Thursday, January 8, 2009

At UN, Ban's Town Hall Is Stacked with Pre-Screened Questions, on G-to-P Injustice and Permanent Contracts, Few Answers

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1townhall010509.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 5 -- As Ban Ki-moon kicked off his third year as Secretary General, reviews Monday by UN staff outside Ban's town hall meeting were less than glowing. "It was like a Soviet event," one well-placed staffer quipped to Inner City Press, "complete with pre-selected questions and answers read out of a book." Another marveled how "it's a new day every day in Ban's UN," constant reinvention with no memory of previous new beginnings not followed up on.

Other Headquarters employees grumbled that other duty stations, from Geneva and Vienna to Nairobi, were given questions first. The head of the New York Staff Union, who had been asked to disclose his question in advance, inquired into the elimination last month of the UN's permanent contracts, and whether this violated the UN Charter. Union officials complained that no real answer was given.

Also from New York, a General Service staff member asked Ban why not extend educational benefits to General Services as well as Professional level staff. Ban answered that the limitation comes from the General Assembly, and that American citizens will not get such stipends unless they move and serve in Geneva or elsewhere. At least there was one seemingly unscripted question. The broader unfairness and waste of talent occasioned by the wall between Professional and General Services staff remains unaddressed.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson at Monday's noon briefing to respond to this Charter-based argument. The Charter doesn't require or provide for permanent contracts, she responded. The new term is "continuing." But what about whistleblower protection? And what about Article 101 of the the Charter's reference to staff being "permanently assigned"?

Inner City Press spoke with a number of senior UN officials on their way in and out of the town hall meeting. One demanded off the record treatment, when discussing Team Ban's crack down on the Press. Others, however, to their credit made no such request.

Peacekeeping chief Alain Leroy, walking in with his colleague Susana Malcorra, replied about the Lord's Resistance Army that the UN Mission in the Congo must focus in the Kivus, and cannot provide protection to the North. Click here for more on that.

The current Special Advisor on Africa may not long retain that title. "I started with Small Islands," he said, adding that he'd prefer not to be too identified with the Continent. So if Ban in fact complies with the stated wish of the General Assembly, expect a new Africa Advisor.

Controller Warren Sach confirmed that for a time he had been officer in charge of the Department of Management, but not on the day for replying to a report of UN retaliation. The resulting letter to the editor was by Catherine Pollard, "that was December 26," Sach said, "she was in charge." And as the Arab League meeting about Gaza droned on the basement, Ms. Pollard held court in the Delegates' Lounge. Every day is a new day.

Footnote: the Town Hall meeting was closed to the press. Even member states were not, at least as of Monday night, able to access the video. Delegates' link to the UN's intra-net had not been undated so far in 2009. Is this any way to run the so-called World's Body? We may have more on this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1townhall010509.html

Sangala Jolie: UN Panned, Praised by Fox TV & the New Yorker, "24" and Harr on Chad, Dueling Propaganda


Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1harrfox010409.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 4 -- The UN couldn't buy better publicity than it received in the January 5 edition of The New Yorker magazine, in a lengthy "Reporter at Large" piece entitled Lives of the Saints, by Jonathan Harr, author of A Civil Action. Harr describes in glowing terms the work of UN system staff in eastern Chad, and adopts without critique their analysis of Darfur. He is treats more lightly the UN's favoritism for Chadian president Idriss Deby, ultimately implying that it is better that Deby stay in power. Despite this, it is a beautifully written piece and may draw more humanitarian workers to eastern Chad, perhaps even to the more forgotten Central African Republic. Stranger things have happened.

Harr approached Inner City Press in UN headquarters in mid-2007. He had been commissioned by the New Yorker, he said, to write anything he wanted to about the UN. He had watched a few UN noon briefings, and now asked Inner City Press for suggestions on what or whom he should cover. Suggestions were made, more briefings attended -- including a July 20, 2007 briefing at which Inner City Press asked Serge Male of the UN refugee agency UNHCR about Chad, click here to view -- and finally Harr told Inner City Press he has fastened on Male, UNHCR and Chad. This was 17 months ago.

In June 2008, still no article having been published in The New Yorker, Inner City Press met Serge Male in Chad. It was a surreal reception on the well-groomed lawn of the French Ambassador, complete with tuxedo-ed Chadian waiter serving whiskey on ice and a small deer frolicking on the lawn. When asked about Harr by Inner City Press, Male nodded but said he had no idea when the article would come out.

Fully six months after that, the article has appeared. It discloses that the in-country reporting largely ended in January 2008, a year ago. What took so long? We understand perfectionism in writing, but this is ridiculous. It not only makes the article less newsworthy, it makes it misleading in ways. Certainly International Criminal Court prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo will like the article, given that it simply posits as the case that Bashir is a genocidaire.

Harr does not, for example, mention the UN's $250 million no-bid contract with Lockheed Martin in Darfur. Lives of the Saints, indeed. Even about Chad, Harr does not mention a major news event in the Chadian NGO world that broken while he was there, the kidnapping of refugee children by the French group L'Arche de Zoe. Harr lucked into that story, and then didn't cover it. But this knowledge makes his purely positive presentation of European NGO workers in Chad feel somewhat forced.


Is it that Harr, having concluded that the humanitarian enterprise in Chad is on balance good, decided that readers couldn't handle nuance or any countervailing facts? Did the UN shepherding Harr around in airplanes and 4x4s create a conflict of interest, or bias akin to the Stockholm syndrome? (Harr was evacuated when battles between Chadian rebels and Deby's forces heated up.)

Perhaps this explains of the disjointed, dare we say under-edited, instances in Harr's article. The town of Abeche, which the UN Security Council visited in June 2008, is first described in the article as "Abeche, one of the largest cities in Chad," then is re-introduced as if for the first time as "Abeche, a town once known among aid workers as a place of drunken weekend revelries and romantic flings." Such moment are more than made up for by similes like comparing a UNHCR complaint line in Chad with "a D.M.V. in a land where people had no motor vehicles."

But if you were a well-known writer well paid to write whatever you wanted about the UN system, why would you turn out a better written version of the type of propagandistic hagiography that the UN itself churns out every day? It's a question we hope that Harr will answer.

Less highbrow but wider seen, Fox TV's program "24" in late November 2008 teased its upcoming seventh season called "Redemption" with a two hour prequel shot in Composite Africa. There were child soldiers, recruited by a General Juma standing in for Joseph Kony. His movement was called the People's Freedom Army, instead of the Lord's Resistance Army. But there were diamond mines -- think Sierra Leone -- and references to exterminating cockroaches, straight out of Rwanda. The country name, made up, is Sangala. Who is funding Juma? A vague and sinister businessman named Jonas Hodges, played by Jon Voight. Some of it feels like an old Seinfeld episode.

The UN is represented, or misrepresented as it were, by a bitter European assigned to a school run by Jack Bauer's / Keifer Sutherland's friend Carl. The UN European judges Jack about torture, but then hides with children in the basement. He did nothing to protect the children from Juma, insisting on being "neutral." (The liberal New York Times opined that "the United Nations peacekeeper with a foreign accent is an appeaser and a coward" and called this a "gratifying caricature.") Finally to save himself he sells out the children to Juma. Ouch -- how does one write a letter to the editor to a television show? And which is more one-sided, Harr's hagiography or Fox's facile caricature?

