Sunday, September 21, 2008

UN Remains Unreformed After Srgjan Kerim's Year, Sarah Palin on Her Way?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unga1kerim091608.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 16 -- At the end of his year as president of the UN General Assembly (PGA), Srgjan Kerim on Tuesday said he is "personally disappointed" with how the member states dealt with a UN reform issue that, due to Press coverage, became synonymous with Kerim: the lack of independence of the PGA due not being paid by the UN but by a particular country or, in Kerim's case, company.

Early in his tenure, Inner City Press asked Kerim how he got paid, and it emerged that his pay came from his country and once and future employer, WAZ Media. While Kerim showed some displeasure when Inner City Press went on to analyze the potential conflicts of interest created by these arrangement, he maintained that he would seek General Assembly action before the end of his term.

On Tuesday, as Nicaragua's Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann took over as PGA, Kerim acknowledged that the problem has not been fixed or reformed. He called the situation "urgent." We'll see. Video here, from Minute 17:53.

Elsewhere in his eight-minute response to Inner City Press' two question, Kerim said that the UN budget process is broken, and recounted that in December he spent 23 hours straight in the UN working on the budget, even telling Ban Ki-moon to give a speech to the General Assembly promising to report on spending every three months.

Kerim also took credit for changing the Capital Master Plan to renovate the UN Headquarters, saying he wouldn't have been able to live with himself if he'd agreed to the initial plan, to leave a portion of UN staff inside the building while it was being fixed.

Kerim had a farewell reception last week, at which shrimp and even foie gras were served, with cocktails sipped out on the balcony over the East River. He was given an award for the Millennium Development Goals, like his predecessor and probably his successor, and now according to his spokesman will return to WAZ Media, which he notes in investing in Vietnam and hospitals. We will follow his movements.

Footnotes: as Ambassadors stream in to d'Escoto Brockmann's speech to kick off the 63rd General Assembly on Tuesday afternoon, it emerged that two new crypto-states, Abkhazia and South Ossetia, have tried to get their representatives in but still do not have visas. It was also said, not for attribution that John McCain and Sarah Palin will come to the General Debate, specifically for the latter to "meet world leaders." This might later change.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unga1kerim091608.html

Alaska House in SoHo, Even Palin-Less, Is a Bridge to Somewhere: But Where?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press in SoHo
www.innercitypress.com/us1alaskahs091608.html

NEW YORK, September 16 -- In a gleaming white storefront on SoHo's Mercer Street on Monday night, Native Alaskan art was displayed and some was destroyed. It was the opening of Alaska House, a gallery and also the state's economic embassy in New York. Governor Sarah Palin had been slated to attend, until John McCain tapped her as his running mate.

The space's two stories were standing room only with hipsters, and it at first appeared there were no Alaskans, much less Natives, in attendance. Inner City Press, drawn as a matter of news by the prospect of Palin, interviewed a series of lobbyists and filmmakers, finally finding one of each who was an Alaskan Native. The initial purpose was to ask for views of Palin, but the trail soon led farther afield.

The U.S. Arctic Research Commission's Mead Treadwell, soon to fly to Tokyo to speak of whaling "among other things," one of them being drilling the Arctic for oil, told Inner City Press about Alaska House's founder, Alice Rogoff Rubenstein. "Her husband David started a hedge fund you may of heard of," Treadwell said. "The Carlyle Group. It dawned on her that her husband didn't need her for the business. So she found a cause, Alaska. The state is lucky."

"But what's her connection to Alaska?"

"You'll have to ask her." Ultimately Inner City Press did. But first the question was put to her beneficiaries, direct and indirect. Andrew Okpeaha MacLean, the Alaskan Native director of Sikumi (On Thin Ice), a winner of the Jury Prize at the Sundance Film Festival, explained that his mother Edna Ahgeak MacLean is a noted Inupiaq linguist, and that his current project is about a murder on Alaskan ice. "Who did it?"

We won't spoil the murder mystery for you, his non-Alaskan producer Cara Marcous said.

They were accompanied by a Alaskan Native who gave her name only as Mary and who said that her boss is on the board of directors of the Alaska Native Arts Foundation. She works in Washington for the North Star Group, which "promotes a bunch of project in Alaska," as she put it.

"Do these include oil?"

They do. Mary is from Dillingham, the same town as Sarah Palin's husband the First Dude, Todd. What does she think of Palin? Her running for vice president is great for the state, Mary said, adding that she'll be voting for Obama. "She's a little too into Jesus," Mary said of Palin. "It makes people who aren't a little scared, that they'll be discriminated against."

There was a crash as an Alaskan Native mask was knocked from the wall to the floor. From outside on Mercer Street came another crash, as the ice sculpture that marked this unmistakably as a climate change event collapsed. "Did it happened naturally?" someone asked, as in a murder mystery. Yes was the answer. An ice piece was carted off.

There by the front door was Alice Rogoff Rubenstein, saying goodbye to her guests. Asked for her views on Sarah Palin, she echoed that her candidacy is good for the state. "My personal views, I'll keep to myself," she said. Inner City Press recounted Mead Treadwell's summary and asked, how did you choose Alaska. "It had nothing to do with my husband," she quickly said. She'd always wanted to go to Alaska, and finally did. She followed the Iditerod dog sled race around, and on the way found Native art. The rest, she said, is history.

But is there any government money behind it? Well, yes. There was an appropriation from Congress used for it.

Would that be an earmark?

Yes.

Even amid the crashing of the masks and ice sculpture, the irony was thick. Palin's tale of rebuffing earmark funding for the so-called Bridge to Nowhere stands in contrast to her state's embassy to hipsters being funded, at least indirectly, by earmark funds from taxpayers, combined with money from a hedge fund involved not only with military contractors but also subprime lending. Alaska House, it turns, is itself a bridge to somewhere. But where?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/us1alaskahs091608.html

In UNDP Secrecy Plan, Even Funders Must Gives Reasons to See Audits, Board Must Be Notified, Resuming Sept. 19

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN Analysiswww.innercitypress.com/undp1audits091208.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 12 -- The culture of secrecy and cover-up in the UN, at least in the UN Development Program, was on display on Friday night. The UNDP Executive Board meeting went into overtime, without translators, due to objections to even the watered-down proposal to let member states see audits of UNDP country programs while withholding them from the public. A proposal was made by UNDP's Board President to add a requirement that any requester of an audit must state the "reason / purpose of the request," and also that UNDP notify not only the "concerned country" but also the wider Executive Board before providing any documents.

This falls far short of most Freedom of Information laws, which provide for individuals to gain access to documents whether or not they fund they underlying programs. Here, roadblocks are being erected to funders seeing audits of what they have funded. Only at the UN...

UNDP's Administrator Kemal Dervis, who has contributed to this culture of secrecy by for example refusing to answer even factual questions was not in the Board meeting to the end. Nor was his Associate Ad Melkert, who had promised transparency and reform. Akiko Yuge was in the house, as a ten minute recess was called to consider the enhanced secrecy amendments. The ten minutes too were extended. "Thomas of Switzerland," as the Board president called him, was called to the front to translate. The Board president bragged that he had a very fun schedule for the weekend -- "maybe you don't" -- and so he wanted a vote on his language of more secret audits.

