Tuesday, March 24, 2009

On Sri Lanka, Japan Wants UN Briefing, Austria Concerned about Killing by Both Sides

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsri5lanka032309.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 23 -- As Sri Lanka's government continues to ignore UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's month-old call for a suspension of fighting in the north, it also bragged of China's blocking of a Security Council briefing requested by the Council's European Union members along with, at least Mexico and the U.S.. Pro-government media claimed over the weekend that Japan, along with six other Council members including Turkey and Uganda, was also opposed to any briefing of the Council.

Monday outside the Council, Inner City Press asked Japan's Ambassador to the UN, Yukio Takaso, if this is Japan's position. "No, I don't think that is accurate," Ambassador Takasu said of the report Japan does not want a Council briefing. "We are still hoping for consensus," he added.

Austria's position had been more openly misrepresented, as their support for a Council briefing being based only on the actions of the LTTE or Tamil Tigers. The spokesperson for the Austrian Mission to the UN, Verena Nowotny, in the course of a ten minute clarifying interview with Inner City Press offered the following on-the-record quote, that "because of concern about the humanitarian situation in Sri Lanka, we [Austria] want to make it part of the agenda of the Security Council."

Inner City Press asked Marty Natalegawa, the UN Ambassador of Indonesia which was on the Security Council last year, why some countries are opposing a briefing in the Council about the conflict in Sri Lanka. "It always starts with a humanitarian briefing," he said, referring among others to Zimbabwe and Myanmar, which humanitarian briefings led to formal inscription on the Council's agenda and, in the case of Zimbabwe, sanctions resolutions proposed by the United States and UK, among others.

On March 20, US Ambassador to the UN Susan Rice told Inner City Press that "the United States feels strongly about and concerned about Sri Lanka and we support the provision of it to the Council- a full and updated information on the humanitarian situation." (Strangely, India's National Newspaper the Hindu sourced this quote to a Tamil website, when it is available on-camera on the Internet, and through the US Mission to the UN.)

But another Council diplomat on Monday noted that "every country has its list of priorities," and that for the U.S. that for now is Sudan. The U.S. expended political capital to get a Council meeting on Sudan on March 20; how hard the U.S. is pushing for a briefing of the Council with "full and updated information on the humanitarian situation" in Sri Lanka is not clear.

Likewise, while UK minister David Miliband has said that the UK would like a resolution on Sri Lanka but has held off because it is worse to get resolutions vetoed -- as China and Russia have apparently threatened to do -- it is noted that the UK pushed forward supporting the Zimbabwe draft sanctions resolution even as China and Russia vetoed it. Every country has its priorities.

A senior UN official opined to Inner City Press that even those countries which are troubled by the killing of civilians in northern Sri Lanka, including by the government, are nevertheless reticent to too openly call for a ceasefire. If they do, the official continued, and the Tamil Tigers bounce back and kill civilians, the Sri Lankan government will blame those who called for the ceasefire.

To summarize -- can't tell the players without a scorecard -- those Security Council members which say they are in favor of a Sri Lanka briefing in the Council have the nine votes they would need to get the meeting, if they pushed forward and called the procedural vote they are entitled to, which is not subject to the veto power of China or Russia. But these ostensible supporters, or at least some of them, are "waiting for consensus," as Japan's Takasu said. Such consensus seems unlikely, unless some countervailing concession is made to, at least, China. What might that be? Watch this site.

Footnote: Japan's priority in the Council for now is the threatened April 4-8 launch by North Korea of a satellite or missile. While Japan said it wanted a Council meeting, it now appears they want the meeting only after the scheduled launch. Japan would like a condemning resolution, but others, including China, want only a less powerful Presidential Statement. Negotiations have already begun -- some have ever mis-reported that a Presidential Statement is already being drafted -- and one wonders how this effects Japan's presentation of its ostensible support for a Council briefing on Sri Lanka...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsri5lanka032309.html

Sunday, March 22, 2009

On Sri Lanka, US' Rice Joins Call for UN Council Briefing, ICC's Ocampo Queried, UNESCO Silent


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsri4lanka032009.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 20 -- With the plight of more than 100,000 civilians trapped in Sri Lanka's conflict zone worsening, at the UN on March 20 U.S. Ambassador Susan Rice told the Press that "the United States feels strongly about and concerned about Sri Lanka and we support the provision of it to the Council- a full and updated information on the humanitarian situation." Transcript here, video here.

Inner City Press had asked, at the Security Council stakeout microphone after a US-requested meeting on Darfur, if the U.S. was considering evacuation of the civilians trapped in fighting between the Sri Lanka government and the Tamil Tigers, being "fired on from both sides." Ambassador Rice did not directly address this point, but rather expressed support for a Security Council meeting.

On March 19, UK Ambassador John Sawers told Inner City Press that the "European Union members" of the Council have made a request for a meeting in the Council on the topic of Sri Lanka. The Mexican and Costa Rican Ambassador have indicted they are actively supporting the request. China, described as "vehemently" opposing any Sri Lanka briefing, was said Friday by a Western diplomat to be asking for more time, "delaying the process."

Close observers of the Council note that even if China remains opposed, a meeting can scheduled by a procedural vote, on which China's veto rights would not prevail. The US and UK have used this procedure before, for example as noted by one observer in the case of Zimbabwe, which China and Russia likewise called only an internal matter, as they call Sri Lanka.


One wag noted that this standard of only meeting on "threats to international peace and security" give a perverse incentive to groups like the Tamil Tigers to internationalize their conflicts, by striking outside the national borders.

All this takes place two days after the UN involuntarily admitted counting 2,683 civilian killings in Sri Lanka from January 20 to March 7 of this year, in a UN document leaked to and published by Inner City Press. The document, placed online here, is now in the possession of the numerous Council diplomats and Ambassadors, and of senior UN political and human rights officials.

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay recently said that war crimes may be being committed in Sri Lanka by both the Tamil Tigers and the Sri Lankan government. Outside the Security Council's meeting Friday on Sudan, whose president Omar al-Bashir has been indicted for war crimes by the International Criminal Court, Inner City Press got the chance to ask ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo if, following Ms. Pillay's analysis, he is considering action on Sri Lanka. They are not a state party [to the ICC's Rome Statute], Ocampo replied. He has been criticized, most recently by the President of the UN General Assembly Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, for seeking war crimes indictments only in Africa.

An ICC staffer traveling with Ocampo told Inner City Press that following Ms. Pillay's public statement about war crimes in Sri Lanka, the ICC opened a file, or database. But she repeated that Sri Lanka not being a member of the ICC creates jurisdiction problems, and noted that the Tamils have not even, as for example the Palestinians have, made a formal request for jurisdiction.