So Harr's belated article and Fox's Africa conflation are, as relates to the UN, dueling propagandas. They do, however, intersect on one point, a now-standard trope in Western discourse at all levels: the complex(ed) do-gooder working for an NGO in Africa. Running the school in Sangala is one Carl Benton, like Jack Bauer a former agent haunted by extreme interrogations past. (Benton is played by Robert Carlyle, previously deployed to Central America by British director Ken Loach to much the same effect.) Benton is trying to gain redemption for having tortured a detainee to death in Lebanon by saving Sangalese children from recruitment by the warlord Juma.

Meanwhile in Harr's article, Western NGO workers are described as either seekers of adventure or runners from the past. One NGO worker in Chad left unnamed by Harr "is a runner, she said, but offered no details." Perhaps she was a guard in Abu Ghraib. We smell a past-deadline and over-budget movie coming on, and a role for Angelina Jolie. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1harrfox010409.html

Vietnam Outlaws News Blogs, Claims Foreign Servers Will Help, UN Security Council Review

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/blogs1vietnam010109.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 1 -- Vietnam in late 2008 moved to regulate the blogosphere, dictating that blogs remain entirely "personal" and not purport to report any news, much less state secrets. The Vietnam government stated that services such as Google and Yahoo will help them enforce these "no news on blogs" rules. While Yahoo did turn in a Chinese dissident blogger to the government in Beijing, and Google has a history of "disappearing" content apparently at its powerful partners' request, Vietnam's claims seem anachronistic.

On December 31, Inner City Press was asked by Vietnam's mission to the United Nations to appear on Vietnam TV to review the country's year on the Security Council, judged to be one of the "Top Ten Vietnam News Stories of 2008." While Vietnam has sought to keep human rights violations from Myanmar to Zimbabwe off the Security Council's agenda, its diplomats have not been unwilling to answer the Press' questions. During Vietnam's presidency of the Council in July, its Ambassador memorably told Inner City Press, when asked about a request for Council action by Cambodia in its UNESCO-enabled border dispute with Thailand, that "meeting postpone, issue disappears."

But in Vietnam itself, the goal seems to be to have news and social critique disappear from the Internet. In November, Vietnam's Deputy Minister of Information and Communications (MoIC) Do Quy Doan argued that "as blogs are personal sites, bloggers are not allowed to use blogs to promote anti-state activities, war and obscenity, or to offend the honor or prestige of organizations and individuals or to release secret state documents."

Doan subsequently signed into law circular 07/2008/TB-BTTT which provides that blogs shall not even "post links which go to information that violate Article 6 of Decree 97/2008, banning anyone who takes advantage of the Internet to deliver distorted information [or] reveal state secrets."

One step down the bureaucratic ladder, the Chief of the MoIC’s Broadcasting, Television and Electronic Information Control Agency, Luu Vu Hai argued that "when we use the press freedom right we have to obey the Press Law and we couldn't use the press freedom right in a non-press environment."

At a press conference about the circular, Doan was asked how the government would "prevent 'black' blogs, blogs that are contrary to Vietnamese customs and habits?" He answered that "most bloggers in Vietnam are using services supplied by foreign service providers... After the circular takes effect in 2009, the two sides will exchange information and cooperate with each other. I think service providers also wish to have a clean Internet environment. I think if state agencies of Vietnam ask for cooperation, Google or Yahoo will be willing too."


Again, we hope this is unlikely, even though Yahoo did turn in a Chinese dissident blogger to the government in Beijing, and Google has a history of "disappearing" content apparently at its powerful partners' request, click here for that.

Deputy Minister Doan went on to note that "some say that blogs are personal diaries. If they are personal diaries, they should be kept for their authors, or their friends or relatives. If they are opened for the public, they are not personal diaries anymore, but become electronic information pages... Blogs don't represent any organization or release orthodox information."

But corporations now promote themselves with blogs. The UN in December invited Inner City Press to make a presentation at an event promoting the use of blogs, click here for the UN's summary of the session. The UN, not only an organization but an entity calling itself "The Organization," brags about its own blogs. Would they be illegal in Vietnam? Will the UN, though its compromised UNESCO or otherwise, say anything about this?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/blogs1vietnam010109.html

At UN, Somalia Peacekeeping Dream Dies a Quiet Death before New Years, US Buckles

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/usun1uksomalia010109.html

UNITED NATIONS, January 1 -- As mortar fire rained down in Mogadishu on the palace of the President, who just resigned, in the UN the Security Council resolution for a peacekeeping force which the United States had said was a priority died a quiet death on December 30. At the Council stakeout on New Years Eve, Inner City Press asked outgoing South African Ambassador Dumisani Kumalo what would happen next on Somalia.

Ambassador Kumalo expressed disappointment that nothing was done by year's end, when he and South Africa leave the Council. Kumalo was the most vocal Ambassador on the Council for engagement in Somali civilians' two decade-long crucifixion. This was the last question he would answer as a Security Council member, and he vowed to continue to advocate for Somalia even once off the Council.

The backstory is that in the run-up to the year-end deadline set by also outgoing U.S. Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, Security Council members met at the expert level on competing resolution drafts by the U.S. and the United Kingdom. When Ms. Rice came to the UN earlier in the month, she and UK Deputy Permanent Representative Karen Pierce crossed swords on the practicability of a UN Peacekeeping mission in Somalia, with Pierce as the skeptic.

While most insiders consulted by Inner City Press had expected the U.S. to push for a vote on its resolution by the end of the year, since its passage would be much less likely with South Africa and Italy leaving the Council, ultimately the U.S. backed down, not wanting an open conflict with the UK. Therefore on December 30 it was said that attempts will be made in the new year to somehow merge the conflicting U.S. and UK drafts.

Thus the U.S. which backed the ill-fated Ethiopian incursion into Somalia during the Christmas to New Years period in 2006 ended up further selling out Somali civilians during the same period two years later. On New Years Eve in front of the Council, outgoing U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad did not mention Somalia, only Gaza. The same was done by UK Ambassador John Sawers: Gaza only. Afterwards, Inner City Press tried to get Africa answers but was told that its coverage is too negative. But what about the impacts in Somalia? This will be pursued in the new year.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/usun1uksomalia010109.html

At UN's Gaza Meeting, Croatia Corrects CNN Report They Leave the Council on Jan. 1

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1nocroatia123108.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 31 -- As the UN Security Council's New Year's Eve meeting about Gaza proceeds and the resolution introduced by Libya circulates, two representatives of Croatia's, the Council president for December, emerged from the chamber and approached Inner City Press. We need your help, they said. CNN just reported that Croatia is leaving the Council tonight. But we have another year. We need to get it corrected.

Inner City Press escorted them up to CNN's office. Both of them showed Blackberries full of queries about Croatia's future on the Council. "Half of Europe is watching," one of them said.

Up in CNN, long-time correspondent Richard Roth was diplomatic.* He said if he was allowed to be more at the UN, the reference would not have happened. He promised to correct it.