The draft he circulated also differed from what he'd read out loud, this time allowing the Executive Board as well as the concerned government to "view and comment on the report" prior to it being given to any funding member state.

Update of 8:25 p.m. -- "Ten minutes" has gone over an hour. Rationales for secrecy are offered to Inner City Press: disclosure can lead to suspension of programs as in North Korea; even if a country commits to not share an audit with the press, there is no recourse for violating the commitment. But if a program is funded by a public body like the UN, how can how the money's spend legitimately be kept confidential?

Update of 8:40 p.m. -- The president finally re-gavels the meeting to order, only to announce that no concensus was reached. China speaks, to say this will have an impact on for example the UNICEF board, which meets next week. China "can't make position at this stage."

Do other delegations which to take the floor? India speaks, supporting the Chinese position, requesting more time. Pakistan says the same (Kashmir notwithstanding). Russia "also would like to express its regret... and hope that in the meantime no negative precedent."

The president says, we are not to wait until the next meeting in January. An African delegate says that the issue has been focused on UNDP, not UNICEF.

Update of 9 p.m. -- the president suspends the session until next Friday. Even the most basic and constrained transparency can't fly at UNDP...

Watch this site, and this (UN) debate.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1audits091208.html

Thursday, September 18, 2008

UNDP's Funding of Saakashvili Causes Russian Uproar, For-Ex Stonewalling Continues

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1russia091108.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 11 -- As the UN Executive Board lurched through the fourth of its five day meeting, with UNDP management having stoked its its ostensible overseers into demanding it re-open the flow of money to Kim Jong Il's North Korea, one of UNDP's equally dubious programs on the other side of the political spectrum fell under fire. It involves UNDP having paid salary to Georgian president Saakashvili, with its own funds and those of George Soros' Open Society Institute. Inner City Press first reported on the program in December 2006, then again on August 25, 2008, click here for that story. This was picked up by Russia's Ambassador to the UN Vitaly Churkin and by Russian media. See examples here, here and here.

The question to be answered is, are the members of UNDP's Executive Board really informed by UNDP management what type of programs are going on?

Meanwhile, despite the Executive Board president's gushing on September 10 that no member disagreed with the head-long rush to return to Pyongyang, even in the face of uncertainty if Kim Jong Il is on his death bed or dead, possibly toppled by even harder-line generals who have restarted that country's nuclear program, in front of the Security Council Inner City Press asked U.S. Ambassador Khalilzad for the U.S. Mission position, video here at Minute 6:43:

Inner City Press: UNDP has been meeting this week. The US position seems to be that the UNDP should go back to North Korea. Do you feel--

Ambassador Khalilzad: We have been under the view that there is a need for steps to make sure that some of the problems that have been listed will not take place again. Thank you.

But when Inner City Press asked UNDP's spokesman early on September 11 for a copy of Regional Directly Ajay Chhibber's so-called "roadmap" to return to North Korea, which even the Executive Board president said should be distributed and made transparent, it was not provided.

Also in front of the Security Council on September 11, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's envoy to Myanmar Ibrahim Gambari to explain the UN system's silence while it was losing 20% of aid funds to the Than Shwe regime. "Matthew, I hope you raise that with [OCHA's] John Holmes and with UNDP." Video here, from Minute 7:19.

Well, Inner City Press has had currency exchange loss questions pending with UNDP for weeks and weeks, and has repeated sent reminded, still with no response. This did not impinge on the self-congratulatory dream world of some Executive Board delegates cooking up rubber stamp resolutions in Conference Room C in the UN's basement on the night of September 11. Nor did it stop once and future UNDP-er Jan Mattsson for patting himself on the back for finally getting an audit of the UN Office for Project Services after seven years, and moving to pay off a blatant cost overrun for Afghan elections in 2005. It all cuminates, he told the Board on September 11, in a new UNOPS web site, in three languages: English, French and Spanish. Maybe that's why Russia didn't know about the funding to Saakashvili...

Meanwhile, UNDP has not provided answers as simple as the volume of fees it collects as a conduit for funding for prisons and military barracks all over the world, and to pay an ex-UN Kosovo Mission staffer to work for Kosovo's government. Not only could this dubious middle-man role raise more Russian questions about UNDP -- more generally, it is for reasons like these that many believe that UNDP is an opaque, unaccountable and even corrupt organization.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1russia091108.html

UN's Ban Avoids Questions of New Cold War, U.S. War on Terror, Excluded Journalists Speak

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1coldwar091108.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 11 -- A new Cold War is how many have described recent dynamics in the UN Security Council. Things came to a boil when American criticized Russian military and political moves with South Ossetia and Abkhazia, breaking away from Georgia. Russia countered by citing the precedent of Kosovo, not only the recognition of its break-away from Serbia earlier this year by the U.S. and most of the European Union, but also NATO's bombing of Belgrade in 1999. Russia vetoed a draft resolution to impose sanctions on Robert Mugabe's Zimbabwe, along the China, put Iran sanctions on the slow boat thereto, and asked the U.S. whether it had found the weapons of mass destruction it had claimed were in Iraq.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was largely invisible during these fights. On September 11 he finally held a press conference, and began by apologizing for what he called his summer absence, promise to henceforth do monthly question and answer sessions. Inner City Press asked about what's called the new Cold War, what Ban thinks and is trying to do about it. Video here, from Minute 14:28.

After reading from notes about humanitarian aid to Georgia, Ban did not answer the question. So Inner City Press repeated it, linking the rift not only to Georgia but also Kosovo and Zimbabwe and asking if Ban is seeking to be an impartial mediator between the U.S. and Russia.

"As Secretary-General, I really try to avoid your question," Ban said. "I do not want to think of that kind of possibility." Video here, form Minute 19:33.

This candidly admitted attempt to avoid questions was repeated in the balance of the press conference. Ban was asked twice to comment on U.S. military incursions into Pakistan in search of insurgents. First he said he was not ready for the question, then that he did not want to answer it.

A journalist from Lebanon asked about Ban's previous envoy to Beirut, Johan Verbecke, who as Inner City Press reported left his assignment due to death threats. Ban called these "unavoidable circumstances," adding that "I do not wish to discuss [them] with you publicly."

Ban was asked, is Kim Jong Il of North Korea dead? "I am not in the position to have any independent source of information to confirm" that, he said. Some of Inner City Press' sources opine that the North Korean military may have moved against Kim Jong Il, finding him too conciliatory to the West, and then moved to restart North Korea's nuclear program.

Surprisingly, Ban did not raise and no one asked about either Iran or Sudan. The latter can be ascribed to Ban himself. He described Darfur and climate change as his two signature issues. Now things are going so badly in Darfur -- even the U.S. contractor to which Ban's UN gave a $250 million no-bid contract, Lockheed Martin, is leaving in failure -- that Ban has dropped the issue. The press corps shouldn't.

