Saturday, January 24, 2009

UN Agency Tests Terror with Microsoft and Kennedy, UN FOIA Called For But Denied

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/foia1unicri012209.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 22 -- A little known UN agency, the Turin-based Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute, held a conference on "security governance" at the UN on Thursday. Microsoft, despite the well known security flaws in its software, was invited to present, along with Kerry Kennedy of the RFK Foundation. Ms. Kennedy, it emerges, will be "partnering" with UNICRI to develop and disseminate a human rights curriculum for kids.

At a mid-day press conference, Inner City Press asked Ms. Kennedy if she or the RFK Foundation had played any role in the UN's September 2007 conference on the victims of terrorism, and whether she believes the UN should have a Freedom of Information Act and better whistleblower protection -- the lack of which in the US's Abu Ghraib prison scandal in Iraq she has commented on.

Ms. Kennedy said she was not been a part of the September victims' event, but that she believes that more openness and information is important with anything associated with government, like the UN. She said of the UN, "I would be in favor of making those as rigorous and open as possible." Video here, from Minute 11:44.

Later, Inner City Press asked UN Assistant Secretary General Robert Orr, who had introduced both Ms. Kennedy and the Microsoft representative, to justify the UN's lack of a FOIA. He said that member states had rebelled at paying "the costs associated with FOIA." Video here, from Minute 35:14. But if those costs are mostly related to redacting and concealing information, and nearly all records are not electronic, this should not be a bar.

Orr encouraged questions to the director of UNICRI, Sandro Calvani. Inner City Press asked Mr. Calvani how UNICRI is funded. He said it is all "extra-budgetary," that one third of the funds from from the Italian government, and other funds from "corporations" including "US corporations." Like Microsoft? He said that UNICRI unlike the UN Secretariat "can take risks," and doesn't need concensus for what it does How nice, to have all of the powers of the UN with none of the accountability.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/foia1unicri012209.html

With Ban Ki-Moot Mute, Obama's US Nixes Gaza Investigation Cite in UN Council

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/banki1moot012209.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 22 -- Returning voiceless from the Gaza Strip and Israel, the UN's Ban Ki-moon sat Wednesday afternoon in the Security Council chamber, listening as his American chief of Political Affairs Lynn Pascoe read out his call for an investigation of Israel's bombings of UN facilities, in the first instance by Israel itself, and for humanitarian aid and reconstruction. While the shift to self-investigation became the focus of the press corps waiting impatiently at the stakeout, inside the consultations room the negotiation of a Council press statement took a surprising turn.

Libya proposed, and most members agreed to, a paragraph mirroring Ban's muted investigation call. But the United States, represented for now by civil servant Alejandro Wolff, was having none of it. Inner City Press is told by sources in the meeting that the US would not agree to any reference to investigations. These sources marveled that, even with Obama now in power, this would be the US position. They contrasted it to the Council's reaction to an Israeli bombing in Lebanon during the 2006 war, or to an immediate denunciation of a Sudanese attack on a convoy, which after denying, Sudan apologized for.

Is this the change you could believe in, the source asked. It remains to be seen. Council leadership predicted that new US Ambassador Susan Rice will arrive in New York on Monday. But even absent his Rice, isn't Obama already in charge?

The Secretariat's press availability, like the Council briefing, was handled by Lynn Pascoe. Inner City Press started it off, asking who exactly it is that Ban wants to do the investigation. Pascoe reiterated the new line, "in the first instance... a report from Israel." Video here, from Minute 1:58.

But reporter after reporter zeroed in on the change. The Washington Post followed up on Inner City Press' question, noting that both John Ging and John Holmes had called for an independent investigation.

Pascoe grew testy, reminding the Press that Ban went to get a ceasefire and got one, we're not saying he got it alone -- Ban's spokesperson used this very same formulation -- but it was gotten. Give Ban the man a break, was the implication. And one wanted to, at least for a day. But he runs the risk of morphing from Ban Ki-Mute to Ban Ki-moot.

On the Obama front, Inner City Press asked Pascoe is he anticipates any change in his status, will it remain the same? Pascoe dodged that part of the question, saying that of course the UN wants to work with the US. As he walked away from the microphone he was asked, "Did you vote for Obama?" Amid laughter, he did not answer. Video here, from Minute 16:05.

Footnote: Ban to his credit, even unable to speak, did come to the stakeout. When the open meeting ended, he emerged with his entourage. While they may have preferred that he make a bee line to the elevators, Ban came over to the Press, shaking hands. An otherwise critical correspondent commented of Ban, he's a gentleman. Ban apologized for his voice, and for not taking questions. Why not by e-mail, Inner City Press asked. If Obama's glued to his BlackBerry, how to engage with Ban Ki-Mute?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/banki1moot012209.html

As Olmert Brags of UN's Rocket Focus, Ban Loses Voice

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/gaza1muteban012109.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 21 -- As Israel's Prime Minister Ehud Olmert brags that he got a commitment from the UN's Ban Ki-moon that "any UN investigation of the damage resulting from the war in Gaza includes the damage Palestinian-fired rockets caused in Israel's south," Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas on Wednesday said the first investigation Ban is asking for is by Israel itself. The steps after that aren't clear, Ms. Montas said. Mr. Ban couldn't speak for himself. He has cancelled a press availability, and will reportedly only appear at the Security Council, but not speak. "Cat got your tongue, Ban Ki-Mute?" one wag snarked. Laryngitis, a more serious source told Inner City Press.

Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas to confirm a Ha'aretz report that Ban had agreed to Olmert's request. She nodded and confirmed, but upon follow-up questions acknowledged that Ban does not control what investigations are done. Questioned repeatedly about negative comments in the region about Ban, Ms. Montas said that a person who cannot be accused of not having the interest of Gazans at heart has praised Ban's performance.

It emerged that Ms. Montas was referring to the UN system's own John Ging, Gaza chief of the UN Relief and Works Agency. While Ging did on January 20 offer effusive praise of Ban as articulate and inspiring, it must be noted that Ging is part of the UN.

On the other hand Robert Fisk, a journalist long covering the region, has written that "
Ban said it would not be up to him to launch a war crimes tribunal. It was pathetic."

