Friday, October 30, 2026

Fed Tells First Bancorp Public Version of Its Filing Was Missing Every Other Page amid FFW FOIA and Protest



Fed Tells First Bancorp Public Version of Its Filing Was Missing Every Other Page amid FFW FOIA and Protest

by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 28 - A Federal Reserve staffer has told First Bancorp, the Southern Pines, North Carolina parent of First Bank, that the public version of its second answer to the Fed’s request for more information was missing “every other page.”

In an Oct. 27 email, copied to Fair Finance Watch, the Fed  wrote that “all the public exhibits appear to be missing every other page (i.e., page A-1, A-3, A-5, A-7 are missing).” 

The email went to First Bank’s Elizabeth Bostian and the bank’s outside counsel. Edwards asked for the public version to be resubmitted “with the full version of Exhibit A.” He also told the bank to resubmit, through the Fed’s EZ File system, a revised public application with all the exhibits “now newly designated as public,” and a revised confidential section with those exhibits removed. Any exhibit released only in part must keep a complete, unredacted copy in the confidential section.

 The instruction comes after First Bank’s Oct. 21 answer to the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond’s Oct. 9 request. In that answer, First Bank said it would refile six exhibits it had first marked confidential: A, F, G, M, N and the rest of O. Fair Finance Watch, which has protested the application, had asked the Fed for the public portions of the application. 

On Oct. 21, the same day as the bank’s answer, FFW filed a FOIA request with the Board of Governors, assigned number FOIA-2027-00050. It seeks everything filed with the Oct. 21 response, including the confidential attachments, the strategic plan (Exhibit E) and the withheld part of the buyer disclosure memorandum (Exhibit O). It also asks for the non-confidential versions of the exhibits the bank is refiling, the Sept. 18 and Oct. 9 requests, the applicants’ confidentiality requests and any determinations on them.  FFW argued that “a confidential label is not an exemption,” that First Bank’s own decision to refile six exhibits “shows over-designation,” and that the Board must decide for itself what Exemption 4 covers. It asked for the withheld material before the Fed acts, because public comment depends on it. FFW pointed to the planned closing of the North Myrtle Beach branch and the Cheraw consolidation on March 12, 2027, as the kind of community-needs matters that comment is meant to address.

 It cited the Board’s record on timing: in Lee v. Board of Governors, 26 Civ. 4556 (S.D.N.Y.), the Board withheld the Enova letter in full in February and released more only in September, after a court order and Enova’s withdrawal - Inner City Press filed in SDNY again on Oct 27 -  and in Isabella (FOIA-2026-00787), the Board approved the application on Oct. 5 before releasing the withheld material. 

First Bancorp announced in July that it would buy First Carolina Bancshares of Florence, South Carolina, parent of Carolina Bank & Trust, for about $166 million in cash and stock. First Bank, with $12.9 billion in assets, would add Carolina Bank & Trust’s $831 million and 14 branches, and says it would be in the top 10 in deposit share in the two Carolinas. Closing is expected in the first quarter of 2027.

On September 1, FFW filed a timely comment against the deal, citing 2025 mortgage data. In North Carolina, First Bank made 1,112 mortgage loans to whites and denied 280, while making 81 loans to African Americans and denying 13. In South Carolina, within the merger impact zone, it made 81 loans to whites and none to African Americans. Carolina Bank & Trust made 36 loans to whites and one to an African American. FFW asked for evidentiary hearings, including on consumer complaints that the Fed has said are not “substantive” even when they come from the CFPB database.  FFW says the lesson is plain: if a bank can’t send the public its own public exhibits intact, the public record that decides whether disparities like these are addressed is incomplete. 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Mail: Box 130222, Chinatown Station, NY NY 10013



Other, earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.

 Copyright 2006-2026 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com