Speaking of failure, Inner City Press asked Ban about the trip of his envoy Ibrahim Gambari to Mynamar without having met with democracy leader Aung San Soo Kyi or military strongman Than Shwe. "I do not like to characterize it as failure," Ban said. "Video here, from Minute 14:50.

Ban also took issue with press reports, presumably including this one, that focused on a speech he gave to or at his managers in Turin, Italy. Ban said he was misunderstood, that he is flexible, that if anything he was criticizing senior officials, not lower level staff. He was not asked to example the phrase, "I tried to lead by example. Nobody followed." That line is more and more repeated in the UN and now beyond. How to avert a Cold War, in the UN and more importantly the wider world? While there were on September 11 more responses than before, which must be noted here, no real answered were advanced.

Footnote: After the press conference, there were complaints about perceived bias in the way questions were allocated. James Bone, who among other things famously questioned Kofi Annan about the financing and whereabouts of his son Kojo's Mercedes until being called "an overgrown school boy," told Inner City Press he has not been called on for a question since. Nizar Abboud, representing both a television station and a newspaper in the Middle East, was again not called on. He told Inner City Press, on the record, that he asked Ban's Spokesperson why he hadn't been called on. The Spokesperson in turn asked, "Remember when you walked out of the briefing?" Abboud did remember, it had been in protest of not being called on. "Well it was wrong," the Spokesperson said.

Abboud comments that this shows the arbitrary basis of exclusion, which is also inconsistent because Ban personally is nothing but polite with Abboud and others. Abboud notes that another correspondent more favorable to the U.S. position on Lebanon was called on for three questions. Another long-time correspondent, who asked for anonymity in order to retain access, said that everything Ban does is in favor of the U.S..

But that analysis can wait for another day. To be charitable, Ban was better on September 11 than in previous press conferences. His offer to come at least once a month is welcome. Whether anything will be accomplished is another question, the results of which will be reported on this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1coldwar091108.html

As Myanmar Defends N. Korea, UNDP Covers Up For-Ex Losses, Mute on Revolving Door

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1rk090908.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 9 -- Myanmar came to the defense of North Korea at the Tuesday Executive Board meeting of the UN Development Program. Urging resumed funding by UNDP to the Kim Jong Il government, despite financial and accounting irregularities found even by the reviewers chosen by UNDP, Myanmar decried "political motives" and called for "national ownership" of UNDP programs.

Notably, the Than Shwe government of Myanmar has shown itself adept at owning UNDP's programs and the funds of the wider UN system, requiring currency conversation into Foreign Exchange Certificates leading to losses of 20% of aid money. Just last week, UNDP Associate Administrator Ad Melkert answered Inner City Press' questions about currency exchange losses by saying that this had been a problem in North Korea, and would have to be resolved with the government there before any UNDP program could resume. But at Tuesday's session, before any other member had spoken the Executive Board president said that "the absence of UNDP from Pyonyang can only be temporary." Even if Kim Jong Il insists on choosen UNDP's staff, and taking their paychecks?

The North Korean representative, emboldened, called for a resumption of UNDP programs and offices "as early as possible." Iran spoke of the need to "redress damages" to North Korea, and said that UNDP has over-reacted to the charges of a whistleblower.

Throughout this saga, in reviewing speeches by member states on UNDP's Executive Board, it has become clear than many languages either do not have a word for whistleblower, or only have words with negative connotations like "rat" or "spy."

Apparently, the word "revolving door" does not translate either, at least not in UNDP world. Over the weekend it was announced that UNDP official Gilbert Houngbo was named prime minister of Togo. Inner City Press immediately formally asked UNDP's spokesman

"Regarding Mr. Houngbo, please disclose as soon as possible any and all involvement he has had in UNDP's programs regarding Togo and, separately, please describe any safeguards UNDP has in place to prevent conflicts of interest or 'revolving door' issues when its officials go directly to work for a government with which UNDP has economic relations."

In the two full business days since, no such safeguards have been described. Nor have questions, much longer standing, about currency exchange losses been answered. UNDP management hides behind the somewhat understandable closing of ranks by developing countries. But it is UNDP management which is responsible for not allowing, rather than covering up, losses of 20%, or even 5%, to government-required currency exchange and other chicanery.

Like any demagogue, it is not difficult to whip up supportive speeches. But this approach has led UNDP from one scandal to the next, each one averted only by self-selected investigators and rebuffing outside review such as by the UN Ethics Office. Ultimately the cause of development and poverty reduction is ill-served by this. But one wouldn't have known it on at Tuesday's meeting of UNDP's Executive Board.

Footnotes: while UNDP's Executive Board meeting proceeded in the basement virtually ignored by the rest of the UN press corps, there were cameras and microphones up on the second floor, where the star of the UN's symposium on supporting the victims of terrorism, Ingrid Betancourt, took questions on both Myanmar and North Korea. Inner City Press asked about her statement about Aung San Soo Kyi: is she a victim of state terrorism, and is Ban Ki-moon and the UN doing enough for her? "None of us are doing enough," Ms. Betancourt said, adding that her definition of terrorism includes any arbitrary detention "without reason" such as Aung San Soo Kyi's. Video here.

Asked about North Korea's abductions, including of more than a dozen Japanese citizens, Ms. Betancourt recounted the kidnapping of a school girl, whose name she said she didn't remember. To Inner City Press, it appeared to be the case of Megumi Yokota. Betancourt said "she should be in the Press every day." Oh that it were so.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1rk090908.html

At UN, From Togo Lies to Red Flags, Discrimination and Corruption Alleged on the Record, "GA Should Act"

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1owondo090808.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 8 -- Whistleblowers about the UN are nearly always nameless, given the UN's record of retaliation. Given this record, Inner City Press grants and defends anonymity of whistleblowers. Recently, however, a former UN system staff member in Angola, Ivory Coast and at the International Criminal Court for Rwanda approached Inner City Press with his story, explicitly asking that he be quoted by name. He produced UN evaluations of his previous work, and a list of UN system jobs he has applied for without success.

"They've put a red flag on my file," he said. "I'm a lawyer but they've given me no chance to defend myself. The General Assembly should start a team to investigation discrimination and corruption in the UN, and they should use my story and my contacts. Please go ahead and name me."

His name is Joseph Owondo. He first approached Inner City Press at the Security Council stakeout. He wore an identification card from the Guinea-Bissau mission, for which he is working. He previously worked for the mission of his native Gabon, and before that for the UN, most recently in 2003 to 2005 as head of human rights for the UN Mission in Ivory Coast. He left, voluntarily, and returned to New York. Later he applied for a UN human rights post in Togo, another French speaking country. But after he applied, a colleague called him and said, "There's already someone for that post."

"How can that be?" he asked. "They've just advertised the post, and they say they're going to interview me."

"That's just for show," his friend told him. "You'll see."

When the interview occurred, it was conducted according to Mr. Owondo by a three-person panel. None of the three spoke French. "But the official language of Togo is French," Owondo protested.

"Togo officials all speak English," the head of the panel insisted.

Owondo disagreed, and made his answers in French. He did not get the job, the person it has been pre-promised to got it.

