions yesterday I can confirm that there are UNICEF staff in the camps. UNICEF has access to the camps so we are able to contact them. UNICEF and UN system colleagues are currently in discussions with authorities about their situation. We will not confirm the names of those staff affected.

Inner City Press has been provided with some names, along with requests that they be published, but holds off for now. Watch this space.

OCHA spokeswoman Stephanie Bunker yesterday replied:

Subj: Re: Q if there are UN system staff / family in Sri Lankan government's "IDP" camps, and if so...
From: [OCHA at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 4/13/2009 3:17:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time

Among those tens of thousands of people who have managed to flee the No Fire Zone in northern Sri Lanka, we are aware that some UN and NGO staff and their dependents have managed to flee as well. As far as we know, they are still in the camps for displaced people set up in the area, and we have repeatedly asked the Government of Sri Lanka to allow them freedom of movement so that they can eventually resume their role as aid workers. While the Government has repeatedly assured us that this request would be met, the staff still remain in the camps. [Inserted into UN transcript here.]

Inner City Press' sources in Sri Lanka say that OCHA chief John Holmes was informed of these people while he was in Sri Lanka, that local staff dissatisfaction with his public silence about it has been growing. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ocha6srilanka041409.html

In Afghan Scandal, UNDP Failed to Oversee, Despite Taking 7% Fee, Dervis and Turkey's Akbank

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: News Analysis
www.innercitypress.com/undp1feeunaid041409.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- After the UN Development Program and UN Office of Project Services repeatedly refused information requests from the U.S. government about missing and misallocated aid money, UNDP spokesman Stephane Dujarric on Tuesday told the Press that "there were lapses, perhaps, in responding" and they he estimates $1.5 million will be returned. But the U.S. government report -- online here -- puts the missing money at over $7 million; a collection agency had to be hired.

Dujarric on Tuesday said that the lesser known agency UNOPS was responsible for the work, that $25 million was, to UNDP, "pass through" money. But what oversight did UNDP provide for the seven percent fee that Dujarric says it charged? Clearly, very little. Funds were reported moved to projects in Sri Lanka, Sudan, Haiti and Dubai. Click here for a 2007 Inner City Press report on UNOPS in Dubai, cracking down on a whistleblower; here for UNOPS' own open bragging about Dubai.

In fact, UNDP has something of a conflict in purporting to oversee or watchdog UNOPS. The director of UNOPS, Jan Mattsson, who notably has refused to follow Ban Ki-moon's call for basic public financial disclosure, was to work at UNDP. Mattsson has been noticeable absent in defending UNOPS against it recent back to back scandals, leaving that job to his also scandal-scarred deputy.

Inner City Press asked, and Dujarric did not answer, which of the individuals named in the U.S. report are still in the employ and pay of UNDP. Carlos Haddad, for example, who refused repeated request for information -- is he there?

Dujarric referred to the "acting Administrator" leading the response to this most recent UNDP scandal. To many, this lacks credibility. Ad Melkert, twice passed over for the agency's top job and tapped by insiders to leave, proclaimed during UNDP's tight-lipped response to a previous scandal that "you ain't see nothing yet." We still haven't.

All of this take place mere weeks before new Administration Helen Clark arrives. Will she move to clean up UNDP, to improve or cancel its lax "pass through money" programs?

Footnote: previously Administrator Kemal Dervis, who quickly landed another UN gig advising Ban Kid-moon for the G-20 in London, has now taken a post with Akbank in Turkey. Inner City Press asked the UN's spokesman if this might implicate the anti-revolving door rules announced by yet another previous UNDP Administrator, Mark Malloch Brown, in the final weeks of the Kofi Annan administration. The spokesman said he wasn't yet sure of the facts of the case. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1feeunaid041409.html

At UN, d'Escoto Fears for Obama's Life, Dubious of Responsibility to Protect, Gustavo Gutierrez to Be Invited

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/pga1r2pobama041409.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 14 -- The responsibility to protect, a doctrine that if a government cannot or does not serve its people others may step in to do so, was called by the President of the UN General Assembly on Tuesday a "new cosmetic improvement" on the "right to intervene." Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, formerly Nicaragua's foreign minister, said that R2P reminds him of the United States' interventions in Latin America "to protect its interests."

Inner City Press asked d'Escoto about his appointment earlier this month of former Indian Ambassador to the UN Nirupam Sen as his advisor on the Responsibility to Protect, as well as on the global financial crisis, and asked if d'Escoto is a supporter of or skeptic about R2P. D'Escoto answered that he has "reservations" about R2P, and may organize an interactive panel on the topic.

D'Escoto has already scheduled for June 1-3 a meeting on the global financial crisis. Inner City Press asked, in light of d'Escoto's public praise of Barack Obama, who might come to the event from the U.S. government. D'Escoto answered that he "hopes God protects Obama," comparing him to Martin Luther King. Immediately after that, d'Escoto praised a book asserting that the CIA killed John F. Kennedy.