The Security Council members headed from their meeting to a weekend retreat with UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, who has previously without effect called for a suspension of fighting. They will be back for Council meetings on Monday. Watch this site.

Footnote: at the UN noon briefing on March 18, nner City Press asked UNESCO's Assistant Director-General for Education Nicholas Burnett why his agency, while condemning crackdowns on the press in the Philippines and elsewhere, has said nothing about the newspaper editors locked up during the current conflict in Sri Lanka, and journalists previously killed. Mr. Burnett said, I can get you an answer. Video here, from Minute 18:36. Three hours later his spokesperson asked Inner City Press to email the questions, which was done:

As I asked at the briefing earlier today, what has UNESCO had to say about the recent imprisonment of two journalists in Sri Lanka, on which RSF is requesting UN action

This is a specific request, also, for comment on 1) the killing of a journalist described at http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=30312

and 2) on the comments which the Sri Lankan President’s brother, Defense Secretary Gotabaya Rajapaksa made about Vithyatharan in an interview for ... Australia's Special Broadcasting Service (SBS). “He is involved in the recent air attack and I am telling you if you try to give cover-up for that person you have blood in your hands,” Rajapaksa said. “And if someone says he is arrested because he is in media, that person also has blood on his hands.”

UNESCO's answers, not received in the two days the question was asked at noon, will be published on this site after they are received.


And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsri4lanka032009.html

UN Still Won't Answer Who Funds Somali Government, Ould Abdallah Bemoans Media

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1somalia032109.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 21 -- While Somalia's new foreign minister Mohamed Abdulahi Omaar painted a strangely upbeat picture of the last two months in Mogadishu, UN envoy Ahmedou Ould Abdallah stood by but clarified his call for a moratorium on reporting of the killing of civilians by peacekeepers. Neither man would say on-camera who funds the new Somali government.

Inner City Press asked Mohamed Abdulahi Omaar, who responded that the airport is now under government control and can be taxed. Is that enough to pay the Parliament, the number of members of which has recently doubled? No, he conceded, it is not. He said the "international community" is making up the difference. Video here, from Minute 6:16. More generally, he called for more peacekeepers, from Uganda and Burundi.

Ould Abdallah, whose comments likening those who reported on the killing of bystanders by African Union peacekeepers with the Milles Collines radio station in Rwanda triggered calls by human rights and press freedom groups for retraction or resignation, expressed frustration that every time there is good news about Somalia, "some Somali grabs the headlines" with a violent act. He said he had "expected a grenade" to be thrown on Friday, to overshadow the UN Security Council proceedings. Video here, from Minute 4:53. Coverage after the meeting criticized Mohamed Abdulahi Omaar's call for more peacekeepers.

Ould Abdallah graciously asked Inner City Press about its June 2008 visit to the Somali peace talks in Djibouti. Who paid for the talks, Inner City Press asked for the second time. Ould Abdallah referred the question to his spokesperson Susie Price. But when Inner City Press followed up with her off-camera, all she would say is "ask UNDP." An email to UNDP resulted in a generic statement to look on UNDP's website, or to await some subsequently answer, which will be reported after receipt.

In 2008, it emerged that the UN was paying at least $14 million to the Somali government. But from which donors did the money come, and what was is used for? After the stakeout on Somalia, an advisor to Ould Abdallah told Inner City Press that while the government now controls the port, opponents are opening for business another port, which will deny revenue to the government.

Inner City Press asked Ould Abdallah about the disclosure in the UN's most recent report on Somalia that a UN staff member had been held by kidnappers since mid-2008. This is an important question, Ould Abdallah said, promising to look into it and give an answer by telephone. Video here, from Minute 10:04. We'll be waiting for the call.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1somalia032109.html

At UN, Who Can Speak At Darfur Meeting, Sudan Asks, As Ocampo Arrives -- Ostensibly on Uganda, He Will Not Explain


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc3darfur032009.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 20, updated -- In the wake of Sudan's expulsion of 13 non-governmental organizations from Darfur, a procedural fight broken on Friday in the UN Security Council, with Sudan saying it has a right to be heard at a public briefing by top UN humanitarian John Holmes scheduled for Friday afternoon. The UN Spokesperson's Office at 11:06 in the morning sent out an "urgent" update, while the Council met on the subject of Somalia. The update said that the "Council will hold consultations on the subject of Sudan immediate following the adjournment of the [Somalia] meeting currently in progress."

Inner City Press immediately inquired Friday morning with a range of diplomats and learned that while a public meeting on Darfur had been proposed for Friday afternoon, when Sudan asked to participate and speak, the proposal had to be changed. The plan then switched to a public "briefing," by John Holmes, after which no members would speak in public. To Sudan and its supporters -- and it has some -- this seemed like sleight of hand, a hit and run proceeding in which they would not be heard. Emergency consultations were then set, on no other topic than the format.

A Western diplomat scoffed that Sudan is using the Council's schedule -- a retreat with Ban Ki-moon is planned to begin on Friday -- to try to block even Holmes' briefing. He said that initially the idea was just to have Holmes briefing publicly, then to take off to the retreat. But if Sudan speaks, "everyone else will want to." He argued that Sudan "could just come and speak at the stakeout."

On Thursday the US Mission to the UN told the Press that they had pushed to get a Friday meeting on Darfur. They explained that some had initially demurred, saying it could be done next week. But with the expulsion of 13 NGOs just after the International Criminal Court indicted Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir for war crimes, and President Bashir's more recent statements that he might expel diplomats and "security forces" from the country, the US pushed for the meeting, it said. But when a country is discussed in the Council, in a public meeting, it has some right to speak. Hence the standoff. Watch this site -- and note that at 11:38 a.m., ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo walked into the Council, then paced around outside clutching his cell phone.

Footnote (followed by updates) -- While the UK, and the U.S., are titularly in support of Austria's and Mexico's request for a second Council meeting on Sri Lanka, it appears they are putting substantially less political capital into the Sri Lanka request than for even interim briefings on Darfur. The above-quoted Western diplomat agreed that each country's political capital is limited, and consciously deployed, but added that the deployment is also based on the amount of push-back.

Does this mean that Sri Lanka has more or stronger supporters in the Council -- meaning, among China and Russia of the Permanent Five member -- than Sudan does? Or that this, added to the procedural point that Sudan is, and Sri Lanka is not, inscribed on an ongoing basis on the Council agenda makes the US and UK less likely to "waste" energy on overcoming objections to a Sri Lanka briefing now that the UN's knowledge of 2,683 civilian deaths from January 20 to March 7 is known?