* - his show Diplomatic License is much missed at the UN

On the way down, the Croatians confirmed to Inner City Press that if the meeting goes until midnight, it would have to be suspended, and the five Council members which unlike Croatia are actually leaving: Italy, Indonesia, Panama, Belgium and South Africa. Then the five new members would have to seated: Austria, Turkey, Mexico, Japan and Uganda. The change makes the Libyan introduced resolution harder to pass, even disregarding the anticipated use(s) of the veto.

The Croatians also confirmed to Inner City Press that they had finessed the Arab Group's December 30 request that the Council's President Neven Jurica write a letter to Israel on behalf of the Council demanding a cessation of air strikes. Instead, Jurica formally handed the Ambassador of Israel and the Permanent Observer of Palestine copies of the three-paragraph press statement he had read out at 2 a.m. on December 28. We could have screwed that one up, one of the Croatians in essence said. There are four more hours to do so, Inner City Press noted. Two hundred minutes, the Croatian corrected. CNN's correction is still awaited, and if seen will be reported on this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1nocroatia123108.html

UN Helps Congo Attack LRA, Can't Protect Civilians Then Disclaims Any Role, as in Kivus

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2orientale123108.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 31 -- A UN-supported offensive against the Lord's Resistance Army has been followed by the hacking to death of more than 180 people in northeastern Democratic Republic of Congo. On New Years Eve, Inner City Press asked the UN's humanitarian coordinator John Holmes about the UN's role in the offensive against the LRA, with the Congolese army, and what is being done to protect civilians going forward. Holmes said that little can be done, since the UN peacekeepers' presence is limited due to redeployment to the Kivus, except to try to let the LRA know it will be held accountable. Video here, from Minute 36:40.

In fact, the UN has previously bragged about its logistical support to the Congolese Army for its attacks on the LRA. Now the UN Mission in the Congo, MONUC, is trying to distance itself from the results. A MONUC press release on December 30 emphasized that MONUC " neither took part in the planning nor in the implementation of the operations carried out by the coalition against the LRA" but added that "MONUC will do everything in its power to continue to protect civilians, notably by bringing substantial support to the DRC Armed Forces (FARDC)."

Which is it? Does MONUC support the FARDC or "neither take part in the planning nor in the implementation of [its] operations"?

In fact, Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson has previously told Inner City Press that "MONUC supported the FARDC "with logistics, such as transport, water and food" and "has also helped consolidate and widen the airfield at Dungu, which serves as operational bridgehead for the FARDC and Ugandan troops"of the UPDF.

Now MONUC's press release states that "yesterday, 29 December, 105 troops were transported to Doruma and 60 more today. Moreover, MONUC committed to provide them with logistic support in terms of food stuffs, water, medicines, sanitation and fuel." So let's be clear, some say: if the FARDC troops commit war crimes, the UN has facilitated these.


MONUC went on to recount that "Ms. Leila Zerrougui, Deputy Special Representative of the UN Secretary General in the DRC, met today 30 December 2008 with the DRC's National Security Board, headed by the Minister of Interior Mr. Celestin Mbuyu Kabango [and] told them about MONUC's determination to support the Government's efforts to resolve the situation." What does "resolve the situation" mean? Assist in the elimination of the LRA's Joseph Kony -- the UN's own hand in extrajudicial killing?

Inner City Press asked John Holmes about the LRA's claims, for what they're worth, that the Ugandan Army's "Battalion 105" made up of ex-LRA fighters are responsible for atrocities to blame them on the LRA. How does the UN know it is the LRA? "It's hard to be sure," Holmes said, while calling the idea that the Ugandan Army might be involved "implausible." Those who thought that the International Criminal Court's Luis Moreno Ocampo should have also indicted some in the UPDF, or who are aware of the UPDF's UN-funded torching of huts in Karamoja in the name of forcible disarmament don't find it entirely implausible.

We know the Congo is big, but the UN seems to have a different relationship with the FARDC in the northeast, where it carries them around and cheers them on, than in the Kivus, where the full Special Representative of the UN Secretary General in the DRC Alan Doss this week "voiced his concern over the closeness of the FARDC and CNDP positions in Kibati. He also reiterated his appeal to the two parties 'to refrain from taking any initiatives likely to provoke new hostilities' and took the opportunity to recall to both parties 'the need for guaranteeing free movement of persons and their goods.'" In the Kivus, to the UN the FARDC is just one of two parties. In the northeast, the FARDC is the horse the UN has bet on, and carries to the race. Until things go wrong...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2orientale123108.html

On Gaza, UN's "62 Civilian Casualties" Misstatement Goes Global, On Wires, Wall Street and Sky News

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un62civilians123008.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 30 -- A number of civilians killed in Gaza, 62, that the UN put out on Monday and then later qualified has nevertheless gone all over the world without the qualification attached, thus understating the deaths of non-combatants. UN Humanitarian Coorindator John Holmes on Monday told the Press that "on the Palestinian side, there's something like 320 dead... sixty two of those killed we believe are civilian casualties." Video here, from Minute 7:50. Holmes went on, "that simply encompasses those who are women and children."

Inner City Press asked Holmes, who made the decision to use a methodology which excluded all men? Holmes replied that it is not a methodology, and emphasized that the number is only for women and children. Video here, from Minute 48:34.

But the phrase "62 of those killed we believe are civilian casualties," which Holmes himself read out from a prepared statement, went out on wire services, leavened by what credibility the UN has.

Associated Press reported that "the UN said at least 62 of the dead were civilians." The same phrase then showed up in an article in the Washington Times bylined by Richard Gross, "At least 62 of the dead were civilians, the U.N. said."

Reuters followed in what they called a "Fact Box" that "the Israeli strikes have killed at least 335 Palestinians, including at least 62 civilians."

The Wall Street Journal dropped the phrase "at least" and reported on "casualties, which United Nations estimated Monday at 320 dead, including 62 civilians." From there it continued, from Sky News to Radio Netherlands, from India to Turkey and beyond.

So who is responsible? And what will be done to correct this?


While the UN might like to blame sloppy reporting, Holmes used the phrase "sixty two of those killed we believe are civilian casualties." Tuesday, after the UN postponed and then cancelled a scheduled press conference by its Middle East envoy Robert Serry, Inner City Press asked for another briefing by Holmes and Karen AbuZayd of UNRWA, on topics specifically including the numbers and how the decisions were made.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un62civilians123008.html

Gaza Casualties Disputed, UN Implies Killed Men Are Not Civilians, Ban Takes No Questions

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1statsgaza122908.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 29 -- Deviating from the way it reports casualties in conflicts from Darfur to the Congo, the UN on Monday announced that less than 65 women and children have been killed since Saturday in Gaza. Inner City Press asked UN Humanitarian Coordinator John Holmes who had decided to use this methodology, and how it contrasts with that used by the UN and his Office in Darfur and the Congo. It's not a methodology, Holmes answered, we were just trying to be helpful. One wag asked, helpful to whom?

Another UN official, Karen AbuZayd of the UN Relief and Works Agency, said that she too was dubious about the numbers, even that "a good lawyer" had told her not to use them. Inner City Press asked her, in light of her report that Israel's air strikes are targeting "individual houses and individual families," how these are being selected, whether they raise the presumption of extrajudicial killing, and if UN human rights officials such as the rapporteur on the issue Philip Alston -- or the International Criminal Court -- have been contact in this regard.