Near the end of Wednesday's noon briefing, Ms. Montas explicitly denied that Ban has been conveying Israel's conditions to Hamas. Time did not allow Inner City Press this follow-up: since Tony Blair has said that the Quartet, of which the UN is a part, has said the Quartet will only deal or even speak with Hamas if it recognizes Israel, does Blair speak for Ban? Does Ban speak with Blair? Today, at least, Ban can't speak.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/gaza1muteban012109.html

As JPMorgan Chase Shutters WaMu Branches, Regulators Missing, Commitments Gone

Byline: Matthew R. Lee of Inner City Press on Wall Street
www.innercitypress.com/jpmc1wamu012309.html

NEW YORK, January 23 -- JPMorgan Chase is moving to closed down dozens of the Washington Mutual bank branches the government allowed it to acquire last year with no public notice or comment period. In Dallas, Chase has targeted 23 WaMu branches for closure, and another six in Fort Worth. In the Chicago area, Chase says it will shutter 57 WaMu locations. More branch closings will follow across the nation.

Community and consumers groups are belated protesting the acquisition, which was a one of a slew of so-called emergency transactions on which no Community Reinvestment Act comments were considered, including the accession of Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley to bank holding company status, and Bank of America's now discredited acquisition of Merrill Lynch.

JPMorgan Chase benefited from regulator-protected acquisitions not only of WaMu but, before that, of Bear Stearns. As first reported by Inner City Press, Bronx-based Fair Finance Watch submitted to the Federal Reserve Board comments on these transactions, but was told that emergency did not allow consideration of the issues raised, including prospective branches closings.

JPMorgan Chase has now told groups who have asked if it will continue Washington Mutual's CRA programs and commitments that since there is no more Washington Mutual, there is no more commitment.

This comes in the wake of JPMorgan Chase's Jaime Dimon reversing himself from a stated commitment to mortgages through brokers to abruptly shutting down Chase's wholesale mortgage unit. While groups are told this will give Chase more control over the terms of loans, brokers point out that Chase ultimately had control in the wholesale business, too. Commitments are made to be broken, apparently, particularly those by companies the federal regulators bailed out or merged out of existence. What, the question grows, is Timothy Geithner's position on this Main Street issue?

Update: later on January 23, community groups were told that JPMorgan Chase plans to close over 40 WaMu branches in New York State...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/jpmc1wamu012309.html

Behind Bank of America's Toxic Assets, Subprime Links Obscured But Continued

Byline: Matthew R. Lee of Inner City Press on Wall Street
www.innercitypress.com/bofa1lewis012109.html

NEW YORK, January 21 -- Bank of America is now headed down a Citigroup-like path. A second serving of TARP bailout funds, government insurance for a widening range of toxic assets, a chief executive on the ropes. While Ken Lewis claimed to have gotten BofA out of the world of subprime, its investment banking arm continued to buy and trade subprime mortgages, and to prop up subprime lenders. Now Lewis implies that the $108 billion in toxic assets being insured by the government came from Merrill Lynch. But a quarter of them come from BofA itself.

As reported by Inner City Press, Bronx-based Fair Finance Watch documented this to the Federal Reserve in Communiuty Reinvestment Act comments filed in opposition to Bank of America's applications for regulatory approval to merge and expand. In its responses to FFW's comments, BofA begrudgingly acknowledged that it did business with, among others:

Ameriquest Mortgage Corporation, since defunct; Saxon, through which Morgan Stanley tells FFW it has stopped lending, Option One, Centex, New Century, bankrupt; Metris (a subprime card lender HSBC later acquired), Delta Financial, First Franklin, WMC (subprime lender owned by GE), Fremont Investment & Loan, rogue subprime lender which told FFW it would only give its Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data if one signed a confidentiality agreement), Capital One, CIT, WFS -- and Ownit, regarding which Bank of America blacked-out a column labeled "ABS/MBS Underwriting," after elsewhere publicly admitting it performs those functions for Ownit’s loans.

BofA wrote:

"Bank of America indirectly owns 24.9% of the voting common equity of Ownit... In August 2005, Bank of America, N.A. transferred the Ownit residential mortgage loan portfolio purchased during March 2005 to Asset Backed Funding Corporation (‘ABFC’). ABFC is an affiliate of Bank of America Corporation that is a limited purpose corporation that securitizes residential mortgage loans... ABFC securitized these Ownit loans, along with similar loans from another loan originator, in its approximately $1.2 billion ABFC Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2005-HE2 transaction. Banc of America Securities LLC served as the underwriter in that transaction....

In two separate transactions on March 9 and March 14, 2005 Bank of America N.A. purchased Ownit residential mortgage loans in an aggregate amount of approximately $265 million. These loans were held for the account of Bank of America, N.A. until they became part of the August 2005 securitization described at Item 2.b above. These loans were purchased in a competitive, arms-length process at fair market terms" -- followed by more than half a page blacked out.

This was the level of secrecy in the time leading up to the subprime lending meltdown. Now Ken Lewis implies that the assets being insured by the government all came from Merrill Lynch, when 25% are from BofA itself. Will Ken Lewis go the way of Citigroup's Chuck Prince and Robert Rubin? Many say that he should.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/bofa1lewis012109.html

Planet UN, Filmed in a Parallel Universe, Awaits Spiderman Rescue from Critics

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1planet012109.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 21 -- In a time before the Oil for Food scandal, in a peacekeeping mission free from rape or sexual abuse, in a Security Council not crippled by five countries' veto power, an hour-long film was made and premiered Wednesday at the UN. The movie's director Romuald Sciora told the Press that there is more to come, including a comic strip in which "Spiderman will save the UN." The film already surrounds the UN with a force field, which apparently did not allow any critics or even much criticism in.

In three acts -- peacekeeping, development and human rights -- the film celebrates the UN. The UN in turn celebrated the film on Wednesday. In the afternoon, the heads of Public Information and Partnerships, Kiyo Akasaka and Amir Dossal respectively, offered praise at a press conference. Inner City Press asked about rape by peacekeepers and the UN's inability to discipline the culprit.

Sciora acknowledged that this is not in the film. He said if member states have more money, rape would be less likely to happen. But the problem is structural: the UN puts blue helmets on nation's soldiers, but takes on no disciplinary power over them. All the UN does, in the case of rape, is send a soldier back to his country, which often does not prosecute. Nevertheless, the UN loudly proclaims "zero tolerance."

Both Messrs. Akasaka and Dossal appear in the film, as do a range of UN characters from Ban Ki-moon and his spokesperson Michele Montas to his senior advisor Kim Won-soo and recent Middle East spokesman Ahmed Fawzi. (Fawzi on Wednesday told the Press that Ban was warned not to travel in Gaza, but wouldn't say from whom the warning had come.)