"This is what happens in the UN and everyone knows it but doesn't say," Owondo told Inner City Press this week. "People are afraid, they'll lose their jobs or have red flags put on their files and never get a job. This is what's happened to me."

Owondo paints a bleak picture of the current UN, saying that disappointment is widespread, even leading, he said, to suicide. "That lady who died out on the lawn?" he asked, pointing down at the grass between the UN and the East River. "Why does a person come in to their work if they want to kill themselves? Then a man died for lack of medical attention. We've hit a new low. The UN belongs to everyone. Member states have to beat their hands on the table and change things."

On August 4, Inner City Press exclusively reported on a seven-page letter to Ban Ki-moon which alleged systemic corruption and discrimination in the UN, primarily in the Department of Peacekeeping Operations. Click here for Inner City Press' story, which called the author, who wrote under the pen name Alice Gervais, a whistleblower, and wondered what investigation or retaliation might follow.

After publication, and without Inner City Press even having asked, a member of Ban Ki-moon's Office of the Spokesperson told Inner City Press that no request for protection for retaliation had been filed with UN Ethics Officer Robert Benson, and that Ban Ki-moon would have no response, since it was an "anonymous" letter. Since then, numerous staff members have complained to Inner City Press about this non-response, asking why the factual allegations in the letter, against high UN officials, are not being inquired into, for example by the Office of Internal Oversight Services. Inner City Press sent OIOS chief Inga-Britt Ahlenius questions weeks ago, only to receive an auto-response that Ms. Ahlenius is on a six-week vacation extending through September 15.

On September 3, Inner City Press re-sent the seven-page letter to the spokesman for DPKO, Nick Birnback, and two other UN officials, asking for comment and response on the factual allegations in the letter. To date no such response have been received. Mr. Owondo has told Inner City Press that he has been "accused" of being the author of the letter.

"I did not write it," Owondo emphasized. "Many of the things in the letter, I know nothing about. But there is truth in that letter, that must be investigated. The General Assembly, which starts later this month, has to look into this. The UN itself won't do it, they just try to silence staff members who speak out. Take my evaluations, please put them online. I have nothing to be afraid of. They know where to reach me."

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1owondo090808.html

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

At UN, Indigestion at Request for Court Ruling on Kosovo Independence

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/icj1serbia090508.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 5 -- On Serbia's UN resolution to seek a ruling by the International Court of Justice on the legality of Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence, the European Union is in a conflicted position. On September 4, Inner City Press asked Jean-Maurice Ripert, the Permanent Representative to the UN of France, which currently holds the EU Presidency, what the EU will go in the upcoming General Assembly meetings. Ambassador Ripert said it is still being considered, but "we do not contest" Serbia's right to "address the General Assembly and we will even facilitate it." But question is what position the EU will take on voting on the resolution, not Serbia's right to present the resolution.

An EU diplomat who insisted on being identified as such because not authorized to be quoted in his own name told Inner City Press that EU consultations are still ongoing. Some, he said, are urging EU support for the resolution as a way to support Serbia's pro-EU government by helping them "park" this burning domestic issue in the Hague. The downside, he said, is that the pendency of such a case would slow down if not halt other countries' recognition of Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence.

Costa Rica's Ambassador Jorge Urbina said that his country, even though it has already recognized Kosovo's declaration of independence, will be voting in favor of getting ICJ review. Ambassador Urbina rhetorically asked Inner City Press, how can we oppose a member state which has lost a province getting a court ruling?

Inner City Press asked U.S. Deputy Permanent Representative Alejandro Wolff how the U.S. will vote on the resolution. We haven't reached a decision on that yet, Ambassador Wolff replied.

Inner City Press asked Serbia's Ambassador Pavle Jevremovic if he thinks his country's resolution will pass. He nodded, and said, "We're trying to keep things uncontroversial." Some cynics even speculate that Serbia's current government might want to lose the case, or at least wouldn't mind losing it, because then the Serbian public could be told, "We tried everything possible, now let's get on with the business of business." Among the evidence presented for this theory is Serbia's foreign minister's statement that if the ICJ rules against his position, Serbia will have to respect it. Meanwhile, even if Serbia won, the ruling would only be advisory. The theory goes, why would anyone start a court case they could lose, but couldn't meaningfully win, unless they want to lose?

Another diplomat not authorized to be quoted by name said it will be difficult for his African country not to support the resolution, and he wonders how the United States could justify not supporting it. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/icj1serbia090508.html

UN's Borg-Olivier, Warned for Pro-Kosovo Quotes, Is Paid Through UNDP to Advise Kosovo

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2borg090308.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 3 -- In Kosovo, the just-retired chief legal officer of the UN Mission, Alexander Borg-Olivier, is now being paid through the UN Development Program to be an advisor to the Kosovo government. This despite the UN's admission Wednesday to Inner City Press that Borg-Olivier was previously warned by UNMIK for publicly bragging about his position in favor of Kosovo independence. His new position not only directly calls into question the impartiality or so-called status neutrality of the UN in Kosovo, it also appears to violate applicable UN post-employment rules.

"Mr. Borg-Olivier earlier this year gave an interview to the Times of Malta which was considered to be inappropriate by UNMIK and the previous SRSG who brought the interview to his attention and gave him an oral warning," a written response provided Wednesday to Inner City Press by the Office of the Spokesperson for the Secretary-General acknowledged. It went on to say that "on 30 June Mr. Borg-Olivier retired from the UN and it is our understanding that he is currently assisting the Kosovo government on legal matters. He is no longer employed by the UN so there is no conflict of interest."

But the UN Secretary General's Bulletin on "post employment restrictions" provides

2.2 For a period of two years following separation from service, former staff members who have participated in the procurement process for the Organization before separation from service are prohibited from knowingly communicating with, or appearing before, any staff member or unit of the Organization on behalf of any third party on any particular matters that were under their official responsibility relating to the procurement process during the last three years of their service with the Organization.

As UNMIK's chief legal official, Borg Olivier participated in the procurement process. Under his watch, funds from the privatization of state-owned enterprises were transferred to the Kosovo government. Now, the UN tells Inner City Press, "UNMIK is doing its outmost to secure the Kosovo Trust Agency funds until all outstanding issues including claims can be dealt with."

It seems clear that Borg Olivier was preparing to go work for and with the Kosovo government while still in the employ of UNMIK. This would violate Rule 2.3, which provides

2.3 While in service, staff members participating in the procurement process shall refrain from soliciting or accepting, directly or indirectly, any promise or offer of future employment from any contractor or vendor of goods or services, regardless of location, which conducts business with the Organization or seeks to do so and with whom such staff members have been personally involved in the procurement process during the previous three years of service with the Organization. Should a staff member participating in the procurement process receive a promise or offer, the staff member shall immediately report the incident to the head of office and to the Under-Secretary-General for Internal Oversight Services and recuse himself or herself from any further dealing with such contractor or vendor until instructed to do so by the head of office.