Ms. AbuZayd described a process in which people receive phone calls telling them to leave their houses, either because there are weapons in the houses -- she questioned how Israel could know this -- or because the residents include perceived Hamas senior leaders. She said her office has not been in touch with the UN's human rights officials, but that she's seen statements she agrees with. Click here for Navi Pillay's statement. UNRWA's web site does not appear to have been updated for these ten past crucial days, or since December 18 as of December 29 at noon, click here for that.


As so often happens at the UN, the questions fell along predictable political lines. As Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon was leaving after reading a statement and taking no questions, a correspondent from an Arabic cable channel shouted a question at him. Later a journalist from a Lebanese newspaper asked Holmes, the humanitarian, to explain Ban's call for Arab foreign ministers to use all efforts to bring the conflict to a close. She asked, What did Ban mean? Holmes was unable to answer. Ban said he had to meet "Ambassadors from the region." But this has happened before, the unilateral statement with no questions taken.

A right-leaning US television network, on the other hand, emphasized the firing of rockets at Israel. He also asked why pressure is not brought to bear on Egypt to open the crossing at Rafah. Holmes said its a problem of allowing only "one way" access. But the "Arab street," as they call it, is asking the same question of Egypt, albeit for a different reason. Why imprison civilians in the shooting gallery that is Gaza? Perhaps the UN should at least advocate for women and children, to which they appear to limit their definition of civilian in this conflict.

Holmes noted in an aside that some women may not be civilians. So is the UN's figure going to go up -- or down?

Inner City Press has pursued the Rafa crossing issue with Ambassador of Egypt, to be reported on later today on this site - click here.

As previously reported, Israel's UN Ambassador Gabriela Shalev on December 23 met with Ban Ki-moon. Inner City Press asked Ban's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe, at that day's noon briefing, what the meeting had been about. That the expiration of the cease fire in Gaza would have been discussed seemed obvious. The question was intended to glean whether any statement as to timing had been made by the Israeli Ambassador. "We'll get you a readout," Ms. Okabe said. Video here.

Later on December 23, Ban's Spokesperson's Office sent Inner City Press the following:

From: unspokesperson-donotreply [at] un.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 12/23/2008 3:31:10 P.M. Eastern Standard Time
Subj: Your question at noon

Regarding the Secretary-General's meeting with the Israeli Permanent Representative today, it was purely a courtesy call.

"Purely a courtesy call"? That is the phrase used when diplomats who are leaving the UN visit the 38th floor for a final photo opportunity with the Secretary-General.

And see,
www.innercitypress.com/un1statsgaza122908.html

At UN, Nigeria Gives Myanmar $500,000, Bypassing UN Programs, Also UN-Transparent

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/joy1myanmar122508.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 25 -- Two days before Christmas, Myanmar's mission to the UN got a gift with no strings attached. In the dimly-lit Indonesia Lounge next to the General Assembly chamber, Nigeria's Permanent Representative Joy Ogwu handed her counterpart from Myanmar Kyaw Tint Swe a check for $500,000. This was Nigeria's response to the UN's plea for funds to continue to respond to Cyclone Nargis, which hit in May.

The UN has been exposed, first by Inner City Press, for allowing the military government of Myanmar to take 25% of aid funds through currency exchange. Nigeria gave its money directly, in U.S. dollars, and apparently with no requirement to report back on how the funds are used. This is the type of hard currency for which Senior General Than Shwe is desperate.

Later on December 23, Inner City Press asked a South Asian diplomat active on the UN budget why he thought Nigeria gave direct. "You make more friends that way," he said. "If you give through the UN, you don't know how your money's used. If you give it direct, you can ask for reports if you want. And if you don't want, that's fine to. You just have a new friend."

There are at least two possible explanations of Nigeria's direct "south to south" contribution. One is that there's a lack of confidence in the UN system as a transmitter of funds. For example, the UN has not even committed to disclosing, in the Consolidated Appeals that it issues, how much it loses in government-required currency exchange. The second is that Nigeria wants a friend in Myanmar, perhaps even a piece of the resources for which China and India, along firms such as Total and even Lloyds, and South Korea's Daewoo, are competing.

Ambassador Ogwu's statement, a copy of which Inner City Press obtained and puts online here, professes Nigeria's "unflinching support for the government" of Myanmar.

In the half-light on December 23, there were only two reporters present. Inner City Press asked Ambassador Ogwu if the UN's envoy to Myanmar, fellow Nigerian Ibrahim Gambari, had played any role in this donation. No, she insisted. She had previous told Inner City Press that her government had invited Gambari to try to mediate the Niger Delta conflict not as a UN official -- that would "internationalize" the conflict, she said -- but rather as a Nigerian personality.

The Myanmar government, too, opposes internationalization, not only in the form of UN peacekeepers, but even election monitors. Ban Ki-moon was told to leave the country when voting in the run-up to the controversial elections, which exclude Aung San Suu Kyi, was held.

The other reporter asked a aide to Kyaw Tint Swe how much the check was for. "None of your business," he replied. Hardly an auspicious beginning to transparency in aid use.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/joy1myanmar122508.html

As UN Budget's Passed, G-77's Champagne Dreams Echoed by Nicaraguan Priest, "Non-Stop Nothingness" to 8 AM

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unga1budnica122408.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 24, 4:30 am [to 8 am] -- It was four in the morning on Christmas Eve when the General Assembly prepared to meet on its budget. Delegates emerged from the basement, where for days issues ranging from development jobs to the rent of the Group of 77 were debated, capitals were called, cigarettes were smoked. Now like a school semester it was almost over. Goodbyes were being said. Secretariat officials, long term players, surfed sentimentality to the benefit of their own offices, if not the wider UN much less world peace.

In the Delegates' Lounge in the lead-up to the GA meeting, champagne corks were popping. And some things had been accomplished. A shot across the bow of unaccountable UN investigator Inga-Britt Ahlenius. A check-in and check-up on the imperious envoy to Lebanon Terje Roed Larsen. For development, 92 new posts, albeit spread out in regional commissions all over the world. Champagne at four a.m. was not entirely unearned.

But as bitter after-taste was the failure to follow through. A year ago, this committee demanded answers about the UN's no-bid contract with Lockheed Martin, $250 million for camps in Darfur that Lockheed never built. There was no follow through; Lockheed took the money and ran.

At 4:20 a.m. the hold-up for the GA meeting was to pick up Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, el Presidente, from his residence. He would come to deliver a speech. Lincoln's was only four minutes, one of his staffers pointed out. There were potato chips and peanuts. The PGA, it was said, was already in the building. And so it remained until it approached 5:45 in the morning.

