UN Correspondents Association's UNdisclosed Lunch With Guterres, After Kazahk Delicacies

By Matthew Russell Lee, Photo

UNITED NATIONS, May 18 – It seemed obvious that journalists should not be serving up the "delicacies" of those they purport to be covering. But at the UN, as with content neutral accreditation and access rules, that is thrown out the window. This year the UN Correspondents Association has partnered with Kazakhstan, whose media law is called repressive and draconian, to distribute "national delicacies" twice a week. Photo here. Now on May 21, UNCA ate from the hand of someone they are supposed to be covering, even watch-dogging: UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres. While it was not even disclosed on Guterres' public schedule, mid afternoon Inner City Press was informed that Guterres had served pan seared corvina, mousse and Chilean wine to the scribes of UNCA, now the UN Censorship Alliance. Printed menu here - who pays for this? Who prints it? Also in attendance were Alison Smale of the Department of Public Information / Global Communications and Stephane Dujarric, the spokesman who only an hour before had told Inner City Press it was bannedfrom live streaming Periscope of Guterres' interchanges with diplomats from Kenya,Angola and elsewhere. The UN Censorship Alliance, we're told, did not raise Guterres' restrictions, or any UN corruption question (despite the ongoing Patrick Ho case, and Ng Lap Seng whom they took money from being sentenced to four years in prison for UN bribery), or even sexual harassment. For Guterres UNdisclosed lunch: Sherwin Bryce-Pease, SABC South Africa
Room: S-415

Valeria Robecco, ANSA News Agency - UNCA First Vice President 2018
FIRST VICE PRESIDENT
Valeria Robecco, ANSA News Agency

Melissa Kent, CBC/Radio-Canada - UNCA Second Vice President 2018
SECOND VICE PRESIDENT
Melissa Kent, CBC/Radio-Canada
Room: S-342

Jianguo Ma, Xinhua News Agency - UNCA Third Vice President 2018
THIRD VICE PRESIDENT
Jianguo Ma, Xinhua News Agency

Carole Landry, Agence France Presse - UNCA Treasurer 2016-2018
TREASURER
Carole Landry, Agence France Presse (AFP)
Room: S-316

Seana Magee, Kyodo News - UNCA Secretary 2014-2018
SECRETARY
Seana Magee, Kyodo News
Room: S-304

Members at Large:
Nabil Abi Saab, Al Hurra TV - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2018
Nabil Abi Saab, Al Hurra TV
Room: S-416A

Erol Avdovic - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Erol Avdovic, Webpublicapress
Room: S-345

Oscar Bolanos, OMB News - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2018
Oscar Bolanos, OMB News

Olga Denisova, RIA Novosti Russian News Agency - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Olga Denisova, RIA Novosti Russian News Agency

Ahmed Fathi, American Television News - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Ahmed Fathi, American Television News
Room: S-0332

Widad Franco, NHK Japan Broadcasting - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Widad Franco, NHK Japan Broadcasting
Room: S-414

Michelle Nichols, Reuters (NA) - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Michelle Nichols, Reuters
Room: S-321

Giampaolo Pioli, Quotidiano Nazionale - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2017-2018
Giampaolo Pioli, Quotidiano Nazionale
Room: S-422
Mobile: (917) 287-3969

Luke Vargas, Talk Media News - Member at Large, UN Correspondents Association Executive Team 2018
Luke Vargas, Talk Media News
Room: S-422A

   This is how the UN becomes ever more blind and corrupt.  Contrary to UNCA, 26 international press freedom organizations called on Kazakh authorities to drop criminal defamation cases against media outlets Forbes Kazakhstan and Ratel and revise the law on dissemination of "false information" often used to silence critical media outlets and journalists. Former minister Zeinulla Kakimzhanov and his son, Ilkhalid, filed a defamation complaint claiming the outlets spread false information. Four separate cases are being heard against the outlets. In April 2017, an Almaty court ordered the two outlets and four journalists to pay 50 million Kazakh tenge (US$160,000) in damages, according to local media reports. The three other cases are ongoing. It's worth noting, as Inner City Press and the Free UN Coalition for Access (FUNCA) have, that UN agencies FAO and WIPO have both used criminal defamation charges, and while Inner City Press has asked, Secretary General Antonio Guterres has done nothing to reign it in, his spokesmen insisting UN agencies can do this. The joint IFEX letter to Kazakhstan's prosecutor general, Supreme Court, Parliament, and Minister of Information and Communications, called for the law, which levies disproportionate penalties against journalists and media outlets, to be revised and highlighted the threat that such legislation poses to critical reporting and press freedom.