Later on Wednesday, the plot further thickened, when UNDP Spokesman Stephane Dujarric chimed in that

"Mr. Borg-Olivier has been contracted as a short-term consultant on an European Commission funded project called 'Capacity Building for European Integration.' UNDP administers this EC project , called 'Capacity Building for European Integration' project, which aims to provide capacity building services to the government of Kosovo. The project is designed to be 'demand driven,' to provide services as requested by the government. It was the government who requested Borg-Olivier's services. The request was then approved by the EC as the EC approves or vetoes all funding decisions. The decision to hire Mr. Borg-Oliver was taken by the EC. UNDP's role was [to] process the paper work according to the decisions of the host government and the donor, the EC."

Inner City Press has asked UNDP how much it got or gets paid to "process the paper work" for the EC to pay Kosovo's chosen consultant. Why, one wonders, is UNDP always in the middleman role? But more fundamentally, do Serbia and, for example, Russia know that the UN, which claims to be status neutral, is paying consultants to the Kosovo government? And unrelatedly, since UN system retirees are limited to making or taking above $22,000 annual from the UN, how much is Borg-Olivier getting paid? We will continue to pursue this, since the UN at least initially did not.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2borg090308.html

As UN's Ban Says Nobody Follows Him, He's Presiding Over Chaos on Ethics and Disclosure

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban1turin090208.html

UNITED NATIONS, September 2 -- Ban Ki-moon, one third of the way through his five year term as Secretary General, is lamenting that nobody is following his leadership. In a speech to senior UN official in Turin on August 29, Ban lamented, "I tried to lead by example. Nobody followed." And so he tried to make clear he is in charge: "When we work for the UN -- when you work for me -- please leave your ego at the door."

But listeners have highlighted to Inner City Press a contradiction in Ban's speech. Ban said, "in choosing my senior advisers, I have always cared less about a person's intellectual attainments than his or her ability to work well with others." Meanwhile he complains that UN officials are not obeying, or working with, him and his senior advisers. How can an advisor be said to "work well with others" if the others don't agree? Is a person a leader if "nobody follows"?

While speaking in favor of "One UN" and against turf wars, Ban allowed UN Development Program Administrator Kemal Dervis to rebuff the UN Ethics Office, which had preliminarily found retaliation by UNDP. Dervis instead was allowed to create his own, friendly ethics office. Can one lament turf wars when one allows this fragmentation and duplication of resources?

Another example is Ban's lack of follow-up on his suggestion that senior officials make at least basic public financial disclosure. Several officials simply checked a box, "I choose not to disclose." And when the UN's top lawyer Nicolas Michel purported to disclose, but did not list the $10,000 a month he was taking from the Swiss government for his housing, nothing was done. So much for zero tolerance.

Most recently, the head lawyer of the UN Mission in Kosovo admitted lobbying for recognition of Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence while working for the UN. Again, nothing has been done. So much for impartiality.

When documents were leaked showing that a senior UN official, Jane Holl Lute, had pushed to steer a no-bid $250 million contract to US-based military contractor Lockheed Martin for peacekeeping camps in Darfur, against the advice of the Controller and of the Headquarters Committee on Contract, nothing was done, except that Ban expressed exasperation at being asked questions about the contract. Attempts to find the source of the leaks were made. While the previous head of UN Management had promised a UN Freedom of Information Act, no steps in this directly have been made.

Ban also focused on so-called mobility, decrying that 790 of 900 surveyed UN staff had been in their position for five years or more. But Ban has yet to do anything about the inability of so-called G or General staff to move in to the professional ranks. And officials expected to leave have been kept on in other positions, for example the Lockheed contract pusher in a Peacebuilding role. Or the disgraced Millennium Campaign director Eveline Herfkens, who took $280,000 from the Dutch government while ostensibly serving only the UN, now recycled at a $1 a year "advisor" -- in line for up to $100,000 in "Daily Subsistence Allowance." Click here for Inner City Press' story on this.

In terms of openness to the press, Ban is lagging behind his predecessor Kofi Annan. Annan held a number of sit-down press conferences, taking 20 or more questions including on such topics as housing subsidies. Ban on the contrary has recently done a brief series of by invitation only press lunches, insisting these be "off the record." Ban rarely does press conferences, and his Spokesperson carefully chooses who is allowed to ask questions. As reported, those holding the microphone boom at the Security Council stakeout have been told not to allow particular investigative journalists to ask questions. This is leadership? Perhaps those Ban has selected believe in teamwork in such a way they believe their job is to insulate Ban from the press, and try to silence those who question.

When Ban's Office of the Spokesperson was asked for clarifications of Ban's August 29 speech, they said since it hadn't been publicly released, all questions should be to the director of the Office of Communications. Is this office working well with others?

For ten days now, the UN has been under fire for its Myanmar envoy's pro-junta trip to Yangon, for failing to meet with Aung San Suu Kyi or even General Than Shwe. Day after day of unanwered questions. Ban said it is not about process but results. In this case, where are the results? What was done about the UN's loss of 20% of aid funds to government-required games with Foreign Exchange Certificates? Click here for that. There is much work to be done.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban1turin090208.html

UN Whistleblower in Tokyo Raises Questions of Fraud, Cover-Up and Retaliation from Below

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undpi1koda082708.html

UNITED NATIONS, August 26 -- Objections against UN management raised by a high-profile Japanese journalist who headed the UN Information Center in Tokyo until earlier this year reveal a culture of retaliation and denial, alongside questions about the purpose and performance of these Information Centers and the UN's relations with major donor nations like Japan.

Charmine Koda was named the directly of UNIC-Tokyo in April 2006. Later that year, she discovered systemic financial irregularities at the Center, including the use of falsified invoices to pay for services not yet rendered. She blew the whistle on these irregularities, first to the Department of Public Information which oversees the Information Centers, then when nothing was done, to the Office of Internal Oversight Services. In the resulting audit, Ms. Koda's own management style came under review, and she was given a series of short-term contract renewals and stripped of various of her powers at the Center.

Ms. Koda filed a harassment complaint against DPI's then number-two official in March 2008, heretofore not reported in the English language press. When Ms. Koda moved to schedule a press conference in Tokyo, DPI's top official Kiyotaka Akasaka in turn summoned some of the UN press corps to his office for a counter-briefing. Only representatives of the Japanese press were invited, an incongruity Inner City Press noted soon thereafter. (Click here for that May 21, 2008 article.)

After questions from Inner City Press, last week finally some answers were provided. Two individuals who requested to be identified only as "UN officials knowledgeable about the case" spoke with Inner City Press for an hour. They emphasized their argument that Ms. Koda cannot be considered a whistleblower, since "it was her job to report what she saw." They stressed that complaints were filed about Ms. Koda by six of the seven staffers of UNIC-Tokyo "and even the interns." They said that the money the UN had spent arranging for management training for Ms. Koda could have been spent on substantive programs in other UNICs.

They could not directly explain, however, why if in their view Ms. Koda was such a bad manager, she had been given the management job in the first place. They said that the selection of UNIC directors is vetted by the host governments, particularly in cases like the Tokyo Center where the host government provides most of the funding for the Center's work. So does a government's view come into play even earlier in the selection process? The two UN official acknowledged that it does.