Update of 6:05 a.m. -- the usual press entrances to the GA hall, through the 3rd floor, were unmanned and locked. A film strip about the Holocaust was playing in a loop. Back on the 2nd floor, one guard stood on protocol and placed phone calls about the locked doors. Another guard simply waved Inner City Press through. Inside the chamber, from the blue colored "VIP" seats on the left side of the chamber, d'Escoto and his Moldovan master of ceremonies looked vaguely ridiculous on their raised green marble stage as if from Star Trek. The voting had begun, paragraph by paragraph --

when a UN Security Officer demanded that Inner City Press go back up to the third floor. But upstairs, the doors were still locked. Back downstairs, the Officer spoke into his walkie talkie, "McClachy! McClachy!" A delegate walked by and asked why the Press was being harassed. On the screens above the podium, votes were being recorded. The U.S. was again disassociating itself. Go upstairs again, the officer said. This time the doors were open. A request over the dark blue velvet rope for a copy of the voting sheet was meant with incomprehension. I'm giving these to them, was the answer. Many nations' seats were unfilled. One one vote -- after all the disruption, hard for now to know which -- the results were 109 for - 13 against - 35 abstaining. It doesn't add to 192.

Update of 6:21 a.m. -- Myanmar is speaking, against "the use of human rights for political purposes," bragging about the Constitution passed in the wake of Cyclone Nargis, with opposition to it illegal. "We will not be bound by it," Myanmar's representative said. And with that, the reports of the Third Committee were done, and those of the Fifth Committee began, at 6:23 a.m..

Update of 6:31 am - as a representative from the Philippines, rapporteur of the Fifth Committee, reads out the titles of resolutions adopted without a vote, Inner City Press is approached again, admonished for having accepted the invitation to enter from the second floor, since the third floor was locked. Front the seats in the back, the chairs of Bangladesh, the Bahamas and Azerbaijan are empty, while the representative of Austria, a country entering the Security Council in January over the defeated Iceland, is sound asleep throughout the Third Committee votes. Turkey's seat, too, was empty, while the representatives in Venezuela's and Zimbabwe's seats were sleeping.*

* - full disclosure: Inner City Press fell asleep and was photographed while waiting for d'Escoto to begin the General Assembly session, sometime around 5:30 a.m., and awoke amid the detritis of a drained case of Baltika, the "Famous Beer of Russia."

Update of 6:57 a.m. -- D'Escoto is droning on reading the names of Fifth Committee resolutions, still not vote on any of them. They are flying through: DPA, Development, ICT...

Update of 7:05 a.m. -- the first request for a vote is from France, on paragraph 3bis of Draft Resolution 4 about Terje Roed Larsen. Lebanon speaks against France's proposed deletion of the paragraph, and urges delegates to "press the red button." On so little sleep, it's good to be direct. And vote it taken, and comes out in favor of France's pro-Larsen proposal, 50; against, 88, abstentions, 3. "In consequence, France's proposal is not approved," d'Escoto intones, in Spanish.

Update of 7:13 am -- the US representative says the paragraph was politicized. Syria begins to disagree.

Update of 7:29 am -- after a 15 minute speech by Syria, d'Escoto reminds "with all due respect that we are taking too much time," then says "I give the microphone to Israel." But the delegation asking for the mic is Lebanon, sitting behind Israel. Perhaps since he was accused of not letter Israel speak, d'Escoto wants to show he'll call on them even if they don't ask for the floor. One can see the sky is light, through the smoked glass windows facing north from the UN.

Update of 7:35 a.m. -- d'Escoto has left the podium, another presiding officer, also speaking Spanish, takes his place.

Update of 7:38 a.m. -- d'Escoto is back, hugs his replacement and resumes his seat, you figure it out. He thanks the president of the Fifth Committee.

Update of 7:44 a.m. -- the budget items are over, d'Escoto starts a speech, mentioning the "Culture of Peace," people are standing and leaving. The representative of Yemen is screaming into his cell phone. "There's no security," a cleaning man remarks. Talk about a whimper, dream about a bang.

Update of 8:02 a.m. and hopefully the last -- on the green carpet in front of the General Assembly, the delegates are pouring out. The President, too: d'Escoto approaches Inner City Press, his handshake is warm, like the Russian beer in the Delegates' Lounge. Inner City Press apologizes for some reason for the delegations that left in the middle of his speech. "The Latins, they all stayed," a d'Escoto aide says hopefully. Ion the Moldovan, master of cerimonies, adds, Look who's hear working hard.

A Security Officer, coming in well-rested from a night of sleep, asks Inner City Press what's been happening.

"Non-stop nothingness," is the phrase that comes to mind.

"If you don't publish that, I'll stop telling you things." Consider it done.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unga1budnica122408.html

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

UN's Hiring from Permanent Five Grows, China by 8%, US by 134 Jobs, Japan Slower While Others Lose

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/list2staff122208.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 22 -- The number of staffers employed by the UN from the 15 member states on the Security Council continued to rise in 2008, even as the global financial crisis set in and Ban Ki-moon appeared to call for cost-cutting. The just-published List of Staff, supposedly confidential but obtained by Inner City Press, compared to the previous year shows that the number of U.S. nationals employed by the UN rose 134, of six percent, between mid-2007 and mid-2008. France rose by 44 jobs, or 3.8%. The UK gained 27 posts, 3.6%. Russia rose by 11, or 2.4%.

China had the sharpest percentage increase of the Council's Permanent Five member, fully eight percent, but this constituted only 27 jobs, as China began with the fewest of the so-called P-5. UN insiders tied China's eight percent increase to Chinese national Sha Zukang taking the reigns at the Department of Economic and Social Affairs, which the Group of 77 and China is now trying to further expand.

Two non-permanent Security Council members saw their number of staff members decrease, Indonesia and Belgium, while Vietnam and Libya stayed the same, at eight and four posts in both 2007 and 2008, respectively. Italy, on the other hand, rose from 390 to 417 posts, having more jobs in both periods than much more populous China, and larger contributor Japan.

Japan, the second-largest contributor to the UN budget, rose by 3.4% from 237 to 245 positions. Rising faster were Germany, from 422 to 450, and Canada, from 550 to 598 (8.7%). Australia grew even more rapidly, at an eighteen percent clip, from 245 to 289.

Leaders in the Group of 77 Brazil and Egypt, currently proposing many more jobs for the UN's Department of Economic and Society Affairs, themselves had only 135 and 164 posts, respectively. Incoming Security Council member Turkey declined from 51 posts to 50. Other decliners included Iceland, from 16 to 13, and Greece, from 56 to 52.

The pattern that emerges from the data is that the UN's employment of nationals of the Security Council's Permanent Five members continues to rise, even as posts for some of the Council's non-permanent members declines. Whether this is because the P-5 actively demand the jobs, or those who do the UN's hiring see the value of pleasing the System's most powerful countries, cannot be determined from the data. On that, our inquiries continue, as well as analysis of certain countries not listed in this first report. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/list2staff122208.html

UN Wastes $3 Million on 30,000 Oracle Licenses Left Unused, Sources Say, As Budget Committee Meets, No Ban Comment

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1oracle122208.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 22 -- The UN purchased 30,000 licenses from Oracle to a computer program called Seibel, a so-called Customer Relations Management (CRM) system. The contract is for $7.5 million, of which over $3 million have already been paid to Oracle. But the licenses have never been used, according to UN computer system personnel.

These whistleblowers, outraged at the waste and of accountability they say is pervasive, have directed Inner City Press to the documentary evidence of the phantom contract. Click here to view the listing of Oracle's $7,581,607 contract PD/C0025/07; click here to view the UN's intranet's presentation that "implementation is expected to begin in June 2006," which has yet to occur despite the outlay of $3,073,214.