Update of 12:44 p.m. -- on the mystery of Luis Moreno Ocampo's strutting presence in the Security Council as members fight about the format for their Darfur meeting, Ocampo refused to answer any questions. His spokesperson, more polite, explained that Ocampo was in Washington for talks, then came to New York to speak with representatives of Uganda about the Joseph Kony / Lord's Resistance Army case. The claim then is that his presence has nothing to do with the Sudan case -- despite Ocampo standing in front of the Council chatting with representatives of Missions to the UN of the United States and other countries. As Inner City Press conversed with a UN agency spokesman and Ocampo walked by, he was asked: are you really here only on Uganda? He smirked but said nothing. The agency spokesman said, you can't even call that a no comment...

It was explained -- not by Ocampo -- that when for example UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Navi Pillay says that war crimes may be being committed by both the Tamil Tigers and the Sri Lankan government, the ICC Prosecutor's Office puts a notation in a data base. Since Sri Lanka is not a signatory of the ICC's Rome Statute, it is said, there is nothing they can do. It was noted that "the Tamils have not even tried to argue for jurisdiction, like the Palestinians have." Watch this site.

Update of 4:09 p.m. -- the outcome of the consultations was a public meeting, with "everyone" speaking, including Sudan and others. The UK Ambassador John Sawers referred to Abyei; Susan Rice intoned and inveighed against president Bashir. Russia's Vitaly Churkin, on the other hand, called the proceedings "symptomatic," hastily convened and politically motivated. Luis Moreno-Ocampo, long after his meeting with the Ugandan mission, is still hanging around the Security Council in the afternoon, now without the Uganda fig leaf. The Ambassador of Liechtenstein, too, is around, the head of the state parties to the ICC's Rome Statute. One would expect Ocampo to answer some press questions while here. But so far, not.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc3darfur032009.html

Candidate for UN's #2 Afghan Post Dismissed Chapter VI of UN Charter, Ignored Arms Embargo, Kai Eide Won't Comment


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2galbraith031909.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 19 -- The controversy surrounding the reported nomination of American diplomat Peter Galbraith to the UN's second-highest post in the UN Mission in Afghanistan, UNAMA, was directly raised to UNAMA chief Kai Eide on Thursday, without it being resolved. Eide insisted that Secretary General Ban Ki-moon is still considering candidates for the post. But when Inner City Press asked if there are any candidates other than Galbraith, Eide said he would choose not to comment. Inner City Press asked for Eide's views on Galbraith's actions and statements with respect to UN sanctions while he was U.S. Ambassador to Croatia. Eide said he will leave that to the Secretary General.

What the Secretariat should and now does know is that Galbraith is on record that it is not a violation to ignore UN Security Council resolutions which call upon" states to cooperate with Sanctions Committees, "including reporting any information brought to their attention concerning violations of the embargo," as long as such calls are under Chapter VI of the UN Charter. This evasive and legalistic approach to UN Security Council resolutions is hardly one to be expected from someone subsequently aspiring to become a high UN official.

A problem with Galbraith re-becoming a U.S. official, sources say, is a series of allegations that he lobbied for the Kurdistan Regional Government without filing a registration.

UN Security Council sources asked Inner City Press about the UN-relevant aspects its March 18 report on Galbraith's past, to which this is added, from Questions for the Record Submitted to Ambassador Galbraith in the House International Relations Committee on May 30, 1996, at page 130 --

Question 6. Did the United States notify the U. N. Sanctions Committee of any Iranian arms transfers to Bosnia in violation of the international arms embargo? Was the United States required to provide notice of such transfers of which it was aware by U. N. Security Council Resolution 740 or by any other U. N. Security Council resolution?

Amb. Galbraith's Answer: The United States did not violate any obligations under this resolution. Resolution 740 contained a number of provisions, one of which "call(ed) upon" states to cooperate with the Yugoslavia Sanctions Committee, "including reporting any information brought to their attention concerning violations of the embargo." By this resolution, the Council did not impose a legally binding obligation on member states to submit particular information, as is evidenced by the lack of a reference in the resolution to Chapter VII of the UN Charter. (Here at Pg. 130).

Eide on Thursday said it is up to Ban Ki-moon. So what is up with Ban Ki-moon? Will he appoint UN officials, some of whom respect Security Council resolutions under Chapter VI of the UN Charter, and others of whom like Galbraith do not?

Eide also said that "I believe that the use of between 500 million and 1 billion dollars are never reported to the Afghan government." Inner City Press asked him on what he based the statement. Eide replied it is an estimate based on which countries and entities do not report. Inner City Press asked Eide to name the entities and countries. I'll leave that for you to figure out, Eide replied.

Inner City Press asked Afghanistan's Ambassador to the UN Zahir Tanin which countries this referred to. "Kai Eide should tell you," Ambassador Tannin replied. But Eide did not say. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2galbraith031909.html

At UN, Union Demands Investigation of Deadly Ambulance Delay, Departure of UN Security Chief


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undss5chaos031909.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 19 -- While the UN Administration refuses to provide answers about its delay of ambulance responding to the fatal stroke of UN staff member Jesmel Navoa on March 5 in the Organization's basement printing plant, Thursday the UN Staff Union adopted a resolution relating Mr. Navoa's death to the management of the UN Department of Safety and Security.

In a closed-door meeting Thursday afternoon, union Unit leaders decried that David Veness, the DSS chief who ostensibly resigned more than a year ago after the deadly bombing of the UN in Algiers, remains in place, adding to "uncertainty." Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon was called to do more to ensure safety, including access by emergency services.

Concerned rank and file security staff intend to meet with Ban's Deputy Asha Rose Migiro following Veness' refusal to implement a previous Staff Union resolution which called for an independent, external investigation of promotion and placement irregularities they said was documented by a leaked internal e-mail published by Inner City Press on February 6. Migiro will be asked to start the investigation. At Thursday's Staff Union meeting, the call was for an investigation of the circumstances of Mr. Navoa's death by the Office of Internal Oversight Services. Staff members linked the death of Mr. Navoa to one a year ago on the journalist's floor for of the UN, also reported on by Inner City Press, here.