When Hillary Clinton engaged in such free association on the campaign trail, there was a fire storm. For d'Escoto, it was one of his least controversial statement. He began the press conference by referring to the UN's failure to bring about a Palestinian state. Asked about his past, he said he is more of a Sandinista today than in 1979.

On why Sen sought and took the post, on April 6 Inner City Press asked d'Escoto's spokesman Enrique Yeves

Inner City Press: I’ve noticed now subsequent to that [inaudible] on the website of the President, a letter appointing Nirupam Sen of India as “Special Senior Adviser” on three topics, including responsibility to protect. First, is the Ambassador a proponent of the responsibility to protect or a doubter, and does this position involve a G-4 visa; do these positions, these Special Adviser positions? And what’s the difference between the Special Advisers, the Senior Advisers and Specials? Is this along the lines of Mr. De Schutter’s or is it something else?

Spokesperson: No, he is a Special Adviser. In this particular case -- as you know, Ambassador Sen had ended his work in the Mission here -- he has been so involved in many of the issues that he talked with President d´Escoto and they both agreed that it would be a very good idea to start giving him advice on all these issues that are mentioned in the letter until the end of the presidency of President d´Escoto. And…

Inner City Press: Is it a paying position, does it involve a G-4 visa?

Spokesperson: It is not a paid position. And on the G-4 visa, to be honest, I don’t know, but I can find out for you.

Inner City Press: Is this the exact same phrasing and status as Mr. De Schutter, Noam Chomsky and…?

Spokesperson: That’s correct. As you know, none of these Special Advisers are getting any salary or have any contractual arrangement as such.

Inner City Press: [inaudible] Ambassador Sen will come as required or will he be based here?

Spokesperson: He is based here and he has already been giving advice since 1 April, which is when his assignment started.

Inner City Press: I’m sorry, I forgot to follow up. On responsibility to protect, can you say something about whether he is thought to be a proponent or a doubter on responsibility to protect?

Spokesperson: Well, I think this is a question for him to answer than for me. But obviously, you will have a chance to talk to him.

See above -- d'Escoto is a doubter, or "has reservations." On April 7, Inner City Press asked

Inner City Press: To this question yesterday of the G-4 visa, did you get to the bottom of it? Whether the Special Adviser, particularly the new one…?

Spokesperson: I understand now that it is up to the [ United States] State Department to decide on this issue, because the Permanent Representative of India is entitled to a G-1 visa and he is now informing the State Department of his new status and he will know what kind of visa he is going to get.

Inner City Press: But it’s the position of the President of the General Assembly that these part-time…this is a part-time position, right? It’s a part-time Special Senior Adviser?

Spokesperson: Correct. I have asked him. Well, I already did and he said he is waiting for an answer from the State Department, so we don’t know yet.

Inner City Press: But he’s definitely seeking one and it’s based on that position?

Spokesperson: Yes, that’s correct.

And so, as soon as he obtained the assignment, Sen applied to the State Department for the visa status...

On Tuesday, D'Escoto described upcoming trips to Venezuela and Cuba, and to Alaska to meet with indigenous people. He has invited to the UN for an April 22 event about "Mother Earth Day" the theologian Leonardo Boff, saying he asked Lula if Boff could come. The Mother Earth Day, sponsored by Bolivia, will feature Bolivian president Evo Morales, who Tuesday ended a five-day hunger strike or fast. Afterwards Inner City Press asked if fellow theologian Gustavo Gutierrez would also be coming. Good idea, d'Escoto said, thank you for reminding me, I'll see if Gustavo can come. And then d'Escoto was gone.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/pga1r2pobama041409.html

Thursday, April 16, 2009

In Sri Lanka, UN Staff Detained in IDP Camps, Names Provided to UNICEF and OCHA, Double Standard Alleged

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: News Analysis


UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- As the Sri Lankan government's detention camps for those leaving the northern conflict zone have become the subject of international controversy, quietly staff members of the United Nations and their families have themselves been interred in the camps, with the UN saying nothing until asked, it emerged on Monday. Inner City Press at the April 13 UN noon briefing asked spokesman Farhan Haq, video here from Minute 13:36 --

Inner City Press: This is on Sri Lanka. There have been some reports that in the camps that have been set up outside the conflict zone from which people can’t leave and can’t receive visitors, that there are some UN staff in these camps -- from OCHA [the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs] and some of the specialized funds programs and agencies. Is the UN aware of any of its staff members that are either held incommunicado or are in camps that they can’t leave from? And if they’re aware, what’s the UN doing about securing their freedom of movement and release from these camps?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: I am not aware of that one, but we’ll check with OCHA and see what they have to say on that.