In the UN's online Procurement database, the information about the Seibel purchase from Oracle is substantially less detailed than from other purchases. For other purchases, the specifications of the procurement are online, often dozens of pages. For this purchase from Oracle, there are no online specifications. Click here.

Internal whistleblowers tell Inner City Press that worse than the mis-management that led to the purchase of 30,000 licenses well before they would or even could be used is the cover-up that has occurred afterwards. They also identify as problematic the UN's contracting with EMC Corporation to purchase licenses for a program called Documentum, ostensibly to replace the UN's Official Document System for the UN's "Enterprise Content Management" system, ECM.

The flawed contracting began under the tenure of Eduardo Blinder, who has since migrated to the even less overseen International Computing Center, to which the UN Secretariat outsources much of its work and procurement. More recently, the person responsible for the waste is the Officer in Charge who replaced Blinder, Chandramouli Ramanathan.

In the UN's basement, Ban Ki-moon's Secretariat's CRM and ECM are being considered for the UN's Fifth (Budgetary) Committee. But the Committee members have never been informed of the waste that has occurred. Nor has the Office of Internal Oversight Services, embroiled in its own scandal, done anything.

In a draft of the pending resolution provided to Inner City Press by a budget committee source, the Secretary-General is criticized for proceeding with CRM and ECM before making any proposal to the General Assembly.

Inner City Press has asked Ban's spokesperson Michele Montas about this critique from the General Assembly. Video here. Ms. Montas said she would have no comment at all until after the Assembly vote on the resolution which she said might not take place until Christmas Eve. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1oracle122208.html

At UN, Korean Staff Rise from 51 to 70 in Ban's Two Years, on Pianos and Lobbyists, An Evolution

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/list1staff122008.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 20 -- As Ban Ki-moon approaches his third year UN Secretary-General, the tug of his home country South Korea remains in evidence, which some around him seek to change. During a trip last month to Bangladesh, India, Nepal and the Philippines, South Korean business representatives sought repeatedly to meet Ban, and even got themselves listed on his schedule, until a staffer took them off. The just-released List of UN Staff as of July 1, 2008 shows 70 South Korean UN staff, up from 51 two years ago. Of the top five official in the Office of the Secretary-General, three are Korean, including Kim Won-soo, the advisor sometimes called Ban's brain, in a reference to Karl Rove and George W. Bush.

In Ban's first half-year at the UN, questions about what some called the Koreanization of the UN were met with denials and even threats. Inner City Press sought the List of Staff as of July 1, 2006 and was told that it would not be released. Obtaining a copy nonetheless, Inner City Press published the list of Korea staff, as a baseline. Ban's Spokesperson's Office complained, saying that the list could not be published. As an accommodation, Inner City Press then redacted the names from the list, and is not running most full names in this then-promised update article.

We note, however, that for the last name Choi, there were three UN staff in mid-2007, and seven in mid-2008. The new hires include Under Secretary General Choi Young-Jin, head of the UN mission in Cote d'Ivoire, and Assistant Secretary General Choi Soon Hong, Ban's chief technology officer. To be fair, Han Seung-Soo has fallen off the list, as he returned to South Korea to serve as Prime Minister. Some predict more of this eastward migration. More generally, a Ban administration shake-up is predicted for early 2009, on which we will report.

At Ban's December 17 holiday party, he told the press that only the day before, a Korean company had donated a piano for his Sutton Place residence. Some sought to snoop around to see the renovated kitchen used, it has been reported, by Ban's own Korean chef. Inner City Press chose not to look around, and as luck would have it handed Ban a wine glass when he needed one to make a toast. Ban's scheduler, Yoon Yeocheol, joked genially that "you are taking over my job." Ban introduced a pianist, also Korean, who played with energy his own classical composition.

South Korea's contributions to UN Peacekeeping have gone up; statements have been made about the Millennium Development Goals and climate change. Relations between North and South Korea have not meaningfully improved, what with North Korea's recent expulsion of Southerners.

An internal Ban administration memo strategizing how Ban's UN could take a central role in Korean Peninsula matters, Inner City Press' reporting on which also led to push-back and a refusal to comment on leaked documents, has not borne fruit. One if left wondering if, just as Team Ban never announced the appointment of Robert Fowler as their envoy to Niger, there might be a stealth envoy to the Korean Peninsula whose existence and name has not been announced.

Other than on some officials' voluntary public financial disclosure, the UN's transparency has yet to improve under Ban. Only this week, Inner City Press was told that the list of UN envoys should not be publicized or provided, and that even the terms of Robert Fowler's mandate are confidential. Click here for more. In connection with this month's Middle East Quartet meeting in New York, letters to and from Tony Blair in his UN role on the Quartet were not disclosed or even summarized.

Speaking of letters, at his holiday party Ban told the press of a Korean saying, that if you really love a girl, a potential girlfriend, you should write her ten love letters before getting some answer from her. While his point was not entirely clear -- other than his obvious and endearing love for his wife -- it appeared to concern persistence, which among with independence is needed not only in running but also in covering the United Nations.
And see, www.innercitypress.com/list1staff122008.html

UK and UK Split on Kenya Explains UN Council Disfunction, S. Africa's Kumalo Describes

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1kumalo121808.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 18, updated -- Following his mediation earlier this year of the violence in Kenya between supporters of Raila Odinga and Mwai Kibaki, Kofi Annan for months has been scheduled to provide a report and briefing to the Security Council. Inner City Press on Thursday asked outgoing South African Permanent Representative Dumisani Kumalo why it hasn't happened, if it had to do with the UK and U.S. taking different positions on Kibaki and Odinga, respectively. Ambassador Kumalo agreed, and said that the Council only works with all of the Permanent Five members agree, if then.

Kumalo gave Sudan as another example, and might as well have mentioned this year's war in Georgia. At that time, Russian Ambassador Vitaly Churkin questioned the objectively of the UN's own reporting, by "the American" Lynn Pascoe of the Department of Political Affairs. Inner City Press asked Kumalo whether in his experience the UN Secretariat is also dominated by the Permanent Five members of the Council. Kumalo recounted that he was required to intervene before the release of a particularly one-sided UN Secretariat report. It later emerged that he was referring to a report on Western Sahara, in which France on behalf of Morocco exercised undue influence.

Kumalo described a situation in which the Council's "lead countries" on African conflicts are not themselves from Africa, but are the "former colonial powers." He gave France's management of all things Chad as an example, and said that when he was in Chad this year, he asked "what are we doing here?" Inner City Press was along for that trip, and the degree to which Council members were asked to defer to France's views on Chad, including cover-up of human rights abuses there, was striking. Ironically, Chadean President Idriss Deby declined to even meet with the French-led Council delegation, despite having returned in time from a trip to Libya. The echoes of that confrontation with the press corps continue to reverberate.

Footnote: In fairness, the South African mission too, at least on Thursday, had some issues with the press. After Kumalo's press conference, a reporter who had asked about "Mbeki's failed mediation in Zimbabwe" was challenged by a South African diplomat visiting the UN Mission. "I challenge your credentials as a journalist," he reportedly said. Inner City Press asked him about the incident, and that more apologetic approach taken in response is now anticipated. As Kumalo would be the first to say -- and may in the book he is said to be planning -- none of us are perfect.