On the evening of March 5, Mr. Navoa had a stroke in the printing plant in the UN's third sub-basement. According to his colleagues present on the scene, there was a near hour-long delay in an ambulance being let it. The next day, Mr. Navoa died in the hospital. Inner City Press ran an exclusive report and then on March 9 asked UN Deputy Spokesman Marie Okabe

Inner City Press: Thursday of last week...there was a death that took place in the building in the third subbasement and they have expressed concern that the ambulance wasn’t allowed in for an hour. I am wondering if you’re aware of that and what is the protocol for that?

Deputy Spokesperson: I am not aware of that, but I will look into that and we will get you something.

Ten days later, no information has been provided. Now questioning is expanding. When will answers be provided? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undss5chaos031909.html

On Sri Lanka in UN Council, China Blocks March 26 Meeting, Vote May Be Called


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsri3lanka031909.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 19 -- The day after the UN involuntarily admitted counting 2,683 civilian killings in Sri Lanka from January 20 to March 7 of this year, efforts to hold a second UN Security Council meeting on Sri Lanka were described to Inner City Press by a range of Council diplomats. Non-permanent Council members including Austria, Mexico and Costa Rica have requested the meeting for March 26, under the heading "Other Matters" since Sri Lanka is still not a formal item on the Council's agenda.

These members thought they had agreement from other Council members, but now China is "vehemently" opposing any discussion in the Council of the plight of civilians in the Sri Lankan conflict. China argues that it is "merely an internal matter," and not a threat to international peace and security.

Sri Lanka's mission to the UN has contacted Council members to make this same argument. Those requesting the meeting are considering calling a procedural vote, on which there are no veto rights. If they have nine votes for the meeting, it will be held -- unless they don't even call for a vote. The position, and strength of commitment, of Western Permanent Five members is not known at press time. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsri3lanka031909.html

As UN on Madagascar Can't Call a Coup a Coup, It Invites Battlestar Galactica

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2malagasy031809.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 18 -- As the elected president of Madagascar was overthrown by the military, the UN's Spokesperson in New York said "the legality of the situation is not something that we can determine... A court said it is legal." No matter than the military handed power to an opposition leader who is, under the Malagasy constitution, years too young to serve. Inner City Press asked

Inner City Press: do you have any statement on Madagascar now that it’s been confirmed the President stepped down? What’s the United Nations mediation role now that the coup has essentially taken place?

Spokesperson Michele Montas: The mediation group is still there. What I can say is that the United Nations does not support any unconstitutional change in Government. Our concern is stability and peace on the island, we have said that before, and a transition through a democratic process based on broad consensus to legitimize any arrangement, as the Secretary-General made clear in his statement yesterday -- the one that Marie read for you. And we keep on appealing for calm and stability. That’s really all I can say. Yes.

Question: [inaudible] yesterday would not say whether or the Secretary-General considers it a coup. Does he consider it a coup today and, if not, why not?

Spokesperson Montas: Well, the legality of the situation is not something that we can determine. A court said it is legal, although, we also heard reports that such a decision was made under duress.


The African Union is considering this question at this moment and we certainly do not condone unconstitutional changes in Government -– I repeat that line –- and our focus at the moment is to urge a transition through a democratic process. Whether we call it this or we call it that is something that will be defined later."

In a surreal event Tuesday in the UN, the "Mission of Madagascar" sponsored an event and concert for the Millennium Development Goals. Who was in change was not clear.

Footnote: Meanwhile in an equal surreal event in the UN on March 17, regarding Battlestar Galactica, it was clear who was in charge: President Laura Roslin, represented by actress Mary McDonnell. Her co-star Edward James Olmos called for UN Peacekeepers in Mexico. A hundred high school students attended and asked questions. Afterwards at a reception, Inner City Press learned of UN staffers in the Department of Political Affairs and Film Society, who referred Battlestar to the Department of Public Information. It was something of a coup, headlined geekery at the UN. It could be worse...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2malagasy031809.html

At UN, Alleged Sanctions-Violator Galbraith In Line for Afghan Post, UN Jabs and Hides


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1galbraith031809.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 17 -- As the UN refused for the second straight day to confirm it is considering controversial American diplomat Peter W. Galbraith for its second-highest post in its mission in Afghanistan -- it declined to back up its claim that March 16 Times of London story breaking the news was "factually inaccurate." On March 16, Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe said that

the story characterizes the relationship between the United Nations and the United States concerning Afghanistan wrongly. When the Secretary-General met with President Obama last week, the President spoke highly of the Secretary-General's Special Representative, Kai Eide... The article is not only factually inaccurate but also counterproductive of the United Nations efforts, together with the international community, to bring peace and stability to the long suffering people of Afghanistan."

That an article may be "counterproductive of the United Nations efforts" is not a basis for the UN to publicly criticize it. We'll see if the UN ends up appointing Galbraith as the UN's Kai Eide's deputy in Afghanistan -- the Washington Post reports the posting as a done deal, in service of U.S strategy.

Inner City Press had asked senior UN officials to confirm or deny that Galbraith was being considered for the UN's panel to investigate the murder of Banazir Bhutto. One senior official, always a good source, responded coyly that Galbraith is in line for another UN post, which he would not name. Now it appears to be in Afghanistan. Inner City Press on March 16 asked Ms. Okabe

Inner City Press: on this Galbraith question: the issue surrounding his role in, essentially, violating United Nations sanctions and bringing in Iranian weapons to Bosnia during the Balkan war. Was that something that was looked at by the United Nations before considering him either for the Bhutto panel or for this post? And this [inaudible], what’s the United Nations, I guess, response to those -- what many in Congress… you read the article. The article says he can’t be confirmed by Congress because of that issue. So he’s being foisted on the United Nations. Are you aware of that issue?

Deputy Spokesperson: You’re talking about an appointment that we have not made. And we’re… I was just [interrupted].

Question: If you make it, will you then respond to this public issue that involves [the violation of a UN sanctions regime]?

Deputy Spokesperson: I have nothing beyond the fact that the regular appointment process is ongoing.

On March 17, UN Spokesperson Michele Montas declined at the noon briefing to provide any specifics about the factual inaccuracies that the UN so publicly alleged. Is the UN denying that Galbraith will get the post? Or only that he and Eide don't get along? To Inner City Press, the issue is whether the UN can blithely give a DRSG post to an individual widely characterized as having violated UN Security Council sanctions.


Before the UN announces any appoint of Galbraith, consider the New York Times' 1996 report that Galbraith

"turned a blind eye to the smuggling of arms from Muslim countries -- including Iran -- to the Bosnian Government. Mr. Galbraith has been accused of everything from going beyond his instructions to running a covert operation... too close to a Croatian leadership often assailed for its treatment of minorities."