Inner City Press then e-mailed the spokespeople for OCHA and UNICEF, repeating the question. OCHA spokeswoman Stephanie Bunker replied first:

Subj: Re: Q if there are UN system staff / family in Sri Lankan government's "IDP" camps, and if so...
From: [OCHA at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 4/13/2009 3:17:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time

Among those tens of thousands of people who have managed to flee the No Fire Zone in northern Sri Lanka, we are aware that some UN and NGO staff and their dependents have managed to flee as well. As far as we know, they are still in the camps for displaced people set up in the area, and we have repeatedly asked the Government of Sri Lanka to allow them freedom of movement so that they can eventually resume their role as aid workers. While the Government has repeatedly assured us that this request would be met, the staff still remain in the camps. [Inserted into UN transcript here.]

Inner City Press' sources in Sri Lanka say that OCHA chief John Holmes was informed of these people while he was in Sri Lanka, that local staff dissatisfaction with his public silence about it has been growing.

Some there ask, if the government of Sudan for example interred UN staff members, OCHA and Ban Ki-moon, to say nothing of the U.S., France and UK on the Security Council, would surely loudly scream. Why not in Sri Lanka?

Inner City Press has been provided by local sources with names of staff on information and belief detained in the Sri Lankan government camps including in Vavuniya, even an assistant field coordinator. Inner City Press has put these names to OCHA's Ms. Bunker and to UNICEF's spokesman, who replied

"I am not aware of any UNICEF staff in this situation, but I have been away from the office for a few days. I have asked my colleagues in Sri Lanka and will respond when I get a response from them, hopefully tomorrow."

He has been supplied for four UNICEF staff names. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ocha5srilanka041309.html

UN's Ban "Dismayed" By Fiji Coup, But Won't Forego Peacekeepers, Helen Clark on Spot


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1fiji041309.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- After the military coup in Fiji in late 2006, then-Secretary General Kofi Annan said that unless democracy was soon restored, the UN would stop using Fijian peacekeepers. More than two years later, not only has democracy not been restored, now according even to the UN the Constitution has been abrogated, the judiciary dismissed and elections put off for another five years. Current Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on April 10 expressed "deep dismay" at this, saying he "strongly deplores these steps."

On April 13, Inner City Press asked Mr. Ban's Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq is Ban's "deep dismay" means that finally Kofi Annan's threat, to stop using and paying for peacekeepers from Fiji will be implement. Haq responded that future use of troops from Fiji will be on a "case by case basis." Video here, from Minute 9:39.

But after the coup, the UN continued to rotate Fijian soldiers in and out of Iraq, and Haq admitted their numbers were not capped. Now even with Ban's stated "deep dismay," nothing is said to have changed. How deep is that dismay, again?

Late on November 28, 2006, after Inner City Press asked at that day's noon briefing about it, the UN issued a statement that "The Secretary-General also wishes to stress that further prolongation of the crisis may damage Fiji's international standing, which it has built carefully over the years, as an important contributor to UN peacekeeping operations and more recently as a member of the Peacebuilding Commission." If 29 months followed by suspension of elections for five more years is not "prolongation," what is?

Notably, New Zealand's then-prime minister Helen Clark as reported by Inner City Press in 2007 said, "We've made it very clear to the UN that we do not believe they should be using Fijian troops." Now Ms. Clark is coming in as UN Development Program Administrator, described as the third most powerful position in the UN system. What will she do on this? It will be among her first tests. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1fiji041309.html

On Sri Lanka, Mexico Invokes Responsibility to Protect, Rebukes Colombo's "Inaccuracies"

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unscsri8lanka041309.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- In the midst of a military offensive in Northern Sri Lanka in which over 3000 civilians have been killed, Sri Lanka's Ministry of Foreign Affairs has put out a statement that the government of Mexico, which requested UN Security Council briefings on the issue, has now committed to keep it off the Council's agenda.

Citing the statement, Inner City Press on April 13 asked Mexican Ambassador Claude Heller if the Sri Lankan government is accurate that its Foreign Secretary Palitha Kohona was told by Mexican vice minister Gomez-Robledo that "they do not have any intention of permitting the Sri Lankan situation to be placed on the Security Council agenda" and that "the Mexican authorities saw the parallels between their own experience in Chiapas and the negative impact of a cleverly manipulated propaganda machine." Statement here, video here from Minute 8:42.

"It is not an accurate statement," Ambassador Heller replied. "We were very clear that in the case of Sri Lanka there is a concern of the responsibility to protect the population." Video here, from Minute 9. The Responsibility to Protect is a doctrine, accepted in the UN General Assembly, that if a country cannot or does not protect its population from harm, the international community can intervene to do so.

Sri Lanka's and Foreign Secretary Palitha Kohona's now rebuked mis-summary of their meeting with Mexican officials is not the first case of cognitive dissonance. It has happened regarding telephone calls with US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon.


Inner City Press asked at the UN noon briefing on March 25:

Inner City Press: There was a statement by the Foreign Secretary of Sri Lanka that the country has received no criticism from the UN of how it’s conducting its conflict in the north. He says that Ms. [Navi] Pillay, the Human Rights Commissioner, “is not the UN”, and apparently implies that, in the discussions between the President and the Secretary-General, there’s been no criticism whatsoever of any action of the Government. I wanted to know, is that consistent with your understanding of those calls?