There are UN supporters from Ted Turner to William Luers, and two Ambassadors, Switzerland's Peter Maurer and France Jean-Maurice Ripert. Despite this last, there appears to be no mention of the Security Council's critical flaw, the veto held by the US, France, UK, Russia and China. These Permanent Five use the veto to put their sins, and those of their closest allies, out of the reach of the. This is another reason the UN loses credibility. But it is not mentioned in the film.

The film appears designed to indirectly counter criticisms made of the UN without mentioning them. Rwanda is mentioned, with Boutros Boutros Ghali correctly blaming the US for wanting to avoid the word genocide, while complaining at any focus on his unacted-on memo showing he knew that genocide was afoot. But corruption and waste, for example, which for some in the US including its Congress are synonymous with the UN, make no appearance in the film. To make an hour-long movie about the UN since 1994 and not mention the Oil for Food scandal, or even the Iraq debate and war, undermines the project's credibility and utility.

Sciora said in French that it is a word of "vulgarization," or popularization, designed for a boy "in Texas" who doesn't know about the UN, to "make him see the world differently." That so much of the film is in French, even from interview subjects who speak perfect English, may make it a hard sell in Texas. That it may be propaganda was not addressed.

Admittedly, there are many attacks on the UN, not all of them fair. As simply one Wednesday example, a New York Daily News story went out on the wires identifying as a UN official the president of a non-governmental organization which comments to the UN, and who was found with child pornography in his bags at JFK airport. Ironically, the UN's own Department of Public Information distributed this internally as a UN-relevant story.

Inner City Press asked DPI chief Kiyo Akasaka if he was aware of the "UNmeMovie.com" project, and he said he was. (Click here for Inner City Press' previous review.) Akasaka's review is that he wouldn't recommend that his family see it. But Planet UN is at least equally one-sided. Where is the balanced film, that analyzes the UN's functioning, accomplishments and failures, and calls it to live up to its laudable goals?

The most concrete achievement shown in the film is the UN's work on children and armed conflict, demobilizing child soldiers from Uganda's Lord's Resistance Army. But now at the LRA rampages through remotest Congo, the UN has no one nearby, only repeats its threat that the LRA's Joseph Kony will face justice. When?

The film ends with four full screens of dense text, leading to not insubstantial laughter in the theater. A film student interviewed by Inner City Press called the production values "amateur" -- it did smack of some sort of UN home movie, with uncles and aunts droning on -- and found it significant that the UN would think this a high profile film project that did it proud. Perhaps, then, the current UN lives in a parallel aesthetic universe as well. To be charitable, Sciora referred to a forthcoming book about the UN, including analysis by Noam Chomsky, who is now a Senior Advisor to UN General Assembly President Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann. Perhaps it will work better in text, or in 2010 in comics.

After the film, a so-called debate was held in the UN basement auditorium, at which four supporters of the UN blamed all problems on the UN's lack of resources, or the inordinate power of the "International Misery Fund," as panelist Ann-Cecile Robert crowd pleasingly called it in French. Lewis Lapham of Harper's Magazine telling did not know about the Millennium Development Goals, but said the UN needs a strong and articulate voice, but no questions were allowed from the audience about this. Does the UN at present have such a voice?

Up in the UN's lobby Wednesday night, Inner City Press asked Sha Zukang of the UN's Department of Economic and Social Affairs why he was not in the movie, while the outgoing Administrator of the UN Development Program is. I only care about results, Sha said, adding that even those the December 2008 budget debate assigned most of the new development posts to regional commissions and not his department, he is still happy. China doesn't need the UN to do development, he said. China, too, operates in a parallel universe. The worlds are supposed to meet at the UN, but sometimes as in this case there is a failure to engage.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1planet012109.html

In Congo, UN Blocked from Civilian Protection, Bosco in the Mix, UK Hears Nothing

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/drc1bosco012109.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 21 -- The joint Rwandan and Congolese offensive on Hutu rebels in the Eastern Congo has involved barring access to UN peacekeepers and to the press, and appears to have involved indicted war criminal Bosco Ntaganda. At the UN on Wednesday, Inner City Press asked UK Ambassador John Sawers about the blocking of Indian peacekeepers and Red Cross workers from areas in which civilians are in danger. "I haven't heard that report," Ambassador Sawers said, while saying of the operation that "taken as a whole... it is good." Video here, from Minute 5:59.

Apparently the Security Council or at least Ambassador Sawers is so focused on the conflict in Gaza that events more directly implicating the UN are being ignored. Minutes later on Wednesday, Inner City Press asked the head of UN Peacekeeping, Alain Le Roy, about event in the Congo. Le Roy confirmed that peacekeepers had been blocked. Has this not been conveyed to the Council or UK Mission to the UN?

Previously, Ambassador Sawers said he wasn't aware of the involvement of South Sudan in the offensive against the Lord's Resistance Army elsewhere in the Congo. That botched operation has left in its wake more that 600 civilians killed. What will be the body count in the parts of North Kivu from which UN peacekeepers are being barred?

As to the involvement of Bosco Ntaganda, indicted by the International Criminal Court, UN spokesperson Michele Montas on Wednesday told Inner City Press that "whether Bosco participates in it is not of our concern." Video here, from Minute 23:45.

Not only is the ICC connected to the UN -- its State Parties are meeting in the UN Headquarters basement this week to elect judges -- but the UN and Ban Ki-moon are on record as opposing impunity, and for the enforcement of ICC warrants, for example in Sudan. The UN Secretariat, too, has been entirely consumed by Gaza.

Ms. Montas had read out a statement from the UN's Alan Doss that his mission, MONUC, has not be involved in the offensive which is a "bilateral" arrangement between the governments of Rwanda and the Congo. But Congolese legislators in Kinshasa now say they were not consulted, just as they were not consulted on President Joseph Kabila's $9 billion mineral arrangement with the Chinese. Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas if Doss' formal statement implied that the UN views the agreement with Rwanda as effectively approved by all necessary Congolese authorities. No, Ms. Montas said, MONUC "has nothing to say about that." Video here, from Minute 23:03.