See also,

"State Department documents, some of which were obtained only under threat of congressional subpoena, and CIA memos suggest Galbraith was more instrumental in the arms transfers than he has admitted, government sources familiar with the investigation said. Investigators also suspect a link between the 1993 Iran-Croatia arms deal and Washington's decision a few months later, at Galbraith's urging, not to block Iranian arms to the Bosnians.

Galbraith developed a close relationship with Croatian Defense Minister Gojko Susak after taking up his post in June 1993, and the two met regularly, including over meals at the ambassador's home. Susak was anxious to get sophisticated weapons the Iranians could provide, especially surface-to-surface missiles that could hit Serbia. One-third of Croatia was still in Serb hands following the 1991 war of secession from Serb-dominated Yugoslavia, and Zagreb's patience with U.N. mediation was over. Additionally, shipments to the Bosnians that passed through Croatia could be screened to keep out strategic weapons, in case of a future Muslim-Croat war. Croatia was under the same U.N. arms embargo that handicapped Bosnia."

While the UN has no confirmation process in which questions are publicly answered by a candidate for a post, how can the UN justify, without more, appointing to a high post an individual credibly alleged to have been involved in violating UN arms sanctions? The interest here is not in re-litigating Balkans decisions or the partisan breakdown of Galbraith's supporters and detractors -- rather it is, does this UN take UN sanctions seriously? We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1galbraith031809.html

In N. Sri Lanka, 2,683 Civilian Killings This Year, UN Leaked Documents Show


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsri1lanka031809.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 18 -- After claiming of Sri Lanka that "we don't count bodies," the UN has now involuntarily admitted that the "minimum number of documented civilian casualties since 20 January 2009, as of 7 March 2009 in the conflict area of Mullaitivu Region [is] 9,924 casualties including 2,683 deaths and 7,241 injuries," in a leaked document of the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs obtained by Inner City Press.

OCHA's top official John Holmes, as well as spokespeople for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, have repeatedly denied that the UN has such casualty figures. Now it appears that unlike in other conflicts from Darfur to Gaza, the UN withheld the Sri Lanka figures, in effect protecting the Sri Lankan government from criticism.

On February 17, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Michele Montas for the UN's estimate of civilian deaths, and whether it was higher or lower than 1200. Ms Montas replied that "we are trying to save people, not count bodies." Video here, from Minute 22:48.

On March 17, Inner City Press cited the just-obtained internal OCHA casualty figure of 9,924 including 2,683 deaths to the Ambassador of a European country active with OCHA, asking if Holmes had disclosed this number in the two "classified" briefings on Sri Lanka the Ambassador had mentioned. "Everyone knows the figures are controversial," the Ambassador said, insisting that he not be identified by name or country. "You won't hear these figures from OCHA." But internally, they are in writing.

Another leaked UN document published today by Inner City Press show that the UN has its own figures for the number of civilians trapped between the Sri Lankan military and the Tamil Tigers, more than twice as high as the government's claimed numbers. The UN document put the number of internally displaced people in Mullaitivu at 150,000 to 190,00, and says that the International Committee of the Red Cross agrees. The UN then dryly but telling reports on "70,000 -- the number of IDPs in Mullaitivu according to the Government of Sri Lanka (GoSL)."

The Sri Lankan government in fact contests any numbers, and most statements, put out by the UN. The Sri Lankan government previous accused John Holmes of being a terrorist, for calling the country dangerous for humanitarian workers. Holmes apparently internalized the criticism, and now has refused to publicly disclose these UN figures, or even admit that they exist, unlike his repeated listing of casualty figures for both Darfur and Gaza. (Neither the governments of Sudan or Israel even called Holmes a terrorist -- they now may wish to do so.)

On March 16, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's deputy spokesperson Marie Okabe for the UN's response to reports of 500 additional deaths due to lack of medicine in the conflict zone -- "is the United Nations or specialized agencies or OCHA aware of this?" -- and about a published threat by the "National Freedom Front" to surround the UN in Colombo if any action is taken on UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Navanethem Pillay's report connecting the government, as well as the Tamil Tigers, to war crimes.

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: What I can tell you about Sri Lanka is that the humanitarian workers on the ground are obviously doing their best to try to assist the most vulnerable on the ground. The Secretary-General just spoke with the President of Sri Lanka, during which he appealed for, expressed his concern for, the safety of the civilians, especially those trapped in Vanni.

Inner City Press: See, that’s what he said. Did he get any commitments back from the other side?

Deputy Spokesperson Okabe: My understanding is that the President did express his cooperation. But the Secretary-General, as I mentioned, did express his strong concerns for the civilian population on the ground.

While it took several rounds of questions before Ban belated called for a suspension of fighting, so far his entreaties have not been acted on by the Sri Lankan government. Some say the UN was withholding its civilian casualty figures to help it convince the Sri Lankan government to suspend bombing, as the UN has asked both Israel and Sudan. But Sri Lanka, more than either Israel in Gaza or Sudan in, most recently, Muhajiriya in South Darfur, has ignored the UN's calls. Now with the OCHA documents made public, how will the Sri Lankan government react?

Footnote: As the NFF threats to "surround" the UN in Colombo, supporters of the Sri Lankan government have written to the UN, with a copy to Inner City Press, asking that Inner City Press be "disbarred" for asking questions about government military action in Sri Lanka. How far would the UN go to placate the Sri Lankan government and its supporters?


And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsri1lanka031809.html

In Madagascar, UN's Role In Protecting Rajoelina Questioned, Who Is the "International Community" to UN? France, It Seems


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1malagasy031609.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 16 -- As Madagascar's president Marc Ravalomanana is deposed in slow motion by soldiers backing Andry Rajoelina, the UN is in the strange position of appearing to support a military coup which has now been denounced by the African Union. On Monday in New York, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe, "on Madagascar, it was said last week that the UN was, along with the international community, providing protection to the opposition leader. Is that still the case and does the UN have any comment on his request that the President either step down or be arrested?"

UN Deputy Spokesperson Okabe replied, "I don’t have specific comments on the latest press reports, but you know what we’ve said and we do have a UN senior official that is involved in this issue, and you’ve seen the Secretary-General’s remarks on this."

Inner City Press' Malagasy sources say that once France switched its bets from Ravalomanana to Rajoelina, the fix was in. But France desperately wanted the political ground cover the UN could provide. Thus, the UN announced it -- and not France -- was protecting Rajoelina. Then it emerged that Rajoelina was in the French embassy. But this was someone deemed to be under the aegis of the UN.