Spokesperson Michele Montas: As far as I know, a number of issues were raised. Humanitarian issues were also raised.

It should again be noted that Sri Lanka's foreign secretary Palitha Kohona, who said the UN High Commission for Human rights "is not the UN" and now blatantly mis-summarizes his meetings in Mexico himself served in and led the UN's Treaty Section. "He knows better," one official told Inner City Press. After a call by US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to President Rajapaksa and his brother(s), Sri Lanka summarized that "Mrs. Clinton appreciated the assurances given by the Secretary of Defense that civilians would not be subjected to any attacks by the military, stating the U.S. looked forward to working with Sri Lanka once the current conflict ends.”

The US State Department, to the contrary, said that “The Secretary stated that the Sri Lanka Army should not fire into the civilian areas of the conflict zone... She urged the President to give international humanitarian relief organizations full access to the conflict area and displaced persons camps, including screening centers."

We are preparing a new report on these camps and centers, watch this site.

Inner City Press also asked Ambassador Heller about the wording of the Council's North Korea Presidential Statement, video here from Minute 6:06, article here.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unscsri8lanka041309.html

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

At UN Council, North Korean Launch Ends in Whimper, Not Bang, Media Decamps

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc9dprk041309.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 13, updated -- With a whimper and not a bang, the UN Security Council is slated to unanimously adopt a presidential statement Monday at 3 about North Korea's "launch" eight days ago, saying it "contravened" -- not that it "violated" -- the Council's 2006 resolution. Over the weekend, Inner City Press put the draft statement online, here. Monday at noon, the spokesman for the Mexican presidency of the Council said no objections had been received by the deadline, thus putting to bed a rumor that Libya might object.

With most of the Japanese press corps having decamped -- click here for an InnerCityPress.org riff about the crews from Tokyo, denounced a "reptile media" by North Korean diplomats -- we are left with the embers of fights fought and misleading Mission statements. Associated Press, for example, has denounced France's Mission to the UN for apparently deceiving it about what Ambassador Ripert said, click here for the AP correction. There has been some push-back to Inner City Press' review of the communications strategies of France, the UK and other Council members, here.

Left unanalyzed in the hoopla about the agreed-to presidential statement is that the underlying sanctions imposed in 2006 are still unlikely to be enforced. Will South Korea actually stop and search ships on their way to North Korea? It is unlikely. Kim Jong-il has won, those trying to flee the country are in worse off state than ever. And so it goes at the UN. If anything transpires, we will live-blog the Council session, below on this page.

Update of 3:11 p.m. -- the Presidency's spokesman has told the Press that there will be no statements by member states in the Chamber, just the read-out by Ambassador Heller, who will then speak at the stakeout. There's grumbling: can the Council expand a sanctions list by a non-binding statement? Duplicitous compromise is a phrase that's used.

Update of 3:59 p.m. -- in a series of back to back stakeouts with the press, the ambassadors of Mexico, the US, China, Japan, Russia, the UK and Turkey all sung the praises of the presidential statement. (Inner City Press asked the one non-DPRK question, to Mexico about Sri Lanka, to be reported later today).

President Heller called the text a positive compromise. Ambassador Susan Rice said that the US views presidential statements, “broadly speaking, as binding” -- a position apparently not shared by the US “plant” in UNAMA, Peter Galbraith, who has told Congress in writing that even resolution, if under chapter 6 rather than 7 of the UN charter, don't have to be complained with. Inner City Press' attempt to ask about the two American journalists DPRK is holding did not result in a response.

Ambassador Takasu put the best face he could on things, saying that at least it was unanimous. (This perhaps implied it was better than a “binding” resolution if even one country, like Libya, has abstained.) Inner City Press and another asked how many companies or entities Japan's wants to be sanctioned. More than three, was the answer.

UK Ambassador Sawers acknowledged that the statement did not impose new sanctions. The Ambassador of China made a statement but took no questions. As he left, he was asked if China will search ships. Russia's Vitaly Churkin took that questions, and said all countries must comply. The Ambassador of Turkey, which chairs the sanctions committee, said the process will start, he is new to it. Then the media decamped and things went back to normal.

And see, http://www.innercitypress.com/unsc9dprk041309.html

UN Continues With Contractor FBI Links to Genovese Crime Family, UN TV Loophole

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN:
www.innercitypress.com/un1petrocelli041309.html


UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- The UN's continuing lack of standards in contracting, and the seedy roots of some of its procurement, are brought into the spotlight by its defense and use of Petrocelli Electric. The firm's founder Santo Petrocelli was indicted for bribery on April 3. He is also reputed by law enforcement sources to have been involved with the Genovese crime family since 1988. Yet when Inner City Press a week ago asked about the matter, UN spokesperson Michele Montas claimed that at the time the contract was entered into, Petrocelli had not been under suspicion:

Inner City Press: I have a procurement question. It’s become clear that, number one, the electrical contractor for the UN, Petrocelli Electric, the founder has been indicted in the Southern District of New York for bribery. At the same time, the operator of UN Television, National Mobile Television Venue Services Group, is basically going bankrupt. Everything is being sold and they’re trying to move their people into the basement area as a final refuge. How can it be that these contracts were entered into with companies in one case being indicted, and in the other case going bankrupt?