It's said Kumalo will be leaving his country's foreign service in early 2009. As he said during the press conference, in predicting that U.S. policy will not change much under Obama, he has lived in the U.S. a long time. Some predict he will stay here, perhaps seeking and landing a job with the UN. We'll see.

Update of December 19 -- Inner City Press asked Amb. Kumalo what he will do in February. I'll go back and see what they have for me, he said. When Inner City Press asked if he'd consider working for the UN -- for example as a Special Representative, maybe in Somalia -- Kumalo just laughed...

And see,
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1kumalo121808.html

As UN's Stealth Envoy Goes Missing in Niger, Secret Process and Payments Questioned

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1fowler121608.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 16 -- Days after Robert Fowler, belated described as a Special Envoy of the UN Secretary General, disappeared in Niger, UN spokesperson Michele Montas said there are other as-yet-undisclosed envoys out in the field. Inner City Press asked if the list of special envoys is confidential. "I'm not saying its confidential," Ms. Montas responded. "I don't see what is the use of making them public until something is actually done." Video here, from Minute 17:16.

But the names of other envoys who have not accomplished their stated missions are routinely and repeatedly made public. Matthew Nimetz, for example, has been the envoy on the unresolved "name issue" about the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia for more than ten years. So what was Mr. Fowler doing in Niger, and who are the other stealth envoys of the UN's Ban Ki-moon?

Hours after Ms. Montas' statement that the list would be provided, it has not been. The only question which was answered after the briefing concerned Fowler's rank and method of payment: " Robert Fowler is employed on a When Actually Employed (WAE) contract at the Under-Secretary-General level." That's a high rate of pay. But how much has Fowler actually been employed by the UN since he was so quietly appointed? And what has he been doing?

It has been reported that "the UN vehicle carrying Mr. Fowler, Canadian diplomat Louis Guay and their locally hired driver was found unoccupied Sunday night about 45 kilometers northwest of the capital of Niamey, raising fears they have been kidnapped. According to authorities in Niger, the trio had visited a gold mine operated by a Canadian company about 125 kilometers from Niamey." This last has been confirmed when "UN spokesman Farharn Haq said the three men were headed Saturday toward an area called Samira, the site of a gold mine that is partly Canadian-owned."

So was Fowler on UN business? Or Canadian corporate business? Was the UN paying Fowler's full salary or only part? What about conflicts of interest? What was the relation between Fowler's ostensibly UN mission and Louis Guay's Canadian mission? Some note, harkening back to yellow cake, the involvement of Canadian firms in uranium extraction in Niger.

Inner City Press asked Ms. Montas where in the UN budget the payments to Mr. Fowler and other stealth envoys are disclosed. In the budget of the Department of Political Affairs, she said. But DPA, run by American B. Lynn Pascoe, has for weeks declined to provide even a simple summary, requested in a UN noon briefing, of what its mediators are working on. The lack of transparency cannot be justified by the purported sensitivity of the topics. Many topics at the UN are sensitive, but nevertheless it is an inter-governmental agency whose budget is public, and whose Secretary-General is supposed to take direction from, or at least make disclosure to, the Security Council or wider General Assembly.

Inner City Press asked the spokesman for the President of the General Assembly if the Assembly was even informed of Ban's naming of Fowler or any more otherwise undisclosed special envoy. He said he didn't think so, but would be looking into the issues. So will we.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1fowler121608.html

Sunday, December 14, 2008

Amid UN's Ministerial Hype, US Praises Departing AMISOM, Sikhs Complain of France

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1minhype121408.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 14 -- A police bus was set up in front of the UN on Sunday night. Inside the building was nearly empty, but metal detectors had been erected in the basement by Conference Room 8. It was the calm before the storm. But what storm?

Monday and Tuesday will see diplomatic action on Zimbabwe and the Middle East, Somalia and Congo. Slated to come are Condi Rice and Sergey Lavrov, and the UK's Milliband. French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner, like Tony Blair, will appear only by video, despite the scheduling Monday of a Sikhs versus France press conference about the Gauls' ban on religious symbols.

Condi is said to be pitching a resolution for UN peacekeepers in Somalia. Since the UK blocked even a bridge force for the Eastern Congo, in which the UN has already spent billions, anything for Somalia seems a long shot. Especially with the U.S. in denial. The quote of the week came from a spokeswoman from the U.S. mission to the United Nations, Nicole Deaner, that "AMISOM is an effective peacekeeping force." Oh really? Then why have the Islamist al-Shabab claimed more and more land, leading to AMISOM's departure?

An article containing Ms. Deaner's quote also cited, without explaining, a professor from North Carolina named Kenneth Menkhaus. He is an advisor of the so-called Enough Project, a subsidiary of the Center for American Progress. Despite the high-sounding name, CAP has refused to reveal its list of donors, even as its director John Podesta bonds with the incoming Obama administration. Was this the change we believed in?

Lavrov's Russia, making nice with the U.S. on the Middle East, should be expected to follow through on its stated anger at Ban Ki-moon's secret agreement with NATO, and his pro-U.S. statements on South Ossetia. Neither is on the agenda these two days. It's a feel-good holiday time at the UN. Only for the Congo and Somalia, there appear to be no gifts.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1minhype121408.html

UN Council Takes Up Vague Middle East Resolution, Tony Blair Stays Silent

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1roadmap121308.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 13 -- Why issue grand pronouncements about elusive Middle East peace just as elections in Israel are approaching, and George Bush is outgoing? At a rare Saturday meeting at the UN, the Security Council met about a vague two-page resolution proffered by the U.S., joined by Russia. The Libyan Ambassador left the meeting first, handing out copies of the draft resolution without comment. Inner City Press is putting the document online here for Page 1, here for Page 2.

Council sources tell Inner City Press that Israel has expressed concern about the call, at the top of page 2, for "both parties [to] refrain from any steps that could undermine confidence or prejudice the outcome of the negotiations." Libya, meanwhile, is expected to return with language urging more specifics in the resolution. Earlier this month, a Libyan ship was blocked by Israel from landing on the Gaza Strip.

But why issue this pronouncement at this time? Cynics in the Council view it as a sop to the Bush administration, for the failure to deliver on the promises made at the Annapolis conference more than a year ago. This way they can say that as they left office there was momentum -- even if facts on the ground belie this Polyanna spin.

A person describing himself as a European diplomat urged on reporters that having the Council involved helps the parties. He assured Russian Permanent Representative Vitaly Churkin that he had only spoken on background. "You softened them up," Ambassador Churkin said. When a reporter tried to cut him off with a question about President Bush, he glared, overrode the reporter and then left the stakeout.

France's Jean-Maurice Ripert spoke last, and Inner City Press asked him about the refusal of Quartet representative Tony Blair to brief the Security Council as non-permanent member South Africa has been requesting for months. "I am not aware of the reasons he will not be talking," Ripert said.

Inner City Press has been told, but the UN has refused to confirm, that Blair's reasons is that he should not speak until after the Israeli elections. But why then is the Council speaking, or trying to speak? The question was not answered.