But this doesn't matter to UNCA, the UN's Censorship Alliance, which has since provided a closed door platform for controversial IOM candidate Ken Isaacs, and for the UN Alliance of Civilizations. It's that Kazakhstan was president of the Security Council this month, and UNCA is selling the correspondents it charges a hundred dollars to access, or the illusion of access, however it might appear. In November it was espresso served up by Italy, the country of UNCA's long time landlordpresident Giampaolo Pioli. Now, it's Kazakhstan. A new and peculiarly UN tradition, of sycophantry, is born. And the Free UN Coalition for Access opposes it. We are certainly open to hearing from the Kazazh Mission its side of the story. But any "press" group which partners to hand out delicacies, and limits information to those who pay it money, is no press organization at all, except in today's UN. Here is RSF's review of Kazakhstan's new law: "Under one of the most controversial amendments, journalists are required to obtain the permission of persons named in their articles before publishing information involving matters of 'personal and family confidentiality.' Investigative journalists fear it could obstruct their reporting, especially coverage of corruption. There is similar concern about a ban on “information violating lawful interests,” which are also not defined. One of the amendments complicates the right of access to state-held information. The length of the time within which officials must answer journalists’ questions is more than doubled, with the result that by the time journalists get their answer, there is every chance it will no longer be newsworthy. Furthermore, officials are also given the right to classify certain answers. Under one of the amendments, Internet users are required to identify themselves before posting a comment on a news website, and their information will be stored for three months. This suggests that there could be a further increase in the number of people being jailed because of their online comments, which has already grown sharply in recent years." But UNCA, now the UN's Censorship Alliance, will be serving up those Kazakh national delicacies for the Mission. In other related news, Iran will be the subject of a UN Security Council meeting of some type on January 5 at 3 pm. There may be a procedural vote - Inner City Press on January 4 askedRussian Ambassador Nebenzia about any Iran meeting and he replied, "Not unless they held one without me." Kazakhstan is the president of the Security Council for January, and just as they refused on January 2 to take a single Press question about Africa (the first question was given as a delicacy to UNCA, which allowed for questions to be bundled in packs of five to be evaded), on January 4 they sent notice only to their favored correspondents. (Notable, given press freedom issues there.) As quickly obtained by Inner City Press from multiple sources, they wrote: "Dear friends, To keep you informed, tomorrow SC meets on Iran at 3.00PM, open format. And a short announcement, our Delegation is delighted to invite you to a Tea and Coffee table with Kazakh national delights, to be served every Tuesday and Thursday, starting from 9 January, 9.30 to 11.30AM, in the UNCA Room, 3d Floor, Secretariat Building. Alma Konurbayeva, Spokesperson / Counsellor, Permanent Mission of the Republic of Kazakhstan to the United Nations." Of what might those "national delights" consist? When Kazazhstan held a press conference about its Presidency of the UN Security Council for January, Ambassador Kairat Umarov began by noting that the majority of the agenda involves countries in Africa: at least seven peacekeeping missions to be reviewed in the month, with Burundi and Cameroon not even listed. But when the Kazakh mission spokeswoman took questions, not a single one was on anything in Africa. There was climate change, from a self-described syndicated columnist. There were questions about two (non-African) countries in the Program of Work's footnotes. But not a single one on anywhere in Africa. 

Inner City Press said loudly, “On the DRC did anyone even ask for a statement on the crackdown?” Video here from 44:15. But the Ambassador chose to answer another question, about an issue he called close to Kazakhstan's heart, then ended it.

 He had said, during the press conference, the Kazakhstan has energy resources for the next 100 years. They won the Asia seat over Thailand; apparently that didn't require political resources, at least in Africa. We'll have more on this. 

Back in September 2017 with the UN Security Council presidency being taken over by Ethiopia's Tekeda Alemu, Inner City Press on September 1 asked Ambassador Alemu four questions, the answers to which sketch out the Ethopian government's worldview. Video here. In response to Inner City Press asking why Burundi, where even the UN says there is a risk of genocide, is not on his September Program of Work nor on the agenda of the Council's visit to Addis Ababa, Alemu said that you can't compare Burundi to Central African Republic, that Burundi has “strong state institutions.” But it is that very “strength,” which some say the country shares with Ethiopia, and with until recently military-ruled Myanmar about which Inner City Press also asked, that has led to the human rights violations. In this context, Inner City Press asked Alemu about the Oromo protests - and crackdown - in his country. He diplomatically chided Inner City Press for not having asked in private, saying that social media has played a dangerous role. On the other hand, when Inner City Press asked Alemu at the end about the murders of two UN experts Michael Sharp and Zaida Catalan, he replied that while the DR Congo is due to sovereignty the one to investigate the murders, the gruesome nature of the killings put a “great responsibility” on the DR Congo. We'l have more on this. Alamy photos here. Earlier on September 1 in Alemu's briefing to countries not on the Security Council, Bangladesh specifically asked that the Council remain seized of the situation in Myanmar. When Inner City Press asked Alemu about this, he said he still had to inform himself more about that situation. The Security Council is traveling to Addis from September 5 through 9, when alongside African Union consultations the Council's member will meet for an hour with Prime Minister Hailemariam Desalegn, Alemu said. The Council will receive the “maiden briefings” late in the month of the new Under Secretaries General of OCHA and on Counter-Terrorism. There will be peacekeeping on September 20, during the High Level week of the UN General Assembly, and Yemen on September 26. But tellingly, there will not be Burundi. Watch this site.