Spokesperson Montas: Well, in specific cases, when the contracts were entered, of course, there was no indictment and there were no suspicion that there were any wrongdoings. In terms of the second contract, of course, we can look into this. There are several companies going under and we cannot predict in advance which company will go under. I can try to get more information for you from the Procurement Office, but, at this point, as I said, we cannot predict what will happen when we sign contracts.

Moments later, Ms. Montas was handed a more extensive statement to read

Spokesperson: Matthew, I just got your answer. It was just brought to me. The contract with the Petrocelli Electric Company covers overall electrical installations, operations, maintenance, alterations and major projects, and remains in place even though the UN has suspended the vendor from participating in any further procurement activity. That’s what I have for you. And we’re also aware of the financial difficulties faced by VSG’s parent company, NMT. The Organization is dealing with the situation in consultation with the VSG management. So I got your answer pretty fast for you.

The speed, while appreciated, appeared to reflect that officials in the UN Procurement Division or the Department of Management which is supposed to oversee it had read Inner City Press' earlier story and prepared a response, only to be given to Ms. Montas if the question arose. It was a super-stealth "if asked" that the Petrocelli contract “remains in place.” Days later, the New York Times reported that New York City has long advised all of its agencies to avoid contracting with Petrocelli. So why and how did the UN enter into this contract which, unlike what is has said of the so-called Indian Enron Satyam, it says it cannot or will not get out of?

Sources tell Inner City Press that the Petrocelli contract was shepherded through by since disgraced procurement official Walter Cabrera. Procurement is the appropriate word, as Cabrera was found based on the testimony in federal court of Nishan Kohli to have accepted the services of prostitutes in order to facilitate contracts with now-jailed telecommunications entrepreneur Sanjaya Bahel and his TCIL. What type of an offer did Petrocelli make?

Petrocelli has received other preferential treatment in the UN, even compared to other contractors. As Inner City Press reported in 2007, while UN TV staffers are required to pass through the tourist lines and metal detectors at the 46th Street entrance, fellow outside contractor Petrocelli has been given the right to enter without checking through the staff's 42nd Street entrance.

On the UN and Satyam, expect more news and soon. On the UN's television contract with Venue Services Group of National Mobile Television, which is being sold off in bankruptcy, VSG is barely hanging in, and is said to be desperately looking for a partner and capital infusion. One would expect the UN to scrutinize any party which buys a part of VSG and thus buys its way into the UN. But it is unclear if any procedures for such review are in place. There is talk of a “bridge contract,” which may be awarded to none other than Capital Master Plan controller Skanska. So UN Television would be operated by a construction company? Only at the UN...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1petrocelli041309.html

With UN's Ban in Laos, Silence on Thai Unrest and Rights, Sri Lanka and Missile

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1asia041109.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- With the Thai government having been forced by protests to call off today's ASEAN summit in Pattaya, from Laos UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's issued an “urgent” statement that “I deeply regret the postponement of the ASEAN and related summits and the consequent postponement of my attendance to the events. I understand the circumstances that led the Thai Government to take this difficult decision.”

Days earlier in New York, Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas had been asked if she or Ban had any views or comments on the already mounting protests in Thailand. On April 8 at the UN's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas, video here --

Inner City Press: with the Secretary-General attending the [Association of Southeast Asian Nations] ASEAN trip in Thailand, does he have any comment on the unrest that’s taking place there? Does he have any kind of, I guess either guidance, I mean I know on Moldova he said things should be done peacefully. Why in Moldova and not Thailand? Is there some, is the Thailand street violence less serious or what’s the distinction?

Spokesperson: Well, in the case of Moldova, we had people who were killed, so he’s not going to say anything about what is happening right now in Thailand. As far as we know, everything is set for him for the ASEAN summit and the ASEAN-UN summit. So he is going to go there.

Inner City Press: Is there any chance that… There have been some discussions, including by some UN officials that he might go to Myanmar either before or after the ASEAN summit. Is that now…?

Spokesperson: He is not.

The previous day, Ban had issued a statement that he “strongly believes that any disagreements regarding election results should be resolved by peaceful means and calls on all parties to refrain from violence and maintain calm.” It was directed, not at Thailand, the country he was about to visit, but at Moldova.

Also on April 7, Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas what Ban would raise in the only other stop on his Asian tour, Laos:

Inner City Press: yesterday, you announced that the Secretary-General is going to make an official visit to Lao People’s Democratic Republic on his way to the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN) meeting. There are a lot of reports right now about Hmong people being pushed out of Thailand into Laos. Human Rights Watch for example has put out a report saying that this is a violation of human rights. Is this one of the issues he is going to raise in Laos?