Inner City Press asked the Ambassador of the Democratic Republic of the Congo to UN, Atoki Ileka, about Bosco and the legislator's protest. Ileka called the former "murky," and pointed out of the legislator that "he comes from the area, he has to say that." People, including the Ambassadors on the UN Security Council, seem to want to close their eyes and hope the offensive against the FDLR works out, certainly better than the one on the Lord's Restistance Army. But what about civilians?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc1bosco012109.html

In Gaza, UN's Ban Meets Staff, Ging Sings for Supper, John Holmes Heads to the Strip

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/gaza1travels012009.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 20 -- As its Secretary General Ban Ki-moon showed up in Gaza, the UN's call for an "independent investigation" of Israel's bombings of its facilities morphed into a "demand [for] an Israeli investigation." Inner City Press asked the UN's John Holmes and John Ging what lay behind this new phrasing. Ging said he wasn't sure; Holmes pointed out that the UN has always called for Israel to look into what it did. But he agreed that an Israeli investigation would, by definition, not have the independence originally called for. Video here, from Minute 23:55.

Inner City Press sources in Gaza say that Ban was only "allowed" to travel to and from the UN Relief and Works Agency compound. They also disagree with John Ging's seemingly forced statement that UNRWA staff "unanimously" were inspired by Ban, who Ging also called "articulate." One source scoffed that Ging's January 20 briefing smacked of video footage of American pilots downed in Vietnam. Holmes congratulated Ging for finally putting on a tie in honor of the Secretary General. That's not all he put on, one wage added.

Holmes will be traveling to Gaza. Inner City Press asked if he is coordinating with the European Commissioner for Development and Humanitarian Aid Louis Michel, who announced the day previously that he will be in Gaza on January 25 and 26. Holmes said he hadn't been aware that Michel would be in Gaza, but that the UN and EU coordinate closely. He said the EU will not have a "rival" reconstruction and humanitarian aid program. He also said that both he and Ban Ki-moon have spoken with Quartet envoy -- and JPMorgan Chase consultant -- Tony Blair several times in the past few days. We'll see.

Inner City Press asked who will remove or defuse the unexploded ordnance in the Strip. Ging said the first step is to identify locations; Holmes' trip will address who will clean it up. Elsewhere, such work is coordinated by the obscure UN Office of Project Services, all of executives are currently in the UN Headquarters basement to convince their Executive Board to allow them to give promotions to themselves, click here for that.

What was billed as a closed meet of the UN's "High Level" group on Gaza was to meet with John Holmes at 3:30 p.m. in basement Conference Room 5, usually reserved for budget committee wrangling. At 3:30 Holmes was nowhere to be seen, while the room filled with junior level staffers from the missions of primarily European Union countries. Holmes came with two staffers at 3:37, first approaching rooms meeting on Nepal and Somalia before being directed to where the youthful Europeans awaited. "High level," Inner City Press joked. "Numerous," Holmes replied, seemingly in reference to the low turn-out at the morning press conference. The doors closed.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/gaza1travels012009.html

At UN, Obama Inauguration Causes Work Halt, Jokes, More Gaza Confusion

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2obama012009.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 20 -- Much of the UN in New York came to a halt for the inauguration of Barack Obama. In the Delegates' Lounge around a big screen TV a crowd gathered, including the Ambassadors of Switzerland, Rwanda, the Netherlands and Mauritania, where the same Permanent Representative remains from before the coup d'etat.

As on the screen Joe Biden repeated lines from Justice John Paul Stevens, there was a smattering of applause in the UN Delegates' Lounge. It erupted when Obama, after stumbling, took the oath of office. "Finally," someone in the crowd exclaimed. Expectations in the UN are high, probably too high, as elsewhere.

"America is a friend of each nation," Obama intoned, "ready to lead once more." But of what will such leadership consist? Already his Ambassador to the UN Susan Rice has said the time is not right for UN Peacekeepers in Somalia, despite the chaos there. Obama's statements on Gaza have left many at the UN disappointed.

As Obama spoke, General Assembly President Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann and his entourage passed by in the hall. Inner City Press went out and asked the PGA Spokesman about the January 16 vote on Gaza, in which Nicaragua and nine nations, including Syria, Venezuela, Ecuador and Indonesia, voted to sideline an Egyptian and European Union resolution about Gaza. This happens when you are caught in the middle, the spokesman said, promising to get back with answers directly from d'Escoto.

Indonesia's Ambassador had stopped to speak with d'Escoto. Inner City Press stopped him as well, expressing surprising at seeing Indonesia in the Axis of Ten. He laughed and said his votes are not based on how others vote, but the situation on the ground. When asked about Obama, he laughed again. Previously he noted to Inner City Press how popular Obama is in his country, based on living their for a time as a child.

Walking by in the hall in the middle of Obama's speech were, among others, the Ambassadors of Ghana and Burkina Faso; arriving late were their counterparts from Costa Rica and Morocco. Down in the UN's basement in the NGO Committee -- which continued meeting during the inauguration -- a human rights NGO is under attack by Algeria for its human rights complaints. The US representative on the Committee told Inner City Press on January 19 that he is waiting from instructions from Washington, for what will now be a January 23 vote. Will the instructions change, based on Obama's entry?

Rwanda's Ambassador stayed past the end of the inauguration, the poem, the flash of Bill Clinton looking like Mickey Rourke in The Wrestler. A cynic from West Africa sidled up, commenting on the tableau of the Obama and Bush couples. "The Angels and the Devil," he said, "except this time the angel is black and the Devil is white."

Inner City Press asked Kigali's envoy about the current assault on the remaining Hutu rebels in the Congo. Is the UN Mission involved? Yes, he said, on the side of the Congolese government. At Tuesday's UN "noon" briefing, held early in deference to Obama, spokesperson Michele Montas had told Inner City Press the Mission, MONUC, is not involved at all.

The Bushes got on the helicopter which rose into the air. "Do you know where they're going?" the cynic asked. Inner City Press and the Rwandan Ambassador waited to hear. The answer came, "Guantanamo Bay."

Click here for Inner City Press' news analysis earlier on Tuesday about what the incoming Obama Administration may mean for top UN officials from the US, particularly UNICEF's Ann Veneman. A press conference by her would seem in order.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2obama012009.html

Under Obama, UN's Lynn Pascoe May Stay, UNICEF's Ann Veneman Not, Consultant Hired

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1obama012009.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 20 -- As Democrat Barack Obama takes over in Washington, one of the questions at the UN in New York concerns the future of officials nominated for their UN posts by George Bush Administration. The head of UNICEF, Republican Ann Veneman, is the subject of much speculation.

