| In Corrupt UN of Guterres
ICSC Bolshoi Junket
Mirrors Mike Waltz July 4 UNHQ
Rooftop Gig
by
Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book
Substack UN GATE,
May 31 â How corrupt is
today's UN system in the final
year of Antonio Guterres? The
UN General Assembly raised the
mandatory age of retirement in
the UN to 65 years. In June
2024 Inner City Press reported
thatthe ICSC staff members
closed to the ICSC Chair,
Larbi Djacta, were treated
differently than other
retiring UN staff, see below. It has been some
time since we last updated on
the exciting state of affairs
at the ICSC and its remarkably
âdynamicâ approach to filling
the vacant D-2 Executive
Secretary position. And,
unsurprisingly, nothing has
changed. Absolutely nothing. More than two and
a half years have passed since
the sudden resignation of the
former ICSC Executive
Secretary, Regina Pawlik in
October 2023, yet the position
remains unfilled. Despite this
prolonged vacancy, the ICSC
continues to operate in a
manner that many stakeholders
â both internal and external,
though notably not
including USUN, most
concerned with getting the UNHQ
rooftop for
4th of July fireworks
âhave repeatedly
characterized as inefficient
and incompetent. Under the
UN80 Initiative, one might
reasonably expect a
long-vacant senior post to
trigger a simple question: is
the position still necessary?
Instead, the situation has
become a curious example of
institutional inertia. If a
role can remain unfilled for
years without any visible
impact on operations, it
inevitably raises the question
of why it existed in the first
place. Yet rather than
reassess the need for the
position, ICSC continues to
issue repeated vacancy
announcementsâeach one
apparently designed to
reassure applicants that
something is happening, while
ensuring nothing actually
does. In that respect, the
approach is almost innovative:
a position that remains
vacant, recruitment exercises
that never quite conclude, and
a system that continues
exactly as before. If there is
an award for turning
inactivity into a process, one
might be tempted to say that
ICSC has earned it. In the meantime,
the ICSC Chair reportedly
appointed Yuri Orlov, a senior
member of the ICSC
Secretariat, as
Officer-in-Charge of the ICSC
Secretariat under a Special
Post Allowance arrangement in
lieu of filling the D-2
position. What was initially
presented as an interim
measure has reportedly
continued for several years,
raising understandable
questions about whether the
arrangement remains temporary
in anything other than name.
The situation has also
prompted discussion regarding
the qualifications and
selection criteria applied to
senior leadership functions.
Critics argue that prolonged
acting appointments can create
the appearance that normal
recruitment standards and
competitive selection
processes are being bypassed.
Whether those
concerns are justified is a
matter for appropriate
oversight bodies to determine
- yeah, right - but
the absence of transparency
surrounding the arrangement
has done little to dispel
questions about governance,
accountability, and adherence
to established personnel
practices. Meanwhile, the
travel pattern associated with
senior leadership has drawn
increasing scrutiny from both
UN staff, organizations, and
member states. The travel record
of Yuri Orlov, documentation
of which Inner City Press has
on file, reads like a
masterclass in mission creep.
One is left to wonder how many
âessentialâ official journeys
are required before anyone
asks whether they are
actually, well,
essential. A growing
number of official tripsâmany
of which appear only loosely
connected to the core mandate
of ICSCâhave been undertaken
during a period of tightening
UN budgets, funding
constraints, and heightened
demands for accountability
across the UN system. One
example cited involves a trip
to Moscow organized by Yuri
Orlov through bilateral
coordination with the relevant
country, using UN resources to
facilitate what appeared to be
a sightseeing program for the
ICSC Chair. The
itinerary reportedly included
cultural visits to the Bolshoi
Theatre, Red Square, museums,
and associated hospitality
arrangements
How many similar
excursions have quietly taken
place without anyone
maintaining the tedious but
necessary tally? And perhaps
most importantly, which body
is responsible for tracking
ICSC's compliance with UN
financial and ethical
rulesâthe General Assembly,
the Fifth Committee, ACABQ,
OIOS, the Office of the
President of the General
Assembly, or, as sometimes
appears to be the case, no one
in particular? These questions
acquire additional
significance against the
backdrop of growing criticism
of UN spending practices by
major contributors. The United
States has loudly and largely
ham handedly pressed for
"financial discipline" within
the UN system, an oxymoron if
there ever was one. So
this is a test case for Mike
"Knickerbocker" Waltz:
examples of discretionary
travel, unclear mandates, and
weak oversight.
Questions about official
travel, spending, procurement,
reporting, and the
interpretation of mandates are
not minor administrative
issues. Overall, the picture
that emerges is one of weak
oversight and unclear
accountability, where
discretionary travel and
administrative ambiguity
appear to coexist with claims
of fiscal discipline. This is
particularly concerning given
ICSC's role within the UN
system. As a body that
promotes standards,
accountability, and good
governance, ICSC should lead
by example. Its credibility
depends on applying internally
the same principles it
encourages others to follow. Previously, the
ICSC Chair, Mr. Larbi Djacta
had been repeatedly extending
his favorites beyond the
mandatory retirement age and
delaying years to replace them
with new staff with the
necessary credentials,
including advance degrees
(Djacta's favorite senior
staff lack any advanced
degrees or credentials, then
same as him). Some of those
vacancies for these posts were
announced early last year, but
so far, no actions have been
taken to select the candidates
who applied for these posts
numerous times due to
reannouncements of those
vacancies as a delay
tactic. [Last year Inner
City Press exclusively
reported: On January 26, 2022
contacted by UN
whistleblowers, Inner City
Press asked Guterres and his
spokespeople Stephane Dujarric
and Melissa Fleming questions
including "On USG Larbi
Djacta, ICSC chair, the resume
states Masters Degree St
John's University 1991-93.
Please immediately state a
Masters Degree IN
WHAT." 23
months later, no answer at
all. This is fraud. Here is the
relevant information on one of
those positions - Chief of
Human Resources Policies at
D-1 level in the ICSC
This is the case
with Ms. Henrietta De Beer!
Once again, Mr. Larbi Djacta
has decided to extend her
contract WELL BEYOND her
mandatory retirement age of 65
years (see attached). The
vacancy for the post has been
announced two or three times
over the last two years.
Unfortunately, there was no
action or news about that
recruitment. So, the pertinent
question that should be asked
here for proper checks and
balance is why Ms. De Beer
cannot be replaced with a new
talent! This kind of abuse of
authority is one of the major
hurdles in the UN towards
rejuvenating the workforce.
*** Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017 Reporter's mobile (and weekends): 718-716-3540 Other, earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis. Copyright 2006-2023 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com |