Spokesperson: Most probably that issue will be discussed. (Video).

But by all accounts, Ban's visit to Laos was “human rights free.” The lone AP headline was “UN Hopeful on Future of Laos” and reported that Ban “cited improvements in health, education, life spans and infant mortality rates as well as greater integration with the global economy. He said the Laotian government was committed to achieving the millennium goals... He also said Laos would have to focus greater attention on the environment.”

So much for human rights. What about MDGs and the militarized “environment” for the Hmong? With time on his hands, Ban could personally try to have an impact on the “bloodbath” in Sri Lanka, but since he has of late declined to even call for a suspension of fighting, it seems unlikely. While several countries plan to go ahead with meetings in Pattaya about North Korea's missile launch, Ban's announcement said his entire visit to Thailand has been postponed in light of calling off the Pattaya ASEAN meeting, which he "deeply regrets." "deeply. By contrast, he only "regretted" North Korea's missile test...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1asia041109.html

At UN, France and UK Privatize Their Spin, US Is Terse, S. Africa Longed For

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1press041009.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- In the aftermath of North Korea's rocket launch a week ago, the varying communications strategies of UN Security Council members have been put in bold relief. When the meeting of the Permanent Five members and Japan broke up on the night of April 9, Japan was the most verbose, understandable since the rocket went over their territory. New US Ambassador Susan Rice offered only one line as she rushed out.

Earlier on Thursday, a protest in front of the UN Mission by Tamils, asking for the US to stop the Sri Lankan government's assault on that country's so-called No Fire Zone, went apparently unremarked by Ms. Rice and company. Even China, which opposes both a resolution on the North Korean rocket and the inclusion of Sri Lanka on the Council agenda, offered a sentence to the waiting press.

Strikingly, neither France nor the UK said anything to the assembled UN-accredited correspondents. Increasingly, these countries Ambassador seek to speak privately to a sub-set of the press, outside the UN building, at the Missions or Ambassadors homes.

Earlier on Thursday, French Ambassador Ripert spoke to a by invitation only group of reporters three blocks from the UN, in the access-controlled building France shares with the UK, the UN Pension Fund and others. With numerous France-relevant events raising questions about his country's foreign policy -- the protection of Madagascar's coup leader by France, the French foreign legionnaire who shot and killed a UN peacekeeper from Togo in former French colony Chad, and French foreign minister Kouchner's reported profiting as a consultant for these countries -- Ripert has of late become less accessible.

Walking past the media stakeout this week, he quipped, Madagascar? Nobody cares. But then the reporters who ask about the topic were not invited to his private Q&A. (Language is sometimes misused as an excuse, as when President Sarkozy excluded all but "French" press from a briefing in the UN's Room 226.) It's diplomacy as public relations, rather than information provision for transparency.

Similarly, the UK Mission gives its real view of issues at off-the-record Wednesday breakfasts to which only some reporters are invited. Why the media would allow a Permanent Five member to spin without attribution about smaller countries and even individuals, for example those on the UN's various sanctions lists, is unclear.

These breakfasts are supplemented by social events, such as an April 4 farewell to departing Deputy Permanent Representative Karen Pierce, held in her amble apartment over Park Avenue. Several reporters who critically cover the UK's foreign policy, for example on Sri Lanka, were not invited; at the event, UN officials like Nigerian former diplomat Ibrahim Gambari doled out sensitive information such as Ban Ki-moon's plans to travel, or not, to Myanmar.

In the nature of full disclosure, when Ms. Pierce first arrived at the UN just after the last North Korean missile imbroglio in 2006, after one emergency weekend meeting Inner City Press showed her how to exit the UN and asked, what will happen if North Korea violates this resolution. Ms. Pierce gave an answer, which Inner City Press reported online later that day.

Early the next week Ms. Pierce expressed outrage that she had been quoted. Inner City Press tried to explain that its understanding of the (unwritten) rules of UN press is that Ambassador speak on the record unless they say otherwise, while spokespeople for some reason are usually on background.

Ms. Pierce disagreed, and Inner City Press out of respect modified the article, here. Later her then-spokesman complained when Inner City Press reported what lead Ambassador John Sawers told his breakfast interlocutors, which appeared different than what he said at the public stakeout. (Publicly he said the propriety of a $250 million no-bid contract with Lockheed Martin was a matter for the UN, at the breakfast he defended the contract, for super-camps in Darfur that Lockheed never built, as "necessary," click here for the story.)

There must be a reason for all this private spin. But that ostensible free press and transparency proponents France and UK are private spin's main practitioners is more than a little surprising.

Russia, while having again an increasingly expansive foreign policy, speaks at the stakeout microphone only on issues directly of interest to it, like Kosovo, Georgia and to some degree Iran. Ambassador Vitaly Churkin speaks more to the Russian language press; sometimes if he does not like their reports or even headlines, complaints are made and action taken.