She was Bush's Secretary of Agriculture, and a visible Republican before that. Ms. Veneman has avoided the press for extended periods of her tenure at UNICEF, not only during the scandal surrounding her giving the UN's North Lawn for a Madonna fundraising event that benefited, among others, the Kabbalah Center of Los Angeles, but even during a recent AIDS conference in Mexico.

Her office was nearly silent while children were killed in China by poisoned milk. She's isolated, surrounded by American advisers, a well-placed staffer says. He adds that UNICEF staff worldwide are dissatisfied with her leadership, for example in India where she sent an all-male panel to investigate and excuse alleged sexual abuse by the UNICEF country chief, who has been recycled to the UN Development Group.

Now, however, Ms. Veneman had reportedly hired a consultant to extol her good works and ubiquity, all with an eye to convincing the Obama administration that she should remain, including after her term expires.

The argument is that Obama does not want to be seen as partisan, as taking out all Republic appointees. On finance, he has brought in Republican Paul Volcker, for example.

But some compare the energetic tenure at the World Food Program of Republican Josette Sheeran with the less dynamic management of UNICEF by Ann Veneman. While Sheeran began by being defensive about her Moonie past, she proceeded to get to know WFP from top to bottom, as demonstrated at an hour-long press conference at which she took all questions. Veneman, a UNICEF source scoffs, could never do that. Another added, of Veneman, that "she never took off the American flag pin and got to know the UN system."

If someone has to go, these people say, it's clear who it should be. Obama is a proponent of effectiveness as well.

Tipping the balance against Ann Veneman, the sources say, is that incoming U.S. Ambassador to the UN Susan Rice served on the board of the US Fund for UNICEF, and was said to not be a fan of Ms. Veneman's performance. Few are. But Rice will be part of Obama's cabinet. If she allows Veneman to stay on, the commitment she stated during last week's confirmation hearings to the reform and improvement of the UN will ring hollow.

On another American, Inner City Press last week asked outgoing US Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad whether to his knowledge Lynn Pascoe will stay on under Obama as the head of the UN's Department of Political Affairs. "I have no reason to believe that he won't," Khalilzad said, a comment his spokespeople later confirmed could be used on the record, unlike his answers on Somalia and UN Reform.

So Pascoe dodges the bullet, but Veneman despite her belated media push is in the line of fire? We'll see.

Footnote: At a UN Development Program reception high above Manhattan on Martin Luther King night, the talk turned from Veneman to whether the US will regain the top job at UNDP, now with Kemal Dervis leaving the agency on March 1. (Dervis also left the reception he was hosting, muttering affably about a situation at home.) Now the talk turns Nordic. In the crowd, angling and perhaps offering posts, was Jan Mattsson the Swede.

Norway's stock is up, both in contributions and its Ad-Hoc role in Gaza. But before Mark Malloch Brown and Dervis, one diplomat pointed out, Americans ran UNDP. Could they both name Veneman's replacement and get UNDP? Or might they pull, in National League and pastime baseball parlance, a crafty double-switch?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1obama012009.html

As UN Office of Project Services Wants New Posts, Hides Procurement Audit and Jan Mattsson's Disclosure

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1unops011909.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 19 -- With the world and UN in a financial crisis, an obscure operations arm of the UN, the Office of Project Services (UNOPS) has proposed new Assistant Secretary General and Director-level posts, drawing a rebuke and adverse recommendation by the UN Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Matters. Click here for that.

But apparently that won't matter: sources say that UNOPS Executive Director Jan Mattsson wants the new posts to dole out to gain political favor, including perhaps the top position at the UN Development Program, being vacated by Kemal Dervis. The fix may be in with Ban Ki-moon as well. In preparation is a Secretary General's Bulletin which would give Mattsson even more autonomy on personnel matters. It should be noted that Mattsson has not even followed Ban's call to make basic public financial disclosure - click here for Mattsson's refusal.

Monday at the UN, Inner City Press asked UN Spokesperson Michele Montas if the Secretariat thinks it's appropriate for UNOPS to create these new high level posts, and if so why. Montas did not directly answer, saying instead that "UNDP has its own governing board... They will discuss and reach decisions." Video here, from Minute 15:03.

But Ban is at the top of the system, and said he would reform it. Instead, he has allowed and even encouraged wasteful fiefdoms. He claims he has no power, while quietly preparing a Bulletin to belatedly make that the fact.

Internal sources, beyond telling Inner City Press that "obviously, this generosity to all UNOPS directors are caused by the need for the ED and Deputy ED [Vitaly Vanshelboim] to have many D2s reporting to them so that they could justify the upgrade of themselves" is "a slap in the face to the common UNOPS staff who have borne cuts and dismissal for some time," tell of a damning audit of UNOPS performed as one of the final acts of the UN Procurement Task Force.

A source tells Inner City Press that "a copy of the report was recently given to Mattsson - as I understood, that is the only current distribution. Member states may possibly be able to request a copy - eventually. The cost of the investigation was several $100 thousand (probably between $0.5 and 1 million) which will be charged to the troubled agency."

UNOPS has already been embroiled in corruption scandals, including firing whistleblowers at its Dubai hub and soliciting and spending a slush fund in connection with its shift of jobs from New York to Copenhagen, along with irregularities in the use of Daily Sustenance Allowance. Since Mattsson refuses financial disclosure, would his Deputy Vitaly Vanshelboim be expect to disclose, if given a promotion to Assistant Secretary General?

Most recently, reports from Afghanistan indicate UNOPS involvement in a European-funded hospital that never in fact was built as described. UNOPS stonewalls the press. In fact, its web site does not include contact information for any spokesperson. The UNOPS website brags that it has apppointed its own Ethics Office to protect whistleblower from retailiation, but does not provide contact information for or even the name of the supposed Ethics Officer.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1unops011909.html

Sunday, January 18, 2009

In UN General Assembly, Egypt's Gaza Text Beats Ecuador's, No Vote for Cape Verde

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/gaza1verde011709.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 17 -- In the UN General Assembly on Friday night, the question asked was who cares more about the people of Palestine? At the end of two days of debate about the war in or on Gaza, there were two competing draft resolutions. GA President Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann started it, with a what he called a presidential text. This could only be passed by consensus. After close of business on Friday, it became clear if it hadn't been before that there was no consensus. And then the games began.