Nor, on another matter, did Ripert comment on the UN's report of both the Rwandan and Congolese government's assisting armed rebel groups in the Kivus. Inner City Press asked, any comment? "Not yet," Ripert said. Some surmise that the report or the possible actions to be taken on it will be used as negotiation fodder.

About Tony Blair, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson on December 11 --

Inner City Press: We heard from the Council that Tony Blair has said that he will not brief them in December based on their invitation; that he may in fact not come to the Quartet meeting. Is it your understanding that he will be here at the Quartet meeting but...? He cited some time constraint, is my understanding.

Spokesperson Montas: I am not aware of that. I can try to find out whether Mr. Blair will be there. I don’t have that information at this point.

Question: And also if he’s declining the invitation to brief the Council, what’s the reason for that?

[The Spokesperson later added that Mr. Blair, as well as Mr. Kouchner, were scheduled, as of now, to participate in the Quartet meeting via videolink.]

This was followed up on at the December 12 noon briefing:

Question: I just wanted to find out about this; you talked about this Middle East Quartet meeting. Mr. Blair is supposed to be speaking from video?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: Yes.

Question: Why isn’t Mr. Blair making himself available to the Quartet? He’s being paid a lot of money, and he has... but he is making himself as sparse as possible. I mean, to come here to the United Nations, what is his (inaudible)?

Associate Spokesperson: First of all, making himself available by video link is participating in the meeting. He will participate in all activities of the meeting. He will just not be physically present in New York. That’s a standard feature of meetings. We try to schedule meetings whenever they are convenient for all people to be in the same venue at the same time. If that’s not possible physically, we try to make the appropriate arrangements by video link, and that’s what we’re doing in this case.

Question: Just to follow up to this question. Who are the Arab Foreign Ministers coming to attend this conference, this Quartet meeting?

Associate Spokesperson: As far as that goes, some of the arrangements are still being made. So I don’t have any names officially to give out to you just now. But if you come upstairs after this meeting, we can provide you with a few additional details.

Question: I mean, it’s supposed to be a meeting between Arab Foreign Ministers and the Quartet; that’s the sign originally?

Associate Spokesperson: Yes, and you may have missed this, but I mentioned that at the start that there will be a meeting in Conference Room 8 from 4:30 p.m. to 6 p.m. on Monday.

Question: The media has already announced that there will be the Foreign Ministers of Egypt and Saudi Arabia. Will that be the case?

Associate Spokesperson: Like I said, because the arrangements are still being worked out, I don’t want to give out all the names just yet. We do have some additional details upstairs, so we can provide that for you after this. Matthew?

Inner City Press: First, it’s a follow-up on this Tony Blair question. Since he represents the UN, can you confirm that he was asked to brief the Security Council in this month and he declined to do so?

Associate Spokesperson: I think, for that, the best thing to do is to talk to the President of the Security Council; they’re the ones in charge of the arrangements for the Security Council.

Question: But as a representative of the UN, he sent a letter saying “I won’t come…” (interrupted).

Associate Spokesperson: He is not just a representative of the UN. He, as you know, is a representative of the entire Quartet, so we don’t speak directly for Mr. Blair. But he has an office, and we can give you the contact number for his office.

But 24 hours later, still no contact information for Tony Blair had been given. And Jean-Maurice Ripert, representing both France and the EU, said he doesn't know why Blair is not going to speak to the Council...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1roadmap121308.html

ABN-AMRO and ING Are Facilitators of Congo Sanctions Violations, ICC Disclosure Not Solved

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/drc1stearns121208.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 12 -- "We're not supposed to talk about UN reform or accountability in peacekeeping operations," the head of the UN's Group of Experts on the Democratic Republic of the Congo Jason Stearns told the Press on Friday. Inner City Press asked if Stearns' Group had at least investigated the reports of top UN peacekeeper and Indian colonel praising rebel Laurent Nkunda, now accused of killed more than 100 civilians in Kiwanja. No, Stearns said, his Group's priority had been to focus on the main supporters of Nkunda's group, the CNDP. Video here, from Minute 28:18.

But if the UN does detailed investigation, shouldn't it include review of whether it or its peacekeepers are part of the problem? Apparently not.

Stearns nevertheless provided one of the more informative UN briefings in recent memory. His Group's report names the wife of Laurent Nkunda, and three banks which transferred money to her: ING, ABN-AMRO and KBC. Inner City Press asked if Stearns thought the financial transfers of these banks were appropriate. "Nkunda's wife is not on the sanctions list," Stearns said.

The same legal hair-splitting obtained when Inner City Press asked whether the interviews Stearns' Group has done will be provided to the Office of the International Criminal Court prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo. Most of it is public record, Stearns answered. But what about the interviews granted on condition of anonymity?

If shared with Ocampo, it seems they will have to be shared with any defense attorneys, as reflected by the ICC judges' freezing of the Congo case against Thomas Lubanga. That's up to to the ICC, Stearns said. Which makes it appear at the UN system is still in disarray in terms of how confidentiality can be promised to witnesses for information that may be shared with the ICC, requiring disclosure to defendants. Doctor, heal thyself...

Footnote: The appearance by Stearns, previously of the International Crisis Group, was a break from the usual invisibility and lack of accountability of UN Experts Groups. The Somalia Group, for example, issued a report alleging the Somalis were being trained in Lebanon, but never came to explain it. Likewise, those who came before Stearns on the DRC implied that Congolese uranium was leaking out, which others linked to Iran. Stearns disclaimed that, and criticized the BCC for implying this Group was wiretapping. Hey, Bush did it...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/drc1stearns121208.html

UN's Rwanda Prosecutor Says He Cleared Karenzi, Contra Navi Pillay, No News On Nepali Generals

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2karenzi121208.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 12 -- The UN system's approach to Rwanda was shown this week to be in disarray. The prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda, Hassan B. Jallow, told the Press on Friday that his Office had been asked about the service with the UN Peacekeeping Mission in Darfur by Rwandan General Karenzi Karake, indicted for war crimes by a judge in Spain. Jallow said his answer had been that he had no case against Karenzi, who as a consequence is still in his UN job.

But on December 9 in the same room, High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay had told the Press that her Office had raised issues of war crimes by Karenzi Karake while with the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RFP), well as getting several Nepali generals removed from peacekeeping missions due to their involvement in disappearances. Inner City Press had asked Ms. Pillay what the UN does about abuses among its peacekeepers, and was told on December 10 that further information was being sought from Ms. Pillay, which two days later has not been provided.

So the UN system's top human rights official is taking credit for raising war crimes issues about a top UN peacekeeping general, while a top UN system prosecutor first says he doesn't recognize the general's name, then says he cleared him.

Meanwhile, the UN's Congo sanctions committee has issued a report linking the RPF-successor Rwandan government with the rebels in Congo led by Tutsi general Laurent Nkunda, while saying on the other hand that the Congolese government army is in league with the Hutu FDLR rebels.

News analysis: Could the ICTR's refusal to prosecute any RFP abusers, and UN Peacekeeping's failure to heed what the UN Human Rights Commissioner says she raised about RFP general Karenzi, have played a role in creating the atmosphere in which the Rwandan support of Nkunda described in the report takes place? The UN doesn't report on itself, at least not on issues like this. But it should.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2karenzi121208.html