By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 11 – Hamid Akhavan and Ruben Weigand are charged with a "scheme to deceive US banks into processing in excess of $100 million for marijuana products."
On January 7, Akhavan and Weigand had a proceeding before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jed S. Rakoff, covered by Inner City Press, below.
It emerged that Akhavan had been presented in Magistrates Court earlier in the day on an alleged violation of supervised release, and detained on consent. It involved a gun.
After being arrested and detained in California, Akhavan was writted to SDNY in connection with the case before Judge Rakoff. He was returned on the warrant related to the violation of pretrial release on January 7, after a December 30 arrest. His counsel Christopher Tayback of Quinn Emanuel consented to his detention without prejudice to make a future bail application.
On February 9 Judge Rakoff heard arguments on releasing Akhavan for the week or two weeks of trial, starting March 1. He will rule by Feb 12. Inner City Press live tweeted below.
Now on February 11, this: "MEMORANDUM TO THE DOCKET CLERK as to Ruben Weigand, Hamid Akhavan. On February 19 at 5pm, Judge Rakoff will have a waiver of indictment, arraignment, and plea proceeding for a defendant, James Patterson, that the Government plans to add to this case."
From February 9: Judge Rakoff: What about his use of a gun?
Akhavan's lawyer: It was gun possession. He needs to be out to prepare for this serious fraud case.
Judge Rakoff: You're telling me, Screw you judge, we're one of the best law firms in the country but we can't prepare
Defense lawyer: I'm definitely not saying Screw you judge. But we just got a lot of discovery, in a corrupted file. I'll be in NY soon. You know the risks of COVID - what is one of his lawyers gets sick? It impacts the trial. We're asking for another chance.
Akhavan's lawyer: We would pay for armed guards. [That's what UN briber Ng Lap Seng got, in 47th Street condo, before he was found guilty of bribing @UN_PGA and others.] AUSA: Detain him Judge Rakoff: Let me cut to the chase. 3142(i) is for preparation of defense.
Judge Rakoff: I'm wonder if for week of trial he could be released to this private facility. AUSA: His defendant is in a fundamentally different position that the co-defendant. He has a long history -- Judge Rakoff: I agree with all that. But there's new docs
AUSA: MCC is allowing in person visits, and video conference. So he can prepare. Being in a rented apartment, he can try to obtain drugs through guards, or while visiting counsel. Plus, we couldn't oversee his communications. He's trying to interfere in state case Inner City Press @innercitypress · 13m Judge Rakoff: OK, last opportunity for the defense.
Defense: We'd have to get the state custodial hold released too. Judge Rakoff: What about interfering with witness in state case?
Defense: We could arrange that he doesn't have a phone.
Judge Rakoff: I'm going to think about this. The only argument on the defense side that has any weight is about preparing for trial. I granted bail for Mr. Weigand. I went out on a limb for Mr. Akhavan, but his behavior was the equivalent of "Screw you judge."
Judge Rakoff: I'll get you a decision by Friday. OK - the trial will start on March 1 rather than March 2.
Inner City Press has been digging into the possible Wirecard link.
On July 27, Judge Rakoff held an oral argument on motions to dismiss, and motions to suppress, with a trial scheduled for January 2021. Inner City Press live tweeted it:
Judge Rakoff expressing frustration at counsel going over old ground, says "I have another matter at noon." Lawyer: If transaction occurred by debit card, there's no damage to the bank, a sine quo non of bank fraud.
Defense lawyer: The banks received a lot of money for these transactions. There was no harm to them. Judge Rakoff: What you're saying is that when they deceived the banks, all they cheated the banks out of was some policy the banks wanted to adhere to
AUSA: It is not clear that the bank fraud statue is a prosecutor's Stradivarius. In the recent case of Attila, harm is a not a factor. The cheating in this case is obtaining the bank's own money through pretense. The analysis can end right there
Judge Rakoff: Let me hear from co-defendant's counsel.
William Burck of Quinn Emmanuel for Akhavan: There has to be a risk of loss to the bank for bank fraud.
Judge Rakoff: I was surprised that no one referred to the civil RICO cases that have address this issue
Judge Rakoff: There was a case in the 5th Circuit, [or the 11th], after an airline takeover, to avoid unionization, the public was told that Continental Airlines was not as safe as Eastern had been. The allegation was that the pilot deceived the public
AUSA (sounds like Dimase) - these are more like Rule 29 motions, arguments about Visa and Master Card, let the jury decide. The indictment is sufficient.
Judge Rakoff: I have read your briefs. And I have other matters today.
AUSA: Conflating loss and harm is a mistake
Judge Rakoff: Let's turn to the motions to suppress.
Weigand's lawyer: The warrants didn't allege that the devices seized were being used for the scheme.
Judge Rakoff: I'd like to hear from the government.
AUSA Nicholas Folly: We only had to show probability... The evidence in the affidavit came from the cell phone of the cooperating witness.
Judge Rakoff: I'll issue an omnibus ruling by the end of August; trial now set for January.
Weigand since he has money, unlike many SDNY defendants, on April 28 already had high powered lawyers from Wilson Sonsini. On April 28 they demanded a bill of particulars.
Judge Rakoff pushed back, setting a tight schedule for that: May 12, May 18 and he'll rule by May 20.
But these high powered lawyers have a grueling trial schedule for other clients, from the Central District of California and elsewhere.
So Judge Rakoff agreed to a trial in December 2020, to be finished before Christmas. Inner City Press will cover it. The case is US v. Weigand, 20-cr-188 (Rakoff).
***
Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.