D'Escoto withdrew his proposal, and immediately called on the representative of Ecuador. She re-introduced d'Escoto's draft as her own, amending it to demand an unconditional withdrawal from Gaza by Israel. Egypt's Ambassador immediately protested, first saying he had held up his name plate -- or "flag," as he called it -- before "the lovely woman" from Ecuador, as he called her, to groans from many in the audience.

Then he criticized d'Escoto for not putting to the vote a compromise he had reached with the European Union, which also referred to the plight of Israeli civilians. The Permanent Observer of Palestine Riyad Mansour also spoke up for this compromise, urging the Assembly to vote on it and not Ecuador's more divisive proposal. Mansour had told the Press earlier in the day that he thought d'Escoto's draft would pass, "but I'm not saying I'm happy with it." Inner City Press video at www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdUAg0q21Qc. D'Escoto adjourned the meeting.

Out in the hallway, the Ambassador of Syria spoke to a group of diplomats by the coffee machine. Inner City Press went to the floor of Conference Room 3 to get a copy of Ecuador's just-printed amendments. Various Ambassadors approached to tell Inner City Press that this was "sad" and "another example of how broken the Assembly is." An Arab diplomat said it would be funny if it were on another topic, but not the bombing of Gaza.

A Western Ambassador, Permanent Five member of the Security Council, said that Israel might be best helped by a vote on Ecuador's draft. D'Escoto's spokesman graciously explained the jockeying about the rules, saying Inner City Press should be rewarded for working so hard, and so late. But many Ambassador stayed to nine p.m. The war in or on Gaza has gone on for more than three weeks.

It finally ended with a whimper, not a bang. Egypt called for and won a procedural vote, to put its proposal before that of Ecuador. Then Egypt's and the EU's draft was adopted, and all that was left to fight about was whose vote was mis-recorded, and who hadn't been allowed to vote. Cape Verde's representative screamed that he had, in fact, paid his dues, and anyway was were Afghanistan and Bangladesh allowed to vote? People laughed, and garbage time was entered.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/gaza1verde011709.html

UNDP Moved on 30,000 Boxes of Records Mid-Investigation, Dervis' Successor Must Answer

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1boxedout011709.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 17 -- Just after the sudden departure announcement of its Administrator Kemal Dervis, the Iran-led Executive Board of the UN Development Program is slated to meet this week in New York. Dervis' tenure was steeped both in secrecy and controversy -- click here for Inner City Press' farewell to Dervis -- and these two come together in an emerging story the Board should be considering this week.

In the midst of the so-called Nemeth Committee's investigation into UNDP's dealings with the Kim Jong-il government of North Korea, UNDP quietly sought bids to move 30,000 boxes of documents out of its headquarters to private locations until at least 2011. Inner City Press has obtained a copy of UNDP's "Terms of Reference" and, beyond the prevalence of mis-spellings not usually found in such formal document, finds therein no argument about why wider UN system restrictions on document outsources are not complied with. Click here for the document.

Earlier this month, Inner City Press asked outgoing US Ambassador to the UN Zalmay Khalilzad a number of questions about unfinished reforms at the UN and UNDP. Khalilzad said that access to past audits remains a problem at UNDP, but claimed that "going forward," UNDP audits will be available on the same terms as those of the UN Secretariat. We'll see.

The US Mission also said that Ban Ki-moon would have preferred having a single unified UN Ethics Office, the one run by the now-isolated Robert Benson, covering UNDP. Why then shouldn't acceptance of this desire of the UN Secretary General be a condition for nomination to succeed Dervis? There are Scandinavian names being thrown around, a Norwegian minister and others. Associate Administer Ad Melkert is said to have disqualified himself. This will be a litmus test.

Footnote: also indicative of UNDP's lack of transparency is the agency's role in the disappearance of the UN's envoy to Niger, Canadian Robert Fowler. He was visiting a UNDP-funded, Canadian-owned gold mine in a remote region of Niger not related to his purported mandate. There was reportedly a UNDP driver, but no security. The UNDP vehicle was found its with doors open and lights on, cell phones still in the car. Inner City Press posted basic questions to UNDP's spokesman, who responded that there will be no comments or information until the "denouement." That was more than three weeks ago.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1boxedout011709.html

Fed's Geithner Evaded Taxes at IMF, Used Statute of Limitations Later, Mishandled Citigroup

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/imf1geithner011409.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 14 -- While working for the UN-affiliated International Monetary Fund earlier this decade, Treasury Secretary-nominee Timothy Geithner did not pay required taxes to the Treasury Department's Internal Revenue Service. This would seem to be problematize, to be diplomatic, Geithner's ability to gain confirmation by the U.S. Senate to oversee the IRS.

This would seem to be problematize, to be diplomatic, Geithner's ability to gain confirmation by the U.S. Senate to oversee the IRS. But Democratic Senators and Barack Obama himself are calling Geithner's an "innocent mistake" which should not impinge on confirmation. Some ask how a financial whiz, head of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, would claim ignorance of basic tax law as a defense.

Worse, Geithner initially hid behind the statute of limitations to refuse to pay $25,000 in taxes for 2001 and 2002: "A three-year statute of limitations had precluded the [IRS] from auditing the 2001 and 2002 tax returns." But his supporters argue that Geithner's expertise is needed to confront the global financial crisis.

But what of Geithner's role, as the President of the New York Fed, in mis-regulating Citigroup, an institution which has already swallowed $45 billion in Troubled Assets Relief Program funds, and billions more in guarantees for toxic loans still on its books? Said otherwise, how can those who oversaw -- or turned a blind eye to -- the origins of the financial meltdown be presented as the only ones who can now save the day?

Also on Citigroup, sources say that the Feds are pushing Richard Parsons to take over as the embattled company's chairman. He ran Dime Savings Bank, part of the now-collapsed Washington Mutual franchise. At Citigroup's annual meetings, at Inner City Press asked questions about predatory lending from the floor of Carnegie Hall, Parsons never spoke up. What did he think of the questions, of Citigroup's venture into predatory lending with Commercial Credit, Associates First Capital and CitiFinancial? The questions should be answered.

Leaving the Federal Reserve Board is Randy Kroszner, who had served the Fed's point Governor on community and consumer issues. A new Fed advisor on these issues was recently withheld from the press without explanation by the Fed's public relations office. Fed chairman Ben Bernanke hides behind the Federal Open Markets Committee news blackout requirements in order to skip speaking to non-financial audiences, but disagrees with and ignored the requirement of public notice and comment while granting bank holding company status to Morgan Stanley, CIT, Goldman Sachs and GMAC.