Inner City Press asked, if the UN and not France is protecting Rajoelina, who is actually holding the guns of protection, the UN's Department of Safety and Security? Because there is no UN peacekeeping mission there. The answer was that the UN was working with the international community. But now that the AU has denounced the coup, is the UN's answer limited to the European international community, or more specifically, France?

Footnote: Ravalomanana has said he may call on "the international community," specifically the UN, to support him. Good luck.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1malagasy031609.html

In DC, Obama Officials Defend Bailouts of AIG and Citigroup, Summers Speaks of Fear


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dc2tarp031309.html

WASHINGTON, March 13 -- The ongoing bailout of insurer AIG and its counterparties was apologized for but defended by a range of Obama administration officials this week. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, until recently the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and before that at the IMF, said he hated to have to bailout AIG, but "it's systemic."

His advisor Gene Sperling, a member of President Bill Clinton's economic team, said the Obama administration took office only to find AIG too big to fail, implying that this was entirely attributable to the two terms of George W. Bush. But AIG was allowed to grow without control under Bill Clinton, just as Citigroup was increasingly unsupervised under the tenure at the New York Fed of Timothy Geithner, as CitiFinancial got deeper into predatory lending (click here for Inner City Press reports on that.)

Friday in the White House Barack Obama met and then faced the Press with Paul Volcker, chairman of the Federal Reserve in the time before Bill Clinton. Volcker rarely used his regulatory powers, at least not to protect consumers from predatory lending. And yet now these are the people, along with Clinton's Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, who are defending massive transfers to Citigroup and AIG, all the while laying blame everywhere except upon themselves.

Footnote: Gene Sperling, recounting his time as an advisor to the TV show "The West Wing," said without irony that "We don't have to rely on President Bartlett anymore -- we have Barack Obama!" He said that securitization is "part of the solution." Certainly that's music to the ears of Citigroup and AIG, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley. One wag wondered, concluding the week in DC, it is Gene Sperling or the Twilight Zone's Rod Sterling?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dc2tarp031309.html

In DC, "Inevitable" Fraud as Obama Jokes with JPM Chase, Meets Citi and ExxonMobil


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dc1tarp031209.html

WASHINGTON, March 12 -- As President Barack Obama promises to find and "call out" misuses of the stimulus package, and to review the over 7,000 earmarks in the budget bill he signed this week, the chairman of his Recovery Act's Transparency and Accountability Board, Earl Devaney, told the Press of a "naive impression that given the amount of transparency and accountability called for by this Act, no or little fraud will occur... some level of waste and fraud is unfortunately inevitable."

Accordingly, the same is true not only at the United Nations -- despite Obama not mentioning the need for UN reform in his comments Tuesday after meeting Secretary General Ban Ki-moon -- but also with the bank bailout funds of the Troubled Assets Relief Program. Nevertheless, Obama joked with JPMorgan Chase's Jaime Dimon at the Business Roundtable's gabfest Thursday in Washington. As a smaller banker asked the final question of Obama -- no questions were taken after his meeting with the UN's Ban -- Obama said that banking has of late become complex, and that he could ask "Jaime" about it.

Also on the White House's list of Roundtable attendees was Citigroup's longtime board member and now chairman Richard Parsons. Citigroup veered into predatory lending, JPM Chase at a minimum securitized it, while lending to payday lenders and pawnshops. What then is so funny?

Obama's successor as Senator from Illinois Roland Burris is said to have a brother who is going through foreclosure. A well-known Representative from the state of Illinois, sponsoring a pro-industry payday lending bill, has taken over $10,000 from the lender QC Holdings. If this is how politics will be in the current Washington, predatory lending can be expected to continue.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dc1tarp031209.html

On Sri Lanka, IMF Says Its Pending Loan Would "Support Government Policy Goals," To Wait and See


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/imf1srilanka031209.html

WASHINGTON, March 12 -- As conflict rages in Northern Sri Lanka, with not only the Tamil Tigers but also the government forces killing civilians at a pace that has triggered two calls for a cessation of fighting by UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, the International Monetary Fund is in the final stages of negotiating a $1.9 billion loan to Sri Lanka. Asked Thursday what restrictions the IMF might place on the loan IMF spokesman David Hawley said the loan funds would be used for "the government's policy goals."

Inner City Press asked a follow-up on possible conditions or safeguards, specifically with regard to the military action in Northern Sri Lanka. Mr. Hawley referred to the note he had just read out, saying that the loan is still under negotiation and to wait and see what conditions there might be.

The IMF briefing, held in basement auditorium of the Fund's headquarters a few blocks from the White House where Ban Ki-moon met with U.S. President Barack Obama on March 12, was sparsely attended and lasted less than 20 minutes. After passing through security and waiting for an escort, Inner City Press arrived just as Mr. Hawley was about to close the briefing. He took Sri Lanka as the last question. Some said it must be a busy news day, that few questions were submitted online to the briefing. (Inner City Press has in the past sought to submit questions from the UN in New York via the IMF's web site and has watched online as it was said, "There are no more questions.") The IMF's own lack of funds would seem to trigger at least a half hour of questions and answers.

During the visit of Ban and his entourage to Washington, the word Sri Lanka did not arise even once, chief UN Peacekeeper Alain Le Roy told Inner City Press on Wednesday in the Rayburn House Office Building. This despite Ban Ki-moon have twice called for a cessation of fighting, and his Spokesperson's Office's claim that he has made the humanitarian crisis in Sri Lanka a priority.

The IMF Spokesman said to wait and see about conditions on the Fund's loan to Sri Lanka. Sources say while these conditions may involve not using the Fund's funds to support the Sri Lankan rupee, what others in the UN system are calling a humanitarian catastrophe, including government-created and -funded detention camps for those fleeing the conflict zone, is not even on the IMF's radar. We'll see -- watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1srilanka031209.html

U.S. "Deadbeat-Gate" Draws Midnight Clarification from UN's Ban Ki-moon: He Said It, But...


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dcban5media031209.html

CAPITOL HILL, March 12 -- As UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon met members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee on Wednesday morning, ranking member Ileana Ros-Lehtinen emerged and told the Press that Ban "used the word deadbeat when it came to describing the United States... unbelievable."

Minutes later, Ban stopped and spoke to the three reporters present, including Inner City Press, all three of whom had tape recorders running. He was asked, did you use the word 'deadbeat'? Inner City Press asked, "Ros-Lehtinen seemed to say you did."

"Yes I did, I did," Ban replied, and then smiled impishly. His spokesperson, who also tape recorded the exchange, then said Ban had to go. He rushed away down the hallway surrounded by aides.