How this plays out in the UN Information Centers in Sudan, Zimbabwe and Myanmar will be the subject for future Inner City Press articles. As related to Ms. Koda, the two officials repeated sought to portray the UN as the victim, and Ms. Koda as "not a whistleblower." Inner City Press disagrees, for the reasons summarized below.

When Ms. Koda finally left the UNIC in June 2008, she wrote a lengthy expose of her time at the UN. This appeared in the Japanese magazine Bungeishunju and has yet to appear in English. Inner City Press has reviewed a 23-page translation of the article. DPI's attempts to limit it responses to the Japanese-language press, and to claim that Ms. Koda is not and cannot be a whistleblower, are now more understandable, as Ms. Koda's critique is comprehensive -- and she names names.

To set the stage, Ms. Koda describes UNIC-Tokyo as

"a small office made up of the Director and 7 staff members, and the Directors have been senior level staff hired by the UN Headquarters and were changed approximately every 2 or 3 years ever since it was founded. In the beginning, foreign nationals were appointed, but in recent years, the position was assumed by Japanese. The first was Mr. Hatsuhisa Takashima (2000 ~ 2002, from NHK), next was Mr. Akio Nomura (2003 ~ 2005, from Asahi Shimbun), and the third Japanese Director was myself."

To this we can add that the Government of Japan's role in the selection of directors, and the use of Japanese taxpayers' funds for the work of the Center, making even more significant the reports of financial irregularities. As stated by Ms. Koda

"The contents of these financial irregularities were later summarized briefly in the report (dated March 11, 2008) of the UN Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS) audit. In December 2005, during the time of the former Director, the Center had 3 companies produce fictitious invoices and remitted a total of 3,130,000 yen... According to the explanation of the staff, they were 'pre-payments' that were intended to be consumed in the following fiscal year (the end of the fiscal budget year is December), and it is said that this practice had been prevalent since 2000. The audit report states that this is against UN financial rules and is requesting that 'appropriate measures' be taken against the concerned staff. The signatures of the former Director and the administrative assistant remain clearly on the fictitious vouchers. And fictitious reporting was being done to the UN Headquarters... I immediately reported all to Director [Paula] Refolo at the Department of Public Information."

But the UN's focus soon turned on Ms. Koda herself. As another UN system whistleblower has phrased it to Inner City Press, "the UN always shoots the messenger." The twist in this case is that, at least on its face, the retaliation was from below. Long-time UNIC staff members who were there are the time of the financial irregularities sent complaints to the UN in New York. Specifically, according to Ms. Koda, six staff members

"sent a letter to Director Refolo accusing me of 'power harassment' and 'misbehavior as International Civil Servant.' (One staff member opposed this kind of action and did not sign the letter.) Letters in support of the accusations addressed to Under-Secretary-General [Shashi] Tharoor by the two former Directors, Mr. Takashima and Mr. Nomura, and a letter by 2 interns addressed to the Secretary-General were also attached... the Department of Public Information took them up at face value, incorporated their arguments one-sidedly, wrote a report pursuing my responsibility, and took the measure to not allow me to refute."

An official the Japanese Foreign Ministry consulted by Inner City Press for this story stated that "we are keen" on getting to the bottom of the financial improprieties at UNIC-Tokyo "since the money is that of the Japanese taxpayers," and that Ms. Koda as well as the UNIC-Tokyo staff should be treated fairly during these reviews. A senior Japanese official expressed support for Ms. Koda. But not enough, apparently, to protect her from retaliation, at least for now. Following this report, Ms. Koda says,

"Refolo sent me an email telling me, 'It has been decided that staff A will do the staff members' PAS evaluation this year.' She was going to rob me of what was close to the only authority I had as the Director and hand it over to A. This will be equivalent to DPI’s recognition of staff A as the virtual Director. When I wrote back to that effect, Ms Refolo responded, 'It is a one- time measure which is necessary... and is being taken mainly as a way to protect you, given that even your most objective evaluation could be perceived by staff as retaliation.'"

The irony appears lost on DPI -- they retaliated by stripping Ms. Koda, who had complained of financial impropriety, of her responsibilities, ostensibly so that she would not be charged with retaliation. Ms. Koda continues that in early 2008

"in Bangkok, a meeting among Directors of UNICs in Asian countries was held and USG Akasaka, Director Refolo and I were there on site. That morning, when I met USG Akasaka at the hotel restaurant and offered him to join me, he asked, 'Have you seen the OIOS draft report?' When I answered, 'Not yet,' he told me to get a copy from Director Refolo. That evening, as she was leaving to go out for dinner, I somehow managed to stop her and receive a copy. I felt my blood freeze. It wrote the problem of staff management as top priority, and by quoting the contents of the staff’s allegations and the Panel report, it recommended my reassignment. Procurement issues such as financial irregularities were placed in the back inconspicuously."

Inner City Press has asked OIOS' Inga Britt Ahlenius about among other things OIOS' role in the matter, including the allegation by some of the use of OIOS as a part of retaliation, but Ms. Ahlenius has not responded. Hours later a message arrived, that Ms. Ahlenius is on "annual leave" extending from July 28 through September 15. But the questions asked cannot wait that long. Ms. Koda, for the record, says she keeps an open mind. She concludes

"Inside the United Nations, the reputation of the Department of Public Information of its heavy-handed attitude is being talked about. Also from subordinate organizations of other area discontent towards the ways of Director Refolo is being heard. However, as long as the issue is discussed and dealt with only inside the closed environment of the organization called the UN, a fundamental solution to this kind of problem can hardly be expected. I have decided to resign from my post and expose the problem to public review. I would like to express my gratitude to all the people for their trust and support in my work at the UN, and at the same time, I wish to apologize from my heart for not being able to fulfill it. I am still a believer in the principles and the meaningfulness of the activities of the United Nations. To contribute my humble part to the reform of that United Nations, I am determined to fight all the way."

In light of the repeated argument of the two "UN officials" provided by DPI that Ms. Koda cannot be considered a whistleblower since it was her duty to report improprieties, Inner City Press asked the Washington-based Government Accountability Project (GAP) for comment. In response, Tom Devine, GAP's legal director, said that "there's not even a syllable in the UN policy that provides an opening for that loophole. It's entirely a bureaucratic creation to avoid the approved U.N. rules on whistleblower rights."

Inner City Press wants to cover more of the UN DPI's side. The initial block was DPI's decision to limit its story-telling to the Japanese media. Now, an outgoing difficulty is the unwillingness of DPI to tell any part of its story on the record and for attribution. As Ms. Koda asks, how then are they the Department of PUBLIC Information?" Perhaps DPI is in a dificult position. But how would one know?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undpi1koda082708.html

UN's Engagement with Saakashvili Included $1500 a Month, Soros and Sweden Also Paid

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/undp1georgia082508.html

UNITED NATIONS, August 25 -- Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili was paid $1500 a month by the UN Development Program earlier this decade, on top of his official presidential salary, UNDP has told Inner City Press. UNDP says the goals of these payments, in which the Swedish government and financier George Soros joined, were to allow the Georgian "government to recruit the staff it needed and also to help remove incentives for corruption."