A cavalier approach to the law, by both Bernanke and Geithner -- is this what would help to solve the financial crisis?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf1geithner011409.html

UN Belatedly Suspends Indian Enron Satyam, Puts Contracts Under Assessment, No Accountability on Oracle Yet

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1satyam011409.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 14 -- The UN has belatedly suspended as a vendor Satyam, and has put under review the ongoing contracts of this so-called Indian Enron, including a $6 million deal reached long after the World Bank first suspended the company. On January 13, Inner City Press asked UN spokesperson Michele Montas to explain how Satyam got this contract, why the UN's Inter-Agency Procurement Task Force process, meant to share contractor information throughout the UN system, had failed. Ms. Montas said she was unaware of the controversy. Video here.

Hours later, Inner City Press asked Assistant Secretary General Warren Sach about the scandal. He said that UN affiliated agencies are supposed to inform others of their suspension, by correspondence and through databases, which the World Bank appears to have failed to do.

On January 14, the Spokesperson's Office answered Inner City Press' question-

Subj: Your question yesterday on Satyam
From: unspokesperson-donotreply [at] un.org
To: Matthew Lee [at] innercitypress.com
Sent: 1/14/2009 10:04:28 A.M. Eastern Standard Time

Satyam has been suspended from the UN Secretariat vendor database. The information has been communicated to the UN procurement system and the UN Global Marketplace. Ongoing contracts with Satyam are currently under assessment.

An ongoing five year contract between the UN Secretariat and Satyam for over $6 million began on July 18, 2008, for "talent management software." It is time for the UN to provide further information on how this happened, what will be done and who will be held accountable.

In late December 2008, Inner City Press exposed that the UN purchased 30,000 licenses from Oracle to a computer program called Seibel, a so-called Customer Relations Management (CRM) system, and has left them unused.

That contract is for $7.5 million, of which over $3 million have already been paid to Oracle. But the licenses have never been used, according to UN computer system personnel. These whistleblowers, outraged at the waste and of accountability they say is pervasive, have directed Inner City Press to the documentary evidence of the phantom contract. In the UN's online Procurement database, the information about the Seibel purchase from Oracle is substantially less detailed than from other purchases. For other purchases, the specifications of the procurement are online, often dozens of pages. For this purchase from Oracle, there are no online specifications.

Internal whistleblowers tell Inner City Press that worse than the mis-management that led to the purchase of 30,000 licenses well before they would or even could be used is the cover-up that has occurred afterwards. They also identify as problematic the UN's contracting with EMC Corporation to purchase licenses for a program called Documentum, ostensibly to replace the UN's Official Document System for the UN's "Enterprise Content Management" system, ECM.

The flawed contracting began under the tenure of Eduardo Blinder, who has since migrated to the even less overseen International Computing Center, to which the UN Secretariat outsources much of its work and procurement. More recently, the person responsible for the waste is the Officer in Charge who replaced Blinder, Chandramouli Ramanathan.

In the UN's basement, Ban Ki-moon's Secretariat's CRM and ECM are being considered for the UN's Fifth (Budgetary) Committee. But the Committee members have never been informed of the waste that has occurred. Nor has the Office of Internal Oversight Services, embroiled in its own scandal, done anything.

In a draft of the pending resolution provided to Inner City Press by a budget committee source, the Secretary-General is criticized for proceeding with CRM and ECM before making any proposal to the General Assembly.

Inner City Press has asked Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas about this critique from the General Assembly. Ms. Montas said she would have no comment at all until after the Assembly vote on the resolution which she said might not take place until Christmas Eve. But there has still been no comment. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1satyam011409.html

At UN, Outgoing Zalmay Khalilzad Quieter on Congo and Reform, the Price of Being Well-Liked?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1khalilzad011209.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 12 -- With Barack Obama set to take control in eight days, it's the time it seems for revisionist assessments of Zalmay Khalilzad, the outgoing Bush administration's U.S. Ambassador to the UN. Khalilzad is certainly better liked within the UN than his predecessor John Bolton. Liberal and moderates even sense that he is one of them. Some of this is due, however, to disinterest. Khalilzad's interests were Afghanistan and Iraq, to some degree the Middle East -- Africa much less so, and UN reform surprisingly little.

Maybe accomplishments on the first two issues had to be bought by backing off on reform. Khalilzad rarely mentions the UN's largest peacekeeping mission, and the largest global war since the one resulting in the UN: the Democratic Republic of the Congo. One assumes that this prioritization will change under Obama and the Ambassador he has nominated, Susan Rice.

In perhaps another sign of disinterest or priorities being elsewhere, there is Somalia, a peacekeeping for which Condoleezza Rice had projected before the end of 2008. While a resolution is slated to be adopted before January 20, as Inner City Press exclusively reported at New Years, it will be a largely UK-drafted proposal, different than which Condi Rice had said.

Under Khalilzad unlike Bolton, the US Mission became unwilling to comment other than "on background" about UN reform.

There are claims of accomplishing a UN-wide Ethics Program and Whistleblower Protection, as well as public access to information and financial disclosure, at UN Fund and Program like the UN Development Program, but Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon accepted outgoing UNDP Administrator Kemal Dervis' assertion that the UN Ethics Office had no jurisdiction over UNDP or its firing of a whistleblowing employee. While UNDP's Administrator answers to his own Executive Board, now Ban -- and the U.S., to be realistic -- will be naming Dervis' replacement. Why not make accepting the jurisdiction of the UN Ethics Office a condition for being selected?

In one comment that Team Khalilzad allowed to be "on the record," Inner City Press asked Khalilzad if American Lynn Pascoe will be staying as the head of the UN Department of Political Affairs. Khalilzad said he has no reason to believe that he will not.

A senior UN official, asked Monday afternoon by Inner City Press about Khalilzad's general non-mention of the Congo, noted that his wife Cheryl Benard is very interested in the Congo, particularly the issue of sexual violence there. So perhaps there is a divison of labor in the family. They are nice people. Certainly they had their achievements. Why not then be on the record?