At least two stories were written. Then, past midnight, Ban's Spokesperson's office issued a midnight "clarification" --

Subj: To clarify any misunderstanding about the Secretary General
From: unspokesperson-donotreply@un.org
To: Inner City Press [et al.]
Sent: 3/12/2009 12:19:10 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time

The Secretary-General said: "The United States generously supports the work of the UN , both in assessed and voluntary contributions".

The Secretary-General also added that while the United States is the most generous contributor to the United Nations, it is also the largest debtor, with more than one billion dollars of arrears owed to the organization.

The Secretary-General enjoys an excellent working relationship with the United States and appreciates the many ways that it supports the United Nations.

New York, 11 March 2009

One problem with this clarification is that it does not address the point raised by Rep. Ros-Lehtinen and the stories, Ban's use of the term deadbeat. Ban's Spokesperson was there with tape recorder running. Ban said that the U.S. has $1 billion in arrears to the UN, "soon to be" $1.6 billion.

The irony is that Ban is widely viewed in the UN as, if anything, too pro-United States. Another Republican who spoke to the Press outside the meeting on Wednesday, Rep. Joe Wilson of South Carolina, said he prefers Ban to Kofi Annan, noting that Ban supported Israel by speaking about and publicizing Hamas' rocket fire.

One interpretation of Ban's laughing statement that he called the U.S. a deadbeat is that Ban was trying to show some "street cred," that he is not in the pocket of the Americans. The Democratic chairman of the subcommittee on international organizations, Massachusetts' William Delahunt, told the Press he think Ban is right, that the U.S. should pay all its arrears before it criticized the UN.

In this context, it appears to some far to defensive and craven for Ban's Office to issue this midnight clarification. "If you said it, you said it," one source argued. "Stand behind it. And if you put out a clarification, at least address that quote you are trying to clarify."

Ban's promised monthly press conference, already delayed, is now scheduled for Thursday at 11 a.m.. Inner City Press is still in Washington and cannot ask these questions. Most current UN correspondents, it seems, would agree with Ban's word choice if not his midnight retreat. Will the issue come up and be clarified by the man himself? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dcban5media031209.html

UN's Ban on Capitol Hill Grilled about Reform, Praised as Hardworking, Darfur Raised


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dcban4media031109.html

CAPITOL HILL, March 11 -- The UN's Ban Ki-moon, beginning his second day in the U.S. capital, swept with his entourage down a windowless hallway of the Rayburn Office Building to one of the conference rooms of the House Foreign Affairs Committee at 9 a.m. on Wednesday. He had met with the committee's chairman Howard Berman, but now faced Republicans including Ranking Member Illeana Ros-Lehtinen of Florida, and Joe Wilson of South Carolina. On his way in to room 2255, Ban stopped and joked to Inner City Press, "You are accredited here too?"

The head of Ban's Department of Political Affairs Lynn Pascoe chided, "You'll have to shoot your White House source for yesterday, Myanmar wasn't mentioned." He may have misread the Inner City Press news analysis: the source spoke just before Ban's closed door meeting with Obama. No UN correspondent was allowed to the subsequent press availability, at which in any event there were no questions. The analysis was of how the Obama administration is changing its Myanmar policy based on lobbying from oil and gas firms.

While the House meeting, too, was closed-door, three Representatives emerged and spoke with the Press. Democrat Bill Delahunt of Massachusetts talked about a study he had commissioned from the GAO for the Subcommittee on International Organizations, Human Rights and Oversight that he chairs, which concluded that supporting UN Peacekeeping is cheaper for the U.S., for example in Haiti, than the U.S. "doing it itself."

Rep. Delahunt was asked if Ban Ki-moon is viewed as an effective leader. "He is hard-working," Rep. Delahunt answered after a time. And his views are consistent with those of many members.

Rep. Joe Wilson added that Ban's visit to southern Israel, in a show of solidarity "about Hamas' rockets," was positively viewed. Rep. Wilson compared Ban favorably to Kofi Annan on this score. He said he'd raised to Ban "nuclear proliferation and Iran." Inner City Press asked him if North Korea had been raised. I should have raised that, Rep. Wilson said. One might have added Sri Lanka, as Wilson serves on the Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia, and head UN Peacekeeper Alain Le Roy later told Inner City Press that the words Sri Lanka were not raised in the House meetings, nor with President Obama.

Rep. Illeana Ros-Lehtinen took a decidedly different tack. She said that while Ban claimed to be moving on "transparency, accountability and reform... we all tend to raise our eyebrows when we hear this."

Inner City Press asked if whistleblower protections had arisen. Yes, I brought up the UN Development Program, she answered, Ban is going to select a new Administrator for UNDP who should be expected to improve UNDP's whistleblower protections and ethics programs.

Ironically, some now express concern that Ban may simply promote the current Associate Administrator Ad Melkert, who oversaw much of the retaliation against whistleblowers on which Rep. Ros-Lehtinen has spoken, as early as Thursday.

When Ban Ki-moon emerged, to his credit he stopped briefing to speak to the Press. On climate change, he said he is urging Senator John Kerry and Rep. Ed Markey to pass climate change, or cap and trade, legislation before the December conference in Copenhagen.

Inner City Press asked what Ban is urging the U.S. to go about the situation in Darfur, from which 13 large NGOs have been expelled. Ban cited President Obama's statements of the evening previous, then said with some passion that "humanitarian work has nothing to do with the ICC," the International Criminal Court, and that "we provide 1.2 million people with humanitarian assistance."

Ban was asked if he had, as Rep. Ros-Lehtinen had said, called the United States a "deadbeat." He indicted that he had used the word. Ros-Lehtinen had expressed anger at this, wondering why by contrast Ban is so diplomatic about human rights violators. The Myanmar situation again came to mind. But, to be clear, the word Myanmar was not uttered in either of Ban's meetings.

Ban's Spokesperson indicated that he had to go. His entourage, including his Senior Advisor and Deputy Chief of Staff Kim Won-soo -- who was not listed as present in the previous day's pool report -- and the American Robert Orr, Lynn Pascoe and the chief of the UN Information Center in Washington Will Davis, hustled down a stairway to the waiting limousine and mini-bus.

Alain Le Roy trailed behind, answering questions to the end. He confirmed to Inner City Press that the issue of which bank UNRWA uses had been raised -- by Ros-Lehtinen -- and that Ban had said he would have to look into it. He confirmed that neither Sri Lanka nor Madagascar had come up, "unfortunately." He said that while the previous administration was in favor of UN Peacekeeping mission in Somalia, the current one says it needs to study the issue. And then the bus and limousine sped off.