While receiving these $1500 monthly payment, Saakashvili committed to increase tax collection in Georgia. Deals were signed with , among others, British Petroleum, for the Baku - Tbilisi - Ceyhan oil pipeline. UNDP, and presumably its two co-funders, applauded this development.

Last week at the UN, Russia accused the UN's Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs of being biased in its mapping of refugee flows created by the Georgia - South Ossetia - Russia conflict. Russia also accused UN political chief Lynn Pascoe, an American, of being biased in his briefing of the Security Council. The US Committee for UNDP lists and offered praise for this paying of Saakashvili's salary.

Inner City Press first reported on UNDP's Governance Reform Program in Georgia in late 2006. Earlier this month, as the Georgian conflict heated up, Inner City Press asked UNDP how much was spent under the program? Where did the funds come from? Who got paid? Has the program continued?

Six days later, UNDP responded to Inner City Press that

On Georgia, the Governance Reform Program initiative you asked about, was two-pronged. To enable the government to recruit the staff it needed and also to help remove incentives for corruption, UNDP created a Salary Supplement Fund, funded initially by $1 million from OSI and $500,000 from UNDP, and later supplemented by another $1 million from the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA). This fund was designed to provide leading public servants with a wage that, though modest by international standards, was sufficient for Georgia. The fund targeted the country's highest officials: the President, Prime Minister, and Speaker of the Parliament each received $1,500 per month, ministers, $1,200, deputy ministers, $700.

In order to make the programme as efficient as possible, a clear "exit strategy" was built into the program, so that the government committed to assuming responsibility for the salary supplements over three years. The government was required to make a credible commitment to increase tax revenues in order to cover this rise in expenditure. Transparency was viewed as essential, and the government agreed to post all details of the salary supplements on an open website (http://www.drf.org.ge/). Finally, and most importantly, the government agreed that the salary supplements would be one piece of a larger effort to streamline the existing bureaucracy and create in its place a well-paid and well-organized civil service.

The second prong of the initiative was a Capacity Building Fund. This was designed to provide the government with short-term specialist expertise in areas of urgent concern and longer-term support in capacity building at a variety of ministries and other state institutions.

The government has been so successful in improving tax collection that the salary supplement program for top officials was fully taken over by the state budget after just a single year (rather than the planned three). Thanks to a drive to curb evasion and improve administration, tax revenue increased by 50%, or 4 percentage points of GDP, just in 2004. Unused UNDP and OSI funds earmarked for salary supplements were at this point transferred to the Capacity Building Fund for use in civil service reform.

Notably, the web site that UNDP says it insisted on was slow to load on Monday. So much for transparency... Why would Soros' Open Society Institute use UNDP to channel money to "top-off" Saakashvili's and a few others' salaries? In how many other countries does UNDP perform this function? This last, we'll be reporting further on. But first, UNDP should answer some questions.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/undp1georgia082508.html

UN's Algiers Bombing Accountability Report Is Late, Amid Music for Baghdad

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1bombs081908.html

UNITED NATIONS, August 19 -- As the UN commemorated the deadly bombing of its headquarters in the Canal Hotel in Baghdad five years ago, the supposed deadline had passed for its report imposing personal accountability for the deaths from the blast of its premises in Algiers last December. On June 24, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said he "accepted Mr. Brahimi's suggestion that a group headed by Ralph Zacklin urgently examine this question of individual accountability and report its results to him within a period of six weeks."

But nearly seven weeks later, with no report submitted or released, Inner City Press on August 19 asked Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq

Inner City Press: on the follow-up on the Algiers bombing of the UN premises, the second report, the so-called accountability report, the Brahimi report, what was the deadline for it to be done and where does it stand?

Associate Spokesperson Haq: As you know, there was a two-month deadline from the start of that body's work; Ralph Zacklin, as you know, is the head of that body and he and that group are proceeding with the work and as far as I am aware, the report is not finished yet. It’s still in the process of being finalized.

Again, Ban Ki-moon did not announce a two-month deadline, but rather six weeks, which has expired. Inner City Press has fielded complaints that the Zacklin panel's interviews were disproportionately directed at relatively lower level staff, who were not allowed to be accompanied by the UN Staff Union much less by lawyers. Personal accountability, indeed.

When the report is belatedly released, watch to see if it takes into account how concern about the investment climate in Algeria kept the threat level artificially low. Even the redacted Brahimi report issued by the UN raises questions of accountability. It states for example "the Designated Official was neither forceful nor persistent with the Algerian authorities to insist on the security measures requested of the Government." (Page 25). This Designated Officer was, in fact, an official of the UN Development Program, Marc de Bernis. As is so often the case with UNDP, de Bernis not only didn't press the host country government in any way -- he allowed himself and the UN system safety issues to be marginalized. The UN-released Brahimi report stated

"As noted in the preliminary DSS report on the 11 December 2007 attack, all contact by the UN Designated Official for Security (DO) and the Security Adviser (SA) with the national security authorities occurred through the Director General for Protocol (DGP) at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA). This restricted contact with security agencies was not limited to the UN; diplomatic missions in Algiers also conduct their security relations through the DGP/MFA. This is the practice in a number of other countries."

Having access to the preliminary DSS report, we find in paragraph 7 that there was an exception, for "large embassies." Why didn't the UN, with multiple agencies represented in Algeria, get for itself as much access as large embassies of its member states?

At Tuesday's memorial event, the President of the UN Staff Union stressed "the obligation of those who call upon UN staff to serve in difficult and dangerous parts of the world to take whatever action is necessary to ensure staff safety and security, including public relations efforts to cultivate the understanding that the UN is a neutral, benevolent organization." Then a four-movement composition by Steve Heitzog was unveiled. As played by the Daedalus Quartet, the music was moving. Mr. Heitzog's written "Notes" describes "an explosively ugly chord" then a "delicate theme pitched in C major that is transparent and healing." One can only hope.

Several attendees at Tuesday's service mentioned Samantha Power's book "Chasing the Flame." Inner City Press' copy is double dog-earred at page 465, where it is reported that "CNN did have a crew on the scene who at the time of the blast had been filming a press conference on the UN's de-mining efforts." Multiple sources have told Inner City Press that Ms. Power has fielded complaints that it was in fact a different network which was the only TV crew in the building at the time. Watch for the errata. And click here for Inner City Press' story on Ms. Power's related endeavor funded by Ebay's founders, "Chasing the Flame with Cheese Cubes," a/k/a fondue.

There is also word in the building of a potential settlement payment to families of victims of the Algiers bombing. We will continue to dig into this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1bombs081908.html

Sunday, August 31, 2008

On Currency Exchange Losses, UN Starts Cover-Up in Myanmar and Beyond

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1newno081408.html

UNITED NATIONS, August 14 -- Despite an internal UN memo admitted a "serious 20% loss" of aid money in currency exchanges required by Myanmar's government which led to an admission of $10 million in losses, on Thursday the UN cut its losses to $1.5 million, then refused to explain. The UN Development Program has for weeks refused to disclose how much money it has converted in Myanmar, nor in which other of the 160 countries it does business in its loses money in government-required conversions. The Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, whose director John Holmes initially took the lead in admitting the losses, has similarly declined to provide information about any other countries, despite Holmes' July 28 commitment to do so. As is too frequent in the UN, exposure of a problem has been followed not by reform but by cover-up and stonewalling.