What approach will Obama, Hillary Clinton and Susan Rice take? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1khalilzad011209.html

At UNDP, Kemal Dervis' Desires, Scandals and Silence Recalled As He Departs

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1dervisout010809.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 8 -- Kemal Dervis, the UN Development Program's Administrator, announced Thursday he will leave the post on March 1, ostensibly for personal and family reasons. His tenure was marked by a series of scandals in UNDP, from funding violent disarmament in Uganda and diamond mining in Zimbabwe to procurement fraud cover-ups and financial irregularities in its North Korea program. Through it all, Dervis largely avoided the media, repeatedly telling Inner City Press that he refused to answer questions in the hallway of the UN, as even the Secretary General and his top officials do. He presided over retaliation, and then fought to keep UNDP exempt from the UN system's Ethics Office.

Why is Dervis leaving? There are a number of theories. One has it that he had his eye, in the UN system, on the Deputy Secretary General post. Many close observers had been predicted that Asha Rose Migiro would leave in February. But recently word came down that she is staying. And soon thereafter, Dervis announced he is leaving the system. Others less plausible tie his sudden announcement to the North Korea scandal, and Ban Ki-moon's recent trip to Washington.

What will Dervis do next? There's high brow chat of a university post, lower brow talk of filthy lucre or Turkish politics. Perhaps he'll write a book like the one his predecessor commissioned, "UNDP: A Better Way?"

All that said, Inner City Press has a single semi-positive memory. On his way into the Secretariat building one blue-skied day, Dervis stopped and mused that, you only have so many mornings like this in your life, you have to enjoy them. We hope he does -- and that the next UNDP Administrator does a better job. At Thursday's UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson if he will at least commit to what his predecessor did, releasing a short list of candidates for the post. I don't know yet, the Spokesperson said. We will follow this one.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1dervisout010809.html

Thursday, January 8, 2009

At UN, Libya's Gaza Draft Resolution's Naming of Hamas Had Latin Roots, Ninth Vote in Favor

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN: Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, January 8 -- The Security Council's non-permanent members played a larger role than usual in the amendments released Thursday to the Libyan introduced draft resolution on Gaza, Inner City Press has learned. A Latin American member submitted changes, including the naming of Hamas, to Libya at noon on Wednesday.

At six, two Arab Group members told the Latins that the amendments were rejected. But a subsequent call to the Libyan Ambassador revealed the the proposed amendments hadn't even been presented to the Arab Group yet. By 8:30 pm on Wednesday, the amendments were accepted, including the naming of Hamas.

The Permanent Representative of the country submitting the amendment told Inner City Press that to explain for domestic consumption possibly siding with "Libya, China et al," he needs to point to something achieved thereby: the naming of Hamas in the resolution.

Libya's sudden acceptance of the amendments is designed to garner support of non-permanent Council members -- not only the two Latin America countries, Mexico and Costa Rica, but even Austria, which is said to be eager to "break out of the European Union straight-jacket."

The UK and France are promoting themselves, while expecting the entire EU to follow them. From the basement of the UN, the call goes out, where are the Czechs, the EU presidency? To be continued.

On Gaza at UN, Western Placeholder Statement Competes with Libyan Resolution

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/gaza1prst010709.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 7, updated -- With Gaza smoldering from 12 days of bombardment, the UN Security Council's meeting resumed on Wednesday morning. Libya late Tuesday said it would be calling for a vote for its draft resolution. But Western members of the Council were promoting the idea of a non-binding Presidential Statement, to give more time to what can be called the Egypto - Sarkozy proposal, announced Tuesday in Cairo.

Inner City Press obtained a copy of the draft Presidential Statement, and in the run-up to the Council's 3 pm consultations on the text is putting it online here. It "welcomes the French - Egyptian plan" and says that the Council "will take comprehensive action as Egyptian and other international initiatives will materialize."

The mere place-holder statement is seen by many as inadequate in response to the level of death and destruction being visited on Gaza.


Wednesday afternoon, ministers Miliband and Kouchner of the UK and France strutted in front of the Council, while US Ambassador Khalilzad was with Condi Rice in the UN's basement, meeting Arab ministers. UN Envoy Robert Serry, defender of Egypt among others, begged out of a press conference to attend a Ban Ki-moon luncheon with other ministers. Serry is slated to return to the region Wednesday night, with Ban Ki-moon to follow next week. It was a struggle to be or be seen as diplomatically relevant. The Council's consultations loomed -- watch this site for updates.

Update of 3:36 pm -- Condi Rice has passed through the stakeout, making a statement but taking questions on her way to meet Ban Ki-moon. As she leaves a reporter shouts, "Why are you opposing a resolution?" A cameraman answers, "A resolution is not a solution." Another jokes, "to pollution." The media talk is why Associated Press had no one at the Sarkozy's Egypt meeting, and had to follow-up hours late with a story from the AP. Reuters and AFP are happy about that. Competition everywhere. But who had the Presidential Statement first?

Update of 3:49 pm -- an hour after Inner City Press got and uploaded it, a Western Council member's spokesman emerges to hand out the draft statement. "The French - Egyptian plan" has been changed to "the Egyptian iniative and the French mediation." Guess who tried to put the word France first....

Update of 5:29 pm -- France's Ripert emerged to say that there is no unanimity on either their draft Presidential Statement or Libya's draft resolution. "See you tomorrow," he said. It emerged that the Arab Group is meeting at 6 pm to decide how to proceed. Inner City Press asked Egypt's Ambassador to explain the Presidential Statement's turn of phrase, "the Egyptian initiative and the French mediation." What is France's role? I can only speak for Egypt, he said, adding that even he was unclear on France's role.

Ripert, of course, left the stakeout microphone without taking any questions. He then summoned an unwieldy press scrum off-camera. Few could hear him. French diplomacy at its best, one wag quipped. Later a spokesman for the Egyptian foreign ministry said that one of the options is for the Arab minister to leave New York with no text at all. The Security Council has such a bad reputation in our region, he said, it is easy to blame it for anything.

Update of 7:43 pm -- Condi Rice, David Miliband and Bernard Kouchner emerged from Conference Room 7 in the UN's basement and paused briefly at the microphone the UN had belatedly set up. They are staying in New York to keep working, beginning with another meeting in the basement at 10 am on Thursday. Later the UK mission pitched an on the record quote from Miliband: the world needs to hear the unified voice of the Security Council. Amre Moussa came out later and said, there is work to do. An Arab Group Ambassador told the Press to expect voting -- that is, on a resolution -- at noon on Thursday. Others demurred, predicting a stronger Presidential Statement than the French draft, followed by two days of waiting on the Egyptian initative. To be continued.

and see, www.innercitypress.com/gaza1prst010709.html