Among the non-permanent members, reporters have recently expressed nostalgia for South Africa's Dumisani Kumalo, who during this week-long private negotiation would have been sure to come to the stakeout to complain about countries like his being excluded, even from getting drafts.

Costa Rica's Jorge Urbina for a time took up the mantle of democratization, but as one of his colleagues told Inner City Press, at the UN Costa Rica is not a big enough country to have heft behind its complaints.

Croatia and Viet Nam, while affable in different ways, speak little to the press. (Former member Panama left little mark if any on the Council's work.) Burkina Faso's Ambassador Michel Kafando is always genial, but he has not spoken to the press in some time. (His country and it capital were ridiculed last week on Jon Stewart's Daily Show, as having delayed the Council's reaction to North Korea's Taepodong.)

Mexico's Claude Heller, before being Council president this month, told some reporters he was not authorized to talk without specific permission from Mexico D.F. (it is hoped that this month's greater openness continues in May and beyond.)

Austria is up and coming, but appears subservient to the UK and France. [They disagree,which is to their credit.] Libya spins mostly to the Arab speaking press. Uganda is rarely heard from; a just-issued human rights report would make for good Q and A. Turkey, surprisingly, speaks very little as well.

The countries one would expect to speak the most at the UN -- the UK, France and to some degree the U.S. -- do so less and less, at least publicly. Then the UN complains about a lack of mainstream coverage, and Council members complain about a lack of effectiveness.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1press041009.html

UN in Congo May Face Indian Withdrawal, Rapes "Happen," Doss Says, Say Yes to Help Arrest Bosco, No Comment on Sudan

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press atUN
www.innercitypress.com/drc1doss040909.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 9 -- Months after the UN Security Council voted to authorize 3000 more peacekeepers for the Democratic Republic on the Congo, still none have arrived. Recent a senior UN official told Inner City Press, speaking on condition of anonymity, that India has threatened to pull out the troops it has in the UN Mission in Congo, MONUC. On April 9, Inner City Press asked MONUC chief Alan Doss if India has filed a communication with the UN about withdrawing from the Congo, and separately if India was even asked to be a part of the 3000 authorized reinforcements.

Tellingly, Doss did not deny India's threat, and did not answer if India was ever considered for the additional 3000 troops. Doss said that Congo's foreign minister attended a meeting hosted by the Indians when Secretary General Ban Ki-moon recently visited the Congo, "but the discussion is on with India about the future of it contingent, but that is a matter between [the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations] and the government." Video here, from Minute 12:20.

Doss is, of course, part of DPKO. In the Congo, Indian soldiers have been accused of sexual abuse and involvement in gold trading, even in returning weapons to rebel groups. A senior Indian peacekeeper was taped praising the now-detained war lord Laurent Nkunda. Congo protested this, and India threatened to leave.

After the briefing, off-camera, Inner City Press asked Doss about detailed reports of over 20 rapes in March by the Congolese Army. Yes, Doss said, "they leave them out there for years, without proper barracks, without bases, without support. These things happen. It doesn't excuse it or exonerate it. But.. we can even help build garrisons." Audio here, in .amr format.

But when the UN known which Army unit committed the rapes, what does it do? Doss said these rapes were by the 85th Brigade, a unit known to have been in league with the FDLR rebels. So now what happens? These are all test cases for the UN.
"

Inner City Press also asked Doss about criticism that during the ill-fated raid on the Lord's Resistance Army in December, MONUC was only told a few hours before the attack began, and thus did not protect civilians butchered by the fleeing LRA. Doss confirmed that MONUC was not involved, then repeated that the UN had only 220 peacekeepers in the area. But might it have had more forces there if it had been told of the raid in advance, at least by its Congolese "partners," to say nothing of the United States, which financed the bungled operation.

Now, Doss said, MONUC may belatedly be building sub-bases in the area. If so, maybe then they can try to ascertain who is flying in weapons and supplies, including satellite phones, to the deadly LRA. Doss said he'd heard these reports, but has no way to know or find out if they are true. Yes the country is large, but with 17,000 peacekeepers, something should be able to be known. Or perhaps, as in the botched offensive on the LRA, the U.S. and other countries including France with surveillance capability are not cooperating with MONUC.

In a strange cooperation note, Doss confirmed that when the DRC government in 2007 asked MONUC to assist in locking up Nkunda's deputy Bosco on a warrant by the International Criminal Court, then MONUC chief William Lacy Swing said yes. Doss said the request "has not been renewed," adding that MONUC will not work with Bosco, now part of the Congolese army, the FARDC.

Inner City Press asked Doss, without answer, how the UN could agree to assist in apprehending an ICC indictee in the Congo, but not for example in Sudan, where president Omar al-Bashir has been indicted. Doss said he would not answer for the UNAMID mission in Darfur. But someone in DPKO or the UN's legal unit should answer this. Perhaps its because the request for Bosco came from a government this is a party to the ICC. But what if the UK or France asked UNAMID to arrest or help arrest Bashir? There are questions that should be answered.