In fact, despite a clear written and video record, the UN now claims that the problem wasn't exposed at all, but rather was "first raised" by John Holmes on July 24. But Inner City Press asked Holmes about the losses on July 9, 10 and 11, just as it had asked UNDP about the losses as far back as June 26. In minutes of a conference call that day, which whistleblowers showed to Inner City Press, a "serious loss of 20%" was admitted to. Inner City Press subsequently quoted from and then published the minutes.

On August 14, after reading out a statement that losses were "only" 4.5%, UN Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq refused to answer Inner City Press' question about how the 20% loss admitted in the internal memorandum had been changed, without explanation, in this new public figure. "Internal conference calls are internal discussions," Haq said. When Inner City Press asked that someone come to a press conference to answer questions about the new numbers, Haq said he's check "if Holmes is interested in talking," but that Holmes is not available now. Video here, from Minute 12:11.

Inner City Press sent written questions to Holmes' office and to Haq, stating that on the record answers were being sought on deadline:

"of how the 20% loss referred to both in the Teleconference minutes and elsewhere was changed to a 4.5% loss, and by whom. I am told, by a participant in the estimate-reduction exercise, that UNDP took the lead; I would like a confirmation or denial of that. I have asked UNDP the following, and hereby ask OCHA (and spending under OCHA's control), on deadline

how much money has OCHA / the UN converted through Foreign Exchange Certificates in Myanmar in the past one, five and ten years? At what rates? With what losses? If any, how were these disclosed? And, please any and all other countries in which OCHA / the UN has faced currency exchange losses of over 5%, and what you have done and, separately, will do about it? And when will Mr Holmes (and separately Mr. Baker, in light of his July 10 statements) hold press conference(s) at UN HQ on these topics?" I trust you remember that Mr. Holmes said he saw no reason not to make public a list of countries in which OCHA / the UN suffers currency exchange losses. So, please do.

Eight hours later, no answer of any kind had been received. UNDP, as noted, has had the questions before it since June 26, multiply reiterates since then. On August 14, rather than providing the numbers about how much money UNDP has converted in Myanmar, UNDP's Spokesman Stephane Dujarric wrote:

On Myanmar, you received extensive answers on the currency exchange question at the noon briefing. With regards to our programme in Myanmar, UNDP does not have a regular country programme in Myanmar. Since 1993, all assistance from UNDP to Myanmar has been governed by a restrictive mandate from UNDP's Executive Board, which stipulates that assistance must be focused at the grass-roots level, particularly in the areas of primary health care, environment, HIV/AIDS, training and education and food security.

Extensive controls are in place to ensure compliance with the UNDP Executive Board mandate in Myanmar and the Executive Board receives regular reports. Independent assessments have all found that the programme is in full compliance with the Executive Board mandate: i.e., that it is effective in addressing the needs of the poor and vulnerable in rural areas of Myanmar, and that all projects operate independently of the government. The full 2005-2006 assessment, including the budget, is available online on the Executive Board website www.undp.org/execbrd/adv2006-second.htm .

But the questions, asked of Mr. Dujarric and in his absence of UNDP's Christina Lonigro and, in great detail, Stanislav Saling, included how much money was been in UNDP's account at the Myanmar Foreign Exchange Bank, how much was converted and at what loss. Also, Dujarric entirely ignores the wider question posed to him and to UNDP Administrator Kemal Dervis, to disclose "any and all other countries in which UNDP has faced currency exchange losses of over 5%, and what you have done and, separately, will do about it?"

This is a question that, as to OCHA, John Holmes said on July 28 there was no reason he would not answer. But despite repeated reminders, the question has not been answered by him and OCHA, nor UNDP, nor the Department of Peacekeeping Operations, to which Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson passed the buck (DPKO in turn has said it has asked the UN Controllers Office, just as it passes from the UK's Warran Sach to a new Controller from Japan). DPKO has promised an answer, and we'll wait for it and publish it on this site.

Inner City Press has been contacted by other whistleblowers concerned with the UN system's currency losses. But is the only way to get any change to shame UN officials and point out their mis-statements? We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1newno081408.html

UN's Darfur Mission Mis-Served by Lockheed and Donors, Agwai Says JEM's the Player

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2unamid081208.html

UNITED NATIONS, August 12 -- The UN and African Union peacekeeping mission in Darfur was badly mis-planned from the beginning, comments by UNAMID force commander Martin Luther Agwai on Tuesday made clear. Inner City Press asked about the $250 million the UN gave on a no-bid basis to Lockheed Martin to build camps, work only 20% completed by the contract's expiration on July 15. Agwai first attempted to defend Lockheed's PAE subsidiary, saying they were only in charge of four "super camps" in Darfur. But he then said that the Nyala super camp has only moved forward once Chinese engineers arrived. Video here, from Minute 29:11.

Pressed on the issue, he noted both that Lockheed was trying to maximize profits and that, as an American company, Sudan's government was obviously not well-disposed toward granting Lockheed visas or fast access to equipment. Of course, this could and should have been foreseen. Instead, then logistics chief Jane Holl Lute, wife of U.S. President Bush's war czar for Iraq and Afghanistan, insisted that Lockheed must get the no-bid contract, that only Lockheed could do the job. In fact, Lockheed was uniquely unqualified for the job. The Lockheed question now is how much of the money they should have to return.

Inner City Press asked Agwai why UNAMID does not protect the World Food Program trucks bringing supplies into Darfur, as WFP staff in June in El Fasher told Inner City Press is needed. Agwai pointed out that UNAMID still has less than 10,000 of its approved 26,000 strength, and has not been given the legal mandate to protect trucks on their way to Darfur. Again, bad planning.

Agwai went further, saying the before the UN took over peacekeeping in Darfur from the African Union force AMIS on January 1, 2008, the AMIS force had its equipments and maintenance from donors. Agwai said that now the donors no longer pay for spares and repairs, and have taken away a maintenance workshop. Why the donors took his all away is not know.

Inner City Press asked Agwai why UNAMID had not noticed the build-up of Justice and Equality Movement rebel forces preparing their May 10 assault on Khartoum, which ended five kilometers outside in Omdurman. Agwai bemoaned the lack of even a single surveillance plane, then opined both that JEM is the only organized Darfur rebel groups, and that they must have infiltrated toward Khartoum in small "packets" of vehicles. He noted that the government must have known something was coming, because it started bombing in the area just before the attack. Agwai said UNAMID was so bound up in verifying the bombings, if they happened or not, that they missed the real target. Video here, from Minute 1:02:34.

Appearing alongside Agwai was his fellow Nigerian Lt.-General Obiakor, the new UN Military Advisor. Inner City Press asked Obiakor about the proposed UN logistics and computer base in Valencia, Spain, which sources say Nigeria wanted. I will have to look into that, Obiakor said, promising to get back with an answer.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2unamid081208.html