To some it appears that, under these Democrats, UN reform issues have fallen off the table. Even Ban's supporters, when asked about his effectiveness or charisma, answer only that he is hardworking -- which is undeniable. We'll have more on this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dcban4media031109.html

UN's Ban Meets With Obama, No Pesky UN Press, Myanmar Convergence Described


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dcban3media031009.html

WASHINGTON, March 10 -- As school children pointed at the White House and threw bread to pigeons and sparrows, a black limousine and 20-passenger bus swept by at 5:25 on Tuesday afternoon, carrying UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his press-less entourage to a meeting with President Barack Obama. An Inner City Press source emerging from the White House described it as scripted and untransparent. He was surprised that Ban's team had not tried and gotten any UN correspondents in.

It's a pool, he said, predicting two questions to Obama, two question to Ban. Some taking photos through the fence asked this reporter about the black bus waiting in the driveway. The name Ban Ki-moon did not ring a bell with them. One mentioned Kofi Annan. The birds grabbed the bread and flew.

The White House source mentioned a sample point of convergence. Ban paid tribute to Burma's General Than Shwe, he said. And now U.S. gas and oil companies have lobbied the Administration to change course on Myanmar, to move away from sanctions and toward economic integration. They want to make money, despite the dictatorship. They pitch it to Obama as an alternative for now to oil for the Middle East and Venezuela. The ground cover is to call it a helping hand despite Than Shwe's still iron gripping fist, a change we can make you believe in.

At 6:25 p.m., as shown above, the entourage pulled out, heading to Constitution Avenue, to a dinner with the UN Foundation. In the van, apparently after no question, was Ban's Spokesperson and media "liaison" team. An hour and a half later, Ban's press officer, which had not asked to get a single UN correspondent into the White House or pool, issued a bland summary that could have been written before the meeting. Climate change, why not, and Sudan, Iraq and Haiti, from which Ban had just returned.

UN reform, transparency and procurement, were not listed on agenda. Pakistan and Afghanistan were mentioned, along with North Korea. No mention of Myanmar or the Democratic Republic of Congo, much less of Sri Lanka, where the U.S. has discussed military moves with Colombo.

At 9 p.m., the U.S. put out a transcript, in which Obama did not mention Pakistan, with no Q&A at all included.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dcban3media031009.html

With UN's Ban in DC, Procurement Scandals Unanswered, No Protection by UN Security


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/dcban2media031009.html

UNITED NATIONS - DC, March 10 -- With UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon slated to meet with U.S. President Barack Obama in Washington, a report criticizing UN procurement was raised at the UN's noon briefing in New York on Tuesday. Ban's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe read a statement denouncing a media summary of the report, by the UN's own Joint Inspection Unit, but she refused to answer any questions, even as to which of the five recommendations the UN Department of Management is claiming it will act on.

Only last week, Ms. Okabe's colleague Farhan Haq erroneously stated that the UN was not receiving computer services from Satyam, the so-called Indian Enron, through the UN-affiliated International Computing Center, and that the UN's now scandal-plagued Procurement Division covered the ICC. Haq's subsequent statement reversing what he'd told Inner City Press explains, some say, Ms. Okabe's refusal to answer any questions at all about the UN's procurement problems.

Inner City Press asked for the UN's response to the report, particularly its criticism of the UN's waiving of competition such as in its $250 million sole-source contract for camps in Darfur, which even the UN's Headquarters Committee on Contracts then its General Assembly criticized. Ms. Okabe said, please don't ask any more questions about this, what I've just read out is all I have. What she'd read out was an attack on a media summary, not the JIU report Inner City Press has asked about.

Ms. Okabe told other reporters, "Few of you have read the report," as an explanation for not answering any questions about it.

Inner City Press also asked for an explanation of the statement by Ban's envoy in Madagascar that the former mayor and opposition leader is "under [UN] protection in a diplomatic residence." Who in the UN system, which has in recent months allowed its envoy to Niger Robert Fowler to travel without security until he was kidnapped on the way back from a Canadian-owned mining company, is providing this protection? The UN is not actually providing any security, Ms. Okabe aid. At least it's an answer.

Afterwards, Inner City Press asked how Ms. Okabe's office, which is the media's interface with Ban Ki-moon, is assisting UN correspondents who wish to cover Ban's trip to DC, his meetings with President Obama and leaders of the House and Senate. "I don't have any information on that," Ms. Okabe said. Ah, transparency... Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/dcban2media031009.html

UN's Harston Removed from W. Sahara As Quid Pro Quo for Van Walsum, Ban Too Quiet as on Fowler, Diplomats Say


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1harston030909.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 9 -- The UN's envoy to Western Sahara, Julian Harston, has unceremonious left that post, and been reassigned to the UN Office in Belgrade, Serbia. Inner City Press is told, by Polisario and other diplomatic sources, that Harston's removal from Western Sahara was a "quid pro quo... The pro-Morocco [Peter] Van Walsun was taken out, or took himself out, and so Morocco demanded that Harston leave, tit for tat," one senior diplomat told Inner City Press.

At the UN noon briefing on March 5, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Michele Montas to confirm and explain Harston's removal from Western Sahara and reassignment to Belgrade. Even those the move, though not the reason, had been noted in the Balkan press, Ms. Montas said she didn't have information about it, would look into and update Inner City Press.

This did not take place that day or the next, and so on March 7 Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas' deputy, Marie Okabe, who was listed as on-duty that day. On March 8, Ms. Okabe replied merely that "we are looking into it." Inner City Press directly asked for UN comment on the diplomat's "quid pro quo" quote. A day later, none has been received.

How can it be that Ban's Spokesperson's Office still has "no information" about the new assignment given to Harston, and why?

Compared with the UN's ongoing silence about its ostensible envoy to Niger Robert Fowler, who was abducted in December while traveling in that country in a UNDP vehicle but without any UN security, Harston perhaps "got off easy," one of the Africa-focused diplomats remarked, adding that the Ban Administration's lack of transparency is making it more difficult for the UN to recruit qualified envoys to other countries, particularly in Africa. They claim they are withholding their short list of candidates to replace Kermal Dervis at UNDP, he continued, out of respect for those who applied. At that level, it's an absurd concern. But silence on Fowler, and selling out Harston, that hurts them with people who might otherwise apply. It's a race to the bottom.

As so it goes in Ban's UN.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1harston030909.html