Friday, October 30, 2026

After Huawei Trial Courtroom Closing Opposed by Inner City Press US Rested & Crossed Chao



After Huawei Trial Courtroom Closing Opposed by Inner City Press US Rested & Crossed Chao

by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

EDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 28 – With the USA v. Huawei trial now underway in Federal court in Brooklyn, presiding Judge Ann Donnelly on September 8 instructed prospective jurors: "China and the Communist Party … are not on trial."

  The same was said, or claimed, in the Southern District of New York in the UN corruption trials of CCP-member Ng Lap Seng, and CCP-NGO boss Patrick Ho of the China Energy Fund Committee. Both were convicted. But is Huawei different?

On September 9 Inner City Press put out a 20 tweet thread of the opening arguments, on X and Bluesky.

September 9 extra on X for subscribers here and Substack here

  On September 16-17 Inner City Press published a book, Huawei on Trial in Brooklyn, Surveillance from Iran to the UN, here. It contains information on how Huawei enables surveillance by many UN states / the UN. In the White House on September 18 there was talk now minimizing spying.

On the afternoon of September 18, this: "on the government's motion to close the courtroom for three witnesses's testimony."

  Inner City Press that night emailed opposition to the closure, along with a request that DOJ's motions for the closure be unsealed, now docketed here.

Jump cut to October 19, when Inner City Press went and spoke at the podium against courtroom closure, noting that not a single page of transcript of October 2's closing had been provided.

After receiving the parties' responses (themselves sealed), on October 20 this:  "After the public hearing held on October 19, 2026, the government, at the Court's direction, filed supplemental briefing in support of its motion to close the courtroom for an additional witness's testimony. The government's motion and all supporting and opposing briefing have been filed under seal. (See ECF Nos. 898, 904, 906, 911, 913.) The Court grants the government's motion. The closure of the courtroom will be tailored by providing access to redacted transcripts as soon as possible after the witness's testimony. Specifically, the government will provide proposed redactions to the defendants within 72 hours after the witness testifies, at which point the defendants may offer objections that the Court will promptly resolve. Opinion setting forth the Court's reasoning in detail to follow. Ordered by Judge Ann M. Donnelly on 10/20/2026."

 So, 72 hours then another 72 hours for the defense? Meanwhile, nothing from October 2. Nothing.

That remained the case even on October 28, when the Government rested. After a whispered sidebar - Rule 29 motion on venue denied? Deferred? Who knows - Huawei put on its first witness, CEO of ICT "Mr. Chao." His bodyguards were in the hallway, and in the courtroom one asked Inner City Press to move.

Here's from the cross:

AUSA: You said Huawei prohibits paying bribes to foreign state-owned companies?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: What about paying bribes to foreign elected officials? Would that be prohibited?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: So if a Huawei employee paid, that would be inconsistent with a culture of compliance, correct?

Chao: That would not be consistent.

AUSA: Isn't it true that Huawei employees working at Huawei's Belgian office paid bribes to European Members of Parliament?

Chao: I haven't heard of it.

AUSA: You're on the Huawei board of directors, but you're not aware of this incident?

Chao: I'm not aware.

AUSA: You're not aware that after the police started to investigate, Huawei-

Defense: Objection!

Judge Donnelly: Sustained. He said he hadn't heard of it.

AUSA: Ren Zhengei instituted wolf culture at Huawei, correct?

Chao: I have never heard of this so-called wolf culture.

AUSA: You’ve never heard of it?

Chao: I have never heard of this fighting wolf culture.

AUSA: You’ve never heard that, according to Mr. Ren, one of the traits of wolf culture is a bloodthirsty sense of marketing opportunity?

Chao: Marketing colleagues should go all-out when an opportunity is found.

AUSA: But would you agree one trait of wolf culture is a bloodthirsty sense of marketing opportunity?

Chao: The wording of fighting wolf, that’s the first time I’ve heard it.

AUSA: But you have heard the phrase ”bloodthirsty sense of marketing opportunity”?

Chao: It’s a basic requirement of any tech company to be sensitive to the market.

AUSA: But we’re not talking about any tech company, we’re talking about Huawei, correct?

Chao: It’s a requirement for marketing colleagues to be sensitive to opportunities.

AUSA: For compliance to be effective, senior executives also have to be committed to compliance, right?

Chao: Yes. At Huawei, we prioritize compliance over business interest.

AUSA: It’s important because they set an example for the rest of the company?

Chao: Yes. Huawei has 5 business areas in over 170 countries, and it’s also an unlisted company. We prioritize long-term success over short-term interest, and that’s why compliance is so important.

AUSA: So the answer to my question is yes?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: So it’s critical for senior executives to tell the truth, correct?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: And that’s to set an example to employees that they should be truthful?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: So if a senior executive lied to a business partner to gain an advantage, that would set a bad example?

Chao: If they intentionally and knowingly lied, that would set a bad example.

AUSA: It could indicate to other employees that it’s OK to lie if it makes the company more money?

Chao: It’s not consistent with the rules.

AUSA: You can’t have a culture of compliance if your most senior executives lie, right?

Chao: Yes.

AUSA: Nothing further.


Judge Donnelly: Any re-direct?

Defense: Yes, your Honor.

Re-direct

Defense (Douglas Axel): To be clear, were other Huawei lawyers also involved in the meetings before your testimony?

Chao: All the meetings were organized by Doug.

Defense: But it wasn’t just the two of us, there were other lawyers present, correct?

Chao: There were a couple of other individuals, I can’t recall their names.

Defense: Would you say it’s expected that an effective compliance program can prevent all violations?

Chao: A compliance program is a message of basic requirements to employees. Even the best compliance program can’t 100% rule out the possibility of a violation.

Defense: Do you get a report on the number of violations?

Chao: Yes.

Defense: And last year, for instance, how many employees were terminated for violating company policies?

AUSA: Objection!

Judge: Sustained.

Defense: So with the allegations, how do you have confidence that the compliance program is effective, not just, as the prosecutor said, pieces of paper? 

Chao: Because we have a dedicated auditing team who conducts audits on an annual basis, and each and every department has to come up with a compliance improvement plan.

Defense: You were asked about various Huawei products - were those products results of Huawei’s own innovation?

Chao: Yes.

Defense: Did Huawei use any stolen intellectual property to make them?

Chao: No.

Defense: Were they the product of an organizational scheme of theft?

Chao: No.
Defense: When you said the allegations were irrelevant, was that because they had no impact on these products?

Chao: Yes.
Defense: Do you think the allegations in any way reflect overall Huawei culture?

AUSA: Objection!

Judge: Sustained.

Defense: No further questions.

Judge: Anything further on cross?

AUSA: No, your Honor.


And still - no transcripts, even redacted, of the closed sessions. And access issues at EDNY.

More on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here


More/update on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Mail: Box 130222, Chinatown Station, NY NY 10013



Other, earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.

 Copyright 2006-2026 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com