Doss to his credit answered several more, including on the $9 billion Congolese "cooperation" agreement with Chinese mining interests -- Doss said that remarks he's heard from "Chinese sources" tell him the deal is on -- and about an attack earlier on Thursday in Uvira, in which ten people were killed and over 200 prisoners freed in an attack by Mai-Mai forces said to be supported by the Burundi-based FNL. Video here from Minute 22:30. Doss said he'd look into it. We'll see -- watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc1doss040909.html

On Sri Lanka, UN Adopts "Janus Face," Half Calling to Stop Fighting, Hedging Bets

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unscsri6lanka040809.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- The day after UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon declined to call for a ceasefire or even suspension of fighting in Sri Lanka, his top humanitarian official John Holmes published an opinion piece in the UK Guardian calling for just such a pause. At the UN's noon briefing in New York, Inner City Press asked if Holmes' piece is now the UN's position. Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas said, "You will have something more precise on this tomorrow... or the next day." Video here, from Minute 11:33.

Close observers tell Inner City Press that the UN wants to have it both ways. Given the resistance of Sri Lanka's government to any criticism, Ban does not want to call even for a humanitarian pause. But if the "bloodbath on the beach" now predicted by Holmes takes place, the UN doesn't want to be blamed. By publishing his article, by adopting a Janus face, the UN covers its bet.


Meanwhile, the UN-affiliated International Monetary Fund is slated to deliberate on April 25 on Sri Lanka's request for a $2 billion loan to make up for money spent in the military action, and for the detention camps in the north. Some say that with the commitments made to the IMF during the recent G-20 meeting in London, $2 billion is "peanuts.... who cares about human rights?"

From the transcript of the April 8 noon briefing:

Inner City Press: Michele, on this, the piece by John Holmes in The Guardian, I mean, that’s the UN’s call or is it John Holmes’ personal call? I’m just trying to judge whether it was…

Spokesperson Montas: John Holmes speaks not just in his capacity as the humanitarian coordinator, he speaks for the UN.

Inner City Press: I mean, we were both there when the Secretary-General yesterday… he seemed to be calling just for the Government to comply with international humanitarian law as it conducts its… whereas John Holmes is saying there should be a cease… you know, a suspension of hostilities. Which is the UN calling for?

Spokesperson: I can tell you that we will have something more precise on this tomorrow.

Inner City Press: Okay.

Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unscsri6lanka040809.html

UN Puts Convicted Korean Businessman on Global Compact Board, Dismisses Complaints

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ungc1skgroup040809.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- As the UN Global Compact hits its tenth anniversary, questions are mounting about its complaint resolution mechanism, its seeming pro-business slant, even its board of directors. On March 11, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon named as one of six new board members a South Korean businessman, Chey Tae-won of the SK Group, who was convicted of fraud in 2003.

Inner City Press on April 8 asked the director of the Global Compact, Georg Kell, why in the world of CEOs one convicted for fraud would be selected for the board of an entity ostensibly espousing integrity. Kell acknowledged the criminal conviction but said that the Compact is "not a white knight," that one can "learn from mistakes," and that Chey Tae-won's inclusion by Ban Ki-moon onto the board of the Global Compact is "very fitting." Video here, from Minute 49:47.

In 2003 Chey Tae-won, whose SK Group is involved not only in electronics but also oil refining, was sentenced to three years in prison after he was "convicted of inflating the 2001 profit of the conglomerate's trading arm, SK Global, by 1.5 trillion won ($1.25 billion)." He only served seven months in jail; his wife is the daughter of former South Korean president Roh Tae-Woo.

Chey Tae-won held a Korea Night event which Ban Ki-moon attended at the most recent World Economic Forum in Davos. Now his rehabilitation extends to being named to the UN's Global Compact board, and being called "a change agent" by its director. While noting that the the UN's Compact with business was started under previous Secretary General Kofi Annan, the current S-G Ban Ki-moon has embraced the Compact, although he has yet to apply his philosophy of mobility -- no more than five years in any one position -- to it.

At Wednesday's press conference, Inner City Press asked Kell why the Compact's annual report says nothing about the 56 complaints against member companies the Compact has acknowledged receiving. Kell replied that most complaints are "by disgruntled employees" and "we are not an arbitrage organization." Video here, from Minute 53:10.

Inner City Press asked about the complaint against the activities in Sudan of PetroChina, which the Compact has dismissed and on which Kell replied that there is no news, and against Deutsche Bank. Kell said that concerned some "investment in a Central Asian country" but "we don't know the background." Well, Deutsche Bank among other things held over $3 billion in natural gas revenues for Turkmenbashi, the dictator of Turkmenistan. No white knight, indeed. Who's next for the Global Compact board, asked one wag, Bernie Madoff? To be described as a change agent learning from mistakes?

Issues surround the UN's and Global Compact's involvement in the CEO Water Mandate arose, but will be covered in more depth in coming days, as information about the session in Istanbul continues to arrive.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ungc1skgroup040809.html